0:00 / 0:00
Another Walking Farbrengen
394 views
Rabbi Taub and Avi are joined by Cantor Mendy Herz on this walk where they discuss October 31, the Lubavitcher Rebbe's visit to the Satmar Rebbe, the spiritual symbolism of walking, online antisemitism vs. online philosemitism, and other topics all on a 1.4 mile walk. For more classes from Rabbi Shais Taub visit https://www.soulwords.org/ Follow us on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/rabbi_shais_taub Support our work at: https://www.soulwords.org/donate/ --OR-- PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/soulwordspayments CashApp: https://cash.app/$soulwords Venmo: https://venmo.com/u/soulwords
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
be like this uh yeah it's good yeah yeah
so maybe you'd be in the middle because
if you're holding the mic
I'm not going to draw any attention a
six nine but you're holding a interview
Michael reporters Mike walking down
Central Avenue
um so last week we did this walk
and I had a lot of people were concerned
about my heavy breathing they thought
maybe I was
um
I was in danger but it was I said it was
exaggerated because I was wearing a
lapel mic it was right on my chest and
it exaggerated the the heavy the panting
and breathing so now we have like a
reporters Mike tatana
so this voice here this Mandy hurts the
great Canter the well-known Canter who
joined me on a couple of my podcasts
about uh rosh hashanahan Kippur daviding
I was practicing kill mother rakamim
okay and avi's here again as well
obvious the founder of the walking
fabrina yeah
we're putting on calories at this speed
I think I think we're doing great I
think any movement is good movement
positive I like it I was very positive
he's very gentle
he made it very easy for me to make this
commitment because he said we don't have
to walk crazy distances we don't have to
walk crazy speeds
yeah
so this week
gonna do a rabbi thing for a second sure
okay so this week is parshus
my favorite really is it really oh yeah
because my name is Abra yeah yeah when
did you change from avram
yes did it
yes so
um means
go to you to you yeah yeah let go to you
but
don't you see how it's connected to this
little uh Endeavor we're doing going the
going yeah halika means going it
literally means walk right yeah so it
means go go for a walk
yeah yeah okay and that's what we're
doing and that's what we're doing so
we're literally
that's awesome yeah all right we have a
lot of connections I see the streets are
kind of empty I remember the last time
we did this walk was much Shabbos
and you know Central Avenue is hopping
hopping on Saturday night last night was
busy I walked out I went from like 10 30
to 11 30 with my wife pizza shop crowd
and then some crowd yeah you went out
with your wife last night you took a
walk it's very not what you two nights
in a row you're taking walks well one
with my wife one without my wife
you know that honey Youngman joke he
says you know the secret to uh
marital Harmony is my wife and I we go
out for a candlelight dinner twice a
week she goes Mondays I go Wednesdays
a drum what is it called a rim shot a
rim shot yeah insert here
now pizza was packed last night
well David's wasn't as busy last night
yeah in uh Five Towns uh I mentioned
these stores unless they're gonna pay
for products shout out no free shout out
this is a very popular podcast I got a
lot of comments but you want to have
something that I felt was like I mean
obvi you're gonna I think feel good
about this did I tell you I don't think
I told you what's that um a lot of
people told me they saw what the podcast
was and so they walked while they
listened to it that's awesome and they
themselves did the mile walk that's
great
that's that's the name of the game
that's where it was a one mile walk it
was a half hour podcast right
[Laughter]
by the way one person told me he did it
on double speed and he only he didn't
finish the mile
by the way double speed's A is a real
sickness I cannot listen to anything in
normal speed people talk to me regularly
I'm like could you speed it up already
right my kids do that anytime they're
listening to any voice notes or anything
like that it sounds like Chipmunks
talking oh I got used to it it's really
really bad
because I'm like tapping my feet when
people talk to me real life is too slow
for you oh my God
it's a bad thing
yeah streets are kind of quiet yeah it's
getting cold
starting to get cool yeah yeah it's
cooling off
it's uh
oh you know what it's interesting
but
this is a very Jewish neighborhood and
that is evident from the absence of any
type of October 31st activity right now
right what is October oh this is that
Halloween right yeah tomorrow as as the
as my co-workers called Jewish poor what
do they call the party they call Purim
Jewish Halloween right I was like close
but
it's not exactly
you know that the lab
went to Williamsburg
in topshin good dollar that's 1950 well
it was still 53 because it was October
of 53.
to be manachoil
who lost a daughter well I know
and apparently it was either the day of
Halloween was close to Halloween
and one of the things they discussed at
the base oval in Williamsburg
was
does Halloween have
the status of an idolatrous yantev
according to the mishnah and avidazada
it says certain rules for Jews to abide
by regarding their dealings with Idol
worshipers three days before and after
their idolatrous holidays
so what was the I don't know the
conclusion but I know that's one of the
things they discussed wow and I'll tell
you an interesting thing in conjunction
with that
the rabbit was in correspondence with
Rabbi zavin yeah yeah actually who was
um
yeah and uh turmeric encyclopedia
he lived in Jerusalem yeah yeah so um
zevin had a friend
named gold I think his name was Zeb
probably Zev gold
who was
privy to the correspondences he saw the
letters that that ABBA was writing back
to rabbi's Evan and he was very very
impressed
by the Reba's responses
and just from reading these responses
remember this is the days where there
was no internet you didn't see you
weren't bombarded constantly with images
and recordings and sound and sites of
people so if you if you lived in Israel
and you had a friend corresponding with
an American Rabbi so these Pages these
papers were the only thing that you
would maybe take a picture of the rabbit
but
it's not like he had a lot of material
from there it was just these letters but
the letters were so
um
they spoke to him so much as a scholar
that he started to form a very deep
attachment to the Reb even though he
hadn't met him
just through somebody else's
correspondence exactly being a fly on
the wall second hand second hand right
exactly
so
he apparently came to the same base
level to this Shiva house like we call
it in America they Shiva house
and
um
you know the joke about the Shiva house
no but the guy's on his deathbed and I'm
on the dark human right so this guy's on
his death back to the funeral did I just
can't yeah you got no that's very good
that's like the heimcon movie number 53.
so guys on his deathbed and he smells
his wife's uh brisket and he's like oh
darling he wanted to make me my favorite
meal before I die
let's bring it here I'll have a little
taste I'm very weak but I'll just have a
little taste she's like no that's for
the Shiva
[Laughter]
all I want before I go is a piece of
Mama's apple strudel that's from the
Yiddish for coming I believe
was that the same as hello Louie hello
yes hello okay so uh
this is gold was he went to the Shiva
house to the satmarov
I think also he made it to New York okay
so he had a shy well here's the story so
he went to New York and he was at the
the samurov's house which I think
think is on Rodney
it's my settler friends will tell me
will correct me
I think it's on Rodney
um
so I've never actually been to the house
I haven't seen it but what it was
described to me is that there are steps
in front which is not uncommon in
Brooklyn
and um
the devil was coming out
as this
gold was going in
and he sees that well maybe somebody
told him that's the Bible and
immediately clicked with him this is the
person who is a schnarism yeah who is
watching the correspondences and he's
very like he's very drawn to him
so he says
he says I'm afraid
I'm becoming your closet the worst
things have happened and that ever sets
them with a big smile
thus that's
why do you have to be afraid what if
they do it out of fear become accosted
out of love is part of that was language
choosing your language right properly
always emphasize the past positive yeah
well I haven't taken that to heart yet
[Laughter]
foreign
so uh back to Halloween yeah because
it's the Halloween we're making a
Halloween themed walk
uh is it are you allowed to leave like
stuff out for the non-jews who come to
your home to be a good neighbor mushroom
Ava
no actually is it I mean it's a pagan
holiday
I think well originally yes it is it is
totally Pagan and see my parents always
told us growing up like if we ever had
an inkling of maybe we could just
you know play with it as an American
type thing Thanksgiving yeah
Thanksgiving
yeah parents were like do you know how
many pogroms there were right right on
Halloween I was like shut it down
yeah then the guilt kicked in that's the
tool
I didn't finish my dinner starving kids
in India
no they're at the table for the Russian
jewelry
the the seat the seat at your
temperature yeah yeah
yeah
yeah with bar mitzvah twins that was
like is that a thing that was a guilt
thing yeah for sure in the 80s like
every Suburban kid you had to be twinned
with a Russian refuse Nick kid so this
before they started planting trees
this is this is after the trees trees
were since the 40s the trees yeah double
dip for your apartment so you got a tree
and a twin and a twin yeah for sure
yeah
we love this religion they're taking
away half our stuff they're giving it to
a twin that I've never met and we're
planting trees in Israel play some it
was before birth rights and not
everybody went right
but this is like a real thing like you
hear once in a while this is like a
total American 80s thing it'll be like
you're Russian twins family just got out
this was it was a totally different
reality back then
very very very few Russians got out it
was a big deal or it was
it was the being yeah when Dad got out
in 1970. how do you get up in 70 I guess
some people got out he actually had a
visa to go to Israel in 67 and then the
war broke out and he couldn't leave and
then they couldn't get another Visa
until 70 and they got a visa to come
here
so he came here in uh in 1970. where was
he living he was living actually in a
small town called Salish which is where
the altaraba's father is buried that's
where my father grew up
he was born in an even smaller Village a
couple of miles away but when he was a
little baby they moved to Salish and
that's where that's where he lived until
he left Russia in that time it was
Russia today it's Ukraine
have you ever been I was in uman I went
to uman for Rosh Hashanah for five or
six years in a row but I never I know
your wife said to Avi we need you back
home right but I never ventured out of
that out of there
said you really never well you drove how
far is the airport from I used to fly
into kievable right and then we used to
get into a cab and then later on it was
like a a mini bus and it would take
about three hours to get from Kiev to
uman have you ever done that trip rabbit
cab no they have a good opinion no no
you lost number I was considering
going to uh
well I said you lost them at minion
you're trying to entice you that there's
a Chabad oh yeah yeah yeah no you didn't
lose me it's just not a draw for me but
yeah yeah so
um there's a there's a grave in bdichev
which is apparently the only grave that
survived
the desecration destruction of the
cemetery
it's a grave from the
1700s from liberagodo
and I'm descended from him
wow so I've spoken to some other people
who are also descended from Harrisburg
to the clients Lincoln's family yeah so
they are also descent from liberagoda we
spoke about maybe taking a trip to
predictive and go to the
no
well probably cheaper to fly though
right yeah I think of it that way
I mean how's your lateral movement
go side to side quickly Waters
yeah
but it's it's a it's a wake-up call and
you get there and you really see what
the shettle looks like because there's
like you go out of the big cities and
you're Ukraine in Russia and it's yeah
it's literally a hundred years in the
past yeah
it's like old babushka's on the side of
the road pedaling you know yes people
moving cows and goats and sheep along
the roads it's really like and all of a
sudden we're like early years when I
used to go to uman they would shut the
water off during the day oh we had hot
water only after nine o'clock at night
like nine to midnight there was hot
water it was salt water pumped right
from the Azar sea I was actually in
Maricopa
and it was it was BR it was it was not
not brutal it was different yeah I would
say that much
but uh
this is a mile by the way when we get
back to where we started it doesn't feel
like it because we have such an
interesting conversation I'm gonna
prepare next time we're gonna be in
trouble
so I'll tell you what I prepared I
thought I thought this is very prepared
might feel too didactic but I'm gonna go
for it maybe let's turn on chestnuts we
don't have to be so like out in the open
walking down Central Avenue a little
leaders religious self-conscious but
that's the basic yeah yeah okay yeah
be careful
okay
this is uh
a lot of traffic for Cedarhurst
okay
um this is like the The Fifth Avenue
like in Manhattan right Fifth Avenue
this like yeah yeah when you look at the
duggage of kid Fifth Avenue
yeah so
the whole idea we said you should go or
literally walk are you ready are you
really giving us a heads up to
tomorrow's class or this is totally
different totally different no I
wouldn't do that to you
I wouldn't you know I wouldn't uh
recycle material so I'm a good recipient
I'll laugh so there's not nothing
there's no joke I'm not serious isn't it
not somber but like
thoughtful so
the idea of
going of progressing of moving
um it's interesting the act of walking
itself
is sort of a metaphor
for all types of progress in life
because when you walk every step you
take you're actually falling
and then you catch yourself
but the best proof of that we don't
think of it like that because we've been
walking probably since we were like
watch toddlers toddlers right exactly
watch your toddler or watch somebody
whose foot catches on something and they
can't move their foot forward try not to
laugh
[Laughter]
watch what like you know like the booby
trap when you have the tripwire in the
jungle yeah you know what that's like so
you're yeah yeah so your foot stays back
you can't bring it forward to catch
yourself so then you fall flat on your
face but every step is actually an act
of falling you destabilize yourself you
put yourself off balance and then you
catch yourself with the front with your
front foot and then you watch what's
inside and you alternate yeah what's the
bump in the side
um
so that's a case of the point it's
interesting that walking is a constant
uh process of surrendering your
stability if you retain your stability
you stand planted in the ground then
you're safe you're not going to go
nowhere but you go no move you don't
move so that's progress progress is you
have to surrender your footing you have
to give up the stability that you
achieved
but that's the only way
to get somewhere else and it's
to make an omelette you gotta crack a
few eggs that's a beautiful thought yeah
and then you got to think about like
while you're cracking the eggs like if
someone just take a picture of the eggs
and then take a picture of the broken
shells I guess with the the egg okay
really cool yeah what did you accomplish
well then you got to wait till the next
picture to see the fried omelette but if
you don't see the fried omelette yeah if
you come in the middle of it you're like
oh no you had something good and you
lost it right until you see the
culmination of the process it looks like
a disaster looks like you've you took
something that was good you lost it now
you don't even have that anymore it
looks just like breaking you don't see
the breaking to heal
that's like working out tearing muscle
to build a stronger muscle yeah I don't
think we're here
this is aerobic exercise
although maybe me I bet you people are
going to ask me to put the lapel mic
back because they're going to say they
were inspired by the panting it could be
people don't write off that you're not
panting in this one
I'm gonna get a special
um EQ like what do you call the the
filter yeah yeah the noise canceler
cancels out panting
yes and panting means you're alive yeah
see there's always a way to look at it
yeah so that's that's life in general
positive look at me wow we're completing
the walk and you're already turning
positive what do you say about Kanye
West uh nothing useless these things
don't ruffle my feathers it's racism is
scary but I still think it's
I think it's a fringe
I mean it's not good what he's saying
but
are you losing sleep from Kanye West I
don't think it's a friend at all
unfortunately
it's a fringe at all I think that the
the trend has been very very frightening
it's becoming more and more common to
have people say outrageous things about
Jews and it's totally acceptable and and
you know we've seen this before we've
seen this in every single generation
I don't think that that it's okay and I
don't think that it should be minimized
it's it's serious stuff
but minimizable no I think we should I
think we should talk about it oh we're
going to get into politics all sudden I
don't think it should be canceled I
don't like the whole canceling thing
because then you're just hammering home
what he everything he's spouting it's
not about to me it's not about canceling
that it's education businesses that
don't want to do business with him
because he's he's an animal have every
right to do that but as the business is
not want to do uh do business because
everybody's whining they're because they
feel because that's what they actually
feel because certain things are not
acceptable and that's one of them you
can't you can't do you got to understand
it that that rhetoric and those
narratives number one are totally false
and number two historically have been
used to justify murdering Jews we're not
talking about like you know they were
not nice to us we're not talking about
they said mean things to us we're
talking about they killed two out of
three Jews in Europe put us in ovens and
gas Chambers using those type types of
narratives and rhetoric that's not okay
you can't you can't accept that and you
can't make believe that it's not true I
don't think it's accepted
what do you think Rabbi is it accepted I
think that because of the internet
algorithms
which are focused on engagement right
they have made everyone more extreme
whatever you're into they make you more
extreme
including
evil opinions have become
less Fringe and people opinions have
become less friends or voices I hope
megaphones has become less fringed I
think it's always there
I think just everybody has a mic now
yeah I remember when I was a kid one
time I was walking down the street and
some guy handed me a flyer for Louis
Fairgrounds no I bet I have gotten that
yeah the final call newspapers uh
um
no it was like a white supremacist guy
and but it was it was this is back in
the 80s so it was like hand-drawn
photocopied
copy of a copy it was terrible but it
was really dark and disturbing I
remember reading it with like these
terrible caricatures on it and but it
was probably the first real like racist
uh
propaganda that I'd seen in real life
and sometimes when I see crazy stuff
online I think to myself
well when I was a kid that guy would
just be going to the library making 20
photocopies of his craziness and handing
it out on the street corner and nobody
would take it from him
now it's on Twitter and a million people
see it right
yeah
do you think it's hatred do you think
it's just stupid
I think people do you think it's people
espousing something that they believe
and know and educated it and real hatred
are just morons being morons Kanye West
himself I don't know a whole lot about
the guy but he's clearly upset I'm
setting aside his his mental illness
because to me it's neither here nor
there
um he's angry he's upset he's got some
personal stuff going on
and with his family with his with his
finances with his business and when
people are angry
they look for an outlet
and unfortunately good or an outlet the
anti-semitic Trope Trope is a real tried
and true it's an easy one it's like it's
like a it's a classic it's a classic one
so the Jews are always the classic
Boogeyman
and from the left and from the right for
both sides Joshua to once said he said
the only thing that the fire left and
Far Right have in common is
anti-Semitism all right well it's that
game you know the computer game where
the thing goes back and forth and uh
it's like a paddle and you have to play
with you you knock bricks with the
paddle yeah so the bricks on one side
the paddles the other side and the ball
is the Jew just kidding now back and
forth between them
okay it's true
we're coming to the end of our walk so
there's there's a concept of Messiah
that you're supposed to
end with a
something positive
go for it
Ava you got something
I don't know I'm gonna let the rabbi
take this one we got to know our place
you know I think
Hashem has a plan
and mashir is coming and we all know how
this story ends and apparently
the amplification of
vile ideas is part of that plan
I'm not sure I know 100 well I'm sure I
don't know 100 that the purpose of it
why these things should be Amplified but
a couple insights I do have is
that just like
uh hate can be Amplified today love can
be Amplified more than any more than
ever before
um you know just like you had you had
the guy who used to stand on the street
corner handing out his his hate and now
he's got a he's got a Twitter account so
two
what used to be confined to walk down
the street and you smile at your
neighbor
you can do the same thing with a
platform as well so we can we could
amplify positivity spread positivity
mayor k
ay yeah he's into this that was a free
shout out yeah send him an invoice
um
also I think it's maybe important
for us to realize
that um
it's not just hate it's let's talk about
specifically anti-semitism
I think the Jews continue to be
misunderstood
um and and you know what
how can you be so surprised because the
concept
of the Jews is a really wild concept
I've been I mean I've been
studying what the meaning is what is a
Jew what is Jewish identity for years
I've been studying and it's such a deep
perplexing concept and it requires so
much
mystical explanation to even
start to
grasp it because it defies normal
categorizations it's not a race they're
Jews of all colors I know Jews with
blonde hair blue eyes I know Jews ooh
well completely dark skin
um black hair brown eyes I know it's not
a language you know Jews speak English
you speak French you speak Russian
speak Arabic it's not a it's not a
nationality I know juice to hold
passports from
all countries and uh it's not even a
religion because a Jew could God forbid
but you could renounce his religious
faith and he'd still be a Jew and
conversely maybe let's turn around here
it's a Birthright it could have
um
somebody who unofficially Embraces
Embraces the Jewish religion without a
conversion without a conversion so it
doesn't make them Jewish just because
they believe in the ideas of the Jewish
religion so what I'm saying is
Jewish identity
it doesn't conform neatly to these
categories like race or nationality or
language we're not simple that's we're
not that's your point well here's the
thing it's a metaphysical thing
a sphere it's a spiritual condition
and the Jewish nation is a nation of
Souls and that's a weird concept
and so it's not that surprising that
people misunderstand the Jews and I
guess it's not that surprising that when
people are confused about life
they make up weird things about Jews
because
they have a hard time understanding who
are these people what's up with them
so I think we become sort of like
not to uh
not to invoke the uh the a meme from
last year but you know Jewish space
lasers so it's like last year yeah it's
so it's very 2021 Jewish space lasers
but it's like Jews in space why the
history of the World Part Two that never
happened right Mel Brooks but why do
people say Jewish space ladies nobody's
saying that about other races
ethnicities because we're not a tangible
thing I think yeah that's right so it's
almost like any weird thing you say
about the Jews almost you could believe
right you know like they'll tell you the
Jews are from Mars oh really okay
it's not funny since I'm the younger
younger one here on the group recently
you know since this whole uh Miami Boys
Choir social IM explosion so there's
been other explosions that have come to
surface there's like this nanny in
Florida she's a non-jewish nanny but
she's big on Tick Tock now with the firm
World a lot of from people are following
her she nannies Jewish kids so you see
the outside perspective of somebody
appreciating Judaism because he's
learning it from the ground up and she's
appreciating it's like it's like we take
it for granted and people who don't know
laugh at it but she's like she's living
in it but she's not keeping it but she
has but she's gaining an appreciation
she has a massive following on Instagram
and on Tick Tock and another guy
recently somebody sent me who's who's
reacting to Jewish videos like
positively and he's like it's it's a
it's an interesting it's a more positive
twist that if you actually sit down and
delve into it it's you know if you don't
look at it superficially if you actually
see what the Customs are and why we do
things it's not as foreign or I mean
it's still going to be foreign but you
get a better appreciation for what it is
absolutely so we have to you use the so
that those people have to be blown up
more than yeah the Kanye West of the
world I guess philosophytes I think
that's the word well she's been on a
bunch of like uh you know Jewish
podcasts like uh we're not going to show
we're not no more free shoutouts
I'm not promoting anymore podcasts but
it's it's actually you know it's
heartwarming to see and I see a lot of
people are watching this guy react to
videos he's got like I know it's not a
big number but like a thousand new
followers all Jewish watching uh
watching Jewish guy sing and he's like
and then he's learning why is the guy
wearing filling why are they wearing a
toilet why are they wearing a Kittle why
is he wearing what's the silver thing on
the tallest so all these little things
that we take for granted and we think is
normal
and they you know people may look at it
weird but they're getting an education
people are explaining it in the in the
comment section and he's you know and
they're appreciating it which is a nice
thing to see I guess
Mama you're going back to the old house
I see yeah I'm gravitating back are we
still going yeah we're still going you
know what I'm going to say is that
yeah we should probably stop here but
anyways yeah so the um
let me looks like uh wandering you're
100 I was very sensitive you you're such
a cynical guy that was so sensitive okay
I grew up in Crown Heights where like
Union Street was like taboo you didn't
walk you know what in the spirit of what
you're describing about educating people
about the Jewish way of life we just uh
made a hairpin turn because Mendy
reminded us we're heading to the block
of the women's Mikvah and it would be
the sensitive thing and the modest thing
to steer clear of there so we're not
going down that block
so
all the people of different cultures and
backgrounds listening to this right now
you learn you got a little glimpse into
our interesting
uh Slice of Life
yeah okay let's see how
I was going to say though that maybe
people virtually taking a walk with
three Jews that itself will be uh a
positive force oh I didn't want people
to think that I don't like to walk down
this block because of safety because
as you already said you're not afraid of
getting my dog is on that phone your
dogs are very safe Charlie yeah yeah
remember Charlie you don't bring her on
the walks yeah people ask me Charlie
coming up no Charlie's not coming okay
let's see here that's obvious thing he
hasn't curved his dog yet right
okay hold on a second all right hold the
Finish
okay good news guys wow 1.46 miles wow
you have any kilometers
one foot see says my 1.46 Mi run it
called it was gracious it called it a
run
very nice took screenshot
okay guys you did it awesome thank you
next week we come prepare to the topic
yeah
Central Evans coming to life