Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[music]
Are we in Yamosa Msiah?
>> A Jew in galas should never feel
comfortable where he is. Something is is
happening. And the fact that the whole
world now is against us is seems to be
what it Torah says
going to be go. The whole world's going
to come against Israel.
We're in the man called the Mashia the
very end of gas before Msiah comes. If
you're here constantly right and you're
attuned to it and you want to feel that
feeling you'll feel that feeling every
single day.
>> Today I sat down with one of the giants,
one of the leaders of the Jewish people
in Israel today who is native to the
Bronx.
And I asked him some questions. I sent
him an email and surprisingly he agreed
to do the interview. So in this video
we're going to share that interview and
I want to tell you that you will be
shocked what he said and it's probably
not what you're thinking. I wanted to
share this with you. I encourage you to
watch till the end. It's very exciting
for me to be able to finally ask some of
these questions that everybody seems to
be asking and everybody's giving
opinions and I wanted to get Das Tyra.
He's a person a RV a god who has spoken
as keynote speakers at the Torah Masor
convention at the U AOP. So without
further ado, here is Rabbi Zev Le. Are
we in Gouog? Is Msiah finally here. Take
a look. Rabbi Le, it's a true privilege
to have you with us. 40 years ago, Rab
Zev left a prominent lifelong rabbitic
post in Miami and brought his family to
a hilltop in Jerusalem with barely
electricity and barely running water and
helped pioneer Moshav Matisio, probably
the first American or one of the first
American Jewish Torah communities in
Israel. My question is like this. since
October 7th with the rise of
anti-semitism in the world and recent
election of mayor of New York. I know
you're from the Bronx and uh the Jews
have always been welcome in New York and
for the first time this has come up on
people's radar that perhaps we're no
longer welcome in Gulos. So, Rabbi Le,
could you share your insights on the
Torah view on whether every Jew should
want to be living in Israel right now
before Msiah comes? Okay, let me uh
preface with the words of the Cleoer.
The Cleoer and the PKitu.
So he says what it means is the
following. Don't
uh copy what they did in Mim. that there
were many people who were comfortable in
Misim even being slaves and didn't want
to leave and don't copy what they did
concerning Arage Israel that the Moragim
didn't want to go into Arch Israel.
A Jew in Golas should never feel
comfortable where he is. You should
realize that the place that was meant
for Clal Israel to be issel
and if it wouldn't have been for uh the
the reasons for the and the golus we
would be in Israel. A Jew outside of
Israel is not in his proper place. As
moral says it's it's not natural for a
Jew to be outside of Israel. But there
are reasons why wants that to happen
temporarily.
If a Jew understands that it's temporary
and he's always ready and waiting to be
able to return to Erit Israel where he
belongs, then uh the gulus can be a
sweet golus sometimes.
But once you get too settled in Galas
and you think that that's your place and
you have no reason and no desire to ever
go to Erit Israel then that in itself
makes the golas a very bitter golus and
sometimes the rabbon reminds us that
that's not where we belong. You can't
get too comfortable in any gulus for too
long. And the Ronis reminds us that
golus is a very temporary thing. And uh
and the desire at least to go back to
where we belong should be there.
Basically bottom line until Msiah comes
the entire Jewish people can't return to
Erit Israel on mass
but an individual thing people can
fulfill the mitzvah of Yeshua Israel as
individuals or even as individual
communities
and sometimes the gives us signs that
we're becoming too uh complacent and too
settled in a golus and thinking that
that's really where we belong. And then
he gives us signs that maybe that's not
where we belong and that's not where we
should be complacent. What's happened
since October 7th and even in America
where all over America anti-semitism is
raising its uh ugly head and even or
most mostly by the elite intelligencia
college campuses or whatever. I think
Jews have to wake up and see that even
America which was a a very very sweet
gullis and uh a land that afforded Jews
tremendous amount of uh of freedom
um it's not forever and uh therefore a
person should realize that if it's
possible for him to make a move towards
Israel and possible means that all of
the conditions will make his life in
Aris Israel Torah wise as good or better
than the Torah life that he has in
there's no reason in the world why he
shouldn't pick up and move after
planning well making sure that he can
make a parnosa making sure he has a
kahila that he can live in and have a r
and have for his children after all of
that is taken care of and today that's
becoming easier and easier to find init
then he should seriously think of uh of
uh of moving. Um if after making all
those considerations
his Torah life will definitely be better
where he is now then he has to at least
realize that he has a goal that if those
conditions change then he'll pick up and
go to Erit Israel. But uh until those
conditions change, then maybe the Rabon
wants him to be in Gulos. But he should
always be ready, especially the way the
situation is now, to be able to pick up
at a moment's notice. We should make
sure that he's not uh doesn't feel that
he's entrenched and that uh living
wherever he is, whether it's in the
United Kingdom, whether it's in the
United States or wherever, is something
that can last forever. And therefore, he
should always have a plan, a contingent
plan to be able to pick up and move as
fast as he can if the situation gets to
be one where uh it's impossible to
remain there.
>> What do we say to the person who's just
following the Torah? He's well off. He
can afford to buy a house. He may even
already own a house in Beamesh and he's,
you know, on the fence about coming to
Eritis and he could pull it off
financially. What would we say to such a
person? What would the RV say would be
the benefit in his life to be able to
come to today before Msiah comes? What's
the
I know the wrote an introduction to many
years ago. Where is the Anglo aliyah? I
think that was the the from Anglo
Aliyah. I think something to those
words. And if that is still applicable
today, can we since we have very good
yeshivas in we have very good yeshivas
in ins. So would there be an added
benefit or a reason to that a person
should come to even if he's learning
well in
>> yes
there are for sure mileers of being in
Israel. First of all, it's a mitzvah to
live there and the kaduca there is
all enveloping and it's it it has an
effect on a person's entire life and
lifestyle
um if he uses it properly. Um, so that's
the first thing and even if the there's
no there's no mitzvah
to live in Israel, but there definitely
is a mitzvah. In other words, if you're
there, you are ma mitzvah. You should
know there's no mitzvah to wear chitz.
But I don't know of too many people who
don't wear. If you have the opportunity
to put on a garment with four corners
and have the mitzvah of chitz, everybody
runs to do it. So uh somebody who has
the opportunity to have that tremendous
mitzvah of Israel which is mitzvah it's
equal weight in all the mitzvah living
in Israel. So somebody who has the
opportunity to do that and ignores it uh
flippantly out of hand obviously is not
functioning like a Jew should function.
That doesn't mean that every person has
to pick up and move to Erits Israel
because uh because of the realities that
Erit Israel is governed not by a
religious uh by the Torah but by a uh
irreligious
um secular government
and many of those elements in the
secular government are even
anti-religious.
not interested in seeing Israel be what
it really should be. So there are there
are challenges just like there are
challenges everywhere and you have to
find the right community where the right
kind of uh influence will be. You're
living amongst Jews in Eric Israel with
the kadouch of arit Israel is very very
a positive positive uh aspect to a
person's life. your children will be
around from people the the uh the
influence of the is much much less
here right even though there's an
influence of secular Jews but there's
secular Jews everywhere and there are
also uh who are much worse than
secular Jews also
so uh and if you can have find a place
where the education uh would be uh
superior or at least equal to the
education you could have init. There are
many many fine educational institutions
init
many options in Erit Israel now where a
person who's used to the kind of
education that exists in America
uh would suit him here in Eris Israel
for a long time that didn't exist and
the the the
um mode of education is was very
different in Israel and for many
children brought up init
families brought up in kutsar it was not
the kind of education that they wanted
for their children even though it was a
fine Torah education but now there are
many options here in Israel of uh really
uh good educational systems where the
the mud kesh far surpasses is whatever
they can get in hutzarets
and there's also a secular education too
which most parents who were brought up
in hutz laets are looking for so that's
an option also now and uh if you have a
rob and hutz laets that you follow you
live in a community that has direction
you have to find in Israel a similar
community a community where there's a
rov who can direct you and uh People
can't just live on their own without a
kahila and without a rov that can give
them direction. Uh parnosa is also an
issue. person who has a fine parnosa and
will have a trouble struggling in erit
Israel may take away all the mileers of
Eris Israel for that person and cause
too much stress on his family and uh and
and he'll lose out on all the mileers of
Eris Israel because of the shalom bayas
that won't be there and all of the
worries because of a lack of parnosa
taking everything in consideration
I think every Jew insets
has to realize that they're only there
temporarily and for them temporarily
mean may mean the rest of their life but
cla belong in Eric Israel and therefore
if our ancestors had the ability to come
to Erit Israel the way we do today right
just to spend some money get on a plane
relocate there's not one Jew who would
have remained in Europe but the Sahara
uh uh what's it called when it's not
possible doesn't care so he left them
with their desire now it's so easy to
come here so the sahara has to take away
the desire right because if the desire
would be there and the the
implementation is so easy who would stay
in
so theor took away the desire and they
people think that uh they can prosper
better inut
and uh there's no reason for them to
move. That idea is trait. There's
definitely a reason to be in Arish
Israel after considering all of the
options where a person's Torah life will
be the same or better then Erit Israel
is the place right if for whatever
reasons for that specific person because
of panosa education
um uh kahila wise um they their tora
life will be better in temporarily until
those situations change. That's where
they have to be. But they should feel
feel they're being there not because
they want to be there. They're there
because circumstances prevent them from
getting the nyla and having the of
living in Israel.
Maybe we could talk about something
which is not talked about enough which
is the part of and the
we experience initiat
that people have this the faith in maybe
the ro could expand on that part of the
equation
>> tells us that
is
special hashgus
in Israel and it fits us like a glove
because we're a people who have a
special hashga protise and the even
though the nit says that as an
individual Jew sometimes living in galas
you need more hashka but as a Jewish
people in general right and as the place
where you live the hashka is only in
Israel so a person comes Israel aside
from fulfilling the mitzvah of Israel
which is a constant mitzvah
points out that there's two mitzvah that
you fulfill with your entire body. One
is a mitzvah of suka, right? Your whole
body goes into the suka. And the other
is a mitzvah of Israel. I always like to
say it's even more than that. In the
suka, the ground is not really part of
the mitzvah. Just the walls and the
roof. In Israel, not only is the whole
surrounding and what's above part of the
mitzvah, what you're standing on is also
part of the mitzvah. It's even better
than the suk.
So aside from that, you have a special
closeness to Hashem. And anybody who
lives here can tell you that in their
personal lives, they feel that the is
there guiding them is there. There's
constant reminder in Israel both as a
nation and as individuals that theam is
always there. Sometimes inars you don't
necessarily feel that all the time
unless you make a tremendous effort to
push yourself to feel it. But here you
don't have to make a tremendous effort.
It's there. And not only that, but the
it's a different Torah. It's a different
learning. The same person who goes to a
coming to a dafomi in Israel is a
different dyomi. a different Torah,
different time in Torah and uh you can't
explain it. You can't explain to
somebody what's what something tastes
like, right? Something good. You have to
taste it yourself. And people who know
who come here as uh as tourists at least
know when they're here, they have that
extra special feeling. And when they go
back, they know that they lose that
feeling. If you're here constantly,
right, and you're attuned to it, uh, and
you want to feel that feeling, you'll
feel that feeling every single day. And
children become more aware of, uh, of
all the places here that refer referred
to in Tanakh. The Tanakh becomes living,
you know, places of that are called not
New Jersey and not New York but beamesh
and
and Ashkalon and Ashd and all these
places are mentioned in Tanakh. These
are the places where where our
forefathers and foremothers uh lived and
and spent their lives throughout
history. So all of those milers are
something that a person should look
forward to having barring any reasons
why for them specifically that dream
can't come true.
>> One last question and then we'll wrap it
up because I know the RV RV's time is
valuable and I thank you for your time.
Last question would be are we in Yamosa
Mashiach?
I'll tell you what the polish said. He
said, "If you ask me if Mashiach is
here, he's not here. If you ask me if I
hear his footsteps, I hear his
footsteps."
We're in the man called the Mashia. The
very end of Golas before Messiah comes.
has said the and the rebas
and the events since the holocaust have
been leading up uh uh the fact that we
have erit Israel back and the fact that
Jews have come from Russia and from
Ethiopia and from America there's a
certain kibbut golios that's taking
place and that Israel is being built up
and there tremendous
rebirth of the economic and and and um
uh the rebirth of the land
its crops or whatever is a sign that
something something is is is happening
and the fact that the whole world now is
against us is seems to be what it Torah
says the novi says going to be go the
whole world's going to come against aris
and uh and so events seem to be
progressing very quickly
towards some
end and that end we're promised is going
to be a very happy ending. So uh whether
Msiah is here or not or on the way or
not is irrelevant. The same mitzvah the
living applies whether Msiah is coming
not it's not the but if people want to
be part of what's going on and be part
of what gave us a tremendous present in
Halai it's in order to reach that level
of Bashia then you don't want to be on
the sidelines looking in you want to be
part of it and be here and be part of
what's developing And if more religious
Jews would come here, the country here
would look different because the whole
demographics would change and uh um the
majority would be here would be from
then the government would also be more
from government. So instead of sitting
in complaining about what the
government's doing here, come here and
change it.
>> Okay. Thank you, Rabbi L. If there's one
key
message from this talk, what would that
be? And uh then maybe you could lead us
out with a braha. Thank you. I think the
the the message is that every single Jew
as they have for thousands of years
since the
have dreamed and longed to return to
Erit Israel. That dream and that longing
has to be even when goal is sweet. If
everybody would realize that barring any
reasons why for them it's impossible
they would be the next day in Israel
then if you live like that then first of
all you'll live in or it's a life that
is similar to the kind of life that's
conducive in Israel and secondly when
the conditions become
possible you'll pick up and move to
Israel if you have no desire you have no
reason to think that there's something
special about living in Aris Israel then
even if the conditions were were ideal
there's no reason for you to come here
and that's something that is against the
entire
framework of what Israel is
thank you again Rabbi Le your words give
us a lot of
I appreciate your time together to see
Amen. Amen. And you keep up your good
work.
>> Thank you.
[music]