At What Point Do Things Become Muktzeh - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

Luther my boyish a making shiritori would like to welcome everyone to today's share from a vehicle zest Smith's liter on the lot s of when does something become MOOC so amigo this got slavery Nash massage specifically Hema today she is lending initial mass a buffer - and family buffer Ben Chester Ruby Ruby Haskell Benjamin Ruby type of question someone had a earlier had he had to go to Psalms up on one of these summersisle summer Shabbos ice and you had to walk quite a distance he made very early Shabbos and he's avender Lee he finished to soothe the early he benched before skia he was immaculate either keziah is pol ila and then he cleaned the table and they said it's interesting you look like like no one had eaten there was mamas nothing on the table but the nearest he went to the shelf and he came home and he realized he has a serious problem now because although he had cows on the table from the halacha snares but he ate finished the phallus and the entire Danish Moses from skia on all he had on the table was the neighbors burning eros but then again he had the cow was there and he ate to Sudha when he made Shabbos is the table looked um is it a buses do we say it becomes mooks it because we're nice rushes there was nothing but in a race or maybe it's tolian when he made Shabbos a very unique Schuyler and I'll tell you another we had a child on this pest slowest someone had a central timer that put the lights on and off and in one particular room he wanted to keep the lights off whenever off so he had a simple husband right now the lights are off all they'll do is go over to the switch the light switch and right now there's nothing there and move it from up to down from on to off so then when the timer comes and puts on all the lights this light will not go on because he closed the switch is that mutter and Chavez are young t'v of course the symbol of Shila when the fire is off of the gas range or the oven can you quickly close the knob so it won't go on with a thermostat and this and tool probably two dozen more stylists are really one specific su gear and looks it up that's the focus for today and that's what really is the circuit of me going no I don't mean the but si amigo but this is a fascinating sook-yin has looked so basically the sight is that we know looked to mean something that is separated set aside on Shabbos things that are usable you allow to move allow to eat things that are mucked up which means it's not functional it's not a Kayleigh on Shabbos you can't decide to use it a perfect example you have a see learning outdoors it's very windy on the sharpest afternoon you can pick up a stone and put it on to the page of the safe a hold down the safer why because the stone is look that is a classic example of a Varnum that's muck so if you mean I've said it before Shabbos if you designate it I want to use the stone then it is motor to use now let's ask a simple question why do you have to be me I hit it before Shabbos why do you have to prepare it I'm picking it up on Shabbos afternoon I'm getting the same use from the same stone why if I may ask it it is mutter and if I forgot to do it now on Shabbos it's the same use I'll give you a more recent Schuyler Dominica many tools on Troost they put up these cut branches and the shoulder the aisle slowest one this special is one of the GABAA he forgot he forgot to cut and prepare branches but his mouth Lee went out maturely Shabbos when already was Lewis and there were branches on the cut branches from so whatever they must have fallen down there in the winter can he pick it up and hang it up in the shul the end is now it looks but why just like the mr. Burris says if you did cut branches before Shabbos don't put it up on Shabbos like mr. Bruin Tufts a big doll I'd see if cutting test if you cut it before shoppers don't put it up on Shabbos okay that's a corner you're appearing on Shabbos for sure is that Sunday or Monday so what should you do says the mr. broom put up the branches either Erev Shabbos or Anyang tip oh so you see a ladder move a branch so why can't I go out to my to the back of the shul take some cut branches that fell off and put it up it's the same branches so obviously we're missing a point and this is based on a Gomorrah and Shabbos mm gimble again the word me glee is the key word the Amar'e discusses what was common in those days people had little chicks little chickens and they needed help getting up unto to where they stayed so he would take a Sal a basket and prop it in the right position so these F raise him these little chicks to climb onto the Sal and get into their place where they stay so the Chimera says that if the chicks the little chickens be frightened were on the Sal onto a call to laugh at the best get the ladder if they were on this basket the entire Bay neshama scheisse then even now on Shabbos when they're not on the basket its coast is clear you're not allowed to use or move the basket but if Shabbos morning you put the basket there they used it for an hour after they left you louder use the basket regular what's the difference they used it now coast is clear why is this more than this is also subtly Maura the crew the critical factor is vital of coal Danish marshes please underline that if the chicks which of course chicks are mucked up if these little apprise them were on the basket the entire Shabbos then Eve now coast is clear it remains look sir why the Thai venison readiness muscle sorry it's matzah why me going this cats are the bane of smosh's is cats are the cooler Yama this is the concept of me going which means if something is mucked up the entire bane of smash ice it had chicks on at the entire banish Marsh ice even though now it is perfectly motel afire it should be once it was looks to banish Marsh ice it smoked sir the entire Shabbos and this is quoted in shin press see climate that's the way the mr. burr explains it so this is one source in Gomorrah for the concept of me Glee if the entire banished marshes it was buxom it remains even though now it's perfectly not look so look higher I'll give you a more practical muscle they gave for all of us we know suka you know I have a knot for the seven days you can't take the walls and burn it even though you don't need it why because silk is us if I'm not questioned how about Romania Tara's you want to cook something why can you take one of the walls and assuming that there's no problem of sois let's say it fell apart already why can you take one of the walls and use it Armenia Terrace I'm talking about a narrative swirl that you know let us sit in the sukkah schmear terrace so this the camera says in souk remember Hamid base since Baena schmagges from hi Shanna Rafa leading into schmick near Terrace since the Danish much choice if you have to eat something you have to go in the sukkah so really the circle was looked to bein a slush ice because you might need it meager discs at soybean as much ice its Katsura kulla yawmin so again even though Schmidty our terrace morning there's no doubt about it it's not a sucker but since it was looked sabina schmagges it remains moocs the entire SH miniatures that's the kiddush of me go even though now it's coast is clear now book them but once it was look to Boehner Smosh ice it remains looks you're wondering why is Boehner Russia is the deciding factor why that the stemple that identifies it looked so on that worked up so push it we know that the concept of MOOCs is based on the plastic and parses mashaallah before you buy a machine she they see no ice I share your view in fact the Martin saw him that MEMS anima days there's a sheet that looks at ERISA where do you see the NAD ERISA this plastic before you buy a machine she they've seen us that she revealed even if we hold which we do that MOOCs is the rabona but Rashi and Bayard up government bears the mask of Eli Oxley mr. burr brings attention us if cotton to Zion that even if you all-star born on but the source the Ramez is this plastic viable a mushishi very new ah re pazzo it's very key smack when is the cutoff point from she she leading industry from Friday and T Shabbos that's peanuts lucious McConnell and Bayer your chest explains it that's when Shabbos actually begins so if Shabbos begins he'll face Shabbos takes the effect but be that as it may this is the aside of me going when something is muck to banish marshes it retains that status on Shabbos ah re bizarre is very understandable our to question that we began with why can't I go Shabbos afternoon and pick up a stone and use it why can't the gobbler go and take branches and you put it up on young till the terrace is because since Boehner smashed ice this son was part of the millions of stones that were mocked sir mica discuss I banish Marcia skits are you the cooler young if he had the foresight of preparing the stone then he was mcian faith in oasis a reveal so really the deciding factor is is an item move on or Moxon is it you hood or Billy you left it on the floor that easily so an economy if the gap I cut the branches before Shabbos now it's not moxa it's not just a sin now it's annoying Lewis but if he didn't it's the same branches and the same purpose but when Shabbos kicked in it was mucked up the moxa remains now that we have burqa Shem that year sight I think we should have enough information for all of our Zyliss let's let me give you an interesting question to begin with that really puts things in perspective a person was learning outdoors shall busy afternoon under his favorite apple tree he enjoys the shade and suddenly he got a nick Shabbos delivered to his door an apple fell off the tree hit him on the head well come up a little bit oh my son sent me an apple fresh as can be so the Embassy's not only you can't eat the apple but the apple is looked why this is a classic meekly because bay national says the apple was attached to the tree you can pull off an apple from the tree on Shabbos and indeed the ship owner and Xinhua base Eve giemo Parrish Sinatra minute Ilan doctormick district American out to eat it that's the famous concern of Paris a nation but the mr. Bruin see if cotton Ziya makes a point not only you can eat it but even to move it you can't why that's mobster me go discuss oil varnish washes the location of this Apple vanish marshes was on the tree it was looked when Shabbos kicked in the book the status remains me another common well-known example you have an egg farm and Mazel Tov Shabbos there are many new eggs that are born baya Chanel de BM t'v or Bashevis and I should mention that the office of me going our Shabbos an emt if you recall one of the sources of me GUI was Yom Tov Shmi near Terrace so Bailey Chanel the be Shabbos bays are McAuliffe and Bayer the egg is muxer why is the egg Moktar it's a beautiful functional egg it's not stones but here it's missing very clean away says she of you you didn't prepare it before shoppers I'll give you another case circuses around the corner and there are some people to make this mistake and it's a it's unfortunate for no reason it happens quite often either noise sucker or star fall onto the table on Shabbos or young type of circus so that's an example of me glee why since there's an is set to have Hannah from the circle or the noise cold shiver so basically this crack or this noise look as pretty as it is is a savanna Oh once it's a sir bernard so when Shabbos said in Danish Marsh says it was that it was not functional it was useless so therefore you now allow to move noise sucker or scarf that fell off but you say wait a minute I'm not having her no I'm just picking it up and putting it on the side you're right that's not her no but since there's an is Sahab a nice wash choice it becomes looks amigo disgustoid vanish Moses now here's where people make a mistake cuz then when it comes Crayola more you did you know don't touch it you know how to move it keep it there for seven days that's wrong you're not allowed to use it but you louder pick it up and put it back where it belongs if I care why not use it leaving on the tables not getting you anywhere you got to pick it up a column or it and put it back you can't use it for yourself but you can put it back where it belongs I I remember it's mucked up of course it's look sir Shabbos oh yeah I'm giving up suckers but not Kayla my it and this is all in tough fresh lime butter sea bass with the mr. brewer explaining that you allow to put it back on so I'll avoid and that's a pushes the case where it's really not looked Sun column oil listen to a case the boys are playing ball with the children that these big balls and they got stuck in a tree and they can't get it it's too high nope a fallen viola hasar and kiss forget it shop this morning there's a strong wind and the ball comes tumbling down so this rabbi psy is a simple example of me Glee since Boehner smashes the ball was on the tree this Anisa this is based on shin Lambertville Seif olive is it is too climbing on the tree getting something from the tree so this ball when Shabbos kicked in was looked up even though it was a perfectly usable ball Mika disgustoid being a smart choice it's cats are you look cooler young in fact if someone put an item onto the tree straight onto the tree hung his jacket and he put at the epoch of Honor to stay there that's also looked even if it falls off well you boy you can't take it off but if it falls off it remains mucked listen to a beautiful Schuyler a person and an expensive Vaz so much so they didn't use it for any purpose he kept it in the breakfront for him the Vaz was a Mook sumac masuren kiss he didn't use it even for flowers is kept in the breakfront it was very valuable no one of his grandchildren decided to play with it and broke it into four pieces so instead of getting angry he decided to be smart you know he rolled with the punches he's all wonderful now we have four covers to keep the tea hot it was for crack pieces and it was pretty flat we're gonna use it from now on to cover the tea we'll keep it hot very creative victaulic and the hurries right because now it's no longer stirring kiss I mean it's broken it's also not mucked sumac must goofy because it works to cover the team but he forgot the key word of negligence sub DeMorgan Aram and shim festive caught me a test with the Hezbollah Boucher's rod since been a smash days Came this Vaz was Gish temple was identified as milk sumac masuren kiss is kuitar the cooler yama i the item changed the true the item changed but it still looks a maximus of meekly now what he could do is keep up his positive attitude and f the Shabbos be me after date for a cover a lots of it so he sighed and next job is and the he could use it but for this sharpest ones it's not some it smokes if a Gewehr has a very big finish that there's no biggest cut so by soren kiss I ain't some but the PI scheme don't seem to accept that how about a regular Kayleigh a regular cheap VARs they're broke and the same scenario it's functional he can use it lots of its goofy side to cover that's fine because then it was not mocked eBay - washes a person had a nest rig a very expensive s rig it fell down and it broke but kids it's pusle and it feels broken about it's a pretty expensive drop since I'd let me make at least s week jelly will have it look of adjunctive you know I always say an SUV is the most expensive food in the world that's around the $400 a pound that's the size when I make some I go use it so this is also wrong this is tough race Samba hey Steve olive the macabre says if you designate a nester it to use on circus it becomes mocked up you can't have enough cold shiver because it's a mitzvah says you have to keep it for a mixer once you can have an Oracle shiver it's not the Kosovo so a broken s rig on Yom t'v is Mook so you can't move it on calamari you could move it but you can't use it that is cat sorry that's the Easter is oven our culture listen to a very thought-provoking question they gaya every single shoppers may be tilted I didn't think about it but this is a good question but to make to give us the more enjoyment for the question let me let me tell you the following my sister who you someone made a Chaba Sheva breakfast for a cluster that added it came from a difficult family bucket so he made the Shabbos ellebra because it was a very lavish affair and by the Shabbos chef like before Hanukkah he spoke about the Causton and glowing terms he's like this stick toyour like the menorah and then he said presented a very beautiful gift a Newman IRA that he could use for Hanukkah Ballena Latoya and he's making this wonderful presentation and summer screamed what are you doing I'm an iris look to trap it and there went his whole presentation a was totally humiliated is the car no right or wrong so firstly don't embarrass anybody for album that was wrong but the emesis could be out of here loca that manner is not booked so now what do I mean if the binoy is soren kiss he would designate it he wouldn't you know leave it around then he's probably right it smokes I'm talking about it's a nice vanilla but it's not a stirring kiss then this Moraira can be given as a gift why let's think well I'm an IRA or elijah candelabra when they're not holding a fire on Shabbos but he didn't use the last on Shabbos what type of looks is it a cliche melaka lista no a cliche Malak Taylor is sir you ladder use a circle for McCoy my subtopic IVA ager in Simmons involve chief cotton pest valve on the bargain i from he says a menorah a candelabra that was burning during Shabbos is a bustah to the fire that we don't move but for dr. Becky Vega amenorrhea that was or life stuff he's taught my life that she that was not yet used in the worst scenario it's a cliche more laughter Lisa dr. Becky Vega that's why the many gives to give Hassan by the shava shava breakfast a life as a gift I had smoked up Raja someone gives a lifetime job but still screaming him but even I use it yes it's a red book leasable dr. Lissa giving it as a gift is syrup good boy so my Mela life the Ormond area that was not used is mucked up but you gotta use of the term goofing scenario-based I'm gonna ask you a very simple question why do we have this whole issue about pretty holla on the table because if not the life this looks and the left and the table becomes Mook so what's the big deal after the candles burn out the lines is a Klee symulast Alissa so pick up the life to Trey and move it why do you have to have Kunsan you put tablecloths and you cut around and you can lift it just move the last of Turku for you want to make this ever brought you want to make a thumbs up why can you move the life stay after the bird a fire burned out excellent question suck tea mug and I've ramen the mr. brewer a scientist Steve olive the macabre says that the life stuff even though the fire burned dad is looked 'some why is it looked so now there's no fire this is a classic me GUI since the fire was burning the entire banished much ice so the life that becomes a book of bosses bosses 2h Asia smack masculine even though the fire went out the life the retains the status of Mook sir Maximus go fight and that could affect the table but here we have a snoo example of busts of me go diskette sorry the banished motion only bizarre is very poshest if you didn't use the light before on sharpness let's say this life still you kept in the breakfront or the man IRA so it was not me Glee what is the worst extent of its look sir it's cliche Melissa then appear egg is right you could give it as a gift so giving him a ton is only let's our Europe Shabbos that's a good question and the chat is giving a costume is a toy of Shabbos he feels good about it so that would not be the problem or else you can be mocked it before Shabbos either one is the easel fine I'll give you a beautiful example of me going in contemporary society again imagine that all the lights went off in the house there's a sensual time of clothes all the lights you don't want the light to go on in the bedroom because phrase you want to sleep in the afternoon so now with the lights are off you're gonna move the switch the light switch from on to off and your nothing is happening nothing electronically is happening I'm moving the switch what's wrong I'm not making to go on or off it's paying off you're right there's no melaka involved but the light switch is look since bein a smart choice you are now allowed to put the lighter on a row of so the light switch is a classic maybe the Scots are bein as much ice and the same is true when a oven or a gas range I'm talking about a non electrical it's basically a thermostat puts it on and off when the fire of the oven is off the thermos I put it off can you close the knob so that it won't go on when it gets cold again no electricity so the answer is there's no melaka involved but this is a problem of me glue the knob is Mook to burnish washes the same is true for a gas range the fire went out you want to close it there's no more luck of course this is a question of Mickey disc a toy now this I saw the schmira Shabbos in your demo curfew dollar diamond cause it's cooking a Laughlin crest and basically you've gotten a say this this simple you soy that a switch of a light gas range oven is moocs ultimately now of course it's partially a gas range that the fact that the fire is off but the it's still feeding gas in a corner about the allowed to close it if need be even be a dying better through - II know but the katana gimmick or farmers test them out you have to close it but the top only is that a innocent switch or a gas range knob or oven knob is a regular case of meekley now I should add the case of the gas range or the oven knob onion tip would not be a problem why not cuz young to you how to adjust the flame so it's not me to discuss our lebanner smashes the only problem on yom did you have is with the light switch because the light switch you can't use even onion tip but here you see a simple application of an old-fashioned me GUI situation listen to a beautiful Shila again a very thought-provoking Shila someone came home during a short Erev Shabbos winter Erev Shabbos he was stuck in traffic it's literally four minutes before this man so very quickly takes the meat and potatoes and Bali everything throws it in put slim down the blue puts on the fire push the shown on top of it and he made this mine by one minutes he has it a set for Shabbos now when Shabbos begins he has a hora he has a hundred percent motor charlington he put on the black there's no cash in MacArthur now cooking on Shabbos question it might be 100 percent most amit sadh melaka but why isn't a hundred percent milk so you look at the beans the barley the potatoes the meat they're all wrong now if you have a huge flame no so hopefully it gets cooked somewhat but let's say he has a big shot with a normal-sized plane we have a right to assume that the entire Bay national shows the cholent every part of it was wrong why don't we say it's a hundred percent looks not 100 percent water it was MOOCs urbane ashlashtik but now I'll ask you a better question we know in healthy Shabbos there's a concept of kids DeKeyser you throw a raw piece of meat into the challenge it makes a motor as a make a motor it smokes so here we come to the second half of our sukhiya which really modifies the concept of me Glee the gomorian bay at the end of curve of my bass asks what to us might be a strange question but it's not frag the Gemara you have a fully cooked chalant on the fire from before Shabbos even though it's fully edible but lamai sub during the entire Bay national chase it is steaming hot the piping hot you can't even eat the shell because it's so hot frag to Gomorrah and barrier cover of McKay's how could we take off the Chong and enjoy your child this morning the entire Bay nurse master is the chalant was my mission edibles so hot so meatiness got soy bean as schmagges got sorry the cooler urema that isn't that wrong but l'm ice it's inedible so the Gemara says alright that's not a costume God will but they are dumb like uh me boil egg so Rashi explains Kievan to be our they'll attack my baby oil lame axle immediately in other words true during the entire banished masses it technically wasn't edible because it was on the fire getting hotter and hotter but if you decide to have chalant paint I smash this you could take it off put it in a plate wait a minute or two and then it's edible that's what's called gum Ruby they are them in other words if something is inedible mom-ish that's look so stones tree branches but the child is really fully cooked nervous right now it's steaming hot okay so have good alt take it off the fire wait a minute or two and then it's ready what's the chat very posh it the asylum looks is that you be Italian or you didn't prepare it but here you put the child on to you to enjoy it God will be the other means you're confident then it will be ready you don't need a miracle it will be ready that's why it's not look so it's not that if you're dying it's not mobster so although the game are talking about a fully cooked steaming hot shell and if you look in Shabbos tasty Shabbos Goffman diamond Amidala still mask libido dices says the same thing applies to a raw talent that will definitely be ready by tomorrow morning because you don't need a miracle you put a child on the fire sometimes at night early morning good morning but the show gets cooked that's also not look so even though Boehner smash ice it was not royal but since by nature you don't have to come on to a special miracle since naturally it will be ready that's God will be they are dumb and therefore it's not mocassin that explains could you the Kaiser true it's raw banish monsters but you know you don't need something supernatural it will be ready this is the second half of me gloomy Glee is awesome gamma with the other miss Muslims laboulaye shroud and senior on the task is cutting down on my murder case if cutting they both say God will be dare you Adam is live - could be they are them not you have to do something as long as it's done the ickey is it's not grumble predation I am the great Redeemer explains something that might have been depending on the weather depending on the you know a circumstance if you need a special circumstance that's look so but Gummer be the other means it will naturally be ready that's not MOOCs also a bizarre we understand even though the challenge Benesch marshes was completely raw but just have patience three hours later four hours later I don't know whatever it is it's gonna be more gonna be mutter so even though though it is now baton book sir or is it not inedible it's not mocked sir because there's no there's no is of me going since we have a gum room but now I'm gonna ask you a fascinating question let's say the same story you slammed the chones on to the bluff a minute before Shabbos ten minutes later you realize that if you're gonna keep it where it is it's gonna get burnt soon you're afraid you might forget so you want to move this completely reward Charlotte a little off the fire so it won't burn can you move this watch all and Danish moss rice off the fire see wondering what's the Shila it's not Bissell if I'm moving away from the fire the question is right now it's wrong it looked very smoke sir how could you move it well let's see you decide you know I don't want to have Joan Travis I'm gonna go away for Shabbos you want to take the chunk off the fire and put it in the refrigerator it's not hot no problem the problem is is it wrong yes is it mobster replace they believe it or not Zil buster timer it's not look sir since the miser you prepared this as a challenge so and Gombu they are dumb it's now Moxon you made the Asahina waste I'll share your video you made the Oksana and if you look into Rob and shins off a sieve of he says there's no look sir by a raw talent I feel there been a small choice but I die when it's on the in a row but nature ain't a Mack zoomi man who died to cloud the banished monsters in other words I'll tell you okay this message the Rob I think means to say when you took the beans and the barley and the raw potatoes and the raw meat and you put it into the Challon pot that's the Hana it's like taking a stone and be making it I'll say wait a minute a stone is functional your child isn't because make it feel like you were making this Chavan pot with all the contents even though it is not edible yet but for that we're going to say gamma with the other so gun will be the autumn and a sauna makes raw sharland into non look so this has the initiative ml of Kazan actually the Pima garden the end of Shimkus also is maker for this forum so raw bali raw beans raw potatoes raw cat raw meat that you didn't prepare for the challenge is Takamatsu once you made the economy boy join or be in a minute before this man the raw child is not mocked now are you gonna say wait a second I remember something very similar we learned myself to Shabbos except the barrier that famous story of Gregory's food smoking you took fully edible fruit and put it to dry so the lava is it smoked son I why is it mocked up so you look in the macabre inch injured with Mohammed discusses this case he says because hey my sweet ice cut them shall UCF's you the Matthias is that these Gregor's have smoked them and you start over them they're edible when you put them on the roof to draw you put them in water it gets spoiled sup the mr. brewer and see if cut and pass when you put it in the status that it's going to be an edible domain of shamash ice it's much worse it's inedible not just raw and edible and also you were you are max for me das you put it on edible to inedible but I was thinking the raw talent was inedible ten edible here to make it worse but since you were amazing it the raw olive will not be matzah today a new care a new example of gumbo but they are dumb people by avocado and basically before Shabbos is not yet right but my shell should this will be okay or bananas or to the umpteenth read am giving these foods Valera this is a good candidate for me going since Bainer smash ice when Shabbos said in the avocado was not yet edible so even those Charles Judas it's wrong it should be mocked up but the answer is this is a case of gum every day other you're not hoping for a miracle naturally Chavez comes as the avocado gets soft up the bananas get ready so this is really included in shocking option you'd see vase that fruits even though they're not fully ripe are not look to because they will be ripe began to South America adds but Greg Lewis is smoking that you put into onto the roof with water and it got spoiled that's worse the truth is mr. Byrne sieve cutting test points out that most fruits even though they're not fully ripe but banished marshes there are somewhat edible if it's somewhat edible so even men are schmagges it's not mocked up father there's no problem of moocs at all here's a summer silent who could be winter also but specially there in the summer people go to the McFerrin shoppers take you shower or both and they want to hang up the towel to use a job this morning for the mikveh so the higher up will you hung up a wet towel which is not usable McCoy it should be mopped some so even though when you come shop this morning the towel is dry why don't we say me going the answer is yes you're right but this is also gum rule the governor overrides the me going since you don't need you don't need need a son even if it's cloudy you hung up the towel in a good place outdoors it rise so the towel would be me good it's got soy true but since its gun Ruby they are dumb that's why it's not mobster on Shabbos morning now again you might remember something that seems to be inconsistent with this the a latke is if a towel fell into a felon - there's the mikveh home for the pool and it's dripping wet sopping wet that is Mook sir the entire Shabbos the macabre says this instant I love member because i'm a streamer maíam you now let move them why oh so here's the catch it's even also to move this towel simmer your viola de sita so that is more than just a wet used towel that's a dripping wet towel it's up to mr. Gura if it stay fair coming as latvia its Assad to use the towel the entire Shabbos Al's neatly but that's not a cash on our you saw it because that first of all that might not be ready if it's not a sunny day it might not be ready so practically it's not even a guaranteed gum room but there's a more fundamental parrots there's an issue there a bond on to move of a sopping wet towel you might come to Sita once is it isn't there a button to move it then Gumba the oven doesn't work sup T McConnell and beiieve of the padishah see it's looks the fest out of quotes Arbor Yasha once this independent it says there are born to move a wet towel Danish marsh ice that even its come with the other but still awesome has thou asked it to use this terrible banished marshes gun was not going to work when there's gum with the other work on a moderate moderately wet towel pain our marshes it was wet but there's no it's to the touch it so the problem is you can't use it as it's wet hang it up come with the other miss look so the philic basically is a very wet towel that's the problem of Skeeter that won't help hanging it up a regular towel that we use in shower mikvah is wet but it's not dripping there's no shush them you'll be discreet them if you hung it up you're allowed to use it on Shabbos morning Beier should know the boo Shabbos or beyond t'v why is it looked why isn't that gum before the other I know Friday afternoon is going to come out be born on Shabbos good question the answer is the same insight synth is Anissa of baya Shinoda because of the lack of Ohana then gum rule will not work listen to a question a person got a Stickle tiara from his son and arity Stroh literally hot off the press and this happens all the time either shallow sugar syrup or Neela's a cocktail from the receiver of the row of the ribbon air to show the Sun was there wrote it up and he faxed it to his parents in America so they received it in time for meals ACOG Machado sure this it comes in a nicely printed tickle tiara on Shabbos you know afternoon it's a seven-hour difference so he has time to have a choppy afternoon question can you read move enjoy mystical terror that was facts emeritus row amateurish abysm Atari I'm Dib and you received it on Shabbos or young teeth so when a fax machine makes noise that shouldn't be done also optional we're talking about either a silent machine or it's in the basement nope no Malaka but the booth believe it or not this might be a problem me clean because the paper when Shabbos came or youngters came was blank paper whichever looks a blank paper is but blank paper still looked so good today it's not concerning kiss maybe maybe it's but it still looks about my school fight so this paper was identified banished Marsha says look sir so even though now it has a prominent tickle tiger why is nemo pizza the answer is this is also the head of gamma B they are them you were waiting you were anxiously anticipating your son to write you that tickle so even though the paper was mucked up but you don't need a miracle it's very sick today it's almost you know natural the son writes it prints it up he faxed it to his parents so here we have both cases it's taka Danish washes its looks but it will be gum Ruby day autumn you know Lena someone has to go to the hospital on Shabbos so they start pressing buttons and paper information and bracelets everything starts happening on Chavez you think about it that should be mucked up the papers looked it was mucked diminish ma says the bracelet was mocked them but assuming again that it's natural these things happen so you know and the from a hospital you have to think about it but certainly nagashi shall flow for them it's regular usable items and they ever happy to do it you have had to use it this would be gum Ruby day order and I give this your hospital there after you have to worry about if Malakal was done then you have a nice enough melaka but the way it is very often this is a simple case of gamma b de autumn listen to an intriguing questions because it's a new scenario where gum rule and me going sort of conflicts imagine a person on a random Tuesday made a delicious roast and putting it away for shop for chevre brokers next Tuesday so you put it in the special freezer in the basement that the items become frozen you know the upstairs kitchen freezes more open than clothes doesn't mean get frozen but you put it become fun in the basement freezer it's gonna be frozen solid and so you'll have it fresh for the sheva brachot or you make shower again you're putting away forever bronchus suddenly doesn't need on Chavez to jump did you want to defrost the meat and serve it Chavez you'll serve it cold jumped of your warm it or the Fowler's the kids up you want to take an item that on Danish mush ice was frozen solid mamas inedible can you take it out on Chavez good morning and let the frost and you'll slice it you'll serve cold roast so you think about it this was a case of me Glee the entire Bainer schmagges it was frozen solid more so the fact you put it into the freezer after the basement freezer night and be a doctor be Italian but then again this is gonna be the autumn what we have to do is take it out and wait a while but we could do better than that this was later is it a pharisee tomorrow are you wondering it enough reason time to the Gemara but this might be no different believe it or not in the case of the boiling hot pots boiling hot pots you can't eat peanuts masters but all you need is just a slight you know change and it's what why can't we appear why can we compare frozen solid I'd innocence and an interesting analogy to a boiling hot pot of soup both of them are edible foods that have with any little tickle and tack up Slainte miss Alma and achievement Atul a Shabbos Simmons ayan someone Esther mom is this case they put it in the freezer but qivana to be deferred their fish ever broca's but he says doesn't make a killing even though boehner smashes it was totally inedible but it's Gummer but they are them take it out of the freezer and have patience and wait now I saw the artifice Jarvis Haley Bay's on the grace Bay's s but why is it different in the case of a frightened the the salah' further they're frightened he says there you want it to be designated for look sir here you want it to stay fresh you don't want it to be mocked so you wanted to stay fresh and also food the cloud is different than than a sow so I think the nursery I would like to say is you froze it to be ready to eat so if Shabbos you want to eat it why is it worse the fact they wanted to the instead of shoppers but you froze it to keep it ready to eat Leah fries them you wanted the ladder to be fair fry from that smoke sir now I did see reversal inhaler gimel Simmons off test he's speaking about raw meat that's edible but he says frozen meat pushes my is Moktar he doesn't explain much but I then saw Bianca fish in the oven you sir okay the custom in your tests he says this case of frozen cooked meat is moksa i what about gum rule say he points to a rich for the ritz vote asks why is the african sound moxa is gamma but they are them you could just chase off all the African the parrot says if you adopt aviod I am you put it there to be there their entire Boehner smash ice that he'll be a diam overrides gamma B they are them so therefore he says I think that frozen food even fully cooked is mocked so it is gamma B they are dumb but that Phoebe a diam overrides that that's where we saw yank official baskets now it's a tremendous credits because a fully cooked food you could be frosted why is it dr. Bhatia died Imam is I mean I my sir there's always the the back your mind you might use it so I yesterday actually someone heard I said this and she has somebody else and someone said you know what you don't understand he's inherit Searles income you knew Absalon q very well this too was written probably 3040 years ago the mentality in Eretz role was I know about today but certainly was you put things in the freezer not the freezer till Shabbos you know you bake collar you ate it putting in the freezer was a darker be a dying you you you probably couldn't even find it afterwards it was more again more emotionally attached to be Italian so today that you put thing in the freezer on Thursday for Shabbos morning it's not that to be Italian whether that's true or not is irrelevant but I saw many postscript on Mako frozen foods even though you put it into the freezer is not a doctor be a diam it's a gamma bidet other my sister hire someone the wife realized that she left refrigerator light on so when you open the door the light will go on so well you should have done she should have done is called a guy who I say this being a smash is called a guy to rectify the problem but she sighed to waits for a husband to come home he's a pie see the rest of the bicycle basket he comes home he says okay we have to call the guy okay Marie she said then the husband tackle was atomic are coming goes wait a minute the light bulb was in the frigerator the entire boehner smashes we couldn't open the fridge way the entire boehner smashes why don't we say that all the food is now mocked sir I don't think she appreciated his lumbus but why isn't he wisely right so the MS is he's right too in the frigerator right some sheep this is a maloha there Isum it's a situation of putting on a light but then again think about it the problem is not in the food the problems in the refrigerator it's I read the ravioli plus we have solutions calling a guy so it comes out that it's probably better than the raw Holland that gum boo-boo they are them is a hectare for raw challenge calls gave a perfectly edible food and you're looking tough so hunger tough cope with Cassie's test myself is empty but it's talking about food that was locked up and you couldn't get to it Danish marshes it was locked and there was no way to get in and someone broke the door down or dinner melaka so if you need an accessorize to get to the food maybe the food is MOOCs but if you just even this as they are born on so the food is not booked sir it's an excessive not mope sir so that's why our case there would be a good Hector this case the food is edible just as a problem so you'll solve the problem and the food indeed is not much abstain Mazama time enforce laymen a beautiful children Taylor I love salmon good has an even more sensitive question someone asked him I'm a kid not to open refrigerator when the motor is off let's say so let's assume I know for a fact that the motor was off of the fridge the entire banished monsters why don't we say migas casuaiiy banish washes so that he says the terrace is posh it there's no problem with the food you have an a to the open it boy - Hector and also he says that's not that would be Italian you plug in the frigerator two years ago you didn't make that to be a diet so it's not that could be a diet and basically it's motor buddy goes through the SU gear very beautifully iron Shum someone put on right before going to shorts Friday these things happen all the time you came on very very late very delayed so you put on the dryer button or the dishwasher or both a minute before this man and so both are going the entire Bainer smushes which attack is not right because it makes noise but the question is now that it finished the cycle can use the clothing from the dryer or the this is from the dishwasher so Lambton will say oh wait a minute this is me going because Venice Moses you can open it it's going you're right but it's also a built-in guaranteed gum booboo they are them because after an hour or so everything is ready so it is a Miku but it's also a gum right I saw the say for earthly Shabbos and with cooked I leave up quotes to kasi nish that someone who's not gonna have to open cans on Chavez and someone opened it he can't use the content because the food inside is look sir now that's because in history sheeter see they're opening a can of malacca there ISO so even though the food is edible as it is but if you need a melaka their eyes set to open the can then the food becomes looked so much inhaling dollar coffee attest hey and hey suburb called outlet is not concerned about moocs least worried about if a good if so you did it for you obviously he held that since there are ways of opening it and the food itself is okay it's just I read the raviolo that would not become Moksa of anus Malaysia I'm gonna ask you a question that maybe till today you didn't think of but I think it's a cushion if law we know the problem of the halo Granero Shabbos it makes the life of the MOOC - it makes the table books you have to put down column let me ask you a simple question what's the problem what do you have against the poor life stuff aina Kaname if it's a busses to the fire so the life is looks at the tables look so but you buy either three hour candles or five-hour candles either case it's limited why do we say every key Shabbos candles that you light our gumbo per day other three five seven makes no silica you use oils that Kenya was fine but it comes to an end so every Shabbos candle is a built-in gamma B they are them so why is it looked so and lavash ice rod ingenuity contest asked this question via cephalic and it's good better question the original case of me GUI of is also gum booboo they are them they're gonna go on Boehner smashes and a few minutes later but that's it so why isn't every case of - gamma B the other y hat Charlotte is OK and frozen the meat of frozen food is ok Android shells and avocado is good and why is pugna rice and a fry some different we think about it I think it Terrace is very posh it when you light candles for 3 or 5 hours you want it to burn for three or five hours you want it to be in that state you can't say god rule when you want it to be like that you want it to be that the entire Bay nice lush lace you put the ladder for the afresh you want it to be there all the other cases you want to get rid of a problem you want to be making it I want to make watch on cook I want to be frost I want the avocado to get ripe as soon as you can via challah is what you're doing here you're doing am I so deeply you want to light it for five hours now I think it's an embassy aside and the aside that I got from missed Isis twice and Shabbos mem gimble asked why isn't a phrase him a case of GaN room the rich var in Bayer comes in is the same question and when I think that Paris like we said if you want it to be moxa your market the function is the Ephraim should have a ladder you want it to be moved you want the neighbors to burn the cases of gun room is you want it to be ready however now but you have to wait you have to wait till the showing cools off or boils or the palate defrost or the avocado ripens all the cases of gun rule is you want it to be ready now with an amazing honor now these two cases the price them and they arise you did a myself deeply you want it to be like that and that's why it's booked last group of questions also a beautiful Aurora let me ask you to follow me shylu its mogera every single shop if someone comes to a Psalms Elka and he takes he's busy with his pistachio nuts and he took a nice China plate and he filled it with pistachio nut shells which are not edible now he has a gouge Allah Thomas all play them up sir how could he move it so he knows her locker he puts a morsel of food the face of jellybeans on it picks up the plate goes to the garbage and he's very quick he grabs and throws it grabs the jellybeans and all these shells go into garbage and he moved the mixer and now he has a trying to play back functional question why don't we say that it was looked at one point it was a boss's only four shells why don't we say Moksa the answer is you stop short true we say meekly but mEagle is based on me boy this got soil of a national size this China played banished marshes is perfectly motive when did it become problem during Chavez this robbery is the question of a Gomorrah and Bayer coverman days eh look to the fatty Shabbos I am boxer which means if it was looked Bane hush mosh ice then if then death me glee but if it became booked on Shabbos so we're a she explains when it's film looks when it's felt a base only for look the shells it's a problem but if you got rid of it the head by lifting up the plate because now the plate is also a bosses for the morsel of food it's a bus a hat Anissa and you got rid of their MOOC the Beretta now the plate goes back to which status I me going carrots is not measly it's not making us get soy banished from Alsace this is the concept of a MOOC to the fatty Shabbos when something was vanish Marsh is a problem it's a problem when something was banished Marsh is fine on Shabbos of a game a problem then if you move the problem you remove this perfect example you're learning outdoor shop is afternoon and a branch falls onto your table so let's say there's nothing on table but the branch so the table is a branch for the mixer true but just tilt the table the branch goes off and now it's motor biggest sorry's not a ploy is not Danish monstrous I'll give you a much better example and this is a commonly asked question summer wants to take the garbage can bring it to the table and clean up after the simile after the Psalms okay if there's I pursue them it's not so positive that that's right if Danish masters there was garbage in the garbage can so once you threw it out been a smash sighs we say me good and the garbage can becomes a buses for the moccasin some people put before chávez they put Hector in the garbage can he put a garbage bag somebody put a can of tuna and it's the assumed you later open two non Chavez but then it's fine because you have health Anissa but if it was just garbage that's inedible that's not usable even if it you someone could eat it but you threw it out then the garbage can became up sir so what's the ate sir empty the garbage can before Shabbos and now I uncharged is you put more garbage but since there is some usable food it's still edible something usable it was not it's a banished marshes so then the Hector could override the issue but the point is to realize that it's not simple to move a garbage can unless you have a Hector listen to a fascinating Schuyler someone is I set to make a Mila on Shabbos he has a and he's a Moyo he has this issue a meal a knife is a classic books of Sauron kiss so of course you gotta use the Miele knife for the Mila it's time for Shabbos certain books but the question is can I put it some people put it in the baby's crib overnight night before the Mila some people that the idea Ben gives the Mila knife to the boil to do the Mila is it mutter before or after the Mila can the moil put it down in his satchel is you have to drop it so this is a very tricky question because the truth is Friday night it's the same concern kiss he wouldn't use the Mila knife to cut a sandwich it still concern kiss maybe it migas got so he banished from our choice is mocassin I how could he use it for Mila cuz the mid slow but then again believe it or not will say aim looks Locati Shabbos since he's allowed to use it on Shabbos go ahead it's not mobster and that's the sheath of the marshal and achieve and simin men and there are more quotes it also passing like this and you're there in your idea that the Miele knife if you have a Miele on Shabbos is not booked to keep it however the maken I've robbed and Shem mom and I love says I don't understand that it's motor to use for the Mitzvah but it still me it still looks even made our smash days because if you can't use it for non-military many pay scheme that I'm a smear that you should not move it for no reason the moil when he finishes making the meal don't put it down and then say can I move it away put it down originally in a strategic place that will be safe but what I did see Rev Osmonds hey look down at cooked lamb and he points out that if to put it in the baby's crib before a Friday night or the father giving it to the moil on Shabbos that's part of the Mitzvah and you know I'm not going to do that so that might not be MOOCs - even from Boehner schmagges I was to use it for a sandwich of course is us to put it away after the Miller and a good place that's the way it should be done but this last Pratt is yesh logical and after and cover by say we have the questions we began with someone had a suit early sooo the Friday night he mama started early and he couldn't wait he benched before skia he had fell on the table the entire suitor but from the entire Boehner smash ice there was only burning candles and nothing else of Hector so believe it or not this is a problem dr. P mcgovney and the race I intest if this since the heta or the it's actually both of them kicks in Danish Marsh ice so look Danish marshals well do you have a national choice only in a race I had to sue the entire my Shabbos but think about it the smarter of me describing a smart race is when Shabbos because Shabbos proper begins not your personal Shabbos so in this case it's a problem if he had it on for part of a nice wash nice to foul up that's a different shy if you have to have the entire Boehner smash is a part of it that's a different sugar but definitely the higher being my ccbhc no it has to be on Boehner Smosh a dog to you'll say making sure like UPS acai October Smith for today she like your biggest you care for this sponsor today she'll initial aside buffer you can it's been over four billion little times over yes will be a Missoula shmita well the like asbestosis sponsoring a shear call arrogant you retire at seven one eight eight five one eight six five one okay well Smith will say a cecum of today she in five minutes come on Yvonne Akashi motorcycle as vocal as I guess it's a solar figure here when I'm telling him it's loose Shane Emily no Hoffa Samantha yeah go to the other [Music] Darby's however you submarine who [Music] Charlotte okay boys I banish muscles all this is mana ready for the cecum just take five minutes you learn today we learned a lot let's try to put it Lamesa the site of MOOCs is something that's not Mullen everything has to be MOOC on that Kino besides of course Asha today for I for the Michele de Chaillot there has to be a corner something that is not inherently a Kaley or annoyance or after the accident you may thin it the important you cite is something that was vain as monstrous looks even if the story change and now it's perfectly usable but McGinnis got Zoey since been a smash this is when Shabbos sets in that's when you have to have a Nahanni and once been a small choice it was looked so it remains look to even though the circumstance is no longer consider it looked so now etcetera but doesn't make a difference if banished marshals looked that's can say banished magis you want to use a stone or branch any item you have to making it before shop is not on Chavez a fruit fell off the tree that's look too even though the Apple is edible this is me gooey a base you know the beyond t'v is a lack of a Hana no you suck the stock fell onto the table on Shabbos or youngters besides you can't use it for personal use you can't even move it polymer you ought to put it back because there's no it's a butcher but you can't use it and therefore you can't move it on Chavez or young tit a ball or an item on the tree and since you couldn't go up on chopping on Chavez take it off so that would live look some and even if it falls off it would would be considered still look - in MOOC - Marcos of a soaring kiss that broke into pieces that are usable as as the broken pieces are but since banished washes it was look sir it retains the status of MOOCs ooh a parcel of Asterix since you can't have enough from it you can't even move it on Chavez a young tip that's me - Scott sorry levena schmuck like - after the fire went out are no longer buses for the fire but since banished marshes it was a buses for the fire it's not a regular cliche philosophy lista like we said it is a mix of buses which is much more severe a light switch an oven or a gas range knob are all considered mica this gets a banished masters even though there's no Malacca in flipping the switch or moving the oven knob but on yom t'v we allow to use the oven or gas range so closing the knob is okay adjusting but on Shabbos the three of them the light switch the oven knob or gas range knob are moxa even if no melaka takes place a roach island been a smash ace is gum Ruby they are dumb and not only that it's even motor to move when it's raw cuz you owe me after that that's the health of kid to the Kaiser and again even when it's raw it's still mortem an avocado or banana that is somewhat edible banished master so even if not if it's gummy but the autumn you allow to use it when it becomes edible you hung up a towel Friday afternoon to the Shabbos it's motive to use it unless it's sapling what is Xavier their opponent of using the tower of the entire Bay nationalists receive the facts on Shabbos it's gummy but they are dumb you expected it that would be mortem frozen food most place keema Mako even though you put it away but it's still edible you could change your mind a fridge that had a light bulb on the entire Bay National State does not make the food mixer there's an eight sir and the food is edible if you mark - not to open the fridge when it's the mode is off it still doesn't make the food looks as we explained a dry eye or a dishwasher that's going in Thai banished Masha does not make the contents look so this is gum rule canned food most pie skin holders not mooks it because there is an ASA to open it when you have we asked the question why neighbors are not gum Babu they are dumb the answer is you want it to burn the entire Bainer schmagges books are on Shabbos as a mooks Locati Shabbos a plate of shells or a branch on the table it Stockham up sir right then but if you get rid of them look to the plate or the table remains heta because ain't look Tallahassee Shabbos after the MOOC to us we see this fine is no shell meal of the the Milam but their cloud amok but to put it away right after the miele in a safe place originally but you could be making to put it in the baby's crib or IV I've been handing it to the to the Mayo if someone has a MOOCs that he made early Shabbos and then they took off the foul as he finished the colors when Boehner smashes came the entire table is Musa because the concept of MOOCs are this cat soy is not Holly and your Shabbos it's totally in Shabbos proper