Auto Collisions In Halacha - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

both cars that does the damage and how does I walk of view a collision that really both cars were partially responsible how about if we don't know who was responsible and we feel sort of helpless how you gonna find the collision and hallucinate and have caused in those days and also what magic is the magic of car and you learn receptive of a camera these are bonuses ikan which mazak is the magic of car to some people think in other ways some people drive it's a car gyro and it's something like sure but we're telling jali which magic is the magic of a car and this is really the beauty of the sucio we'll find the three sources in has ow exactly for collisions will find exactly a precedent for car accident and I think I could almost say that it's will reduce it to one word the answer to all of our questions is basically one word applying it properly the rush in the chuhwa and Ximena McLeod cook olive CPA has a interesting vinegar I can't explain the meaning but the minute was that the custom after the Cooper went together with some of his friends they went by horse they galloped by who else maybe that was a form of simplest classes McCullough whatever the reason is the pasta was going ahead with his this time was a kamar it's for his friends were following behind and apparently one or one of the friends horse smashed into the cousin's donkey and as the rush because it did extensive damage to the hostas animal so the Costas said you know some class Gosselin Kawa hey Nina hair you have to pay for the damage and the friend said basically why am I responsible will golden wishes sir Robin we both have a right right to be there and you should be a more defensive driver you should be more careful it's your problem not mine and also the soil says what type of mazak is it when a horse does damage so the rush says very clearly you're wrong in the Shuster Rob you have a right to go there that's but you have to keep a safe distance you know the horse that's going behind has to keep a safe distance you have the right to be in which is a Robin but you have to maintain a safe distance and therefore if you didn't and because of that you collided with the Hudsons donkey you're responsible now in other words what we know that's a basic law and driving up to keep safe distance the source is this rush I don't know if the government gathers from the rush but Tiger definitely did but then the rush discusses what type of a magic is a person driving on a horse says the rush it's the magic of Adam it's like he's magic the guilfoyle and if you look in the rush would be the words of the child he used the word it's like a pizza which is a very informative word imagine I'll give you a must imagine that a sub was a good idea good hard to Archer he shoots an arrow and a bull's-eye right in time Alex hot and kills him instantly nope you kill someone but a Savannah has here the Chicago forget the Salam did he says it's not my fight I didn't do anything maybe I was a drama but I didn't touch the other person in fact I'm so many feet away from the from from be Ahmad that was killed call me a grandma not more but he's wrong why this is Seguin Sanhedrin its of an arrow that a person shoots is his kiyah it's directly attributed to the person so the rush says that if you're going with a horse and you're controlling the horse it's like part of you it's automatic and this exact case of the rush is quoted in Haitian mister at the end of Shania yes now I must tell you the Kazon ish involve a comic ballot cast wonders how could you call a living horse that has its own car yeah you know I guess we could say it's horse power literally going by its own how could that be part of a person so the rush is not there because not so convinced that that horse is autumn amazing but I want to tell you even first of all the circular past is like the rush but more than that it's very possible that even that has a niche that questions of horse because it's a living animal and goes on its own but a car that's only driven by your person only because the person puts on the engine and steps on the the gas pedal it's possible even the Fabian issue would hold that a car is like part of the person the person controls the car and it's automatic and I think it's a pretty good proof of you look in the has a niche in our Italian similar might evolve live it was a very common question they had people Tim that Muhammad song was muhawwil Shabbos and the cousin ish said if a person does harissa he plows on Shabbos with a tractor he should not think if any less little Shabbos that's a sin miss Jim pizza and every plow that he does with the tractor is real solutions so you see the cows a niche is clear that using a tractor who was in a car is considered a person's mice entirely and I thought I did see the Pisgah equation in the Z Kannamma nyah-nyah Thea via IMF a big test finish with seven hey here's a Schuyler there about a driving up stoma sleep and did terrible damage so he says that a car is considered Adam Hamas ik he quotes this kaze mich regarding a tractor and it's not just the grub it's a mice to be attacked but anyhow be that as it may we see two biggest ideas on this rush number one we see that the magic of a car like a horse is automatic and also we see the concept of collisions even though they collide it but if the person behind did not keep safe distance he is directly responsible narrow way say let's learn a Mishnah and again we'll find one word that will be very clear guidance for for all of our Zyliss now the mission the well no mission above a camel I'm an hour from the bay is there Bubba kavita's ever buckaroo sight but I wanted to make it really very simple so we could relate to it so instead of using Kavita and Caruso and him and me and you everybody gets confused we're gonna use two words throughout the Mishnah beam and barrel let me explain the mission says there Bubba Kavita one person is coming with his barrel now there was a barrel of wine okay and ZEB Bubba karosta a person's walking in the street with a bet with a beam now a beam and a barrel is not a good because the beam rams into the barrel breaks the barrel of wine and the wine spills out so instead of using sadita and kairos we have to start translating it let's use barrel barrel of wine and beef is up the Mishnah neseber cava shall serve the kuru seychelles have the barrel was broken by the beam Potter the owner of the beam is pata chala zealousness mihalis who lazzereschi us Muhammad they both have a right to walk in viciousness rabbim so he's taught as a state minister but when you learn Bubba , you wonder why is this so the barrel the beam broke the barrel he's definitely a magic ally didn't do with malicious intent but the basic cloud is other mood the oiler even itís so Rashi and Isis and the turn she mention alien tests all explained that Lamesa this is a typical case of collision they were both walking both walking safely both long bearish us Zahra she she's named Shaba mystery Rosslyn Chapel a phobia saya bisa rustic in other words you barrel person was walking regular speed he was walking regular speed and you collided and both of you contributed to the headache and therefore your putt no one's at fault everybody's allowed to work so this is the asite of the Mishnah that collision or you call it missed mr. hood SKU they damage one another putter the mukhlis have aired that when you're walking you don't have to think that someone's coming along with a barrel so as long as it's a embarrass us and host coup it was a collision putt as I stated let's proceed hi about Larry showing about hobbyist a frame the beam is in front and the barrel is behind and what happened was the barrel went into the bean pot dibala colors he's putt now again you wonder why is he putter the barrel was broken by the beam the barrel was the newzik the beam was the mazik y'see part to other Medina says Rashi this case even was simple because the Barrow Mohammed Erica who me Erica darkly the beam was walking at a regular pace the barrel person decided to speed up so he rammed into the beam I the beam broke it but it's not the beams fault you know why because the barrel did not keep safe distance now we could also add will soon see many who shine and learn the next part of the Mishnah even if other moola eylem but Amy's Gummer is Pato is right are you his gum respond to the rush crisis other was shining say this no in this case the beam was an eye on his collar he was walking with his beam at a regular pace and the barrel person been rammed into him what he wanted for my life I'm opposed to things I was gonna splash it's mentioned to me the Russian Baba kama demo I love Tyson's and hedge and I in Zion the - viserys roof Aleph Volvo key I said all say all these Gummer the person is part so so far so good to see that you have to figure who's Bruce and who's not versus let's continue in all my valve cleric the beam person made an abrupt stop a sudden stop Caillou and then of course the barrel when in 10 he's tired now this needs a husband why is the beam tired the barrel went in damn the answer is one word resist or maybe the lack of it mr. Barrow mr. beam has no right to make a short stop or Sarada everybody's walking at a certain pace sup Tina Mookie ISIF this case is f God versus the barrel is Burgess the B muscle a vs. you can't make a short stop in your sister Robin and since you'll be made a sudden stop you are surely Bruce and therefore you're hired so we see that the word resist is the key concept in this mission now this just does not mean you're allowed to walk there you're not trespassing because we're a beverage ladder walk which just means the situation that you're in the mat severe in your ladder walking survivin you want to carry you to your beam but you can't make a short stop a sudden stop so the beam by making the shortstop was a hilarious now a very interesting question I could ask you okay so the beam person you're wrong you shouldn't stop suddenly what type of a magic is a beam AB inverse sister album Craig did Mookie I stood on this on this Mishnah the her should be the magic of born a beings not a human being and what's the lover of a barber sister Robin hi Yvonne miss Kay Adam and his Potter fan Kaelyn so if the beam broke the Barrow which is Calum even if the beam was responsible it should be part outs Marvell I can't read the muki Isis Sugden look the ice and the MSB finalist even a person could be a part if a person fell on rooster album and sadly wants to take a nap that's lazy laying there so if he does damage that's the damage of body so why can't the bean be boyfriend will be ice it says it look the ice if I don't stand if a person fell down and didn't move or a beam is on the ground and laying there that's a bar but if someone is holding up the beam it's part of the person and if a person isn't automatic so is the beam and this is very similar to the rush that we learned when someone is holding to something will drive you something that's an extension the other yesterday and that's other my mask okay fine we're doing great let's continue the Mishnah let's say the barrow the the beam person taka made a short stop but before I made a short stop he said beware I'm making a shortstop he put on his blinker whatever he did and he warned the person behind that I'm making a short stop I'm humble about lobbies he told the barrel person I might be careful putter if the barrel did not take the warning and he kept on going right into the back to the beam putter why is he putter is Upton Maki Yosef healed I've said enough said mr. Barrow I warned you wanted you slow down that's your fault you know it's not half the comparison Hoefler if someone stops in the street he's tired it's you didn't warn me if he warned him sufficiently he is putt sup delicious of course you have to have enough time to be able to stop sup the Mishnah let's say the Barrow is in front and the beam is behind and the beam went right into the barrel and broke the barrel so the Mishnah tired why is he hired this is a simple magic the beam rammed into the barrel that's a regular masa you see you broke someone's battle that's boss let's say the Barrow person who's in the front made a shuttin a sudden shortstop the demisch nepata why is he putter the beam broke the Barrow sucked I told you to restrain him to rush and then theis this and then Saharan this is a case of - come you made a shortstop I didn't know that I was going with a regular pace my aim is gamma I'm put the Mishnah then adds if he warned him I'm stopping then he cited because you stopped also so as you see godly this is all quoted equation mr. Simmons Chennai and test the keyword to all of our shyness is the word vs. so replies to BC two sources of a collision the rush where two animals collided the Mishnah that we just learned we're two objects two items the beam and the beam and the barrel collide one more sauce which is negated too many of our stylist that's the next mission in bava kamma lama days basically the Mishna says two people are going to mr. serabian and they collided so if they're both going bearish suits they're both walking and a safe distance and a safe speed and they collide it and one person got very damaged doors I even got damaged Putta why both are was just but let's say one person is running and the commencement Anala run in the street he's hilarious and he's - all damaged this is a third source of collision the rush spoke about animals colliding the first Misha spoke about objects colliding and this mission is talking about people colliding and basically the one words for all the asite is's versus if you are Bruce your punt and this is the end of Simenson I invest the allowance of two people colliding there Seuss is the deciding factor so let's apply this ylim ice that I think we should have enough information to all of that we shine a typical auto collision with two cars collide now assuming that one person that's fault of course he's responsible but very often no one knows who was at all they're both going decent speeds there was a collision but it was a very lopsided accident one person's car was totaled and one person had minor minor damage this is our Mishnah it doesn't make a difference if they were both Burruss and hoods ku they damage one another it was the collision was the impact both apart I mean each one takes his damage and that's it you can't make the other person divide the damage this is a simple case of hood scoop slam versus and putt if Lamesa one was at fault even though it wasn't with malicious intent but other Muto Island then he survived it's just an aside the I should mention I should mention this more and more but we're talking about paying money but we have to realize that the real fear is a person has to be careful twice's in Kazan of a days above a camera says a cloud a cloud and driving a client in living yo-yo say yes like this much to logic missile a user you know what person thinks he has to be a defensive driver and ask to protect himself that's very nice maybe a little selfish but the tiger says more than the defensive drive you have to be a careful driver you have to be more careful not to hurt someone else damage someone else and hurt yourself entirely the drive is concerned about the other person more than himself Tyson is talking about in his time that people collided and you know other type of damage today when a person is driving a car a car is a very very dangerous item I heard the stylist said mr. Clair's we ever said this had they had cars and the times of her they would answer that because Alcinous mataman I should say but they didn't have cause sometimes it has out but Lamesa it's a lot more dangerous than people colliding and what I'm gonna talk about hoophouse hi if the pay we're talking about Camila loss of human life people may get paralyzed and crippled I mean the stories are unfortunately too common the first cloud and driving is to get about who's gonna pay is you have to be careful but getting back to collisions we hope it should never happen but if someone were both of them were going at fair speeds there's a collision pup if one person was speeding so besides violating the smacklin actually save them he's going to Labour's just and about these guys someone was parked and he's pulling out of his parking spot and he pulls out I guess not so carefully and he collides with the car that's going down the street the ongoing traffic so this is an easy shock because the law is when someone pulls out of a park spot he's always responsible because you should have seen so this is the person pulling out is hilarious so limey buddy if he smashed into the car so he stole a business and also he's amazing but even if they collided so was was cool but if seviper's just is responsible the same is true when someone's pulling out of his driveway and he smashes into the car that's an ongoing traffic the law is when you pull out of your driver you have to be careful you are responsible so you have to inch out very slowly I know it's not easy also have a driveway it's not easy because you're driving pulling out with the back of the car but you have to do it carefully the person that were pulling out of a driveway or out of a spot is always legally responsible because he is shallow bristles when you see a student driver on the road that's of a ferry submission um that's a big sign I might be careful you know student driver means be careful drive slowly be very defensive be very careful so you got to be careful now when someone changes lanes even if he's allowed to it's that of line which has to be careful now a lambda1 said yeah but I'd change lanes but I put on my blinkers yes Shekhar yeah the plinkus helps with a fella behind you not with a parallel car that's in the other lane so unless you're certain you could do it don't do it next question someone backed up trying to get out of a parking spot he backed into a parked car so this is not hood scoop because the other car was parked this is his ik he was magic he pulled into an innocent car that was not that was not moving the only Shyu was and this is interesting Shila DePauw he backed into a parked car that was parked illegally whether it's no parking or no standing you know I think in our neighborhoods we have plenty examples of illegally parked cars but he backed into a car that was parked illegally so here there is reason to believe that maybe the car that was parked illegally was so very British us initially business but that's not what the mission amendment shall a bridge just meant that the person that was the cause or who contributed to the accident the car that was parked illegally was illegal but that doesn't didn't make you smashing thing now if it was a situation that the person says there was no parking in the universe no standing even that can't be a carving I don't know I just backed up so if the person could convince the best of then he was not expected to look behind him and that's why I've contributed to the accident he was parked illegally that might be a title but no one but no one backs up and doesn't look behind there might be human being there you know come on it might be a child if you can't even you know that's unfortunately a cause of so many accidents so unless he could prove that this was the cause of the accident that's not sure Larry Bruce just I just had this shot was a true story because a teenage girl that had a permit without a license and the whole story was that the parents went away for two weeks and she was told to a certain errand Bukit says she pushed it off till the last day the parents are coming on that night and she got desperate she didn't do her errand so she decided to take a chance you got to the car she's driving to take care of the sleepless Lamesa she was in an accident the car was destroyed mama Sh but here's the point she was totally not at fault she was driving very safely the car that hit him to her was 100% asphalt there's no question about it so after she got out the first thing she says plead it don't call the police because I have no license when you have a permit in New York you gotta drive if you're accompanied by a adult and the parents were out of town at the time so the drive isn't oh you don't have a license okay I'm not gonna say anything but you can't say anything because if you are according to the law it doesn't make a difference who is right or wrong a driving license is absolutely wrong what's the halacha LP tyrant so this girl that was driving was clearly salubrious and someone said that it chalet versus the other person is Pato but I'm not so sure that's right because again here I think all agree that the fact that she was without a license had no impact on the collision at all it was the other person's fault and I saw the wonderful say from mr. Teja Mazak and Perry Zion he says who says that in fantasy cotton fest in the bottom who says such a case miss Fabri that's not considered to live versus survivors just means that if there if the girl was not so experienced and we're not sure whose fault it is up then you could say maybe you weren't alert enough you weren't quick enough to react but here it's no doubt about it it's the other cars fault just because I had no license does not mean too late versus and the other car probably is responsible someone was driving along and he made a short stop now the other person was not aware of this person's the last-minute decision and is what we call a dybbuk of a let's put it that way the back car rammed into the front car so we'll say well there's no doubt about it the back car is the mazak he smashed into the front car but this is our rush and our mission actually the back car did not keep a safe distance and the back car is responsible for two reasons first of all the back car was shall I Bruce we didn't keep a safe distance and also this is not hood school this is his Eco this is he rammed into the front car and that's pushing but I'll tell you without that I discussed with a number of dhyanam and I think I have the answer but it might be somewhat of a finish let's take a leading case okay someone's driving along the Garden State Parkway you ladder go 65 you gotta go 70 I mean whatever it's people go 70 up till 74 is that is acceptable but it's even going 70 okay and it was a night like tonight he decide a season LaVon oh let me make it ISA Vaughn up say decides to slam on the brakes didn't make edition of under the car behind them already make it asleep on the last night or what any other reason but did not know about this last-minute decision and smashed in Tim and goes what are you doing stopping on the highway the kid sir this is a momma's a reckless shortstop but the truth is according to law the person behind this guy why the law is I hope that is not a surprise to anybody that you have to keep a safe distance too high no per 10 miles that you're driving you have to keep the big D is the length of your car that means if you're going on the Garden State and that you're going 70 miles an hour that's the 7 car distance between the person the home front and then the person behind no even if someone stops to make additional runner on the highway if you have 7 car distance you're not gonna smash into so if you only kept the 6 car distance according to law there's old data bad the back person is responsible no now what would the tire safe did what I love to say to this I was driving behind then I kept the 6 car distance that he was driving I will drive you 70 so there's no doubt about it I'm responsible if I don't have seven cars too bad now did they honor that I spoke to said it's it's very hard to understand because you the police will never enforce this rule if you're driving only five cars behind they're not gonna pull you up to give you a ticket but if an accident happens you're responsible so again I'm not gonna figure out the law but what it seems to me is they feel the save distance is 10 miles per cup you don't want to do it you want to be a compliment okay at your own risk do what you want but after you collide don't come crying to me what do you want I told you to keep seven car you don't want to keep saying God do what you want at your own risk so that you could do what you want but if you collide you're responsible does crazy Mizpah take the same approach so that the audence told me and I saw Tucker of the zilberstein in heisuke effeminate overcomer I'm a gracious as Robin our limos today up amid the tough race club days he says this clearly that this at the end of the day this is the way bristles it's maybe a little of homra to keep so much distance but that's the law not unreasonable it's like the case of of the person driving without a license here we didn't keep enough distance and you're responsible would be if uh if something if somehow something was in front of the car acted pulled through a short stop so again you know he told me there's some data question this but if the law is you have to keep the distance that might be included in our rush if someone disinteresting question someone stopped by a yellow light and the car behind them didn't wasn't aware of that and when I didn't tip so I asked a few people you know do your physics it sound like a funny question but do you have a right to stop suddenly by yellow light so out of town a yellow light is a much as much longer you're supposed to go through it in New York is most stop al right is the person most expect you to stop so sounds funny yellow light means stop though so I asked a few experienced drivers so once says I never stop and one tell me I look in the mirror if someone's behind these someone's mind me I will go through and someone tell me like I see a tractor trailer behind I'm not gonna stop that's for sure but the emesis it means slow down other than me and go through it okay so Lamesa it seems that yellow means careful but your stop and the person behind them should at least expect that the driving drunk is going to stop and he didn't maintain a safe distance that would be higher there's no doubt about it if he's not enough of a distance to stop by a yellow light that's too close in fact the price can say this a mrs. posh it let's say a person made a stop a yellow light and there was a pileup that second cop rammed into the first third into the second if the car was not keeping a safe distance so each car behind is responsible again the safe distance is an hour so Homer our Mishnah and our rush summer went through a red light now here's interesting question someone went to a red light and the the car that was going properly rammed into the red the one that jumped the red light so he'll say wait a minute you know you smashed into me it's not his school it was his equal but that's foolish you were not supposed to jump the red light I'm allowed to continue going so even though it's his eco but the red light that when the render Ella is a momager laborious and of course he would be fired they once asked the basis throw this attack is that also goes to a red light because it's a third posting impartial school cussed by metal of Eden and I'm is red Louis a VAR b don't go through me I thought a differential ASD son of the obvious easterly business arrived about red lights this is a different plastic by you're more in erred I'm not saying avoid Gillooly evidences you don't mess with my my red light but a little more seriously if I say you know someone brought me in a safer a thick safe that's called ANSI by scallion so I'm talking about driving a hole safe about driving and the big part about driving safely there are stories there that are heart-rendering managed they muster ice the hearts of people that wrote letters or a story that people that drove recklessly and either killed other people or paralyzed people I got a letter Mama's growing to tear someone's go to my children's Hostin of it I can't get out of bed he with his whole spine was was damaged because someone jumped the light and he couldn't stop enough you know you know we like to have all this all this madness that the road madness that people do things wildly it's a Suffolk would say you know we have to be very very careful I saw a true believer Moses the final Ibrahim and he writes that them about what he sees he writes of a very strong Lawson he says called the mayor FIFA say Yakima linemen had done which design you now love that people drive quickly the AMA possessor Castro ain't in the mayor's Parliament people are always rushing we're running to make Mincy skia the football the sheer de bris and he says because you are a nother mayor's poem called the mayor FIFA to Yakima linemen are dumbest not a Guzman so all these rushing and making lights because I have to go for a mitzvah is not a mitzvah it's an it's an Easter comer and the smile connection Satan well now the dry because I'll did not sit but has to be safe next question I'll tell you the some some foods for thought let's say the same case someone was shirisha's and someone rammed into so the red the one that jumped the red light too bad your Caillou the Shia is let's say the other car also got damaged can he make through the one that jumped the red light painting why not why yes ma'am you rammed into me okay so I got damaged I have to pay for you but if you the cause of my damage you have to pay or maybe this is a case of bird maybe the car that jumped the red light at the end of the day is a farmer's gallop oh he's he's a bar he's not an order okay I'll go we're going to say based on our rush but since the person is driving it it's not a bar it's an other western Africa Mena if it's bar it's parked on the other person's car if it's other the tribe you can that's a big sugar but think about it Mabel's all but a different thing I just heard a shy of the following stylist someone was in a gang absolutely as a car service he opened the door to get out but he opened the door facing the street and a car came along and smashed the door and got damaged so by opening a door the wrong way the law was to open the door facing to the sidewalk he opened door facing to the street now there's no doubt about it the person that opened the door was so my gracious because you know go out to the ongoing traffic but the passenger who was a stick alarm did maybe they're very small stick around it he said there but my style was wrong but I didn't do the damage the car that the oncoming traffic broke the door so go to the car now the car will say it's a my fault ok I didn't do it maybe I'm a girl gremlin is up in Sparta beginning ultimate least but he forgot a fairy shigemori the gemara in the top of new involving bava kamma how cry faith camasta Schalke very birth natalenko in other words there's a fire going it's raging and I put somebody's item not into the fire in harm's way so to speak and it burns the item I'm tired why cuz I put it to an inference of of an ongoing case it's not grown so putting a door of the car in front of an ongoing car is like putting the car the door in harm's way and that would not be grandma that's a nice of hezekiah skies i'll say but this is not her school this is his ik truth but this is a survivor just a nice guy what was really interesting the second here for the shylu the car that rammed into the door also got damn it can be owner of the car require the door opener to pay so this is not so possible because if you look you look it closely let's say you open the door and he let go of the door because he wanted to get his package to go out the door that's open into the street is no boy no more than a barber she's around a bar is popped on Calum my car is Caleb Madam President get hurt if he was still holding on to the door when he opened the door made will you maybe we'll use the rush it's like part of other if he was holding on to it then it was all that they thought we did be held open but if you open - I left it open the open door is a bar and bar is pufta on Cape the only Shila which is which is a fascinating question which is not for now but I mention it just briefly the question is let's say I'm I made a bar mr. Sir Robin and I damaged Caleb so it's a plastic and attire gossip come over like a muppet I'm my responsible I'll spit DNA's shamaya true it's not a bar because it's Kailyn but I caused damage drama the nizam kit is tied with initially a modified Nadine HTML so the pair could small and simin basic cotton base says it's not less than a regular girl deprived initially that has a niche in semen base it comes I'm says he doesn't cause bad words but he says it can't be a fevered a Somalian when the plastic explicitly says it's part so this is a big sugar in India later crinum if there's a perturbed apenas shamayim on her Marvel a kingdom but basically we all have to be careful these things shouldn't happen a person lets out passengers you know the problem is that the driver told go ahead go out didn't tell him where to go go out the other way go out towards the street do towards the sidewalk not towards the street next question also a true story someone backed out of his parking spot and went into a garbage can and destroyed the garbage can is this hi Yvonne the garbage can now we say it's not a few thousand dollars but that I've been protected in a and the second question was when the car somehow got damaged from the car made it was a metal garbage can like these stabbed but the question is when someone backed into a garbage can and did some damage so Lamesa this is mr. Clara is the law you know our God our hard-working sanitation engineer are not into slain lesotho the cans as close as they can very often the cans are where the car next to where the cars are pop and this I think according to I think the name is this look it's the act of nature thing is a few hours after collection the person has a right to keep the cans where they are you know after wall you have to pick it up but you're not meleave to leave work and run home and then pick up the cans so the cans are there versus now the question is the person backing up was he bears us just to go into a a garbage can of course now if it's not a garbage can differ from other son it's a child that bent down to pick of his ball behind your car which unfortunately happens if the person that's crossing and go to the street but you shouldn't be but it's walking behind your car you know when you back up you have to look for for people if they look carefully you may be a young child that's short you can't even see him but yeah a person has to be responsible so here the garbage can is there perhaps vs. but the person backing up has to check can't just back up cuz you're in a rush that's an omnipresent and that would be shallow business and he is responsible to replace the kid the question is if the car the the garbage can of metal can did damage to the car now he wants to make the owner of the can pay for the damage so this first of all if he will show a bruise just is no claim but besides in the worst scenario even if both in a martial ID versus this is only a case of a bar a garbage can in the street is only a part and a bar is part two on cable but basically when you back up look and from there are such stories of muddled son children get hurt they bending down there playing you back up you have to be careful a question again that happens unfortunately a pedestrian wanted to make the light was already yellow maybe red the kids are a pedestrian dotted into the street to cause sees a person running and he's a pretty good driver and he turns a last minute turn but you know you can't just end up no way up he ended up smashing into a parked car so the pedestrian continued going he made his bar who he made his bris he made his Matt Meyer and he car smashed into a parked car now the parked car was perfectly British us and the one that smashed in Tim was his it mihari the one that's meant the Messiah but I did see up Sakurai mango saffron that's one of the feet but they lay a place missionary to throw and he says that if he was going to save this person's life so the loss is it the sodium bava kamma that when someone's going to save lives and it does incidental damage he spot that's like a Nutella member that's driving and they sometimes they take crash to have to go as fast as they can so if it's within reason he's going to save a life he put this person the driver thought as quickly as quick as possible he saved the person's life funny I think we're going to a car there was no other option now if he was driving and he saw a cat running in front and it was not interested in having the cat blood all over his car he's trying to save himself or even if he's trying to save his own life and he smashed into a car which is very important to save your life but Maxell absalom chilka very society here we was trying to save someone else's life the hairy spot on the car damage now what is very missed a verb and I saw this in the safe of mister deterrent buffer comma I'm a gray suit gimel but infla my sir he which is usually the case the person that ran across was totally at fault he shouldn't ran across on a red light so the he is responsible for the damage I what did he do he was running to my Earthman but that's not just a grown up in a socket that's a guy me to run to pass the car that he has three seconds to save your life and he runs he smashes into a car that's like almost like sending him pushing him into the damage and that would be garmi which is not drama and he's higher than his open someone was driving it was icy weather and he skidded on the ice and he did damage and says it's not my fault it's an oilless so that's not a taina I mean this is sky if I'm a secret to say it's an earnest glomer is almost never reasonable because when it's an icy condition the person has to go slow any inclement weather you know people are driving under snow snow ice or during the summer on a heavy rain yes you didn't please leave extra time when you drive and inclement weather winter was somewhat people have to make their get this a sharpness and they don't really this when when is when there's bad weather it's dangerous you have to leave extra time but person can't say it's an onus Gumba that he he was driving in the snow and he collided and he slipped and you know all these things are at man around his gum a person has to leave extra extra time when this bad weather I'll tell you a interesting story a beautiful shine I'm proud to say this Schuyler someone was waiting this goes back a few years you might not recognize it but Samoa is weighted by Ocean Parkway a few years ago and a car drove by at that one then 50 miles per hour was I think was legal the kid said the car drove by and it was little self a puddle of mud like slushy black mud you know dirt from the snow and all and the car went over there the puddle and sent all the mud onto this person's coat Destry and realized he has to clean the coat destroyed can wear it as it is and it's no but sure but listen to this to drive a cop right away made a right turn which you're now gonna do today so don't do that today but then you're allowed to make a right turn ocean park with plate a complete turn and sort of chase his music and Esther did I do that because yes do I have to pay now he didn't ruin the coat but to send the code to the cleaners is also amazing no difference it doesn't be a million dollars there's definitely a magic and an Izzy know who's responsible so there's no doubt about it this is Mazak music man whose school has Eko so that must we would think of course he has to pay well you think about a little deeper it could be in a certain sense the pedestrian is Chilean prisoners let me explain in a person years ago there's driving along Ocean Park where 50 miles per hour and he comes to a sudden puddle right what are you supposed to do you know they have not yet designed a helicopter option that you hit the button and your car just flies up you know what opposed to do swerve into the left lane and some Sekar there it's not an absolutely slam on the brakes in Ocean Parkway not safe so what it was to do now then again the pedestrian that's standing by the red light and sees the puddle in front of him he should stand back you know that makes more sense so I can say this with certainty but maybe the pedestrian solid versus or maybe they're both useless and this is a nine discover now Lamesa if it's let's say today's 25 miles per hour and that that will not make such a big splash and he was going at 50 so the speeder is hilarious but in such a scenario or better yet during in the mountains when people walk on the road and the drivers have the option of moving to the side that wants to know is it's the roads and that is as busy you can move to the side you know to drive over a puddle and hit someone that's maybe that's amazing but in this case where they drive had no option and the pedestrian had a better choice that might be a case of the shots and salubrious and each time I saw a finish I'm not sure I agree but in Indy say fish per day mr. magic science of test here he tells Seward a beautiful rush grab her the east side of the rush is important the rush of the two was cook Alex Valle has a style of two people who are fighting and never one not got the other person's eye terrible damage so the rush says that he's Pato even though other mood oiler but if they were but we're wrestling I know who's fun or not I mean it in turn to be fun of course but both of them know that one might get hurt I died to the hockey that got into this mess and like a mouthful and the Sahara in topic of a love-hate quotes this and the shock explains deal the CI issue or mostly I adore me now this we always use in the summer when the boys play basketball and they have the showers when we run up for the rebound ever and knocked up the other person glasses and did this damage it tourists it's us you know all the has they can take place in basketball and football or all the games that's this rush if you know you play ball that glasses other things get broken if you have to expect it but in this particular case is it so partial that when you walk Ocean Parkway you you're like Michael when a car drives by and hits the mud if yes you might have another smart to be make up this question should never happen but watch me it does someone black someone else is driving okay say decide he's gonna call the police have to Kartik it it and towed or I mentioned the wheel as we began someone double parked so now there are three cars on a side street and he has to go to work he tries to squeeze through the cause but he tore off the other person's broken the person's mirror and the intimate so this Grandda is nama alwa sodium Ray's FLE this is the word British us that explains the sodium the Gemara bava kamma for ssi mamalakat sekai very kinda yeah in the car they chemin someone decided to put all these things on someone else's property bow cuts in the shop of the yates of the shop of an illness the drive the person that has to leave his house you have to go to work is allowed to go out of his house and he didn't even break the other person's barrels he's why cuz you the person that put the barrel this survived Bruce I'm very shows I tell you that mom eclipta to start collecting all your barrels and I'm okay this is quoting Haitian misfortune I intest see talent it's very reasonable that this supplies that I will submit not a mixed claim but you have to apply it properly I'm allowed to go to work now if I want to go to work and is the car blocking my driveway no theoretically of course if I work in the army okay and I go to work with my tank I'm allowed to drive out and smash the other car that's a de Faria my shop in Chennai intestacy dollar but let's say I don't know on the tank and I instead I excite the flattest tires so that's amazing the health is not that you're allowed to take the kama a lot of take out your road rage they had to time not to go to work at the other person's cost if I could somehow get out by damaging the other person it's okay but to call the police and you know do damage the other car is definitely wrong the flattest car tire is not gonna help me get to work if I'm parked on the ground a pop on the sidewalk and I want to go to work but before I do I do that I want to take out my anger sighs let out the F Moustakas that's amaz it you know I'll do that too if let's say since you can't drive out because the car is blocking and the only way to do it is to call the police having a ticketed and towed that might be motor that's cheaper than destroying this car now I just don't think it's the safe thing to do because anybody who parks and someone else's driveway its accosted on the worst things you know who will do that otherwise so you know I'm not sure it's advisable but it's probably what to call the police to get out to go to work the other Shila we're driving trying to squeeze through a double parked car and you tear up the other person's mirror it sounds similar but it's not it's very different to explain because I have a right to go to to get my own house and the car is blocking my house here I have no right according to law to try to squeeze through a tight spot he's wrong but I can't be wrong I don't know in the streets this is not British us not my street so the lawyers if you see a car double-parked turn around and go the other way so basically for two reasons it's hilarious and so labor issues but the one that double-parked was I even caught a cooler Sani la habra place avid citizens at the Martin Chavez I'm at home base zu he caught area cool is as clear as can be the one that double Park the park park Simon's rival was just violated car tire cool the interesting thing is if the person tried to get through the spot broke the other person's mirror and he was such a swim I assume that his old car was scratched believe it or not he can't require the double parked car to pay for his damages why the other part the double parked car is no more than a bar be sure sir album I mean a real bar but it's a bar and bar a spot to ante interesting question I have this in my neighborhood but it's quite common you have a big apartment building in the corner right so basically you're coming down the side Street and you're coming down the Avenue black and you can't see one another until you actually collide because the partner building goes all the way to the end of the of the corner so one person going on a side sweep one person's going down the Avenue black and they collide so it definitely it happens you almost collide but let's say two people came from place that he couldn't see one another and they collide it one was carrying something valuable he dropped it it broke and one wasn't what's the law what's table I should say this is my Amish I wish them to people going versus host who's a business but if one was running it's other running person is fired because that was the damage but it's both and about going host Cousy Bizet is pot I should mention I thought that I purchase bills and cries to me to mention what we see today the bar from our sons our grandchildren that drive bicycles on the sidewalk beside that it's not it's against the law and it's a terrible collage them and she was were driving against the law it's dangerous it's dangerous for young people walking it's danger for dangerous for older people a bike on the sidewalk it's July versus it's a Kalash em please it has to stop you know they say what do I do it is on the streets also dangerous I know that but that doesn't make two wrongs don't make a right now I think sir under a certain age is allowed to go on the sidewalk but boys that beyond their age the labor just is mama it's a magic and to how I share much too like it it one interesting exception I would like to mention is the same Gomorrah more than mama days if someone's running on Erev Shabbos to make this man Bruce Lee's Potter now this is terribly misunderstood I've heard this more than once people you know some people drive Erev Shabbos it's a strength where they driving they're speeding to making his mom is a very good martyr of this justice but I'm saying the Solomon is quoted initialize a bromination list which anion fest the only health of running Erebus is only running by foot driving speeding by car is dangerous even Erev Shabbos is awesome besides that the heta of Erev Shabbos is not a heckler for for a mitzvah the founders yarda to the sim enrage design has a two story it was a kid asleep on a night but there's no levana until a little later so the guy by I guess they have to Mayer announced in this was Walsh tackle kidness Lovano but one person took that literally decided become his reason my demon person went to run to make it Isla Varna and broke Kochel Shemin and comic Lee's focus of a vendor and he was obstacle II they are safe to dr. haddassi Ernie says I'm running for da Mitzvah nepata so the caviar there's two problems first of all the sales problem the only help is running errors Shabbos why is running Arab Shabbos Mota because all people are Shabbos aren't high alert they know that the street is wild out of control you got to be very careful so you're very much on the defensive but to run the kindess Levana no one else is running but you so there's no healthy but also says that you have this yards only Arabs Shabbos that it's Otto Chavez and foolish honest but to run to do another Mitzvah there's no help so this is something that we have to mention I'd like to close with this running is always dangerous but especially with cause it's a Sakana now vaasna truven caleb of cookie Bay's rights push it my ID that part of the ISA the rights of miss Martin is when someone drives recklessly he says this Russian I quote the way some people drive is a Sakana that's an alive Suffolk receiver and Suffolk map and AB Smilodon I don't know which is worse murder or suicide but they're both not good you know the driving that the fast driving that we see is a shred diminish it couldn't fail the test Kaufman has has a number of things that have a driver does list you'll not a report to authorities and have his license revoked I think a lot of people in our neighborhood will lose their licenses based on this man has its cub but one thing I think I'd like to mention is the the newest problem of driving when a person's on the phone or texting you know it's no doubt it's allowed their I so you know I read studies that 18 percent of fatalities is from people that are either communicating texting or on the phone 18% of people killed accent is because of this when a person drives with what when he's texting or on the phone he loses 37% of his focus isn't that Miss America managed to save them so today it's like part of the guqin schmuck they talk on the phone you see a copy put it away but it's jack someone told me he said he knows this personally in New Jersey it was it was not Jewish not again but there was a woman talking to her sister on the phone and the sister got distracted lost control and was killed instantly now the assist on the other side of the phone said where are you I have but definitely knew something was wrong was waiting someone pick up the phone because why you screaming the person that was in this car was just killed the DRI the other drive with you the sister that was talking gave out a scream of Estrella shriek the mom the mom is almost like shudder shook the world somehow be the police got a recording of this phone call every phone call is recorded and now it's the law in New Jersey if someone is caught driving with the cell phone they either have to pay a hefty fine besides a ticket or listen to this recording this conversation of this woman's scream that she killed her own sister and as such as reckless a phone call that most people rather pay the fine which is insanity that means was so afraid to face the truth at this is dangerous you know the someone came to borrow bells II wanted a brother for driving viral Belzer says he feels that driving is dangerous he only gives a bra on two conditions number one you pick up a passenger when you go and pick up people who test it and number two is of our LaBelle's is lost as well as quoted in the tuba shaper costing you keep the laws as if they would be a serous a dippers a barrel the Belzer was an issue Amala who lives to like it there had to have okay to do it but when this he was like the saris are dippers let me just be messiah the double tie someone was driving i'm elisha fine steamed and had the lack of sense and was speeding and he got caught it's pulled over by the policeman he was so embarrassed he decide he has to say face he goes or she might understand screw him it's like and I was right at the receiver I got a ticket somebody says exactly because you were doing a mitzvah the vitam sent your aunts Allah sent you a policeman to slow you down otherwise even got into an accident and it would have been much worse so if we slow down that's the Mitzvah we should all drive safe they're good to tell the fuel thank you very much mr. Roberts like two announcements number one tomorrow we're gonna have disclosed beds - Amy's birthday have a one o'clock yes ooh hi Ravi economist Kia hatate grabbed on say go this speaker the Volkov prognosis at Tuesday raises passions among the sharpest Shira but come tomorrow I wanna copy this whatever machine up don't say go Sheamus is even more important at my side with everybody looks for diameter which amidst in his lifetime we have on right here then the hospice registrar who never unfortunately was never home his father and mother separated they threw out all the kids and the key and this book has a hot sugar Bobby Stanley write about a team he doesn't know what I'm talking about he's standing right here he's getting married in a few weeks he's here in America a few weeks and doesn't have money's coming around to his own handsome I know them personally they're installing Shiva they took them in they taking this book and they sell to me for a few weeks the maid of a Stephen Smith said they surely made him see his mistress him to make him cast on a few weeks he one of the mixer please everybody not less than a hundred dollars this is a mystery Pedulla Boyd you gonna checks the congregation Bassam you give out the credit card or adulterous yet to take the credit card we want and given the marble table door just give him a check $100 go with him and then chemonics she have a simcha and she be simply easy in getting married himself he doesn't have his parents he became himself within a few weeks and is he standing and hoping people will help man the next three weeks is going back you should know he has brothers in America that kiss him he should be the one care about each other and this goes by your kids and you you have a lot of symptoms that make customers metallic simcha and this was go over and at least $100 even bigger money you gotta give us our mouth - and this Mitzvah is a biggie Mitsos was premeditation alcohol from a boutique in the good tinnitus of karenacaracas matsutake this holiday you know and here when I'm tired of me twice she'll never recover semantics oh yeah dr. Ravi are they college [Music] [Applause] [Music] revelation season baddest up on a mountain top of it oh no he has good to be busy give please Skyler see come any minute [Music] Alysha hops around amidst the simplest customer color [Music] you do what you can walk in there I see I see come see come tomorrow the McGill have gone Sega don't forget that's a seeker so short something learnt about them first of all I think first and foremost he will see Cummins oyster yesh lysmer selasa diverse Elizabeth IRA has to be extra careful more careful than his own damage is worrying about someone else's damage specially that's stung in he'll Kosmas ik Mikulski and Calvo Kramer then the notion of a friend when someone's driving a car that could do so much damage we have to be extra careful these child should not happen but if they do happen as we saw a car based on a rush is part of other my Mazak it's like a that's like the person's car yah he's controlling that kya we saw three sources that collision generally the key word is birches we still colliding of animals of people and of Calum and if it's versus then hood school is part two even if it's a lopsided hazard a person has to keep a distance from the car in front and that's basically a rush which is really a Mishnah and a car that's going is part of a person it's not a bar and they're prescribed on damages two people collide is also if both members just there's no fear even though one got damaged a collision that one was totaled and one was minor injuries minor damage I should say if it's purchased and her school that both pata that's the mission of a embrasures host coup is Pato someone pulls out of a parking spot or pulls out of a driveway he is generally responsible for any damages because he should be more careful so you have to do it slowly and carefully a student driver is an indication you have person has to be extra careful and that might be more of a fear to be careful when someone changes lanes and putting on the blinkers only helps to the people in the back but to the parallel cars you have to make sure they could only change lanes when there is enough distance between the car behind you and your car when you pull in a person backed up in a parked car is responsible for the damage the other cars parked illegally and he should have seen the illegal car he is still responsible when someone drives that a license so basically if that was anyway cause of the accident so he's this laborious if is the other cars fault it's probable even though some people were not excited about this but it's probable that would still be considered British just because the driving was not the factor for the accident a short stop that collides with the car in front when the car behind collides with the car that just made a short stop according to the law the the car and behind is always responsible because he didn't keep a safe distance and it seems Lala claw halakha would recognize this safe distance as being the deciding factor if someone stops the yellow light so even if you don't usually stop you have to expect at least a person to stop and therefore the second car should certainly slow up enough time that if the first car stops the second is able to stop as well a red light is why Saab RB that's a Nissa probably it could be an S at the rise to the drive to a red light and our lack of communities would not walk through a red light even early morning when there was no cause on the road - he felt that was Dean of the Mahoosuc but certainly driving through a red light is connect in Halawa besides against the law an open door that someone opens a door that's supposed to open door to the sidewalk be open to the street he shall a bridge just if he did damage to the door he's higher on the damage we did damage to the oncoming car he's probably his pot - Al's Kalin if you back into a garbage can so he's supposed to expect that at least look for it and then he would be responsible if the garbage can damage the car so that the can owner is a has it's only in the status of a bar and the can is not responsible the damage I did to the car a pedestrian that darted out and caused an accident is a garmi and of course besides jeopardizing his own life is responsible for the damages out scare me but the car that swerved and smashed the car to save the person's life is part of our Seles natasha's and he's not responsible if someone skidded on icy or was any accident because inclement weather we can't say it's an earnest Gummer a person has to be more careful and certainly should give more time before traveling in this weather if someone's driving along the highway and he hits a mud puddle that that dirtied someone's coat it's quite possible that he's particles he and other choice and the pedestrian shoulda stood further back blocking a driveway is a violation of Cola Tara Kula and should not be done but a summer block C Drive were you allowed to get out that you can't do magic to call if someone tried to get out of a tight spot because of a double parked car and broke someone's mirror he's responsible you should not try and his cars damaged he can't claim any payment from the other person that's that shallow brushes and shallow braces and his tire if to walk is collided then after both walking there Potter if one was running this guy if Arab Shabbos you're out to run but not a lot of speeds and running is also not a good idea and most important to follow rules like a Sarah say Deborah's texting while driving talking on a phone while driving is connect in a lava is a suffix Sakana Margaret's gonna die away tell you but certainly should not be done we should have the insurance of driving safely then we could talk up have a safe trip [Music] and he didn't do that