Challenging Tumas Kohanim Questions - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] like to welcome everyone to today's show from yakuza smith on challenging two muskegon questions thank you very much from someone recently asked me he's a bus driver and he drives here in our neighborhoods and he was told that you can't drive in certain blocks because he passed the street with the basic viruses and there's a tree in the basic forest that extends over the street where he drives i never heard of this he wanted to know a little more about that okay and that was one question another question is regarding a interesting question a true story a dentist that had to shield up where he was told that the the the certain bone extract that you use in typical implants comes from human remains and he didn't know anything about that and i guess the israel that has an implant can't open his mouth if he learns with the cayenne another question we had about uh zeda took his grandchild to the museum and there is no sheila but he didn't realize that his ankle was a cayenne although it's a cotton and the museum typically has human remains as we'll soon see and i wanted to discuss this sugiya because it's a good start because we think the thomas kahanam pertains and here you see three stylists that are all negay and along but to easter alam as well but the truth is the whole indian of thomas as much as kehan in a certain sense besides the fact that if he swallows me causes a kaya mitami this is islip naiva but it's much more specific than that the shock in the beginning of shinai and aleph and we're gonna promise to burn shin mem gimbal quotes this as well one of the shining shin tests asia's kind of mubarak mutters the khan mays in other words a woman who was not a koyen but she married a coin and she's expecting she's allowed to go to a lavaja for example now we think of course what's the problem she's not a korean and the child wasn't born yet it's a double suffolk shema nafalu maybe the child will not survive the birth so it won't be a cayenne and even if it does survive it might be a girl so the rakeach has to come onto a head of svex maker and to us it's a plea because the baby is not yet born what's the problem more so even if it is born it's all of one minute old the mother is not because she's not a kayan but anybody who knows anything knows it's not akasha it's a pasuk it's a gemara it's in two different places and that's the very big sugya of the is of safinon we learned it not long ago in parishes mrv amerita zhakti marine vamos that not only is there an is to become tummy but there's an issa on a israel to cause a cayenne to become tummy not just lyft naiva but there's an issue the rise of safino there are three sukimas the kimora discusses but again for us one of the three sukim there's an isadorai on israel to cause a cayenne even benjamin as the mystery bureau and shin even on a baby cayenne a one day old just like you can't feed a child tarpis you can't pimbatama understandably had to figure out so why is it muta to go into the oil of a maze maybe she'll have a child that's like soccer so then you come on to sex so that's why for a bus driver who's in israel to drive children even if they're loyal very young children if indeed he is entering an oil hamas being under the same tree it's a possibility of course we know that bismarck even it's the same issa of thomas is fully in effect as the writes in and even if the korean was once tame he attended levi of one of his shiva craven but the issa is not being tame or not the iss is being atomic so we have quite a challenge because as we see in these neighborhoods alone there are a number of areas in fort hamilton parkway in the 20th avenue in ocean parkway in flatbush where trees overlap a basic forest on one side and where pedestrians walk or drive on the other side now i'm going to be very clear i'm going to try not to give details for what's today negaya because things change and our precious listeners that live wherever they live there are many other questions other suburban areas particularly it's a very much a real question especially in our city where we are we have a million trees which is nice for the landscaping but it causes complications about this sugia so the embassies the question of course is very simple is it true that a tree that's on one side over a basa forest and the other side where cayenne walks are dry does that conduct a tumor so the past is actually two mishnays in the holy spirit base where the mystery basically gives examples of mavian which really basically means the kai might be in a different place but there's a conductor that brings a tumor from one side to the other one of the examples the mishnah gives is an elan to put this very clearly a a cayenne is living in his house and it is under a tree it's a huge tree on the other side of the tree there's a mace so he says i'm in my own house and what is that what i have to do with the mace but an elon conducts pluma from house to house if there's a pesach but basically a tree is definitely a conductor of toma the question of course is every tree every branch there are big branches there are small branches there are leaves is very specific but very little information the koyen has to be careful not to be tommy come tommy mace in other words their effects are clear there are a number of branches and there's a mace under one of them it's unknown to the cayenne which branch it is so that is the majapa says that the coin should not go under these branches because maybe his muscle he goes under the one that has the mace fractal of us at most it's a suffolk so why is there a problem so the bush says the understandable response speaker is like i told you earlier if there's a big tree on one side there's a mace the other side there's a cayenne and even in this house it is the tree conducts the tongue in fact i once saw a double nipple theoretically a coin's allowed to go out of if he's out of the diamonds of the of a mace so why can he go on a basic curve and be careful he'll navigate his his way he goes and he'll stay out of the balance of the forest and the answer is because but the quarries have trees and that spreads the tumor more than he realizes but the point is that our question about a tree bringing the tumma from the basic forest to the cayenne outside pastures is a bearish mishna but the big question is it's not a big tree let's say it's a small tree let's say it's a stray branch let's say it's only leaves and basically the question is but one thing i could tell you trees are a potential problem in fact says that a tree that over that that extends into a rabbit you allowed to cut it down because it's a magic for the cannon walking in the street now of course don't cut down somebody else's tree unless you know that that how luck applies to this situation but no doubt about it it's a magic when a tree inhibits the walking of a cayenne so one thing we saw that under the same branch where there's a mace and a coin is it is that's the prison but maybe we could say from there we'll go a step further let's say it is the mace is on the one branch and these and the and the coins under a different branch says the prison because the only concern that the mecca has based on the mission always is under the same branch and the shah and taz quote that that if the mace is under one branch coin under the other the character is okay i said we'll soon see why but the big question is but wait a minute but it's one victory why is the priesthood so we might say well maybe the current's walking under a stray branch that has no shaykhs to the rest of the tree in other words there are some trees that look like one that's a problem like the two homes let's say you have a tree that that's primarily in the basic forest and a stray branch is extending outward that might be okay and the question is when do we say it's okay what are the guidelines so i must tell you i am not about moifes because this sugiya is a huge suggest in the resharing him learning the mishna in the hallways and there's a bunch of the different gemaras in nazir and other places in shas about when a tree conducts turmoil but i'm going to try to give you the klolin and again i didn't do justice to the sugiya there's a lot more written but this right at least touch upon the major you say this there's no doubt about it that once a branch is a tephach which is three inches inches [Music] that conducts tumor now since i was learning this i was a little more sensitive and i went up i i measured some trees like some trees in our neighborhoods the huge tree that are here for decades the average the average tree not that the stump is around three or four feet but the average branch is approximately an a foot and a half a big well-grown tree is definitely a teflon feet not inches a small tree that just they just planted now in the city it's barely an inch the the the the leaf the branch itself but one thing we do know that a tree that has the branch of a tafak is a tree the holidays the question often is when it's not fully grown and there are spaces in between do you count the tree as one or you look at each branch individually and that's really what the priesthood is talking about how about if there are a lot of leaves so basically what seems to be the mascana of many poisskin is basically that if the tree it looks like one and it's within a tether the branches are within a temperature of each other and according to many sheathes if you count the leaves that sort of combines one leaf to the other that is viewed as a tree as one even though there's usually a tefl open separates it but there's a special that's the kiddish of the mishnah that the elon has its own that since it's interlocking and overlapping you look up and this branch is over here and the other one a capital higher but if it's perceived as one and there's no discernible place in between that we treat that tree as one now it's i know it's easier said than done because there's a lot more to the suggestions and the rash and the mirror the rajput but the question really is can you count the leaves to combine and make the tree one because the same pericress in the hall as mishneh said that vegetative growths vegetables like mavian do not transfer tumor so if vegetative growth doesn't transform why should i worry about leaves and the embassies there are days that hold that leaves don't count you ignore the leaves especially if they're less than a tether especially they don't survive the winter and like the ram that's a very major criterion if it doesn't survive the winter typically every green evergreens do most many leaves don't and also leaves that flap in the wind there are those that are making regarding leaves so you look at the branches then there's a reason to be makeable but then again very often the branches are within a teflon the other you're not on the same line but higher and lower you could see the connection and that's why you'll notice when you look in the posium that a a full-grown tree a decent tree has to be treated like humor as one i'll soon tell you the mammoth but what i found very interesting the malamata hoyo that was in the chubus hayley based kuflam at bays is critical of the prison and shakantas for that matter because they say as if it's a done deal if you have a stray branch and you know and the cranes under a different branch it's fine it says the mohammed lahoya it's connected many missionaries that a tree is considered one it must be that the priesthood were talking about like i told you a stray branch the bulk of the tree is in the basic forest and there's a stray branch extending outward that that's not connected in any way logically with the rest of the tree but the mom of the height says it's misleading because you get the impression that if the current on the branch a and the basic virus is branch b or mace is branch b it's no problem it's not true because very often the tree is viewed as one now as i told you there's a lot to say about this but i'm going to share with you a extremely important chuva this is a must read and that is the chubas in simenzian now let me give you a little bit history the asian iraqi was a korean incidentally from rapaport who basically has a chuva that has really four parts to it there was another coin that became reverend lev little 401 years ago to be exact tough and shin pay out he became reverend lev and he was a kamiyakov couple cats his name was and he looked mama she looked up and he saw that the place that that people go there are trees that line up from that area to the basic forest and it was a very leisure place to relax and he realized that the trees are overlapping and interest and interconnecting one to the other and he saw that's the mavian tumor from the basic forest to the place that people find very uh comfortable so he told his children right away don't go in that area and he says my responsibilities are i have to mention to the people that they shouldn't go here well he'd met some fierce resistance because the people said excuse me before you there was a rav the priesthood rather the same priesthood incidentally and he lived here he was a korean as we know and he walked him so i i responded he writes that maybe in his times it wasn't so overgrown so maybe it wasn't connected it wasn't interconnecting but today i see it i can't deny the fact that it's one connection so they said oh that means according to you that house you can't live in because i was about to say that yes there's no end to thomas kehanam if it's legitimate but came air v and kippah and the khan and went to that place some of them in fact they said that they collected money and the kind of sat in that area that he forbade them to go so he realized he had a serious problem because they were relying on their previous rove that was makel so he sent to a number of good islam this so one of the two of us the first two of it is this koyen this yak back of couple cats the rub of levov the second one was i don't know how lavi i'm sorry about a lady's name was and he said leaves don't count unless the leaves can support a thin layer of plaster when you learn the missionaries in the hollis it has the macabre mazeva so if it's just leaves that cannot support a thin layer of plaster and certainly they don't survive the winter it's like many residents they don't count so maybe they are right maybe if there's not overlapping of real branches maybe that's why the priest was making he wasn't getting involved in the specifics but his ashita was that it has to be leaves that are strong enough to be macabre which the mishnah is the missus criterion for macabre maybe tom the the asana himself also was more makel regarding leaves he said it has to survive the winter otherwise it's not on the alaric map but the ahref of the fourth and final tube in this very long tube is the twice's yomtif grace poisekador and he basically also was making regarding the leaves independently but his point was that a branch that at any point has a tepha and typically the branches get smaller but closest to the stump any tree any branch that's at least the tepha has the alaric identity of of a oil and even the rest of it even if right of it is not a tefl it is resigning will be more than this year and we have a big agenda but as reversing the rights and shame in our lives he's cutting hay of that silver that the average tree is at least suspect to being a mavi tumor again average i mean i don't mean they planted it last year these trees at the first stages it's not even a tefl of the branch itself and certainly the leaves don't count if there's no branch but basically as he says shitupshita if you have a tree that's a decent sized tree and again gives the perception as one we have to go at least for home run and don't forget we'll talk about is esophagus so they're iso now there are others there are other factors there are other sheet is again you could find we shine and that are makel and do not count the leaves some are mahmir but all agree and that's really what the places youngton highlighted that if the branch is a tepha at one point even if the rest of it narrows down that is counted the truth is i saw a beautiful description of our helicopter which is really applicable to our sugar because i am not making it certainly but the divi writes the following he said i'm not going to waste my time and your time the reader is to read it right reading is safer to in other words that's a wonderful vote of confidence for al-qaeda i'm not going to even bother riding a locker because they don't need the lock but they know what they they stay away got him stay away the truth is it's a new meaning of kahanam's reasoning wonderful understanding but this question of a typical tree again not just a young tree but a typical tree is more than just kahanam's reason that you know irrational humors according to many this you do count the leaves and certainly the branches and again the way the malamata hoyle highlights that even the misquoted driesha was only mako by a stray branch but not a tree that you just look at i'm on the leave a i'm on the brand j and the mace's branch b there's another chuva also very insightful for our sugiya the chuva mehava that was the talmud of the of the native yehudah and simon pay test he got a letter from his an interesting problem and you see how this it has to be an attention paid to these suggest someone realized that the base of kinesis the sure of the city is off limits for kahana and when the windows are open why because there was a at a distance from the shul there was a little plot of land that they buried in the fallen the stillborns and over the years trees grew and there were trees connecting the basar chorus all the way and were touching the wall of the shoe now if the shoe window is closed the car should be a problem but if the windows open you know they're kind of going down during the wind in the shoe so they asked this if it's a problem so he said there are no number of speakers first of all you don't know where the nephrolums will be begins and he is with another and a whole bunch of coolers that he felt it's okay so he writes back then like has to i don't know why you're finding somebody cool this why do you cool is in a place you have to maybe mahm he says you have to and and also you have to realize that things are changing you have to have much more they not just dismiss the issue and only and and fake this is not enough and he writes i remember growing up that we were constantly cutting trees and in my gray surrounding i'd be huda and i quote a lotion upon him if you have a suffix cut down the branches so it wasn't nervous but it's something viki dashtai the job of the kihanam and the job of the australian to maintain produces kuna so again things are changing i mean you think about that matthias that we saw in both the chuva we have that you could have a place that one day's mutter and years later becomes awesome so that's why le mais there are other hispanics and i know there are those that are making in certain cases but la maison a cayenne that has to travel in a certain area whether it's here or in the mountains or wherever the condom are living it's not so hard to stand at a distance of course from the suffolk and try to study it you know if there's a a a small tree in the first place or there's a stray branch and it's just not connecting any other part of the tree so the fact that it extends out of the tree is not enough of an issue then we have the drisha but if it's a real tree a big tree and there is certain some type of connection there then at least the homer we have to be careful this is typically by a base aquarius of the of eden there are some patek virus that are known to be non-jewish the question is if it's a non-jewish cemetery are there any leniencies opposed to a yiddish the same child of course is a hospital a museum which the body parts and the mummies which are typical in the museum typically not eaten so in gemara ivamus bay is the very end of the ahmed quoting the oil that's the sheet of the helicopter and the dashes are possible so it's a very relieving uh cheetah nothing nothing else but there's more to it because the amount of vamos and kuf you're dalid has a mycerav and he goes aren't you a coin what are you doing here she says don't you know that based on the passage says kiriyaki meaning so you can't get a better combination than of sakura shin by yakoi and am i survival yo navi the problem is there's a mission in in the hallways the sheet of shimmer mangano leo is that kibayakim armatami and the bostik is learned differently and taisus says that that the story about it was just another hectare but now we have a mccoy and the chlorine is we passing like and that's why somebody showed him twice this invariably has that cheetah however the rush in the truest beginning of it the guys and that's the of this very indicative of the sheet of the showing and that's why if you a typical standard museum that has various vegas or maybe vadoya is a mummy and yes dwarf i assume there's something there that's a kibber that's akum body parts uh someone told me they have a they exhibit the the lungs of a smoker to show how damaging smoking is but that's a that's the size of a maze and typically we have to assume that a decent museum has but has at least body parts i mean you know could have a museum that's exceptional like i hope the bar park museum is uh for free of these fakers but a typical museum is has a problem of some type of tuma and indeed kahanam should not go with it but i think applies to museum you'll find a different halloween trip what about if it's a frying a mummer is that a problem let's see driving by a chapel and that is in fact in flatbush there's one uh awning over basa over a chapel and your mother is a leviathan in progress it's a friday yet but that's a yid so even though in certain allah is we might not consider mediate because they don't count to a minion according to some and question giving aliyah but regarding our sugya afi israel and that's why there are more in the end of shania and base based on the rajva says this question all agree mumma is israel now that's a mummer or that category so basically we have a problem now because the truth is the chris adam who lived close to 300 years ago and the safer kuffman test writes that in his times and like the light elida we have this problem much more than he had it he says today in a typical basic verse of there are eaten there eden that didn't live like eden and died like like not eaten and never astound basic verses they never had you have to suspect they were eating them how often in our times we hear this you know people say i'm not jewish my mother's jewish but not me that type of you know attitude so it's a problem because even what's known as a goyisha basic verse could have eaten a non-sectarian the basic virus that officially has as everybody so of course that's that's a problem but what's interesting is that the i found probably a half a dozen pie skin that i make a regarding the our question a tree that overlaps a no what you know to be a grayish-based aquarius they all say that basically if it's a if it's a cayenne that's traveling under a branch that oval that that's in the other side in the basic foreign so if it's at most only anoch only zohair so maybe he can be maybe that's the way he that's his route that he's taking of course if you could avoid it avoid it but he's in the middle of driving he notices that there's a basic forest he's driving in the mountains and all of a sudden he's realized he's under a tree that overlaps the basic forest the marsham [Laughter] connecting this conductor is not a problem why you guys are in a bikoyan so ibazoo that comes out that even if it is a vabe mason the basic forest but if it's akum and the tree at most is a mavitum it's not the the the tumor itself so you have that to be slammed on driving as opposed to walking there is another thought to be makel and that is the very big sugiya which we once discussed but was again for us that there's no doubt about it can be right next to a mace and it's upon him and in certain cases why let's say there's a mason room a and the the the coins in room b and it's totally separate he has the windows closed and open it's not safe for tomorrow he's he's in a safe embassy if he's in a separate rashus there's nothing connecting the two so the queen is could be tucker very close to the maze i mean it's just a wall in between but that's fine as long as there's no place for safety etc so the question is so let's say cayenne is in a plane or in a car maybe he's a separate resource so even what's he might be flying over basically but let's give the plane the status of a separate oil and the windows are closed nope so why is he any worse than a cayenne that's on in one room and there's a maze in the other room but this of course is the well-known surge of oil zoro it's a mishna in the house it's immar nozzle all places but to make a very long story short weep asking oil syrup so it's not independent regarding the transfer of toma and that's why there's no hecta per se as far as aquarium being in a plane and not worrying about flying or basic words because i'm in an oil zorg you're right you're in oil's arc but oil zorro lois may oil i mean that's it's oil that's flying but what's that that's when he's flying or in the mishnah's case when there's a bird flying or a palace a cloak that's flying in the air that's oil zurich oil but let's say you're in an oil that's grounded on the ground let's say in an agola or today in the car and it's pretty much grounded in that respect that it has a certain permanence where it is says the michelle milner maybe that oil zurich pay and the situation say that might apply to today's cause if there's no but the windows are closed so even if you say oh it's my oil but this is on the ground but the overwhelming majority of price given strongly take exception to that the relation is still moving the fact that it has a a little more permanent than flying in the air is not enough to make it an oil you know we don't see kahanam attending a levia or basic forest and being in a car with closed windows i mean the ralph paulo and jeremy kimmel writes with pain that he once saw heard of a cayenne that went to a basic forest and he said i'm oil zorro and he basically said you can't do that because we know we don't rely on that regarding in our goal and today's causal one is a perfect example but and here's what the big but the price can do add if a person is driving and and the worst scenario it's a basic foreign and the tree situation is not known to him so then you could continue driving you have enough starting to make them not that we're magabe pulis but again we don't do things like killer but this is enough to to to allow the current to drive of course as quick as he can out and avoid this vehicle but these three fakers sort of combine to make a sort of a stickle of a cooler in the case where a person's out of town and we could say typically roy oil is going him and roy mason so an unidentifiable base aquarist you could assume to be guys so he's driving and the tree is not sure what the status of the tree is and also the oils are quite some now the truth is that's part of this course of being a client to know your roots you know when you see it once okay the next time figure it out the status of it again you don't have to be a yachting yachting if you just you know how to study trees and see the the situation of it but basically this is the you saw it the the other question that i mentioned about a bus driver so the truth is stamp bus especially during the summer the windows are open so it wouldn't be an oil zark even like the maquillium and to get all the boys to close the window is not going to happen so really if he's going under a tree that overlaps again this should be sakura's even if he has children might even be the nest of the ice on the isro because that would be amber amartha that's saphen and the adam i saw an interesting question where queen is driving and he stays away from basic forest and trees he's in a tunnel and his muscle there's a hearse that pulls up side by side what do you do now so this is oil zaryak at best but it's still not better than oil sorry delicious that we say oil he's not in an embassy for himself so someone said i would just step on the gas that's dangerous you know it's not your valyabra and the issue was going into oil not just uh finding yourself in the oil so we don't do dangerous thing that's for sure but here we have one possible hectare if he closes the windows quickly so you have at least the oil zorro gates up the only eight is to drive out quickly and safely quickly that is because there's nothing to do to jump out of the car is suicide and also it's worse because if you lose the head of oil zarg you don't gain anything you're still in the same oil the tunnel is one big oil now if it's a glacier hearse so you have another tab that the mace acumen is only metabolic mass and not the oil ravasana has this sheila and hailey kimmel quickly it's hard to know the the situation but he says if a i think what he's talking about is not a gay here he paid his toll for example he's about to go into the tunnel and this is a hearse pulling into the tunnel so he should not go in he should back out i i lose his money but la meissa have said money is not a hectic to make hamburglar mason even though it's a guy but you know that's the cost on a bissell to be a cayenne now in our times you can't back up in a tunnel that's that's dangerous so it has to be a case that says that and maybe a big fine you don't have to incur to avoid thomas kahane now of course what he means to say is if it's yiddish rehearse and it's not the head of thomas akum then maybe you know if he backs down he'll get a big hefty ticket so that's part of the the privilege of being a client because there's no i mean it's pashtus alab and koma moines something you've heard raponna now so if you know in advance but again typically i don't think you could back up you know buy the ticket they might arrest the person but oh yeah okay well so basically that's for you not reckless bosnian rights i philosophically but if it's just a question of momminess that a person should know the difference that yidn't going someone asked me he's driving minding his own business and he looks up under he stopped for a red light and there's a hearse pulls up next him and the streetlight is the the maybe tumor from his car to the from the hearse to his car so same idea this is if his windows are closed this would be an oil zorg and if you notice that it's a gorgeous hers so you have those at thearum and the question is what's your option just to pull out dangerously is he's definitely not an ather but you know maybe talk if he sees his either hers and he's a little of an aggressive fellow he'll jump the light when it's not dangerous of course i'm talking it's not dangerous so if i get a ticket nope it's it's uh you know it's on the house version will appreciate that uh zehirus the other question which is really a beautiful sugiya but the dental implant you should know the mathias is that typically they used to use the dental implants that's for dentures or teeth that are put in a permanent bases they used to use the bone crushed bones from the animals but after the mad cow epidemic it's all humans now whether you like it or not i don't want to you know tell you the new bad news but that's the mathias the question's not the mathias the question only is that if it's a goyisha bones that it comes from so it's not even a hetero because true every occupation but oil but magen massa is so the so the cayenne is carrying uh that remains in his mouth so it's not even the head of of akum but the point that revolves it's a beautiful safe it has many shallows very reliable from his talmud that um he was emphatic about it and he said that since that the bones were were crushed into some sizes smaller than era because that is from bossa but from bones to ayura it was made less than a saw area and the so it has a lot of chemical and doesn't regain its status even if it's put together to a size big in this area and he says and he said i know what they say in my name but that's what i'm telling you so that's relieving that would that would not be a problem but what's really a little of an issue is the last part of the sugi and that is a client visiting a hospital now the truth is we could definitely say that the messiah says that you know healthy people don't usually stay in hospitals there's always a concern of a person dying or maybe died already minimally there are nephilim there are body parts i don't get the details but with any research there are autopsies especially if it's about there's a pathology that has body parts because there are certainly university hospitals that are affiliated and are constantly teaching and learning so it's almost a music that there is some tumor that ukraine has to avoid that's bizarre but then again the question is if there's anything he has his father's in the hospital and he has to go visit his father so the fact that it's a mitzvah in itself not a heter because i'll have a special term it's called mitsuba can't do a mitzvah but my favorite that's possible the question is a more fundamental one because as i told you earlier even if there's a mace in the building a coin could be in a separate embassy in his room with no pesach and it's fine so this is the uniqueness of a hospital in this respect the truth is most poisons say that a big hospital especially a galicia hospital is almost a vaday that is a mace a mace or a maze or whatever but the question is going to visit if i go carefully who said i'm going to be entering the oil mace pathology is typically in the bottom then it walks in the bottom floor what's that do it with the client but the question is you never know now this i want to tell you you know i have a i'm an ishiba and we have a lot of experience with this i heard from three different kehanam er from all khanna they had to visit grandparent they had a hetero go in go out and they found out before there's no mason and walking out three bucks told me over the years that right next to them they're willing out of mace now it's not the hospital's fault i'll tell you whose fault it is and it's not lashing her you know whose fault it is the malachim of us because you know the hospital can be very careful but if someone dies what are you supposed to do now typically they keep their more critical patients in a different floor everything is fine but la meister it happened and it happened i know three times over the years so no one could guarantee anything but again typically trying to go and come and not come into a problem of being in the same halachic oil yes the same hospital the same building but that really is irrelevant for al sugiyam so the shaila is is it svekada is you might end up in a hole with a mace or do we say that that's unreasonable because he said there's a big suggest of suffolk tomorrow and a hospital has the status of them so there's a beautiful discussion rabbi yashiva in the sunni al-aqsa amazing and on a very thorough discussion but basically he says if there's a real suffolk then we don't say suffictoma and that's his cloud as many others saying that basically regarding air travel right they're not officially flying over a basic forest but you don't know what the flying gold might be flying over lavay i mean you know there's always the imagination what will be and again a half a dozen police can say that that's sufficient and don't worry about it so it's not it's more than statistics the question is how much of a chance is it that you could go and come safely and avoid it now once you've reduced it to a decent suffix then you have a suggestion because the very the very famous sugiya of the base the basa pros which is basically a place that there is known to be there was mason it was the area was plowed so it's a suffix aleph quotes that and that is in other words it's a suffix it's a suffix rabbanan and khazal made an issa of vasa pras but mocha mitzvah's motto oh so now we have not tamamese mitzvah but if it's a suffix rabonan there's nothing they have to mock a mitzvah so the question when is this applicable to alva shilas so again i cannot tell what i found the first one that discusses this is the chura shah he was the robin sigit it was printed in 1905 on the sparring and it's hard to understand but it's seeing that it was he writes a big hospital that they may say i don't know maybe cigarette had their own hospital but it was a vaday mesa isro i'm not talking about bellevue hospital that's gorgeous so he says that you have to be mavara a korean that has to go visit the parent let's say and it's a mocha mitzvah and physical parents so first you have to send the scout to know what's doing and then he says if you can't be mavara en la noya because of the mitsubishi he goes like almost a about face now i didn't understand that at first because you told me may see a throw so why are you also making like a mitzvah but then i realized like i told you earlier having a mace in the hospital does not mean that you client will encounter an oil hamas if you go and will soon see how to go but you go on the safest course of action you could avoid being in the same oil as amazing if there is a mace but this one i could tell you what i saw again the information is very brief but that's what he says rapslam is almond and miner so that's really neutralized the hecta of suffolk tumor surrounding but then he comes to this question of visiting someone in the hospital and he says well you can't a person can go on to basically isis because of a sufficient here it's a it's a hospitality throat where this body may see israel so he says that it's kavoor mason but he also says that even in the room we're visiting the the maybe the windows open maybe so tomorrow says so you have to be careful not to go into battery hoiling good island where it's israel the cayenne mitzvah's bigger that's his washer holds his mutter to go in when you have no other choice so again the karl maccurum but again i think it's the same you saw it if there's a van they may see throw that's available but the coin could go carefully and hope for the best what are the chance that he's going to have the experience that my bachelor had that he met a cayenne i met a mace in the hall it's a chance but it's a very remote chance that's faker keep making the mitzvah but the third is our moisture in and this is a bit information that we have to know because this is really very often the american scene not cigarette or earth israel a hospital that's roy akum and typically most uh hospitals except for our local hospitals but most hospitals are definitely right back them so much just says that to be honest maybe it's a year you have to be gracious roy you've got live islands got him and roy mason he says butler myself we stay away from akamoso that's been knocking his arm and reminisces off of his quarterback his makeover has to show them he writes twice to wash the soyuz what sorry had godo the queen's allowed to go to a hospital that's very vacuum not stamit's mutton again lost sir goddard you could be makel and sorry god of the aviv that's expecting his visit that's where mauritius lost now he says one try to be valor at first but again the point is that the bottom line is a claim could go in carefully and reduce it to a very minimal sophicle this is why lamisa in america and hutzler's i should say absent the few hospitals we could assume it's ray vacuum now the truth is that ravosna in hello kay kuff pedalid is also making makkah mitzvah but he comes from a different angle and he says typically it's not even a mitsubishi and and then he says but very often it's not because it's a social visit he says i said that's really my problem it's not really maka mitzvah it's not necessary and our emotions are the same thing and our palm avoided going to a hospital because he would go sometimes to the hospital stay on the outside and wave to the highlands sometimes communicate when possible because you know very often it's the show of confidence to show of of care a phone call sometimes could replace that or a nice gift a thoughtful gift it's very hard to give kuala lumpur i will just tell you what ravosna says that basically his point is that if you can reduce the chance by going in a proper way but again he says avoid growing if it could be avoided minimize the visits and shorten the business says something and you have to take it with a grain of salt he says go visit the aledas the korean's a wife had a baby and afterwards go run to the hospital who said that's necessary you know she's not uh critically ill and if it's a day and a half that you know she won't have a visitor now i'm afraid to say this some people's wives would not remodel them but but the story there that i want to point out yeah that's with someone's wife a coyote's wife suffered a miscarriage and he wanted to visit her at night when there's no problem of the nightfall being in the vicinity so ryan says what's up this give her a call so on the bottom they write that rabbi ashiva knew the koin and knew the wife and she would be satisfied with the phone call and they quoted berkey isis precious washington in the end of shinsai the gimbal a child you have to be cycled by shekel aquidish some wives are proud to be asia's kaihanim and they're the michael to visit them and a person's a deathly ill they need visitors but uh everybody's bringing flowers and everything you know so they'll wait a day and a half so approach with caution at your own you know at your own understanding each child is different the shekel koi is bringing the younger brother of the newborn if the newborns are kind of obviously the brother is also a cayenne that could be a violation of of of of emma marta now basically when a parent is sick is a very different story a parent needs the child there's no one that could place a child and the parent needs the child and the child has to be there even at a longer visit so whether that's his place you know then that we have to say that this is something that you have to have a little that checker like now a few practical tips how to do it and avoid or at least to minimize reduce the concerns the there's no doubt about it that being in the same building or the same floor in itself is not coming it's basically being in the same resource or in this in the same area where there's a pesach so when a client has to decide if the shekel occurs he has to visit someone in the hospital step one try to be mavaro i mean some hospitals are more friendly than other ones but try to move out what's doing on this floor what's doing in the in the lobby send a scout non-coin ahead of you is a good idea then typically travel by stairway not elevators elevators has the problem of you might be in a mace there obviously because they don't bring mason in stairways also safe templates is a very big factor so if you know that his coast is clear on the ground floor and it's possible of course it's not a very very high climb go by stairway that's a that's eliminates another problem and when you get to the coiler's room close the door they might give you a hard time so you try to explain for religious purpose you have to keep the door closed windows are no longer you know find windows in hospitals anyhow but basically try to keep the room without a place if you have if the parent needs something so if you get a nurse to bring it you call or if you have a daughter she could go but try to avoid going in the halls unnecessarily because that's where the either say for tomorrow says or more so it could be just happened to be in one of these you know minority situation that amazes is wheeled out and again no one could promise you it's not it's not shaykh it's getting over this decision i mean the personal decision but malcolm x is the one that makes the trouble so basically check and go stay in the room and before you leave again if you have to have a scout going ahead go the quickest route to the staircase and go down and when you get downstairs again try to see what's doing and go out as quick as possible the the basic point is the shorter the visit the better because that that relieves or eliminates some of the concern what will be now all of this would be mutter even be making that this there's mason in the in the building because again the fact that the ground floor or the pathology is nothing to do with the the khaila and his rooms the real issue is you might just meet a mace in the hall itself that's a small suffix and that's with the pikachu and of course make sure that now a parent that's sick the child can't run out they have to five minute visit so use the shekal akaidesh and habal atari a certain messianic someone asked me his he's he's a korean his wife is an asia's client and he was told she cannot go to levaya because she's mubarak she's expecting and someone told him that she can't go to levays or basic forest now this seems to be contrary to what we began with there ikea the chaos said an asia's cayenne muberus could go into an oil amaze but the problem he said was that his wife took a ultrasound and they determined the gender of the child and now it's no longer sex faker it's a zakha now hopefully he's not hoping for the fallen so what's the hector so the embassy is representing zion writes that you don't trust these ultrasounds they're wrong and he writes stories some horrible stories about people told that the child is born is gonna be born without a head i don't know how even the story was but that's he has there and it was not true and and the deformity we don't trust ultrasounds but the embassies even if you do have a reason to believe that it's going to be a zohar there's a whole other factor to consider and that's the magana ram and shin mem gimbal who won this why do i care have to have a head of sex maker why don't we say that even if it's guaranteed it's a terrible law it's in the embassy of its of his mother and that's another behavior even if it's not a sex shaker plus almond in this is quoted in the bay semen he says let's say you don't come on to the head of tower balloon but what is the status of an unborn baby is he have din kahuna uber who told you it's considered a kite now this of course puts a question mark on the whole reikaya that is only talking she might deliver in the oiler mace and then the baby is one eye it's a baby that's the problem and that's why typically a mubarak has no problem being in a oil hamas vomit however the guy bits incredibly to be concerned that in the ninth month when she is not to go on the lms it might happen and i saw other players come say that so we have to qualify that that's only in the ninth month is the proud of mubarakis being an oil and mace but then i saw the min members where someone asked him this question and he said there's a minig that any mubarak is not going to oil amaze even in israel and it's very you know relieving very it's a breath of fresh air we're talking about mason he said the mystery says in paris bays they had to get shepherd water for the the mayan of the of the para and they had to have special use raleigh that were brought up bittahara no and women looked for the opportunity to have that child so he wants to say that that's where the minute was that mubarak stayed away from oil lames even anytime even easter alice she had the amount of she wants to have a child that's hey look okay that's a minute some baklao have have a minute just keep um keep mubarak's attabasa forest that's plummer but that i'll see the but let me leave you with another beautiful aurora a cayenne one of those wonderful malachi rahman who works fatsola and he told me once i guess in jess but he said he ran to a call and the person i think said coded as to what he said but the person was stopped breathing he's considered clinically dead so he revived him he was looking to revive him and he felt great about himself there was mikhail mason they said hey what did i do i was in the oil of a mace so i told him he made it to a tasis twice is i said that's one hectare but the reality you me and you is you are mikhail mason i mean you're a great person but yamaha mason pariah the person that have to have a new conduction that as if he was reborn again so basically it's just that he brought him a little more his and hopefully we'll have those type of horrors i couldn't talk to you [Music] 718 851 8651 or email ist yoshida.com as is hashem after the minifigure of smith will say a secret of today [Music] is foreign