CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 55 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning. We're here in Austria. It's You see the waterfall over here. You see the mountains. You see snow. Dozens of feet of snow covered with a little dirt. But we got to learn Tyra in every situation in every place says the we discussed in the Mishna that when you have a ka even if it has a small hole it's not tra but if the ka has a hole the size of an iser then it's grave. I should say cella, but we're in the middle of the waterfalls. I saidella. So, says like this. Think about it. When I tell you I'm going to give you a test from daf lammed, how many daft do you have to take a test on? Is daf lammed part of the test or it's up until dam? That's is not included or is included. So when I tell you everything is kosher, everything is green up until beyond the cella it's all tra. What about the cella itself? What about llamid? Obviously you're not going to take a test you don't have to take a test all the way to test. What about what about the is from the factor of saysella? He says that the cell itself is like more than a cell and we're going to go into it a little bit more up until a cell obviously is kosher. Everything beyond the cellah obviously a whole larger than cellar is traia itself exactly a cell. So that's the famous in of somebody brought a muscle in the others here. You're supposed to say on Shabas every Shabas it says Shabas. So do you see it on Shabas or not? Means in that case not Shabas. So if says that the when it's the size of the coin it's already strafe that means he says because he's saying up until now it's kosher this salah is not included in up until now this is beyond it's lalo we're going to see it's above if it's below it's included in what he said which is kosher but it's not it's above it's the next category it's another mushel a good mushel is that Diru they give you a test they say from d until dam is the test. So do you have to prepare that for the test? So there's a steer they say in itself because when it comes to it's not included when it comes to that it says that you know until means including okay got next time I speak to I'm going to ask him what's in the in the contradiction he's going to tell me but let's say let's say certain things it includes when you say up until here means but including that and some up until but not So says not not included it's not included is above it's already the next it's already pes it's already afterwards and when it comes to the con when it comes to the the yeah yeah trachea trachea not the esophagus it comes to the trachea the breathing tube this it's another type of coin kisser so when it's exactly is ker let's say it goes lala goes above It's already the next category when he says up until it does not include the word he used the whatever she is using it's already in the next category. So now the is going to ask you didn't you didn't help me out last time I told you to to count. Now you have to count. Let's count together. Here's number one. You have a bed that has a string that's that's hanging off the bed. strings themselves are not but if they're part of a cleab. So it says if it's up until five is too small it's not appropriate for any kind of so it's not a but up until five where's the five what about five itself is also says no we have the same question same answer multiple times maybe seven times or It's like when I mention a word, it means it's in the next category. It's not with the category that I'm mentioning it with. I'm not saying from zero to five, but the five is already from like five to 10. It's already in the next category, which is awesome, which is a cle. Yeah. Number two. Thank you. Tommy from 5 to 10 is Tommy says a beautiful thing. What would people do with this string from 5 to 10? They would use it to tie a sheep to their bed. Today we unfortunately have md so we don't bring the corbonus and we don't tie a sheep to our bed upon him. It says from 5 to 10 it's remember that is a from 0 to 5 it's it's a we would say now it's like a so it's in the category of it's beyond 10 it's already different category number three when you have small earn If they're broken, even if they're broken, but as the is going to say in a second, they could stand on their own. So you have a piece of broken earthwware that's just the bottom or you have a wall, but it can stand on its own. So it has a shear that if it could hold this shear, it's considered a cle. Otherwise, it's a broken cle. doesn't cotton means that you could wash shampoo a young child. So if you could hold that small amount of of soaplug that's the shear. Now adl what's once again we're going to ask a question he says here seems what number is this four now we continue with these once they're larger they're from it has to contain more than that it has to contain a reas like what we drink now 80 what time is it we have a camera everything is good Yeah. Okay. No, I'm looking at the at a message sent me. I didn't see it before. Okay. My sorry my is down number five. Oh, so it's only five. All these you answer me that it goes with that it goes to the next category even though I thought it's all these things that you just answered me that it goes to the next category. By the way, if you don't like this whole it's going to be over in a minute and every two minutes is Oh, but it says that we go says and this answers everything. When do you go? When it's We always want to go. We want to go says. So we're always going to go to So if we go if we go when it comes to a woman and a stain of dam on a km on a on a piece of begged. So over there we go. Why? Because the whole idea of that a woman has to be concerned of on her clothing that's only a we are in that in that wholeish over there of we have we we treat it because it's and because once it goes above it's not a So will be like a kamisha will be like a kiter. You go from both directions. We're always being mach in a brand new brand new raai. We're on a bridge that's between couple thousand ft from ground level in between two Alps. Beautiful waterfalls, beautiful rivers. Love to learn little gar up here. It says in the if the spleen is completely removed, the animal is not a tra it's cauter. So thear makes a distinction and you can look it up. I looked it up this morning on chat GPT. There's a difference between removing a spleen completely and puncturing the spleen. If a human being or an animal has a punctured spleen, they could die. But if you remove it completely, then it's kosher. Says it's only because it was completely removed. But if there's a puncture that it's What about if you cut off a piece? Cut off a piece. What's worse? Cutting off a piece or a hole? So that's also interesting. We'll see in a second. When the entire spleen is removed, then it's cauter. But if it has a hole in it, then it's a if somebody cuts off a limb from within an animal, a pregnant animal, cut a limb from the baby. Is that is that called? No comes through the of the mother. But if you cut a piece off the from the spleen and from the kidneys, you're not allowed to eat it. Ask the you're not allowed to eat that kidney, that piece of kidney, that piece of spleen. Why? Because it is but that the animal the mother you're allowed to eat. You're not It says that piece doesn't talk about the mother. How could you eat the mother? It's missing a piece of the the spleen. And we just said that if if you poke a hole in the spleen or you take a piece off the spleen, it should be a tra remove the whole thing. We're not talking about removing the whole thing. Just took off a piece here. Of course, the animal is you just made it a tra by taking off a piece of the spleen. We're just trying to mimic the ratio that says motor. So we say er in terms of the the the the actual spleen itself. The mother is also okay. We said if you buy yourself another when we said that making a hole in the spleen makes the animal tra that's true for a hole but if you take off a nice chunk of the spleen it's similar to removing the whole spleen and that that animal remains kosher if both if the if the kidneys are removed it's kosher. If it became diseased, one of the kidneys became diseased, it's a tra where exactly how exactly it's in the place of the how do you say in English? A crack uh crevice >> a crevice. Okay, there's a crevice. I'm going to show you a beautiful um here are the kidneys. This is a large animal and the amount of fat that covers the kid kidneys is incredible. But he's going to show you the head of move to the side. the corn inside the shoulder and that's where the giddy was connected to the clothes. >> You see the crevice over there where the white is that's what that's what you're saying I believe. >> Oh, not the crevices in between the G. >> No, no, no. The back crevice. The back. There's like a long line. It's one crevice, not a bunch of It's a It's not a crevice. It's a It's like um Maybe there's a better word than crevice. More like a You saw in the back. It's like the white part that's underneath by the loins. I asked all the in the ones who make who pass is that a clo that kidney which became diseased is a tra and is not like that says that when there's a hole in the spleen that is a tra in the spleen we're talking about where is it kosher in the in the in the thinner part. So here's Rabbi Vicefish again. cast. He's got two parts here. Bio part. There's a if there's a hole in the thicker part, >> it is it's called when there's a hole through in the thin part then it's kosher in the thicker part like this right over here. If there's a in the spleen there's a a thickness of uh dinner then it's saying if there's a tra when it comes to the lungs that is actually kosher when it comes to the kidneys ne a Little hole is puzzle in a kidney. But in a in a in a kidney, it's kosher. They say a lung. Okay. A hole is ple in a lung. That same hole is kosher in a kidney. And if something's kosher in a lung, certainly is kosher in a kidney. So says a question mascul lines down. Is that really a rule? When this p the bare that is something that's kosher in a long where's that thing here right over here pictureong is kosher kidney is is possible so it's exact opposite what we just said when there's clear waters both of them are kosher now says what are you comparing we already had You can't compare one organ to the other. Remember we had it. If you cut in the lower part of the leg, the animal will live. But if you cut in the upper part of the leg, the animal will die. Or sorry. Cut in the lower part of the leg will die. Cut in the upper leg part as if you cut a finger the person will live. You cut the arm he could possibly die. I'm saying the upper part would seem to be worse, but it's not. But is saying according to Rashi, if you if you sh that animal on his neck, he's going to die. If you do the same type of cut on his on his thigh, he won't die. So how you how you bring a rat from a thigh to the neck, from a from a from a lung to to a kidney, they're two different organs. When you find this water, it's kosher. when they are clear when the cloudy and even the clear water doesn't smell if it has a smell to it an odor even if it's clear water it's a kidney that that's shrunk when it's a small animal the size of a how do you say in English certain bean a legume uh >> when it's a a larger When the lower here it is it's completely removed. If the if it's completely removed it's kosher provided that that a human being could feed it. That's an addition by the Gar doesn't say that. Okay. If if he can't stuff the food into its mouth and and it's going to die like that then it's a says another says if the womb was removed it's the same word anytime the mention one of these three words you know it's talking about the womb remember this guy right over here who's scared So one of its lungs shriveled. Now listen to this. We say second if it happened a person went boo and it got so scared that it lung shriveled. What is adding the first part? He says all the B eyes let's say a lion went rah scared it then it's what it's straight for he saying anything is also when lions do it or even people is he arguing he says even people that scares is like or that says that a person that that scares a animal strafe and I'm telling you other other creatures It's also uh tra they call it not only a person but even a lion says it says in the if it happened through a person that he got scared through a person not only a person even other animals. So you see that he's not walking in the desert. He met he bumped into a bunch of rams. Did something do their lungs shrunk? You didn't want to throw them out. What should I do? This is the This is the rule. In the summer, you should take white earnware to put cold water in it van lace and leave it there for 24 hours. In the summer, you take a a white earthen wear and and put water in it and it cools off to the lung and you leave it there for 24 hours and if it if it goes back to where it was before, then that's considered heavenly. If it goes back, it's sorry. Yeah. But in the winter, do the same thing but with a blacker than fill it up with warm water and put the lung in there for 24 hours. If he goes back to its original form, it's kosher bela. And here we have a little short video. them. So it seems like says that animal without skin is kosher not a tra and they say it's possible retracted he holds that an animal without skin is poss still argues himself says here agrees that it's possible. Okay, there other people say it's possible holds kosher like And if there's left over a little bit of of of of skin the size of a salah kosher because the whole idea is that if there's a little bit of skin left it could regenerate and it could heal. But how much? So what does it mean that they didn't argue? Their mayor didn't remain with his. Sometimes a person gets stubborn. A person is in argument and he wants to win. Everybody wants to win. I'm a winner. I never lose my arguments. My entire life I always tell my wife an entire marriage I only lost to you twice. You know, I don't lose arguments. is selling. If one piece of skin the size of a cell is left on the animal pictures, where exactly is this piece of skin? Could it be on his nose? Could it be on his toes? Like where it has to be on the entire top of the spine as like this very very skinny narrow on top of the spine. Get pictures. a cell worth, you know, like like a fishing line. Long long very very thin but long. It's very th very long and thin. When you put it all together perhaps it's very wide. Something like this. This a little thicker. That should be the cell the whole size the whole the whole length of the spine. It is a wide and as long as the whole the whole spine. In other words, many many many cellas. It has to be on all the joints. Here's a beautiful job they did here. You see on all the joints, on the knees, on the thigh, on the on the uh spine. Welcome to how you say in a nice way. Belly button. Belly button. Naval. Naval. Oh, so now he's saying if the the skin must be on the shedra and it's a no no place on the body but the shedra. So what if you do the reverse? It's on the entire body missing on the spine. Do we I thought we had a picture for that. I think yeah. Here he has hair everywhere. I mean skin everywhere but he's missing the spine part. It's a great character. Come on. It's an original. Got p the pas with the board. He's drooling. He has a thermometer in his mouth. He has a box of tissues. Walking around his yamap. >> All right. Um, what if he's missing from the navl? He's missing. He has everything, but his his navl is missing. He must have that also. He has everything besides the joints. My all. Should we stop over here? Have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.