Daf Yomi Chulin Daf 21 by R’ Eli Stefansky

slides from the bottom omarama so we had yesterday a major hitters by xiri theory says that if you break the neck the the spine the neck and most of the boss or most of the muscles surrounding it then the animal turns into novella even if it's myth far Hess's even if the animal is sort of alive moving around it's still a problem it's still unavailable you might want to bring Araya from from what do you call it to muster Bleus oyf from Malika now the more I push that that cash off Robert says like this Amuro EK Schiele if i have a proud what see here he said that breaking its neck creates an available I have a much bigger problem the casually all-cash Lee became a saw a middle my leg anytime you do Malika really do Malika from from the back of the neck so the nail goes through the spine creates an avail according to xiri and then you continue on and you caught the C Mon Amie so a straw oh why are you cutting C Mon what's the point you're cutting semana of a dead bird there's no Indian to do Chiquita if you want to tell me that Mallika happens by by breaking its neck okay but why continue going on to the C Mon and what's the point of according to see market or Malaya by uh what's your kasha if you're ready asking from there as from somewhere else with actually oil I saw the by a snake seemed on him as we're gonna see the whole studio today when it comes to the bird or law you need to cut both seam on it there's gonna be my flag is whether you need to cut the entire seam on him completely or you're now a Dakota completely you have to cut it right but you have to cut both them as the buyer but he may saw you know might look after you cut one simin we know that buy a bird all you need to do sheet on is one sim and why because one sim it is what kills the bird so the what's the point in cutting the second Simon what do you gain by cutting a second simian in our less oil if one seaman kills it then why you continue on to the second where is the even as I live because you see more than what Simon once him it is enough well you cutting a bird that's already dead by the time you get to the second Simon it's a dead bird there's no such thing as killing a dead bird chuffing a dead bird on my leg says Robyn oh that's not a good cash on me possum today the kind but misses half dollar you're right when we ship to see Monument a bird it's not for the mitzvos kita it's for the mid sis have a dollar there's a concept of separating the head from the body but nothing to do with Chiquita in economic would be enough one Simon but but Lamesa east Eliza's question why according to theory why buy me liquor do you have to do C Mon Ami you already killed it by breaking its neck it's by says the game Aram hockey if that's the case that the whole point of calling the - C Mon amis for half dollar or Nami how come you don't have to cut all the skin off completely says the game Mario call him a hockey mosquito net occupied a dollar so right now the the key word in this Terrence is the word Moroccan whatever is ma a Cuban Chiquita is Mac you've enough dollar so by Chiquito you don't need skin around at the birds neck let's say the bird is missing its skin it has some problem it lost its skin right before Skeeter you can do shaquita or you have to chef so since you have to share that's why it's Maggie because she any marketer she into any market by half a dollar and therefore that's not a question why you don't have to cut the skin because the skin is not part of something that's market as the Gemara if the word is my active only something that will prevent a skin from happening vermeil see Madame labonne on the Lyman activist key to actually map dollar according to her bonnet if you share 3/4 of the Somalian that's good enough for schita but it's not good enough for the mitzvah of dollar yet the cot whole thing yet so let's let's take the let's take the sheet oh the 75% of the street let's say call 51% seventy-five percent just to make it sound good 75% three-quarters is the shaquita the final quarter this final 25% is not for sceeto it's for Abdullah but why do you have to do it if you just said that the key word is mahashiv what's my active in the shmitah what's my condition - only the first 75% the second the last 25% is not marking miss Rita so why would you have to cut it says the kymaro you're right you know you just have to change the wording a little bit instead of saying in my active but meaty monitor I bought into like Marketo my acne by half a dollar the last 25% is not Mac even the Chiquita why cause it going through our bun on Raw Eve but you still need to travel along a ma cause she yes maybe she keep talking about the key word here is its in the parsha cutting the content event is in the partial of kita it's not my active skill because you don't have to do all of it but whatever is in it that's what you have to cut here's me mafdal up anybody IMF dollar math shaking when it comes to skin skin is not part of schita it's not yesterday the Chiquita you don't need skin with asking you could also do sceeto so Mela when it comes to half a dollar you don't have to remove that yeah how does is it says Natori Villa yeah bill you shouldn't or you should be map delayed so it's a mitzvah in the tired though like we learned in this welcoming me you you have to put it on separately animals back whatever it's it's Suki we're gonna we're gonna discuss some of it now we call Magan Kashi at the end of the day we still have robbers Kasia Robert just did away with a bias kasha on his own kasha but at the end of the day you have robbers casual which is according to the Erie that says that you could buy breaking the neck you create an availa the question is how come by Malika which you break the net before you get to the C Mon and why do you continue on to the C Mon and what do you gain by that you your shafting your being my like a dead bird a mother a mother hey new i sir Seema Mela Rob is forced to say on his own kasha hoid up she drove my fred is below your own bus on the way to do you put your nail in there and you make sure you don't sever the muscle and the and the tissue and the meat that's around the corner invasion you just go straight in because if you got the right posture around if you're gonna cut that that's gonna create an available but by going straight in knocking out the muff Rekha's the the spine and going into the into the cone intervention then it's not dead yet it's not an available in a veil or because look at zebras lotion I'm a serine is Burma fracas Mariah i'ma only when you have most of the meat that's caught as well as them a fracas then it becomes an available but if you don't do right boss so it's not in a villa he's sure took a water after it's good to see you it's good to see at the show you see by the way he gets eat before he question I just want to say look if he's sitting here by the shearing listenings that means that all the times that it wasn't there it's as if he's there that's what lady said that his speech it's just it's just because is just because he can't do it he partially has to get us coffee yeah yeah sorry what was the question doc and it was a difficult it was hard is difficult you have to be strong but we're talking about here we're talking about with just just to clarify there's two concepts is something called the tray foe and it's something called an availa a tray for something that we know is not going to live more than twelve months a very large wound it's walking around but it's gonna drop dead soon not not today necessarily but later but within the 12 months and the VAE law is technically dead dead so now Rosie Ruiz said by cutting through all the stuff that you just described all this bony tissue and the spine that the animals dead now but I I'm looking at the animal I see that and we're going like this how long had leads dead is an available and what happens if it's an available it emits tumor versus trayful now we're saying yes he penetrated through the spine but since he didn't get all the stuff around it all these other muscles and whatever then it's not technically dead it could be a trophy right it's gonna die but it's not an available it's a trayful that's something else yeah it doesn't matter we're talking about milliseconds here according to the Erie that it becomes an availa as soon as he hit the spine then you never got a chance to get to the even though it's part of the process you never got a chance if you slow it down in slow motion by the time I got to the corner of a shot he's already dead Esther over and you're killing a dead dead bird so Robert answers no he's not dead because he's not you have to be very careful and he he derived from this question the the there's a certain way to do mallika can't just be be careless and caught everything after we very Medaille can go right through the spine and make sure not to cut right buzzer as we're gonna see says the Gemara okie saw him is there a stricly river I mean the also be calm I launched my tub when ribs air came very strong he met Rob a me and he told him everything that was discussed on my leg became a so I meant no more like he told him everything that he said so Ravana has so what do you mean and then if she is right the breaking your neck creates in a very low then how do you do Mallika says the Gomorrah and stymie Machado he was quiet and he thought about it amar lay a macaque oil rubs are rubs area I think a macaque were you sir I thought she drove my fricassee also came to the same conclusion whether she drew my friends believe real by the way I saw I looked it up how many times does say chunkin' Shahada three times and all three have to do with represent but I'm not sure I didn't like it seem like one time of zero was was the one that was shocked I don't want time but all three observers brought down in that in that uh what yeah no new book it's time to Shahada there what was it called here Robin back you see that's the name of the book Italian a mahaki Kate and Malcolm Kappa side now we have a price of the test it's instead of a question in the answer and i haha this is a lahar and his broad entrepreneurial kids a multimeter sorry - drama why did she draw my freckles below Freud buzzer at McGill event or ela corner he gave a vegetal a kind of quite a similar hot Oh Roo boy Barabbas very much so then it says here in the price so that first you go through you get to the corner that shot and then only afterwards it says variety mode you have to be careful not to do right boss or before you get to the content evasion oh boy law says why do you have to do it I don't know why the immune but maybe that's how you kill it better I don't know no that's the Euler Euler name or age nine you know I law you have to cut the balsam on him or the majority of both see mine ask the game are just on these words mani ear a bono on and this is what we're gonna be dealing with for the rest of today this mock like is a rabona on arabela's rib Shimon this is Michael agus ear a bond are abundant all the Irish named after upon a whole you have to cut the two-seam on him completely eerie below the ribs Shimon hall my Reifschneider blossom in the halls that you're not allowed to cut the two-seam honor they have to be hanging by a thread as we're gonna see all the way then the Sookie may be enough for Bay's that according to their laws of Shimon when you bring it out in this Bay F the head has to be connected to the body so the only way that that is connected the body says rubbish if you don't cut the seam on him completely you cut them right so why are you telling me that you do either all of it all right basically you telling me a contradiction you tell me your opponent and rebel is river swimming in the same sentence three quarters of each one from you mean the one of the top of the other yeah you can move it around we learned you can move it around no he's saying that they go like this the knife comes in by the time I get to this one this is completely severed how logically could be it will be okay if one of them was still holding on because he still have that head connected no cuz it says Shania means totally complete and right that doesn't change anything why is it changed only it says rave of two or completely to the two separate things but I'm saying one is complete and the other one is right it's still right Amos immerses you right should I am their opponent rich time the rebels machine basically the prices didn't want to get into an argument here they didn't want to pass kin one way or the other price it brought both sheet this yapper a bond on the lotion doesn't fit so nicely the other abundant station I mean you have Rebelo that says Roche name but the boy same it doesn't if it even it's even worse we buy same Ahava horrible lots of rich women both duration is safer laws regime you know my name should do me much night in other words so rad she explains here that on the one hand rebel Ozma Sherman says you have to cut it weird sneak are that you did right but you could see it visually visually see it that you look at it you see uh rooibos cot ah he says the Bryce but if you didn't you know you can't see it it just cost fifty one percent and you don't you can't really it's also good but buddy of it so what the Bryce is saying the way you read it is roshni I'm you need I'm sorry oh boy lush nyam you need the cuts name and you have to see that it looks like to it you could see that I orbit the air bed ropes nine fine now you remember naphthol he's not here how about we I asked you riddle how does it shape that an animal is alive and it's Makabe it gives off tumor so enough thought I was the one that said going old going on a caver the Anna was on a caver shy looked the animal moves away here's another riddle it's the same riddle how's it possible that I was not on a caver that I was walking around and amidst Toma says the Gemara reviewed our mission well miss Burrell my fracas if a person his neck was broken burrowed buzzer mo MIT Tama Boyle so a person's neck was broken with most of his meat so he's considered an availa and he's Mitama Boyle he's gonna be considered a mace now just I made a quick chart because I thought there's a finish here in oil the way we normally understand the oil is how do we understand the oil that it is a dead person in a house everything in the house becomes comic there's more to it there's two more L office I thought I just want to point out this is how we understand oil by the way we're gonna get photo shots gonna be much much better but if there's a dead person under I owe everything underneath but here's the other 12 hours are very born if the dead person is above the person just hanging there let's say he's on a tree hanging dead and you walk underneath him you're also taught me at a vile and if he's underneath you and you're above him you're hanging on the tree then it's also oil those are all three offensive oil no because it's that person you can't go below a dead person forget about a roof just the dead person himself creates the oil and you create a oil over the dead person and you're talking fine what about the ah sweetie um no I think there's whole things that you shouldn't be building on topic farm nothing to the table they don't give up to what they care about they don't like we live over rat bones or whatever animal bones they throw in there alright alright according to we have a friend in Chicago that's what he Titan is Ricky Rothery said they have videos that I'm coming in with bones I like bones and they just put it in then they make I'm gonna the next day that's what he claims I mean he owns sneller so obviously gonna say that right already those will know that's what Baldwin says also fire no I get a half a smile from him over have you loving some world listen with my friends rebel sing on the town boil them time iron out the Gemara ass what a bad oh he said my Sedalia holding in middle def colorful middle Alif in the middle meantime I my sedately what happened with daily acclaim the famous story fell off the chair and he died my friends billary boss IV over there he just broke his spine but there's no road boss are how did he die says the Gemara is sickness shiny he was very old he was 98 years old so over there the posix says that the Jews went to war the push them captured the alright and the messenger came back to tell Haley that his two sons hophni and Phinehas died and then he said that was okayed and fall off the chair he said oh by the way they took the Orang BAM he fell off the chair and he died so it says manage it says he told them about huffing pinnacles and it says ye Caskey right but when he mentioned yes I write not only him then it's in the hands of the pushed him by evil Malachy says clear and as he fell backwards bad the other Shire batty Shaba my fractal biome always wise as the puzzle he's knocking - ish he was 98 years old The Hobbit and is also very heavy the point is that like by the spine the cut from top to bottom from tail to head they open it up right so if you do that to a person with a sword from top to bottom he can be running around and screaming he's he's Mitama boil a murder i'ma buy a stock Kumagai but this is all talking about he did it from the back of the person not from the front just like a fish was that that's more of a killing that's the more of a killer I guess maybe in the front he could sew it up in the back you can all my school I saw August Errol novella if you I have a picture for this it's a saw cutting person death no it's one of the things he was talking about no I saw distro now distros also references three things either he caught it saya you know two in half or cut off the head by the neck or he cut the spine and he opened it up that's August Errol oh my ribbon laws are me talheh you're a the hollows shallow novella if you take the hip you take the whole thigh of an animal all the way to the hip bone and where it's clear you can see the hip bone and there's no flesh and there's no skin covering the hip bone then the animal is an available I'm not sure doc what do you think happens how long does it take an animal to die if you remove this entire thigh all the way up to the bone good I'm sure there's some serious arteries there no to docks so anyways even if you see this animal walking around on three legs this animal is an availa it's a dead animal why hey P dummy kalalau what does it mean you could you could tell that you could see the all the way to the bone on my rubber cultural roots of veneers casts a row when a cow lays down on the floor so basically lays down on top of its own legs everything is folded up so if you could if everything is folded up and you still see the hip bone all the way to the hip that's considered missing then you know it's missing cut the leg off it's only in trayful so if you take if you chopped mark kouvola motto that's one of the eating traitors it's not gonna die in six minutes couple minutes we'll call Coover llama llama llama now couvreux ya lamu that's what you see you know it could live but probably won't live very long it's a traitor won't live more than 12 months hello higly ok 9 awesome we're talking about the SH - Watson who to reshape if their heads got chopped off completely or not completely we see in a second a puppy Shima Ferguson even if they're how do you say I say Perkins in English I I know how to do with my hand but how do you seizuring ok samay him they're like his novel atashi me podcasters everybody knows the lizard we caught off its tail it looks like it's alive it's moving around when we were kids and been every once caught a snake in half and it was like both of the you couldn't tell which one was alive they were both like moving around slithering through the streets so this is all just these are all what was on Chavez of course video it's not a big job know your ladder code and have on Charlie's the monistic on is the buzzes kids are so this is just nerves it's not it's not alive it's just moving because the nerves it is it's dead sounds good more of my hoots do what does it mean that this the head of this Manos got chopped off oh I have my system I seized his head got chopped off for a different time especially if you have one of those traps I'm just saying it like this you know like just cuts the head right off hoots ooh now my own Zoo and that's an obvious is one of the it's have a tumor right it's a UH you become a recent if you touch it huh yeah after a shiny new yeah you shouldn't even call math were you saying okay your shine my uber slugma like is Rakesh Sharma hoot Sammamish the whole entire head came off completely severed completely the Basia my very Manny have de las olas hoy similar to the way he severed the head of annoy law now as we mentioned briefly before it's a Schuyler whether you sever the head or not according to her blossom even seem like you don't sever for opponent seems like you do Emily are you really Revathi have done so if the rough on on rely police are you saying like the way you several on like Rabanne on you say you have to cut through the to Simone and completely and the mailer the whole head comes off or you didn't look after the rebel eyes every shame in maybe it's only going like oil according their mishima thing you only caught three quarters group shimon holds it has to still hang on by a thread when you put it on Isabelle oblique to and melee there is my legs are astonished and you rush lager says the head is completely off only then it's Mitama and you say even if that is not completely off only 3/4 off share its is Matata from La Cava dollars on the rapid loss of regime you know punk you know on yes there is my Floyd cos I hold that only three-quarters of the head and that's it pinky the Omri that it's more than foolish from Sri Lanka Sharma who soon managed that the head comes off completely about your romantic have dollars I flew a B+ Shimon he says mom and says she that is I hold like rebbi shimon barouche line the shower said they'd come off completely only rival the head came off now the governor says Myra bun we're talking about abundant velocity but what's going on what's the cheetah says the game borrowed this sine U of S has Shanee yeah sorry the Commission would suppose like this there's a lot of Supremes I didn't really print them in the beginning of my ikura you have the partial of managed in the first paragraph other and the first sukima by talks about a lesson above that's one person and in others in the door but we're gonna see soon there's a possible we're gonna be using today it says very very this oil on the table the soilless life as bad who Moloch is really showing the hick near this is not this is a Mallika is a Katara and then it says this meets you damn which is a little bit reversed the meteor that should have been before Amala that's we're gonna get into soon oh really right now in empiric hey later on the tire discusses something else nada Adama not a guy brought out there but he was forced to how was he forced to bring oil oh sorry because he messed up with with the schwöre and so he has to bring a hot dose a Bahama but he can't afford it we can't afford the carcass so the first two can talk about a hot dose bring an animal if I can't bring an animal what I bring I bring two birds either two pigeons or two doves one is the ILA one is a hot dose okay now all the way tender the parrots as this has Shanee the second bird gasps oh oh look commish bought the second bird you should make an oiler what does commish put mean like the laws of there's only two possibilities like the laws of the bird we just discussed a second goal which is kata safe or like the Bahama the hottest Bahama which is folks open before commish but it's a very interesting word check the oil look like like we just discussed now there's a reason to go here and there's a reason to go there the reason to say that it's similar to an animal is because this bird is instead of an animal so should have that office like an animal the reason why it should be like like a birdhouse is because that that was the possum right before also it makes more sense that they should both have the same Ilana's why should you share one this way one other way the both coming to do the same to accomplish the same thing they both instead of a caucus Baima so have all that love is like a like a baby says dig in Mario like hotter side which is one posi before or like HUDs name which is three chicken before has Bahama because it's instead of a happiest Bahama it is Ivan it's one pass it before it's closer to it it's closer and you want to make everything similar everything should be the same Allah you're bringing two birds instead of one animal so the two birds you should do everything the same unless otherwise noted like severing the entire head might be different like one I'll offer but everything else Milica this that whatever it is it should be the same this annulus has Shanee the second bird yeah sorry law you should make it all look kinda schmuck like we just learned like that loves before says the Gemara this is the tonic kama and this is gonna be the sheet of white atacama holds you have to sever it completely commish potatoes Baima it's just like the animal the bird oiler is like an animal actor I'm a commuter McArthur's Bahama or your animal - so life may be comparing to the puzzle right before why he's jumping 3 pursue him before or Forbes to move or Yeshua maybe Creve oh now we're going back all the way to the beginning of my ikura a different pair egg marrik talinn and it says in the buzz of a cream boy referring to the oil I saw if the cream voice a meal that's why it's in blue it should save he craved the cream boy Daffy get this oil acai has a special way being macro vet which is different than how to solve call I got Kosovan clatters on floor last time it's over there with that word bakery boy the tiger made a difference and said it's different than cattle soil will manna me claim commission bought the tire says on the one hand the nurses believe our oil is there in the hands and other answers commish but it should be similar to commish MacArthur's bahama not Abbas I should be similar to the hotness of maim Omaha's mayor in a ball ello ello I'm gonna win you can't buy a Bahama from my sash a knee with my yo and you can't shift it during the night only during the day will be any money saying you need the right hand right we had all those suckas how you learn it if you learn it from you yeah you learn from here at Spa Kuna whatever that other thing is for that's all right in a boy LM in a kulen by a minute and your money's in malla hollow on if you're learning from hot sauce beer is named after British 9 but my hot dog I need to do ROI tamil Omar who Moloch Victor that's a problem because it says who Moloch victory and then after you bring it onto the MS bath what do you do you spray its blood will you get blood from it's too late it's on the Miss baffle ready obviously the toy is saying will Maliki Victor that you should make a comparison whom I like Victor otherwise it should say on Moloch and the name Saddam Oh and then Victor the reason why the type puts Hickman next to Moloch to tell me that this similar market or oh hi ROG but adds more value if that's my just like when you put on the MS BAE out the head is severed from the body of Malik oh I raise the axe mu if I go back to my so here's the command Sheeta the hand has to be completely severed gone you cannot leave Roy there's no halakhah right now now as a lock off half a dollar separate them British male mayor now this is not important I was to get out this is a second cheetah we are looking for a bilasa that's on the bottom of the page but he says very similar terrible loser he says commish bought him is Pocahontas olive I made a chart here I'm not exaggerating you think I'm exactly this chart came out at 7:10 and I only realized afterwards you could tell that I didn't get on the whole page was the wrong size and the whole thing happens to me a lot but at 7:10 you there's no there's no going back so that's why we're gonna not use this today but basically just says what what is what are the three sheets do with commish but what did they do with the retriever and what do you do with them well to make that I wasn't so sure what rebel Lhasa doesn't want Victor I think I got it secret nine hundred percent don't quote me on it I'll compile them if you want I'll put it on the whatsapp later ribby small a McCamish but was he do with the Commish pod that the oiler hatas the eiffel ila is like the laws that we learned before which are what not the animal okay miss Mahathir sorry like the bird deposit right before McArthur saw if minimal or if it's just coming to tell us where's the mocking Malika where do you do this math had the sorry mother I thought boy that's our I'm in moola Rev and where does Ruby small learn that the three things that we said in the beginning of the page Hulan yo him this stuff so rad she says with Zoe's tires ha as I sat Tyra MacArthur you learn all these Ibaka's one from another fine says the Gemara Ramallah hello boy looking for any Magda if you I'm comparing the Euler to the to the hottest bird just like by the hottest bird you don't sever the head the anally not only that they never seem an ephod you all you do is once a min and you shouldn't do the other one it's not part of the Mitzvah I've kinda more like veiny mark CC mean I thought maybe you should only do one sim in viola Tamil I might be creepy so now rubbish was learning from the word very boy that it's different our law is different than a hat us and a hat is you're right you only you only do Malika I want semen by oil or you do it on to see mother Eliza from Shimon ohayon this is what we're looking for commish bought the same thing like Rabbi Shmuel Cammie spoken is maracas I've just like the Hatters olive whatever that woke us up might happen so if that's what I learned by hola soy mala lon or his burro issue but who for masses just like I hold on to both the head and the body and I sprinkle on his back I've kind of this barrage will go boom as it my karma does he really does the coin have to hold on to both the head and the body where does it say the Tori Manhattan's they have to hold on to both homie gamma mal along issue aqua Suraj but guru masa masa just like by a-ha toes the the body is attached to the head the head is attached to the body is not a complete detachment I've conned true officer rhoads bakufu massa so therefore the rubella zarbor Shimon holds that you don't sever the samaram completely you do right but that's it because you need to have this Holika that the head is attached to the body Amala how long beseeming f4f can be similar hanoi my big river you need to see Malini Roy we need more than that and you should it can be hollow completely it has to be attached have a great day a great fast easy fast a meaningful fast oh we was not supposed to be here today no there's a date old man forgot what it was you