0:00 / 0:00
Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 104 by R’ Eli Stefansky
114 views
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Manuel Manuel live it today he's like a
minute for the machine to warm up
everybody's telling me that the first
minute is very choppy I got to warm it
up a little bit it picks the this really
YouTube takes time to warm up okay fine
is anybody else coming in in so we wait
for a second no okay let's go ski trips
you're a dope Eric Paree collab us are
starting up give me the babies on the
bottom so this is this Parekh is Brett
is talking about the inner of boss or
the hollow milk and and the meet the
tire says three times
Lisa vasilieva Haleiwa Maury to teach us
the isser bitch'll you know how to cook
with their rice you know how to cook
meat and dairy together you know how to
eat meat and dairy and you know how to
benefit from eating dairy so since the
mission of Carla have boss are also the
vasco black olive what is the definition
of boss urgh
you now have cook boss or the column
what is the boss or mean so we know if a
short means cattle goats it says Natalia
you'd be what about the big question is
what about foul what about chicken bird
so Liholiho by the way the Chanel Prada
my colleagues are showing him how we
pass him but thus cannot pass kids at
the end of the day that it's not awesome
with their rights that the cooked
chicken with with milk so when the
mission says call a boss also about
sugar hall of could be the mission is
talking about the isser of eating not so
much cooking Hotz
me boss our dog in the fog of him says
the Mishnah that there's no easier to
cook and we do this today
there's no is there to add milk two
salmon two fish and grasshoppers for
those who eat grasshoppers
vassula hollow a mikvah no Olajuwon this
isn't a racer this is er - it's our
another eyes this is our to put cheese
and meat on the table holds my boss's
dog of him again the same kind of sense
the meat of fish is not considered meat
the meat of grasshoppers is not
considered meat and therefore have no
neither now wholly in time enough of
Dalit almond I was there for I know them
in a bus or boot or big Buster dog in
the hog of him so if a person makes a
net there and he says I'm not I'm gonna
refrain from eating meat he's allowed to
eat fish he's letting eat hunk of him
why oh that's it you're done
oh this also you need to you need to get
the new you have to download it but the
you shows remind me every but if you
have are suppose you need a new art
scroll okay what does it say here in the
Mishnah it says in the mission a very
interesting thing in the commotion go
into it a little bit more depth when it
doesn't pop up the ratchet doesn't pop
up in your face to show you what's in
horn was not listen when you're making
that there it's all dependent on what
people have what language they speak how
they speak in a language in Israel for
instance when you say besar I think it
means a lot more than in any other place
that the referring to chicken no no but
Sri Sri means chicken but no buts are
not what what do you eat on shava seat
beside no but servants Basava carriages
okay but when it comes to the door him
it has to do with how people speak and
therefore when person says boss or he
definitely doesn't mean fish he's not
gonna eat Buster doesn't mean fish
therefore he could eat fish he could eat
grasshoppers says the Amara
how awesome they rise so the first part
of the mission if we go in the first
part of the mission
nothing boys just gonna say thank you a
typical question the guar always asks is
it seems like from the Mishnah that it's
talking about two different mandalam the
beginning of the Mishnah goes according
through a pod on and the end of the
mission
go to container makeva so now the camera
develops the question how or if awesome
there is a command when the mission that
says the beginning call our boss are all
meet to exclude one meat fish or meat is
a sir one meat is motored fish meaning
its average from the Mishnah that
chicken is also include included in the
insert the eraser command the lake of
Akiva is going to learn like in two
weeks from now
it's McPherson omission of the ear of
Akiva Oh mark I have arrived in a minute
I wrote two things are not there I saw
Birds fowl and Ohio
so venison very interesting to go to a
restaurant medicine is dear but that's a
payment so if you go to a restaurant and
according to Akiva you and you eat
venison you could eat it with but you
could have a cheeseburger venison
cheeseburger according to River Kiva
middle item Amos afer so now we have a
problem
if the raesha cannot be going according
to the key because your makyo halls it's
not an issue to eat chicken with me with
milk and the mission seems like this to
chicken parmigiana
this guy is a guy in Chicago
I just know because you just mentioned
that did struck my memory I didn't think
about this much before this guy he's a
guy in Chicago that I helped make about
true by brought him to stroll on that
mentors mission or some F he called me
up one day and he said you're gonna be
very proud of me I ate kosher today I
said really what happened he says I
called up the the restaurant and I told
him that I my chicken sandwich
leave out the cheese my Sicilian yeah so
I explained to my how to explain that
you know
there's a shame in chicken not only is
that share him even it was a kosher
chicken in that restaurant might be also
an issue but he was convinced that he
was yeah so
but according to yeah according to akibo
yeah you know by the way this guy has
he's a Froome guy as his kids go to
adore him and everything alright
Zoli tomorrow so what do we do with the
safer Amos a I know they mean a boss or
mother bleep sighs doggy in the high
government person makes a nether that's
gonna refrain from eating meat diet he's
on the opposite of that diet he doesn't
eat any meat but he's allowed to eat
fish and grasshoppers
haw haw sir it seems from the Mishnah
that when you make it matter and your
frame from eating meat that includes the
meat of chicken oh sorry we gave us this
does welcome to keep up with the ratio
doesn't go into human this is the issue
not my call me Lida mimic Elisha Leah
bear Mina you she says a very simple
thing if you want to know if you have a
very vague term in in just in regular
language somebody says boss art I don't
know what he means is I mean chicken or
he means red meat if a person says
vegetable I don't know what he means
does he mean cucumbers and tomatoes or
does he mean also gourds I don't know so
what do I do
I just I think to myself what would a
messenger say if I tell my messenger go
buy me meat if he turns around to me NES
to me on the spot she can also then
chicken is included in that term meat
because otherwise why would the
messenger it's like you Shalu Athena
gives you you want it you want to know
if the valve is a you or if you take a
six-year-old you say yeah what does it
say in the tire and that's how we base
it that's how we know four letters the
letter over here if she turns around to
you and says do you mean also good then
obviously gourds are from the metro
family otherwise why would this guy ask
you the meat also gourds he doesn't ask
you do you mean also Baracus that's not
part of this question he doesn't ask
weird questions yes so Mela that's how
people talk it's in the family what it's
part of a family but did you really mean
this do you mean all of it but he's
asking he the defect that is a question
now obviously by the way obviously Gord
is a hot dumb oh that's nothing question
the question is is a considered a green
is it something you put in your salad is
it considered in in in uh do people talk
like this then that's the question the
vernacular
oh that's a good lush the vernacular
this Sonya had no Ximena your mother bit
blue in if a person says I am gonna
refrain from vegetables I'm not this is
Manish opposite of diets I'm not gonna
eat any vegetables so but he's allowed
to eat gourds
what's the gourd here i have a 'shmock a
picture of a gourd this yeah this is
there are actually larger ones but I
didn't think anybody would believe
there's something literally on tractors
what and yeah I brought a big guy this
guy's pretty large is that is a true
farmer anyways
that's a gourd if your wife says go buy
my vegetables that you mean this it's a
shame you just write this guy this guy
justice give me a homeless or thing that
the cousin pictures they teach their
guys that when your wife says XYZ you
mess up on purpose she says go go do the
dishes so you break two three dishes and
I shall never ask you he says this mama
SH the heck become what it has to be
so either Bobby's supposed to help her
and supposed to bill your relationship
Doug do you might have mqi sir
Makena says no gourds are included in
vegetables or male live akiva email them
you look like oh oh here's mr. Kornbluth
hello everybody California Road where my
limits Osceola blew in I'm sorry I
didn't come up with any vegetables
anyone came up with a gourd on my land
canid over that's exactly the logic here
clue or a lemon saucy on the kidneys do
people say oh I didn't find vegetables I
found this this doesn't work no I wasn't
opposed to be fine no this is you know
what is not included I don't know oh
come on they're all beans these are all
the same family one two three four yeah
I kept on him nobody ever comes home
with bring me vegetables for the sale
nobody ever comes home with this you
could come up with something you could
use a little pumpkin in the salad that's
not a big deal but kidness know either
all they're all the same Bronco it all
grows on the ground they're all had
Dharma no that's not what people it's
not in the language I mean kidneys and
claw your ugh so the bottom line is
racial Urbana is a very Kiva the ratio
of the Mishna says that chicken is
awesome and they rise to cook with milk
and the safest says that when it comes
to Nidoran we care what people speak how
they speak and how does she have speaks
that's a lot of the Riverkeeper says I'm
ready I see so we have 2 - root symbol
either
it's the Mishnah is split or the
missions going according to Ricky whoa
the first there it says America isn't
ready who wrote the Mishnah Rebbe
venosus of la lleve at the tannery and
he passed in certain way in each Aloha
many times over here Akiva that it goes
by what the the guy asks the the
messenger as the sender the possible
however happen on that chicken is
awesome there I saw vacío Markkula
ribbit Eva he vaca calm our entire
mission goes according Akiva what do you
ask me that
keyboard chicken is on there a button
you're right Jim is the rabona the
missions actually mentioning three
categories man madeira Tyra there is
meat red meat that's Midori rice to cook
with with milk or Muhammed every sorry
for him and there's venison this deer
and chicken that's Oscar but only with
our bond on puts me Buster dog in the
hog oven but fish shame let me do
Victoria River let me deserving this act
the zero zero fish you could you could
add milk to fish no problem and there's
never Xavier ask the Gemara for some
reason this new dad's here but it should
be a continuation of votes or the
hollows it says an admission er that
there's an insert to put cheese and meat
on the same table or maybe a salami no
boss or if the holiday right so you're
just telling me that chicken is durable
and it's three categories there's meat
chicken fish the chicken is the middle
it's only there about an extra base if I
could prove you from the mission that
the chicken is a de-icer not a drive but
like you just told me this architect of
the rabona on appeal ago four zero
banana exert hello aunt guajillo why is
it also to put chicken on the table
because you might come to eat you might
come to eat it you might eat it together
with and so what have you eat it
together because then you might need a
burger you might eat a steak so that's
two steps removed you now how to eat
chicken you know how to put out there on
the table cuz you might eat it and if
you might eat it you might eat regular
meat with yeah correct go to the point
to the point but that's all that's all
that's all part of the xerius then the
ister is the isser is to cook it with
with me but you know how to eat cheese
with with meat that's part of the
example you're saying it's exam exam
that's maybe that's what you're asking
says the Gemara lumenok timber out the
log is reading zero zero where do we see
this concept that you don't do one zero
to another zero that you don't go two
steps remove this nan how our scoot
alerts we're talking about our freshest
Halloween when you when you make go you
have to remove a piece that piece that
you remove has the halacha of true moe
it's a surfer a you stroll to eat just
like it's a surfer it's all to eat rumor
it's a dairy riser
now fellas in Missouri Luhan so if you
remove if you take column from dough in
America in host laureates which is only
the rappin on so for all eats it it's
not the end of the world so I'm allowed
to put it on the table with a yeastrol
the coin is a lot of invitees row while
he has a piece on the table now what's
the brow maybe these fro will eat it
okay so maybe he'll be over in the
rabona
but the robot on is only because maybe
he'll eat it in there too strong only
eat a real piece of collar from the
caper marriage is broke and then there's
another halakhah this is not important
to us Vinnie tennis look all crunchy
your two coats laureates I could give it
to acronym or it says Rashi that
somebody that doesn't even keep the
Torah he says he describes I'm already
and somebody that's not doesn't keep
what Shane yeah but where do you say
[Music]
what did I see that okay I seriously no
no I see what he's saying I thought oh
maybe the right I'm fine yeah okay shall
die fine I'm all right but the point we
that we have is that you see that we're
not great execs era in whose Lords your
ladder eat a meal with amar with or with
a straw at the table if it's Hollow
that's the rabona all their value it's
not a good writer from over there
usually I am in the house who's Lars
barrette if you're talking about in air
too strong you want to eat at the table
you want to eat a piece of challah
that's from cool sources there are
abundant in a table and I'll just roll
that I can understand
but over here the equal mix that mission
cars are is they right so Vegas Reno you
see that we're not guys are two steps
removed a holler from who starts to
harness all in their distro equal mr.
Marino then you're right then it's a
good ride and the hoodstarz which shows
the luckily mixer who you don't have
hollow from who slaughters over there
who who's bringing dough from register
all to America it's not something that
that that's available so therefore it's
not a good riot it's not really exactly
zero novel hockey charge like that Suki
AVG Vina if you allow a person to bring
chicken and theory on the Vino doesn't
necessarily mean cheese by the way means
any kind of milk whatever it is I'll say
that Suki Bostwick vino and make how
possible holiday right so if you allow
the guy to bring on his table chicken
and theory then he'll bring meat in
there and I'll eat it so it's it's it's
a it's a disability but how there's no
possibility really it says it's too far
removed masculinization at the end of
the day what is the exact technically
what are we doing here had what cigs
area exactly safe sign if it's on you
know you have to cold products there's
no Easter at all that's basically what
you saw was asking what you know you're
gonna put chicken on your table it's on
this on a plate it's barely warm and
you're gonna have it cheese
so let's say you put them together this
is like three steps removed it's off
away from cooking because it's chicken
and cheese to meat and cheese to putting
the meat and cheese on the stove it's
too far it's on your table it's it's
it's not cook a bowl just such a word is
up tomorrow on my back exhaustion or
Yallop the Opus retail no big oh come on
really hot from the oven from in the
serving plate so I'm sorry if we shaming
you at the end of the day it can cook
because it's one time removed from the
oven Oakley Shayna enemy vassal
once I take that hi logically speaking
if I pour from a kettle into a cup
that's it that cup cannot cook anymore
don't mix until one and become possible
although they they will be cooking
together no SOT both of the China
bitterness what we worried that themself
it's too far removed that's the rabona
we're talking about the rice is yours
you're making it zero hold on yeah yeah
no but the minute they put the cheese
into the meal when I told my she's on
the actual dish the cheese is on the
table no what's it then once exotic
there is that if you have these two
foods over here you're gonna take a
piece of cheese and dip it into your
meat and that's cooking the meat and
that's spoken to me how is it cooking to
me I think it's really the only way you
can do it as a Cleary sign but going
back to what you were saying you now I
put two things on the table cuz what
because maybe you'll cook but not yeah
it has to be a cook you have to be able
to cook it on your table just because
maybe you'll eat cheese and chicken
together in your mouth that's an ulcer
that's only in there are born on and
that's why I can't do another derive
bonnet to put it on the table that's
that's too far away as there is very
legs are you know how to eat cold cheese
with hot cheese because maybe you'll
cook the cultures of the hot cheese but
you can't cook it the cooking somewhere
else so it's three steps removed mmm are
you cooking it here on the table how do
you cook it on the table by putting a
really a clear a sheet on your table
[Music]
it's zero yeah they're examing zero
three three zeros
why can I put on the table why can't it
first of all why can I do chicken
chickens only right Bonin let's say
we're talking about the rabona cheese on
the red button
why because maybe I'll eat me and and
why can I put on my table because maybe
I'll touch it and if I touch it so maybe
I'll cooked it it's too it's too many
serious but I'm saying that that's what
the Kimura says but we're all going in
the side that it's near a bond on but
the only way to do it the only way to be
very much to say that I have to be macro
is if I can cook it on my table the only
way to coconut table is if it's a Cleary
shine it's boiling hot just came out of
the oven a guy will come and say wow
beautiful he takes a piece of cheese
dips it into the boiling galaxy just
cooked it that's the only that's the
only way because once the cliche me then
it doesn't cook I'm a male now you three
steps away from eating it's eating in
their eyes yeah you touch it ten fifteen
minutes later you you cooks your hands
yeah cast iron Pat yeah right so so so
some people say it's a toe cipher some
people say the show canard it's a
mistake in the shippin are a lot of pass
things like that the macabre says you
know how to eat it
where did he get it from it there's
nothing here that says that so they say
no no I think this one ro and I I
believe they say that it's a mistake
justice pardon say that since the the
macabre wrote it they dev Dev that's the
I look into it
yeah not fishing though it's what in the
Shannara leash come out right sit right
this is some sort of that's not to say
it's a mistake
this farms say even if it's a little
messy wrote it and and there they go
ahead with the home run
it's a weird it doesn't have any basis
really in in Gemara so far yeah yeah
because we don't have a riot that with
knock where zero zero your whole rise
from crowler
maybe collars not true we don't have a
good right from 0 X 0 at that point of
Isis what which one are one zero two
zeros
all right hi finally McVean a coupon for
a no in Natal so now we're going back to
the first mission er the first missioner
says that all buzzer doesn't go on the
table with cheese now the missions gonna
explain that it's not not as simple as
you read it
this is mahadji's could you put chicken
on a table with cheese
- McVean are Superman in Ethel Devery
bish am i they said Oh mmm lay a lever
like that how you now a deport chicken
with cheese it's the same Alaka as
regular meat
Omar IB IC and this this is the
discussion in the Gemara right now we
have to pay attention to these words
Omar bi c zu makgulee by shamim Okumura
missile if ruby IC wouldn't say these
words i would also know the same exact
thing Bashar may says a cooler and B
still says a homo shall we say I could
put cheese on the table and B so says I
can't a cheese and chicken and B so say
you can't put cheese in chicken
what exactly was really seeing myself
and the Gemara says an amazing thing as
we're gonna see that it wasn't myself
anything but he was actually the author
of the Mishnah we're gonna see in the
Gemara it has to do with poram our VI c
zu may cool a imma imma career
missile bases she phenom ro the choke
enjoy call all of this is between a
table that you invite people to sit down
and eat and a preparation table of
suicide all of its a tap show noise and
service has any questions let's say on
your countertop or you have a prep table
ready and aside whatever over there
there's not a problem that somebody
might come and dip food in people are
used to taking different types of food
but when it's mixing on the table and
moves around with hajjaj that people
will start dipping in mixing and who's
else what happened over there oh they're
only together of course they take you
like take you let think the prep table
is a place that you take you don't mix
we stop we stop that it's done they
don't come anymore and be locked out
Ruby I see high note on a camel what
exactly the Rebbe I see a didn't that
come you didn't say the heat a Mahela
goo for a Cuban are you maybe Rubio I
see maybe I'll go as far to say it's not
some stabber maybe if you want to be
dead like maybe I'll say the everybody
was saying there be shot me hold you lie
to even eat chicken and and and and milk
maybe they calm down a comment about how
low come if Louie luckily please of
course wish ami holds you now that eat
chicken and milk what RBI see the race
he gave me a tequila cooper mokuba
shopping for me so no we shall hold you
allowed to eat chicken maybe he gonna go
so far but cannula or replacing there
she should marry me could he be shamming
become be silly Jacques man if you AC
says there's six things that Bashar my
are more lenient imbecile now Reggie
pointed on the spot
there's a lot more than six if you open
up ideas there's a lot more so this
these are the six that people argue with
reversing and they said the it's not
true which Ami's not make up this is one
of those six Rocco partner he says
before is viscera of his mom which which
is boy if oil a mikvah nada shoe home
for a mean aha
the very shaman its ESMA forest that
rubiaceae holds that we shall I say what
know the words in in a cow oh no but
Gracie says it that was the town of
comedy mission says we want to say in
Ruby I see that maybe he he argues and
he says bhishan me all you could eat it
but reveals he's the one that says
before us that this is one of the
coolest and he says the word he says
what they say
I hold a hold and this is a cooler that
you're allowed to eat it well they say I
remember
hello alchemax Malone Montana Tom Oh
Ruby I see the reason the batana
and is amazing we saw this a few times
they had Mitch nice that were written a
certain way and everybody hazard them
for generations or I don't know how long
and just became part of Tyra
now you can't change it anymore it's
part of the song it's part of the
everybody knows it the only thing you
can do is add a little bit so they added
on the end by the way the author of the
Mishnah is Ruby I see why Kalama Dagobah
shame I'm Roy maybe Google Elam I never
realized how strong this is
Gulam so he bring a cooler like some
sort of ruin is the good thing the more
says now it's a physical thing it
happened in history
Shinae marbeth homer esther lamella
mache Mordecai since Esther mentioned
Mordecai - Mirage right that's where it
comes you knew I didn't know that what
that gosh where is remembered more hi
and therefore he let him take care of
hamon and that's how he had the gula had
she not mentioned Mordecai then the
whole the stylist had varam would have
happened then we wouldn't have been
niggles because she said she did a shame
on Roy and that's why the Mishnah brings
in Ruby I see to tell you that the whole
Mishnah was really see but we've pushes
raschi sticks in there he forgot the
kind of forgot playing simple I'm
convinced that the next line is like to
prove the point tano I grew up her
mother Ababa the Agra the father law of
robbing a bar said or Evil Queen and a
holomap Aquarian when you eat chicken
and and you don't have to be careful we
need chicken and cheese you could eat it
by a bit heavier if Carole what does
that mean who Tony law all my law below
Nutella pseudonym below Aquino a copy
you don't have to wash your hands
between chicken and so toast goes to the
discussion which one is first basically
we're gonna decide that doesn't matter
which one is first but the very very
interesting types of zealand four lines
down from where it becomes wide on the
bottom right where it becomes wide lines
look at this thing it says river every
time with Irish you have it very
retirement for edge Nathanael office
burgers the AHA boss are also local vino
hi no bellowing Attila Vicki Noah
have I been it through the very cool
Shari Vicki no sorry
he says they're a bit of time and that
loves Pascal that if I eat chicken I'm
allowed to eat
she's right after chicken
not to bring this home but this is how
they pass cannot have we pass can every
time and that love is always says you're
allowed to eat cheese after washing your
hands you just make sure your hands in
that 30 watch that your mouth a little
bit a little a little schnapps
and you're good to go there are between
enough column every corner between in
buzzer oh sorry says the camera myself a
beautiful grader I'm sure she equally
Bhairava she isolate we know they
brought him cheese oh how nicely miss
row of happily mushy all day it's not
referring to the mouth it's referring to
the hands he didn't wash his hands
between a steak she's in a steak first
thing a cheese and then he ate a steak
and he didn't wash his hands in between
I mean a photographer mother a bow or if
you've been in a home but because no way
it's mash where there's no difference in
order because he said I forgive inna and
he's talking about Vienna knife but
anyways says he's postal only leaving
Vienna in Boston airline only when you
eat chicken you could do behalf Queiroz
now when you eat regular meat normal oh
honey mealy valerio happy mama haha' II
know the whole point of washing your
hands when you don't see what's going on
in your hands but if you could
physically look at your hands and see
that they're clean then it's not
necessary to wash it even between cheese
and meat he doesn't mention at all
anything about mouth Tanya let's just
continue cuz you have a few minutes and
tomorrow seems like a lot of words it's
a easier tough but there's just a lot to
say just simply to say the words it
takes time Tanya be Shami argument
mikania mechanic means to wash out your
mouth with red face Illinois media you
wash it out with water now you know that
when you eat a hot pepper or something
really really spicy water is not the
right thing to put in your mouth that
that ruins it so sometimes you have to
use bread bread is sometimes a better
way to what rinse out your mouth then
water but Java says bread Priscilla
onion
they say my because my maconel for my
media eel Amy I heard that
Elaine's a shaman can everybody media it
be Shami said you only use bread and you
don't have to wash your mouth out with
water we sell immediately women can have
and be still argue and they say no only
water in that bread a little Homer eb0
in quinoa lob pass Kim man could be
shaman
it doesn't make sense there's a rope
asking like neshama a little bit Xiaomi
or maybe can envelope India so maybe the
chat is bhishan we say use bread but you
don't need water we still owing room F
media you need both you need water and
bread how about a shaman who may be
Silla this night I got me could be
shaman whom we still now you have
another thing to add to the list that
wish I'm saying you only need one thing
to wash it out not to Elevation shaman
every Micanopy who had in the media wish
I may say you can do either one but he
takes the bread but we still want made
me do I avoid them you can add you do
either one and we still talk about water
my Omaha or my room I heard of a lorry
pleae
so Rashi says that you need both though
at the end of the day you need both but
there's no mellitus
they both say you need both have a give
all to get everybody side
[Music]