Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 102 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning rap boy's in the house Dave and whoever's behind these Beautiful sphere. Is that not you? I don't know who it is. Okay. >> Kobe Kobe Gold. Breakfast sponsor Lance Solar in honor of Rebel and my first complete year of doing the DAP. Wow. >> Lance, where do you live? >> You've been here before. >> Yeah. >> So, a whole year. How's the daff helped you? >> Organizing my life. >> Organize your life in what way? >> And then my day starts. >> Oh, midvashi. These are great sandwiches over here. >> What is this? Avocado, cheese, eggs. The whole beautiful. All right. Lands should continue with us for many, many years to come. Amen. >> In good health. A big announcement. We are doing in our looking for sponsors. We're expecting I don't know how many people you said. Where's Benny? >> How many? No, you're really expecting a thousand people. A thousand people. He's serious. Okay. A thousand people. We're missing about $30,000. We're looking for some the the event itself costs a lot more than that. It's a lot of it is taken care of by the owner of Mosha Cohen, who's a big big part of the Hebrew Shir. Uh there'll be a shear in Hebrew at the at the sem. It's for everybody for the English speakers, the the Hebrew. And uh we're going to have music uh vocals, vocal music, ac capella. This is uh the sign in Hebrew. My son Moisha says Gil Harris is sitting right next to me. How you doing Gil? Let's hold hands while we read this. Moisha found today's shir while we were out doing a non denominational family barbecue. So in in uh in Hebrew, the AI did it. I'm reading it in Hebrew and it says um >> Oh, he took it out. It said it said a barbecue lo like oh man as I attend live almost every day it's not often they get to see the sh on screen he was very excited to do the famous ah some barking in the woods this is not staged I told him I would send it and maybe it'll be famous Gil Harris here we go >> he needs to teach the here in the English. That's how they do it in the Hebrew. But in the English, um I want to show you something very interesting. You know that uh when she the sheer starts on video, there's a Rivzer song. So they did they did Remy did one special for the sphere. I thought it was very cute. And how about this one? Have a wonderful day. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com. Um this is from Ishai Stro. He says that he attended the satellite location in Miami. When I saw serious learning Miami where all 20 people sat and learned to do seriously and the atmosphere is more serious even than the live show in MDY. I realized that I made a mistake. If anyone in the crowd thinks like me, don't leave the DAV when you're away. This allocation are as good and clear as being present in MDY. With all said, I'm still looking forward to being present again in the MDY shortly. Shro were looking forward on a plane packed with movies, shows, and every possible distraction. Shragi had other plans. While everyone else was catching up on Netflix, he was catching up on Rebelli. Dive After Dive, the hottest new series out there. And with the rebell you just binge watch non-stop since the Shiva doesn't allow phones and computers. Bas manim was his moment when he took and he took it seriously until the last second. Who needs inflight entertainment when you've got the daff after daff with rebell as a gawi. He's just binging daff after daff. Beautiful. Ah very proud of lab. Very proud. Check this out. He doesn't even know it's >> Oh dear rebellion. The entire MDY team. I'm a 12year-old. I'm using my parents email who loves to do the daff with you. Today's actually my 100th day with you as I really started putting on fillin ding about fillin really helped me with the in school. We recently started to learn pikra and we learned the past few months helped me with knowing the key kind of such as nida zoo and many others. Now that we're learning and I'm starting to recognize some of the pukin from vayikra that we learned in here's a story about the daff for you. As I started, I wasn't officially part of MDY as I was watching it on YouTube in his mind like you become part of MDY somehow. I started talking to my friend about the DAV and how he explained it clearly and I have videos and tries to explain it especially hooked on the fact that the videos decided started doing the DAV during mid winter vacation. He called and said they started doing the daf. He even started going to the first dino and learning them. He was officially signed up. He's official. You get to sign up. He went and invited me to join DAP. After that, I signed up and you hear I think it's like a >> Yeah, thank you Rebelli and the entire team for making the D so enjoyable 100 days wiser. He says >> you heard that Meny Ver this kid 12-year-old kid >> tomorrow marks 100 days of Dafy for me another person. Wow, I didn't realize I put it back to back. back a kiss from Hashem. I think this is the longest I've done one thing ever. It's really hard and sometimes I really don't want to do it post surgery when I've got the flu when I'm feeling down and depressed when I want to chill in the hammock all day etc. Besides learning as the consistency by itself is life-changing experience and that and if that were the only benefit deno after two years in a tar and then college eventually accepted that my role in life is not to be a gad or even a rider ever finish a save let alone shots. Now my kids brag about their abba is working towards finishing shafts at 40 years old. If you told me four months ago that the kid whose family started keeping Shabbat after he was born will be on track to completing learning shas for the first time by 40 and enjoying it too, I'd have laughed in your face. Thanks again for all you do for all of us, especially the working guys who never thought they could do this. A big shout out to the who make it happen behind the scenes. >> Yes, we'll never find out who will we ever find out who the consortium is. with much gratitude sinc and uh finally regarding what you said preparation for that if anyone is queasy over blood you have a hard time with the visuals once a young man told the r that he had a hard time viewing a brisma because of the blood the looked at him in surprise and said that's not blood that's dam brris perhaps if we two view the blood as and as dam it wouldn't have the same effect as regular blood hopefully that will help those who can't look at blood. If not, we can always stare straight down into the gimar until the videos are done. Or you can have a sound effect like ding at the end of the blood. So the people that can know, they can open their eyes for the unbelievable wine. battles coffee corner month official edition by the Iranian families per anonymous lance ela solar and family in memory. Oh, how do you know you you you this is your 100th day? Wow. Sponsor. He's in the garra forever. The gumar is just getting better and better at boyisai. We're going to hire a full-time artist bas on every it's going to be it's a whole in memory. Oh, I didn't tell you no. In memory of Peter and Bernice Solar and Mike and Barbara Rosenarten. Yeah, we're going to get full time geta sponsors David Solomon. dedicated memory of my father foundation. So proud and family island rebell who changed my meaning of life and all monthly sponsors and by weekly sponsors anonymous daily sponsors in honor of Kovations LLC who teach us how to support MD The Y the consortium. Who is the consortium? What does consortium mean? I I have an idea. What does it mean? Like the the group >> do business together and they buy things. I might be sitting next to some of the consortium and we don't even know art. The head of the consortium is no. The consortium. It's like he's the last guy on the list. Let me look around there. Who's part of the consortium? >> Yeah, you. You. All right. today. You know, one thing I I forgot. I said it in the Hebrew Shir. And the following morning, I was like, we're finishing up and we were late. I forgot to say a very important thing that that that one that has one line to it about the paradum. So why is it why is it only one? Because the whole dav is a tas. So they say the story goes that the balas in year tough tough tough tough nunv were locked up in a sh I think or something and they knew that their life is almost over. The guy who came and actually they died the next day. They got they were killed the next day. So they sat and they wrote this typhus. That's the last tyus that they wrote together and uh somebody uh piped up in the Hebrew shin and said they wrote it with their own blood. Okay. But that's the story. That's how it goes. Okay. Now we're learning we're learning about there's a concept in that if something's about to be done let's say about to be thrown so I can consider it thrown. We saw it also if you're about to redeem it. You don't have to actually redeem it. It's as if it was redeemed. What else do we have in sh that's like that? No, much better than that. Much better. >> Oh, if it's about to be burnt, it's burnt. Yeah. So that's today's something that's about to be done, it's it's done. So now the gimmar all we have until basically the bottom of Alf the Gar just takes us through a whole bunch of different cases in chass you have it by by is do we consider it food just to throw out a question here throw it out the says it all the way at the end a paradum what do you do with the paradum you burn it so it's so but you didn't burn it yet it's sitting on the steak over There it's on the on the you're about to burn it. It's on the on the wood. So you're about to So it's as if it's burnt. If it's if if it's about to be burnt, it's it's burnt. So how do I view this part? So is it a bunch of ashes? It's a bunch of ashes. Oh, bunch of ashes. Then it shouldn't be the is it's why >> it's about to be burnt. So when do you say it? When do you not say it? It's just uh something. So I just want to show you we'll start off with at least to start off with the I have to show you some of these pictures just to get you into it. Who are these children over here? >> Do you guys see what's going on here? >> You have you have Benny. He looks a little upset there. You have Mark Ashkenazi in the back. >> And you have AI. I guess it looks like one of his kids actually. All right, Ravoa, here it goes. Take a look. I promise you this is not how it's going to be in a year from now. The the the the technology is going to change, but the way the guy speaks, it's just that itself is hilarious. But we're going to we're going to we're working on it. Whoever had this rebby, raise your hand. >> Shake it. >> I'm giving you a short gumra quiz now. The coffee stain >> that Stefanski, why are you throwing airplanes during the lesson? But I didn't throw it. >> Is he going to throw him out of the class? >> No, I already threw it. Key. >> All right. It's thrown out of the class. I threw the airplane and I was thrown out of the class. >> All right. So now the way the what we had yesterday is >> do you need to see it again? You look a little confused. >> Much better than the one with the bulls on the >> Ah. No, you like the bulls. You're just pretending you don't like it because you're part of that uh place you ding. >> You're let you let you let you let it release. You enjoy watch this. >> Time out. Time out. The bol thing. If I got a buck to come to learn because of it. >> If he explains the h >> it doesn't matter. Let's say I didn't explain it. He comes to learn now because of he came yesterday. He was shocked because of this whole he thought he's going to get another soccer thing. No, he didn't come yet. >> All right. So, >> so let's say let's say we have a situation where Shiman says you have the blood in the cup. You could throw it. It's as if it's thrown. If this is thrown then then you're allowed to eat the the carbon, right? Said be with me. It's it's I'm telling you it's good. You have something that right now you can't eat unless you throw the blood throw the blood on the he could eat. So, we're going to view it as if it was thrown. It's not thrown. It's in the cup. And therefore, what? I could get to eat it. I get to eat it. Now, it becomes tummy. Because only if I could eat it can it become tummy. So, I have to use the whole thing. It's as if I threw it. If I threw it, then it's edible. I could eat it. If the if the kite throws the blood on the mah, the other kite could eat the steaks. But he didn't throw it on the mah. It's as if he threw it on the mah. Oh, he threw on the mah. Then becomes edible. Comes edible. It's tom right that that's what we have to if it's edible it's tommy that's the so now ask the we're like eight lines from the bottom by the way good news today want to big we're all we're trying to get to the Mishna on B so it's a shorter daff today it's actually going to be hopefully a shorter she than usual so the halan lan what's lina we said again lina I'm not going to show you the video I showed it yesterday lina is when the the carbon the blood whatever it is remains overnight before that's one of the cases we had yesterday the carbon stayed overnight before you were able to throw the blood on but isn't this a problem the mitzvah it's a mitzvah to throw the blood and if he wants he could and therefore but we said that anything that's about to be thrown it's as if it was thrown But you you already established that there's no meaning that it it wasn't. If it was thrown, then it would be food. If it's food, it becomes But you said it's not tummy. That means it's not food. That means it wasn't thrown. What do you do? Not 78 years old. It's unbelievable. You're right. If there was a moment, one moment that he could have thrown, then I use this rule. Anything that I could throw, I threw it. I don't have to physically throw it. I could have. Okay. I I don't use that rule here. You know why I don't use the rule here? Because he did it by heck the animal a second before. He didn't have that moment. So So basically, there's two cases. If he had a moment before, then it's as if he threw in the blood. It punked happens to be over here. He didn't have a moment. So what's the classic question? Classic. So then tell me a difference between these two cases. Why are you jumping to a far-fetched case? Two very similar cases. One case is that the cayenne threw the blood at. So there's not a second that he could have thrown it and therefore it's not considered food. And if it's not considered food, it's not. And case number two is no he threw the he shafted this animal five minutes before. So he had a five minute window. He could have thrown the blood. So it's as if he threw the blood. So then it's edible. If it's edible it's why why don't you take give me these two cases. >> We're only talking about here. Right. No one says you can actually eat the carbon. It's not it doesn't have a head. >> Correct. Correct. Listen, at the end of the day, it doesn't say, "Oh, you don't have to do because it's of course you have to follow through in the second. >> Yes. Whatever it applies to you." >> No. >> No. No. It's just the ability to do it. But if he had a moment to throw the blood, it's as if he threw the blood. So then it becomes edible and it becomes edible becomes. So let's just show you the chart for a second. Check it out. There's two cases that we said yesterday in the one is Lena before Zero. One is Lena after Zer. Yeah, you have Lena. Those are the two cases. Ask Gamar, why don't you just give me two cases that are much more similar. One is that he did Zika. They were all Lena before Zria. Both cases before Zika. one, he had a moment. You give me a now. You're saying, "Oh, he did it the last last moment. He didn't have a second to throw it." Okay. So, give me a case where he had two seconds to throw it and and will be the opposite. Just say within that case, one case is where he didn't have a moment to throw it. So, it's not. If he had a moment to throw it, even 10 seconds, then it would be the food would become because it's as if you did throw it. Says, "You're 100% right." In fact, that's what it says. The two cases on top are identical to the two cases on the bottom. is not not if the was before was available to okay another case what about we had yesterday also we had Ellis come here and told us what's this what's yeah if a person had a in his head. He thought to himself that what I am this isam let's say let's let's talk about pigle for a second pigle you could do in all four avoid there's four actions that are taken when you when when you bring a carbon you macro a carbon first you sh the carbon then you receive the blood then you take the blood to the mah and then you throw it on the misbri is the top that's the most important one that's the one that gives the kapara Okay. But in each and every one of those four avidas, you could have a thought like in this chart that I am going to eat this uh this animal in 5 days from now I don't want to mix up the but you could also have a thought that I'm going to be on the because put it on the is a type of eating. It's the anything that has to do with eating and food and zik is also fine. That's not the point. The point is let's say let's just take one thing. the the left top top left side he thinks in his mind that he's going to eat this animal the steaks that come with animal eat it in 5 days from now that's pigle now once you do pigle it becomes possible right away now the says I have a mitzvah to do before I do and he has the ability on top this is a question is going to ask and everybody here should know the answer on the spot is going through the steps and he could and he could throw the blood. So if you go back to the chart he had from the time he does to the time he does is five minutes. So during those five minutes he could have done he could have come I don't understand if anything I'm about to do and I could have done it's as if I did it. So it's I I could have thrown the blood and I had five minutes to throw the blood before I did the pigle. at 5 minutes from the time I did to the time I did at 5 minutes and I could have had I could have thrown the blood and if I could have thrown the blood it's as if I threw the blood as if I threw the blood what's the what's the fear ice then it's food his food becomes so what's the obvious answer his of pigle was not all the way at the end of the five minutes it was in the beginning of the five minutes as he shed the animal he had a maka that he's going to eat this animal in 5 days from now. So there's never a moment that he could have thrown the blood as he as he when when's the moment that he could have thrown the blood before he shed that doesn't count. The animal's alive. So as he it's too late. So there's never a moment not even one millisecond that he could have thrown the blood says I knew that but I'm I'm just trying to lead you into my question. was so I'll go with you. But what happens if he did if he did this the pigle by zero at the five minutes into the whole process five minutes after he did he he did a pigle when he did the so in other words he had five minutes where he could have thrown the blood and he didn't but if you say that in that case you're asking to me that what that it's that that what it could be very good in the case where the people was at the end where there's a five minute uh slot for him to he was able able to do Zika and he didn't. So he's able it's as if he did and if he did it is a kosher kosher then the food becomes edible food becomes edible question every single case pickled by you say oh you could have done so you couldn't do it now and there's no pickle because tomorrow >> dummy it's as if you did it now so >> it should ruin the pickle >> no so that's what so that's what that's that's basically what he was asking certain things use it in certain things. Not obviously you have to do >> right exactly obviously you have to do you have to you can't just say oh so the same exact question that we had before basically these are the two cases that we have yesterday we learned two cases a person did pagle when he was doing an animal a person did pigle when he was doing aar's question now I have much I have Two cases are much closer to each other. One he did pigle by the that's what we just said now. Oh no no no we're talking about a case where he didn't have a moment to throw the blood. How is it possible when he did it by but if he did it by by if he had the pagal thought then he didn't have he did have a moment he had five minutes. So I have two cases that's so much similar why he jumped down. One case is where it it's not food and one case is where it is food. I have two cases in an animal. One is considered food, one is not considered. One is one is not how one I didn't have a moment to to to be able to throw the blood. How is that? Because I I my my my goal was during the all the way in the beginning and one was all the way at the end. We had five moments. asked same question we had before why are you jumping to another case it's farfetched one case a guy shifted an animal number one on top right case number two top left is there they're different things one is one is I'm thinking about two different you're different areas in I have one and They're both in animals. One is if the bad thought happened all the way in the beginning where there's not even a moment to do then it's not food and it's not but if he had five minutes in between and that's when he was but there was a fiveminute window where he could have done so it's considered food considered food says you're right but I have a much bigger I rather tell you a distinction between something that are almost identical. There's two in the in step number one in the oneita is considered food and one is not considered food. How's the pas? Because guess what is a the part of the ma is how let's check this out. Look over here. The four that you have on an animal that that are on top is the four they have is putting it in the same thing and they line up with each other. The going like this to flower is like an animal. So that's what I I wanted to show you. What's the word I'm looking for? Not a distinction. is a better the the the contrast the contrast between two types of on an animal I cannot consider it food but so to speak on flour I could consider it food as I do it >> it's a big that it's it's sort of like a yet it's still considered food how I want to tell you that even though the people have during the is like an animal make it how because flour before it came to was flour and was edible. So that's what we had yesterday. Anything that had a kosh had a moment of fitness before it came to mdash. It was you're able to an animal didn't have a moment of fitness. You were never able to eat it. The only time you're able to eat it is when you then it's already too late. Then it's already it's it's not considered food. Fine. So that's that that's or we're holding already says I'm read and I said this over the and he told me you could even say in it doesn't matter Lena is literally in other words Lena is before or after doesn't matter when before after the we already established that the that the pigle only happened in step number one by the Not true. The the the pigle could have happened on step number four by the zika. He says, I want to I want to tell you something. You came, we started this year. Uh something that you're about to redeem, it's like it's redeemed. Something that you're about to burn, it's like you burned. Something that you're about to throw, it's like you throw. Not true. There's different distinctions. It's not It's not It's not a one rule for everything. It's not a a blanket concept. Think about it. When a guy has a handful of flour for a what does he he's about to then his wife calls him up. I need to make pancakes and he's holding this thing that's kadesh in his hand. So what does he do? He says all the that's in my hand should transfer to my $5 bill in my pocket. Did he do an action? No. He said something with his mouth. Listen to this. It's very simple. Since you don't have to take action, all you have to do is say for me it should go to there. So then it happens by itself. Even if you didn't do it, I could hear the logic that even if you didn't do it, it's as if you did it. Why? Because it's so simple. But anything they have to take a physical action. I have to get up and go and then I have to throw it at the mak. You didn't do that. So why is it as if you did it? >> Difference. Yeah, it's literally the words here. I'll show you Rashi. It's hard to see. Rashy's all here. He says, he uses those words and they stick in. Look how many kids. But that's what he's saying here. One is missing action. One is not missing action. And it actually makes sense logically. Something that's missing action, you can't say, "Oh, it's as if it happened." No, it didn't happen. Of like I want to build a building. I want to build. So it's as if it's built. No, it's not as if it's built. It takes three years to build a building. But I I want to destroy the building. I just want to give it a little zets in the corner like they do in Gaza and the whole thing goes down. Maybe that that is a big I'm just throwing it out like some things you do say this concept, some things you don't. If it's easy then you say it. If it's harder then you don't. I mean, so you want to redeem it and it's just saying a word that works. You got say if he wanted to, he could have thrown the blood. He didn't. It's >> okay with just why not wait. >> Yeah. As opposed to waiting to see >> first of all the right the says that's how it works. That's the way it becomes, >> right? No, >> do here. You're saying you need a for it to be considered. >> No, no. We're saying something else. >> We're saying what the whole the whole she this whole is all about where you didn't you didn't you're supposed to do something and you didn't do it. But since you could do it and you're about to do it, it's as if you did it. That's very different than says you have to do xyz. The says you have to do but you didn't do but I'm about to. So it's as if you did. That's a That's like a That's >> a No, >> you have to do >> it during during a during a you have to have a but that's something else. Okay. All right. Here's another another one. I don't know if this this chart over here maybe I should have show I should have shown it earlier. Let's see some of the stuff we learned already. In a paradum we said that you have a paradum you kill the paradum and it's very normal that if somebody comes with a larger better paradum you redeem it. So in that case you say even though you didn't do it why because it's normal to do it's but we don't say it. So the gumar made a distin distinction a and a paradum. There's in other way I was just trying to show that there's like eight different things here that sometimes you say it sometimes you don't by here we just said okay fine I don't want to mix up but here's a chart if anybody wants to see a chart. Okay, fine. Says like 12, 13, 14 lines down. So when it work, the way it works in the B mikdash, if there's food that's owned by the mikdash and you eat it, you use it, what do you just do? >> Mila, >> and what do you have to do? You have to pay 25% penalty. You have to bring a carb on the whole thing. Let's say it's food that went from being the B mikdash. It went to being the kay. Any kind could eat it and then you went ahead and you grabbed the steak and you ate it. Is that mah? >> No, it's not. >> Why? >> Oh, because because there's no mdusha in it. The of the mush went away. Now a human being is allowed to eat it. >> That's just correct. Not from anybody in particular from the whole. Yeah. So, >> but what about if it was available to be to eat for a moment also since it was available to the for a moment. So, the flew away and it shouldn't be there's a moment that the kind could have eaten it. There's no of To me it was always confusing as a means like almost you should do but means on it was never able to eat it. So remains the remains. So what does it mean there was it was available to the in other words to but now it became because it's overnight it was became it was it went outside so nobody could what does it mean that it was never available to the in other words of it's in his head as he did he thought to himself he's going to eat it outside of the allotted time. He's going to eat it in a week from now. He said I'm going to eat in even though he's not the was done by that's through the blood or through but what does it say these three things happen now? So when the Gar says over here means that even the blood there was a lean on the blood. In other words, there's no zika yet. So what's the question? There's no zika, but you could have done zika. It happened before the night. It went through the night. The blood went through the night. The the meat went through the night. And that's bad. It's called Lena. It's overnight. But at the end of the day, he could have thrown the blood. And if he could have thrown the blood, the client could have eaten it. >> And the could have eaten it. So it's not it's not kadesh anymore. It's not the it's not the mdashes. If the client could could have eaten it for one minute, then it's not why is there since I could have thrown the blood. I could have it's as if I threw it. So is it's as if I threw it then the coin could eat it. The coin could eat it. There's no Lena. It's the same same concept we said before. Sorry, not Lina. I'm just reading inside. He could have thrown the blood. Why? It says that it's it is >> which case >> no >> again again >> which case >> I it's what I said just the outcome is the is is different you know it's m the kinds of the same no you have a kayen who if he's able to eat this food then you don't if you eat his steak instead you don't you're not over amo if he could eat What happened by us? All the blood was it was not thrown on the it went overnight. And that's considered as if the could eat it. Why? But there's no so you must say that it could have been thrown. There's blood. It had a right before. There's a pot of blood. There's no on it yet. I'm asking you. You tell me. Meni there's blood. I could throw it on his back but I didn't and the blood went through the night. It was never a Is that considered that the Ken ate it or not? In other words, Israel comes along and eats the steak. Is he or not? I'm asking you what's >> it's possible. >> You're right. It's possible. I'm I'm asking you is it not if it's possible? >> It's not me because it was never >> No, no, no, no, no. You're starting too late. >> No, the flesh is in. Before it became possible, I was able to throw it on the >> Yes, I was able to kill. Okay. >> So, it's as if it went to the for one minute. There's no So, what do I see? What do I see? I see that I do say it in something that requires a before. I said, "Oh, if I throw it, no, that's too much. I I have to throw it." So, and since I didn't throw it, it's as if I can't say because I have to take action even if I have to take action. I do say because in fact if you eat this meat because it's as if he threw it already. No, you did throw the the story is different. The story is not that he didn't throw the blood. He did throw the blood. There was a a complete So in other words, the blood there's no lean on the blood. >> The only soul that we have over here is Lena. So yes, the the the it was roy for the cayenne. It was right for the kay. It was right for the kayen. And that's why there's no ma there. So it's right for the kay. There's a real zika, not a fake, not a pretend zika. How there's a physical zerria. And and then therefore at that point it became the kay and it became the kayen. It it it's no longer ma because it's the k just the problem is that it went through the night what >> a classical >> everything was done in ner exactly a classic case of >> nothing to tell you that that that doesn't have to pay that he's just a guy but not of this. That's the whole thing >> that's a big kesh. If he didn't say it I don't know. What if he didn't do Saddam? He didn't do Saddam. According to what you just told me, it's because he did Saddam. That's why it went out. It went out of the B mikdash's possession went to the possession and therefore comes in. He didn't take from he took from but what if he didn't do so would be oh so now the just asks a question on the lion so let's let's just do this together outside it's very simple what happens if the blood was thrown the blood was thrown they threw the blood so is it the kay right now they threw the blood. The moment they threw the blood, what happens? >> No, no, no, no. Forget that. The Gar says it has to do with you're throwing something else in there. Why you throwing a wrench in there? The gar the whole Gar is it doesn't matter. It's available to the It loses the at that point. So when is it okay? When is it okay? Yesterday or right now? When I do right now. When does it become okay? Right now. So why are you telling me that in the past of the past it should say right now this is because right now I did right now it's the so that bothers the what let's just read inside the used to have a that's Not good. Why say you say right now it has so it's that the mission is talking about on a case where there was no because if there was a mission would say right now there's a reason why it says that there was no because it had back then sorry. So he says okay what do you bring me from this from this business you can't bring me from a what tower tower why what it's not about is it food or not food that's what we're talking about in our become food not food is it considered food it's a different thing is does it have ducha or not ducha what What what what establishes the is by by >> does it have who's does does this piece of steak have on it or not? If it has then you did mel and you have to bring you have to pay 25% and bring your car but if it doesn't have okay >> so the pocket like so what happened over here >> this could have blood okay so this the you could do so the flies away and the can never come back once it flew away and and let's say they didn't do you can't say oh let's bring it back the is gone but Even if there's no and it never became there's no forever because once the leaves it leaves but when it comes to tuma is this thing susceptible to tum or not it's whether or not this thing is is is edible and this roy not royro is not enough for it because you need roy right now you have to there's a bunch of you have to be gurus The Bach takes out words. I'll just read it. I think the way the Bach says it if he literally does then you made it physically food then it it it's physical food. So physical food becomes take out all these words. The bottom line is if you didn't do so if you did it's food. If you didn't do it's not food. It's not food. is not telling me. Okay. So now it gets easier from here. It's a new basically almost like a new attached to the previous. It's like new maybe what's the story? A person is not sure what he ate. He ate something and his wife said what do you do? She said I ate a piece of fat the gala. He says, "Are you sure the guy I had a piece of over there that I was going to give to the guy? You crazy?" He says, "But I don't know if I ate the right or the left. I don't know." Per doesn't know. It could have been. It could have been nothing. It could have been mish something mut something is gallop. So what do you do? If he knew for sure that he ate, his wife said, "You ate, what does he do? brings a katus. But if he can't bring a katus, what does he say? Bring Donnie ashum to a hanging. What does it mean hanging? If I find out tomorrow that I that I that I didn't need it, I I figure it out. I go I take step back. I look at the video. Well, then I don't have to bring it. >> That's about the shaku. I don't know if you have to bring a kadas for that. >> Just 10 people just left to share because of what you just said. Thank you. Um okay. Yeah. Yeah. So basically there's three options here. There's three options. Either three either. If you find out that you did not eat you get the beautiful news you didn't eat it. In fact the babysitter she comes she the cleaning lady. says, "I took the the the I know I took it. It's I ate it and you ate the good stuff." So either the tali becomes a regular animal goes right back to where it came from. Zeroa, nothing. Why? Because he made a mistake or I'm telling you this cuz you'll see in the video there's three um belts like in the airport. Three belts. Belt number one says on top. Belt number two is Kevvis land. Belt number three, let's see in the video. It's mishik magnific. It is empty. Oh, absolutely. >> Yes. you get until you get a and then you redeem it. So what happened? They thought with it turns out they got a tremendous. So now what do you do with soita number one says he found out that it's not that it's not he didn't he wasn't it's don't worry about it. Put it right back in the pen mayor. It's not a problem. You put it on a line going down to the airport. You make sure it breaks its leg. You take the money that you sell it. Take the money and you buy what the dessert is. Why? Says because you can't just put it back in the pen. A person is worried that he didn't have says I don't have that. Okay, fine. He he he was already asking him to do it. That's one of the the three belts over there. If it's not for this, it's like um a father-in-law. It goes over to son-in-law, gives him a smack in the face. So, what did I do? He says, I'll tell you the truth. I don't know, but I'm sure you deserve it for something else. So, you know what? You didn't you didn't do this. Trust me, there's another variant that it's good for. So, what just as a regular carbon? You like that joke? >> No, I made that joke up. I put it in the I said, "You ever heard the joke?" He says, "No, I don't know what you're talking about." Yeah. With the kids. >> I just changed it to father-in-law. Yeah. Oh, so answers. Oh. Oh, >> the middle. That's why when he already the blood must be spilled that was here for what does it mean it was spilled? Where do you spill it? >> Where do you spill it? >> In the ammo right next to his bath. You spill it in there. and you burn the meat. Why do you burn the meat? Because it's like don't don't don't bother eating it. What about the blood was already on and you found out that you didn't eat the meat. If there was the received the blood in a in a in a cup, keep on going. You found out now that he didn't need. Keep on going. Spray the blood on them. And let's just get to the thing. What? >> Yeah. >> Okay. This has to do with that what that what you have blood in a cup. You didn't throw it, but it's as if you threw it. You threw it then it becomes like it's edible. And ties into that taught me that you do say the concept that it's as if he threw it even though you have to take action. Turning of the daff global specialist in international financial services says no you think the reason is no I have another reason what's the reason what happened there the blood went into the cle that not because I'm a I'm able to throw the blood it's as if I threw the No, the cle gives it special powers. It's as if it was already the it allows you to be mash and this is the question I asked you guys before. If you say the concept anything that's thrown as if it's thrown. So therefore, let's continue the logic. Anything that's about to be burnt is burnt. So I have the I have leftover meat that I to burn or that I burn. I need the ashes. How come the the the is that if if a person to touches the part of becomes why let's just consider just a bunch of ashes on my leg. This is the the thing we had yesterday. I'll remind you I said it's in >> in uh >> the what special love that fora we said it by wood we said it by over here also a special thing for parad you're right you're right 100%. It's it's burnt but nevertheless we'll make it to So the way it works is we know you have top top level of tum then under that what do you have what do you have under what do you have under that under that whatever okay but there's also a concept called puzle it's not it's not p I something touches this apple it becomes possible. It doesn't have the power to keep on giving to something else. It's not a make something else. It's just possible. So I could understand that you want to take this part and say even though it's a bunch of ashes because of the love that we have foresh I'm going to make it poss. And if so, and if you want to say yes, it does have the power once as a question. You have flour. What do you do with the flour? You pour in a bunch of oil and you mix it. What's going to happen? I did it once in sheir. Last time we learn, they should have done it. You take a bunch of flour, that much flour. You pour in two cups of oil. You mix it. What's going to happen? You're going to have globs of flour like this big that not a single molecule of oil touched it. It's impossible that the the the oil should go everywhere. In order for something to become tame, you need a liquid to touch it. So here's a glob of flour that liquid never touched. It should be immune to and he's asking does it become tummy or not? And the answer should be based on our gar that it does become. Why? Because I love so much. Everything in the even in the globs in the calls it is a glob of flower doesn't have but yes make it you you have the answer right here because it should become and not but that wasn't his question. His question was does it become you're telling me it become more than possible? He wanted to know is it a real real to we're only talking about the rebuttal level that he's masking that it becomes. You want to know even more than that and that's why he didn't have an answer. Have a wonderful day. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a share today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.