Daily Gemarah - Thursday Jan. 10, 4 Shevat - Pesachim

you second of zion a mood Alif around 15 lines from the top the line starts Mamina there's two dots and a new suki begins on my rubber bar of Hoonah amar Ralph after the Gemara concluded explaining why ralph taught us that we have to do bittle after because comets in case we find the middle of Pesach a nice roll and if we do not do bittle we can run into many a problem so now the Gomora explores a new situation and this is a very interesting situation which is hard for us today to imagine just to give a little intro because today we immediately recognize the difference between comets and matzah as a result of various differences that are usually present in comets versus matzah and conversely but there were times and even today in certain communities where comets and matzah seemed very similar in fact the matzah in Yemen and other places where they still do not like pita bread the matzah looks like Floyd pita like farfel pita bread and very often in earlier generations especially in Marx it was very thick matzah was thick so often you have a situation and this is what the camera now addresses you find a piece of bread in your house on Pesach in the Box that's designated for bread and you don't know if it's comments or matzah a murder by Ravana my wrath rabbie the son of Ravana said in the name of wrath a pastor if Shaw if you have bread that was spoiled and you discover it on Pesach in the designator the person had a breadbox where they would keep their bread a whole year including on Pesach and now he's in doubt what this bread is and of course dark many questions can he eat it does he have to destroy it does he have to eliminate it even if he doesn't want to eat it because it's spoiled because you have to get rid of it or can eat it sometimes a person is hungry there's not enough food you want to eat it you want to feed it to your hungry children so pastorship sure this bread got spoiled says Rav Kevon shall rough some mats or Mujeres what are the words keyword should of sir matzah the way we understand it now is because this is a box that was used more from matzah than for comets so therefore we follow statistics and we assume that this is a piece of matzah not a piece of comets meaning a person has to be aware and be able to say throughout the last year this box was a container for a hundred pieces of matzah a hundred pieces of matzah and ninety pieces of comets so statistically a piece of bread that you find in what would it be you go according to the majority since in Toyota we always follow the majority so therefore if we say that according to statistics it's not 50/50 or I don't know if I know that ruffs are matzah so therefore in majority of situations this would be marks and out comments according to statistics Toyota follows the majority after a bomb happens and therefore I could treat this as a piece of matzah that's the kiddush of rough shape Shia spoiled first of all maybe it's from last pace of the monster you want to know how can it be spoiled in its March first but maybe the matzah was baked before pizza maybe it's old matzah that was leftover from last year pace there could be different alternatives but the point here is that if I know that rough samat meaning the majority of the bread used in this container is matzah yeah 500 pieces of matzah 400 pieces of comets statistically I found out the majority and I say you don't know you could go bust Aruba even though according to the majority rap she says Kevon should have some Atsuko so good night even the stamp should be tables ooh Matsuyama comes the way we think a way we understand graphs words at the moment is if in this box they used matzah more than comments well let's say 60% of the usage was matzah and 40% comments or even 55 whatever even just a majority any majority could be 5149 but the majority of it was used for matzah Asli non boss or uber we follow it's a statistics game we follow ruber we follow the majority of motorists and you can use eat this piece as much probably you want to know why spoil just say you find a piece of bread right okay that would be the same mission yes so practically you would say it seems like you can't tell because it's so spoiled it's so old and so moldy very hard to tell all even if they were identifying features he can't know that's probably what he means in other words the same concept exist in any situation but practically speaking that's how we would interpret it now if it's for that you simply can't tell so you don't know what to do so you follow the majority this is the middle of Pesach this is a middle of Pesach if this box is never used for comments then you don't have a problem but this box is used for bread a whole year that's the issue so therefore we don't know so that's what we're saying that if you go account you could count and you could say that the most the most pieces of bread that were in this container were Mattson are comets so then you follow that statistic and you say that this is much even though it may be comments - Valda considers maybe comets but you can treat it as matzah and eat it no if you have comments comment doesn't get bottle but I don't have comments I don't know what it is if I have comments there's no bittle and comments on pesos even in a thousand but he write I have to establish what it is you understand so when I have to establish what it is I follow the majority of situations and I say it's matzah you're right once you would know its comments there wouldn't be bit to arrive but here when it comes to establishing what it is I could follow the majority you wonder why he didn't do boudicca's comments well he doesn't know he know this is a Jew who did the business commerce but he doesn't know maybe he overlooked it maybe he doesn't know that's part of his question if he knows he knows what talking he doesn't know he did the COS comment he doesn't know asks the Gemara this is the statement how passive should be we should have some Matsumoto's now we have to analyze this hey see dummy what are you talking about Elain if it's talking about the yoga but the comic see if it's talking about that you look at this piece of bread and you know that it's comments well obviously kid off some at some I haven't the fact that you usually in most cases use this container from APSA is meaningless in other words the fact that this container is likely to have matzah verses comments great but there's a piece of Hamid sir so he can't be talking about that so now of course this is only a rhetorical introduction the gemara didn't think that ralph thought that you look at something and you see its comments but you can eat it but it's it's leading us into the trap okay Ella the lawyer didn't boy is homage to him at so obviously he's talking about doubt again if you know it's comets you obviously gotta get rid of it if you know it's matter then I don't have a problem it's months the problem is I don't know I can't recognize whether it's covered so much so now Ralph is telling me what do you do you have a doubt so what do you do so I'm telling you if you could know for sure that the majority of bread that is found in this box throughout the year is matzah if you take account you could follow that statistic and say not so great i buzzer if that's the situation my area clear ofsome ATSA why does arap allow you to see it as Maps relying on the condition that your officer matza that the majority of bread that's used with this container the majority of bread la in this container is matzah meaning if not if it's 50/50 or or let it's more comments than not so you don't know you don't know I don't know how much it's this I don't know fifty fifty maybe not I don't know so I can't say summit Germany in all these cases or of what I would say throw it out certainly don't eat it get rid of it why I feel looking laid off some at tsunami even if you know for sure that the majority of bread in this container is not matter roughly rough so much it's not that the roivas matzah Namie it should still be permissible why because nasal basa basra we should follow ba sebastio the last the last situation we should follow the last step of the game what do we mean what what is the meaning of the Gemara here follow the last usage of the box let's explain now it space on your a good Jew your ear this is an airless here this is a sure material mitzvos obviously if not that's all i wasn't a poor so that means he's not using the box now for comments the bread that he's putting in now obviously the new bread that he's putting in is not comments it's matzah but you found a piece of bread and it got there was spoiled so you don't know if it's hummus or mots so we're saying follow the majority says wise they gave the majority nasal basa Basara follow the last usage of this box what was the last usage of this box let's understand when it comes to a type of thing that before you put a new you take out the old so we can assume that when you put in the new you first cleaned out the old bread this sucker I think why because if you put a new warm bread on top of old bread it's going to spoil so you'll first take out this old bread and then you'll put in the new brand so we're dealing with a type of thing when a person puts in fresh bread new fresh warm bread in a box generally the appropriate thing the natural thing to do is first clean it up from the old bread because if it remains there under the hot new warm bread it's going to decompose and spoil and bread was very very precious it is very precious so whenever we can assume that a person doesn't just stock up it's not like money you put in more money more money more you'd have to clean up the old money the old money he's not gonna get ruined by adding more money or more jewelry or more letters or more paperwork but we're dealing with something that you can assume that before you put in the new one you take out the old one so then the halacha will say nasal buzzer Basra I don't care about the majority let's say throughout the year it's 90% used for prefer Hammad's and 10% used for matzo but now it's based on now it's based on the last bread that was put in here is what is obviously matzah cuz Pesach you using good pace when I told me you don't use it for basil if you never use it for pesos then it's not a question that it's comets obviously use it for pizza so the last bread that's used here obviously as much yeah now it's a type of thing that you clean out the old ones before you put in the new ones so if we would follow and we would ask a question what would have been the last usage of this box for comets or matzah obviously for matzah so if you tell me that you put in bread and you leave the old bread it could be the last usage as matt said you still have comets but if it's a type of thing will you first clean out the old for the new then the halacha would dictate that you can assume that this is what matzah and upcoming here there's a second incentive in addition to the fact that you don't want the old bread to become mouldy and that's why you clean it out first before you put in the new ones there's also the mitzvah of because comets that's another reason that before pacer he got rid of the bread because there's a midst with the get rid of the bread if that's the case why does the Ralph depend why does arrive a tribute the hatter to the fact that it's mostly used for comments I'm sorry it's mostly used for matzah even if it was used 95% comments and only 5% matzah nonetheless he should still be matter this why because nasal boss ambassador we should follow the last shamash the last thing that was used for and assume that this is in other words look at this bread say what was this box used most recently for coming to mops it's a middle of basil it was used for matzo and therefore you should say that this is from the newer ones which is matzo because you usually clean out the old ones okay one moment how do you know that is the truth a case maybe you don't follow the most recent maybe you follow the majority you have to prove this so the gomorrah says there's a mission me like turn on haven't we learnt in a mission ER the following you have to help cup now a little bit more usin em solution associated bahama you're walking in jerusalem and you find money in a stock yard in the market place where they sell animals so should I behave my merchants of animals and in that area are you walking around with a sell animals and you find money on the floor well I love my sir you always have to assume 365 days a year you have to assume that this is sacred money it's called my same money we'll see in a moment the reason bahara bias what if you're walking on the Temple Mount the Hara by the mountain on where the base--emitter issue was throughout the whole year Hulan you find money you can assume it's mundane money you can use it any way you want you should you shall I what if you find money not a Mara bias and I'm in the stockyards where they sell animals in the marketplaces where they sell animals front of the stores you find it in the streets of Jerusalem the shots are a go if it's during the 3 mm typing paste are for suckers my sir you have to assume that this money is sacred it's called my Simoni however wish I admire Shauna if it's the rest of the year you're walking today in New Rochelle I am and talking in the time of the bass I'm English : then you can assume that it's mundane money for all my tips my Abbas ADA came loose magazines at my timer what's the logic high over Shakira Shalimar soon discovered Michael Young because the streets and the marketplaces of Jerusalem they would sweep up every single day this is the Mishnah and explanation of rubbish Maya in the missional what are we talking about a little intro is necessary to an order to understand this secret the concept and the sequence and the relevance here one of the tithing that was done was called mice her SHANY when you had produce you had a farm or a field that produces two percent approximately had to give to the client was called Troma 10% you had to give to the Lavy it was called my sirisha another 10% in the years in the years no three three and six is my surrani in the years one and two right I'm sorry what 1 1 & 2 4 & 5 the second 10% after you give to the lavey you have to take it to jerusalem and eat it there and this is sacred fruit or sacred produce that's called my so Chaney year 3 & 6 that 10% goes to poor people that's called my sarami and then the seventh year everything is heavier and then it goes again years 1 & 2 true my sirisha my sachet me year 3 gets substituted with my surrani 4 & 5 my sachet me 6 my surrani and 7 your back to shmita you don't own your fields so I take these fruits I bring it to you shall I am and I eat it there it's sacred I have to eat it inside your salon ask the Toyota what if it's a heavy burden you substitute it with money and the kedusha is conferred on the money on the winds of my so shiny and you bring the money to you in July this money can't be used for everything you can't just spend it on any Jerusalem item you want it has to be used usually for food most of the money of my sir Shanee was used for people to buy sheep or goats or accent which they would bring there's a carbon slummin in the base of McNish and then enjoy the meat in Yerushalayim that was the majority of what the money was used for when would people bring this money when so people who had a more luxurious life could take off two weeks in January or two weeks in February or two months take their money of Mycenae take the family for a beautiful spiritual retreat in the holy city and hang out there for two months and spend all that money and buy the food and buy their meat and eat there in your shall I am with the wife and the kids and it's a beautiful thing but not everybody can do that so most people would take the money of miser Shanee and they would bring it to him when they were going anyway which is paisa sewers or suka sueño anyway going and they would spend it there during how am i it but very often there was too much money to spend hello Maya so you would Luke and are you gonna take it home so you gonna take it home we can get mixed up with other money and it's a problem because this is only money sacred money so you would give it to friends or relatives or poor people and Jerusalem and you would tell them you're living here anyway let's go Sunday night and again most of them would use it for buying meat they would buy a kosher animal and use it for a carbon and then eat the meat in the carbon schlomit a little bit to the Cayenne a little bit to him and he could give it to the family and give it to the friends this was the system once you understand this system you'll now understand what the Gemara say when you find mommy in front of a cycler bahama in the area where they're selling sheep they're selling oxen they're selling bulls etc but it could be a you paying with regular money but the majority of money that was being exchanged there was what my sister Shane so when I find a coin I don't know what this coin but I follow statistics statistically this is holy money so I can't take this money and go buy go buy a newspaper I can take this money and go buy I don't know cigarettes I can't take this money and go buy my yacht or my car I have to use this money for what you're allowed to use my society money it's not cool and money it's not regular money that's if I find it we're in front of sorry Bahama because most of the money over there was Meister Shaney that's the clock that's number one what if I find it in the Hara bias and Hara bias right all year around I say it's Hulan why people came to the Hara bias they dropped a coin most money in the world is not my such technique most money in the world is : so statistically this money is mundane money that's in the hair abayas what about in the rest of your shall I am the Western flame it depends if it's during the holiday season perceptual suckers when all the guests would come and all the guests would bring their Meister Shanee money so majority of coins that were being maneuvered that we're moving around were what my sir shady money so if I find now on the street a coin statistically I say what it's my sash a knee but if it's Dow it's fat and I'm walking the streets of Jerusalem now you don't have all of the guests there may be my sachet me money you may be in Jerusalem atomizers any money but the majority of coins floating around Jerusalem now are not my sustaining money they are regular money so if we've been treated as cool a smile you're why in the Hara buyers don't you make the same distinction why are the Hara buyers do you say it's always : the answer is because the streets of Jerusalem they used to sweep every single day since they used to sweep the streets of Jerusalem every single day so we assumed that any coins that fell there during the holidays were discovered by the sweeper when they sweep tit and therefore they picked it up so now when you find a coin it's not yontiff it's a new coin that fell today maybe it fell last night maybe fell early in the morning and therefore it's : but on the Hara bias they never swept the Hara by for two reasons number one it was on a mountain it was an incline and therefore the winds would clean up on their own and they didn't have to sweep it number two you weren't allowed to enter into the HERA bias with shoes and with mud and with dusty clothes so therefore they didn't have to sweep it so when you find coins on the Hara bias even in middle of young TIF it's very likely that it's there from two days ago five days ago we could go two weeks ago and the majority of coins during the year would be coolin so they form the hera bias you can always treat it as whole this is how I explained the difference of the Mishnah so again in front of a cycler bahama all year it's gonna be my so shiny it's a Suffolk but statistically I say my so shiny on the Hara bias the opposite all year even the middle of young different schooling in the streets of Jerusalem it depends the middle of young turf it's my so shiny the rest of the year it's Colin that's what the missioner tells us a mission to masochist color what are we learned from here what do we see from this Alma I'm Rena and we say that in a place where you sweep up in a situation will you clean up the old Kamui come my Osley leh we assume that their original money is gone the honey a hurry Nene no and the money that we found now is new money that just fell down today because yesterday's money was already cleaned up and since it's Pesach let's call her MA and pacer and the coin I assume is that's from before pesos it's from now so therefore I say it's my sash a knee but in the Hara bias where I can't say the old money was cleaned up because they didn't sleep there a bias so if somebody dropped money there poor him or rich tradition is soon or a week before paisa that's the coin I may have found it maybe from a middle of Pesach but it may be from the whole year so statistically if I look at 365 days a year Pacers rules and suckers is a small minority so if I see a coin what do I attribute it to I attributed to a coin that fell throughout the whole year maybe it also fell now but it could have fallen a week ago two weeks ago a month ago five months ago etc and nobody ever discovered it I had I discovered it so therefore even fell throughout the year you would say the pre bomb the preponderance of money the majority of money would be how is this relevant now to argue Maura we have here clear Mishnah that to teach us about our case I have her a box I have a box of bread this is not like the Huayra bias where I don't clean up you don't any normal person does not put a new bread hot new warm bread on top of the old bread you first take out the old bread so children get smashed it shouldn't get moldy it shouldn't get spoiled so it's something that you clean up just like the streets of Jerusalem before the new bread you take out the old bread plus there's a sieve of Dicky's comets so there's an obligation to take out the old bread before Pesach considering these two factors it's now a middle of Pesach maybe the majority of the box is used for comments just like the majority of mummy in Yerushalayim is holding up my sash a knee but on young Tiff's you don't look at the majority what do you look at statistically if I look at the majority this coin in this street if I go throughout the whole year statistically is it holy to my sir statistically it's : but since it's the middle of Yom TIFF I dismiss the concept of majority in statistics and I say you're right if I compare it with the whole year it's going to be Hulan but I'm not doing that I'm actually looking at the most recent coin if I'm only looking at the coins today right and I have to statistically say is it my sustaining your holon most money that is floating around in Jerusalem now that people are carrying around other guests because thousands and thousands hundreds of thousands of guests would come with their money of my session they didn't come with their other money that's why they came to Africa came with the money of my so shiny I mean it may have had a little cumin money but the majority is my sustaining and therefore that's what you look at so I look at what is the most recent usage what is to what what type of coin would have been the most recent coin that fell here that's what I do here I should do the same thing nobody nobody who's questioning the fact that recently this box was used for what for matzah not for Commons what did I use it this morning what did I use it yesterday what did I use it to middle of pacer I used it for matzah I clean up the old one so now when I see a piece of bread and I don't know what it is what should I say I should say follow the most recent usage which is matzah even if the majority of the year it's used for some it's not for Madison why did you rather then tell me that of the majority of the year most bread in this box was hummus not matzo like you must treat it like comes this is the question of the Gemara let's see Rashi who explains all of this in very clear words so trashy Kevon should have some matzo ok we learned this because soca diet the finished um she says Rashi that she gives us a whole presentation revitalade possibly a lion kali massage on demand my is my sister shaney most people who ate meat most eaters of meat in your shall i am a whole year came from the money of my society which mean means if you saw somebody eating meat in Yerushalayim statistically we're not sure but statistically you could say this meat was bought from the money of my sashimi this cow or this sheep or this goat it was purchased with money of my sashimi that's what you're gonna serve why why people are eating meat they bought meat from a south Kabam because it won't any be that we eat meat it's not money of my surgeon you go to this store you pay for them - hey man you buy the meat why do we say this so Rashi says latisha law you must speak unless all combos my session is lamb burger the visitors didn't manage to come to use up all the money of my so Cheney on Yom Tov wasn't enough time there nice to know some Lavinia here but over Sanaa so for a little benefit they give it to the residents of the city even if you don't have a friend or a relative yeah for a very cheap favor for a very cheap price I'll give you all this money because for me to take it home is the very very hard thing I have to take it home and have to protect it and I have to watch the cat mix with anything else and have to bring it back with the people who did it for sure but the majority of people would do this the Haines oil my symbaloo shaston and the people you shall I am there anyway living in Yerushalayim so it's not a big deal for them to eat a carbon in uracil to eat the meat in your shall I am with the holy Maya shame the here at Hillis now it could be in two ways either they could just buy by a regular animal and shafted you didn't have to bring a carbon you could check the regular animal and they would just eat the meat but oh so that was brought from what it was brought from Maya's Meister Shanee that they used to eat with kedusha but he says even more than that the ikura Hillis Maya's my sir Swami Miami vehement cat the camera lumbermen office in fact the most common food that they used to purchase with the money of Meister Shanee was carbonate slumbers the Gemara explains in two seconds when offices that pay base that was the most common money wasn't used for at was used probably for apples and it was used for it to be used for any food but nonetheless the most common food that was used for was meat he'll cook like a man be Hamer's so they would take the money and buy animals the calls Mon chéri - my sir ain't a mud see my schooling and here's another principal as long as you have money of my sir with which you could buy something you're not gonna use Marius of Holland because you want to use up the miles of my security solution them it's sensitive so when you have mice mice sir you still don't use mice : since the people of your schlomit - mice money of my so shiny they would use that first and what would they use it for they would use it first and foremost for meat so therefore when there's money in a marketplace of animals money that was given to the seller what do I say the Africa FD Killam a mere sham Amiata Mariner flu here's the cash the coin fell on the floor how do you know from whose hands it's fell that it's full from the buyer that it's full from the seller if it's felt from the buyer statistically its Meister Shaney but if it's fell from the seller once I give him the coins and I take the animal now the kedusha of the coins went onto the food right so now this coin is cooling so even if the money was Meister Shanee great but if it fell from him if he was the schlemazel not me so then the money is cooling Raschi says you're right Shama me a demotion of flow more schooling hand but Suffolk is surah Cobra remember this is a Suffolk there I said this is a biblical doubt if the money is Holden or holy so I go with home restriction see and I say maybe it fell from the buyer maybe it fell from the seller I assume it fell from the buyer and therefore it is my so SHANY bahara biased loyal M : why I feel of a shower I go even during Yom Tov sure yesh moach mice Reuben billion miles : where there was more mice and money or shall I am more than my isola majority of money or shall I am now being used being spent being transferred being carried falling in the gorilla ground was most my son nonetheless limas African and Luba my sir we don't attribute to it the quality of my sir does lean on boss Sir Reuben is shotta we follow the statistics of the majority of the year very non lava eaten enough will Allah Coit America I have no proof that it fell today maybe it fell before Yom Tov OB or shall I am in Jerusalem Bashar you may search under the rest of the year it's : d dr maya say it Holden because most money being transferred in the city is mundane / shah suri go my sir could the my father's time I like the Gemara explains my time but shall I go mice why do you say during Yom Tov it's my civil lamb didn't come and I don't know for could I'm in a bit I'm sorry my rabbi is why don't you say it fell down on the streets before Yom t'v oh you loose Rock here Ashley I'm assuming the scabbard will call you me play at it they used to sweep the streets of Jerusalem every day because of the mud the ena foci Tamar Raglan if it was fell before Yom Tov how much back to keep a nice keyboard the sweepers would have found it during sweeping it would have been found a Valera bias but the Temple Mount Mattel showmanship er since it's on an incline for heroic Mahabharata may a fry so the winds sweep the winds sweep up the Hara bias from its dust from its earth from its mod because it's on a steep it was a pretty steep incline but I need further more another mission is Bhavik shall grab a rag love you weren't allowed to walk onto the Hara bias with dusty muddy with with with mud on your feet you weren't allowed to the NAIC this happened there were no sweepers so therefore you can clearly assume that the coins that fell before Yom Tov were not necessarily found and therefore I can follow the statistics considering the whole year and saying most of the coins here are woolen they're not Meister Shaney even during Yom Tov we're in the streets of Jerusalem you must make that distinction Alma what do we see from here but cold umber also this happened anything that you would sweep up you know we say Kamui Kamui us do the first coins the earlier ones left they're gone why because it's likely that it was found already anything that uses the concept of sweeping you don't look and say maybe it's from yesterday I look at today who stomped over some assumption when Iceland so Rashi now comes to the punchline regular boxes that are used for food no to induce generation conditional assumption when you put in the new one you take out the old one so that shouldn't get spoiled the culture came certainly here the mastaba both cuz the earlier boss here we have a second idea that he probably did thicker on the night before pace on the high the bass ready so now when you have a piece of bread here should you say it's from the new stack the new stock or the old stack the majority a whole year it's gonna be comets but don't look at the majority look at what is the most recent stock I see a priest is it from the recent stock or from the old stock is this something that you sweep up yeah before you put in the new you take out the yoke especially there's a mitzvah vicar so I assumed that was your question I'd be for Pesach he did bedico now there's a piece of bread what should I say about this behind the bass ray this is from the most recent one again if it was the Hara bias you don't say that you know why because they don't clean it if you if the rule was that it's coins for example I don't know that it's the new coins how do I know if it's a new coins you leave the old ones but he had only the old for the new because you don't want it to gets worse plus there's a Miss from thickest covers so therefore you should say motsi so Rav should say a simple dinner if you have a box and it's covered so much that it's much why is it matzah ah you use this box for comets a whole year and it may be comets you're right but the most recent usage was matzah so now I found the piece should I say it's recent or I should say old so if I never used it for matter if it came pacer can I close over the box that obviously it's comets because it's old stuff but we're talking about you using it from us it's very important to understand that there's no shower that you're using it for matzah then there's no question it's a box you just use for then it's comments we're talking about that you use it for Pesach if you don't use it for Pesach then there's no question that it's comets obviously we all have things that we what we call comets cabinets no one asks no one wonders if it's matter or not here obviously is using it's a base that means new bread came in so assume that the old one was left especially particulars comments and say that it's matzah give out the cash I love later on wrath so the gomorrah says you're right you're 100% right of course you're right but let me ask you a question let's go back to our jerusalem example it's the middle of young turf right and you see a coin there and you say it's my sir Shanee money because if it fell a week ago somebody would have found it right they say a story they say to a bunch of higher-risk I don't know if it's happened with him what happened with somebody else with her God will be strong that his father woke him up very very early to go to show extremely early it was like you know for a second before sunrise and and and on the way going to show her the way coming from sure the way going to show they found the golden coin in the street so his father says you see this is the scar this is the reward for waking up early you wake up early and this is what you find these is actually the guy who woke up even earlier dropped it so I'm not sure I'm not sure this is the reward but in any case so you found this coin here in Jerusalem so you say when did it fall it fell today it didn't fall a week before pay stuff because it would have been found and that's why I say it's my sash a knee but what if you could see the coin and you can see that this coin is not used anymore what if this coffee is some ancient coin that when out of use went out of use surveys event right nobody uses it anymore so now what are you gonna say we're going to say is right I have no choice but to say that it must be old and the sweepers missed it that's what the Gemara is going to say we understood Rav why is the past moldy why did he say that it's moldy so you don't recognize it no now the camera says no no no he was very meticulous shiny akka this is different the e.push am idea i love a it's old it's so spoiled that's what use it it's old bread that's the point yes you have more beautiful explanations to tell me that this is from the batch of matzah follow the newest granted but what if you look at it and you see that it's not new it's very old Raschi my vehicle a chalet who's a young member album this guy is an old man for comments who it's just a comments that's the problem therefore ralph can't follow the logical consideration that the most recent usage should trump majority that works if i could say that this comes from the recent brand in other words it comes from the Pesach bread but that's what he said they didn't say you don't know if it's coming so matzah if he would have said you don't know if it's Hubbard some mats are very good he gave an intro pasture up shop it's spoiled so we might have thought he said that simply to give a practical illustration of why you don't know no that was his point this point is it's spoiled it's old its ancient so when you look at it you see this guy is not a fresh piece of bread this piece of bread is a trickle over bottle he's old if he's old meaning Pesach has not been forever he comes from before paisa he comes on before Payson and this is a box used for comments obviously it's comments so the commercials ok got it but now we have the opposite problem really he pushed my vehicle if the if the spoiled miss demonstrates that it's old kid off some at some I have er what do I gain from the fact that if the majority of this box is used for matzah I can use it you're telling me that I can't follow them recent circumstances because this is not recent this is an old piece that comes from before Pesach so therefore I can't say it's mats I say it's comets so Ralph tells me but ever the majority of the box is used more for matzah than for comments then I could use this as much so what does it help if I see that it's from before Pesach even let's say it's used paste non-stop yeah used a thousand pieces of mats in the box and 500 pieces of comets and rocks 80% matzah and 20% comments but if you could see that this comes from before Pesach because if not then you would say what if you can't see that comes before basil then you would say what then you would say from the recent batch that's more logical but you can't say that why because it's too old for that so obviously it comes from the old before because comments if that's the case then what does it help that statistically most of this box has mats in it Raschi okay no my vehicle a ceramic omitsu answers the camera on my rubber rubber says you're right we completely misunderstood RAF you push a misunderstood Lloyd a Murshid off so matzah love did not mean that the Matz's used more than comments that's not what he meant Ella ami he meant share Abu you may not see love it that the majority of the days of mats have already passed ruff some matzo does not mean that this box is used more for matzo than for comments that would be completely irrelevant here I don't care how much it's used for mats I don't know what care how much is used for comments if this piece of mats if this piece of bread is a moldy spoiled piece of bread and obviously it's old so it doesn't come from the new bag it doesn't come from the new batch I say it comes from the old batch right it's like the Hera bias Terra bias and therefore how can I know that it's much it could be very likely be comments so rabba says the shot is completely different ruff some matzo doesn't mean most days of pace of past rough Sam Matson I'm sorry officer that doesn't mean it's used mostly for matzo it means most days of pacer past why is that relevant because Rashi says rather you may have maps we're oily smoke push mission is nicer person because most of the days of pace have passed so therefore it's very likely that it's spoiled after pace if it would have been the second day of Pesach it couldn't have been a Pesach child because it's so spoiled but since it's let's say the seventh day of Pesach or the eighth day of Pesach so therefore you could say what that it got spoiled when on pacer in other words it's matzah II ha see if that's the case then obvious then you need then you need a finish of Ralph's I don't understand you you find the piece of bread in your house yeah why should you super comments rashly says the I feel a Suffolk lekker the mastaba vada baklava might say we assume a Jew did vicar's comments and this is Marcela what's rap skiddish what does he telling me you found the piece of bread it's spoiled right most of Pesach went by this is a box that used to be used for comets now it's used for matzah why should I assume that it's comets say a Jew did thickest comets he cleaned up the Comets and now there's a piece of bread what's RAF telling me it doesn't just sticks you don't need majority it's basic of developed basic of the veldt what's the problem in other words if it's so old then it had to be from before Pesach then I have the opposite problem then how can I say that it's months after say that it's comets it comes from a time when it was used for comments right LMI you telling me that it was so it was in a situation that you can attribute it to pacer already most of the pace of past that's what he said a pastor Cuban sheriff's a matter what's rough Samantha rough sir you may have matza the days of matzo have passed most of them and therefore could get spoiled on pacer great so they get spoiled on Pesach so what's the hidden why shouldn't you even think that it's comets we assume every Jew did Dickus comments he cleaned up the box and if there's bread there it's much what's the problem our matzah doesn't spoil I told you their matzah was like pita bread spoils very fast it's not matter you're calling mats is not matter what you're calling marks is our invention of matzah that's not matzah matzo just means that the door wasn't fermented their matzah was a soft as PITA yeah yes and they used to bake in the middle of pacer oh so firmly hockey and for the Gemara Lloyd sirisha I'll tell you the issue it pushed me rubber you have spoiled and you have spoiled this piece of bread is extremely it's excessively spoiled in other words it appears to be not old but very old so now I can look at it in two ways now the time I would say keeping the push of Aruba since it's abundantly spoiled the Gloria mill said this reveals to me divided by comets Mallya who that this is absolute comets I do was thickest comets I'm forced to say that he made a mistake he overlooked it somehow his bleeker's comets failed he missed the box whatever the box was hidden something happened I wouldn't say this logically I would I assume call your Abba cos cos conscious that he did because comets and this past as much as now comes but I have a problem here the problem here is it looks very old because it looks very old I might think that you have to assume that it's ancient meaning that comes from before pacer before pacer who was used for comets it was comments I what happened with the Dicker's comments you made a mistake because comets wasn't perfect you missed something maybe you went I rushed you were tired you were stressed you didn't see the box whatever it is commercial Milan that's what graph says no don't go there Kevon should I be you may Marci Louie since the majority of the days of pacer have Paris in other words I can also attribute the spoiled nosov this piece of bread to have happen the middle of Pesach as a result of so many days past so even though it looks so old and you could say that it's from before Pesach but since I don't have to say from its before paisa I couldn't assume it's the middle of Pesach I'm really not that's what we do we say call your mother join me every single day namaha me ma this fellow bakes warm bread as I told you they used to bake their mats on face it would come morning that we we you know we're used to bakeries and commercial matzo commercial mops as a business that industry did not work that it didn't work that way everyone bake their own matzo for the Seder you baked much Sarah Facebook and then you bake matzah the kids needed bread you bake matzah every day a Facebook you took your week you're grinding you wheat you had your kernels and you made your dough and you make your matzo the middle of the year you didn't care if it became comments and basically made sure that it didn't become comments it had the same flavor the same texture it looked the same etc now it becomes mouldy and you're not sure if it's before or after but you could say it's after so we say call you a mother in Manama coming off every day of pace has this fellow baked warm Mattson who shudder a lawyer and he threw it on top of the on top of the one from the previous day the absence way and that's why it got so so moldy in other words you don't have to attribute it to the fact that it's really really old you can attribute it to the fact that throughout Pesach you eat matzah you eat a lot of matzah he baked every day warm bread and he put it in this basket and as a result of that this poor piece of matzah became more spoiled than usual even though it happened the middle of face Rashi he hush it a philosophic like of the Mustapha vodka waha matzah he write if what if the most of Pesach past so this is what the Gemara answers that you could go both ways so therefore there's a finish of ram without rabbi would say you find a piece of comets you find a piece of bread I'm not sure maybe I should treat it as hummus that's his signature as long as you could say that it happened on Pesach we don't say this Jew failed them thickest hummus we say he did a good Nicholas comments and therefore there's no way that this would have been a piece of comets i-it's so old if you can at least give a logical explanation why it looks so old assuming you did because Cummins that's what you do if you can't of course if it's so old that it's obvious that it comes from before paisa then you have no choice and you have to say yeah your particular is coming from just like today's day if you find a piece of bread under your County and you know it's not matter you don't say well I did thickest comets well you dip the consumers we didn't do a good job and obviously it's comets obviously that's the case but that's the finish of Wrath then in this case it would be motor but pack in a case where you could attribute it to the most recent we would attribute it to the most recent not a question in other words if it's not spoiled then there's no question if it's not spoiled what are you gonna say you're gonna say there was business comets and this is this is this is March it's not summits if it's not sport you're not gonna say it's from before pace even if it's the first day of pace on the finish there is even though there are arrows pointing to before pace up you don't say it if you don't have to why because you could say that there's a Macias where it could become so old we go bus a Basra and and and and we have with the precursor comets the particular comments adds a tremendous as a tremendous we go by sebastio and we said it was because comets it was because comets since it was because comets so therefore you can eat the bread you can treat it as much because comets makes this pasture you understand like by the coins thickest comets makes it faster because if if there was no concept of Dicker's comets there was no concept of cleaning up the old so so faster doesn't help you know what I mean why should you go about Sebastian just like the coins they could be from today they can also be from from a month ago they could be from a week ago why is this better than this but sebastio Trump statistics even though it's what's used more for commerce than formats that becomes irrelevant if you don't have a choice if you can't attribute it to pacer if you can't say it's Basara if you have to say it's Karma because so old so even though this proof that it is bachelor cool stickers comets but you have other proof that there was no good because come because it's so old so you can't you can't fight reality so you have to say it's comments practical murder Oh me as Lynn Abbas Abbas Sarah do you always follow the bastards that's true waha Tanya let me show you a Bryce a clearly the opposite the police about you who'd ever used to be who this says very interesting case you have TAVR you have a box for money nostalgia bomber is so little more use myself this is the place you use money so sometimes you put in money of Hulan sometimes you put in more use of my so shiny here's the problem you find a coin it's just there and you don't know which one it is Roy who Lin Hulan drive my surmise you follow statistics if you say throughout the year yeah how much schooling is money here how much is my sir you say : thousand coins my sir 50 coins I find our coin I don't know which one it is statistics and I follow the majority if the majority is Hulan it's hold a majority of mice is mice now let's understand we assume that a person will not put in both coins together holding a mice because you don't want it to get mixed up therefore when you finish using it for my sir let's say you use you're keeping it till you go to Jerusalem what do you do you clean it up your boy take it you make sure there's no - my session and then you put in coolant when you finish using it for cooling you want to put in for my sir you're not just gonna put in the whole in money because you stop wasting money you first clean up the old and you're putting didn't we remember this is a concept where you're gonna clean up the old before you put in the new because you don't want them to be mixed up right that's one of those if that's the case why do you follow statistics by my laser by sebastio go according to the last usage that's what you should do again if you don't clean up the old to put in the new then I have to look at the whole year so I say what's the majority of coins that this chest contains granite but it's not that situation you clean up the my sir before you put them home you clean up the whole in before you put in my cell for obvious reasons you don't want the two monies to get mixed this money has to be taken to your client the whole other Allah if that's the case what do we say what did we establish you don't follow statistics what do you follow you look at the last the last circumstances so now you found the coin why don't you ask one question what was this used for yesterday what was this used for last week what was this used for last month what was the last thing this box was used for if it was used for cooling assume that this money is what if it was used for Meister assume that it's mice just like we explained by your shall I am if you look at the whole year it's mostly : but you're looking tonight today it's Yom Tov jumped if I say this coin what was the last coin that fell here nicer SHANY and for the Gemara what do we see for me that it's not so simple it may be statistics are more important than the last use and the logic would be yes he cleaned it up but maybe he didn't clean it up well so that's a whole other perspective I'm fatigued of murder I'm gonna answer my it's not your misunderstanding talk about Maya's skin and this is talking about a case musician it's Tom Shuba my stolen or mice mice rainy day is a man beside he used it for both but he doesn't know what was the last usage that's the problem it's very nice if he knows what he used it last week for but he doesn't remember he knows I use it for this I use it for this I don't remember what was the last so what do I do now with this so now I have a coin I can't say what was here last but I don't know what was here last if I wouldn't know it wouldn't be a problem but I did so what do I have to follow so I look at the whole year and I say statistically it's my circle and based on the majority second best option observe Adama rapid says consciousness Tom Shabbat see Putin supported you use them both simultaneously each one in a separate seaboard in a separate bag you put one in a bundle in one corner the other one a bungle another corner so now you took them both out and there's a coin left you say what was it used last well it was used for both I don't know which one it is right or even if they're both there there's a coin we're in the middle where did you say what was it use last it's used for both I don't know so I have to go into the majority if Papa Mir Papa says going to stock this big umma a third situation you can explain it is you found the coin in a cavity inside the box as a whole an indentation and that's where you found it if that's the case we can't say follow the last time it was used because the previous one was cleaned up cleaned up of the coins are there but this coin obviously fell into some hole so it's very obvious very likely that it was overlooked by this person when he cleaned up the last money so here is a special situation we're cleaning it doesn't help it would be like the streets of Jerusalem if there's a hole and the coin is found deep in a hole where doesn't get sweep tup you're not gonna say on that coin that it's my sister Shanee because it fell today because of it fell yesterday would have been sweep up it would have not been sweep tup so now you follow just the general statistics I don't know what this coin is so I follow the majority but we still maintain the idea that bossa Basara is more important then then buffs are comma I want to conclude here with two things first of all aligned from Hebei no hana no and then how it works halakhah la mesa if you take a look on the left of your Gomorrah Raban Yohanan oh just a very interesting line that he puts in past sheep sure you see to middle of rabbinic enano very small letters on the left side probably of your Gomorrah past sheep Shaw the line starts to appear been a phenomenal pasture if Shawn you got it the lawyer de e Matsuyama tzu amir abu you may matter if it's the majority of basic has passed Butera see it's mutter peters after happy only after pacer here we see them in a phenomenal interprets this Gomorrah completely different he believes that your now let I eat this son pacer why cuz even if you have a slide out because it's a Suffolk dairy rice and perhaps it's an Easter chorus to eat comets so therefore he doesn't want to rely on any statistics even saying there was particular birds and it got spoiled on Pesach no after pay stuff you can eat it which is a hidden cause come it's over all of our paths are you now that I eat but that's only an instantly rabona it's not indecent monotonous so there freezes wait till after peso and then eat it even if it's comets new but I'm Pesach he doesn't even think that the Rav said you're allowed to eat it that's the Dorinda Kannamma it's not the off of him a fortune but that's his even if you hold a coma trouble or passive is awesome and I tell you that still not an Easter chorus but I'm pacing it's an issue chorus what is right so he doesn't say you have to do beer you could leave it because that's not an Easter chorus by you know about you must say is not an Easter chorus so he lets you keep it because right because we say that it's not so but he doesn't let you eat it he lets you keep it cuz he says you a lot even after Pesach that means you could keep it very interesting oh you may be overrun by a robber you might say that's true but it's not an Easter chorus but eating it digesting it that's what it seems he doesn't save them that's what it seems there's a myth so of beer on home it's not a matzah it's a Suffolk it's a Suffolk very nice but that's the point that it's a Suffolk that I said that's Suffolk nice little humor means if it's a Suffolk but here the Suffolk stands against many other statistics the statistic is that you didn't think us harm but you did a good thing so it's not a Suffolk anymore yes that right Suffolk the rice alhambra means that it's an absolute Suffolk here the point is it's not a Suffolk it would have been a Suffolk if we move remove the idea that a Jew does because comments but since Andrew does because comments and this could have gotten spoiled on pace Suffolk anymore it's a vada is it a real bad day of course it's not a real bad day because people can overlook things but the whole office has it survived it would have been a commando does not rely on it he says they Rav is only talking about after basic it's a big finish no he found in the middle of pace he doesn't say found that after base he says we're gonna say further ah in rubble you may match the Moutere see pillars are a person its motor after pacer that's what it seems the way this is a local oh my sir it's in Sonora in Simon Simon tough man valve I'll read from here hi I'm Simon tough involve just good night good night I mention it I'll read from Sonora harav cement of involve and he'll to spacer see this is how the suji is summed up halakha La Mesa ok in Turin and silicon are all here in cement tough move off if somebody finds bread in his house on Pesach and he doesn't know if it's comets or matzah again this is without spoiled when you have to sum up the suger right if somebody finds a piece of pita so you don't get confused a piece of pita Yemenite the pita in your house on pace and you don't know if it's cumbersome at Sur the answer is you say it's matzah and you're allowed to eat it it certainly mats of why coz every Jew does boudicca's hummus before Pesach and we assumed that he got rid of all the comments that was in his house and hence when there's a piece of bread in the house on Pesach we say what that it's matzah there's no reason to say he didn't do Pickers comets and therefore it's a piece of comets even though it could be because it doesn't have the identifying feature of matzah but that's the finish here that what you say it's Martha but vada and therefore you could eat it again according to American ah no that's not the case right then that's one in Halawa the Mishnah brewery discusses it but generally speaking most poised skin say you can eat it on Pesach give out the cavort why think his comments was a good thickest comments oh you don't know if it's coming so much I don't have to know I know that I'm a Jew and I got rid of my bread before Pesach so if I find bread anywhere on the couch in the pantry even if I find it in a hole I'm not afraid that you missed it because we assume that you did a good thing comments and thickest comments is done but Hiram will be stuck if it's done in crevices it's done in holes but that's only if the hole is exposed so you could see it during meticulous comment and you probably did predict but if you found it somewhere in a concealed hole for example under a box but not in the hole it's covered by the by the lower planks and therefore it's hard to see so here there is a concern that he overlooked it which maybe not because he didn't do a good thing as comments but because it's so concealed and you have to get rid of the summit's immediately not only an hour to eat it you have to get rid of it well it's a piece of comets in your house and even if you did bit though bit till only helps from in our tired but still me there are bond and you have to get rid of it what happens if you find bread in middle of your house but it is spoiled it's more EPSA so if it's a situation that it was impossible to get spoiled from when Pesach began or from when you bake Matz's during these days when we bake all of our matches before Pesach so if it's a situation that from that time let's say you baked Marx's two weeks before Pesach right you baked pita two weeks before pace so if you can say if you can't say that it's spoiled so badly since that time because it's too little time to attribute so much mole to it so then it's recognizable that it's certainly hummus why because even though you did thickest cometh you're right but but look at this it's obvious that it couldn't have happened since Pesach let's say you baked you mats on pesos and this didn't happen on Pesach this happens from before or even if he baked matter before Pesach but this is too spoiled to be able to attribute it to that time so then obviously it's Hammad's and you have to get rid of it right away right that's where I've said that the only reason you say it's mutter ears because you could say that it happened on Pesach so then you do say but here you can't say it so therefore you going to say your now let me keep it in your house but if so many days of pacers went by Oh you baked your Marxist a long time before paisa and therefore you could say clearly that what that it got spoiled after Pesach or a got spoiled after you baked the matter before paisa but what got spoiled Matson are comets so then time in law Hakan we look at the lenient route and you're allowed to eat it why because you did Dicky's comments before pacer and therefore we say the choc another Baskins since you did but it can be for patients as rashly explains therefore you're allowed to eat it and if in that house they bake warm bread every single day if it's a house where they have a minik that every four o'clock in the morning the mullah Buster gets up and bakes fresh warm bread then even if the bread is so spoiled and you would certainly want to say that it's old but because it's a house with a baked warm bread every day then even if this bread is so spoiled you still follow the lenient route and you say that because he baked warm bread every single day and he placed it on this old bread therefore the matzah became so spoiled which means if there's any way of saying that the biggest hummus was a good Pickers comments you say that even if you have to push it and you could say no it's oh no it's not all that's new but because this is a house with a big warm bread every day and they place it here unless you know that he doesn't place it here but if you know that he places in there and you can attribute it to that and that's how we attribute and we explain the mold and the spoiled nurse based on that and therefore you could say it's matzah and you could eat it according to the holo ha if it's a piece of cake we know that it's hummus you're right you're right I had a miser once when I was a bucker I found in my house my parents house I remember the second day of Yom Tov I was sitting on the couch I was reading something and I picked up the pillow just to straighten it out I found a nice big nice big tray of cookies and I remember I went to my mother screaming and she took a look and she said that one of my niece's was there one of my nephew's was there and they came with the pace of cookies and and it was fine if it's a piece of cake that could be crushed on the pedestal if you did because comets and it could be it could be pacer that you assume it's pacer and you can eat it that's the whole that's the whole part you assumed it was a good comments and it's you could throw it away and there is such a shitty rabbinic enamel holes like that vishnu guru brings them to etcetera because he dealing with chorus you dealing with carter's hey some cookies would be a very similar situation you find a pace until you find a pace at brownie well the truth is if you look a little if you know a little bit you could see it's huh but if you if you talk a can see theoretically if you don't anybody if you know a little bit you could see but you're saying in a situation where you can't see okay again again you have to be practical if you know for sure that in this house nobody would have brought in a piece of brownie for example some houses they don't know i'll place a piece of snacks there they have a home right they don't allow all these things till your grandchildren come yeah depends on the standards of your daughter-in-law and your son right but let's say we know that this house then obviously again you only say it's Kushal up a son it's months if you can explain it if you know that in this house marshall the base of brownies don't come in then I have no choice after say it's comets again we're talking about in a case where you could say that it's discussion the pace of brownies I don't have to say it's it's comets I know I shouldn't say it's conference I can eat it have all the cover this is the finish of Ralph the finish of Rav is a pasta up shop which means it's very old so you naturally you would say it's a cycle comets but since since most of Pesach Pat passed keep it shut off Samantha but mainly you can attribute it to what to the fact that it got spoiled on Pesach and what and he bakes bread every single day so you can go both ways I say that it's matzah give all the cavort no question no question today people would say throw it out buy them a piece of bread you did not throw out you have to remember it we have to remember that most people were complete civilizations that died from hunger famine was was was as predictable as sunrise you know what I mean the rain didn't rain one winter there's no such a thing you bring food from another country you go to the store you have food food stamps surplus it didn't exist if there was one season there was no rain right if a storm came and knocked it out that's it people would starve that year wasn't there was no joke it wasn't like I'll go to the store and buy a column I'll go to the shore and find Khalid it was very very such a serious situation you found a piece of bread you didn't just say throw it out today bar Hashem nobody needs that piece of red so throw it out you can burn it off you want but that locker still didn't change the locker still didn't change although the Mishnah brewery says interestingly I'll just read it it's very interesting how he puts it because the Chicano record of past games like this shocked American explains it we should a brewery Simon tough love it's unbelievable without fart of what you have today Roberta says this whole outlaw has basically I would used to work in the olden days that the monsters were very thick or at least a little thick and nobody knew the difference between comets and matza what come as the Komatsu say beer hawa oh she says like this is very interesting dude if this how lost is brought in torrential caloric I mentioned that you could eat the bread and shook him out of her out so he says dear if the Rambam and they rush not the torrential tomorrow did not put in this din they Ward this hello Henchard Gemara it's a question why ok he says when you see the rabbinic enamel and he says that it only applies after Pesach because the middle of pace of his chorus so therefore don't try to be lenient because it's a shock comments gummer wait till after pace at which only an issue there abundant and even half comma telepathic and even it's an Easter Day right sir it's not chorus so he says maybe the Rambam and the reef in the rush because they weren't clear from anal canal is right or not right and if he's right then the Gomorrah never said your lie to eat it on pacer if you have any Suffolk even if you could say it's matzah you now let eat it so therefore maybe they didn't put in the along but the fact is that a tour and their Sinatra did put it in and said you can I eat it so the Mishnah Brewer just says that Lamesa it would certainly be certainly one should not be Ling in the middle of pacer against remain a phenomenal she called varam him Divya Kabbalah he says that's what the the beer Halak of the Mishnah brewery the Cubs game writes very interesting you have to make you complete you have to make your own assumption 100% how do they make the thick matzo they still do it in some places it just it just comes with a lot of problems it's just as much more concerns because the thicker it is right our matzah why do we make our matzah you want to know let me explain you how we made our matzah is very very hard it's also very thin why portion and we put holes you put it into the oven they leave it in the oven for around 20 seconds 30 seconds why is it always burnt because it's so thin if you leave it in another 20-30 seconds you end up with with with ashes with charcoal you can't eat it so we make it very very thin but mainly it bakes extremely extremely fast right you take it out immediately there's much less concern then it's gonna become comments it's very very thin ah the water gets dried up so fast it's such heat yeah and it's so thin it's so thin I thought you leave it in the oven for a longer if it's thicker you have to leave it in the oven longer so even though yeah so that's how I used to do it there were matzah I read there was one of the restraining writes the Martis thick @fr imagine matzo dough is thick @fo like this look how thick matzo like this but it was matzah wasn't commerce much like a mocha even I believe in Yemen they would make till recently maybe even recently like a pita much like a PITA it's very good Schmucker matzo Kairos people think Maps is very nice it was Kairos here they had the based on mr. had lamb chops with with with with lettuce with with Carosa it was a very nice sandwich it was like a burger people don't realize Kato Sahil oh you have pita bread with lamb chops yeah and you have mortar as a spicy I'm a beautiful beautiful food today we're left with with matzah and lettuce okay I was in a pace of program breakfast pizza bagels thick bread so that's what we're talking about that's what the mr. Brewer says so they don't know you don't know if it's covered so much ah our oven is very hot right you can do with such a hot oven so it takes more time it's a smaller fire so you just have to be more careful and that's why they stopped doing it by us they stopped doing they just make flat matzah very very thin bakes like this it gets burnt and there's a lesser charge comets but it's not oh they used to do it we also do it all before Pesach we don't do anything in middle of pacer why cause before pacer comments gets bottled after pace of Commerce doesn't get bottles so there's a little crumb that's that's comments dick it doesn't get buckle say we did all of these Hummers that didn't necessarily apply this one anyway that's where the Gemara says you could bake matzah every day of Pesach and that's why it became so spoiled today that's not a possibility that's America Rav says if you're not baking bread every day of Pesach and therefore this thing is spoiled not from the warm bread that you put on it you have to attribute it to the fact that it's conference