Dispatching the Emissaries for Tishrei, Ader II and Nissan - Gemarah Rosh Hashanah 19b-20a

the yeshiva dotnet nine lines from the top that's actually overall there's two dots we began the mission and a few tests Amidala from the bottom the Mishnah said the following halacha that there were six months out of the year when Bezdek the Supreme Court the Sanhedrin would send out emissary solution to notify Jewish communities in Eretz Easter all and the world over about the time when Rosh Hodesh was established a day that was established as a side dish so that they could know when to celebrate the respective holidays of that month what are the six months so the Mishnah said Nissen they had to go out in order to notify everybody when Pesach was the next was off they went out to notify them when the fast of tisha bhav was number three was ll they went out so they should know when the first day of ll was so they could know when russia shahnawaz as Rashi explained what does this mean if they know when the beginning of ll was so then they figured out if this is the beginning of L let's count 29 days and the thirtieth day will become Rosh Hashanah in other words L o will be a month of 29 days and the thirtieth day will become the first day of Tishri which is Rosh Hashanah Raschi explaining the Mishnah because most years the majority of years ll did not have 30 days L had 29 days and even though would be possible that maybe that particular year they had Mazel and best didn't added another day to ello ello was not 29 days but 30 days and therefore a Hashanah was day 31 maybe that happen that's possible but they don't know they can't know I'm living in Iraq in Babylonia I can't know or even foreign ancestral I don't know what happens in your show by the base--emitter I don't know what happens by the Sun had room or wherever the sun had room were I don't know so I follow the majority the Toyota says you follow the majority of situations and the majority of years lol as 29 days but if they wouldn't know when ll began they wouldn't know when they thirty of Emma would be why wouldn't they know one day thirty would be because if you don't know when L began why cuz it could be of has twenty nine days it could be over half 30 days if RS 29 days so then and will began a day earlier so that means day 30 of L is also a day earlier if I've had 30 days so ll began on day 31 of of so then the 30 it has to be and they later said they had to send out Slocum on Ehlo to tell everybody whether it's Troy - L wasn't there with know when to celebrate celebrate Rosh Hashanah because they celebrated it on day 30 that's what - she said of the mission then you had the next time they sent Slocum was Tishrei in a corner somewhere Justiciary has a lot of holidays which a chaton was already too late but you have yom kippur you have suckers and you haven't yet saris right that's three holidays and then kiss love Chanukah and number six is other for Purim there's no one to do poor mr. nabban when the Bayside McNish existed they went out for ear because of pace society people have to come to your shrine to bring the carbon if they did not bring basically but that was only relevant and time to miss I make this after that it wouldn't be relevant to know any day a year in terms of strict halakhah of something you have to do a holiday after Pesach Sheni is a serious yump if you have to go and bring a carbon Pacers often on which day which day is is you Dalit year the 14th day of ear because it could be one of two days depending of Nissen had 29 days or Nissen had 30 days and restraint this year was either day 30 or day 31 that is what the mission is set in defuses the first surgery of gomorrah discuss discussed Thomas and Tavis why they did not go out Thomas and papers even though there's fast there's shavasana Thomas and a sort of Tavis that was the sugi about fasting the time of the base--emitter after the base of mechanism Achilles Thainess thank you very much now the Gemara goes on to a new discussion the two dots i'll LM the player Shoshana about tissue a pentacon Osama's the discussion is now going to be lol and Tishrei when Slocum went out on both of them for Rosh Hashanah and for the other holidays of tissue schleimann and Iraq I'm back that it could take a look let's say it's an hour to walk mean yeah so suck the good martyr illuminator she start about tissue Matakana somewhere this so going to get modern I don't understand key the question of the game art Kevon didn't of kahlúa hello since they went they went out the Slocum went out for the month of ello so that everybody in the community in the various communities knew when the first day of ello was if so RT sheilamalone why did they have to go out again for the month of Tishrei what is it about asking if everybody knew when L will began and therefore as we said before they counted 29 days in L oh and they celebrated mr. Shana on the 30th day of ll assuming that in the majority of years that is the month of Elul 29 days and therefore Hashanah begins on day 30 so they also know when Rosh Hashana begins they know until she begins if they know when tisha T begins assuming this is true why did they have to sensual him a second time so the command is gonna elaborate heat a me an answer okay Dilma grew a low fart of course in the majority of years lol s 29 days and therefore Islam has to be on day 30 but there is a chance that ello will have 30 days Hebrew 11 literally means maybe they made ll pregnant which is the expression maybe they made a Lube or maybe they made a little pregnant with an extra day in other words al who had 30 days so Rosh Hashanah was a day early they did it a day earlier so therefore if that's the case they're gonna be doing Yom Kippur and sukhasana wrong day if L o was 29 days and Rosh Hashanah began on day 30 that's al of Tishrei beautiful Kippur is great so kisses great size but what happens if everything has to be pushed off by your day so they're gonna be doing in Kippur what they think is 10th today and really it's the ninth of tissue why because we Shoshanna started a day later so it has to be tomorrow so they're eating on in Kippur the same is true supers they're doing in sukhasana da latisha really Circus has to be tough of Tishri so first of all they're gonna stop so kiss a day early right they're gonna do sue kiss a day early and therefore they're gonna be doing Malacca on the last day of so cuz they're gonna be doing him a lot hunched mini answer is they're gonna think it's this roof rack everything was a day early besides making all the brothers in the wrong day they're gonna do love the wrong day and suck in the wrong day everything the wrong that but that we're not blaming them but we can understand why him watch look him go out we're not blaming them they're following the majority doing the best they can these are not Jews who are trying to eat on Yom Kippur they fasted the wrong day by them it wasn't the wrong day they were trying to do the best I can but I'll have to see well quote to the majority now let's say they'll figure out that what that they were right ello was only 29 days oh so Bhishma why have as an actually said in the mission are very nicely that when you send out this looking for Tishri he says what does he say he says shall ye leave I'm Mike fun BM I could put on the circus what do you have to give Jews leave him like for nah aggravation a shredder hearts they're sitting and eating it out of tissue in the same a beats in Kippur let's say they attack her right ella was 29 there's just still a value at sending out Slocum to validate a hundred percent let them know it's a hundred percent Tim Kippur it's a hundred percent circus it's not 90 percent in kid print service let the Jew feel that it's really young TIF he's not just doing the best he can and he may be off so that's what the Gemara is asking what do you mean why they sent slow human tissue it may be ella was movable and therefore they're doing it the wrong day I they did research on of the wrong way okay so that's why it's a mixer to do him Kippur then so cuz they're wrong then there's a subtly there never choice that's the Shiloh of the Jomon saga you motivated this is not a question why a piece of history I'm gonna begin another common on my Ralph's hidden of the Sun Kahana said in the name of Rob me my sensitive a little Amos in Louisville ear bar from the days of Ezra and on we did not find ever that ll should have 30 days it never happened that ello had more than 29 days now this Mishnah is written at the time of the mission of course this is hundreds of years after azor azor let's remember lives in the time when the first when the second base uh McNish is established the second base emitter stands for four hundred and twenty years and ezra is the first generation he comes up from Babylonia after seventy years of exile with the permission of the Persian king as we learned in the beginning of mitosis none of the whole story he comes up with forty two thousand Jews the second base on Mukesh is being rebuilt and renovated and permission is on and off and on and off and he really revitalizes the community a nature surro invigorates and blows in a fresh here a fresh spirit in clarinetist role establishes nine check necessary doula and the beginning of the second base I make this begins the base--emitter stands for four hundred twenty years it gets destroyed a hundred years more than a hundred years later the mission is written that's when this this mission is written edited by w darkness a Roth who's already the first generation of a Miriam says from the days of Ezra till now that's hundreds of years we don't have one story of ll having more than 25 years not wonderful Ezra terrazzo Oh private has no you have the whole the whole position so you have four hundred years till builds the first base emitter four hundred forty years after it's after the commentary too strong he builds the base I make this plus you have another four hundred and ten years of the base of mixer standing and 70 years of the Corbett so you have close to a millennium close to a thousand years one hundred forty years to Lazar plus till the soy mama plus four hundred and ten years of the base of McNish that's more than 800 years all right that's 850 years mom was 850 years and then the 70 years of godless bar so you have a tradition that's from Ezra lemon single mom we don't love it before he said I would see us let me see well the answer to the solutions role that what do you mean what's going to happen in the future so so the prasat that what they did we're gonna see in a moment way twice miss Lindsey my successor is that in estrus time there was an element over that's why he says when my says it's not only the beef we doesn't know because my answer there wasn't albums it's just from the days of Ezra till now limits into a little more if that's the case you're writing a missionary okay once up here very good answer you say climate see know is we had Mazel for for 500 years but that muscle may not continue you don't know what happens tomorrow you have to be yeah yes scientists always say the fact that happened 500 years is not a night it's gonna happen tomorrow morning you have to see what happens tomorrow morning all different my sir today we have a little no we don't do it yeah but today's a holder for my so we're talking here every month was a new Macias there was no predictions were based on the witnesses can't so that's what the cameras gonna set my sensitive and the climate see no Elmo but if this is the case if this is the case the Mishnah was written hundreds of years after the days of Ezra L was never move over so that's the case nobody should be afraid nobody should be afraid that ll suddenly is gonna be 30 days and therefore they're gonna have to set a new solution for so we're back to the question why resentful and petitioner if we never found from the days of Ezra that L was müber Zog the Gemara one second this is not a problem when Rob said that from the days of Ezra Ella was not moved but what he said was Lloyd must see them take his words what does like much sino mean let me see no means we haven't found we haven't experienced in Elmore but you know why delay its theorem because it didn't need one oh it's didn't what if you would need an elbow that's thirty days what if you would need why would you need good question we'll see - in a moment but let's say you with Muppet in LA they would make Errol thirty days it's not shot that ello can't be thirty days it means for five hundred years they never need it and ll that was thirty days like it's terrifically but if it's you're it not really you're going to give an extra day forever if that's the case so it's still possible in the future that you're gonna have 30 days right according to this you'll say that's why they had to send out petitioner even though for hundreds of years everyone who L is 29 days and therefore they can assume rashanna is on day 30 without guilt says you're right but still because it's possible that maybe this you hear things changed they're gonna need to do it so therefore they had to make ll 30 day CFO sent the crazy mistake they shouldn't do em kippers suck is the wrong there and again I even if it's the right day they should feel karma valance that's what the Gemara says and that's why it's possible that Tishrei started a day later in other words day 31 and therefore you have to send outlook them to tell them how many days there were an L what does it mean they would need to do it what does it mean they would need to do let's see what Rashi says this is going to be the view of Rashi and place versus might have a serious disagreement with rocky and but let's see that so crash ha it's do a short rash it has a lot in it what have they need then they would have to do 30 days emissions ARCA emission Messiah could Allah command aha they would need two for two reasons for the vegetables or for the dead as the Gemara is gonna say later on da meaning there was a situation where right right good good point at this point we would assume that all has to do with when witnesses come as we're gonna see aandava huh we have a rule Loy I do rush we don't establish your Sultana on Sunday on Wednesday and on Friday I do Alif dalla drove three days which we still follow in our calendar Rosh Hashanah will not be on a Sunday on a Wednesday or on a Friday if Hashanah could be on the other days but the first day there's only one about do the Gemara is gonna discuss the reason for this this is not a reason now this is a reason in the past that was very relevant the first reason is vegetables the second reason is the dead what's the issue of the issue of the vegetables remember this is before days of refrigeration if any of the young employ them during Tishri falls out right near Shabbos before Shabbos or after Shabbos Friday or Sunday when do you cut the vegetables you can't cut vegetables on Shabbos nor do you cut vegetables on young to from the garden from the field so therefore you have to do it when you have to do it on Friday you do it on Friday now you have this is Shabbos and then you have Sunday what happens is by the time the second day comes the vegetables are welted yeah wilted wrapped and decomposed for Chimel or Chimel decadent yeah right they did not they did not want that because since it's going to be two days straight after it was cut off it's going to dry up ah you know we're talking even with this one day it does with these two days that you now that adumim do you know let's do Malacca so therefore you have one day Shabbos you have vegetables from yesterday but now you don't have vegetables from yesterday no more cause it's Sunday so this means if the 30th day of element Rosh Hashanah is on Sunday or Wednesday or Friday if that becomes a Shoshanna so then rosh hashanah suka so Yom Kippur will be either on Friday or on Sunday that's what they ate that's what they that's what they for us it's hard to understand but this this was life this was life there'd be no vegetables everybody would be eating or eating rotten food and they did not want them so therefore what do they do they say we'll make wishes on that day later this is petitions gonna be on day 31 so therefore if you're young teeth will fall out on the right day they should have what to eat on the second day never should saw me of him kippers circus here to make a Cashman let's say wish your son is Sunday right but when the suckers begin you see so this is day 15 so when this hookers begin Sunday right so when are you cutting your vegetables for suckers if you suck is Monday Sunday evening right be foolish and then you cut beautiful vegetables you have fun tonight yeah for tomorrow if you suck this on a Sunday you're cutting your vegetables on Friday if it's all yourself as you can't cut any vegetables Wednesday if your son is gonna be Wednesday so ferocious on itself is good right ah but when is it kipper gonna be make it hedge but Wednesday is Aleph yeah so Thursday is base gimel dalet cave of Zion has test you'd in Cape is Friday Travis okay so the Gemara will discuss about you kipper if the problem is in campus Friday and kipper a Sunday will soon see but you have your problem of oh so you have to think about it your Sherman if they my name could be everything about suckers okay the second issue has to do with Mason what's the concept of Mason when you have again you have no freezers amazed eyes two days he's gonna lay without being buried shabbos injunctive and this is a Brazilian for the Mason because of this they did not want the ailment item should be right before Shabbos right after Shabbos Yom Kippur is on a Friday so somebody dies on Friday morning or Thursday night they couldn't bury him whatever it is Thursday knives ready in kippered and what happens Friday he's not buried now Shabbos he can't bury him either he can't bury him Friday night you can't bury him Shabbos so then what happens to the mace is smells and it rots and it's a bizarre you for the mess so this is how Rashi catches its theory it's serious bizarre namaz okay you say my ear Octus is Mossad refrigeration and by the message simply to lay around I mean it's one aspect of it that you know they Reyes and the rally this is how it actually touches it so therefore the head taps look my I four hundred five hundred years this wasn't a problem this is how we're assuming there's no problem but you don't know what's gonna be this year maybe this year problem so therefore besten will have to make ll 31 nose rag the Gemara one second if this is the case Houma Calcutta Shoshanna they're gonna ruin Rosh Hashanah what stuff my calculations on as a crashing the nintzel are suing a gorilla collar him opera now let's say best and sees that you know what there's gonna be a problem yeah we need an extra day enamel we need everything to be a day later but you're ruining russia summer meaning what you're causing is that all the been a hog oiler all the Jews living in Gullah Gullah say means far away from the center of Sanhedrin they did the wrong Russia Sharma why because you're pushing us on a day off nobody's gonna know that you can't don't know when circuses because you send out soccer but they kind of wonder if your son is because that's the day the Rhino is not gonna be on Friday ah they know this rule they know that some day Friday and doesn't exist that's it so you're asking the question if you're living in Iraq or wherever you're living and you see Richard Shawna is among you li see that faith 30 is gonna be on a Wednesday or on a Sunday on a Friday you know they're kind of you know that bezel is gonna push it off you're smart so you know their judgment so what's the problem and if it doesn't fall out they're not gonna push it off right that's you're asking you you're asking a good question okay good good question not announced it is not a pray and not sit for issue some how am I gonna know from living in Iraq when or shoshanna's or from living in a lot say he's saying if it's based on updos so then you know you don't even have to announce you know the Frenchman okay but let's say they don't know okay let's the will go they will go to that in a moment they're ruining Rosh Hashanah cuz nobody knows what they don't know that ello had an extra day so they're relying on the majority of years that ll at 29 days and they made research done on the 30th day and now it comes out then they did not do Rosh Hashanah on the right day so the Gomorrah says motive to coal coalition obelisk Alcala Coulomb I honest you're right but it's better that Rosh Hashanah should be ruined for these people in other words not that they did the wrong thing they did the right thing even though retro actively turned out it was the wrong decision and not to ruin all the madness all the other young entire even if they will keep ll 29 days and the Yellin totem will fall out right before right after Shabbos better to say okay we're sorry don't worry God is not gonna hold you guilty you followed the rules right instead of ruining and making a problem in all the of Anchises day Konami and this is module ik in the words of the Mishnah what's the words with the katana the Mishna says this look um we're not all Tishrei mie pene kana samehada's for the fixing the corner of all the LM table this is strange says I'll listen Nippon a pestle I love monotonous a timeless ll will play Rosh Hashanah Kistler for Hanukkah are therefore put images of said ta how am i others you don't want to say you've keep it because it's more than Yom Kippur Jim Kipp ritsuka system in yet service say Allah Maya this while tacoma summarizes you don't say tikona stop asa the connoisseur tiniest OCONUS Kamaka ala maya this for the album diagram what's the corner somewhere this ah this is the Duke it's the fixed holidays tikona so much not for the Muslim inside the mode is itself they already know when Rosh Hashana is based on Ehlo and from Earth from Ezra they never made Ella more than 29 days but econo Samoyed is for the tinkin of the Maya this why because they may want to fix the holidays and therefore create here Shoshanna they later this was a problem and that's why they sent some again dissolution to tell them if Rosh Hashana was a day later there's no in yom kippur positional circuses and if not they should be calm and no they did it the right thing so Rashi says every today because there was a concern ello made me was more yeah so if Ella wasn't more burn great a filbert and the fellow was me Ober than they really got it no one to do your kid puts a day later Rashi says they Kaname become a calculation some of the Nemesis Allah our Subhan our garlic I love him a Brunello they Kaname the law hodja hodja rabona the little cow coluche are modest they were afraid that the other holidays should not be ruined VT rue she hey Richard Shannon was cool : Galya so therefore they allowed themselves to do this even though in exile were they're far away from the Sun hadron rosh hashanah becomes bruit now this big question that were asked is of the Gemara Sh'ma me nah this is good proof this is good proof that this is the Platinum Mishnah tikona Samantha's sucked Isis let's eat oysters just two types verse in here mmm I says de and by his calculus kilometers so first he says me my says my my says of a little I'm at sea no LM over maxima from here it seems to be May azor Ahai I'm over in the times of Ezra it was mu bar from Ezra and are not how does the governor notice how the draft notice he says us Marcus smart salad over there is some support for it in the Tanakh Dixit in the safer known as Ezra Mia pairings and he says ye gar ha ha - Reva going the seventh month arrives Vegeta means it arrives so like you could touch it hunger it yeah oak sieve it says there the next panic my young be Ezra Hyannis a total of now call as through the kyon brings us a photo in front of the congregation book sieve it says by a method Lahaina Shastri it was the first day of the seventh month oak savannah says by equal a boy and he read in the safer Tyra Oaks Eve Bennett says hire him conditional a sham this is the holy day fraction so we see that he read the safe at area on the seventh month the first day so it's clear that this is where it's under the seventh month the first day is Rosh Hashanah books eBay products evite it says by Yuri Marche me on the second day Ness for Russia Elvis Lala the heads of the families of the nation gathered Hokkien em alluvium vallavan and the Cuyuna mandala VML Ezard are safer or lajas kill Olivia Taylor to understand more of the words of Tyra in other words they learned and they read again at this asset owner so ty service is wondering why by Yamaha Shane Lee did they come back for Kia Sedona why they come back to learn more tighter ah mosh mosh also snail intervention is Hashanah it seems like that year by Ezra they celebrated two days with Shoshana in other words llama della was the first day Richard Shana at law was 29 days and they made the 30s dado Shoshana and then they made one more day Richard Sunna which became I love tisha huh what do you mean depends why they came Yeah right right right now so he's tithing what's by youry mache me by a machine it means the second day of Rosh Hashanah why would it be a secondary Shoshanna because ll they decided needs 31 days and therefore the sushumna has two days day 31 and day 30 days 30 became Muslim and day 31 maybe by Yamaha Shanee means Monday it was a Monday the ranch says maybe yamashina means it was a Monday and therefore Ezra made at econo Korea cetera de Monday and Thursday mystic honest Ezra so maybe it's by a machine it's a Monday stay rather save a third arm under you read a safe area so the Lance says it can't be was Monday cuz if the second day of Tishri was Monday it means the first day of Tisha was some day and we say Leia do rush they don't do Rosh Hashanah on Sunday right so therefore he says what's by Yo Ma shady baby my shiny may means Elmo was more Ober and therefore they made Rosh Hashana la Modelo and all of Tishrei anti services vacati lei Shaney why does he call it a second it was out of Tishrei so why is it a second shot is l'm Ilse che milla milla means a second to the thing to the experience of yom tov a second day of Rosh Hashanah in other words not a Monday and not based Tishrei you could say Shamy means the second day of the month or the second day of the week no it's the second day of Rosh Hashanah SIV Nami another proof for this is the UMS enviable now you can't say this is a clear proof that's what Tyson says smack sasayama doesn't say clearly this two days with your son it just says they came the second day to read the traitor again if your son was a second day suppose crease at Ida on yom tov this crease at Irina but toys which brings another tsunami it says below him as sin mob all the hoods on the 24th day of the month nests will call you strong but so mobis Akkad the Jews gathered to fast and to put on sackcloth Oh marshmallow Elisha I saw him I saw his circus nestled since it was the day after sook risk of the Letitia day they gather together too fast a day before they wouldn't fast why cuz it's Yom Tov this means when was circus over of gimel Tishrei and they fast coughed a Leticia reflect I suppose I don't understand the eel of the abreu if they did not make ello an extra day of also sue crispity suave boy so they made circus on the 15th day of Tishrei in other words el old was 29 days where's your sana began day 30 day 30 was one and day 15 was suckers can you download the art yes 14 days of the month of Tishri the first 14 days but has the circus then you have eight days of circus I read of Ben's yard 22 days how much is 15 plus 14 right 15 plus 14 so what do you have 29 days and they have Bay's yo you have 22 days huh no you have you download the Yaffe of the first 14 days of the month of Tishrei now you have eight days of circus so now what are you were you're holding your holding conveys you have 22 so when the swimming at Cyrus come out the 22nd day of Tishri right you download today's era of circus test of of Tishrei is circus of the slough design you design you trash your testicle cuff I love tough days that's the eighth day so you have gimbal is my toy circus 23rd days it's rockets that they have to suck us so why they fasting only on the 24th of Tishrei they could faster ready on day 23 the a lo my you can say the chef's cool the tiny sigh you mission receptive perhaps they abandon the fast on cuff Gitmo because it's a day after Yom Tov or mission Cosentino out of Dalit boy so therefore they wait one more day Tyler says they may our law how you know Jurgen boy then there was no concept of Israel then there was no concept of celebrating the day after Yom Tov so therefore they could faster ready uncover gimel void sorry double shivered Saburo yo this was not for a private person this was something of the Seaboard of the whole community we could faster day after Yom Tov so why couldn't they fast off gimel today I wish mama Nadi brew Allah hello this is another proof that lol was pushed British on was pushed off by a day hello at 31 days since I left 31 day so therefore it was takahagi mo from al of Tishrei but it was still if they would fast come get both Bheeshma nyet Cyrus why go because if you would count wish a Shanda from the firt if you would count from the first a so then of gimel was still young she's saying why did they call it of Dalit you're right that carved Allen was the first day after suckers from the first day of Rosh Hashanah but later why there's a cult it was a cult of Dalit Sultan's a value that it's not become valid Lajoie dish cuz but time the month it was topic of Gitmo because I love Tishrei started a day later but it means of Dalit from when they started to celebrate youngters in other words if you're including the first day of Rosh Hashanah which Islam at this rate this is going to be the 24th day that's gonna be the 24th I mean that's how you have to Titans Ya Ya Ya Ya yes so the mela the time of ezra ll was a little but that's why i have said me my surveillance then reshawna was two days but after that it wasn't Wilbur but Ali's Scout kulu kulu my unders the other holidays shouldn't get ruined Sarah she says Lomond arm Allah come on some a blemish Amir kya if you say you make an embryo a a an extra day so that the vegetables shouldn't be ruined because vegetables get ruined fastest by the way it says vegetables not fruits because vegetables get ruined much faster than fruit so they won't be able to eat the vegetables the second day because he can't guard them for two days so he says Nyssa the Shia huh cool it makes sense that it relates to all the amon tobin I will Amanda mission Messiah but if you worried about the mace that wad that it shouldn't get decomposed because you have to leave the corpse two days without burial because he can't bury in my choppers on Yom Tov kasha I have a problem toys missus that could kill kill LM earmark a portable hood day you only have a problem on Yom Kippur cuz Yom Kippur and Shabbos you know let it bury the dead what about other young I'm tired of him that I'm near Shabbos we said you could we learn to miss activate so we're gonna see lady you could bury the dead through non-jews in other words you're allowed to do it through a non Jew so if you know through an Andrew it's not a problem so the only problem in Kippur so why are you telling me Ali asked alkyl cool Umayyad this it's not an issue in all the holidays vegetables initially Shoshanna Tennessean kibbutz initial su cos it's an issue Sweeney at saris but may say is on the initiation Kippur number 1 by ie now comes your question keevon the other curious ello if everybody knows when L came out I might this calculation under wiser is something gonna get ruined uh y'all be the tits company I'll do they know that if rich Hashanah was supposed to fall out Sunday Wednesday or Friday bez Dhin will not establish wish Hashanah then and therefore it's gonna be a day later so you go ahead what do you have to send out looking for tisha what's your problem you're telling me cuz you may make LM uber and if we have to send out solution they're gonna know why are they gonna know like you said because they know according to dashi it's with the headsman of other lawyer to rush so you good forget this look at them you're good to go and as your son will never be ruined the much if your son is not some day Wednesday or Friday they're gonna know L lose 29 days a fish your son is Sunday Wednesday Friday I will is 30 days every summer starts and they laid it what's the problem this is the big question of place miss on Rashi I'm going to add one more question on Raschi the dirigible and the ron and the Ritva ass on Raschi which is why you're showing him like Isis and the others have a different shopping tomorrow and then we're gonna have to answer a what's the next question I ration the gomorrah says that me moist as river a lihue I'm at sea no LM over was never ello more personal I said what does that mean doesn't mean we know for sure is that they didn't need but if they would need to they would do it actually says why would they need to cuz there's a son it could be on a Sunday and a Wednesday and a Friday and that can't work they say one second so you're telling me that for 500 years there was never a situation where a shuttle would be Sunday Wednesday or Friday but the witnesses for 500 years oh you came perfect timing the reshawna was never on a Sunday Wednesday in a front that's ridiculous obviously it happened over 500 years you can tell me over a few years than that you can't tell me for more than 500 years Rosh Hashanah was never Sunday if Rashi is right that the reason you would have to make a little burr is why because it um is gonna be Sunday Wednesday or Friday it's gonna ruin the issue with the vegetables in the mason it certainly happened many times just like you think it's gonna happen in the future for that many times of course that to make LMO bar this is the height a huge question part of the practicalities the zoo attraction belief if it sees it's not shy that it never happened this is the kind of big question the Gomorrah doesn't mention to say why you need you'll soon see places as all different flower dad I don't have a proper the witnesses came on the right thing yeah why not the witnesses saw the moon 29 at night they came the next morning when they came that night but your honor was the neck of a beautiful and that was it it never change they don't have to do an evening show the moon they came so these are the two three questions are now she ties with this question number one Mason is only an issue yom kippur not are they mmm title that's a satin ash chattanooga more question number two you don't have a problem everybody knows if it's odd do I love dollars love push it off do it yourself you're good you have no issue Fisher Shana won't get ruined you don't need slow question number three what's the other Regina mention is how could it be that it never happens for hundreds of years dr. Cesana didn't have to be delayed based on national stature of what's on your mark sucked Isis a whole different world veneer the live Michonne I do Kumada it's the mob remember when the Gomorrah said if you need you're gonna make an uber lol it's not because it's a dolla dolla devolve elements from the zoom in the way wrong way them that's it 500 years we had Mazel there were no clouds in the skies and the night of Rosh Hashana aid them saw but you couldn't know that for the next hundreds of years the mission is written aid them I always gonna see the loved one or the night of 30 days out what happens if they don't they can make mr. Sun of the day of 30 what do they have to do then after wait a day and make wishes on a date so anyone they don't have witnesses hopefully it won't happen but he can't be sure no yeah yeah yeah but that's the work the Amick action I'd um Amidala they will not be MacArthur's till day 31 mission the Mitzvah LaCava shall be area because it's a mitzvah this when you can to sanctify the moon based on when witness to sanctify the month when witnesses saw the moon this you could never know in advance that she can announce and say hey if fresh Hashanah is gonna be Wednesday were pushing it off that's not something that you could announce but you can't announce of a this I'm not coming if atheists are coming or not coming they don't know this is a whole different issue this is what it means is gonna be a Kilcullen Maya does not kill Cole Maya does that there won't be vegetables or that the Mason will be ruined kill Cole and Maya this means it could be it was gonna be a wrong day suckers gonna be on they that's up shop this already answers the question it's gonna be a Kilcullen all the holidays yom kippur ish when the ABS Enders goodness number two nobody knows this he can't say everybody knows her son is gonna be a day later maybe not there's something gonna be on the right day but maybe it's gonna be a deal later cuz there's no way this this he can't predict nobody could predict the weather only God can predict the weather even the forecasters can't so that's the situation you're stuck that's why you have to send up I for 500 years they had Mazal wonderful but you don't know what's gonna happen tomorrow and therefore we don't know yeah yeah let's say they pushed it off because I'll do rush right but you can this is not something you know I'm an original so even if they know when L began we'll address that in a moment the gnocchi's worked let's just finished Isis well par this how this mother says huh McHale color is your son is she a solution am I miss something if you do this you're gonna ruin rich son what do we mean even a ruiner Shoshana if you're going to push off Elmo if you're gonna push your fish Hashanah by a day because witnesses don't calm and you're gonna say listen you see what do we do today today we don't have witnesses we do it based on a calendar because there's at econo of tyra that when there's no witnesses you could make the search bonus and establish recorders that way right so toaster says maybe that's what they should have done that's what the good mother is asking they should have said you know what we're making wishes on a day 30 there's no witnesses there's no witnesses why because McHale coalition was fed my calculation she assertion a.m. and Miss Suffolk outside they're gonna have to do two days out of a Suffolk because they're not gonna know so it's better not to make ello 30 days and therefore norther the first days always wish Hashanah and everybody will know when Richard Sherman is cuz they know when Ellis why is it a kill call to make two days like we do it you sing white you wanna know why I raised your son is not a - your son - macoco you'll make everything two days a microswitch on the two days why is it a kill collider at least Richard Saunders mr. Sumner and they're adding another day in case Davis came late they're adding another day not in the base of macness they know what to do they know what to do the pastures de Voort is once Castle said you should do it you should do it but what's up killer to do it I guess it would be a gather of brothel of a collar rat you're not putting on tefillin number one number two you making a brothel Ishmael call Schaefer you're making kid your brothers on kiddush all these brushes that you mean that we make the second day when really it not to be simple making these days you can't make a broad bars today by some resolution really concise they're doing good today another choice they have to blow straight for Tuesday's so toasters calls that aquel cool or Michonne EMU tough dyscalculia Shoshanna do that make two days value Scout color color modest don't ruin all the holidays yom kippur suckers mini at Sarah's in Yasuo PE Omar a double LP area if they're going to basically make young delicious son and not based on when they really saw it in other words they won't push it off a day but they'll basically do it right away on day 30 and say this is Rosh Hashanah no matter what no matter what that's very good luck they don't want the money this should be the wrong day al you Scout Kahlua it's not the right way of doing that - they should be done up here that's the canosa - pathetic honest Amaya this to fix up the - they shouldn't be on the wrong day why we call it a sommelier Marist oh so you see here stomp on interesting Hara Rashi kindness' what's the kill Cole what's the kill Clara she says you remember coma conquer that they did Risha tion of the wrong day in my a Brunel will they do with the wrong day Kaiser says that during two days because in the mission that this is Alicia tosser in the missionary she says they would do - a tion of one day and they would feel bad they went according to the majority tourists are using redaction says no they always did British on the two days so you see the same argument here Rashi says they did it one days to kill clear they're going to be doing it the wrong day if best in really made Richard Sumner day later they didn't do it and Shona place was as they did it they just added a day that was unnecessary so we say better do that appointed actually better delicious under the wrong day or court the toasters better add another day of return which is that Richard Sumner as long as the rest of the mmm type of honor preserved in the right bus was just yes Mia says oh so now we have to understand the shift of Russian and the strong questions here huh what do you want to say motives at the Scott coda Shoshana means in godless not everywhere no saint a cop one day or two this corn tadashi motifs of this calculation Shona that they're doing it on the wrong day they're doing it on base thirty will it student they they're you want or Court the faceless know that it's not on the right day the reason this without the vegetables killed collisions gonna be the wrong day I'm doing there's a Shana yeah day 30 so um kipper is gonna be a day early that's a problem I leave it that way leave it that way some Irish your son it should be preserved he says you know what that is your son will be a mistake Jim Kipp Brown suckers will be on the right day why do they need that you're right the time with some it's a bureaucracy right your typhus not that I'm worried about the vegetables we are worried about the vegetables that's the asite what do you say sheep what maybe not what you should eat you're speaking from 2017 go back 2,000 years back 2,000 years it's not partially so that's saying you take everything for granted you open your pantry you have potato chips and pretzels I mean with that you take them for granted they make everything what so I want to tell you what the Oracle mayor says the Oracle in there in his commentary here my cetera Shoshanna this is how he explains this is how he answers closest asks a big question this question is light rash the only reason you're pushing off your Shoshanna is because it fell out one Monday Wednesday or Friday so then everybody knows everybody knows when you're pushing it off so there's no problem that's why toaster says we're dealing with a whole other issue the issues that the ADA's didn't come the Oracle in air says as follows very interesting even if Rosh Hashana came out Sunday Wednesday or Friday now abus come they come at the best and they say to guys come and they say we saw the moon last night they're like oh my god you're not supposed to see the moon last night we need this to be a day later what's all of this all Bezdek could do is take its islands day this and do us a favor go get a headache go to the dentist go find somewhere else once the aid is testified the they're so to speak their hands are bound they have to make it rich I just have to make it Hashanah they can't change that the kemon dip you latent so if the ADA's saw the Levon and they came and they testified and best and heard the testimony this is what used to happen it became recession and therefore there was no Ybor ella was only 29 days and this is what happened most of the years and the been a hog oiler relied on this and they made Richard son on day 30 this is what basically happened ah the earth Lanier explains this enough so 37 says no cuz it is done is I love down with love you know for sure it's gonna be pushed off you know no fish on it's gonna be pushed off why don't you know for sure cuz if a does come and open their mouth it's not gonna be pushed off so you don't know for sure so rashly is right it could be that they're gonna get the ADA is to be quiet like Isis if it says EU my them they're gonna get them to be quiet and they'll allow res your honor to be a day later but it also could be not and then you're gonna be stuck I they didn't prefer it because the vegetables in the mason you're right we're stuck they the spoke neither spoke so therefore it's not a certain absolute thing and if we still have a suffered what's your suffolk you Suffolk is maybe yes maybe not and that's why they may be doing mr. Shonda the right day they may be doing something wrong today that's how the article in a tie just of art that's how it touches the heart so maila this answers a big problem of tightness look I love Dollard love they know automatically lawyer do right you don't know because 8 is still come and do it and therefore it's gonna happen this explains also the big question for 500 years British Shana was never on a Wednesday Thursday on a Sunday Wednesday a Friday look like a huge sideline actually he says it was but you know what happened they ate the spoke the ADA spoke and there was no album over there was no element they order a this came and spoke in that's not gonna happen may happen next year may happen in two years that's how the Oracle in a tries to answer the question of the questions of the join in on onrush I couldn't do Canada but then he says one more part which is another very interesting word the whole different Mahalo that I want to mention we'll finish with this third one a says as follows we're gonna learn later the Huff the of rabbinic enamel and some say this is the of the Rambam that when Bezdek added a day to ello it wasn't the vegetables in the dead this is the official reason when the phenomenal says there was a soy de Bourgh sorry da Eber means they had very deep mathematical astronomical and spiritual fresh bonus that they received a local emotion is seen I how the monks have to work because it's very we're gonna see soon the next sugar it gets very very complicated with the moon it's not predictable situation we have a general Mahalo but it's very very complex it's extremely complex the Gemara has an expression Shemesh yo Dom avoid we say in Berkeley Nava shemesh of the rigamarole a fluid on the water the Sun knows where it's going the moon doesn't know where it's going which of course doesn't mean literally the moon doesn't know where it's going it means when you follow the moon you see that there's a lot of confusion very very difficult to deal with the moon that's why the moon is called lunar right lunatic lunacy the moon is not normal the moon is not predictable the moon represents a little lunacy is called in the movies ah so there's a coming so everything is very nuanced you gain here day you lose here they had a soy de Bourgh they knew Richard Shona can be Wednesday or Sunday or Friday the reason that was given was a raucous and Mason which was true but that was the tip of the iceberg that was the Tommen in Nicola there was what's called a Hana calls a soy de e board the secret of a bore which they didn't tell the island because it was it was just beyond most people so therefore they said you raucous and mace so maybe I been a phenominal says this is the Vaart when - she says you ruckus and mace and rashes following the reason of the Gemara but there's a whole other dimension of why they pushed it off so therefore even if day 30 did not fall out I loved Alan involved that could still be a reason that they should push it off it could still be a reason and since they could still be a reason they should push it off and best enjoy the whoa know about it so there's gonna be a kill cool in there's gonna be a kill clinician so rashly sticks T raucous a Mason but he says there's a whole other Tasman why it happens and because the whole other judgement so therefore even if it's not the um I love doll evolve it's possible that best and should make it a day later this also answers twice vez says the reason of e raucous only applies the reason of America supplies everywhere but the reason of Europe Mason only applies on Yom Kippur not the other element either GA says again it's not stop kill kill a Maya this means because you raucous and Mason if that's the case rash she has a big problem because Mason is only a problem on Yom Kippur not a problem other ones use a guy the practice that best in used to make the Citation X today because of soy de eboard and if they wouldn't do it according to say that Ebert then all the madness would be ruined because it would be in the wrong day it has to date according to their spider has to be a day later that's the prom all the mothers are gonna be ruined since all the miners are gonna be ruined they had to send ups looking for this trade because everybody knows how it could be I post who says what I mean the mode is the Mason was not a crime only and Kippur he said that's the tip of the iceberg there was a hole deeper hole deeper problem this is the of Russia toast resolves the issue is because maybe a this didn't come they saw the lavona and therefore even if they may courage has shown on day 30 it's a problem because you want to be Mikado so Peoria and you want the arm toy room should be based on sighting of the moon not based on na yeah shot the shopping tomorrow to deal with yeah yeah so according to this when it says limousine OLM uber Cinderella move up son never fell out Sunday Wednesday and Friday the shot is that they had their husband and they worked it out that ll shouldn't have to be shouldn't have to be more about this desolate Bay's the middle over the page the line starts mom in on these two dots while kiss love me play Hanukkah while Adam and I have put it [Applause] so the Gomorrah is done with I'm not done but the Gomorrah finished discussing Evelyn Tishri this lookin went out ll to tell everybody when Rasheeda Cheryl was not because ll itself and will itself has no days that anybody has to really know but it's the end of Ella it's when when written when Rosh Hashana would be according to Rashi they were therefore no one L will began sirisha Shana would be day thirty because they assumed that Elmo had twenty nine days according to Taurus they would know when L will began so they would celebrate with her son a day 30 and with a doubt they would also celebrate day 31 in case ll by some chance had thirty days so they would also add add another another day and that was a possibility as the Gomorrah says that sometimes they never knew maybe maybe Elmo will have more than 29 days either as Rashi puts it because bez de mood make a decision that we have to delay Rosh Hashanah by a day if we can or because who knows witnesses may not show up why and therefore they have the number that's why you know without only ocean I need to have one thing because nowhere so the answer is as follows because that's is as follows so the truth I guess he's saying the big boy is your son was one day right now so here's the deal in many parts in most of our sister all they had to do with Shoshanna two days cuz this look some wouldn't get there but the reason today they do Risha tion in two days everywhere is and this is what we learned in Bates ax is because even what's called in the base have odd meaning even in the place of the sanhedrin where the action happened wherever there is no doubt over there's what happens they often celebrate it as a son or two days why because they didn't know right so we learn you know that they used to wait day 34 witnesses right okay so what happened was they used to keep 30 because they didn't know if witnesses are gonna come so they tried to treat the day likes gum two witnesses could come at 12:00 they could come at 2 they can come at 4 they come at 5 right so and if they come it's gonna be rich Hashanah retro actively you don't have any other asteroids like this you thought you can't work here you can't work it's not like and this sin or Tishrei or or other month were you waiting for other days for young so they would wait that day okay so now what happened was once the aid this came very late and it disrupted carbo department Amud and all that because once he did the carbon comment you can do any crap on us after nutritious certainly have two components Muslim so was a disaster so they were moussaka not to be macabre ladis minimun column Iowa okay but what uh-huh so therefore but cause in all those days if the ADA's would come the first day it was Takayama tough the way they decided to keep the day initially invaders woman come that day so then the second day was Yom Tov soma Tod that orphan Rosh Hashana itself was celebrated two days even in the base of that not always cause if atheists would come right away day 30 of course Rosh Hashanah was one day but very often that didn't happen some it's not that your Shoshanna became the concept of two days even in air too strong even in nourish align even in the place of the Sun had room right never no one much see no LM over right but they but they waited but that's the point so that's why the first day it's are the same in together Saints are the same in submitting over sin oh yeah so now we go to the next step could be no karma though messes things up oh yeah yeah yeah yeah while kiss let me play Sonic while other money I put it now you have this look I'm go out kiss love because of Chanukah and they go out other because of pool that seems very logical straightforward everybody has to know what to celebrate Hanukkah anybody has to know when to celebrate poor this is during the base on my condition after the base of meekness remember Chanukah was established in the middle of by is SHANY right Purim was established at the end of godless bhavo so throughout the second base on McNish and of course after that you have come a camper so you need to send out emissaries to celebrate these holidays fine saga the Gemara this is the Mishnah the alone is a bruja is a brush on Yeats in offal other Shana Mina put him like a Tony the Chimera is now struggling with a problem this should be one more month when this look and go out and that is Nyssa brasov let's say the court best in the size that we need a leap year now if they decide it should be a leap year in the previous year or in Tichenor - when Chris left Ava survived wonderful so then they establish restraint this other recién and then there's a restraint this other shaming and they send out this lookin for the right order to tell everybody who important this but what if they decided it's going to be a leap year middle of other the middle of other they realized we can't just go to missin we need another month of other as we recall the Casal the Sanhedrin would sometimes decide that you need a leap here the primary consideration was what that pay sucker should fall out in the proper season and hide the shava which means in the spring season after the equinox in other words when spring begins when the Sun reaches a certain point in its orbit around the earth basically when the Sun what we called what we learned earlier hits Mazal clef if that's not happening you have a major problem because pace occurs in the wrong season our calendar doesn't follow the Sun our calendar follows the moons as we learned you often have to add an extra four weeks an extra 30 days in order to make sure that Pesach is coming in the right season so now what happens if this decision was made when in middle of other so they already sent out slow and restrained ashore there to tell everybody with Pyramus the problem is this other is not going to be pouring next others gonna be pouring because they're adding a new month so look either the Mishnah should have said that if little the year became a leap year they had to send out Slocum a second time for the second other to tell everybody went poor it was yikes and now follow their shame in airport it since they decided to add a second other so therefore you have to send them out for Porter him and nonetheless lunch like Tommy this Domitian to did not say that people should find out when Purim is because there's a new other MS this wouldn't happen every year you could say the mission is talking about consistent things every sing this wouldn't happen every year because not every year is a leap year and even if it is a leap year if they decided to leap here earlier then it's not a problem in order to send out Slocum twice they only have to send them out further Shanee ms but the Mishnah mentions ear and the Mishna says a year is only the time when the base of ministered in other words the mission is including all possibilities even possibilities that don't exists nowadays when the mission that was written for example the month of ear certainly it should add this which exists even after the kerbin based on makers this is the heart of the Ritva why you can't just say the mission is talking about things that are every year the mission is not the misters including a very broad range of things including here whorfin often they they always rewrite in or before but sometimes not start the Sun in the moon you're right they would know but there's other issues for example the harvest is not ready they needed to harvest to be ready you understand so technically you're right plus there were things that they would use as Assad in other words as an extra support to make a leap here it was a very rainy winter and the bridges the Gemara says the bridges are broken so the Jews won't be able to cross rivers and Brooks and streams and lakes and it's mom or cyclists no flushes there's no bridges the roads are not paved it's full of mud nobody could be oily rag oh okay it's a very poor year of the sheep produce not enough sheep were born or flock born people need it for carbon pay so they need it for illustrator here for slum them all this these were all not the primary reasons but they were all used as support reasons sometimes till the middle you know the Mishnah starts of they send them out for six months here you would be sending for seven months fine but you sending out Slocum again we're not blaming them but you're sending out some will come again don't say they would have known we're talking again if they may decided that a leap year should be made the decision was made after in middle of under so they already sent up this this look left destroyed this gone bought a week later they say you know uh two weeks later they say we need a leap here or three weeks later you remember you could make a leap you throw out other till the last day you don't you you don't want to try to make it as early as possible but you could that's gonna be the discussion now that's gonna be the discussion now why our mission does not say this opportunity this alternative if they even if you would say there anyway you bet they decided even if they decided let's have inside an onerous redness but they're not get they never do a leaf here oh so that's the question and let's say they do poor immoderation that's gonna be the cool discussion now what happens if you celebrate Putin in the first other instead of the second other okay now technically what's the real problem here so you essentially come on us okay you gave some extra sucker Michigan Fairland you had a mealy hey you got a little drunk okay that may be a problem the problem is becomes pesach right you missing is the next month and really has to be two months so the harder you have to send out Slocum again so the Gemara civilians must miss in the likely ready with this reach with this tell us something which we try to avoid pretty much saying our Mishnah is basically inconsistent with the view of review adonis a why rep ease of use the tonya we have a Bryson Rebbe i'ma in the Saab Raja no Jenna follow the same with Napoli we have a Bryce Rebbe clearly stated if there was a leap year they have to go out a second time for others Shane McMahon Airport and this is a Rabi that would mean that our Mishnah which does not acknowledge this alternative disagrees with the of revealed on us know what's the big deal lame of us this intellect clear that be why is the camera baffled by that the problem is because generally the Gemara has a problem saying that a mission is inconsistent with rebel you know why right because he wrote it he wrote it Mahalo somebody said history is gonna be kind to me because I plan to write it he wrote the Mishnah so he wrote a mission to basically assam he doesn't say that mayor i'm gonna be abusin he writes a mission to stop disagreeing with him so that could be for one of two reasons one reason could be it was taken for a vault and the halacha was chosen not like your everything and this is the intellectual integrity over the tunnel you I have a different opinion but I'm writing a mission this is the hollow that's it cancel that's a possibility that that look is not like it at being happy himself wrote a Mishnah in opposition to what he himself held even though yell digital camera that's a possibility or another possibilities of the mission is not been consistent with Neffe but the Gemara has a struggle to say that the mission is to look at him I'm just explaining why the Commerce's label must listen lay out my system to like Kadapa you like it happy because he wrote he wrote the Mishnah now something immoral ami bacha Maliki perhaps the logic behind the argument is as follows mice of our the time of our Mishnah holds called mitzvah San Diegans be Shanee Nargis Venetian our time' holds all the mitzvahs that you can practice poor him of the second month you can practice also the first month in other words if you fulfill the mitzvot support him and other issue and then later there was a leap year you don't have to do poor in my second time you did poor him I you did put him another issue in our town oh that's fine if you want to do others say you do other shiny it's like becomes two possible poems you can do so you do others Shamy but if you didn't know you did other issues or some that you didn't know the leap year was created after the port after the after putting this all day you don't if that's the case what you have to send out some again you don't sell them out what's the problem people will think this is their real order they'll do put in fact I next month that's gonna be a shower one second about listen you're saying you have to stick around at your tribal you have to send out solution for this Shanee not support it for missile because basically what's gonna happen is others shame he's gonna become miss sent and what's gonna be the next month it's gonna be here they're gonna be eating comments eight days after seven days of pace that becomes a serious problem you understand let's say you don't send them out for port and fog they did put them other issue so pay sucks they're gonna celebrate other Shamy the next month they're gonna think is ear they're gonna eat comets for seven days of Pesach listen it's a chorus okay the gup-a sigh hidden for one month before they say they're gonna do two paces if this looks don't calm they know each other say me that's what I suppose if this look them don't come they know it's other Saints that's not a problem these days places that they come they came very late okay so they'll do pacer they'll do pay something what are we gonna do what are we get out there for you say so what's gonna happen they've only comments to gluten-free for another seven days what's this one the problem is to make my brush I love Phyllis smart that's the problem say the braava taller that's true they're making you sing they're making a Brussels vittala yeah that's always a problem well it's not their fault Ashley Roberts they do the best they can there's always a clown like knitting a turtle of my mafia shorris you this guy was not given to angels it was given to people people do the best of their ability after you're a Baptist they follow what they can according to their knowledge if they don't know that itself is a harsh caca that itself God knows it's any can demand things from people that's not shy it doesn't make sense so we're fine with structures that work for human beings we can't we're not angels before the internet before what's that when we became angels yeah or addict's euler that girl you mean time to be something - no we're talking after missions after the Corbin the mission is all written yeah after the work okay so so according to this so the Gemara wants to say what's the logic of the argument our panel holds all the mitzvahs that you do on Purim you could also do other issues so it's good so therefore comets for some actors but shady disposition see you don't need to look him to come out and tell me where the second destroyer shot because I don't care if they don't know when poor him dr. Rashi let's see dashi vivillon miss a brush on a la Hache an isthmus other addition you see the Eber was made after the first other cause of Matthew none of a problem but who has looked in this looked him left yoshiwo best in de Loup best in sits down and it starts being my eye and starts scrutinizing the situation we brew a lot as other deshaney are kaiser they're making a second order so the essential look at my china holds know why cause now a disposition we up to you they have Ruston to put him show us supervision they fulfill their obligation you don't have to send out solution to tell them about another put in this would be our talent what about Debbie oh my server Rabi holds Cole Mitzvah Samantha's Bechet me a nerd is British and the Mitzvah stack you have to do in the second other you can do with the first order in other words you did not fulfill put them in other Asian so therefore debbie olds you have to send out to slip him again why to tell everybody when Pyramus so this would say our mission it disagrees with rabbee rabbee will hold you have to send out Slocum and the reason the logic is if you did the mitzvah support them the first other if you fulfill the Mitzvah or not that is what the Gemara is thinking now according to this our mission would be inconsistent with Rebbe let's take a look tie service before we go further must this is the lake here at B you see the third try Swiss on New Testament base sohcahtoa is in time I look either here you can ask a question what's the shylu well the time the D down according to our time they're keeping the way now a lot Irish Amy since they're not going out for the second other hey the audition is Sabra Hashanah how are they gonna know there was a leap here lame Amy Brewer coid them other if they decided on the leap year before the asylum idea my dish will say other when the Slocum of other come out they say by the way you should just know yeah that there was a leap here arveleï me Brewer and and by the way and according to this you don't enough to send out father Shea me you don't even have to send them others Shanee because let them do put him the first other right and you should just know there's gonna be another other I believe me blue Africa but if they did he bore afterwards hey fee Rd how they gonna find out the Hama Britain are sama call other Tyson says that Allah who is that you could do Eber throughout other all the Houma pockets I'll put it and certainly before put until put it so that means what's that what's bothering ty Swiss poor him is not a problem but they're not gonna know there was a leap year that I don't know there was a leap year they're gonna get stuck with pace on the Ashley mark even this looks him you'd seen on this sin since look am I going out every year fitness and man mainly yeah be she a dearest Reuters range so she hates in them cannot sanam or Baris when Rasheeda Smithson comes and they see no Slocum King so 30 days no solution came remember they're thinking other Shana is listen right restore the Smithson Slocum was sent 30 days later there's no solutions to what happened in que nos anima banners they understand even in far far fun communities where it took 30 days where they would have to do two days Yom Tov that's the answer to a question you see even those that live many days away when they would usually do two days young turf they're not gonna make this mistake cuz I'll say why did know she looks I'm arrived to us an answer is there was a leap year it's a second other we don't need to look at them and therefore automatically what's gonna happen they'll know next month is necessary next one for placing now some of them may have done Pesach the wrong time some of them the ones yeah who would not expect the solution to come by tests above if I expect this was going to come back test of of the fact that it's looking didn't come means it's not listen if it's not listen I don't do base on but let's say I live in a place which 20 days away so I don't expect this looking to come I already did pay something but then I'll do pace us again cuz this will never arrived why just never arrived because he never came fun there say me that would be the of art Anna Rabi says not this looks have come far they're saying this is the Harmon of the Gemara that there's a real mellitus between every on a mission yes you have all these people living these smartphone places what if something happened to this live you mean it's a general question there's certain huge problems you say something can always happen but they didn't said if there was a Jew who ended up in the Congo or in or on Bora Bora I don't know if they sense listen they sense welcome to the large communities of Claudia so remember this all ended this all ended a few this all ended a few hundred years after the Corbin so you know it was a limited there was a lot you wanna know they sent him to Spain devotees are fast fired ah Rome of course Italy force new Joseph on in a boat was two weeks problem with so they would all the way round I'm een but all these places they wouldn't arrive for young tough anyway they wouldn't arrive down time you have to get to the event give me to the port and then go to that yeah doctor Gemara Lloyd not the cool man mr. Sun daggers machine ene this British yes what we did today yeah of course the reason not really you could say everybody holds are the mitzvos of Purim in the second month don't apply to the first month in other words you have to redo poor him ah if so why would our time and not say to send up salute them for put in forget pace of opponent haha be borscht Annika me Fellini the argument is a different argument the argument is about Ybor shana what do we mean abortion ah what are the number of the days of the first other issue that's the question Rashi says comma Eber sana mahashiv or sonically the time you with enterprise to combat evil Shawna's a crash like amoeba Shana you may other Asian choice Isis and Ebola Shama remember other Asian is called the Eber for the year he bore Shona because that's the month that was added so the question is how many days does the first month of other hats since it's an artificial month what do we mean an artificial month it's an added month that we usually don't do so it's not really artificial I mean we're counting it based on a new orbit of the moon it's not like it's not it's not a superimposed month not all beat ever but the question is does it have a number of days or not this is gonna be a mock like a fixed number of this what we're gonna discuss now he puts on the committee the tiny will Enterprise camera abortion how many days are there in the month which is called Eber sana the month that we add to the year so the first time it says slow zoom young this is a fixed number they always make it a month of 30 days which is a finish because a month could be 29 days not they always make it 30 days what's the savato of this even if nothing came you mean ADIS yeah yeah they make it look uphill it's gonna be 30 days it's gonna be 30 what what's this water the smarter is this goofer the Torah heaven the Shabbos are you in his commentary on it says perhaps as fun as this they wanted that best and should not have best and didn't want to have to send out solution to say when recite this other Shamy is so people should know when Purim is if everybody knew that other issue is always thirty days you'll never have a problem knowing when pyramus right why because of this look and go out other issue they tell you when other issue was established now you just count 30 days and then you start with straighteners so you know when put in this that that's what they're doing they're doing 30 days so it's not always they unique 30 days depends depends how often you add remember the discrepancy between the lunar year and the solar year is 11 days a year over two years it's 22 days right over three years it's 33 days so if you wait three years then you want 30 days if you wait two years then on the contrary you want less because then the loonie is gonna be ahead of the solar year i'm just depends on the situation okay it just depends on the situation here why can't they add 629 days the answer is that's already much more tricky to make 29 days because to make 29 days you say even that we're not relying on witnesses we're just doing our own kadesha hi - right that's a little more tricky to do 30 days is we don't accept witnesses by default it becomes 30 days to make it 29 days you're already breaking the rules which is you supposed to accept a this you need aid this you don't have a this so you're saying it so now we have no choice but then they had a choice so they decide but it's gonna be 30 days that's what tannic emotional minimally alignment Shipman Gamliel says hi - what does a hi dish mean so actually says csoka dieter huffed se llaman the Gemara assumes hi dish means 29 days watch like this means a month but if you said the first it says 30 days so Craig this means 29 days if so the town of our mission halls like kanikama and therefore he says you don't have to send up solution for the second other why because they know that the second order begins on day 31 of under issue day 30 is still other issue day 31 is olive are there shady but they're happy with holder captioning I'm lil who says other ition has perhaps 29 days if that's the case you have to send us looking for the shiny flag the Gemara you didn't answer the question my snot solution why do you say if other edition has 30 days you don't have to send up Slocombe the yogi cuz everybody knows when other Shanee begins new hi - Nami Rd hey if they know that other region has fixed 29 days they also know the mine African minute that according to the first opinion you have to send let's look I'm gonna go into the second Bay you don't have to send up solution as long as your numbers are fixed you don't need emissaries for the second other Shamy right because everybody knows when it is what's the problem what's going to be the problem amber if Papa Papa answer's no manda Omar hi dish the second opinion of shimming I'm Leo who says that other region is a high this she didn't mean didn't say huff test he said try this what he means is rots a high dish Rutter Schleicher what he means is it depends if best in wants it's going to be 29 days if Basden once it's going to be 30 days the pastas what this means is that since the new month could be 29 days and 30 days so beds then basically has two each time establishes based on one a to see the moon time that karma holds no they will always not accept the ages and let it be 30 days if sermon that will says ruts a ruts it doesn't mean by when they wake up in the morning they we want 29 ruts the needs of a disc on 29 the night did they say they saw the night after 20 I'll be 30 if aid this don't come till the night after 30 or they don't come at all it's gonna be rich right this will be a day later instead of related to being day through they'll be day 31 but the point is it's not fixed if it's not fixed so how's anybody gonna know nobody's gonna know so that be says have to send us looking for the Shamy that's the mock likeness ruts ahoy dish ruts are sliced simeon and therefore you need have solution to send that rations is my journal amanda much sliced in the internal collapse of willis let's look come on kill each other actually you don't have to send out solution for this tradition under Shanee why even though they didn't know and put them is the yadi been a hog oiler shallow oil lamar the tradition over they know that other mission has always a leap it's always a leap month in other words it's 30 days will be your and lament aloofness Kaddish so Lomond I'm afraid this nominate sorrowful idea though y'all be the lot of them cost it'll be a reflection of Scottish they know that it's always missing the day your Scottish is day 30 and serious not to hide this rubbish Lyceum Lafitte physician lady a muscle male aha sir so they have to notify everybody if uh derision was male if it was a 30-day month or was a hustler was missing meaning it was a 29 day month they have to tell everybody when it is that's the maloik is between Rabi and our mission suck dicka motivator hey w urban Lavy masoom coholic ignition or shall I now be a Schwaben LaVey testified in the name of the Kahala Kadisha the holy community of yerushalayim basically cuz i'll tell us in a few places that there was a community inertia lion called coholic edition why they called colic edition so the Gemara says in your song me in my Suchet me because there was a jew there his name was Ruby I see been hammer shulam and another Jew his name was of Shimon Bama Nasia and they would split up the day into three thirds for Toyota third forty one and a third fur and a third for work and because of that they had this special status they called them coholic a dish of your salon so i be insurable AV testified from them i'll Schnee adam sanic action by simbiani boolean that both others you make recite this on the day of the Ybor meaning on day 30 which is the day that would have become the ii birthday that would have been the extra day in other words if they wouldn't make it restrain us that day would be added to the previous day that's called a yogi beret and the day of pregnancy meaning the day that you would add to the previous month so the Michelin lady says both others they would be makanda SH they would sanctify us like this on that day in other words day 30 of other Asian was always a strike this under Shaney day 30 of other che me was always restrain dismissed so both others are always 29 days to be sure believe he says Rashi says Makati nice nvme beret and young slurs and carry you in Ybor day 30 is called the day of literally Eber impregnation pregnancy so are you saying recent Ebola hiding some abre nicer because that's the day that is added to the month when you are my I bury the month when you make a larger month some macaques enjoy insulation so snail Illustrated some business to be sure ballet be testified that it's the day 30 that becomes the new let's write this for both months young la middle of that initiative shredders under Shane me the I'm Lama tell other are senators reddish this that's the finish before we learn too much like us about other mission doesn't have 30 days or is it dependent sober Navy says both others are fixed both have 29 days so I'm gonna chimera Lamia in other words what he's saying is that has Satan of dinner Malayan way of dinner basically best and strived always to make sure that the two others are always huh same they're always missing there 29 days they're not 30 days that's his point and this is not a question rash she says been the host the camera is saying this as a statement a relaxed statement the name did not remain Bria how could you say no memory this is what he's trying to say why is that so significant lapu Kimmy the doneness of nothing Bethesda this excludes this negates what they're banana the some of his Detroit what did he teach hey you dips in more he gave another anus he said nobody seemed I testified mr. Massad guys sorry Oh Malathi in the name of three personalities that you can't dismiss easily this is hi guys sorry Emma laughing in other words rip see Molly says that he heard from his rebus in the name of cognizant area Milwaukee this doesn't mean he himself heard from them because it was impossible for him to hear it them that acharya malarkey are considered the last prophets of the jewish people they are the ones who come up from Babylonia and in the era when they're rebuilding the second base time because they make the second Aliyah and they are the new via Macarena magnets come 11 Tanakh ends ends with the prophecies in the books of sod right sorry I'm alive so they're like the last of em the last navi and Tanaka's Malaki the last one what did they say they said I'll stay out daughter my both our darling shame ruts allah saysö say in Malay in Iceland you want to make them both full 30 days to do that Sneha sayin both missing Iceland and cook my way back across them I said the first 30 the second 29 is good the car car you know again begala and he says if not even said this was the mimic in exile this was the mega mega what do we mean the mimic in exile when Jews lived are been a phenominal says Jews living in Babylonian pumpa DISA and they had to do Ybor Hashanah over there because basically he bore a son always has to be done an artist wrong but the losses the gomorrah says and brothers that if you have a Thomas Holcomb shalini akamai severity strong you have atomic off from living in Babylonia and there's no parallel terminate Cicero he could make it a Shahi dish and eBrush uneven it looks like which is it usually it has to be done next as well but seeing takes a certain advisor Mira shall I but if there's nobody like him and exit strong and of course he got smithy schmoopy ish and he's living in bubbly can do it so there was a time that in goalless they decided he brought Shonda and he said that's what they used to do the car you know even burger ela what did they do but gorillas they would do exactly this thing that this tradition of haggis higher Malacca soca beat both 30 both 29 or 130 in the second 29 Mission Bay no Amuro but in the name of rev it was said Rav alum he was called Rubino in Volvo rattler olam acid male vehicle Casa usually best and always did always did the first one for 30 days and the second one 29 days when we say low oil omit doesn't mean always it means usually actually if other little critters ready to piss man unless you find out the Slocum that actually they may dress traders are their Shanee in its time what do we mean in its time it's time with me that the first month was 29 days and they did it the first opportunity it's time means if a test came that becomes the time so that would be biz mana so this is a third so we have the to be sure but maybe that what both others were always thirty they always kept them 30 in other words they would delay the aid this if they ate this came they want to take a this they wanted it should be 30 days both others they wanted more days the second is the name of haggis hiya malarkey all options were available all options both 30 both 29 130 129 the name of Ravi says first 30 29 but it wasn't oil until you know was otherwise in other words this is the system they would like they would prefer but if it didn't happen it didn't happen if a this thing they could make it also 29 Rashi says machine grab a new Ralph so hook we're shredders miss mom I actually am real aha boy emeritus all keeps you best illustrators are the Shana be my maid latte tradition but also s hurry shine cluster okay this is all the different shifts about the two others based on the Maha locus it all started my focus and our mission if you have to send out for other shaming but our time obviously believes that it was a fixed amount at least the first other was a fixed amount he's not talked about the second out there and therefore you had to see you don't have to send out solution for or their shame me because we know how many days right well usually if it wasn't a knee be saying if it was an every year what do you need miss right but if it was an if wasn't an abrir and of course you need something a motivator soul who Laila Marrickville they sent the message the Benelli she was sent a message to my truck over my Rockville lived in bother he was a peasant he was the head of a best in in Babylonia order has some muslin listen loyal all costs a whole move art under that comes before Nissen is always 29 days no difference if it's a leap here laughs now is a problem is no difference a leap here or a regular year are there before mister they always made 29 days even looking Duncan what are you slowly meet a this a this yes you mean if a this don't come that's really saying whatever they always made it they always made it in other words they always wanted it should be 29 days always other anatomical listen Larry long costs the Gemara is going to reject us the Gemara is going to reject us because typhus asks a very big question your question if my rule is if the Bnei Akiva right we have a problem why they send instruction furnace sir you have to say they're sending looking furnace in because nobody knows when your tradition is sin is but everybody doesn't know you know that once you know when other began because they sent out right so you ready know what missin began because others 29 days what do you have to send that philosopher missin and why do people have to make pace out two days everybody knows what does they hear about the solution of other by the time basis came they knew when other was they figured it out that's a big question so theis vicentico Marius anyway gonna reject this whole Linwood because the commands men to reject this anyway we're not even getting into this question because in reality this wasn't the case it could be twenty nine days are calendar that's a killer case I believe in our calendar that stack of a case or there is loyal on Carson but but Twitter today this is not a game because we don't have kids traditional Peoria but here the camera is going to reject this limits of mail it's not a question why they didn't send out some famous this is the last place for some pictures without Amos even if they say this great if this Aid is great usually do aid this usually the wages even if there's no way this they can be commanded us just like we're Commissioner now there's no ages fast enough detective mccartey stress conditions it's not the claim in other words just two ways of making their furnish the initial way is aegis that's that that's the ideal perfect way but this alternative number two alternative number two is medicine has the class to Macalester stylish even with Vedas you need best there but I mean business but how do we have why first registered a holy hello was cave a yet even though there's no way this coming cuz he was conveying it now we're not gonna corrupt best and then there's not a bathroom tour my business completely loyal to Tara and I want to know what that what what does what Toyota wants what Hashem wants of course it's not stahma piston wakes up in the morning we're making restraint Achanta Zionists and is not very it has to be with her best week I could do we in our count that we talk it when there's an e BRE I believe we do other ish in 30 days and we do other so listen 29 days and the reason we do this ourselves we have to do it in the reason we do 30 days is like you said because you want to leap here you try to for us it's not negated schlong shouldn't go out again there's no Slocum you try to add another day because you want the whole point is you want extra days so we do our first other we do our first order 30 days now something tomorrow other before Nissen the day I achieve a time that is always 29 days Mesa blah blah Reb madman asks a question we're soon gonna have a mission about half a loaf of snake Hadassah makaula Nasser Shabbos there are two months when witnesses who saw the moon are allowed to desecrate Shabbos to come to your shall I am and say they saw the moon usually they can't be Muhammad Sawa's what's the tool Shabbos of coming to your shall I am of course to Chiapas I'm living far away in exile I can't walk a certain amount on Shabbos more than the total more than 2,000 amis nonetheless there were two months if I'm an eighth and I saw the moon I can go shop this morning and walk more than 2,000 amis even though it's at the home Shabbos outside of the city there's no area of common in order to come to best it there's gonna be a mellitus as usual basically we're gonna see later therefore follow miss Abdeen tahra you're allowed to be Mahalo for all the months as we're gonna learn but the command only allowed it on these two months in practicality because the DMM tie them which two months missin and Tishri why because the album totem depend on them so they felt let's say Kistler okay so the eight is don't come okay so they don't come so they're straight this will be a day later and they felt that Pesach and Tishrei pay such Nissen and tisha because they are meant even as you want them to be so to speak as accurate as possible so therefore they allowed to aid this to come I'll listen Val Tish this is what we're going to learn some Rashi says makaula Nessa shoppers a diem shadow is olive honorable tradition Macallan as a Shabbos Lutz's hood slit home love with a basil olive man why the fish are mired in cool including business additional on the oven - depend on these what does he mean all the oven - because she was - because Luis depends on pace the csoka die Tallulah - ah Ramona mushroom de creus the article of Frida here some LaVonda who in Moline Moline kousaka's Nachman things why does the Toyota allow pillow shoppers because the only way to establish your heritage is by seeing the moon if you saw the moon after 29 it's 39 days have you seen the moon after 30 it's 30 days that's what we thought so now the binocular is asking a major question you're telling me that other before listen is always 29 days they have a big problem hey I'm if you tell me lamer zoom in Molly's impulsive sometimes are there is 29 saunas are there is 30 and you need a this mission lucky McHale Alina now I understand why you tell ages come Bhima howl Shabbos for your aid this because without you be Mikado Shabbos I got no rich letters and I want to ever enjoy this because I want an accurate place I wanted to be really basic I want to smoke sweet as well Emma's the tightest says whenever we make restraint this is gonna be restrain us what we want paste there should be a real place and I need you so be MacDowell shoppers and get it the Phillips opposite has an objective it's all totally in your anus if they saw this moon on day 30 and they don't come to say hey this what's gonna happen Baz then we'll be stuck and they won't be Makar digital signage that day only the next day and other will have 30 days instead of 29 years la omlette but if the player yeshiva right cuff from without flaw LM crosser it's anyway always 29 days I my masala Lina well you have to be Mahalo shop is for I don't understand you let's say one second let's say they don't come you say he'll shop is they don't come you telling me that what it's Milan concert what does whatever me Loyola means I don't care if you cover you don't come so what do you need killer shop so there's no sabes fine why not this market of this little shop is YB Mathis in the shoppers Rashi says le I'm a clothing closet Minami Liars away them Mike action Lane so without a this anyway doing it so lemma let Mahalo you don't need social shopping and for the Gemara it's not a question if Maximus question is not a refutation you right from the Mitzvah Licata salary the initial Mitzvah is to sanctify the new month based on the vision based on the ear based on the vision of witnesses of Suleiman actually said I worry I'll be a deceive is never a good question NIC save deposit says and boy ah hi there shall ma femme rose Photoshop it's a small ration but it's not such a small Raschi the puzzles are high - as a low hemorrhage traditional example hot Sun so we have a problem here the problem here is the pasta cos redundant first it says this month is the head of all the months and then you say the first of all the months thank you ahead and the first is the same thing so now she touches these two parts of the pasta the second part of the pasta tells you that listen is the first month the first part of the posix says something else how are you - how's their fight this is not the like this is the new moon I hide this as there you see this new moon look at red reduction when you see this new moon house there you may Crusaders Khazaria a look at this type of moonwick ah - I shall show them this moon what it looks like after the birth after the moment the Kaddish make a new month in other words that's the ideal mitzvah to look and make it a shock I just could besten do it without it based on astronomical calculations they could but midsummer got stopped in India and for that it's worth little Shabbos I understand tissue they said they wanted to make sure there's an extra showers they wanted extra flexibility the type in the dates you don't have Kippur on Shabbos let's say you know back to that but what's the difference instead of meeting if you're gonna say miss and it's like any other month what's the difference in listen who cares who cares what they work when they stop for the earlier day later what's the difference based on the well that was his question his question is yeah what was your question what why only in this identity of McCallum to understand no why not why not other months to understand this race because the mq / you want to make sure that chavez you want that actually for Shabbos and young to shouldn't be together in other words the way I see it seems is that because it's that it's it's not stammers hi - as a Rashida Sh it's negated to pay son they wanted to be as accurate as possible with astronomically astronomically if you could see the new moon it's a stylish that's what your strategist so I if you see the new moon of this pillow shoppers they want to move it around sometimes just moving around anyway no wasn't us that's his point that Nissen they wanted to be very mock but that was this point the McCallum shall be a super that you probably ought to be more much better right she says in the Senate District five million kippur they're gonna move it around based on Shabbos we're just gonna defend refute this rate it's not it's not to be monitored on the day so it's move mister shadows absolutely yeah what will soon see two reasons generally when you say they move it around it doesn't move it's like musical chairs they never wanted to work right for the benefit of the committee but what they would do they were doing in a wise way meaning they would make sure right yeah they would start months nine months before but if you know if you don't have the dates for the guys to show up so you're right you need that 29 in your arsenal you don't have the 29 yards to know you could lose your they don't show up they don't show up but the point is then you would start months before Neos every month you ever do the absentee potentially right you have a two day option but you could delay with the ADA's sometimes well you can investigate them so much that they don't know what hit them they'll say you know we didn't see anything you're right so you can always get the 30 day right put in order that's what I want a nine day but this is the word that they want accuracy because it's young to Thomas okay so that's the wrong day so on the day after the my little breakfast so all happen so testify families is really off okay but paste ahead I want it to be over I don't want any come to the right the right but we're talking about those who are doing it you're right me and you were good we're not responsible but those who are responsible they want to do it in the most perfect way not that if not it's forbidden God says I give you the authority as long as you're following you know the rules of toilet but when you're that when you're in charge of the project you want it to be accurate with the strong-armed angels that's the part that's what it's a distraction because of this faith of Yom Tov and yup TIFF is a serious thing mr. Malacca wholly sir comments whatever it is could be of security of joy for a fee of the fastest a gesture no it's all my best in themselves well you could see every month time at the mullet the moment that the the moon should be accurate okay so let's just finish this thing ah you asking a good question if myths will the car disappear right admits for the car disappear yeah no no so what's your shylu ah she said you throw sorry every month but suppose it's mix for the cat dissipate in other words we're saying that are there may be 29 days anyway but we want to have a discuss the midst of us all Mahalo summers so every month we Mahalo shops that's a good question great question so it's interesting did it why asked this question he says the Gemara has a better question and thus far Samus says that that's the next question even though it's written in different ways he says that's the next question you'll see in a moment this is the next question you'll see cuz goomer's gonna ask a major question and and and and and reject us versus for them iike Dominic some say this version the way the Brockman rejected was a little different I'm Arab not coming of national instead of asking he proved a phenomena meet Elena we learned in the Mishnah I'll say the best masala NASA Shabbos this imitation is so if knock him in the same yeah I'm with will a mother who cluster if they were right it's always 29 days are there some boxes McCullough Linda I know why this pillow shop is why the Mitzvah Licata shall be early right away assumes it because it's a mitzvah to do it with witnesses so therefore you have 29 days and you have a this and you want them to be masala shoppers cuz you want 29 days to do it the right way even though if they don't come you're gonna do it anyway Ellie Amundsen Melissa and Custer but if you say that sometimes that could be 2930 so then I might masala linen so then why do you have to be Michael Shabbos what's the big deal knob Rhea Edna let them do other 30 days and the catcher you'll make this right this tomorrow at 2:00 Schuyler in other words it's not motorist it should be 29 if it's I'm going to be trying to go be 30 okay so what do you mean killer shoppers for what do you need to do Hillel Shabbos for it it's gonna work anyway it's gonna work anyway sock the Gemara EDA I'm slow samba Shabbos - Ammi if day 30 is on Shabbos that's gonna work not a problem why is it gonna work don't be Michael Shabbos let them come tomorrow house of Amaya skin on but the mission is talking about the equally I'm slash of asset Michaan's 31 is on Shabbos and that's when they see the moon so bez 'don has to be my cottage the fighters that day because he can have a her dish more than 30 days and mitzvah the Kaddish al hurriya and it's a mitzvah to have witnesses so therefore they wanted them to be my columbus cuz now you don't have a choice anymore you can say I'll let them come tomorrow no they can't come tomorrow they may come today I forget just do it but it's a mitzvah to do it with a this huh so now comes the question now comes the question this you should say for every month so now come the last question which is going to refute the statement they sent to my recover that's if they had bad witnesses yeah it's not not if they can have witnesses great cloudy exactly what is what he gonna do he not gonna have a straightish you're gonna wait and then the strength can only be one of two days 30 or 31 there's no other option you're not making recite this to 16th of the month the head of the mug right right regular Mesa Ripken yep and I said I have one problem one problem what's the problem we said the Mishna says that you could be makalah shabbos for two months but the Mishnah adds shemitish Khayyam when there was a base on mukesh Macallan I felt cool on they could be McConnell service for all you know one liter connoisseur carbon because here they wanted every month to be accurate you know why cuz I have to bring a carbon under so dish I'm covering most of today we don't have this so it's the wrong day okay it's the wrong day but then they have to bring the carbon so they tried to be accurate Nate a connoisseur cart what do we see from here midday coulis lab mission the Metallica the salinity and so what's the hectare to be much followed by the other months not because MIT's Willa Cather so Peoria the reason is why the connoisseur carbon in this imitation army lab which is the material Catalonia if so missin and Titian is also not for that because if that was the reason so then even after Corbin our buyers you should be it matter by all months you see this is the question you're asking from the fact that it says this man base some mix it was all months will take a connoisseur carbon and after the base I McNish it's only missing and Tishrei so that obviously the reason is not because miss Willa Cather superior because then it would apply to all the markets even after carbon our bias is the higher the reason is not that the reason is because listenin Tishrei is because it's the time of young employ them and that's why they want a this for the moon because they need the aiders for the moon so yarmulke Schlemmer xinlin molly was in a commercial Massimo : if are there could be 29 and 30 I understand why you allow Hillel Shabbos because without that you can't be Mikado's no side dish miss mana la I'm little oil imposter but if you say it could always beats always when I got mine I shall in know why you allowing a little Shabbos your anyway going to do it on day 29 and you can tell me that what Mitzvah the car disappear here why because then every month should work not only these two months something Amara to you this rejects it's a refutation of this that other there's always 29 days it could be 29 days it could be 30 days and therefore you want aid this to be Mikado Shabbos why because you want them to come and test the fly so you should have the yom tov on time because if they just see it and you don't let them be mcconnell Shabbos they're gonna be delayed by a day and even though it's still gonna be restrain this but it's not the ideal way of doing it at this applies only to dinner and listen when the time of the basis of meekness would apply to every every single months and therefore they rejected this idea even though as I said our meaning is that the other before listen is always 29 days because we fill up the first order and not the second Monday the Youth Day is what they sent them are who cover the other before Nissen is always 29 days there's no such consistency which of course explains why this slows him in the month of Nisan because you don't know Wenders tradition asana not yeah because that's Nagoya forest Reuters - Hillel Shabbos is for the Avis not for the small because the civil service is - no Endres her dishes - look no master no but the main thing is that this really - was established in Jewish life and the people around there will know and this looking will be there for most of our places and just some of what other saw shoppers know walking work telegrams were invented in the 1800s huh and the 1800 but then they would most look him anyway then there was a calendar half of Jewish history literally destroyed this was established based on the moon based on witnesses and half of Jewish history based on the calendar who gave a about it remember ashes boy this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot a yeshiva net / donate