Gemarah Rosh Hashanah 18b-19b

the yeshiva dotnet good customer base right we're in the middle of the page it to my right okay you try some with Bayes around what is it 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 for the 16 lines from the bottom the line starts let's say there peroneus admire the Gemara concluded the discussion why the Mishnah would not count Tavis and Thomas has months when the Schlieffen went out the reason this wasn't the time when the mission was written it was a time when there was no serious amethyst there were no terrible decrees of the Empire in fact Oh Beulah Donna see the editor of the mission himself was on very good terms he was one of the best friends of Antoninus the Roman leader the Roman Emperor it wasn't a time of Shalom the Jews of course were in exile they were under Roman rule but and there was no base on mikdash but it was not kind of Zaire some hollows and therefore yeah yeah right right a millennium it's my own bleep Oscar yeah so Raph so so that time some faster than something in fast it was a choice that different communities behaved in different ways and therefore destined didn't feel compelled to sell much land for those two months where tisha both because of the stringency of the day and the seriousness of the day everybody accepted on themselves too fast even though that was also voluntary because the PASOK enumerates all of them and puts them into one category so fetish above a sense looking because people accepted the tightness and once people accepted the tightness they had to fast and they sensual now the Gomorrah continues a new question and an interesting question which has to do with a piece of Jewish history and it's going to be connected to the sukham deposited sorry that we discussed above it Tamar we learned the following a debate Robert of cannon-armed read avoirdupois Nina said bottle of McGillis thymus once the second mr. MacLeish was destroyed the book known as McGillis thymus to scroll the fasts is gone it's bottle meaning it's not relevant maybe I should have it available Navy Omri no beer should have be sure but maybe disagree they said my bottle McGillis timeless what is the meaning of this in the time of the ten million approximately a hundred years before the destruction of the second base emitters a pamphlet was written who was called McGillis thymus it was written by a man named Khan Anya benefice kiya who was the time of the Tamilian before the a century before the destruction of the base of Mukesh Kaname the son of this Kia and Magilla Steines is an interesting book that we have today it includes 35 dates of celebration that most of us don't know anything about it goes to the calendar and discuss is 35 extraordinary some miraculous but all of them very beautiful amazing thrilling events that help the Jewish people throughout the time of the base of McNish and as a result of that haha mom said you now let a fast and these days they would celebrate the days how would they celebrate them you weren't a lot of fast on these days in some situations you wouldn't even know how to have a hospital eulogy on these days this was a day of cherishing and celebrating the day's part of it it's kind of one of it is Hanukkah one of its poorab sure when in McGillis time yeah I mean it was doing by a shady so the whole governing was about that if it wasn't our governing but you know with the car Bonus with everything we had we have we go Stern this year huh no it's not lost buckle doesn't mean lost we have it buckle me it's not relevant anymore so now the questions are just still applied today I mean this was a very serious Takano puzzle that they already made the middle of my is Shanee with a safe they're called McGillis timeless it's called McGillis tine is y is equal to Magilla stylus at the end they also have a list of fast day so they named by the end even though most of it is LM Tizen it's called the Megillah Rashi says elsewhere because remember McGillis timeless is very significant because of another reason I think it's the first he bore of terrible path at that time the rule applied still that volumes of XIV after I saw Elizabeth and we varnish about Petra negative it was a real real rule perishable Peck could not be written I mean people could take notes from shear and they said act but as a as a Hitler as a book you weren't allowed to write on tears about path later debuted our Nazi do to save tears about path he he decided that we have to write a taste losses for sure my favorite area so Lucas at Valhalla terrible pair remained had to remain an oral tradition transmitted of rabbit is to diversion attention because I've written McGillis thymus was the first thing that was written down in order to preserve it and that's why it's called Magilla that's why they called it McGill there was a unique thing that they wrote it down in history books it's nothing Nova Scotia myself time marks the story should work so Google Stannis that's terrific Sam of course that was written down what's the question this was not terrible yeah of course of course we bottle formula sister needs both money's my revenue yeah bro but it's still terrific sound yeah but that's terrific son so now the question is so for example of just give an example that will say McGillis time is that from rich rightousness until 8 missin the last missin was especially aunt of why cuz it's Duke him had a huge debate with haha thats took him felt that every week somebody else should vanish and voluntary should contribute the carbon tonic in the morning one week you brought it another when he brought it other we keep trolling you brought the Sheep the Hubble said you now let it do that it has to be brought from cloudy Cyril you can't bring the donation the carbon Hamid and that's why you had to have the mattress a shekel whatever was a big debate they defeated them in the debate and they made it a young tooth there were different miracles that happened different events that happened this Gator was all of this gazania was of this thing was this community was saved throughout the year so Megillah Steines records these 35 holidays the question is the base image was destroyed is it still relevant it comes today one of these days am i light of fast I might let it do a husband Robert of caninus said Buckland McGillis tightness it's not relevant anymore reputation emission was said Lloyd Butler McGillis thymus the obligation still exist so the Gemara now explains the views an average of honey nominee bottle Mandela Stein is navigable come in a whole bottle McGillis time is let's see that she was a megillah' Stein is where she says young boy from Chicago Akamai they miss him she do behave Austin Burton is V ash named after husband the cost from the Megillah Arcas Alain Jeremiah delay listen Abu hooli acts of jihad of abayas both loom autonomous with the protagonist so it actually defines what McGillis tightness is the holidays at the hub I'm established as a result of the miracles that occurred and they prohibited these days too fast and some of them even to make a eulogy and they wrote it down in one scroll now that it base Emily churches destroyed these holidays are irrelevant meaning I'm a lot of fast on all these days why hockey calm are this is what they said let's go back to the pasta cups car you pay to guests side motivates i'ma come here she'd say much we'd say my serie ela BC hood Alice Arsenal Asim column Adam Titan the MS Vaisala ma Haven what did the Gemara explain how a comma what is the meaning of the plastic the meaning of the puzzle is in a fast day or is it a happy day so the Gemara explain your pop explain miss Mancha a shallow ulis Arsenal is similar ain't southern soil Baja nationally key honey we learnt when there is peace when the Gentiles don't dominate the Jewish world and the base--emitter is standing that's called the assalam then Sasha no simcha then all these days whether it's Tish above or a Sarah but a vision of us at the time wasn't something that I have to be days of festivity what do you mean have to be days of festivity what do you do you know a lot of fast you're not gonna make a hasp it ain't Shalom uh there's no Charlotte meaning the Jewish people don't have independence and the base--emitter is destroyed now sorry it's a fast day or as the Gomorrah said before that itself there were two divisions if there was also a race as a time of fast if there's no shoulder but there's no exact Asst then you could choose what you want no Hana tsunami these holidays are McGillis titushki I have exactly the same status remember these four fast days from the time of the second base of McNish was a sign and similar and by Adam Thielen right in his mantra yes Shalom it's us innocent Oh madam toilet certainly when the Jews ruled and were independent so he says it's like Megillah Steines with there are other days of Simkin why didn't I know has been no time is the transformation driven a political this hopper for social and Ira so now McGillis kindness is the same status you were celebrating him by you say me I understand now ain't solid is affirmation what happens to all these young men tourism just like the four days went back to faz days or at least notes not celibate not celebration days here too in the mana buyers they would de simcha now after the sorghum bottom Achilles palace I'm not telling you the fast on these days when I think the fast in these days but we're just saying if you want a fast you could fast that's not a day of Yom Tov that's the of Robert of Canada they're using this posit as a model for Manila stylist maybe I should have been a showman lady I mean label Megillah Steines know why he says you can't compare honey who would eat only nourishment of opinion based on Ignis the four fasts and the four days of scimitar it's clearly that it connected it to the building of the base I'm English why were these four fasts established because of events surrounding the destruction of the first place of McNish I'm sorry but Avis this city was sieged this seeds my neighborhood Madsen she was a baton was the walls were breached Tish above the head a summit this was burned down Sangha Dahlia Gedaliah been a freaking was murdered and the Gemara said before that this assumption that they can is kiss Rafe ass vase la que no in other words you know was an extension of urban based on English so now I understand when the second Mesa make this gets rebuilt you say Sasa no Simba Shalimar them to him the walls are not breached with some extensions not burned down was rebuilt so comes back to Sutton and soon now that makes I mean it gets destroyed again you back the inmates I'm in other words the whole institution of these four is totally in the Binyam Mohammed leche so therefore the sussan and the sims exist as long as it'll be based on McNish so now when the base--emitter SH was tacked to destroy the first place I make this so what the first place of me this was destroyed they were enacted when the second base I mean this was rebuilt they would transform the holidays when the second millimeters was destroyed they call back the fastest a vahana but these holidays in Manila Steiners can decay me Kai me they exist as they existed they're not depending on the Bingham is some big fish and therefore eliminated with her Mesa McNish Rashi says eight solemn so in Varig of them is mana by his korean-american TV this is the of revenue economy we see that youngin typhoon could become fast days after the urban Siham economy the McGillis time is key Hani Marshall in Oulu we compare them to the fast days okay for the honey but Lee honey Nami motley these become irrelevant these become irrelevant they say to be a hilarious show you can't compare the four fastest old in opinion they they have a horrible hook of all that sucks what made them a fast day was the urban by they have Binion hook volume test what made them a young tourists opinion the construction of the second base emitters section evening buyers Shanee when the second base emitter was built salsa by a hog oiler the Jews living in exile in Babylonia sent the message to your shall I am and the question was an F ker beside the shack amis akka machine he knows Akash RCC's economy i'ma Harbin should I still continue to cry in the fifth month and separate from from pleasures on this day like I did many years from the day of the urban they want to know that you continue celebrate morning on Tisha both commissioned a Martian like it says then sky Ashima could his we're cooking something was fight become issue every possession Shana the guy Meramec on the hailer heel assassin Ellison column Adam it's clear that's when there'd be a bit we submit this was rebuilt they're like should we continue morning so he says how now it should heal assassin alyssum hello madam Tizen so it all revolves around the base some because got it but the holidays in McGillis time is don't revolve around the way some English they were different you may assure that the Jewish people experienced evolve the Cadiz that existed by the base I'm a that even this is destroyed they're still great days that happen they're not about the urban versus the Binion so therefore they have a different to Magilla Stein is still applause that's a great question the Gomorrah there's no mention of tiny sister anywhere no no we're not a mention of tiny sister and Gomorrah it's not one of the first things one of the first days of that we talk about and certainly not Antonov and not anyway and good morning on over mention of finest s to nowhere nah the Titus is a week yeah but it is a very big debate how did it start when did it start and why did it start and who started it how when why and who it's not so clear all the other Tiny's it's clear exactly when it started how it started why it started who started it when it stopped me you know um Kippur we noticed your mother man I'll create about kuberan of Shem and have a debate about us are potatoes but generally it's clear very ramsay time assess that it's a complicated fat so complicated in terms of origin but it's not mentioned here that would be so much nemesis very much named us it's not part of the possib the story of Pullum happened but the story of Pullum is not the story of tynus Esther so you put him as a story or quarter that's mention him again stylist put him as a McGillis time in stock for what which look yeah Mesa flip con would have come asked a question on whom are now forever canina my said is a story because retainers Veronica balut it was the holiday of Hanukkah and Lord they decreed a fast day with some crisis some challenge and they made a tightness in loot fiora wle a server office on the first day of Hanukkah it really as it publicly displayed the fact that he's not acknowledging this fasting generally when there's a fast day so publicly you don't engage in entertaining pursuits the bellezza went down and he bathed publicly on Hanukkah and of young schewe and abused schewe went to sip and he took a haircut both of them wanted to publicly make a statement that they're not acknowledging the kindness because generally a time is Sid were a serious time is super that the whole super effects in themselves would accepts upon themselves we're not talking about a tiny sauce it hmm this was Chanukah generally with her - yeah so you don't do these things but they did it for um rule ahem they told the people of the city of wood su v--'s and washes and listen you should make a fast for the fact that you fast it that's what you should make a fast you should make a fast for the fact that you fast it in other words you have to do two before your fasting you should fast for that why because you now let a fast on tight on a hammock what do we see from here the blessing of Yeshua lived after the destruction of the second base of McNish Tomica is one of the UM anti them in McGillis thymus because of a special event that happened during by Shamy it happens to me the most famous event recorded am achilles thymus that importantly but it's one of the events of Magilla stylist after the base of Mukesh people are fasting and they're blessed official protests they say you have to do truly for that clearly like Buckland McGillis tightness this is a great contradiction to the ravenous I mean who say but now she says you're a durability hazard fidelia's it'll be sure after urban high bias haven't maybe they lived in the second place this time instead of a salmon dish so no they be made of Eurasian a Ben Zakai album Halawa bias we know that in the days of their ever regulation immense re that's when the second missile makers was destroyed the reaction of exacta was the leader of the Sanhedrin of the Jewish Supreme Court during the horbet the camara machetes gittin has a whole story I we negotiated with a specialist with his the space here about different things in he get out of the spear you have another hakama and a doctor for episodic and the dynasty of rim Gamliel tribulation of exactly was the man who saw the Horde man he is really responsible probably almost single-handedly for the transition of Yiddish guidance from three-horn by ascended to post course any he created a structure of halacha that would commemorate the base of McNish without a physical based on McNish and ability for the muzaka has two students in the lesson to be a schewe so they obviously live after the urban and they are protesting a fast on comic a meaning McGillis tightness was not bottle after the Corbett you can't say this was a middle of or at the end of the second base summit I'm gonna be a sift abusive said this is not a question and why is it not a question shiny sonic don't compete Konica to the rest of Magilla Steiners shiny Chanukah the iike Mitzvah Hanukkah is not just the day that they made you should have fast vomit chemicals all made a mitzvah you have to like Hanukkah candles now like all the other days of making this time is that our days where you don't fast you don't make a husband that is bottle after the Mesa make this was court was Horace panic is different the Eco Mitzvah hammock has a midst of a block of Hanukkah what you think amid surviving Kamaka candles so therefore that Mitzvah the ha common didn't want to obliterate after her Mesa maybe they made a mitzvah it's not just you don't fast on the days after the me submitter she'll fast they would have to now beam of a through limits of live in Hamilton candles that they didn't do they because I'll kept up that Mitzvah but although all the holidays Ravin upcoming and maybe right maybe it's bottle at least there's no refutation from comic I'm alia by a by Intel's abusive one second I don't understand your answer if you hold that bottle McGillis time is so then so there's a mitzvah that they bottle even the bottom it's awesome if the holiday of Hanukkah gets bottle just like the other days of McGillis thymus you say the holiday the festivity the symbol of the days bottle after the herd miss emitters so hammock is one of those holidays with tea but early but made of at the bottom its fossa mailer the Mitzvah comes as a result of the holiday I buy your holes that the main tack on of Hanukkah is it's a young turf so you're not a fast you know whether you know that have a eulogy yeah you telling me the young turf is not bottle because there's a mitzvah the Mitzvah comes from the yonk of the under doesn't come from the Mitzvah it sound like you first have a mitzvah and then you make a young tough first you have a young tip and then you made a mitzvah to celebrate the young turf right so if the young turf is not here so the minister goes that's what I buy your accent LMI you have to say what automata stylist al-amin abusive abusive said the bureau's have said Sami Tomica hammock is different than Mufasa Melissa the nests of Chanukah became so public because it wasn't only you don't fast cause they made the Mitzvah Hanukkah it became what we would call a household holiday every child looks forward to it every home looks forward to it it became part of the fabric of Claudius rothman they felt that the nullify Chanukah surpass Nations you're right the Yom Tov gets bottle the mitzvot gets bottle the nest became too Jewish and it would leave a sour taste to bheemavaram it's such an experience that she says them afar submissive Argo will how I saw it became a holiday for a leaden haitian abu by a mitzvahs because of the mistress of Chanukah now she says lost and robbers so there's not so Porsha time Hanukkah gelt not kismet sources allocated latkes Alamos and maybe he means Alamos New Mexico Boyka Sultana and the Jews Ashley adds not just it was famous or sentimental they held on to it like a trader dick experience like knock him of a play could you be a technocratic and be Atma vato yeah like nothing of a play it's inappropriate you not do it it would deprive the Jewish people from too much this you to have a rich heritage and schmuck answer no the mother sided the colonists are not to be movable the same have come who have died have that Korea the Sun Hedren decide it is not that mr. krinkle from the from the kishka store one to the Psilakis over the days no no but the other days of McGillis time there's limits oh oh that's what you mean you see cuz everything you say mr. sloshed around because everything's different myths of flying in the camera okay now the gumar is russian was iike mitzvah but they bout to leave at the bottom it's la sera she says not sure not so because of the pearson mr. McPherson is it now it's interesting our rationals you could touch the dome on a mission number five sadness that Hanukkah was celebrated for assuming listen they didn't want to take that away the segment actually says miss Iceland it became too much force and by edon and it would be not nothing it wouldn't be proper to take it away from the Jewish people so therefore don't bring a tire from chronic so that's why when they fasted on Hanukkah SS in derbyshire went to take up one to one one to the to bathe and one went to take a haircut but other days of McGillis time is here the argument still stands you could still say that bottle McGillis tiniest avenue Vanina may still have their position and say that the Megillah Steines is his bottle twice vez the hora de bellas Avira hots me must Nyssa doll Kislev anatomically Havel a luxury place was asked her to give all the cash either Nahum is asking a question are Gavin a pnina from what he finds a story that they fasted on Hanukkah and the bellezza went to bathe did we show went to get a haircut kinda could've a study see requests you have her a Mishnah that says you said she lookin for Hanukkah when was this mission written after the whole base of McNish who's the mission that says in the time of the base I make there they used to do it in ear clearly dismissed it after the forum is I make this has the Gamora said earlier to write so sis it says how the kid muscles are my sue in a blazer to be shoo-in would to claim mission that will Ernie now what do they have to bring that I am in Merrick every last one it's a taste of us answers of summer kids you could say low oil my house you jumped you could say that comic is not considered a young TIFF its bottle Magilla status but philosophy my blinking nate is a holiness but the Jewish people used to light candles as a commemoration for the Masonic even though the Yom Tov is bottle no yard said candles let's say you want to say now what shot whatsapp shot the collider later Abhaya holds that the mitzvah had locked and is certain this Apollo is a bizarre by uses clearly if there's no young tooth get rid of Nair Kamaka right so ptosis is making here a distinction I by himself says I don't understand this fort if there's no yump if there's no chemical abusive says they didn't want to be mulatto live because of omens if isomers but apparently the Kahana who didn't ask this question from the missional holes that you could make that distinction you could make a distinction between the mitzvah and the easter tynus so in other words you could say the easter time this is gone because bottle McGillis time this it's not a young turf anymore but they held on they held on to lighting the Chanukah candles the held online oven that's how you have to learn that your karma disagrees he says you could make a distinction it's two separate things I'll just add this in Ducie Haram Holt says that your Kahana asked from this bright circle it says clearly another fast on Hannity here in the price it says that he told them you have to do children for fasting and our Mishnah just says they sent out here it says he's now at a fast on comet hit so did so clearly what bust on McGillis tightness that's why he asks he asks from this doctor tomorrow right so in conclusion we have no proof from Chanukah this way or this way Chanukah we hold on to even though Buckland McGillis times Mesa next acum mace with Ibaka Beruna rub after the son of Hoonah asked a question our Davin a Buchanan who say the bottle Megillah Steines why now we're gonna have for example a quote of McGillis Tiny's you'll hear you'll see here a new holiday that we don't know about because it's a bigger less Thainess this is one of the days talking to Magilla stein it's a quote but Klus this this quote is basically an example of what McGillis tynus looks like goes through the whole calendar it was reading bhisma by Jenny it was written during the by SHINee around the century before the Corbin but her mind a benefice key and his friends and some things apparently were added later also by other Tamilian yeah much before the Mishnah of course hundreds of years before the mission it's the first a bit of Thai - Ababa that's what's called Magilla Steiners the back of my syllabus about Haruna Tessa Magilla Stein has been lost the petitioner on the third day of Tishri is a holiday no fasting no eulogizing we fasts actually we've had some good value we'll see in a moment base losses but loss of petition the third day of Tishri tailless at Cairo Minster ayah they stopped mentioning Hashem's name from documents at Carta in aramaic means mentioning the current they stop mentioning at character what say myself from documents and therefore they made it into a holiday was shot so the commodity the good Megillah Steines explains nothing in my meal Chikara malluci ovens a dish and Loyola asked essential myopia the Syrian Greek regime when it took over Aaron Cicero made a decree that the Jewish people should not mention the name of God this was forbidden famous Madras mouth was the oven made a decree kiss who loves a mile Kenan Ashur shameless unfailing but the case right on the warrant of the bull you don't have a pardon my son's name but here we see they didn't allow them to mention Shang Shung I should govern our Harshman ivanitsa when the hush vinayan prevailed and triumphed over the avantime over the syrian greeks and eggs area was gone his kilo the Harshman oi'm instituted so yeah hey my skill in shame Jemima filibus tourists they went to the other extreme they said you shouldn't only mention our son's name even every time you write a document you mentioned our Sam's name in other words they wanted to go to the other extreme even though you're not supposed to mention stomp Shan Shan I am right we say Hashem they said mention shame sir my and why because they felt that after the Zahra a slaughter said my failure tell yourself you have to go to the other extreme that every way you should mention said semi we're gonna see we're gonna read but calc are you closer this is what they used to write in their documents the schnozz cosmic on the earth women crying goggle in the year so and so via telling other like we learned earlier in Russia Shana then in the documents you would write the anniversary right of the king how many years he became a king that's what we said Rosh Hashana love malakhov you will start with her straightish innocent in this in this year of the earth unicorn God though Lacaille alien now was written it was written with her shams name Lama Dalai Lama look at not with a CO flick alien I'm just saying the hell that was written without shams name in this in this year of yokomen crying God though the cave alien to the God above now you have to understand why you're smacking goggle Yoshi MacLean goggle was from the families of the cosmonaut in fact he was Jana he was known as yamaha Mela he became what's Dookie he was from the family of the Cashman and he was also a Cohen gondol or it could be that this is your son and crying God on the father of Matisyahu you could learn two ways we may Marcus urbanization and Congo the freshmen are you have enough who was the Kohen Gadol after shimon hatzadik it was shimon hatzadik was a conga at the beginning of my Shanee and then after that you had yokomen klein goggle and martin show was his son and his five children with the cash when I move for the Syrian Greek or your stomach on God was talking about later a grandson of the original rushman Jana who became a pretty rotten apple Alexander Jamie is they called him in Greek Alexander genius he hated the column it was a difficult time with them created almost Civil War nerds is wrong so they would mention - echoing God Allah Kelly now kale is one of names of Hashem that you're now letter erased known as one of the Shiva Seamus and in the Concord it's one of the names L Y is also associated with with Herman's name why did they say why did they say kale Elyan some say it's connected it says that when I've Rama V no defeat it's dying so he came back and Shan Shan took out bread and wine right so it says Malik he'd said that mela column height see lesson VI in who who Corian Lacaille alien so he said yokomen coin Gardo Lacaille alien it's not something to cut the the prosecutors vu I am a chameleon so he say the coin gobble he works for God he works for sham he's a coil okay alia and when did Malky sceptic say this he was thanking Hashem for the victory of a rom over over snowing and this is also the victory of the Jews over the Ivana so that's what the SIP said how come him says that's why they chose this name of Hashem you could have chosen other names it's based on that possible kala so now what happens everybody is writing in every star assembling some will have cumin bend over come him here about it and they say very nice the mouth attachment I want to bring back shame shame on but is a problem I'm who they said l'm offer tomorrow Moscow doesn't only mean tomorrow means like Rashi says yes ma Calathes Mon the future Zephyr day s favor the borrower pays back his debt nope the lender gets back his money he has a documents what does he do throws into the garbage venom system with lavage but it takes the document throws it into the dustbin on the document camera shams name 218 for shame huh no they every one case of the documents et up our son's name is loading the garbage bit long that's why we say Baraka sham you do with her with a base a and even Hashem is not Hashem just means the name why do we say a sham because of this reason you write base a a based on mass now you want to mention my son but we do it in a way that if it gets called stone and the garbage it's not an issue but that's how they wrote it [Music] yeah yeah they some $1 Bora Hashem these types of things it's mentioned same Somalia a cold call yeah shame some I'm huggable fearful so what happened a bit alone so they will move out all this no more writing or shams name in documents no more now the problem was nobody accepted it it was too it was too common was too entrenched for I say I am I so iam death finally of gimel Tishrei they succeed it and they stopped jus stop they turned it into a young term so this is how McGillis time is the kilometers the day they stop mentioning are shams names from documents ace losses yeah yep some safer huh yeah some sofa asks why did white get mortician it for more than why do multi she does I mean it's a date that it stopped so there's some sofa writes in his Peterson home but she says that it's broadens for him that I seriously made sugar are connected are Sarasota Bruce the first day of Tishri scam egged on my flesh a Malacca show the second day well ye look on the third days can negatively see says Seamus amalaki kolosov third one of the two commandments they cease to say well you shouldn't carry shouldn't mention our shams name in vain so that's why they chose gimel Tishrei to celebrate this myth Macias shame shame i so it's interesting they turn this into a amitis what's the yom tov really that juice stopped riding Hashem's name in a star why because it's being disgraced it's being embarrassed it's gone to the garbage ship the marsh oo adds another reason that it was a young turf he said that the oilmen coin goggle was yama yamaha yama amela murdered many of the ha common because they said that he should not he should not he should not be is there was a problem of the - I'm the fashion vanadium work lion em but they also became Kings Kings are supposed to be from shaven 200 there was an insurer than there they felt the unarmed Ellis is not good for them alone and he's not good for the corner and therefore he murdered them when they took out sheiks of mine from the documents they they thought maybe what he could do is say oh you don't want to mention the coin got the LOS Conchas you don't want me to be a Korean and there could be another tragedy so that was also um tough that it went through peacefully my Russ says so gimel gimel tisha is a young something a Marisol colitis bottom Achilles time is if you hold that bottle Magilla Stein is like lavender honey no I don't understand then we have a big problem we have a big problem what's the problem come I said bottle Nana you saw myself in the first ones are gone and now you being myself knew once you understand the crisis a very interesting question give all Tishrei is what some gundalia in the time of the second base our victors what did they do on gimel today it was a simpler was a holiday so when it says the Megillah stein is that they made a holiday of gimel Tishrei it means a new holiday because it was already a holiday so when did they do it when did they make the holiday of gimel today after after her based on McNish because during the base I make theirs anyway a holiday they'll have to make a little holiday so i'm Gedaliah became a holiday listen so when they can give this time it says they made holiday gimel Tish it has to be well after the urban-based some mixes because then some Gedaliah was not a holiday anymore it was a fast day or at least the voluntary fast day so that means that after the base I make Thursday was still adding holidays of makyla Steines so he says this doesn't make sense you're telling me that what come my sabato all the holidays of Magilla Steiners Arbuckle after the but after than the awesome ice if and now I see that you even a heading holidays after the Corbin this is ridiculous Robert and RAF can't be right Lavenham honey they can be right you understand this quest a very strong question no no this is a conventional cache Minoan they used to write to the time of the crime they used to write yoshinogawa care value and later they move out so that when he was alive the question is when was the Yom Tov made as a young tough huh but it was already a young gimmick till she was already a young tough but I'm saying it was it wasn't a finish it was already a young person and similar so you have to say that this jumped off' was after the Hortman when it wasn't a young tiffany more was a young time so they made a young tough because of this right if so how could you tell me but Allah Megillah Steines that after the Corbin all the ante of my irrelevant here we see not only are they relevant they're even adding a new one you're telling me that they will move out the Baldwin that I'm telling you not only they're not my bottle de última they're making the new one which is much stronger than not be move out to the old ones they're like make my new holiday after the sorbets and make of the stylist and not Sangha Dolly's a fast what would be the give us time that's the question that's the question and for the Gemara yeah that's the part that's the vert in the base of meters there was already a young turf now you're gonna tell me you can ask even though the Takano was by Johanna yeah you see was the times of Johanna they used to write couple of can value Korean goggle means it was a vessel McNish enough to bring enough something that I for every ocean and coin goggle means it was a second base a mixer you couldn't read claim you don't have to bring yoson understand the word kind of amis was a base on McNish but nonetheless the back of our owner halls that the main tak honor to make a young tooth wasn't a gaya for the to Kufa after the home base emitters because in this Maha bias kimmel Tishrei was anyway was anybody empty lots of missandei rocks away Masana no better because she was only simply after the whole actually saying after the whole some is Bambi some beautiful was the promise i up the big send in the interfere and for the Gemara huh come on Maya skin as much of a stomach - Kyle you have to say that the mice sir with the starters was during the time of the base Simon was still gonna get to the quite obvious question would tell me submitters in other words gimel Titian it was not made a young TIFF after the Corbin it was made a young to during this man of the bias when there was a base emitters they made it a young test now it makes sense after the urban both from Achilles tiniest including the young team of Kimmel Tishrei not Kamaka including Kimmel Tishrei I I you said yeah but I had not but Wilma girls times because they added the UM tough lay there Matt it later they made it during the base of it and after they some ignitions calm just like the other holidays during the second base um Eclipse they're gone after the Corbett McCandless Tigers becomes irrelevant so ravenous I mean are right ready to give more at least not right but there's no roof refutation check the Gemara the obvious question but typically da ville' a option added with all you man I hit them I don't understand even if they wouldn't have made gimel Tishri empty it's the day when Gedaliah banaji come was murdered which made it a fast day and we learned before that same a Sri HeLa base you hood Allison Allison column her than 10 members mashallah a vu so what are the common ad by making it a young turf when it was already a young turf and you're now at a fast so yeah I have to say that they made it a young team only for after horn based on methods because then it wasn't a young tough anymore the Huayra a megillah' Steines was not bottle and not only it was not buckle even added nuance they even added new Wang [Music] on my Rav Rav said no it was doing the base--emitter Shh line it's akela lessard as a shallow fauna very interesting answer Roth says really bottle Magilla stylus they never added this after the urban this was the middle of the Miss America what do you need two young and tie them for gimel tisha it's already a young test by making this day a special young TIFF in addition to some Gedaliah they made that you shouldn't a lot of fast even the day before based assuring the holidays in McGillis time is were established in a way that that day in a little fast and the day before and the day after second Israel hug before and an era of youngters before it extends for both days one before one after so by making gimel Tishrei especially young Taz in addition to the natural Yom Tov because of sun Gedaliah that became a young this they added a new gather together is in a lot of faster they before based issues for us for us you might going to ask a similar question one minute for us it's our social right right right right right right yeah okay so see in a minute we'll see in a minute okay so now we have a very interesting Mahalo here the Gemara wanted to prove that bottle McGillis tightness that lloyd bottle McGillis time is because they made it after the Corben what tribe they made it after the Corben even though it was already even though the yom tov was made for something as mana buyers but mana bias was already a young tooth so therefore they extended it should also be after the Corben when they won't be excited so therefore there won't be an obligation to fast some good Alakazam plication the fast son good doggy they can't make it a young tooth but when there's no obligation to fast time you dial yourself you don't accept upon yourself the fastest time gundalia then you should have some d'italia as a young tooth it's interesting and if you want to accept some Gedaliah as a fast and you could and then you know let's treat it as a young tough so this is a very interesting date according to this have arm in there then after the urban they make a young tur for those who don't want to accept seunga dahlias a fast now if you do want to accept it then you could accept any now gonna make a young tough so you have a choice either you celebrate or you fast there's nothing in the middle it's not like it's okay I fast I don't know if you know fast it has to be a young tooth subside you don't have such days in Jewish ah it's one extreme to another extreme either your party or you cried there's nothing in between you can't just sit with a stammer face not such a thing then celebrate good so that so the good mark this was the Hammerman of the kimono that it's really after the Corbin and that would prove that what Lloyd bottom with it was timeless on this dig Murray says now it's not after the curve and was on this mana bias and they just added this has a young Tiffin addition that son Goodall you why because they wanted to add also the day before but some good day they wouldn't add the day before the Kumar's gonna explain why you're right that's a good question it's a good question stahma Harada thus far sir mrs. may shitless arrambam is that even in the task man of the base hamikdash of the second my submitted there was a fast petition buff because he holds ain't solemn doesn't only mean there's not be some weakness ain't shala means that Rashi says that there is no that the Jewish people are not independent his mana by a shame II there was most of the period of Irish a me they were under foreign rule they won the Persian rule they were under Greek rule and then they were under Roman rule that was only around a hundred years and they wonder their own rule hush monoi so therefore the Rambam holds that the concept of ain't showin existed even in the second base of victors and that's why we said that ain't shalom rot so miss anna rots away miss anna see healed the tissue both was a faster even in the second base emitter statistician to ceramic according to this if in the time of the base emitter there were times that there was no shaolin and therefore tisha buff wasn't a young tooth you could say maybe that they made gimel Tishri a young to them in those times of the second miss HaMikdash when some Gedaliah wasn't a young Tiflis to surround mom cosy olds ain't show them so then you could say that's when they made gimel Tishri a young tooth however but that wouldn't that Wilden work also because in those times the yellow typhoon McGillis time is also going to work remember Robert of cannon are comparing the autumn Achilles tiniest to the fast days so when you're saying that the fastest in the time of the basin Victor's are not the untie them so that McGillis tie this is also not a hunter just like buckle McGillis tightness after the Hornbuckle McGillis time is and the times of body shaming that ain't shallow so therefore that wouldn't work that they kept get multi-layer youngters when sun gundalia I see up to the middle of a machine in a monitor if it's a young pip so that simply values a young tooth and if it's not an octave so that is not even that's also not a youngster so that wouldn't work a very English Marquardt of this far samus you wouldn't even give even a cord to the room you would be able to give this answer that happened the middle of the Bayou Chene you you have to say it happened after the Corbin but happen after the curb may have a problem with lavender caninus so the governor says no what happened the middle of the based on meekness when there was a young turf I why did they I they add it to add the time as before for negative your mother I don't understand your question shall the fun of Nami typically novel um slaw horseradish based history is a day after a Scottish restore this is considered a mile is considered a holiday so the day after you don't fast so therefore why do you have to add a new young to Fung gimel Tichenor because you want that the fast should extend a day before you're ready you're ready covered alum are you making the umpty for that day itself but that day itself is already a young person's mama by training so you have to say they made the yom tov after the horrible after the hor bin is the horizons Nicholas time this is not bottle that's the commode of Shiloh and for the Gemara no Richard this day rice trade isolate boy hazel rasoi dish is Moya that's a young Terminator didn't mean a tater don't eat sizzle they're very powerful they have a certain reputation and a sense of urgency by the Jewish people cause of the administrator so you don't have to add a day before they after the time yeah we learn to Bryce the Bryce's says in Megillah Steines how your memory locks of Regulus times would I write syllabi physic it's a statement destroyed this is their nice oh there isolate boy official let's see dashi let's see does she now she the typical a ebay Simon fish avec I am the Miss a mistress exists but I will he have a young to Diamond son Gedaliah Oh Kyra monomer them home is mana buyers it's anyway a young turf what do you have to make a young tooth line it says Akashi ha daughter come over McGillis tiny sold over there and a lesser s small gamma button is the reason they made it amagad less tightness is to add the day before cuz I'm middle the Khmer we're gonna see soon I am a may like some of the Megillah English man laughter am i certain Haim they are forbidden to fast the day before the day after recite there's a cry she Maya died rice it's a biblical festival would I sell Lloyd boy his Eccleston the front of the locker of I William a megillah' Stein is there are Burnham what's written chisel you know where they need physical okay so the lay motionless I miss Bianca Foxman a young tough men are tired I'm not afraid you're gonna fast a young them that I born on it needs his look it needs strengthening how do you give it physic you fur prohibit the day before in the day after so you don't get close to fasting on this day so that way that day is secured McGillis kindness I am entitled that meat is over so therefore the celebration of Sonja Dalia that they added was that you shouldn't fast even a day before she won't come too fast that day to Masha a cane gosh I wish you could fast on based issues creditors just a day in and of itself you don't have to add a day before a day after the time that we learned to Magilla Stein is how yamame lots of regular Stein is these days written in McGillis time it's a pseudonym endless named by marca I mean a lot of fast they be from the day after bosses we haven't even what about sharpest injunctive hey must sort of me and a lot of fast on that day listening ilaha rayon moot arden fled the town and my half fridge bring Zelizer what's the difference Shabbos and young turn I'm a lot of fast before and after the days of Magilla Stein is not lalu divinatory innovatively turn it's razor-sharp listen yom tov our obligations may not a to the words of taylor don't need strengthening and therefore you don't have to prohibit the day before the day after ha-la-lu holidays of McGillis time is divination safe from their rabbinic the dividend so flim rhythm ISM the words of the sages need strengthening why so people should not come to denigrate them and treat them lightly and therefore they prohibited also the days before and after so therefore if gimel Tishri would not be a young turf of McGillis thymus you would be allowed to fast on base tisha flag the Gemara typically the hobble am surely from a you're in genetic by Gedaliah banaji come great question why do you have to add a young turf it's a ready a day and now that a fast base today why because Gedaliah pan-african was killed on gimel Tichenor during the buyers Shamy it became what a young tooth if it's a young - if you extend it a day before not the faster they before and a day after so base tisha is already a day that you're not fasting i'm ana boshy know the value of a knife he comes every day Kabbalah Kabalah kitty litter in Adamo the story of Gedaliah ban of Hickam in other words the fast day and the holiday is diverted Kabbalah didn't come all the means words of tradition which is a metaphor for the words of the prophets it's called divarella Kabbalah dividend the VM is called dividend Kabbalah why is it called Kabbalah because they receive the prophecies were received by divine inspiration every prophet in his era scenario Navi was macabre he received a prophecy of or about the fast day of some gundalia and the holiday of some Gedaliah so he doesn't need see so it's different car but looks like Didrik Toyota doesn't its actions in Yom Tov so therefore wouldn't go to based astray so Matranga Dalia it would only stay gimel tisha by the harem and adding during the second base of McNish a new young Tiffin gimel tisha for what for the fact that the Jews stopped writing in the documents the name of Hashem what was the addition the addition was that now based history also became a serve became austere betina's right but here you already have a strong question why don't you have to add a day before by some Gedaliah cause it's Divya Kabbalah interested in physical why do the how come and buy their young and tie him add a day before Rashi says because they were afraid that you're gonna fast on this day so therefore they expanded it even more so you'll go with a before one second if this days anyway turn Gedaliah and 3rd battalions are young too and it's minute or so in sort of physics so what are you afraid what are you afraid of you just said it's DVD compilation physic and that's we don't have to fast the day before why that's why you don't have to ask her a kindness a day before because people are certainly not gonna fast so now let's think what they did they made a new young to fun gimel Tishri so it should be us at the time mr. day earlier why so people should have come too fast on this day when this day itself is Mohammed Kabbalah and you've just said eight sir exorcism if I can't the reason that base today wasn't a sir is because inside a scissor we're not worried gimel today is safe it's gonna be a similar here nobody's gonna fast people don't fast on Shabbos people don't fast I don't the people are not going too fast on some get out it's an interesting thing and yet they make a new young teeth why only so they can add based astray in the list of the hey stay out of that what do I care what do I need you to add based issues old new design based in it cuz you need to isn't what do you mean tears are care for if it's only a holiday of McGillis tightness I understand people are gonna keep in the day but now you're not a problem it's up such a difficult thing to understand what are you saying why plug what my plug they're making an ood nobody make me a new jumped offical a new young SMSs a very ish muck of art he says you have to understand it a little a little deeper it's not stomp shot they made a new young turf it's really irrelevant to the terraria young TIF so now we want to know what's the relevance so we say oh they added a fast day before they added an Easter of a fast day before he says the the reason they made young typhoon was they want to juice should remember them should celebrate them it should become part of the conversation part of it there should be an emotional response to the ailment item the problem here is the Damara says since Kimmel tisha is already a yum t'v so it swallows up the new yump if nobody is even going to remember it because you know like we say a mire and simcha similar you know mix once in with another similar each since there has to a queue pi its own space once time Gedaliah is celebrating because of the transformation that happened with the second base something that's being rebuilt so by making a new young turf on that day you're not really making it a young turf because people won't be able to experience it because there's already another young TIF that eclipse ascent of them Zelda Gemara no because this new young turf has an additional date to it which is based history so may that has something that the original younger doesn't have in other words the young term so to speak starts based astray even though base dish is only an outgrowth of gimel tissue but it starts base tissue so therefore you'll remember the young taiga Dahlia was killed right after the urban by assertion the base emitters was destroyed Tisch above and Gedaliah was killed the next year it was a fast day for 70 years for 70 years it was a fast day but then bisman hobbies' Haryana V said that all these fast days are going to be sawsan and Simkin madam type of a mr. Shalimar Havel so that includes losted lover but it includes also during the saying people are gonna think the Kabala and that's why you're not fasting based is not because because this engine of of gimel Tichenor the play issuer has a different part opposite part he says they wanted to make a young turf or what happened gimel tissue was the time to make the um turf once you're making such a young turf you have to also a sir the day before why do you have to ask her the day before because that's the club i McGillis time is you don't make distinctions like you said all the Clallam McGillis times you have to I the day before here is it relevant because people are anyway not gonna come too fast you're right but they're not gonna make a new get there that this young TIFF doesn't go a day before they're not gonna cheap in the hump t'v lapel you're right you don't need it in this case it's not like the other I'm gonna tell them that's a different part that's of the pineda short lines for some must learn those tant's your question you have to say that I guess it was publicized that way it was publicized that way his friends killed him right you small B small B no Sonya julia from base dovid nah so trashy youngsil if may youngsil if may who loved the rice hoo hoo boy sizzle which words is Russia going here the how will a young shall dismay um genetic by the doll even Africa but who loved their die Superboy physical some Gedaliah is not minute area so that needs his Oh so therefore based history is already a certain tightness on this video more assertively Coppola gate of literature but I've I mean it was that it's anyway not a day of thymus on this more answers no it is a day of time is because it's Divya Kabbalah and therefore they added this finish of gimel Tichenor the bottom line is there's no proof that bottom Achilles times and there's no proof that light bottle Manila Steines you could say bottle of Magilla Stein is I there was a young to get Montessori it wasn't after the urban it wasn't after the cumin was a little bit a McNish so there's no proof that what that but law the guiltless tiniest or light buckle Magilla stylus either way you could still maintain both this about Magilla stylist Shana could have been one of two days usually it was the 30th day of Ellen they we do it differently then base tisha wasn't you asked about base to should be English economist if she wasn't Rosh Hashana why we're talking him as mana bias yeah we took him is mana bias wishes Shana was basically one day Rosh Hashana was one day because Ella was 29 days and Rosh Hashana was day 30 even if you want to say was her Shana was two days was treasurer Shana was two days day 30 and day 31 not based and no they were never my country without a this they used to wait they used to wait the first day they 32 ladies are gonna come if a this came in the morning beautiful Shoshanna was one day day 30 was her son and you're done and tomorrow was based history day 30 became I love to shred you understand or a this didn't come so day 30 became 38 the message of four-ish Hashanah they couldn't get the message out mr. Chandra they made two days it was it wasn't a principal always two days of reality so they keep two days the reason they keep two days and external is because even in the time when they were Mikado's the Hydra shop here here Rosh Hashana had to be two days in a row because the Slauson couldn't make it it always started if you were in a place where you didn't know it had to be two days that's not based astray yes by us and I understand in our calendar all McGillis time is they made a day before and a day after remember also practically speaking for us a time this is a big thing then probably people fasted constantly they didn't have so much food I'm serious serious idea to say you're not eating from sunrise to sunset yeah okay it was a normal thing wasn't such a big thing huh wasn't a lot of food wasn't a lot of elements they missed a breakfast a lunch and a supper today is hospice although there's food everywhere so the common said you know fast you eat something it probably didn't make it yet a young to that they said a day before they after three days in a row you should eat less up somewhat see this when we days in a row you should eat okay let's summarize the Gemara quoted a big malaika's between Java and Rebecca Nina verses rebuking on it'll be a sharable a V the question was if McGillis thymus the 35 think it's 35 young entitled that were established during by his Shamy by the tano liam to celebrate various victories and miracles that the jewish people experienced and they created a halakhah you now that are fast on these days and some of these days you know that he even make a hospital eulogy for somebody who passed if that those institutions of these two economies have this safe from achilles thymus was bottle after the Corbin base of militia not Ravin of Hanina said absolutely yes just like the holidays of the for fast days which became holidays were bottle and reputation review sure but maybe said you can't compare those were bottle because the urban base of mikta really destroyed them you can't turn our syrup potatoes into a holiday or Titian above into a holiday when you have no base emitter dish but these holidays of McGillis time is they not dependent on the pinion of baser McNish they're not of course it's a shock when they survey some licorice but now that i still exist even without the billion base emitter for example let's take what we know poor poor him is not canceled because of her masonic there's the jewish people were saved important even if there's no base on makes us so put him is one of the holidays of McGillis Tanis attacker poem we celebrate everybody holds we celebrate poem but they're tiny is not connected you can't compare so the Gemara thank you the Gemara goes down on a series of discussions questioning the first view of robert upcoming in the because time this was bottle the first crack is Hannukah we have a clear halakha lien a little fast on Hanukkah so the gomorrah said Konica was different because of them of the mitzvah of had Lucas Narus and the mitzvah that became accepted by all of Claudius Rome and they felt it was inappropriate to take that away even though the rest of McGillis tightness was bottle appointed up in a plan the second question was from the holiday of McGillis time is the third of Tishrei where they made especially opt of why because they managed to get the Jewish people not to embarrass denigrate shame shaman by putting it into every single document which seemed like a nice idea but ultimately defeated its purpose and therefore they made that a holiday and the question is if Butler Megillah Steines there's a big problem because during the Masonic there was anyway a holiday because it was Sun Gedaliah sorry says sustenance mhmm item type so you have to say they made the holiday after the film based on the condition are you saying after cumbersome uses don't be careless time is and I'm he telling me they made my canoe yom tov after the court but this the gomorrah says it over the peninnah would say no they did it during the based on minutes I was a young tough anyway the answer is butts at the author of some gundalia there will only be an Easter tightness on that day gimel to tread which had the young turf of Magilla Steiners there's an extra component and that is the day before also becomes aa Sabatini's like all the amount over mcgillis time is the Gemara said it's listen a.m. ya allah karim it goes it goes on both of them bailiff they obey Muharram it's awesome patinas i the day before is look lighter anyway else of the thymus because it's the day after asteroid ish he says not you can't compare that because we related to the dinner in our Toyota and the writer doesn't need his look you don't have to extend the days with the killer's tightness is deeply sorry for him I'm a 10-minute Ida these are all holidays with their opponent it's different isn't I says fun but if it was a holiday ready in the base I'm Englishmen satsanga Dalia to that extend it also than the day before he said No David a Kabbalah this could do great words of the prophets are like the words of credit in this sense in this sense that they don't need that physic so this was the high sofa the addition of the young to evangelist Imus according to rabbinic annina that based issues also us of the times but after the wooden base I make this bottle of Magilla Steiners including the holiday of gimel Terra Firma Kazan exception that's the of Revenue Europa there is a in you shine him that he was killed on Rosh Hashanah they didn't want to make a tiny solution as they pushed it off the day after she shot yes it was a celebration a speech it was a young tooth the question is based today somebody wants everything it's me that Minotaur and we still do one day before Monday after she said now when the Minotaur donate physic what do we do it that one actually no cuz it's to hug itself as a service because it's just this you hug by voice a mechanism is bare so the has all say color is a good Allah honk if you continue the card my rule of a castle in stock itself as an Indian yeah now each other in each schism that that it extends something the motivator masive it up to V by mass 'no never to be the son of mass asks a new question on whom again arrived and ab canina who hold the Megillah Steines was buckin what's the question he now calls Megillah Steines again another holiday the Estrin and this again these are holidays as we said that we don't celebrate today because we don't we're not aware of these young hug them unless you learn Magilla Steiners the estimate Amanda obey assume is 20 tamna is 8 on the 28th day of the month of other basically McGillis tightness is divided into chapters every month gets its own chapter so once you hit the month he doesn't keep on saying which month he just says bay in him that's why it doesn't say here it's other you have to know what it says him achilles turn this is just a best cuz he goes through a list of the month the estimate omnia bay on the 28th day of it asks assertive early hüdayi good news arrived to the jewish people the low e e didn't my rice that they don't have to stay away from terra what type of good news was this so the Megillah stylus explains cigars rahamallah Xena the mouth was the empire of the regime which is the Roman the Roman government the Roman Empire issued forth an edict the decree on the Jewish people shall I ask a potato they should not learn tyre shallow ammulu Esben a.m. they should not circumcise their sons which say hallelujah bosses and they should desecrate the Shabbos three sailors the marsha explains that these three mitzvahs worked the romans more than any other mitzvahs because these three mitzvahs set apart uniquely specifically the Jewish people by Toyota it says key Hamas como been asking Lena Amin this is your wisdom before the nation's my bris millet says waha so Louis bris mania mayonnaise him it's a covenant between you and me and Shabbos the ice P Benny obey knife from Assam between you and me so the marshal says it's these three from all the other mitzvahs that really perk them and hence they made the Seder on Tara I'm Bruce Miller and on shimira shops what happens ma I'll see you would have been Shamu over cavero what did you would have been Shamu WA one of the turmoil do together with his friends quite an interesting plan whole Hoover not later Mima Tunisia they went to get advice from attorney so Martin ISA means a princess like a an aristocrat and a Roman a Roman aristocratic woman they went to get advice Martin ISA a cos one particular aristocratic woman but she wasn't just a regular woman she called daily rainy Matsuya tax law all the greats of Rome used to frequent her well uh they asked what to do they asked her what to do apparently she had her she had her finger on the pulse of Rome you know she knew Rome intimately partum asthma and they asked her what she would advise advice I'm reliable what did she say Bayou volcano it's time for half gonna you have to make a demonstration well you will have dinner have dinner literally means scream come and scream shout bar Lila at night somebody screams the middle of the day there's so much commotion to come in each town you can't hear them at night it's a quiet time you scream everybody hears so go scream at night in all the streets that's what you should do halloo V is given about Lila that's what they did they went and they demonstrated they went out and they started to scream at night I'm ruined this is what they said a shaman like we would say for heaven's sake for God's sake like a shoe mine for heaven's sake like a semi national are we not your brothers Rome Binet Avesta demands new learning of extra dimensional are we not the children of one father the labeneh a moccasin national are we not the children are we not both children of one mother who managed managed to Nina McCartney Stan ænima Coahoma of a larger shaft in goes the millenniums areas cautions why have we been set apart from every other language and every other nation that you issue forth on of such malicious and difficult decrease obit alone and as a result Rome nullified these decrees for I say Hyori Masaru Yom Tov that day was Kafka's are the twenty-eighth of other men am tough this is a classic young term of Megillah Steines what did they mean are we not brothers are we not the children of one father the children of one mother because I'll always saw Rome as a perpetuation of Asaph Roma's a service associated with Edina huh let's deciphered i makea he ho he's your brother Asaph is a brother say he says I was not brothers ASA was our brother are we not the children of the same father it's cooked I mean other children of the same mother difficut so - tani no man Astana há uma Hazare this nation from all the other nations of the world this was the advice she gave them they father the advice and they succeeded it's interesting the Marsha again says that they said three things are you not our brothers are we not brothers are we not the children of one father I mean are the children of one mother it seems like a repetition or just different what's the point she says it has to do with the three xavius one Zeta was tighter one Zeta was Shabbos and one's a was Miller so he says when they said are we not brothers they were being me Ramazan the Azalea not to learn turned it because I'm tired itself let says lei society but by me Kia he who who he's your brother and Malthus ROI me is connected to ASA are we not your brothers Detroiter that you want us not to learn calls us your brother calls us your brother and calls you our brother the second thing is Lloyd Bonet of accident nationally not the children of one father it's your father was circumcised when he was eight days old in fact the first Jew to get a bris at eight days was its lack of rum was 99 it's like was eight days old then he said Lloyd Binet a moccasin a salami not the children of one mother because the risk we know observed Chavez the passage says via via hits cook paella sorry my so we say that what that nail does she was like sorry that Nair dull ax of candle burnt my head of sharpest lat of Shabbos this was a ramus for the Gihon shop mr. Marcia says that's what they said these three things and others for all these fish - you should let us learn you should let us have a Gris and you should let us celebrate harvest your own mother your own father and and and the toyota calls us her brother and they were successful this is the source for allah havoc on us I'm a hot glass huh yeah I didn't throw eggs they actually said something but yep and this was the eighths of a non-jewish woman over tonight the middle of the middle of the night now it's interesting yet now she says have give new tsakuba shockable very famous scream in the marketplaces in the streets today she used to I started beer alpha male you needed asaram were the senate this the rome was run by by a senate they were called asaram they should listen addition of Ramona Sonja you would think sometimes such a thing can have opposite result right I guess that's and they did they took advice from from a woman who knew who knew the matzo I mean you can't know when this works when it maybe it's counterproductive but she said this is the eighth son and they were successful Asia minds are actually colonial America this Borough Hall we would say for God's sake for factor these barnacles sake why are you doing this to us Asia Maya what's the question here's the Shila ysou could night bottle McGillis time is give all the cash i'll if revenue plan in are right that after her mesa McNish Makela Steines was destroyed here's the question come ice a bottle the first german term that you established during the buyers Shanee you're saying our bottle they're irrelevant because the torment happens so now I ask you after Niassa my Siffin so now the Megillah Stein is ads after the Corbin new holidays doesn't make sense if you're taking the old holidays that already exist in a by Jenny saying once Gullah started it's all over so now you telling me not only are they not over you're even creating new ones not only are you maintaining for memories sake the old ones from the good days in the bad days when it's all bottle you're creating new ones that wouldn't make sense if you hold it to all that the Tison of the observed McGillis times are not shy it's the gulls so mad that's the ones that were in a time of gula you're still maintaining in dollars here here you're doing even much more towards you creating a new one in Collis right that's the pail according to the other doesn't make sense McGillis time this was never both not only was immortal it could tell you they even added the term I am added new ones after the Corbin I mean they didn't go for much longer at some point McGillis tightness was sealed but they added more but according to having a plan in its Apella the heat tamer if you're gonna answer how konami was much of mr. MacLeish guy okay say that it was during the time of the bay something goes wrong took over the Middle East before the Horde made sandwiches they were the ones who made the gourmet sermon so once Rome took over maybe it happened before the Hartman and there was Xavier and Kafka saw there was the salvation and they made it in time at the base of it just like we said before about the young tip of gimel Tishrei that they made it during the time of the Mesa McClure's the gomorrah says hey you can't say this in the previous yom teruah thermal Tishrei wasn't associated with a name but here we have a name for how you hood the bench Shamu were you who dimensional who's the one who went with his friends to get advice about what to do for me this should have mayor he was a student of the mayor we're soon gonna see how we know he was a student of it of may maybe he was not well soon see but it may buzzer off he Hoffa and there's no question that a mayor lived after the Corbin Mesa make - how do we know so rash she tells us right away the cares would take a look around she Ramaiya muscle urban hava the Gomorrah means comedy itís not right after a few generations why the hobby may rabirius in a Ben Zakai heart of a bias the base of macness was destroyed during the era of Riviera Ben Zakai this is not a question as a whole sugamice F is gettin - involved the famous suger comes to become sir Perry Connie's oaken where we learned that a vehicle of in soccer was near during the horrible he managed the situation he was taken out of your shall I and he met with Spacey and he made the deals with him etc next Mirabelli yes sir Tom Midori hi Oh rabbi eliezer was the famous comedy a film exactly in fact the gomorrah says over the innovation was actually wanted to be brought out of your show lion to meet of a space seen a specialist who was then the commander in chief who was then the commander in chief ultimately running the whole operation later the spacing would become the Emperor himself the Emperor himself and they wouldn't let out anybody from your show lion because the car no Liam the secret of the zealots were what they want an absolute war so they had to the service was a key Fane that he died was dead and they slept him out on a bed who slept him out says it FL as it was one of them just how miserable as it was as Talmud so crashy vital for the about Kiva Tom we do should have merely Ezra can diminish alia by missus rebbi akiva was a student of rebellious at the Gemara seventh son hadron rabbi eliezer was Rebecca's Talmud rakshasas the beloved who relates to her back even as a student and conversing about Kevin relates to him as a rabbit this is your blessed God the Lord of blossom an organist he was ultimately put in harem over the story with her venom of a midsi and who went to visit him but even went to visit in this town with one to visit him but that was their relationship Veidt it may that may it tell me this about Kiva that Mayor was a student whatever you because I'm gonna never pay to come at the aid of them the Gomorrah says in a ravine called Malcolm shot I might say miss Umbria be small on my combat effort of native Akiva a night Ellen had made wherever it says in shots that atonement said ash more to there be a keema in the name of her be smarter be whatever keep our colleagues it may was a comment of alumina booyah so that mayor is considered the calm of the rebbi akiva Romero's had another lever as you said Alicia Panov oh yeah after who continued to learn from even after he became a heretic as the Gomorrah says a high giga we continue to learn by him but his rabble was Ruby Akiva so now you have to be asking him exactly the time of the horbet Talmud is another lesson his time with his Ruby Akiva his Talmud has remained they've made is certainly after the formation if this is the case you who the bench ammu was a time of the Romanian so he certainly have to hurt by a knee so this story of Kafka thought that couldn't happen the middle of the base of meters that happened after the second base of makers here are the Gomorrah analyzed the dates if that's the case we have here a big problem with bottle Magilla stylus this doesn't make sense now the Gemara has to prove that you had the bench ammo was the time of the resume maybe he wasn't so now the gomorrah goes off on another subject and proves that you heard that when Shamu or was the student of them made something tomorrow right how do we know he was the student will it make so here we come to a different sugar for a few moments which is going to prove this issue we have to remember a little introduction when it comes to tumor purity and impurity as we mentioned a few times by us the words to mantari are basically Chinese but if you lived as a Jew in the time of the second base a McNish to man Tyra was as relevant as today's chakras minsum idath it was part of the fabric of Jewish life as big as comets as making the same it was part of literally the daily fabric of Jewish life things becoming Tom a and things becoming talk in terms of people in terms of clothes in terms of Calum of utensils and the harvests that applied to each and everyone over them not only for Kyle unit but for any Jew any Jew Jews were going to the base of McNish in a few days you'd go to be something there's a carbon-based sir you have to go if you tell me can you go into that her Tobias could you go into that sort of me these were all issues that relate it to everybody somebody died in a house everything in the house was now telling me everything the blankets the food the drinks the utensils all the people that were house because they wanted for the expression of the expression of it look at so now we have to remember a few years itís when it comes to two-man tire the tire says clearly clematis any vessel made of metal becomes Tom a minute IRA clay Marcus you have a metal for a metal spoon a metal knife it becomes impure biblically what happens if it breaks what do I mean it breaks it's not suitable anymore to be used in the way it's supposed to be used or that matically becomes taller why the definition of tomb is only when the Cayley is functioning as a Cayley let's say it's a bowl and there's a hole in the bowl it's a kale it's a picture of water and there's a hole you can't use a picture of water with a hole yeah if it's a Cayley made to put in pomegranates I don't care if there's a little hole the pomegranates won't fall out but if it's a picture and you want to put in water there now there's a hole it's useless it's a broken Cayley automatically it becomes taut main hot area came the harkaman and they decreed a tumor if you fix the Cayley if the Cayley is broken it's dark it's gone the tumors gone but if I now repair the Cayley so minute later it started it broke it became pure you now repair it lucky you use it the common said no if you repair it it goes back to its original Toma of course unless unless you make iron unless he cleanses you could you could cleanse it in a mikveh or if it's Tomas mace then you need a more serious cleansing you need a para Duma but as long as you didn't cleanse it it goes back to the original tumor even though a second tumor didn't happen it didn't become Tommy a second time that's a mission ER in my sector Kayla what's the reason for this why would they do this what did they care you fixed your ceilidh Starman operator the reason is because what happened was this became a regular method that people were using it wasn't such a bad method you break the Kayle you make a little hole or something and you make it not usable and then it becomes taller and you repair it and it's all good what was their concern that concern Wow that often people would make holes that were not large enough to disqualify the Kayle if it's a Kaylee that's used for a liquid than a little hole disqualifies but if the Kaylee used for for fruits right you have to make a large enough hole if you're just doing it to make it tart often they when they saw that people are not making large enough holes in other words the Kaylee never became Taher and now they would just repair it and they used it as Tyrande it was a serious thing a coin could put through him into it the Truman is now Tommy he's now that heated or all the other other other obstacles that are gonna happen so therefore they said it's a house mesh it still told me this was the reason they made things a day there was another reason they made the zeta and that is a Kaylie that brakes immediately becomes tired you don't need anything else the moment it breaks it started you don't even have to wait till sunset of that day what's called higher of temperature becomes time what about a Kaylie that didn't break it's a hole Kaylie but you put in a mikveh you put in a caution mikvah here you have to wait till nightfall for it to become taller it's called Harry sandwich many things even though you went to the Mickey you still have to wait till nightfall in other words you need a new day it's not enough that you're in the mikveh you need a new day for the Taira to happen they were afraid that if they're going to allow the Taira through breaking so people are what gonna use it right away because you don't need anything else people who didn't see the breaking think a Kaylie became Tommy you made it to her and that day you can eat it right you can use it right away even if you went to the mikveh even you put it in the mixer [Music] but that once you had the first reason that the cloud the issue was that's this is this is this is the mission of a scepter King now we have one more detailer glass glass vessels are not tommy minatoya they're not the common made it two months focus the reason they made it to me is because you make a glass from sand liquid sand or other sense now the classic calum that art um they are claimed artists and clay terrace clay ferrets are earthenware vessels glass is not an earthenware vessel on earthenware vessel you push to take birth and you make from it a Kaylee you take earth and you turn it into a Kaylee and you bake it in an oven or in the Sun that's called clay Harris unlike clay Adama which is just plain earth you just take mug you make a Kaylee out of it and then it started it's not macabre to him it's so cheap that it's worthless not Makabe when it's clay Adama but clay Harris is earthenware that you actually bake it it has some harsh evils not a very big cut you as it comes from Earth not like metal but it has some value and it's McCobb altima since clays hook has also come from sand and of course they have a prominence so the hakama migoi Sertoma on clay Scotia's glass what happens if the glass breaks its Makabe pirate becomes torn what if it repair you've repaired again of course minute Ida there was never a tumor Madeira born on you would think the tumor should come back by clay shooters they were not closing why were they not great of a clay so cuz cuz the whole plume is mightier up on the whole tumor by clay schnapps is the tumors minute area and they were afraid that it's not gonna break in a sufficient way with larger enough holes that makes it toys so you have a serious tumor here the whole food was meant there Ivana so therefore what's gonna happen it broke it start now you're gonna repair it why should they keep the tournament over here they they they allowed you treated as a toyotacare Kayle so a klase hooks's stomach that broken it became tired and it went back you fixed it it does not go back to its ultima why could it's not man I turn it on therefore they were not Marshman with this yeah it's all based it's that's a good question you're asking hold it up honor okay tickle didn't the one who came there nice it thickened so why doesn't it have the same gather of clay Cyrus my clay shatters is add-in that lets say something that's tummy touches the clay shatters from the outside it's not tongue the only way it becomes tummy is if the tumor goes in the inside even if it doesn't touch it it goes into the average to the atmosphere of the Caylee inside the only way it could become tummy that's why if you have a mace in a room and the clay Faris is tied on the top it's not Tommy why even though the Tomas mace even if the mace touches the clay terrace it's irrelevant it has to go inside so if you haven't summoned phospholipids if there's a sealed lid the clay Harris remains tar only a clay shatters everything else becomes coming from the outside so you're asking why clays hookers doesn't have the same a look if the whole clays hookers comes in with clay shatters the answer to that is why is a clay Harris Makabe to them only on the inside not on the outside every Kayle a clay mattress yeah metal gold silver star metal that we use it's lockable Toma anyway inside outside the answer is because the other kalyan have value clay Harris is extremely cheap it's made of Earth what's it's Russia vez its car services then it holds something else inside of it it's that it's a Cayley atossa that it's a killer that's Makabe something something else is contained in the clay Harris because that's a total shivers so therefore the outside of it is considered worthless it's like clay glulam you make a Cayley out of dung people would make poor people would take dung of animals I make clay it's not macabre Toma there's two cheap Duma cobble tomb ah term has always commander it with a shivers how much it's used by people but clout the whole year you are the Mortimer right because to me always is attracted no no no no I hope you try to hire man there's a mini the sensitivity the tumor is attracted you know you you don't go rob us nor you go rob a bank you understand tumors attracted to power of kedusha so wherever there's more potential for Duchenne and there's an absence of it is more tumor yeah that's why by a person more than by an animal with cetera wherever there's more potential for kedusha there's more capability of tumor there's more sensitivity and there's more depth over there right high your soul to Mars is called a government have a date you'd say I said model higher souls also can have bigger shrillness a bigger sense of srida because the demons want to get there because there's a lot of good food there there's a lot of good a lot of good nutrition there but Mela the more service and the more it's useful by a person than what's my couple Toma so clay Ferris the only service is walk not on the outside the only service is was that it has something inside of it but clay focus clays hookers and a fashion makayley elamite the Holman series of school this is not me couple two momenta theta but once they're abundant safe to be macabre tumor it's already a customer Kaylee it's a bunch of Achilles but couple to them everywhere but the reason they made clay shooters from a couple Tamila capital is what do they mean it for because it's daemul of harris why is it thermal of harris because you created from sand sometimes the massive earth becomes stronger than the silver Yaphet Kotto been weak i have sometimes the result is stronger from the syndrome we learned Jewess is more young potential go yes is more common than the other young traditional colleges because it's avada the whole shoe is came because of the other younger token but it becomes more calmer so you have them at see us here of clays hookless which with a different allah what's the issue now the issue is the following situation you have a glass cup or a glass bowl or whatever it is it became tommy and now it broke there's a hole it's cracked since it's cracked it became taller how do you seal the crack you didn't seal the crack with more glass you seal the crack with metal you seal the crack with metal what's the hollow kana the tanaan we learnt a Mishnah clay surface you have vessels of glass that became impure the Nick who knew and they Shanna crew they know they got a hole to the point that they become Qatar the heat if LaSalle can avert the person poured led into them what it was a glass Kaylee who could McCracken what does he say Nicky says crack probably no perforated okay always good you use a fancy word than it works perforated glass gets perforated showing either which you had the made of google and figure it out sure the heat of the Sun tomorrow you put LED into it all murdered shimmy minimally shaming the son of Gamliel said you who the been Shamu WA metonymy Sharif may you who the bench some who are said it's Tom a and he said in the name of red male let's understand even though after you seal the whole the clay smokers did not become tell me again but it goes back to the old tumor that had had before you know why because you put red into it and therefore the how luck of the Kaylee is established based on that which holds it up based on that which strengths is it and since you put it in with let you put in let and the tomb of leathers what I mean I'll tell you to see every an interesting thing the let itself wasn't Tommy the glass scaly itself became too hard and would have become would have remained tired even if you put a new glass and you repaired it but since you put in now led into it so the Cayley now has a new Macias it's considered like a Cayley of lead and therefore it's how long it changes and it goes back to the ultimen that's the finish of rib mayor huh let's see Rashi becoming the tyrant and if I come and say it's not true this is not the ha'la'tha if I come and say it started in other words we treated as a glass Cayley and a glass Kaylee has a locker that if it gets perforated it becomes pure and I don't care if you repair it are you repeated with lead it doesn't change its status from this bryson number one we learned that you who live in Shambala was a student of ram mayor that's why he was saying a lot in his name and therefore we also learned that the holiday of Kafka's other was after the horn based on English now let's see Rashi about our locker itself look trashy the turn-on we learned to Mishnah in this mission that teaches us to the buda mansion more tell me they should have made have a place hookers janicoo she need to move the first thing you have to remember is they became Tom Raven Nick vu and then but not Kevon and he actually perforated them he's the one who did at Eva he made it Lata Roberta massa be this abscissa question even if it doesn't actually happen he did it especially in order to be in Makaha a vet a fetes he put in land he poured and that lists him as a necklace to seal to plug the hole he would have been somewhat Tommy Lamar said positive the Tomas Sonia Shawna the official another shoe bittleman even though they didn't touch to them again they become Thomas the r4p Shankly hook is crazy on Tomas and you know even though glass Calum don't go back to the ultimate when you repeat Kodama be ready to come at the Shabbos she like Gaza too hazardous to meet you Sean Ella became a plastic Zaid of Tamia Shana is only by metal I mean ah me here Holly over ha a ver mommy died to claim a Pakistani status changes because you put in lead to hold it up so it's the aver that Evert Beach is a Ferris led fr not either Ivor is mom either holds it up so it now changes its status it's not called Elise hostess called the clay marques the hot color diamond if mayor says everything goes according to the minded minded means that would hold you up that would gives you so to speak your foundation that which makes you all repaired Kaylee so even though the term happen when you're a place which is but now what's your get there you got there's a claim Atlas and you were once tummy right your once tummy and it was repaired so therefore you go back to Tamia Shana that's the main but how come I'm Italian why the ikura Cora Cleese was the same because fundamentally essentially this is glass bleh le Buster reminded you don't follow the lead even though the lead is holding it up is that which caused it to be repaired it plugged the hole fine but you don't go busted on mind you go Buster Iker Kaylie meaning the majority of the vessel is not led the majority of the vessel is glass this is one interpretation in our sheet explain them on Michaels Rashi continues I an olive you know what I analysis in yanaka another way of looking at it another explanation in the argument a different explanation from now on it's an honorable death before and that's America the new Monmouth will be with a seeker I like this from now on you want to know if you want to say baa-baa-baa - Sh I can answer you that somebody if it mayor holds you gonna remind me and it's called Marcus yeah so you may think that or somebody else may think that clematis that became Tommy and it broke and it was repaired becomes taller again you know you may compare it to other claim others if you going busted are - if you want to say baa-baa-baa Tesh in yanaka another explanation clay sauces to hide and should Nick movie tool the second album the Calum of glass are pure and you perforated them and you put in let you could have been Shamu I'm it I'm on to must claim artists very nice the other way around the clay cyclists were taught her they broke it's all good it's all taught you repair that how do you repair them by pouring led into them now they become Tommy now they become Tommy after you poured let this is the Molitor you who dementia mullah says it has a din of claim offices in other words it's Tommy me not Ida Anagha band tumor if after you pour the lead into it Toma touches then we don't treat it as glass anymore which mean it is metal the hakko hey look after her my mid since these calum are being held up by the lead which plug the hole they have the halacha led them a couple to Malik Marquez I come and meet our him coming mama tired it wasn't me Matata not like we thought before they say it started me too must claim Africa's their ERISA they say it doesn't have the definition of tuna that's biblical as metal elements from too much glass hookahs their opponent they only applied to it the impurity of glass vessels which are rabbinic by nature and not biblical why Shane claim artist may in paradise to El Amin new in the passion serve kesef necrosis Basel Bedell very ferrous the only metal Caleb that ARMA Kabul to Mamina Tyra those the toyota says amicable Toma in Paris with a partial shoe cut purchase parshas matters right Matos we have gold and silver and copper and parcel iron and dill what's the deal huh what is dill bdellium okay deal bdellium sounds good cook it McKenna's cooking yeah a mid well I made a lot of bass vomit out of cook base they come back from the war of Midian and a Lhasa the son of Aaron tells them to what to be meat on here all the Kalin so he says the gold is silver the copper the iron the 10/10 the tin and the lead everything that comes into fire you should pass through the fire so this is the luck of Clematis so his glass was not counted there it's not McCobb altima meditator that herkiman would go easier tumour why as we said because it comes from Sam by the way what's the difference if it stung me that I submitted a bond is there enough cumin we know one mouth come in if it goes back to tumor after it broke and it was repaired does it go back to Toma or not right according to two minute tip atooma not tired there's a common with geyser told me that I've on they weren't guys but there's another knife come in and that has to do with burning car bonus or burning trauma meaning if a Cayenne has truman he has let's say bread that was made from grain that you gave him a stroma or you ate a carbon you have a carbon pacer you have a piece of the Lamb of the carbon pacer and it touches a Caylee that's Tommy man I'd say that somebody doesn't realize and they put the piece of me in a killers tell him in our Toyota you have to burn it if the Caylee was only Tommy Medina born on then you don't burn it you don't eat it but you can't burn it because to burn a carbon you have to have a hectare of tied it to burn it Tommy man I tell you that you could do it this time even did Ivana so then we're not title my hair huh you let it be you let it be right right right cuz you don't wanna beat Mitama yet okay so this is the second shot there now she a different shot the Milan the second shot is what it's easier to understand it it's it's it's simpler to understand because it already had the lead before and then it was Makabe tone the problem in the second shot is how hum and matheran is difficult to understand because how come and me tired in the first shot means they say it's tar the second shot they don't say it started they say it started minute ida so the words recover metallian are a little more difficult in the second shot either shot we see that yahoo dementia MOA was a town with a rib mayor so that means the young tough of cough guests are there was not made when after the instruction of the second base i McNish if that's the case how could the robber to become in this a butler McGillis tightness give all the key question yeah and for the Gemara tannoy he the question of McGillis tightness was bottle or not is really not a much locus of a million we thought it's a much like asthma may i am it's rather napkin in verses wi for an interview so of a navy that's what we thought it's a mic locus of am i right missus tonight's microsoft anna the tonya we learnt in McGillis thymus another quartz from the Gila stylus I am in my a look solving the Megillah stacks of limitless times these days that are enshrined are written in McGillis time is we're now at a fast and sometimes you know letter eulogize babies monster base amethyst Khayyam babies man shame-based amish Kaiama sooner and Magilla Steiner says these days are forbidden to fast when they base um it exists with me similar doesn't exist deviated mayor this is the opinion of Romania Rebbe I see I'm mayor of the IEC says not this monster pessimistic I am a surgeon when the base--emitter exists these days are forbidden to be seeing as days of mourning and grief widened they should simply lamb because these days are days of joy for the Jewish people ain't base-emitter sky when the way some English does not stand Muhtar it you're allowed to the chives and fast during these days why map neisha evil ahem because these days become days of grief of mourning in other words this Brice in McGillis tightness is talking about a particular situation and that is there were people who used to bring wood to the MS BAE aha what shot when they built by ash Amy in the beginning there was tremendous poverty they couldn't afford it wasn't like the first place emitters built by my mother to the point that the gomorrah says that the elder jews the elderly Jews who saw the second base emitters being built but they still remembered 70 years ago if they were 80 or 90 years old they remembered what the first base emitter looked like they were crying they were crying because they said how could you compare how could you compare the second to the first yes the poverty was so profound they didn't even if they couldn't even afford lumber and you need lumber that's the most important and one of the most important items because a stomach took her long as may have a perpetual fire on them as bailiff so what happened there were individual Jewish families who donated lots of lumber to the base of McNish to be using the base emitter and they would make a young tooth that day that they would love donate and what happened was this is called as man Atsuko herman threw out by his Shamy because of their situation because of their donation they would always celebrate this day as a young tooth this day became the young turf when they donated woods for them as beya so the v.i.c says after hurting besan McNish the celebration stops why because it's over lula it becomes a day of mourning why because it reminded them that there's nobody some exhibition there's no word for them as bear they allowed them to always perpetually throughout by in Shanee bring water on this day when they brought it the first time and there was a young to for that they will in fast they would make a Sudha there was different Jewish families in submission and kindness they would go through all the they go through all the days there so WIC says the holidays in Manila Stein is also because many of them most of them are somehow connected in his opinion to the MS BAE after the visa McNish and therefore it creates a novel and therefore since most of them I had them were bottled they already Morocco everything they already move at all everything or you could say that even the Allen tyvan that were not connected to the base on my condition nonetheless after the former base emitter they became days of oval because every young turf became a day of awful why because they remember the Yom Tov when they did it during the time of the base time if there's a different API she says it was canceled the mayor says not so we have clearly on McLucas of two million if bottle of Magilla stein is after the urban or not so now we have no problem the brighter that says that how guests are there was a young tip and when was the aunt of made after cordon bass emitters by you would have been Shamu and his friends this follows the of remain so to be who the bench ammu he made the Yom Tov of confess other because he followed the mayor that mayor holds Lloyd Buckland McGillis tynus and therefore he made a new Yom Tov even after the court man if you would ask her be I see yes you would say no way not only can't you make a new young tough even the old ones don't celebrate anymore so it's a much like this of tonight so now the question is rather economy have a question and then from the review dementia more they follow the develop you see they follow the that is do another there's another that's really good more answers this to is about my girl's thymus now the question is what's the halacha the gomorrah serves with officer the challah is this is a fascinating expression now but who said that love is bottle the luck is that McGillis tightness is bought all the oven pay for my bottle the healthiest and how lockers lie bottle they not mother this is what quantum mechanics the halacha is bottle and the love is not but if like the Gemara kasia who you have your problem yeah this sounds confusing it's a condition from one a lot against all of you tell me that how long is that McGillis time this is gone it's irrelevant then you tell me the locker that's not relevant what shot and for the camara Laye cache conv Hanako poram conversation when you said our losses that McGillis time this is like Butler it's talking about comic Emporium which are miracles that are recorded in McGillis tightness the miracles of those days became so public like we learned before about Chanukah and here we just have an additional forum they could not they did not feel they could take away these young until after the kerbin based on McNish they could not take away put him from college snow it would have been too much of a clock too much of it became too famous it became to entrench why because these young impose my not just days when you don't fast this childish Mona sigh my Thomas Livia in him and McGill led so this Porter in this lighting Hanukkah candles just saying how allow I listen whatever you do on climate can put him it became entrenched and claw his throat actually says it was like so tighter they wouldn't take it away con when it says I love the buckle McGillis time this is Bashar yummy all the other days of Magilla Stein is for example we learned gimel today with a tough guess are there all the other hollowness all the other days is multiple McGillis tightness in other words today you're a lot of faster in those days you want to make eulogies during those days they're not considered young employ them anymore to be part of it but how you have them totally stuck and we shot some up with a Mac important it was doing base addition or any doing bases dr. Rashi Taniya he Butler McGillis anatomic locus of 10 I'm about the Megillah stylus now according to the conclusion that kana can put him is like bottle Magilla stein is there is one one detail to be mentioned and that is we learned that all the holidays and Magilla Stein is you know what a faster day before you're not what a faster day after but the fact is that when it comes to Hama can put him are you a lot of fast out of convocation I would have fast out of comic well sorry that without Magilla Stein is you know that a faster of can occur because we said it goes the day before the day after right but Shmuel you tomorrow miss after tennis brings the halacha from Shmuel that it's not sure that hannah can put him even though it's not bottle the days before and after I not acerbity knows even though the Burin over there argues and he says the days before are austere Antonis but nonetheless because we see that all of Magilla Stein is his bottle booze Manasa so even though the garbage sonic emporium we can take we continue the Megillah Steiners but we are lenient about that detail that you don't have to extend the Easter to the day before the day after and therefore Arif Kamaka or a day after comic a you're a lot of fat and that's the reason we're a lot of fast when time is Esther Authority you're not a lot of fast Highness Esther why because today before put him see now with a fast Megillah Steines that's why you won't have in gomorrah the marshal or missionary you don't have a mention of time disaster now the mission in c'mon is already after the Corbin so if you say like but Allah Magilla Stein is we can understand even if you say but Allah McGillis time is but put him it wasn't bottle put him everybody says it wasn't bottle why could we fast I nice Esther the answer is because since the whole Megillah Steines was Monta la huaca they will move out on this detail that the tightness is austere even the day before or the day after that's what they did WA did it's versus ah so that means during by his Shanee when the Gila Steines was like bought law they could they could have no time assess it before they couldn't attend this Esther before and those who hold Lloyd bottle McGillis penis completely nothing so how to put him also continued and so tiny assessed is a different gather of a thymus tiny sister different get there in our generation nobody nobody knows nobody knows because it's battle our generation what we don't none none of this mmm Trivium we to make mcgillis time that's right kind of component we do yeah kind of opponent we do place this has an interesting order here har w hood the bench somewhat Amadou should have may I take a look at estimate I love PC part of you who'd have been Shamu Artemisia should have mayor since the view dimension was a tumbled over may the question is how we could make a yump if after her buy a shiny so toaster says Taemin the paydex say the tiniest in the sector tightness the gomorrah says skates up they did say the tiniest skates at part of he asks a question their estimate isha nami my area the gomorrah says that the 29th of other is acerbity nice why the hovel a yo MMA comedy it took him to media interesting question one of the holidays of McGillis time this goes from her stylishness in through a penis why that you do come had a fight with her comment and they said everybody donates different weeks people donate carbon thomas and they said no it has to come from all of Chloe's strong when they won the debate they made a jump to from rich tradition isn't the fastness and I guess they won the debate so the Gomorrah says that the 29th of other is acerbity ninis why because it's the day before rich high - listen which is the holiday of McGillis tightness from rich heritage so the day before saw some potatoes so the cameras is my area why does he say that it's awesome the time is novel a young muhammad it took me the typically novel away with the Buster estimate omnia say the other way today after have has other have test others and they have to confess other you think of castle there's a youngters so the day after is also why do you have to go later and say today be foolish - listen even without that it's a day after circus odd noises my cushion what question is this how he D took him to me deserve as much of me something to Scalia the Dean the the young term that happened because they established the whole office about carbon thumb it happened of course when the based on meters - because that's when you made a carbon tom and after the curve but it was irrelevant it was no carbon tamil anymore move did the estimate am now yeah the story of Kafka's other how you'll be made of you dimension what I mean it should have made good time dimension where the student will remain so why is the Gomora say don't make tough test or than a fog a day when you know fast because really - listen do it because of Kafka's other look like that there's a big mind when doing it because it factors because it happened much earlier in other words the Easter tiny son have tests ultimate solution is son happened years years years earlier than the Easter time is not Kafka's other what type of question of the Gemara is this the tiniest how could you tomorrow ask such a question you can doesn't make sense this happened hundreds of years before are certainly many many decades before the Ashley Mayer the Macomber coin Rabi Chassidim missional I have a Leila listener may they shouted innocent he would the be Yamaha Ashley Latoya the question is Rabi is the one who says in the Mishnah that estimate issue but other you don't net fast she says it ever you made the Mishnah he shouldn't have said actually nothing I'm Achilles time is he's holding the girls time is a mission here Rabi was Masada the Mishnah should have not said a megillah' Steines that made a she iris adenosine that it's austere because of his condition is sin Mike even the BM of I usually let Sarah in his days was already irrelevant in his days was after the formation Victor was already Butler bottle Mohammed so therefore if bottle at Ahmed you're not gonna ask her because of that the day before this writers so therefore the Shia is in his day it was already irrelevant that's the shiloh of the tomorrow if they know what traffic that's insipid a missional excited that we didn't write in the Gillis tightness that's tickle a peloton toaster so this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they you Sheba net / donate