Halachos Of A Small Minyan - Rabbi Zev Smith

i recently saw the following stories people waiting for a minion from infa and a person walked in okay no astray ashrae and he said there's no minion because what does it mean look there's six people darkening and there's four people learning where's the minion well shishmaspal was good enough so the truthers are getting a little levitic is it true you could have him with six people governing and four people learning but the truth is this question is really negative also to marry and you just have a small dominion and you don't even have ten people it's negative chakras when you want to start your main asteroid and a few people are still governing birkas krishna you don't have ten people starting from an esther it's negative as we'll soon see 10 or more that more than a few people are saying kaddish a base oval that you have six people saying kaddish only four people answering and really the question is whenever you need a minion do you have to have a minion mamish is six enough do we go by kakula and as you'll see there are many in afghanistan so the truth is the source of the concept of a minion that's the amar the mishna miguilda from the days the mishnah has a list of things that you don't say it unless you have a sorrow unless you have a minion the gemara explains we learned the concept of menya from the pasik israel minimum for abduction you need 10 people and this is quoted in sofa north and simon hey sif alif you don't say kaddish or any davos with less than 10 people in fact some say that this field of dominion is it their iso the the minimum amount of ten for kaddish could do chelating is at their eyes okay most most place can believe it's only their abundant but one thing is claw a minion must be had not one less than a million so now the question is where'd you get this she should misfollow him if you have to have a minion you should have to have 10. so the truth is what people say is rubaikakula which happens to be a gemaran hyrus that's gimel amadez bakhola taryakula kaimalan rubaikakula so if the minion is so six is enough so maybe it makes sense you don't need ten you need six and the truth is we find this in very serious context rubik akula just to give you a mission and uh one example for now the mystery speaks it out you have the chapter is also enough so there we have it maybe this concept of rubicon applies to a minion you need 10 people to dive in true but if you have six people dabbing and four people just sitting there will make a cooling but the truth is it's very hard to accept because if so is it enough to eat royba because i use doesn't make sense i'll give you a better muscle let's say you work hard one week and your boss pays you and your check is missing most of your payment a big part of it so you say what's going on here you may have to pay me a thousand dollars the check's made out to 501 dollars he says don't you know ruby kakula he's not alarmed and he's a ghanaian right so why by minion is ruby kakula good enough so i'll tell you when ruby cooley works the mishta in sanhedrin says to have a bed of been in the flushes you have to have 23 diana now it doesn't mean 23 that three dayana have to say as long as you have two more saying then potter in other words you got thirteen said and ten said pata you give me that's the londis aruba kakula out of 23 13 is enough but that you look around and bears in most of the a big part of the beds and didn't show up now how many do you have oh 13 okay let's start rubika kool-aid what's the philip very plushy you have to have a number you can't trim the number and you're like akula you have to have a casios you can't say right because i is imagine a person's a tiny coyote what's this ruben kakula you don't say look a cooler by shiren by numbers if you need a number you need a number so why should we even think ruby cacoola works so what's interesting there's a rambam in beginning of perique quest of el castrilla where the rambam says precious word that we have to hear from time to time tommy and even if you have people that do a various if you have a tzibor they're banished i'm listening to the tv now it's interesting the rambam seems to be rep repetitive the realm says you doubted that with a minion and don't die and be a fridas so i think the rambam is really a source of moisture's important fibers and again the gimbal zion where someone asked him he likes to learn late at night and he misses filipino is it a right to miss filipa because you're learning late at night where moishe says you have to realize you can't be bizarre as a fee of dr moisha it's not just a plus and a and a mile of what it is but it's a tremendous huss and moisture says a very strong argument that when possible it's almost also the davon be a fetus and listen to wisconsin that today lida we don't have proper kavanaugh no one says it in two places but today we don't have proper kavanaugh so moishe asks obvious question if we could assume that we're not going to have the right kavanagh to dive in so what's the head to the start happening a person knows before he starts dabbing he's not going to have kavanagh so what's the head to the david the twilight penis cable the territories we have one great defender and that's called filabotiva because kale you almost are certain they won't be discovered now of course if someone like elena was sick he has to die from your feet is okay he has no choice but when a person has the opportunity to happen with sibor it's almost us our motivator says you tell me you want to learn i also learned i mean but i find time for it happening you know like what's the problem why is it a steamer learning individual not a sphere but the point that maui says is it's almost us to diabetes when you have a minion available and i see that in the lotion of the rambam he says you're supposed to dab him with the tibia it's almost like this if there's no if the minion is available but be that as it made this rambam tells us the thrive of trilobativo look at that philosopher what's this so the rambam describes our davening our our khazar sashats and people listen and then the rambla says and i quote i feel lu hoyo mit saw son clarus paolo let's say you have exactly a minion and a few of them already daven you allowed to make hazards do you see what the ram is saying if we got the twilight zebra she should misspower him is enough and he points to massachusetts from the end of paraguay which is based on a passing possible tanakh regarding kadesh and buruku some say seven is enough and some say even six is enough because rubik's cooler we'll soon see the num why the number seven it's based on a perfect but we definitely see from a rambam and because the mishka highlights this that regarding the bateaver ruled by kikulai and that's why the min points out that indeed there is a source from rambam so the people that said let's start diverting we have six people dabbing they're based on a rambam the only question is why does it work no one eats fifty-one percent of kazayas matzah and thinks he's yoiza so why should feel it be different and that kasha is stronger than we think because there's the chubas katanas noon gimmel mamash asks the question that we have to answer when sometimes we say rubakukule the regatta is most talakas you need a shirt you don't see rubykakuli and he says you're right when you need a shear or a number or a weight you don't suffice with rubika cooler imagine you walk into a mix for a morning and it's mama's very little water so yes the shamans what's going on here he goes well we have roy memsa and just go so you're going to go attack him and not go to the mixture right so it's ridiculous i feel a drop is missing you can't title in it so here's your side is that when you need a shear a number amount you don't see it with a cooler but obviously regarding street if you check wife simone the animal is considered dead regarding street he doesn't speak about sri lanka but the head of some soy foreign also discusses ruben kakula and it's a little more custom-made for us and to put in the safest lotion we don't say rube and listen to his brilliant martial he says marshall of khabib and 13 say the man is kayed so he gets lisa but if just 13 show up you can't pass can ruby kakule you have to have the amount 23 from 23 rule boy meet kulai not kukule rubai mikuli started with 23 and then 13 say hi it's good enough but you can't trim a number and say uber kakula and listen to his martial one of his muscles show him you need 10 people for double shipping no one's going to say as long as you have seven people we could start because rubik's cooler that's the show so this sun safe already says when we need a minion a number an amount we don't say rebukaku anderson says the same is true you can't touble in a mikvah that's missing a drop of memsa but let's say you have a mick for memso and some of the water is puzzled then we say beethoven arrived because we'll be kakula so we're starting to see rubika cooling is not an easy pass to trim but what's most custom-made is someone answered our very sheila i heard that if you have six davenes is is enough to make philippa atheba and a moisture that's not true if you need 10 dominance for a minion you need 10 and not one less than 10. because ruby kakula does not work with shielding does add that's probably implicit in the lash nagamore in bronchus says basically if you need a million of ten you need ten divers so whoever told you shishma's fallen works is making a mistake sai from the gemara is not above and also in swar the only question is what about the ramban where moishe did not forget the rambam so in that shoot where moishe explains look again you'll see son of the rambo the rambam starts off in mahalaka with what's trilogy how look at that here's what the rambam is saying let's say you had six people dabbing and there was no minion they died in six people then they say you know what let's make hazardous shots we have four people that are willing to answer the question ah that's good enough because you have roids if six people dabbing that's enough to make harasser shots and it's lush of the rambam kate that's one person gets up and dabbins and mighty them all that's kazar not philip so here we have a rambam that pashtus seems to say ruben kakula many others learn it's not a right but there's another raya that even rubico cooler works and that is in simmons quotes it and i'll read the last who adds a very key few words the poison we are talking about when you have less than a minion so again the magnum says that if you have six people that dive in trying esther that i could see begum or six people and you can make hazardous shots so mr brewer uses that word six is arrived gummer a complete seaborn so this is a raya to what we're looking for that rubika kulai is considered to feel about sibo but i'm sure you realize that it's not really a ryan because i'm gonna run mr we are talking about make hazard shots so maybe the six people never didn't have twilight because there's no there's no dinner cooling but they can make hazardous shots and we'll soon see why that's possible attack of emotion that shiva says the mother of rama is not a raj it's like the rambam it's saying then six people is enough but for minion you need ten people darkening but before we apply this lemaiso we have to see one more the kayode in the beginning of cloud your test says the biggest sight graduates could i to mention because like he says it's a toyota's god there are some people that are moisten their fish to dive in with minion but they don't know the true definition of tilapia you see people come to diving with themselves nephews but they either they come a little late or they dive in slowly or they take the time the kids are they answer borojo and they answer kadusha but at the end of the avenue after the tiber finished could they back at their own pace and firstly you come late they have no choice but i made barack oh i said kadusha and that was my nurse when i leave saying ashley the real chill of the thieves ten people half the davinci reinescent together in other words what he's saying is boroku and kadusha and laning is great mybus and tv lebatebo but the real thrill of atiba is you dabble with the minion so that filler goes straight up and the merge bomb accepts philosorable that's the point of kayode but as our moisture and many others point out but look at the way he describes filipino what's he saying that we don't settle off ruby cool you need 10 people dabbing in estrada so now we have say there's no dinner rubikaku like however it's not really so convincing because the kyogre's main point is that the ikea is schweinster so what should he say six is enough i mean that's that's you know not typical 10 people but the way though i saw the base borough is perish on the hayatum he says it's a hell of what people say in the name of the odom that he never said people say you have to have ten people his point is not ten versus six his point is that the icca of trilobites don't come late and catch baruch and catch kadusa and hear laning and go home i dab with a minion the ikky is dabbing with the zebra now typically it's zebra is ten but loved africans so maisha says it's a raya from the other silva says don't put words in the in the mouths of the other so in interesting in igor's moisture the next two of them someone wrote through a moisture maybe it's not arriving maybe had them just means to say that as long as you damage my nest says then why do you have to say this whole thing the ick is the dab and pen together he should have said the ikea tree of baseball is so this is the challenge of our original simple question does ruben kakule work with for kazarus for tilapir we have the following the passage of the rambam and the magnum was right is enough but it's not a riot the passage of the other means that you need ten it's fighting but let me tell you one thing we have to clarify before you apply the islamizer and that is what's tack of the swara of those that say and hold that roid is enough for still of its evil if you have to have a casalis and you can't satisfy yourself with 51 if you have to pay your work a hundred percent why should filibus be enough six why is it different than a reverse you can't have a rival vias in the case the terrorist i think is positive the the field is to have a minion that's at their isa or they're born and that's non-negotiable now once you have a minion so i'll say rule boy meet kula i'm not going to say six people and shows enough that's the show 10 people i have 10 years now once i have the number 10 i have a minion so how much is filabotsiba ruboi metoyakula i know there's two denim minion now those that are mahmeer and say you have to have 10 avenues they say there's no spout it's all the same it's one of the same a minion of the avenues that's philippa zebra so this is basically a poison valid regarding philippe cebu now what is halakhala mesa so i'm not qualified to answer but i'll tell you what i saw and sim and savage he got in the base did a homework for us and he has a long list of places that hold that ruby cooler works and some that doesn't work but the truth is the kasa mishna is from the earliest source that says ruby cooley works with he says they're horribly suffic that you have to have 10 people happening to make it feel a placebo but it's interesting that most poisons seem to say rubika cooler works the brisker of intrusion of conveys and the haziness and that's not the all insist that you need ten people dabbing we don't say you're like a cooler but leader and this is noteworthy in the pisces he quotes uh close to him more than a half a dozen poiskon all say that the minute always was to rely on rube kakula in other words sixth daveness is enough they all wonder why people disturbing the peace now this is interesting and i think i can understand why they're all saying that because the earlier players can do it now the real cooler works now i'm not saying that the prayer and the whisper of and uh malicious is disturbing the peace but as the manhattan writes people started talking maybe you have to have 10 governors but all those places they all grew up in europe and they all say i saw all over in lithu in hungary and poland that people were saying so although the taina the how could six work is a good taina but it seemed that the minig was that the velvet relied on rubika cool again the other leo was the earlier the 150 years before it was lifted he was ready he was nifty so you talk about someone that lived two days ago he'd consider convinced that you that you don't serve a cooler but i think we could say that the minute always was to rely on ruka cool if it's filabot sieber i'll say let's follow the mishna brewer right but that's hard because the mr brewer quotes the modern agreement that six is a simple gummel but he also quotes the hayaodang that the ichithila zebras are diving 10 people together so back to our rally is that that bring us in different directions so what i think we could say is that basically the minig was to rely on rubicon but their epiduralia poison that insists unless you have ten davening bishas nicer that would not be filipitibo i also want to make another point even if you hold ruben cool it works who said it just like we find we look forward to pesach that really at the but the avid roy works so maybe even if you hold ruby cool it works with fila but sieber maybe it's only but the other so i think we could say that the minigun was to rely on chisholm espalier for the vetiver some say you need 10 and even though that are mako the fire is preferable to have 10 governors to have a real field of achievement now let's apply this lemisa and here's the question basically we began with someone walked into shul but and he got a hero's welcome okay let's start ashrae he looks around there's only six people with him but they're dabbing uh relying on rubika cooling so again it's not so plushy but if they need him he should dabble with them because this is the mini gistral of ricka cooler the truth is that the police can say that if you dive and tackle it with such a minion chakras so for us you'll say oh davin what do you have to lose you know what this is could be a very tricky question in eritrea they don't every morning by chakras if it's not a real to feel a baseball then you and the police can say when you have a minion of ruby cooley regarding chakras so that gives us some confidence that indeed ruben gekule is a valid minion if you did it certainly with the evid and you not only you could that you could rely on it but even the kakayon kuduken okana buddha when you have this small minion the next question is when you rely on river kakula do you have to have six or seven now the first person that gave me this question was that sam seif what i mentioned in sim and kuffman and he keeps on saying for trilobite sever seven would be ruby cooley regarding hazardous shots where'd the number seven come from i'm not i'm not great in math but i think six out of ten is right right so what comes to mind is brachisto memphis regarding zimwin that how many do you have to have that ate bread to make a zima basara seven ruba dominica so the question does that apply to our tulip yeah if it's especially a bin regarding zimon so who said it applies to tila but the embassies besides of some sofa dimension seven the shivali elected one of them he says if you have seven people that are dabbing you allowed to make hazardous and he says mother benching which is only one bracha simon you seven's enough you have to have seven but kosh game shots you have to have minimally seven and there advas also says that those that say seven it's ruba dominca but he says i'll explain why if you have to have seven people that are answering so then as the way the lesson is it has to be nick of the coil and nick of the coil is only when you have seven not six if you have to have numbers so then six is enough but you have to have answer is my clarissa shots it has to be very nica and it's only have seven aruba dominica might he himself was make one six but we do have a source of seven the i play where else i saw the number seven as opposed to six six the character in tough coup sandbag rob seat cotton dolly has an interesting shirt you have a minion on the tiniest and not all the people are fasting can you dive because as long as there are seven people aruba domenco that are fasting so you see regarding a minion for time is you have to have seven not six but i must tell you i guess it is a point when the belt is maykal on ruba kakulai the number is six and i saw that very respectfully says maybe i'm sure branson's life was saying the truth and where he lived they needed seven but where i lived i was i lived in europe i lived in a in erits israel developed relies on six to be ruby cooler so this is basically the aside that if a person wants to rely on ruba kukule so you could even rely on six because that seems to be dominica island now the mice if someone has only six people and they can wait till they get 10 dividends i've added tamayo don't forget that 10 is a millionaire holidays but let's say a person on a plane and you know some people don't want to die for now and and other people let's have an hour or never says even though my shoulder is not to feel a baseball but a shasta like this is this or nothing avadik rely on shisha mastalan rubagakula is enough if let's say you have a shoe now and they're relying on rubika cooler should i dabble with them or i could travel and find the minion go to la masala and get a minion of 10 dominance he says definitely it's worth the extra effort because after all some say it's not enough but we can't be miss owls challenging question you walk 10 questions you walk into school and you get a hero's welcome you are number six and you're not interested in relying on christmas album and i'm leaving they say when you're leaving we're not gonna have a minion so it's two questions if you already walked in and you're number 10 in their eyes can you walk out or number two you're walking by and they call you uh 10 to 10 so yes and 10 to what center person or david no you're number six and you keep on walking you walk by so let me tell you that if you're in school already and you're number ten to walk out it's not safe remember you can't ruin a minion so that is positive that if you're in shoot already and you're number 10 by walking out you're going to ruin the minion so better be from and stay with them and don't ruin a minion he holds that rubicool does not work with tilapia he all the kermisha and the uh yana leo you have to have 10 davinas but yet in the same sticker he says if they need you to make up a minion then dabble with them and do the festive and rely on ruben kakula even he says even if it happens a lot every other day you walk by the shoulder very shakka attendance and they every day they need so he seems to say it's not philippa sieber but if they're doing it stay with them tremendous mischievous i see this you know from and crumb is sometimes the invisible line but he says it's but i think the point that you have to see is that insisting on a sore mustang is not a wild but also true that relying on she should must follow him is not as well the cooler it seems to me strong and basically when someone helps a minion like that he's not doing it he's just complying with minigola next question comes up all the time let's say you had a full minion okay 10 people dabbing and believe it or not they all started but the maester come to shmonesra you look around and one person is telling krishna and he's still saying he's close when he heard from desolate that in kelm they were they were so disciplined that they all started they said goliaths rolled together and the whole minion started barakat hashem but laughs look out if you look around today it's interesting that people are holding here's my question you have a minion of 10 or more even but it comes this way necessary looks around and it's basically uh all along he puts together six people could you start trying esther or do you have to wait for a sore miss following so everybody say this is mama's the same child if you hold that fishman you have to have ten and we don't do the cooler like where moisture then you have to wait that's not a half stick because it's sarah of course don't be quick to say girl you struggle and then turn around give yourself some leeway wait and look around but if you hold like the minutic seems to be that rubrica cooler works so then you could start now what should the civil do typically it makes sense that if he could wait so wait the problem is on a morning rush hour during davening we with not even sneeze because that's where this is but certainly to wait so again if the sibo is it moving and everything they have to be out by a certain time he has all the right to say let's start as long as we have she shouldn't stall them it's the same concept that shishma's palin is considered maybe this is better than a typical shishmaspal because here the other four are dominating with you but one's holding by krishna and one's older than beerus one's older by ezra's they're not just four people sitting in the back and answering and that's what that means if you have to have a sore mustang it's transfer but myself without that slaughter i think it's important to realize that have 10 daveness but if the people are behind and the people have to go and again this is terrifying sibura you could start with six misfollow them now if you want to make a point and hope it reaches those that if they get two when you do that with a minion but tsum tsum it's a it's a responsibility it's in a crisis you have to make the minion work now some people typically dive in in a small minion that's where it is and it's it's budget and avalobino they either come late or dive and slow or both and every day they turn a minion into a a machis why because if you dive in all ten together you can make trilobite holidays and have a wonderful david but one or two people are dabbing slow and they didn't have gabon so you want to dive in slow and have honor go to a big minion because they're dead but if you're part of a minion and they need you you're one of the ten you have to keep up with the zebra if need be even skip part of sukhothi zimbra but it's not right because of his hindu to make the entire minion into a mask like is if it's silhouette that's something that you have to realize is the responsibility of a person that was together with a minion with something next question when do you start in other words let's say they're all kalamas and they all started on time but something muslims ran esther so this we spoke about it before the last year it was paid 10 57 but to make a long story short the mahabharata steve dalit says you have to have tisha nine people ends listening and answering for the broadcast if not it's a bracha a car of leonis of lebato hazard shot is different than felipe siva you have to have nine listening and answering now this is based on a rush in the chubus cloud why are you repeating it the terrorists what justified another hazard if you don't have that it's a brochure that's the sheet of the and you know what that's like her body site that's like gosias of matzo you need a kazias not not roy of and regarding hazardous shots you need tisha not roy because the original takana of hazard shots was you need nine people answering so you can't chop his eyes into 51 percent and you can chop tisha oinen into six and that's why by federer is the most common now the question is let's say you have a minion but sometime and you have some one fellow who's a slow moving moving vehicle pardon me and he takes forever can i recruit someone that already haven't and say you'll be then the teacher ain't in you answer and the answer is why not i he ready to have it but then again we also have in the ready parrots you need nine answers so you can recruit one or two as many as you need until you get to roy that of the davinder the big question is by meyers and here's the question you have a minion but something of 10 people and you started on time everything is doing great but again people are behind so we would say you have to wait to say goddess now you have nine people answering but in same way earlier he says if lamasa one person is still diving and he can't answer the kaddish or he's sleeping you're allowed to start kaddish the magana rum says as long as you have a minion in the shoe you could say kaddish but wait he quotes that even if you have three or four diabetics you could say kaddish because you have a minion and you have roy that are answering you hear that and the obvious question is but in kofka steve dollars you have to have nine and here he says you only have to have six right four dividing six left so there are a few to roots in but i think what the developed assumes that the isotherate is based on the rabb in non-hazard where the rav says the philip is passionate regarding kaddish that's a regular double ship exam what's minion 10. now your question is how many have to answer no that's i the way we're going to say it rule boy me cooler you have a minion you have 10 bodies there but now you throw how many have to answer right is enough like you have a vias of wine the kicks you drink review answering kaddish is a regular dinner of ruby kakula but khazarsa shots the whole hectare repeat this right answer is if you have tisa oinin so we can't say right when you need nine in other words it's only hazardous that you have to have t it's the regular din of a minion so make sure you have 10 people in the show and shisha oinim would be enough actually i should be more medic you don't have to have six answering you have to have roive answering so if the shots looks around and five finish my nasra five are finished four still happening so it's shisha including the shots so the shots is one and five finished monster kaddish even though four are still happening so the philip is hazard versus kaddish after myra now i should mention that the mahabharata does say that allah in the same seminun hey that if possible the shot should wait till everybody finishes my nasra so they could be zoyokin answering to kadish alabai you could do that and you know be mazaki then that's their rights but if someone ashats realize people are rushing that as long as he has five finishing and he's the sixth that would be roy's rubika cooler so it comes out something very important to stress there are really three levels in this sugiya thila batibor needs a minion is shisha mespaulom considered a minion that's good to start with a shot you need t-shirt oining and that's the way it should because my makeup if one's missing that's the sheet that the yoshi is good enough but you're talking about the curvy as behind we try to have nine on them for kaddish after my reef that is enough five finishing with the shot is six a really tough question i hope it should have been again it lets you have a minion but sometimes everything is going great the others started together they're saying for the shots they're all answering in middle someone has to go to the bathroom pardon me and he walks out and you look around and you're missing nine people you don't have a minion even so the embassies that will say you have to wait for two reasons you don't have t-shirts opinion but there's a lock in simeon and hey see base and steve gimmel that if you started with a minion and someone walked out of the middle you're allowed to finish that thing now this is the big sugar we have to talk about it in the chair for itself but this might qualify to be the sac in our case he walked out hopefully he has a he's an ionis but right now you look around you only have nine people and eight oinin but you have the aloha once you started now if you think it's the right thing to wait till it comes back no maybe it's you know you can wait but it's first i'm not right for the t but not right for the person it's very embarrassing everybody's waiting for him so again if it works out then you could wait for him because him to hate but if not if the accident feels not going to be happier than waiting continue saying as you started the foreign what is a question we hear from time to time people are learning in school in late morning or early afternoon and a few people come in and they want to dabble what time is it don't ask they want it happen okay albertson we need you you have to answer we have six people dabbing and we want you to be part of our minion that's that's that right because this is my time for learning why should i stare because of you know you're because you're a minion now you don't have a minion and looking at the time it's back to something therapy and why people dive in so late way after this month's feeling so that's not like the previous case where there's an established minion are looking for a minion the point that i think is important these the chuvas in the hadasha's caleb he has a fascinating shiver he is just a minion and they're relying on a cotton as one of the minion which is a big macho kiss a poison and simon hay so he says you should walk out and don't be part in that avala forget about everything else you can't partake in that avalanche now people are dabbing after fatsoys and they want you to starve to dominion that might qualify for this statement that you don't be part of that minion when it's really connected allah now la maison another question that comes up that when people could not put together a minion partially they couldn't have a minion so they dive in separately and after they finish they realize hey there's some people here maybe we could put together hazard shots so bizarre can say so this is what we mentioned earlier this is simon samartest if you have six people that haven't now you could make a full-fledged hazard the magnum says and mr says that that's considered glommer and you could in fact say a regular hazardous shots i once heard this shout out to an interesting question they had just this they had six people davening no minion no children's even and then they wanted to make a harasser shouts the problem is one of the six admitted afterwards as after they started that he's a cotton he was wearing a hat wearing film because he was at three months was by mitzvah whatever a month before can you rely on five and a cup so the radhvasan that took a valid symmetra has this very shallow and he says you know what you could you could do it maybe you rely on the cotton and also some to say one's enough okay and here's the problem about to start laning and one of the people establishment i don't know where he was for those shots but here's the question can you start lane we have exactly ten and one davening so you're wondering what's the shield there's no dinner of tisha ironing but here we come to a bigger side because the past is as from the surface the michigan megillah you need 10 people for laning why do you need 10 people for laney so pasha ain't doves with your focus that's the passengers but the ran on nakamura and i quote that candidate will i take you need a minion fellaini it's a special tack on us what's that after me to these two reasons either or takanis let's say one of the ten is not listening to laney either he's learning sam or he's dabbling if you hold double shipping conducion needs 10 so you have rubika cooling if you hold that you have to have 10 people for laning and listening then you have to have 10 people you don't see rubikakula by a number he's understanding that if number 10 to listening and that's why the allah discusses this very question and he says like this prema god that it's possible that a minion for laning is more hammer than anything even people listening to the entire hazard and he said i'll prove it to you because there is a in shock that if one person missed those shots he could make puris and make a neutralizer so we hold six but no one says for people laning one person misleading can make laning to make laning with the broncos you have to have 10 people actively listening to the lane so it comes out of an iphone that laning is more than even 10 people listening to the lane now what's interesting is the kayode in cloud seafood isle of clares let's say you only have roy people six people that want to make a lane they have a million but only six didn't hear laning as long as you have you need 10 people no suffoc if 10 people misleading you could make another lane if just seven you can make a lane and listen to this criticism and kuffman gimble says as long as you have roy ming that did not hear laning you could lane again [Music] all say if six people miss laning marshall they landed in a flight and they want to make a laning six is enough to make lane says this so to me at first was a plea bill you have to have ten listening how does he have to have how do you say that six is enough that's not a cash at all you have to have ten people listening true so you'll have six people in here laning four listeners and you have a wonderful meeting then we'll say ruby cooley listens that would not then yet but if you have 10 people in the shoe and one is not listening that's much worse another minion but tsum tsum that's a i think the sticker mitzvah sim ram and simon says it says that after learning don't mistake and think that as long as you have 10 people by kaddish you could say kaddish ashrae in other words not just a minion for the kaddish but a minion for what's mecca of the kaddish and in this case what's michael the kaddish ashrae or cabanas in the morning or learning with dominion it's not enough to have a minion for the kaddish that's a problem because in some schools for cabanas it's a no-show i mean they say kaddish on the carbonis you know in a different uh you know like the cabanas is a an older minik where the sugar bonus became a carbon you have to have a minion now barak hashem for us the taz and nun hey sit cotton gimbal says i don't think that's true he doesn't call his mother he says the icos you have to have a minion for the kaddish for the cry of the kaddish he says regarding the concept of sukhoda zimmer and myriv could be the modern ram is made that you don't need 10 people so it's very hard to know what to do la maison because the mr guru does say the best thing should be if someone knows he doesn't have a minion for caddish of cabanas or ashrae to say three succumb after the minion comes so again i want to be very clear that regarding learning it's best to have 10 people at least by something to make the kaddish by ashrae if there's no minion for ashley i have a few people when you came later at least on this of the task a thought-provoking question i once thought about this you have a base oval you're gonna have six or seven of the ten same kaddus what do you do you don't have to you don't have anybody answering you have two three people answered so here they i saw they're after all them in failing bay and there's nobody else they could all say kaddish so he says and how about when you say spanish three times a day you end this when i serve amen who are you talking to territory talking to them is going into my locker and then he says you know but my kindness could be you have to come on to this because whoever's listening maybe someone's walking by the base level and he hears the kaddish but the wrath for all of the troopers is convinced if you have 10 of them saying kaddish that's the entire minion a minion but um they could all say cabbage and no one answers he says maybe i think of his kaddish maybe but he holds 10 people kaddish is fine now in his safer vanishing you see he modifies it somewhat he's at least one person should be answering says once you're modifying it have two people answering so the imro on me that's fine but it didn't 10 people saying kaddish no problem memory is one more important and that is when you have two three minutes should they divide dominion to make two million available so the truth is that when you make two minyana mitsumitsamim it's fraught with difficulty i'm talking about you may you have 40 people i make 20 and 20. so emotion says even if you have 40 people and the both myanma will not be mutsumsum it's not proper to divide a minion and he says potion if you dabble in this shule you could say in the field sapayam regularly if you dive in the hallway you can't see the fuel supply because i'll say more so the gemara gives a special of taka to kedusha's base like kinesis impacting stavening if you dive in the hallway it's not produced basically but they're moisture but let's say you have bhattai madrashin and you have two shoes but lemaisi says you are still encroaching on freyja because there's a myeloma based on gamoras of roy from hajj smaller simon you can't divide a big demon into small siemens riva so moishe says who says because a person has a fierce he could divide a minion and take away from of the aguero he has other problems typically the people dive in the hallway and one minion disturbs the other you can't hear what's coming what's going also the misspelling don't have a malcolm kevour and they don't have uh the cloud they they learn in one place most of that we learn it's just a problem but then he says what really was convincing but he saw his own eyes there was once 28 people in the shul and there were three khiyovans so people are very creative when it comes to an ahmed so they had nine nine nine and one fellow was in the middle and he didn't starve to all three of them now this reminds what i heard once someone who came in to made a two-minute on him and it was a disaster somebody asked them knew how many are various did you do they'll say conditions your father today a shop i wouldn't talk that way but you're good you know we're out to make sure not judges so to disturb people to push people to join a minion in a basement in a hall upstairs downstairs you know even if it's done right sometimes it's lacking now i want to make a point also what he says and he says grow exponentially 20 is not 2 times 10 20 is many more times 10 because that's the way it works it grows so he says even if you have to switch off with another field and what you do here is my read and you're diving 40 people with one minion you get more custom in the diary once then that will be two small million that's what he wants to say now this is easier said than done people like the ahmed i want to mention on the tough i invest they say that disgust of keeper of allows you to divide a minion but as they both stress that's only if both miyanim will be done properly in other words to cut it into two miniatures of ten and you have to rely on all sorts of coolest is it sorry in god if you have two nice menu on them and adapting in but russian not in the hall not outside hanging out you know from this way or that way if it's done right then there is it's sad to be making to divide me on them that's taken a mini we need for a minion 10 people some say the rice some say they are bonan but no one says ruben kakule regarding the number 10. the question is for twilight but sieber can rely on shisha must follow them some said you need ten nothing less mini golem is to rely on chisholm as follow them seven is a hither but the ik is sheesh is also enough and basically it's not a new minigla huckle and it's not a wild if a person is could wait for a better minion or go to a full minion it's never better but don't ruin a minion of six that are relying on this balloon and it's not khalid the starch main estimate chakras the best idea is to have ten people but if six are ready to start your lattice thoughts feel a baseball on a participant of minion but something to make it work make sure you're there because you have to have nine answering and by the way they have to listen and answer to get some of the answer to be one of the nine is okay mired when possible you should wait for nine to the minute to finish but six is enough if one of the teachers should go to the bathroom you can continue going khazera says you could say if six didn't hear khazar says shots but the other even a cotton could be added but laning is most common you need ten people listening if six misleading you can make another laning and again the ten have to listen kaddish needs a minion but for the learning or the ashrae or the the cabanas you could be signed up that as long as there are 10 now and to make 2 million on them if it's done right it's fine but it shouldn't be done about the evidence