Halachos of Coffee - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

welcome home volume two today she love are going up Yonkers emilita today she had sponsored by mesh Pakistan tur billion is mass Rafal dovid Baraboo's kaya a year here with distillation with after distillation also need wasa beets external issuance of a rubber field three but I'm Aisha RA la vie the Earth's a take-off Davis and now her other gonna be ACOs F Smith Lita someone knows that subject today was seeing a lot cuz of coffee asked me a whole share about coffee I told him actually not actually now we have to shear in our coffee after I started I realized that it's really two different sugus but today I'm gonna focus on the office of coffee specifically beginning with a festival and bring us all the way to help us pour them and everything in between as well see there's a host of questions specifically about coffee you know those we're not talking about the bracha crying on coffee if it's hot or preparing coffee on Shabbos or the big sugar of coffee and Bishop aquam but coffee in its unique status the feature of coffee is something you don't find by other food and explain every other food you could eat it raw or cooked coffee which comes from coffee bean as well soon see is not edible you can't eat the coffee even after you cook them coffee is grown to make coffee beans are grown to make coffee and this presents a host of Sheila's begin again with hillcrist filling and her first Fela and his breakfast and Cosima can you use coffee for calm our Medina for kiddush for half dollar drinking coffee out of the silk etc etc I guess a poem Shiloh VI - laughs - by sending coffee but basically before we enjoyed the cilia we have to know a little bit of the Matthias has an initial set of mistaken Matthias is worse than a mistake in our locker and proximate we did our homework and I'm gonna try to share with you the MIT seus that's important for this sucio coffee grow on a tree it's not like choy and beans that grow in the ground it grows on a tree just like cocoa beans grow on a tree coffee and cocoa beans grow on a tree i why do we call the beans new welcome to the oiler my shaker why they call it buckwheat and there's no scientist to eat but what's more fundamentally difference between a cocoa bean and other beans and other vegetables for that matter cocoa bean as we said you never eat if you want to really appreciate this you think about 80 big a teabag hasn't it a tea leaf the tea leaf has a very good taste and an aroma but no one eats the tea leaf that's where you keep it in a bag coffee is the same way you roast the coffee then you cook the coffee and you but you never never eat the coffee bean the coffee grind so how is it made so again I could explain it in detail but it's really not a cure but basically what isn't a Gale my locker there are two methods of making coffee every master that is today is used first you take the coffee bean and you roast it now roasting the coffee bean gets out the flavor now I will say this do the same they roasted the coffee beans then they ground it coffee grind and then you cook it now cooking gets out the essence get out the flavor of the coffee and now you have what we're going to call for a good reason coffee soup now don't get insulted how do you call my coffee a soup you know people are very good I feel very very much into coffee but the MS is that's really what it is when you cook the roasted ground beans you get out the flavor of the coffee beans just like a crazy chicken soup or a vegetable soup you get out the essence of the thing you're cooking so that was the way that coffee was made for centuries you cooked a bit the coffee beans you got out the flavor and you with the advent of electricity it was made much easier by using a percolator today they have the cake ups the Keurig which is the same idea you buy ground coffee grind the ground coffee and with electricity you percolate it but also it also gets out the flavor of the coffee beans so coffee beans are roasted they're ground and then you cook it either in a percolator or today in the Curia getting the cake up the then we enter the instant error where everything has to be instant and no one has time to make coffee not even to make with a percolator so then they invented what's called instant coffee now the truth is it's the same idea the company whether it's Maxwell House that used to be very popular taste this choice they take the coffee beans the coffee grind they cook it and now you have the same coffee we call coffee soup but you can't sell it with the water so they extract the water from that coffee that they produce now there are two methods the old-fashioned method is by removing the water by cooking it by by heating it actually I should say you spray the coffee with a hot air turn 480 degrees Fahrenheit and the water of the coffee is evaporate and you're left with the hydrated dried coffee crystals that was the popular method of doing it you remove the water and you're left with the coffee the custom of the freeze-dried it's supposed to protect the quality and the aroma you chilled the coffee you freeze it this is called sublimation and to make it into like slabs of coffee you remove the water by the method of freeze drying and now you have what's called freeze-dried coffee so it's really not a gaya how you do it but coffee was made by cooking coffee removing the water and now you have the essence of coffee now when you buy instant or freeze-dried coffee you put back to water and by arif I invite you back to the coffee that's very appropriate we live in a door of Gil gülen that's what you're doing you'll be creating the coffee they cooked it took out the water you put it back close the kalila and everything is fine so it's what's they gave us even if no you can't now make your own coffee but basically there are two types / curated coffee including the the new recent k cup which cooks the coffee and your own house and then there's the instant coffee that they cooked it and moved water and you put it back but now let's talk tactless what's the proper broker on a cup of coffee whether it's instant coffee percolator coffee so really what's important and I think this is really the gets us to the crux of the issue how would you classify what is the status of a cup of coffee is it 95 percent water which it really is but there's the strong flavor of coffee whether it's the coffee grind whether it's instant coffee but essentially coughing is like raspberry syrup just a different flavor there's water and is a flavor so is a cup of coffee primarily water with a flavor or maybe how dare you say coffee is water coffee is a very question of mascar even though there's so much water but now it's a masker that's called coffee and you could think how many nasca mean is they would be for example is the official akkem when a guy makes four he'd a brewed cup of coffee going to a coffee shop assuming there's no problem of conscious but the guy cooked it with olive outside if it's 95% water no bishop are come by water if it's a massacre hush the massive cold coffee it's awesome all awesome there would be bish alack what bravo do you make on coffee if it's 95% water with the flavoring my grass berry syrup the broncos a shackle if it's a new midsi is called coffee well it comes from a coffee bean and the coffee bean grows at a tree and it's grown to make coffee it might be I ate so this question as we'll see effects entire or Italian which is today's sugah but another question which you also have to Claire is how do you identify a coffee powder instant coffee freeze-dried or whatever it may be which brand is that the essence of coffee is it coffee is it just a powder so if you think objectively which means not what do I do because who said that's right what should I do there's a strong reason to believe that a cup of coffee would be a buyer creates because let's think where do we have in a lover an analogy to this and you cook something and you have a soap what rough is it enough to think too far this is sodium prophesy climate test Cheeta my the silca silca liam beet soup the broth is Adama Maya the lifter turnip soup is Adama Maya the coolest luck shulkie the coolest shulkie the Gemara is saying clearly that a vegetable soup is a boy ready prehung now as i told you it's a this desuka of soup is a big circuit we once gave a whole share about this because it's a big question how could a vegetable soup be our Dumber the Gemara early in broth Islamic us says if you squeeze an orange may Paris the breakfast shackle so there's a rush there's a rash well this is a mortar fight all say different shot them which is not Nagaya for us but basically the rush says when you cook something you get out more of the flavor than when you squeeze it so juice that squeezed is a shackle vegetable soup that's cooked is our Dahmer the Roger says that since the vegetables are eaten that way so if it's an Adama but juicy fruit and are we supposed to eat the fruit not to make the juice the modify says a soup is an eye soul you eat it or dip bread into it but apple juice arm induced is a Mashka but it's the other day we could say very carefully there are numerous vegetable soups that Medina Gemara and chiffon are and Seminary say the proper broth is very pre-adamic now generally our soups today are a shackle if you have balding or locks in its Amazonas but definitely alpide dinner Gemara there's something called a vegetable soup that's the by OPI don't now I asked you if that's the case if you have a quote a coffee soup or as we call it a cup of coffee which you cooked the coffee beans the ground coffee beans and you made it into a coffee shouldn't that be a real boy or a 308 okay vegetables you sometimes eat and some of you cook it but coffee is made that's its Eloy that's its function that's why you plant coffee beans to make coffee and if you want a more custom a dryer the Gemara the same Kumar and Broca's Lima test discuss is mired the shifter shifts up is Shepard service as a spice which is typed as dill some call it a nice that's really the same family the chef as dill or anis is not eaten plain it's only eaten when you cook it and the Gemara says that on this Maya the ships on the Sheva soup the broth is very pure though because that's the way it's used and that's why as early as the elohist gitanos lives just about over 350 years ago in Fela Calif simin tests was asked mama SH this question Kate said Mubarak and I'll kava says trouve it is a copy ain't in Africa because you hi Alec Island I say first you roast it boo Royal Avila Lucretia doctor nice and then you grind it on the fashion label my mom is like I told you who are you hi Olivera followed by a pre Adama eleda I'm at the barrel of our charcoal but the meaning is to make a shot now when he says boy Eric Lee Adama is a pelham and tackled America Thea in similar age dollar grant reminisce why have gamma it should be eight so there's a tubers poulos avec that says that it's a toy a cipher in horses guitarists and it should be boy pre-race because the coffee bean grows on on the tree soup is the vegetables I've done but look what he said it should be a bio create so that's according to the revised that the gear sir but the mini is to make a shackle know why the vinegars will soon see put all eight makes a lot of sense and he's not the only one the panama erased in Keighley base simon cooked Sabich writes made elijah mayan boris that I when I was in information burns the city worms the goggle have dirt very called small satin made on T Boyer pre-adamic and I asked him I argued with him but the whole belt makes the shackle me before II so you told me but a minute toys I don't want to follow and T is a burpee a dump now I want to explain why is T by RP automa a t leave grows on a tree just like any other boy it creates the answer is a 308 is a Blair create a leaf is not a pain you notice like it's like today to have heart of ponds heart of palm comes from a palm tree which is a huge tree but still the minute is to make a butter pure dumb why Adamo because you do not eating the pre of the 8 you're eating to 8 the harder part is the center of the trees so very similar is a 80 leaf it's not the prelates it's the 8 it's delete so we see Liholiho the fun Amira's records a minik to make auntie a burpee I don't know according to that is no doubt on coffee the breakfast bar creates and the Putterman ears himself is nighter to make on tea a burpee Adamo because it's mom-ish like mace Lockleys now ok that's ok look Alif Simmons South decay in hayleybay that I mentioned he mellows and he says but then I can't say I don't want to be different everybody else so I'm a Concha I'm Tia shackle but her voice say it's not so outlandish to make on coffee or AIDS and I will say how could this be if I eat plain coffee bean or plain tea leaf there's no bra at all but on a tee Kodama and coffee o8 is up the Ponte mirus what's the costume cheves the same thing no one eats plain dill plain dull you don't make a brothel but if you cook the deal so now the super comes out dama so I can coffee vo eighths and tea for the same reason our dumb don't forget this is why coffee is grown to produce coffee not to eat the beans in fact he brings a bass yosef the parameters make the base your Isis and simin rage doubted that I may vary it I mean you take rose and make a a soup out of it the broker is like the Verret itself very pure dumb why because that's the way of using it so to say her eights on coffee or Adama on tea is not outlandish but as we see both are Bacchus katanas and the Panama erase who say our aides are mayor that the minica island is to make a shackle and the big question is why but now we see it's a bigger question than just a three mistake of why the big question is why is it different I made schlock ice then made Chevis various soups atta boy opiod um so it's probably the earliest jouvert that discusses this and I want to taste interesting there are hundreds of tubas and mr. Brewer kitchen America Yaga Maha Chohan discussed coffee and tea the macabre and there are more to my knowledge no place mentions coffee or tea obviously they didn't have it now they had it in shine in the ninth century but it didn't come Terra tea sir all didn't come to Poland with her motive it probably came here for their most time you know hocus katanas was about a hundred years after the rama that's when it came to the industry circles but be that as it may the earliest rumor that discusses coffee the Parramatta IRA simin men perhaps 300 years ago he was asked the brother what's the proper brothel on cava and why is it different than mace lucky that's Adama he says a brilliant dang phone he says you know I'll tell you a different quote unquote soup that should be not r8 or a dumbest should be misogynist and yet it's shocking know which drink do we have primarily by in Psalms oh I'll give you a hint that should be a very meaning bizarre nice but yet we make a shackle beer beer is barley beer hops and frack tasteless in Brock Islamic crescent a blood earlier why is beer Chikako why is it different than them a socket and a vegetable soup so theis asperities three truths and but base laser terraces that bear only has the time of the of the the beer hops and bio eight bestia a mystical twice's says in a tremendous aside not every cooked fruit or vegetable becomes a soup vegetable soup Sheva soup fine but beer is not eaten like a soup it's drunk like another drink anti sucess cross the board drinks are never the original bracha drinks always are shocked only before it that's why on beer there's no Mozilla's charcoal iron juice even specially grown our orange juice oranges is a shackle and ZUP the Parramatta Aran that's why on coffee and tea even though it should be her eights and a dummy respectively but since it's a drink the broth is a shackle and many quotes over to Versailles rush in cloud eyelid sim intensiva that has a Shia about someone cooked a barley drink for a while oh well hired should be a very minimization is Kochi estimations mean a dog another blindness is up the rush no since it's only the Cletus time of Bali and the mask is is clear there's no pieces it could be soon he says is for the Jews it's different than soup where you cook it to eat the vegetables also and therefore this barley drink for Hilah is not Amazon eyes it's a shotgun now isn't the similarity striking listen to think about this Madoff on a Bali dream that's essentially by Raymond amazonite and calcination Hamish's dogyum is always miss a nice still we say a drink is a drink and it's a shackle and we overlook the fact that it's Amazon ice so coffee that's not Amazon ice it's a regular fruit and you throw away the coffee beans no one extra coffee beans after they're cooked and roasted shouldn't it be a regular drink and a bonafide flavored water we'll call it and therefore the broker is chakra on the inventory in other words drinks always are suhaka so now we see there are two categories soups could be hard AMA drinks are always shackled so coffee and tea is like beer that would be a shot and I have a whole long list you have to trust me from getting with the Pradesh the Marathi the kid or kids Ashoka Maurya Rob chef Lemar up in two places I am all Salem Isola Luca on coffee and tea the broker is shocking if you want to think about something for homework tonight why then is chocolate the food chocolate why isn't that appropriate because chocolate is not a mask you like a hot cocoa chocolate is an ISIL and that either the cocoa beans are ground and pulverized and process true but it's not like applesauce because here it's grown to make cocoa to make chocolate and so miss Alma turbans persuade miss him inside the galaxy cotton base says for 30 years I wondered about this I though the Easter I didn't get a satisfactory answer so that's it sort of here because chocolate is an oil but when you're naina coffee and tea that's a masker we have choices that compares it that Willy would become comparable to beer so to me was so good smack we started with a very intimidating question the coffee and tea should be like soups and now we have no less than four sugars why coffee and fear shackle Maslak ice may serve as beer and we have the wrap the rush regarding Bali so naira buy a box and we have the Assizes let's begin with help us breakfast and we'll go in order of Soho afterwards but I want to repose our original question how would we identify a cup of coffee is it 95% water with a flavor or is it a new drink called coffee and that's we're going to see as we proceed imagine someone that makes a very cost of a cup of coffee and he's so busy with the cup if he finally makes it he makes a boiler creates his little you know into his coffee he was thinking did the air but if you make a boy creates on a cup of coffee are you Yates or not until today you would say what's the Schuyler any child knows you make her 8 on a shackle you know you're exhibit the Emmet but now we see that probably will be a to do the other because according to could only apply skin it's a very create I saw the time out said egg and this is in the Taylor comas after breakfast Perry Bob the end of see cotton hey who says on stairs tea the broth is charcoal with the a bed if you made on te a bear pre Adama you are you're itself and its portion according to that if you made our eights on coffee but the ever do would be ice the alkali serve and tough time I'm a tough time a test says the Farish you're probably right somebody a bed or their eighth son coffee what to me was beautiful and symbol suki na sukham let's say you didn't make a cup of brewed coffee percolator coffee AK a cup of coffee you bought instant coffee and you made a cup of regular coffee and you made a eight that with the other tights with the eight on a cup of instant coffee that you made so we would say what's the difference instant coffee percolator coffee coffee is coffee not really because Lamesa the instant coffee was transformed they took coffee beans they cooked it they moved the water now it's like coffee powder know if it's my coffee powder it's probably like potato powder mashed potatoes the broth is Burpee Adamo but you make mashed potatoes from instant powdered potatoes the most poisoning that's the minute you sell to make a shocker in other words let me put it very bluntly if you make a cup of coffee from coffee grinds from a k-cup that's the essence of the coffee beans and we could say that's a new midsi is called coffee and maybe but the LED lights with very pre-aids but if you took instant coffee and added water you know that is that's 95% water it's the flavor of coffee and I snuck in the safe the same Barossa page for 50 compares this to a Mentos Lima and Simon dalit then on wine and grape juice you make a very pure guffin but if you make more take wine and grape juice and you reduce it to the concentrate and then you add water the browser shocker so it comes out America finished with the oven on a coffee that's percolated which is the essence of the beans but the evidence is good but on coffee made from coffee powder whether it's freeze-dried or instant coffee that's water now I can't say the holiday is but the best 8 is the health cup and make a shackle on coffee but it's very you talkin that the coffee that's roasted and grown and did you made from the beans at least but the other would be a burger it creates would be ice now the next question I thought was an academic question someone told me there is something on the market that this mom is this shy of this question imagine someone eats a roasted coffee bean does it take being there Sidney animal but sugar its flavored do you make what profit they make on a roasted edible coffee bean in other words if you eat a raw coffee bean there's no bro that's in edibles like a real potato but our question is prepared coffee bean so I would say the Clara if it's edible it's a burner creates what's the Schuyler I you'll be alarmed thing to say wait a minute we once learned talking with lenses in here based on a mr. Bern raised base if cotton lambeth test if you prepare what we was a call today candied orange peel orange peel with sugar the broth is chocol so if that's the shackle why is the coffee bean fire creates the delicious question why is the candied orange peel the shackle aya grows on a tree the answer is because an orange peel is not the pre ice it's the khalifa' khalifa' is not the original Bravo but coke but coffee bean is the original cocoa coffee bean why shouldn't be a bar pH now if it's inedible like in a raw state then there's no broccoli but if this is you tell me it's it's edible it's sold it's marketed and the cafe I am and tackle Etsy enraged Bayes ayah now left does say that if it's edible then under coffee cocoa bean the coffee bean the Brussels should be very eyes and we does call other sheet is that the breakfast should go down maybe a dumber maybe shocked oh I'm not really sure why but lamai so definitely we see that the code the coffee bean if it's edible is white not defending other free now if you look at the mr. Bern rage Kimmel you'd these pick savannas I'm de Ville type of spark a type of a spice that that you prepare it you make a berry pre Adama so the truth is coffee maybe you'll say coffee bean is likely turbulent it's not a pre but it's again the cup of bean but havoc I am does bring sheet is that on a repaired coffee bean the brussels would be a bright red prions now someone will be alarmed if you say i have a chocolate covered a coffee bean so there are two reasons to make eggs first of all the bean is AIDS when it's prepared and the chocolate also be iet me in you so then that's more time to make a barrier create now agave sell today coffee beans which is all chocalate it's shaped like a cold little coffee but as maybe taste a little bit but that's certainly a shotgun I'm talking about the original coffee bean someone asked me the Shia he wanted he was getting tired he wanted to continue learning but he needed older caffeine and he's uh from Ibaka so he took a spoonful of instant coffee vitae and he's ready to learn you know you don't need the hot and sugar and the milk you know I have rusev did the same thing sorry I found this very you know deja vu mistook a cup of a spoonful of coffee it's going down so we would be tempted to say this is a very sticky mark the morning broke Issaquah macbeth says if a person eats of food with full muscle he needs prune juice and he would never drink Brueghel's but now he needs it so the Ameri says you make a brother keeping the Isfahan dominate boy you brew it even though you're doing it Leah for you make a brother but there has no science that will shine because prune juice is an eyeful a powdered coffee instant powder is that an oil it's hard to believe even a bean is not a nice look and if you make regular coffee then it becomes an iPhone but taka it makes very much sense to say that on coffee powder even draw freeze-dried is still not edible you know what it's like a child that did that sneaks into the pantry and sees this cocoa and it takes a spoon of raw cocoa there's no taste but you know make a brush on real cocoa real cocoa and real coffee the favorite should be no broth or whatsoever now Lamesa I did see a kiddush the Pisgah tubers rice that if you take the cocoa coffee powder and you add sugar then it's a pirate prelates now I'm not sure that's correct because Lamesa it's not an oil you add sugar that overpowers the bitterness of the coffee but maybe you'll say it's a shock oh but the coffee powder is miss Donna Johnson that can be a burn prelate even if the sugar will make it edible but this is in this situation it's not the original pre-aids so at best you can take coffee powder with sugar at most it's a shackle but I can't believe it should be a barrier periods next question someone told me to my society in a certain yeshiva the to bar from arguing about a chocolate Isis and if one they made a bet where Evers wrongs you have to drink black coffee now many people drink my coffee but in a Shiva that's a taboo black coffee the kids up what profit they make on a hot cup of black coffee this is a gaya for a person that once the cat Phoebe has no time to make a coffee he puts out water and go on coffee what bro could you make on black coffee in other words cost without the sugar or the milk so again we'll think what do you mean it is what's the Shila Dick Morris says an article a massacre even though a fool you make a Bravo but the question is if you don't enjoy a black coffee only drinking it because of the caffeine or because you lost the bet in that situation why is it an idle water if you don't enjoy the Morrisons know why for plain powdered coffee we said you don't make a broth it's not a rival so we added up to two zeros so it's fight another nice now if someone enjoys black coffee no so he enjoys it but if you're just doing it to the caffeine Locker it would be no problem so again that's the unique status of coffee is it an eyeful is it mouseka is it not a rival it depends on the handle so listen to this this is a fiduciary on receptive brokers is called someone's ammonium but in the end of the six para can Brock is the guy in is quoted as saying drink tea without sugar you don't make it broke every sales so my tea unless you're drinking it looks small now that I could understand in other words black tea if that's the right word tea without sugar coffee without sugar and milk if you're only drinking it because you need the caffeine is not a mask oh now the does say if you drink the tea and you enjoy without sugar and a body make a broth and it seems that that's the same would apply to coffee rabbi yosef indeed she were my myself to breakfast I'm a tough paydays on the bottom says this guy was talking that you had a lot of tea sense and have you made a very strong tea with a little bit water which that you don't enjoy but if it was flavored that it's drinkable then the going would accrue you make a shot Connie but Roy and I believe the same would be true with a black cup of coffee if a person says you know I into a coffee why should I add milk and sugar then it's milk and sugar some people are real kind of sore is one plain coffee so then you make the broth of you enjoyed but a person drinking the black coffee just because of the caffeine then according to the going no breakfast said so basically we see that this question is coffee water with a flavor or is it a new Macias of coffee depends how you use it now let's go up either side of sukumara hope I'll have enough time and I think we should of all the various showers regarding coffee question number one health is still in question someone wants to learn with in the morning before diverting or after diverting any doubt really he wants to do what's right that you should wear to fill and as long as possible don't forget Mirka the day supposed to be fill in color yarn but he thinks I'm learning I have a goof lucky let me with children and learn before we after darvany but it needs a coffee are you allowed to drink we're wearing trillion a cup of coffee so in South America Simon memc pressed the muhabba says you allowed to eat up hitless Thai Roy while we were until no so coffees I feel as I write comes again from mr. berg quoting a soul from slain but that's the miracle and he says the Mahabharata you had a drink I Roy eat and drink i Roy was in those days that they what's fill-in : so then it was inevitably after you know dream but today we only where to Olympus asked villa even after sara is awesome nope going to that you can take a coffee while we're in throne but I did see the to outshine kala kalah crash test buff he doesn't quote the silken climber but he he does say that we have no right to make a gimmicky series that today don't we wait till only an hour don't eat or drink and he's convinced your mouth to eat and drink i roy even while you were until they man huh get to some safe for outlook you trust me cause if some cipher gave a sheer and drank coffee while it was wearing told because an ignition be named Ann Hargis gimbal test valve also says this so basically I think we could say that my love cook if someone wants to we're chillin and learn a vada its motor to drink the coffee in fact I saw the Abner Yoshi failing science and olive says maybe even acquainted even the Slocum Swami bus talk about I feel asteroid with children but a drink is I really and I'll be more to even bisman a cell so basically of course I don't mean silly the missiles and convinced just children but someone wants to its fill an extra time but it needs a coffee so beam a smear in the mid sloth chillin and keep the filling on and drink a coffee next question which is a little more tricky is drinking a coffee or tea before Domini so again what's the problem so I'll tell you there seems to be a major problem there's an is a bummer of eating or drinking before the opening why do I say it's a comma because it's based on a caustic them because kind of considers a might in the other eye so sorry koala dumb to eat or drink before diverting tomorrow cause a guy laughs fishing is God's their FD as is food in any comes to God okay it's not a derisive pastas but the Embassy's the Rambam and the culvert the tour and simin pay test quotes these we shine him that even drinking water is Oscar before Dominic then he quotes the IVAC that says no water is motor because it's not so water before Dominic is mud - according to many recite him and that's the way the pahala potkins and simin Paytas says the gods of ice one of the earliest acronym what is multiple but water with sugar is gaia and it's awesome no according to the reservoirs coffee is certainly awesome guide now later after the pecados writes and simin pay test that the miser in mitts Ryan where he lived people cannot dive without their coughing and therefore coffee before Dominic is at Cyril filler and his mortal as I tried the Posada but coffee with sugar is Vava Guyver and his awesome now the mr. brewer in our sim and pay test if cotton club vase he says my son if you put coffee is sugar into the coffee and make it a hot sugar Mashka that's not awesome but if you put the sugar in your mouth and drink it as such then it's at syrup for the coffee and it's okay and that's talk of the many girls do you even know this don't have do they they have a the COTS cook the sugar D the sugar cubes that's most of the four dominant but pokazhi Miami d'Ivoire people make a cup of coffee and tea with milk with sugar so I saw the pajama oven - Larry says that since they have to is say your tiller and today people can't drink coffee without milk or put the sugar giving them out so the coffee is one Victor of tiller and the designer of says is their house Oakland says this you know the coffee has to quote hit the spot so I say you know degree I'm going to have a bc AC by eating mostly have a bc there are some people they say why'd you do that it was before my coffee yeah you know before the coffee they're inanimate cervical Isis now they can't function so there's a BC this the AC the Meister people today are they need the coffee and the presenter of the office often say coffee is mostly before that now what made a big Russian I don't know factor of the - iam younger man he says he doesn't go through these special coffee coffee the coffee but shabbos he the Shabbos he buys a special flavored coffee the coffee before Dominic the cover Chavez he has a special flavored coffee okay and it's anything but I'm thinking now I'm thinking that also anyone the same thing down now I could say something is it soap a before diving - I have a special flavored coffee on Chavez taka there's no issue of drinking before thousand examples because it's salty of kiddush there's no that because you need a beer there's no he of kids but the issue of drinking before deafening there's no different Chavez and weekday now I saw the bridge honor of an ex ticklin that Cyrus says the latter drink coffee before diving but the drink takes special click SF like better Kashiram that's awesome you know what's needed is not the guy who's awesome the only question I'm thinking is maybe on Shabbos since you're gonna classify it as carbon Shabbos so it's not Gaia but I think required during the week if someone has puts in an effort to have his coffee with all the he do remand the Mahajan manner Mahajan that might be also going to the vagina grove but Shabbos you know that statistically and me maybe taka the coverage I wish your boy outweighs the problem of guy but definitely during the week between coffee - bell - Davin and that's it there's a concept which is brought into American Kaufman hey it's a Gomorrah of past chakras person posted pacifist it's a very important start up for the day the buchecha and Cookman hey says those that don't eat past chakras there's a limits cause maybe they are too at the coffee so we see coffee being more than just flavored water the Prima Gotham rights it's you don't have to have bread pass pasta baba Kidston with Miami's okay dr. Kawa hi massive cotton club demo that's coffee or tea so we see coffee is not just flavored water it has a past chakras quality to it now of course even if you say coffee is Bhim coin past chakras but then again a BIM coin coin is not a coin so better would be to have passed chakras but if you can't the coffee with the cake would be okay this people have a Minich you know that they dip their misogynistic cake there don't that's whatever it is into hot coffee you know that's the Hema subversion of Dunkin Donuts that's a we do but the embassy is it's very possible that for those that are mode optic on double ship it will of a Moscow to wash like we do on paste that when we dip the carpet the carpets into the salt water that you would have to wash if you do that why raise that fell mr. Bruin cook noon festive cotton cover quoted Eric I am that if you you dip the leg up the cake into schnapps cinch snaps is not a mask it's it's just zeliha by Alma you don't make it's not too good of a mask you don't have to wash soap the mr. Gerber but if we'd be Packer predominantly water then you would have to wash because you put the lecar into the mask is people liver mask oh no our coffee today even if it's a brewed fancy coffee is safe go safe is ravenite and tack up the price cream saying for those that are marked with the Bulova Mashka so well attack our Dunkin donut that type of miserliness into coffee you have to wash or at least make sure that you don't do it because this is with being here in the Teelin a big sugar when you learn mr. word you get all flustered the mr. boo booing cook iron down let's see if cotton lama test quotes from a kyoto if you have coffee at the end of the meal you would have to make the brussels and why is there something it's part of the suit that does not require a broker dessert does require a bro the high autumn explains that coffee is consumed the end of the suda2 the oculus am buzzing to help the digestion i could explain this coffee is a stimulant it makes things move you know makes the person a bit hyper it helps the kiyose it also helps in digestion it just stimulates things and coffee is like a kale esta muslim so therefore it's not part of the stood up and you have to make a bra mr. burr rights towards the a name worker it's not necessarily true but the minute he says is make a shackle on the sugar and that would help through the coffee as well now this is half understand if the he is pot from a Bravo so what make it mine make a broth on the sugar self - salmon salmon meats they make a brown sugar and eat it separately as a candy and then drink the coffee but Lamai supply Kazi the veldt does not make a burka on coffee at the end of the meal and i understand very much why today our coffee is consumed not as a Alcala samosa touch the in breakfast it's part of the breakfast and listen carry out in a safe on breakfast to choose an August Himalayan base all say that today coffee is part of a Sudha it's no different any other drink and therefore no brother is required what I found beautiful the biggest abides with 100 plus years ago in cuff olive club gimel he says if you drink cause black coffee that's like awesome awesome and then you make a shot go but if you drink up a regular coffee that's part of the Sudha you don't make a brook I understand that today we drink regular coffee it's part of the soup I also saw in the business of values on a black coffee the Broca's chakra obviously he felt that indeed that the my son it is a brother there is a taste to it if you enjoy it to make a bro next question someone has nine people that eight and then short one through Zeeman so someone is sitting there who didn't eat so you know what please eat or drink because I can I'm full give me a good cup of coffee I'll drink it and then I'll come part of your Zeman can you use coffee or tea for a tenth person fizzy me so first of all this is a problem because the only person that could be counted at this even if he ate or drank enough to make a burn of phosphorus if you hold on a hot cup of coffee there's no burning of fosters there's no shadow we're talking that's it cool off because he's going to make it burn the flashes of the coffee is he counted into zina my voice this is a beautiful knife Kamino the macabre says the cooks have big giant Bay's on any food or drink you could count them into the Zeeman except water now the question is is a cup of coffee 95% water so that you can count them in or maybe it's a cup of coffee so the are let's see I'm in member of llama DA says Iike a Malian like huh she licks tires coffee is essentially water and it's not part of the zine however most Pais can that I saw it my Ritz that sister schinsky original ocinski rub and many other pipes can say what do you mean coffee is a question of mascar and that's why it seems that the price can seem to agree that if you have a cup of coffee cohaagen a regular cup of coffee and you make you buy a fosters a sort of stereo canal of quebec in most dresses you make you buy enough arches on it then you could be counted into the zine next question a beautiful shine someone asked this question recently I've heard this question more than once he loves the smell of brewed coffee when someone makes a cake cup of coffee for him this guy Nate just at the smell they make a brush on the smell of coffee or I'll tell you more common question you walk by your coffee shop don't have to walk too far for this and you smell the tantalizing smell of coffee now I was told this is the truth that the exhaust fan of a coffee shop goes out to the street so when you walk by you're almost overwhelmed by the taste you know you almost paralysed by the smell of it and you decide to go and buy a coffee but that's the component it's made to attract customers so it's made to give a rare do you make a broker on the smell aroma of coffee now until today I'll say what wealthy but the truth is today it's a perfect example on ice and there you have toys the pears it is a pain I will make the butter creates on a cup of coffee that's because it's a drink but it is the ray of type of pace and the MS is that the mr. Brewer and raised a scientific on design quoting a bear hate it says if you smell coffee farmer surveys Hanoi therefore autumn Nana sorrowful avoid their possession necessary f-type the taste it's a simple application of a Gomorrah that on a fruit that has a fragrant smell like a nest Rick not on circus you make a brothel why is coffee different now of course he does stress that razenoid if it has a smell but why not so someone asked me sir that's the case if you walk-in in bar parking fifty fifty eleven on 44th Street when most of the week you smell a very distinct smell of bread you should also make a brother I told me right on the cava to Rama there Monty and the rage to Zion if you smell past time you make brother a tray of type a person so if bread you make a brother certainly cook now the Meister our mini gaze on bread we don't make a broker because there are a few problems with the making a broken bread first of all mr. beretti says that the smell the bread is not strong enough to make a bro club I mean it is a distinct smell but not strong enough also says mr. Brewer does the other place can save this time mr. groom that bread has other ingredients that forms the smell of it the flavoring the sugar and the cloud the broth a nice array of type of pass others wonder would you get that no sir from there are five disguised five brokers in the gomorrah there's no brooklyn pass so the meaning is not to make on pass but the same mr. Brewer that says not to make on bread the end of race design says in civics if cotton tessai and to make on coffee why because it's the real thing it's a parry it's a strong smell there's no additives now this I think is possible if you smell instant coffee that there's no Bravo that's not the original pay read and I should add when you open a cup of instant coffee there's a strong smell that is as Scheckter as compete that is a spray it's like when you know you buy a new car they'd have a special new car spray and I kid you not earlier my second so coffee that's instance there's no brough on it the coffee that's percolated but it's flavored in the various flavors that these K Cups have is also not the smell of coffee it's other flavorings so that's no problem but it does make sense that coffee that has the original coffee beans smell Tom rape I know there should be a problem now myself the belt does not make a brother I think I know why the calf Italian or ahsoka and Barriss Tobias all say that the minik is we all make a broth on something that's it Kroy larae are the muscle if you have the summon or an S triggering the year and you grow a surrogate for the smell but a food that's produced to consume even though it has a strong flavor Regan's you don't make a broth even though your calves on isla haria now that's the cousin in c2 also although the mr. Gore is not go with that he requires the broth on coffee but if you ever have a timer for sure compare myosin because an ish so maybe that's why I were to make a bra on the smell of coffee not because it's not way up type of Paris but because it's an article essentially question someone cannot drink wine or grape juice he's a diabetic the Kitsap is coffee or tea a viable option for kiddush or half dollar is that what we call Hammar medina so we know Hammar medina the Siham Eric says only should be used if you if there's no wine available but if someone can drink wine so it's coffee at t an option so you're wondering wait a minute this language snaps snaps is a Moscow Medina beer more sense of our Medina but coffee is 95% water and that's taka why many poisk in the marcelo and Simmel am adalat he says coffee Mahamaya Medina its water there's no Bissell Akamai coffee because it's right water via B or has a tuba that you make kiddush on coffee it's a brothel that's all because it's equally mine so here we see our question once again reappears if you hold its equal I am happy to make conditioned Abdullah on the crema and as it's even better to make on apple cider which is pure apple juice or real orange juice but coffee is this is mostly water but there are make elem it's it's Eleazar hail you down man bay there's a thorough tuber that basically it's not it's a very prominent drink called coffee rough moisture inhaling very seminar in hey to talks about tea and he says that the the definition Tamar Medina is it's not consumed when you're thirsty I'll give you a cup of soda and you say I'm not thirsty forget it okay I'll give you a cup of tea you say I'm not thirsty I didn't think this nurse team I want to be a habitude something that you drink as a keyboard without being thirsty that's come on Medina and remorses but the other tea is a c'mon Medina he doesn't say coffee but obviously who are there so we could say the following it's better if someone can't drink wine to here kid is not dull from someone else but if coffee or tea are the only option yes I'm assuming we had a shower someone wanted to drink a coffee before Meyer if I'm at SRI Shabbos after I shall share that's been seen before my liver so if you knew that losses it's not so outlandish me it could add in your ladder drink water before half-dollar now grab the developed is very Mac bit I'll stash at Cana but me icky didn't inch of America lighted drink water so the other that's Ian and of a Zion rights your ladder doing coffee also before Myers and that's a beautiful she tossing because his sheep is that coffee is water it's not Maccabi other lovely mentioned earlier you can't use it we said oh god baby the question of the common Medina's definitely it's not to it and he says did here also to drink coffee before my rib is waters mortem but develop does not drink any water and certainly not a coffee but I was thinking the person that is making the drink coffee before my remit sorry Shabbos should not turn around and then drink and they make half dollar on coffee because that will be attached to this a stream next question it's Friday night and someone wants to stay up but it's very tired can he take a caffeine pill which of course is the extract of coffee or the like it's caffeine that's stimulated or question number two can they drink a black coffee what's the Shila is it a question of your for so one thing is Clark to drink a black coffee even if you never drink coffee is more cuz it's Michael Bray like we said it's a niacin you make a broke on it if you enjoy it and Avada it's not a problem of a fool caffeine pill I saw some is almond sauce for slime assertion for foul of cough gimble mean cos it's a gimmick of a lofts a caffeine pill is the reform it's not an eyeful and why should it be mortem now this to me was a hideous because it's not I I agree it's not a it's not a Oracle but he's not sick it's not a fool he's tired maybe a sleeping pill that the person hasn't has a problem can't fall asleep maybe that's a rapport but a caffeine pill is just a stimulant and fatality they held the fact that it's in a pill form that would make it a problem of her food I know that the patina road was not there to take a caffeine pill and I understand why it's not a before you finish the afikomen on pace up but you have a seder apartment Satan left to go but you're holding a chatot Spanish Cena he's tired can he take a cup of coffee after he came in to finish the rest of the Seder the the clayey what's the shiloh a my fear not capacity kinda but if you look at the mr. Gruen tough paralysis cotton Aleph he says you'll add a drink mild light drinks and key he does not speak about coffee very closely is stronger flavor than tape but I did and talk to the Knesset a Godiva and see if cotton base says that coffee fib camión is awesome because it dilutes the taste of the athlete claim but if you look in the earth the sky in the sprinkler quotes that has some Sipho had a tea at a coffee after the after claiming the birthday Yosef is mayor that's the minute to drink a coffee after a beacon obviously it's stronger than tea but the end of day it's still basically water so we seem to be going back that coffee is maybe even a parameter Moscow but it's still water and water is not the f-type he claimed someone asked me he wants to percolate coffee on if you like to do that now he swatted me I'm not taking cries but he said there's no doubt about it there's no more luckily keeps it on it keeps water in it just editing the grind and making the coffee so the heart is no silent if there's no Malaka taking place now he was wondering it's matched up of a whole nephesh well first of all probably today her gonna call for you shovel call net fish and also by Oakland FSU don't eat troubles on their fish it's only by not sheer Mike's like showering so if you have a perk oh there's no melaka it should be month taking a caffeine pill on a tie nice you said a serve the Tabas is that considered useful no you're not caffeine is on oil even if it originates from coffee it's the chemical it's the drug of the coffee but it's not a nice for Yom Kippur we don't take caffeine pills because it's a real full and Lamaze when any type of consumption but it makes sense that on a tiniest a caffeine pill should be motor it's not an oil circus questions someone asked about drinking a coffee out of it the silver man he's obviously not marketed to drink water in the sukkah but maybe coffee is more of a Prius it's like drinking wine out of the sucker that could be as awesome you could it did but this I saw the price can say that wine taka is considered a careers of hasta pasta cerca but coffee is not wine in fact the price can say clearly that coffee is motor cuts the silca unless your market on even water hostess look we have a permit I love that when after Meyer gone they'll purim really the fast is over but the mitigates to continue fasting outs covered for the Megillah also she was a megillah' until after the Megillah bashar saqqaq a person is allowed to drink because the fast is over water is multum is coffee before the Megillah but someone that needs it is that motor so the high autumn and coughlin hey I love cooking hey hey writes the fairest retiree of gobble gobble if you won't be able to listen to me Gilmer properly he's allowed to drink a coffee because I'm safer had a mini grocer drink coffee before the Megillah obviously it doesn't take away from the Perseus if you have water before them again so coffee is considered water in this regard another permit I love the question of sending the Slayer from an iced coffee so if you send a cup of hot coffee - laughs - and the person gets it it's probably iced coffee that's it this is no silent it's good my mask is good I'm talking about if you send either the coffee grind a cake up or instant coffee so pastas this is our Schuyler how do you identify coffee is it an eyeful is it a talent - sup - Stan but from the tubers in hey ray slime without what's - Schuyler even if it's a table yo-yo eat sir mr. layer tamales it's nothing less than a Pharisee tomorrow now Zion about our lives of the Gemara Soloff a male Casa de sang vila whom Allah cast appalling he sent them spices why isn't that good for self - so even if it's as if it's only a spice it's not a no I thought you still you ISIL but he says like that you've been around an olive static Bay's that those spices were edible as is maybe coffee would not be good to miss my ass - an aqua Carville let me just briefly tell you just a little bit about the question of Bissell akhom Bissell Akram seems to be a serious problem in any type of coffee we consume whether you buy a jar of instant coffee was made by max allows a faceless choice they're not Jewish they roasted and cooked the coffee cake up that was made by a guy or the coffee grind same thing made by a gun worse yet you go into a coffee shop that's the guy who owns it and even if there's no problems of conscience a guy made a cup is Mickel about size and you go on a plane and the stewardess makes a cup of coffee for you without milk and everything is kosher but the guy made a coffee from the beginning to the end max allows made it and there the stewardess made it Antikythera miriam that coffee has the problem of the Shalako why is developed Meiko with coffee believe it or not sir provide us since it's iike a Mayan the coughing is bottle and just like there's no problem of Bissell a combined beer there's no problem bishop welcomed by coffee so size mastered about Java tilde comes out that coffee is essentially water and a certain sense it's even less flush of than beer because then coffee adalat I love to mohabbat says in oliver doing beer in a tavern even if it's kosher but the clears of drinking in a grayish the tavern has AO acid similar to the e serum of fastness like other surya bonaly but the place can say regarding coffee there's no problem the latter drink coffee in the coffee house of a guy if there's no consciousness to so what's the answer original fakira what is the status of coffee it's basically water a prominent drink will be it but it's not like there it's not like wine we should drink coffee to Santa hates I couldn't talk to you [Music] hey hey hey Keela [Music] all right Jamie you Sherlock you'll begin to the character of Smith with today's year like you being a staff to respond how sensitive is sponsoring today's shield in the niche Mouse called Ovid another cylinder of Zakaria sheath here the legislation also the sponsor tape you'll inish Mouse little bit he'll be very shy our lady yes so soft alias by REITs external awesome troops our time they'll be a secret of today's year in a few minutes [Music] okay everyone had time by now for the second coffee so we can mom said to share the secret Oval Office in yella GABA coffee Zeeland of up to the Zeeman I said a secret I scare finish the coffee Suvarna cautious at the attic evasion is revista some we learnt a recession as we see tea and coffee are unique amongst almost all of the foods it's never eaten in any form as an eyeful and it's grown its purpose its Eloy is to make a masker and that's really the crux of the issue so how do you define and a lot of coffee so basically coffee is made by taking the coffee beans its first roasted to bring out the flavor and then it's cooked so although it seems like with the luck would be that it's like a soup like a made Chevis or may erupt ice which is our dumbest of coffee should be on aids but the price came seemed to agree and that's Dominica Island without doubt that if not like a soup but rather it's a drink like beer it's not an Amazon ice but rather a shackles so again min ago alum and forth the auntie the brother is a shock only a bit very but but the other someone said our eights on a percolating cup of coffee that comes from the original coffee grounds the brother the eighths would be Russia but the other Adama auntie is the same thing but the other dumb auntie should work instant powder coffee is little worse than than the coffee grind in it the fact that it was changed so maybe even with the other the AIDS with would someone ate a roasted edible candied coffee bean that might be a better create as we explained because that's the original page that's rendered edible those that hold it's matter H is because it's just not a food it's not a pre it's only used for drinking a spoon of powdered coffee is like a spoon of cocoa which both do not need a brother it's not an eyeful black coffee or tea without sugar would be totally if this how long you can make a bra cup if it's just consumed for the caffeine of it or to drink down a pill one person takes black coffee then no breakfast should be said it's mostly drink coffee when a person's wearing to fill and SSDs are Oi the many gears before dabbing to drink coffee with sugar and milk and someone pointed out taka the mini gets dim saber cetera first and that would certainly be mapped to the midok of drinking before happening coffee could substitute past chakras but better past chakras the real thing a dip doughnut into coffee or any machine isn't the coffee for those that are mock bit and tabula Mashka that would require unity lassi Italian we don't say a broke on coffee or tea at the end of the meal because today it's always as the meal not the Occulus amahzing if someone drank a coffee or tea and feta burner fauces he could be counted into the Zeeman best to avoid the raya of coffee because there are many fakers if someone will mama SH enjoys it and he makes this rare for just for the smell then about that the brother should be a nice array of type of Paris if there's no option there's no camera Deen available you can't drink wine or grape juice then for kiddush and Abdullah one could use coffee or tea F Michelle showed us the medic is not to drink water or coffee but of those that are Mako water is motor and coffee is it's early and maybe it's more than just plain water coffee caffeine pills on Shabbos those many points my marker because it's out to be maker but but certainly if you drink a cup of coffee or your drink Cola just for the caffeine there's no shine laughter - thorium and on Shabbos is no concern FTF requirement chiasmata and it seems a minute get to make up even with coughing a tightness a person can take a can feed bill except for Yom Kippur drinking coffee what's the sukkah is okay Bashar subtract a person can add for coffee before the Megillah and they'll pour them even though most of the Sieber is still fasting you can use coffee as a slam on ice there's no it's official a kumbaya tea and there's no zero like buy beer coffee is not as scholarship as you