Hasogas Gevul Or Competition? - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] right the roof of my blemish Amy again she retired would like to welcome everyone to today's here from row vehicles at Smith Lita on the topic of DNA has sagas go to Vegas a character of Ephraim Eisner for sponsoring today's Chavira knishmas email Asia hinder Vassar of Rome time alehsalaam to dismiss a sewer viscera fire receiver someone asked me the following question one of the welcome had like a cantina called he sold the can the candy machine and they sold sodas and someone else wanted to open up a symbol of business and the question is is he allowed to and the other the first buck I said this is how suckers Cavalia now allowed to and I realized that it's not only a question of Shiva we have this you get older you know if you have a store and a competing store and a big store knocking out the small store these are things that we hear all the time I heard another style that really touched me there was a younger man that was being pushed and to take a certain rawness a certain Stella and he didn't want to take it then he told me why he says listen I'm gonna come into a neighborhood there are existing shoes if I am at slea where where the people coming from other shows up I'm not opening a shoe on the moon no there are other shoes in the day but I'm taking other people I don't want to kill me this casitas so I decided to look into the sucio and it's the gates of course opening is Shiva opening a playgroup and opening up different medical practice and really if you notice the common denominator you're taking someone else's potential customer business miss fallow but then again you have to realize that it the first storekeeper doesn't own the customers who said it is you know if you walk into someone else's store and you pull out as customers that doesn't sound right but is there a Nissa to attract someone else's customers that does not really his and the truth is it's very a very emotional question I want to explain you could have the first doorkeeper it's doing business and someone comes along and open up opens up a competing store and the first to a storekeeper could prove it black and white that since the second star opened his business decreased by twenty thirty percent is he's a accountant could show it to you on black and white and if he's a pal McLaughlin will say it's Mama's youngest cabaret and he's a master gavel so first of all I want to make something clear the word thuggish gaveled because the pasta can parish to shift in my sauce lickable area club has nothing to do with opening and competing store house of this cabal has that then explain the tough cook our bays and in Eretz Israel there was different boundaries and if someone wanted to extend this land he just moved the boundary so he basically stole and inerrancy strong that's like Sasha Gloria but we use it as a borrowed term that basically you're encroaching someone's pan awesome okay so we could understand why there's a case not to open a competing store you're taking his business and we call it my seqable but then again you have to realize is it really a Nissa you know my experience has proven to me that when someone says it's the biggest of error there's probably no a favor at all people get all emotional it's the worst thing let's think about it objectively am i stealing something that i take something by exhaustion is no I but I might be magic the first store keeper I didn't break his window I didn't touch his store at most it's a groomer but not even a regular grammar it's a grammar in Linnaeus River I'm depriving him of a potential profit manious River is far from mr. there Isis also you have to realize there's another side of the story the first tokeep has the right to make pond awesome and how about the second second storekeeper he also lives in the city he also has the right to making a living in his neighborhood so what's the big Tanner and then again probably the most important fact is we have to think about the benefit of the community if a store has a monopoly that's very detrimental to the community if a store has a monopoly on an item he could charge what he wants he could have very poor service but he's not threatened the healthiest thing for a community is when there's good competition so when another store opens up the existing store is gonna have to work harder it's probably going to bring the prices down so the point is that when you look at the big picture there's a first store there's a second store and there's also the benefit of the thousands of people in the community and the embassies Lahav the secular law allows almost unrestricted competition my lawyer that I know said basically that any activity to limit competition is probably against the law so this is our challenge our privilege to look at our eyes to toy and to see what taça the unlawful response are you allowed to open a store that's going to that's going to disturb the existing store so the fire this seems to be a Mishnah the Mishnah Bava metzia DAF sama Rabi who the I Emily Insalaco Anthony coleus veganism Latino caucus with Macy Magdalene the Lafayette's Lloyd dr. B Hooda in our to give out candies to attract the children why I guess in those days like today the children of the Bella bottom you know if the children want to go to that store because they get lollipops they're gonna butcher their parents let's go there Cebu that says you can't use a clever way of attracting customers because you're going to hurt the other store keeper uh-huh so you see you now wanna make a promotional that's going to hurt the first store but you didn't even finish the Mishnah because farming material how come I'm allowed to make a attraction by giving out Ken even though you are taking customers from the existing store so our question can I take someone else's customers isn't my latest 10 a.m. but we're not finished the Mishnah then continues Leah plays SSI which in English should not undercut the other store Rashi explains if you're going to offer a big sale your macca pay off Mozilla's kaveri if thought number two is gonna give make a big sale is gonna cost or number one to lose customers and this is - what we're looking for Mika pay up Missouri noise Kaveri right if I'm giving a very good sale I'm hurting the first store but again you can't stop the middle of a mr. become my mum's awful I tell you Rashi explains if the second store makes the sale the first so we'll also bring his prices down and what you're doing is you're ending up benefiting the community so our money our question can I attract someone else's custom is is a math wakest an item but presumably if it's enough like is to name how to reap ask in your figure a melodica Robin so in other words instead of it being the biggest affair in the world it's as awful that I visit Avila Bravo if I do something to bring the prices down I get a breath of the common but we could do even better we have what seems to be a more custom-made riot our question the demand of a basket of Kavala from the bays has the following high bar mabui someone has a business and a courtyard for us to bomb avoid cabaret the Kabuki gabay and this in those days a very big business was Mills or Italian someone told me that's the name my man a mill is so popular Miller comes from Mills it was a very big business sup the Gemara if I have a mill and someone else opens up a mill Dino the maraca Villa vein the humble a compass ocular you see you coming in into my domain and you're making a sec you're taking my paw no sir and this is mommy's custom a flower Schuyler a second score is now to open a competing business that's the sheath reporter now this sounds great but there's a big problem at this Ramona seems to restrict competition what about the malaika's in the Mishnah in Bava metzia DAF sama Ralf una seems to be favoring the Rebbe Hooda but the problem is that's connected there's a thumb say allowed to give out candies and you're allowed to make a sale so Ravana seems to be putting himself in a disadvantage it's connected to Carmen and that's the Kumar's costume Treg the Gemara lame baboon at the armor could be who the witch is the like ha ha MIM suptig Mara no no you gotta go wrong Reb you who the holds of course you like to give out candies and make sales you know why cuz you could tell the other storekeeper you also give out candies and you also make a good sale I'm not hurting you but to come along and to open up a new store that's wrong and he has even if a car would agree is awesome so now we have the following to make promotionals to make sales ok but if Hoonah holes to open a competing store is awesome but to avoid say that's not the end of the sodium the mer then quotes throughout Hoonah braids of yeshua that a person from a different city cannot open a competing store well soon see the smart because you have no right to butt in the same city you're allowed to open a competing store if you ask me why is it mutter are you hurting the first person's business we know the answer first of all I'm gonna open a store because all right I'm the same city ok that's why you're different City I can't do it but if I come from this city I have a right to make Panozzo sup the a grandma that that's the reason why slaughter you you want you're contacting him and what about me I also write to make pan Austin more compelling and that's the the explanation of the Remy gasps why are you thinking about the first floor keep up what about the benefit of the community if there's fair competition it's healthy for business in general if I come along and open a competing store both stores will work hard to succeed and that will benefit the community survey say we have a malaika's ten million if you allow to make promotionals and sales and we passed it of course it's matzah now we have a math way cuz I'm a Ryan our very question can I open a competing store how do we pass skin like a Huna or a Huna braid review schewe maccer it should be simple reform debate that we sure was abbas sir he was later a logical my site and also in theory reformed maybe she was like the calm him and that's why tasteless postions the love of the who debated be sewer and that is how luckily my sensation mister cook no involve see if hey you're allowed to open a competing store as long as you come from the same city now I want to just add a little bit this to storekeeper the first goalkeeper will be very emotional and he's distraught he's losing panacea but you have to realize that her lover looks at the big picture the whole story you have to think about the other storekeeper he also lives in the city you think about the community the campus ER and it's human members he writes it emphatically this how this Schuyler is Mutola Attila and even though people wonder about it but that's the Minich now why do people wonder about it because they get very emotional in the here the first thing storekeeper proves black and white that he lost his business he lost twenty percent of his plan all since the second storekeeper came true what about the second stalking what about the community I saw that the retirement achieve up inflation mister kaelin days the end of Nunez regarding a slightly different Shila but the same idea where the rough in a city pass condensed a Yahud because you think of the type of the Tea Board and the yahud was hysterical so the victim says just ignore all the crying and you don't you have to do you have to pass skin for the deceiver forget about the individuals reminds me a story I once heard about that summon rubbers in a bedroom and one of the one of the ballet then started crying so the ROVs wait a minute you know how to cry in a peasant you want to cry go to the kreisel and cry you can't cry and invested in other words a mere accident but didn't you have to pass can I love them so our question you'll think about the first doorkeeper very nice rather think about the Mishnah is awful a toy the second storekeeper is promoting healthy competition he is benefiting the community he's not encroaching on someone's Panozzo per se he has a right to do it and the efforts month now of course we all know there's a terrible is of your illness have a write the morning you've almost I invest says that's almost like murder the kymaro insert hedging pay Aleph compares that Romano's lung to Mitama HSA oh that's when you take something that's not yours if you still you are come your competitors secrets and other than such unscrupulous activity your Riddler on the survey right Marcus card outlet says that's why also AAU Rossler yard on the sky very but opening a competing score as long as you do things on PA locker we saw the converse your says it's Mutola hot skillet now I should mention the Rav circle now and he'll cause havoc about sagas gavel or semi-nude ice you'd get Moe says that Lamesa to open a store that's going to hurt the first person even though it's Malta but outs me discuss ceded its best to refrain okay so if someone wants to act my few meters can see this topping la brasa but if he asked a child is it muta or not we swore to have the sea all we saw this on our we saw the game or we saw the Mishnah it's what Allah Katella as long as he's part of this city so to apply this from Isis I'll tell you my sister higher that I'm aware of in this neighborhood in Borough Park of if someone came along and opened a different store on the same block like it's competitive and not a grocery it was an even a more specific business not as big as a grocery store but he opened a competing store on the same block like his competitor and the first storekeeper branded the entire and that that Bettina Rosa final Ross kept askin that he has no clay there's enough in Borough Park to go around to support two types of stores like this and you know people say you lie to open the after be amazed the ten blocks away raise twenty blocks away there's no basis for that if you ladder open in the same city than even on the same block that's the fastest again a different city and now allowed to if you come from a different city and allow two let's go further I want to tell you a shower you'll be the judge in the olden days they had what was called a marvel now today a good example of a mummy and we're not exactly but a good enough for us is a dead-end street imagine you have a bar pop there's a dead-end street because then 50th Street an ATM you know imagine you have a dead-end street and they're a bunch of homes and there's one store at the end of the dead-end street all the way at the end someone comes along and opens up a competing business in the beginning of the dead-end street so everybody has to pass his store to go anyplace can he open that store in a very strategic place in the beginning of the dead-end you think about it no one's going to go all the way to the end of the dead-end street to go to business you got a right there this is a question that the mortifyin bhava Basra and I will still be a tough cooked as I in quotes and obviously one of the restrain him that says it's us that to open a store at this strategic position because basically you're putting the other person out of business no one's going to schlep to the end of the dead end now the question is why is that so and a phenom me it's it said but I'm gonna open up a business don't we learned that law is its mutta so it's interesting some PI scheme say that's are going to have una cita and that's that guys in the modify says but Lou didn't you lie to open up this score even at the beginning of the Marvel you but if you look in the dark a moisture and now Simon Beckham Isis know this how love of opening a competing store in the beginning of the dead-end street is a silikal 'days the question is why I think we know the answer you will now to open a competing store yes competition is multum but if I opening the spoil you knock out the first store that's not mutton I'll put it very succinctly competition is motor elimination is awesome to decrease someone's business ok but to decease his business to basically close it because no one's going to schlep to the end of the monthly that is unacceptable this is based on a extremely important historical tube of there are more and similar than the to assure Emma there are MOBAs this was asked a very famous shylu just about four hundred eighty five years ago where I'm path of one of the golem and his times worked and put a tremendous effort in reprinting the Rambam he took out all the mistakes and all the printing errors mama she put in a work of art and he printed around them and he was charging that to the affair price there was a non-jewish printer who was incensed because the man Padova did not use him to print use his competition so in a personal vendetta he set out to destroy them around path of her he was so upset you know in the guy's Chevelle don't get mad get even he's gonna get even he that he reprinted the Rambam a different round bomb and he gave it at a fraction of the cost so who's going to buy the man father this random if you get the guy should you know print and manage a fraction of the cost and it basically was going to destroy them around Passover and his investment but the mice that are open competition so the this grandma is a celebrated silver yes for biggest sizes but one of them is Nagaya for a low sodium and the month and there are mas says that Yosef says it's also why is it as to what's wrong so we have to make it Felix says there are more when something is Boreas a come if i opening a competing store you're destroying the existing one that's awesome dr. grandma since this guy is Boreas a cut no one's going to buy him on path of his print not only he had over here was wrong for doing it but there i must says it's also to buy that new print i grabbed the remote seems to hold forth of a portion if it's also to open a competing store it's also on us consumers to buy buy that store that was then opened the Issam ok not old agree but that's where I lost sense but here we see this important you soit fair competition is lotta circulatory competition that's elimination Boreas ache is awesome that some safer and a number of tubers uses this you saw it in some in some ha'la'tha fluorescent seminar in tests and facial mist but i intestines are an extremely important to ver for those that want to learn the sugar be Eon but basically this is the aside fair competition is water elimination is awesome I just saw a moisture inflation mr. Caleb a lemon olive was the ester following Schuyler someone opened in Tufts in Italian a Judaica star in a very small neighborhood a few years later someone opened they're competing today gusto yes from Asia is that right so moisture rights Guevara kawaii I investigated I spoke to people in the community and they told me that the community cannot support two Judaica stores maybe two groceries but not two Judaica stores and therefore I told the second person he acted in correctly because one's gonna go out of business so you can't do that the same idea this is Barajas acre you want to Sela Boucher mortify inflation wish but semi-nude get moment do a deliberation out of coke LeMat gimel different cases of Barajas acre that there's no Hector to open a competing store what's noteworthy the Masters Vigneron also one of the earlier pie scheme does not mention that the Austin but as a very interesting story then a certain city only one type of store Wow to open but you know either laughs they open the second store even though you're not supposed but it was it was existing so master Yama said you can't do that because if the second store is going to put the first two out of business there's no Hector they had this competition but not knocking at a second store so the mass of enjoyment on this all was Mohabbatein at the Austin okay so we have rabbi side to following your site to open another stores look uh if you're the same city as long as it's not eliminating the first store now if you'll ask me why is it also taco when you eliminate the first store is it Gizella is it magic it's hard to say it's namishyami it could add in it's probably a Tucanos puzzle like many other hull artists Akana so I'll um thickener all of them and some cytosine to say it's more of an it Sammamish but definitely it's awesome else the huzzah had to protect the concept of fair Commerce that's why it's awesome but I'll sit is the price we say it's awesome now we go on to a different Schuyler let me ask you what you think someone's on the way to Lake where he has an empty van he decides you know what I might as I make a few dollars he pulls up by a bus stop bus stop that's reading existence for years that has a bus route area to Lakewood and it happened instead of $20 I'll charge you could someone drive by your bus stop and scoop up all the passengers and make money question number two someone wants to make money quickly and he heard about a very big watch sale tomorrow's must be a big watch tale in a store they can be lines out the door the night before he's a clever fellow he goes to a friend of his was me a wholesale watch business he does a lot it takes a lot of watches the next day he goes to the watch though I'm sure enough is a line out the door so he goes over to a customer what's watching you buy eek oh I haven't happen to my pocket I'll give it to you the twenty percent less next gust majalaya I haven't have it in my pocket right here he has every watch in town this is my idea of selling online you know he's just selling my Amish online no look like what's wrong it's not Berea Seca you know the person will still have a business and I'm knocking him out you might just you know you might you know challenge his big sale but you're not knocking him out and also I live in the city what's wrong so here we come to a Gomorrah that's Nagaya to a big part of christian masuka's but certainly for us it's integral the Gomorrah earlier of us that we mentioned has a cashandra Hoonah how could wrap who look tight and that God says a rioter of Hoonah that wholeness says you're not allowed to open a competing explore lame and Messiah a pariah because the Gomorrah says it's in condition my freakin Mutsu there's a dog man had dog Kamali meets us hot dog which means basically and those days fishing was a very big business and someone had a fishing net in the water and that's Rashi explains he did some research and he figured out the best place to put the nets and right before he caught the fish someone comes along and swoops out the fish suptig amar that's awesome why obviously you can't compete with someone else's business suptig amano-san Araya maybe calculator open a competing store I why is this case of dogyum awesome so Rashi zipped up the marsh I need dog India javi Sierra so rashly explains the first fisherman investigated put in time effort to figure out where the fish are in the ocean any guy ain't almost ready to capture you come along as a vial of equipment when it's about payday and grab that fish so Raj's Russian is since the first person was but Toa command the monthly are they even in Sakai very mozzie Co now with truth is he didn't actually catch the fish yet because we caught the vision we take it from his nephew Nathan but it's almost like he has it but two of who he is confident tasteless and kaduche enough non-test has a different shot why do all the fish come to this person's net because he put out bait he invested money and he bought bait dead fish so he spends money invest in investment in attract new fish and you grab the fish you use it as investment that's awesome so we see from this Gemara an important concept if so if the first person invests the time quantity or money acquainted Isis and they're both true you can come along and take his work we're going to defer to this as the hollow of dogyum doctor I mean he invested time or money and you come along and grab it now again he didn't yet catch the fish so I can't say it's get Ava mama SH but you're taking his investment you know it's like it's a Michelin getting definite estimate days only a monocular races iose master tapster of also gazelle me dr. Shalom which means someone gets up on the tree and that's down deed olives but he cannot get down the catcher at the same time and you stand on the bottom of the tree and you catch all this Aysen and you take it it's not tackled again Ava but that's that B got dark Rochelle and Gaza he works and you reap the benefit and the postman repaired the tool he's an easy trapping the fish and the last moment you grab the fish isn't that a perfect analogy for our case the bus company invests time money both running a successful route route and all the passengers know to go to the bus stop at the last moment before the bus comes you scoop all the customers so you're not grabbing fist you grabbing passengers that's not right that's the case of Duggan even more clearly is the case of the onliner seller this man invests makes a big sale he tracks all the people that want to buy watches and you come along you grab the customers and this is something sort of a qualification to our Suqian yes you allow to compete you allow to open a competing store but if someone invested time or money if it's something similar to the case of Duggan that is improper now you want to just mention there is a reservation with this Halawa because if you know if you know remember I just said that the Gemara is the kasha under Hoonah it's a rioter of Hoonah from the case of doggie summer it's not a Rio but the whole Shuggie of doggie is going according to Ralph una and that's why some say maybe Lizzie Dan according to ref who no brainer have you sure that we pass can but you lad open a competing store maybe the gemara of dog M is not relevant if you Morris said that regarding Ramona and the MS is the Rambam riff and rush to do not mention the Aloha of dogging and that's why the bass the fryin says it's not a gala my so the D done but the truth is in swara was not a spirit we passed you that open a competing store true why because you're not taking his customer he doesn't own the custom but if a person invested time and effort like the case of dog in maybe that's taka awesome and that's what most post Kim seemed to accept that taco let's just review you latter open a competing store if you come from the same city summoners Barea sake is awesome and something that we could say is similar to Doug him where the first person invested time money or both that's untouchable and of course you have to realize that a customer we won't say the customer belongs to two storekeeper number one people are very disloyal to their stores they shall pay it today here tomorrow it's hard to say that a typical customers like dogyum so that's why we'll make a feel like doggy miss hasta and opening a new stores would let's apply this the mice a typical question someone wants to open a competing fruits for pizza shop bakery the list goes on and on so basically if you follow the rules you're okay if you come from the city and you're not doing you're not taking be a diam someone else's things I survived stambha and the truth mr. Fela Calif tough stuff and toughs afoul of and both to be says what's wrong said a rough told him to close down I don't still why the rough did that he says you can't go into the other person's store and attract his customers that's tacky wrong but basically to open a fair competing store make a grand opening is all within the parameters of Allah the question that I began with any Shiva someone wants to open another canteen like they call it the cell from his locker raised danishes or that's a big business you have to realize but he's opening a competing business again as long as the first person didn't buy rights exclusive rights to have his business the second Buckner is okay I'll tell you a my sister higher that really is an important inside until I was lucky there was a certain yeshiva but that was not in a predominantly Jewish neighborhood there was one grocery in the corner of the Shiva that basically existed because of a little business from the neighborhood not much and I think primarily the business from the yeshiva people bought things in July the bokram and basically Shiva realized that this is not good for the Shiva bhakta magong the whole days that of corner grocery you know it's not good for the store 'm so they installed in these shiva soda machines and candy machines and the danish the machines and the storekeeper came running this not it's not good you would in my business it was a possible Boreas acre but then again the sheba says we don't open achiever to support a grocery it's very detrimental our welcome leaves say to go to the corner grocery and foot narendra who once said a buffer going to the corner grocery today sees more nationís than his aid in the step like ants 11 the corner grocery going out in the street is not healthy especially during the summer but this is a question the store people is losing but you have to protect the consumer in this case the buckram you know you have to push it was a question of citria shiva rose Gnaeus so here it's very logical to say that we're gonna have to think about toy bus I like him at the post can refer to don't forget the whole reason that you might have a competing store is tightness how like them think about the consumer here we're talking about a situation that you have to save the achiever you have to say that smarter the Ruhr so maybe we'll say toy bus like him in this case overrides even Boreas ankle now I won't explain you can't do an issue to do a mitzvah imagine SML tells you you know if you break someone else's window I'll give you I'll give $100 to the doctor you can't break a window fit sadaqa so how could you cause sixth or the clothes because you want to protect the buckram deterrence is as we explained earlier even when it's Bari has a cup the case of that be Austin when it's Boreas acre is not ostomy dinner Gemara summer same whole there's no such it sir some households only according through Huna and even we passed him that it's all sir but it's not it's a gum it's not gesso it's not magic it's protecting the the big picture the other consumer the other storekeeper but in the case that there is at econo for the like them maybe we have to think the big picture and say listen you have to save the Tommy's mother yeshiva and I know there in that case the Shiva is allowed to keep that those those machines open because again the sheave is not there to keep the support of local grocery and as we'll see as we proceed the toy bus how likely is a very big factor in a low sodium but here we have to realize Titus I'll like them is again the deciding factor and we'll soon see as we go along more shy versa I'll tell you a beautiful nice say that I saw one of the Yanam or to say that they were a mish but I match in summer well he described the shout that he had there was someone that had we call a van service who took both women seminary girls narrow from the airport to the schools and back and forth and he had what we call a patent he took your luggage to the center for free and they know that brought it to the airport and then he charged a rate for transporting the person to the airport and that he was a very very successful business he had to hire extra workers then another person says that's a good business and he opened the same business luggage the little bit free and the course to the airport is the same and the first person is not right he's taking my business who's right so this Diane said that basically it's not very as a club because they already coexisted for a year and a half and both are existing ok the second person attacker took a significant part of the business but he didn't put the other amount of business I he's using my cup my patent so he proves which is really push it there's no you can have a copyright this is not the biggest world's biggest costume in the world you can't have a copyright that you know clogging the streets like saying I'm giving a free delivery and no one could copyright that's not a copyright material I the case of fish that the fish did was a specific surface to this fish here it's future fish you ever selves the future fish so he says that basically it's not something that you could say you have rights to it exclusive rights to it so he's passing that the second one could continue business but as absurd which which but but they didn't typically do use a different language for advertising and also charge a little more for the actual transport of the people to the airport but this is something after real life not everything is automatically my copyright or my exclusive rights you know it's not such a customer that whatever this person did question someone had to somebody's destroyed the Shila a jewel has the old Minik which is brought in PI scheme death on a shine around but the shaman sells a shyness someone came in the shoe and started selling a shot it's not the shaman and they evicted him is that right or not why can I fear business I'm not open to business oh but this is not true even if it's not Boreas acre but this is the case of doggy because the shul caters to the psalmist that's part of his patients income and that's really what he was but Toa and that's his rights now if quasi could go in the corner but he can't say you can't in the store that's in the show that's the rights of the Shabbos and her pulse is a hundred Ralph used to tell us he wants when it was a young child go back probably seventy years ago he once sold her shyness on the corner of the black with the Statler of business was and the psalmist which is not the Shama Sunnah that we didn't have two rappers God but a shaman in those days was so upset he took the stand and turned over all the shot a shot of her onto the floor and conquered them Sam Grover bo walked by and notice what happened and he yes to shine this what you own the block so you bent down and picked up a shyness and bought one for him and his Rebbetzin note they'll see them store that they're ever bought from those in shyness and they bought out the whole van the whole store so if you want to make a big business you have to try to reenact that but that's all of them the soul is your exclusive rights but you don't own the block my sister Jolla someone pulled into a neighborhood and with a fruit truck and souls fruit at a discounted price and the locals were all upset but the embassies he has no right they have the right to be upset if these are been here and it's not Berea Seca he also has the right to make Panos in fact I serves the ecig zilberstein and the safer of a nose job fiacre on the tough race a decade he says even if he's not a venire if he's selling at a significant discount he's allowed to because this is Toyota's election there are more in cookin involves iron and our simin says if it's a benefit to the community even a Benny Eric Harris ladder operate again the bottom line has to be we have to make commerce accessible to all business accessible to all and that this will be a case of pirates who like them perhaps even a Benny Eric area is what question someone pulls into a bungalow County and he has a truck and he sells food or items but his fruits and bakery goods and the bumble County owner has a store and he wants to evict him I have a store and you obviously can't come into my bungalow County so this tadka he in this case talk to debunk all he has the right of way because this is his territory he built the colony this is part of his income this is like something that's like his dog and maybe it's like even a little city but certainly this is like his dog in and you can't come in to take away his business we had this child of someone else in the camper I go to you know typically analysis is pretty common they have these ice cream trucks going from Camp to camp economy to colony selling special ice cream so the canteen manager was not happy to lose a business so the bottom said no no but this ice cream is a totally different product I guess there's a new type of to a denim you know two different ice creams so if that's the case that it's not much a different quality then we have the Remora mas says that if ii like a second life is selling a different product so the first way if it can't you have a timer I'm selling a different product different quality the same remote and toy bus how like someone asked the question and this is a question that today we see a lot of this this idea people in recent years have focused on helping click a dish with is reborn and Rab am curling delight and the for Pesach Allah muscle there's this food that's sold that a significant almost cost price or suits and then chosen the question is it's nice to help younger light and help rub on them rebellion but you are hurting the local stores so here we have a number of reason why that's what them first of all it's all been a ho ear it's not Berea sake but it doesn't put the other stores out of business before pace up they lose taco a significant amount of sales but this is something that is not Boreas a cup but most of all you have to do this is a bonafide toy us how like them this is something that we have to realize that is helping you know multitudes of people that buying things that find it hard to fool young teeth I gave a muscle you know imagines - someone finds the cure for an immaculate something Allah to do that because you're putting the Funeral Chapel out of business so even though it's not exactly the same but if someone wants to help people you can't see you can't help people because I'm losing my profit so if the whole focus is Titus how like him it's understandable that this would be a taze awful a type now we understand without a question if I open a good mask and I give out I give outfit I things for free you can't say closed down because you're hurting the locals because asset is not competition I'm not opening a business I'm open guy I'm doing acid so we have to realize that when it's a big type of the like him that would be another example of Zaku Latoya question there was a community that has a number of small stores a bakery a grocery and their fruits fruits gone and a butcher and a fish store and someone comes along which is the the fear of all fears for the Lord the small stores opens what's called a one-stop shopping opens a big store that has everything under one roof and you know the small stores are hurting come you know he's a he has a big store so again emotionally get old involved but you think about it this is a real toy bus I like them now Thursday night the younger man has to go shopping if there's six different stores well she she by eating the time to learn he spent six hours going from butcher to fish thought the fruit store that the grocery store you go into one stuff short one-stop shopping you buy in an hour when you go learn for five hours you know that's that's really what they're you know time is that night is to learn so to say that because the locals are losing some of their business you're going to say you can't open a benefit to the community this is something that is tie us how like Jim which is merely the main focus of everything and the place can say unequivocally this is multiple the question is if the big one-stop shopping store puts the locals out of bed this when it's Boreas acre that's a very difficult and often painful Schuyler because Lamaze so we could still say that if it's Titus I like them how could you hurt the Sieber because of local stores I know someday on earth told me that that might be the right answer again as painful as it seems but when you have a significant type of solution that might outweigh the Boreas acre of you see them but I would say it's not push it also we have to realize you have to see the big picture when you give full support to a once big store he might exploit that he'll put all the locals out of business and then he has the monopoly and then I really take advantage of everybody all around so in the long run it might just be a type of like them to keep thing as it is so I would definitely advise before you even think about a sub-meter nightly Boreas acre SQ Schuyler get an objective suck and do Kedah cetera does the hollow these are locust of what we just learned does apply to a non-jewish store let the non-jew store is an existence that we have the same whole office so the piston equation in immigration and pest he says if the issue is outs teeming Asia sorry al it wouldn't apply to a guy it's not real but if it's Al's grammar maybe it does apply which lose a witness because really this LP like a Medina there are no restrictions there again there's almost unlimited unrestricted competition so if lamai said according to the high comedy Neil I don't do what you want why when our relationship to the norms you want we follow the secular law and basically that's what it seems is the correct answer that as long as something that is done fairly according to law that would be the guiding force my sister Jolla someone was working on a and a different shots were heard of the idea and decided to take the Shiva when approached what are you doing you're taking is fantastic so now I'm doing the show mitzvah so that's wrong because when my sir this is not just a four this is something he put his time and effort this is like the case of the dog I'm a dog in which is his and I added I told him if you want to do the share Mitzvah so by all means so work on the when it comes to Chicanos give it to the first person the Mitzvah is to do the that's not to take the shot cornice so all of a sudden he was no longer you know so altruistic as he used to be but anyhow basically it's taking someone if the place can say Avada is an Advil especially if the first person invested his time or effort even though he doesn't own the boy or girl there's no pinion but it's basically an effort that he invested the question that we began with the bus stop can I Drive by a bus stop an offer ride so past this if you take you and objectively let's say I come from the same city which I do and it's not Berea Seca the bus company is not going out of business guy took five of his passengers it should be moto but then again this seems to be very similar to the case of dog they established the bus route and some ones they run a bus at a loss just to keep that schedule and you take their schedule and pick up customers so that's definitely a case of dogging my serves Augustine and his safest year Toyota - discusses other shells of sagas caval and says this is definitely austere out the case of doggin I did seem akela min this shiloh the Pisgah equation I'm enraged Samak test says that dogyum is different fundamentally because you have you worked on this dog so that dog is yours but here they worked on other customers today it's a different a different customer what gives them the right to the new customers that they not yet have but then again of course we could argue at me but they brought these customers here but this what he says also what I would a smart that I've heard is the bus companies are not so but Toa they know people come along and authorize or take rides or get hitches and are else called hoppers for reason they happen what what doesn't belong to them but people grab passengers but really what I think the real Tyner here is that this is a type of a like them someone has to get to Lake with takes a longer time you get a ride you could trim you got your travel time to have an half-hour Lamesa if someone is an icky cop I am he doesn't take someone just to make money that's for sure it's definitely a big therapy and maybe it's us and making it in because this would be something similar to dog him now of course if you pick up someone and give him a free ride cuz it is a Camuto somebody asked me a tricky question he was thinner my bus stopped and someone drove by and said I need two of you come for free because he wants to go into HOV Lane he wasn't making money but he was saving time so maybe you look at that as you know fast said that you know mountain score would see them but definitely we could say professor it isn't what's up and leave that peace if the bus is late you have to get to your destination so that would be a type of selection that can't be ignored and then oh is this a motor to take that right after and father is the very challenging question of opening a show you Shiva crazyville medical office when it might interfere with someone else's panel so it's interesting the Gemara based on the Gemara it should be the same guidelines if I don't put the existing chul-soo Shiva out of business and I come from the same city what's the Shila but what's interesting is the Kumar at the end of the oven is a file from a days after tomorrow discusses raccoon or gonna be aw sewer and I quote oh my the Rav wound up who's underlined that the mick retired decayed by a mohammed Lamott SEMA a kiev he can't stop another mohammed from coming into business dumb american aside from terrible kaufman Rashi explains because if you have competition you're going to work harder now this again is the same basic premise that competition is very productive very helpful for the consumer if the Shiva has exclusive rights to a certain area they peek so to speak they could rest on the laurels and base to the complacent and that's it as soon as competition opens up they have to earn their existence they start working harder they start finding the reasons to have a resource room and this that and everybody prospers so the Gemara seems to be saying Daniel Attah oh we ought to be open up a different race Mohammed is there to them sorry wasn't yeshiva because again we're encouraging competition to give maximum benefit to the ton of us how election and the circle earth twice record this and face the misfit and see Bob and in your a day erase them hey cabeza a malama to lie to come along and open his tutoring services and Ramos spells out a row of in the air that's that's been in the city someone else who come along even though he's in the cafe a class - Tyreese and I was a state near a mall now the big question is is this Litella the Rob that asked me to shower is it a killer to open when I will hurt other a bottom in the area how about if it's barriers ankle how about if this rub is so talented he will put the other row basically out of business and he might exist but he's not going to have any panel so so to answer both I will ask a different question a very simple question what's the Big Finish of MacArthur cadets mutter we just learned to serve your corn through Nevada we show you how to open a competing grocery store so if a grocery is multa what's the fitness about of Malamud fish slime according to rob muna that hold you can't open a competing grocery that's the finished and indeed the kumaras lotion is employed Arizona but with the down that you could open a competing store so what's the big finish about of Malamud so the answer probably is posted by a regular grocery even if it's multimeters casitas not to butts up the base a Fryman similar curves iron based on a marsh or by milan magar ithaca we have to encourage it it's not even a sauna me this casitas it could be even more than this if you look in the rama and the chriskate Shubin seat caught me science tells us out by a regular store there's a hatter only from the person same city but regarding a Malamud even from a different city its motor a rough from a difference that he could open a different show in a different city and the end although Rashi and tasteless and the beer Gras and see phenomena seems to say that it's only from the same city but Lamesa we see in the realm on the Pacific over there will be the kiddush of the Malamud even enough from a different city he could open a differential the big question is is there a heta even if it's Boreas ankle let's say I come from the same city I open a new shoe and that will put out the put the other suit out of business in swaro you'll say since the heckler is can I say from tyre become a young adult i reveai de like throw more quotes so why isn't an unlimited heads-up you have to increase Tyra learning and Andrew and Rob honest etc but if you look at this lesson Lucifer Laura and in your idea the second Rob is multi even if his make up a up SAS de ponerse of the first one is masked Maroney he slightly affects the first one and you know it could be this far is what are you trying to do try and be merry but IRA so so you're not making two shoes you're knocking out the first and now you're their only show so what's the brunch time game there's still one show left if you have a second suit and they both work hard and they both produce that's the objective but knocking out the first and and you're the number one ally the only issues to what we gain and Reformation tries to miss but hey look a Laflamme at first seems to hold like that it's a very interesting - Berber cloud you know I know there are many other factors to it but Meister does say the second school that opened put the first rub out of business had no right to do that now I know we look in the tuber it's not as simple as they make it it was a very bizarre story the first rough calls his valley bottom communists to show him and they weren't too happy about that as you can understand so they got a different rug so it was other factors also very much does that you can't open a shul that basically diseases the first 100 arrests Nelson inhaling doll equipment offensive cotton test says a difference for while you can't open and put a first and most it out of business he quotes up some sofa that says if you're gonna do that so who didn't open Atari the game I said he'll open today and someone come along tomorrow and put them out of business subject some site we have to protect the rebuffed IRA if we don't protect the existing my is this that's the biggest sovereign for the like there's an asterick chuhwa and then Kazee it's could fail equipment outlet goes back to top Salama tests he was asked by the Museum of Seagate the community seeker that we have today they invest a tremendous amount of money effort time to established a community there in Seagate and they were afraid someone's gonna come along after all the work and open an existing a competitive outcome I'm competing sure so the minutes cook joined a number of bond under said you can't open a shul and see it at that time why this is not mr. case of document they invested dumb and parity and you come along and just use all of their investment no that's that's certainly a case that's positive if someone establishes a community and builds a community and a competing rough can't come along and do that now Lamaze I wanted we be clear this question is a very sensitive question to open a Meister Latoya that puts the other my CID quote out of business is a very sensitive question if you look you might find some are Mako we did we did find some amass mill I spoke to a dying that said taka it's not a partial deshyla but definitely we could say that before you do some of that make sure you ask asylum but the shout that we began with with this very tiny mistake at our local Rob want to know okay open your community that I'll take some as far from other tools but no one's going out of business we told them do it like Attila and it's not a concern and meters can see the season this is the Allah God this is the Gemara does the show Camaro from two places that yeah go Turkey the Knesset entire Coffman as long as ever it continues to exist this would not be absurd even a meters casitas it slammed Africa a like we said a Martha picks it up Mohammed Arthur he laughed after Mohammed our Turkey the same is true regarding opening at competing yeshiva a coil Oh a basic Lloyd the fact is Tyra has to be more of a Revo and by comparing competition that really great ins the extent of hats lock in Tyler in fact some safe and achieve and Simon iron tests seems to say this Hector of Mohammed Arthur he is live Darko Tyra it's any divine Mitzvah in other words competition breeds success and loud bass guitar any Mitzvah now I've got the saw ones that the price can use this the muscle and Lucy Mordecai in the injured in Haitian mr. base semi-nude base was the Esther stylist someone built a mikvah and grout he charged very high prices and they opened the second mixer and the first person that time is so one of his time this is that some cyclist says 'add vomits this mata you can't stop the mixing opening and also add parenthetically that when my sir you've charged so much that pushes women didn't go to the mixer because of you it was too expensive so that's certain that famous I like them so although not all agree that every mixes motive I saw the some of the place can question if some cipher but definitely when it's a mocking Mitzvah that will enable more to do a mitzvah there is a hectare opening a medical office when there is an existing medical office opening a medical practice this you retire absorber Stein I'm at 150 says this is something that it's so important because Lamesa if a doctor has a certain complacency he's not going to do the job the way should the more doctors the better for the consumers not consumers it's people that are fighting for their lives this is very important what I saw was interesting to me opening a playgroup a babysitting service when it might affect others so it's the same your sight as long as you don't put the others out of business is mutt Joba Steinem is safer quotes is Varuvaayaa ship that may be a babysitting service or a playgroup is look too even if you come from a different city because each babysitting service each player has their own special devotion special care special concern so it's like a different product that the original one cannot offer I would be remiss and I mentioned at least briefly what I think is really severe the cecum of today that has initially Moonen betoken para Gitmo in the beginning discusses a scandal where there was a certain city that a Malamud came from a different city and started tutoring children and the malama in the city were outraged outraged and he wanted to run him out of town he's a ride that he's a gun if and has an ish said if only people live out pattaya this person was following a lava he quotes the sketch over that we mentioned even from a different city you allow to do it how could you you confuse the right that's under narrative the second Muhammad was do not read in the existing Malanda wasn't right film and then later in sto demo you dollar and tense verb he gives a tremendous high scuffle and he said that really when any discomfort to any competition you should not worry at all you know not even do anything I'll PL pH gopher because the Gomorrah says in you Mohammed customer base ain't a nageire massugu holiday I flew the coop winema you're not you know if the work you're gonna have you up on a story Shona hey Shona is could sue them so why do you have to go to the entire that's your fever be status mega status but it's not that you worried that he's taking you up on hasta because no one takes and I saw up Sehgal the Manchester receives the final live rock and his snoozin I'm a coffee mo he says how should either shouldn't area look like this is moving should come swimming I love you obviously even efforts I know you can't touch a proof in my Panozzo but there's a fee of of me to make establish so let's go to the entire but we're the best of friends and I want to say reps ago was not Irish now McKay hurry this my talent of his at the end of his life is his Shiva was dwindling and someone came along open a different yeshiva and it was a big threat to see Shiva of Sehgal italic that he was not only didn't say anything but became best friends between Russia Shiva and he said publicly than when he says hollow honest my she enough the first Hashanah is busy Shiva the second one is for the other Shiva the first huxley for not is for his Shiva and the second one is for the other yeshiva that's see the scoffer I couldn't Doug the same you should say like you'll be a Shack after us mr. today's special share a few biggest your character over Omaha I'm Eisner sponsoring today sheerly the niche mass emo should hinder Buster of a roma malayalam Smith says cecum of today's share five minutes open on you've been Akashi massacres bizarre cases so figure here military mission Emma I know Hoffa salon seized a yard will tear thee out there [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] Oh [Music] Oh [Music] just a short time we learned today you have to realize that first and foremost during this year we said at the end of this year but I will say at the beginning of the shift the cecum a nothing they get my some Oakland Kaveri the person should live with the talkin do business with talkin but there's a fee established to be on top of things and basically how the basic cloud is a competing stores allowed to open if he's from the been a year and it's not Boreas acre now Perez acre means if you will not do take enough take business that will put the other person out of business know how to advertise your data make sales and I'll make promotionals there are a few suarez while you how to open a competing store la loca number one my own behind me hide the first the second person also gotta make up Inasa it's very much the toy bus like him that should be competition and also in Halawa its he doesn't own the business or the customers for that matter so basically in a fair situation you allow to open a competing store to unto unfairly encroach on someone spinosa or take his business secrets or there's a different share for but you take someone's work is which is wrong you're on the sky very that's that's worse but basically fair competition is a logically sanctionable there's also a me discuss see this not to do that but basically an irregular cos a situation you allow to open a competing store if the other person invested in a time money or both he has more of a claim he's but to ask to these two this item that similar phenomena chief Barajas arias that's what we call the case of dog in that even though it's not his halakhah mommy's but it's it's as if it's his and it's hands off for any other people to take it to open a different store in the neighborhood is okay open and miss Eva a different canteen is okay we even considered when it's very much Latoya Sega Shiva they could put machines into the yeshiva even though that will affect the local store and a possible Berea Zakim you know how to open a different van service if there's no copyright on the first persons approach you allowed to sell our shyness on the corner of the shoe but not in the shoe because that's the exclusive rights of - Amish a fruit store a food truck that parks on a block in a neighborhood is okay but in a bungle County can't come with your own store when the owner has rights to that bungalow County you let us sell a different item because that there are muscles a type of cell like them an ice cream truck in a camp or colony you louder give professor said or Agra ma that's not competition you're doing a mitzvah one-stop shopping but there are cloud is mahtim when there's a possibility of putting other person on a business please ESCA sila it's a very sensitive issue it's basically these these are the halacha supply taking someone else's thoughts for a siddha for a bus stop it's not push it to take passengers you're doing it for money I wouldn't do it certainly so there are some that I may go but if you're doing the Shah Mitzvah or if the person is late and needs a ride then you'll have to do it because the type of Tsar like them in this case overrides it by Tyra whether it's see shiva stools Carlin Basie archives the tutoring there is no basic cloud of competition it seems even there's no meet irska see this to refrain even a different city could could involve themselves in this city if it's Boreas acre many pie schema maxima and definitely city as cassava for any Mitzvah but some sites seems to be Maiko to opening a medical practice a in it even in different neighborhood seems to be muta as we said because that's like Tyra that we had asked the more medical practice the better treatment there are for the people a playgroup seems to be like a different product a lot of open even coming from a different city but certainly to open a babysitting service playgroup in the same city is fine dick is that the talkin and live with her husband