0:00 / 0:00
Here's an uncensored RESPONSE to JEW-HATRED
923 views
A fresh approach to antisemitism. -- Unpack the Talmud and explore; A story of a pias man's approach to haters.
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Candace Owens was on the Pierce Morgan
show she was debating with another Rabbi
and she's come out as an anti-semite as
a Jew hater I mean you listen to her
opinions she's just her comments about
the Holocaust when the issue of islamist
extremism was raised that this is
starting to show and emerge in the US
her reply is there's also extremist
Judaism and you have to be careful you
have these crazy kabad people they're
are followers of the
lbab and they have crazy extremist
views and they're following this rabi
and they're digging tunnels at their
world headquarters and throwing benches
and she starts ragging on about kabad
how just like there's extremist Islam
well there's also extremist Jews be
careful they might give you some good
cholent and chicken soup I don't know
the initial reaction would be to be
defensive okay friends The Story begins
we are back we're exploring the secrets
of the talmud the values ethics and
lessons from the
talmud and we are on the toward the
bottom of
bra
32b and if you're following the link on
k.org that I had sent it's the second to
last Hebrew
paragraph of the page toward the bottom
where it says the sages
taught and I think today's lesson is
going to be very relevant to the times
which we find ourselves
in because what I see over here is a
lesson in how to approach anti-semites
I believe I just you know you follow
people on social media
and or see what people post on social
media advocates for Jewish people and I
strongly believe we are approaching
anti-Semitism
incorrectly because we're spending so
much try time trying to defend ourselves
and less time trying to become
ourselves and if we were more
comfortable with
ourselves and needing less the validity
of other
people I think we'd be in a much
healthier
space with that introduction that's not
directly what the t's addressing but I
think it's strongly related let's read
it inside you guys see it the sages
taught there was a related incident
it's continuing from a previous incident
in the talmud there was a related
incident involving a particular Pious
man who is praying while traveling along
his path when an officer came and
greeted
him the pious man did not pause from his
prayer and did not respond with a
greeting so he's in the middle of the
amida he's doing with
concentration and some sort of Officer
or government official comes up to him
and says hey and he's just ignoring him
he's back in his book the officer waited
for him until he finished his
prayer after he finished his prayer the
officer said to him you good for nothing
you endangered
yourself I could have killed
you right that's how it works in uh a
lot of these countries isn't it written
in your Torah take utmost care and guard
yourself diligently and that's the verse
but from which we derive the obligation
to remain healthy you not put yourself
in danger he says you put yourself in
danger you ignored a government official
who has the power to to take you into
custody to kill you to do negative
things to you you should have that
should have uh been a priority over
prayer you could have interrupted your
prayers for that and is it it also
written take therefore good heed onto
yourselves why did you ignore the danger
to your life this is what this Officer
says he's kind of messing with this Jew
and using his own laws and rules rules
and to kind of mess with
him when I greeted
[Music]
you why did you not respond with a
greeting were I to sever your head with
a sword who would hold me accountable
for your spilled blood would have been
your fault you had it
come this is what the officer says to
the
guy what does the pious man say to him
which by the way that's in some ways
he's right you generally don't interrupt
or pause in the middle of the IMA
because you're talking to God unless
it's a life-threatening
situation
um this is a life threatening situation
right if an officer or police officer
were to stop you in the middle of doing
while you're at the airport or whatever
it
is it's questionable do you stop do you
not stop right how big of a scene is it
going to make but if you're
in a communist country Canada no I'm
kidding I've been waiting for that if
you're if if you're in a communist
country you're in China you're in
Russia and an officer stops you and you
don't answer right what might happen
next right if you're in Iran and you're
in the middle of talking to God you're
doting and you don't stop you have to
stop so he says the blood would have
been on your hands you're doing
something wrong now it's interesting by
the way just to point out that the
officer didn't actually kill him he was
just messing with him
right he didn't actually say what he was
going to do he was just being
theoretical over here philosophical
about it the pious man said to him wait
for me until I will appease you with my
words in other words I have a good I
have a good explanation over here he
said to him had you been standing before
a flesh and blood king a physical King
and your friend came and greeted you
would you return his greeting this is
what the pious man asks him let's go to
the top of
33a the officer says to him him no the
pious man
continue and if you would greet him what
would they do to you so you're standing
in front of a king in his Palace he's
King's in his on his throne you're
standing right there and you start
chatting with somebody else what would
that King do to you the officer said to
him they would cut off my head with a
sword the pious man said to him isn't
this ma a matter isn't this matter aary
inference there's no good English word
for that but in Hebrew we say
which
means how do we translate is there a
good translation for this somebody
shared with me once a translation they
use in the legal uh terms but isn't it
something like uh something follows
logically because of exactly like like B
has to be true if a is true exactly like
if
I if I can reach the top shelf Rabbi
Raleigh for sure can reach the top shelf
right didn't you see a term 40 or
something yeah but that I think that's
like a French word no it's from Latin
but we use it in English we use it in
okay fine um for area Hebrew
say you are standing before a king of
Flesh and Blood and whom you fear is
limited because today is here but
tomorrow he's in the grave so you're
afraid of a king of Flesh and Blood
you'll respect him and not just be
distracted and talk to somebody else
even though he's here temporarily he's
not
Eternal would you have reacted in that
way way right I who is standing and
praying before The Supreme King of Kings
the Holy One Blessed Be he who lives and
he and endures for all of eternity all
the more so I could not pause to respond
to someone's greeting if you're afraid
or or have reverence
for a temporary
King shouldn't we have reverence for an
eternal
King now mind you this is an anti-semite
I don't know if he believes in God
necessarily right maybe not the same
version of God but this is what he's
saying how did the officer react to this
when he heard this the officer was
immediately appeased and the pious man
returned home in
peace okay a number of questions
practical questions come up here which
is where does this Pious man get this
piousness to ignore the officer at the
expense of his
life there there's there's something
called in the talm
a you know what a means a means a Pious
person literally a means a fool and
sometimes a person could be a
foolish Pious person and that's that's
frowned upon the tal gives several
examples of a of
a of a Pious
fool somebody who sees somebody Dr
drowning he says I should save him oh
it's a woman I can't save her that would
be physical cont right that's called
that's a Pious fool right obviously life
would be the priority saving somebody's
life would be the priority and Jewish
law of not touching the opposite gender
but would be suspended the T gives
another
example um let's
say you know there's a there's a um
there's a Jewish welfare program in the
Bible
right
called and Le and right the corner of
your field that you have to leave and
the sheaves of your field that you had
forgotten to collect while you're
reaping your field but you're supposed
to or or harvesting your field you're
supposed to leave it for the poor people
right now how do you define poor
people right there's an income level
that the Tom talks about and somebody
who's just below the income level and
now you give him a quarter for charity
out of the kind of your heart and you
put him above the income level but now
you're starving the guy because he can't
collect that charity
anymore right the name of kindness It's
called The I'm just giving random
examples in the tal
of of a foolish Pious person he's not
really P he's more foolish than he is
pious obviously right we it you say
Pious factiously over
here we don't refer to this man is a
foolish Pious person he's just a Pious
person and it sounds like we we we see
his behavior as something
commendable something we want to learn
from this is how we do it during prayer
we stand up what is going on here so
there are a number of commentaries that
address
this some of them say the fact that the
officer had introduced himself he
already knew this was heading in the
right direction that he's messing with
me he's not actually going to kill me
right he was able to read a situation
but there are some commentaries that
take this uh that see this very
differently why was he allowed to put
his life in danger and not respond to
the
officer he didn't even notice the
officer that's the real answer he was
praying he was doing to God he was
connecting with God when we're standing
and connecting with God
it's you're like on a date you go on a
date with your spouse you shut off your
phone talking with God I shot off the
world nobody
else
matters this anti-semite was
irrelevant that's why he didn't answer
him the real reason why he didn't answer
him and if I'm going to I'm not going to
sacrifice my
relationship to answer the
phone I'm not going to sacrifice my
connection with God because you want to
say hey why didn't you answer me while
we were
praying in other
words this fellow was so
comfortable with his relationship with
Hashem so comfortable with his Jewish
identity he didn't care about the other
guy about the
anti-semite it wasn't like please don't
distract me and this is why it's
important that I pray and let me justify
it's like bro I'm in the middle of
something come back to me soon he didn't
even he didn't even give him the
attention when I read this story in the
talmud the the first thing that came up
in my mind was what's going on in in
current uh
events of Jews and Israel being blamed
for things they aren't
doing and US thinking that we need us as
a community thinking that we need to
justify ourselves we have to justify why
it's okay to protect ourselves or why
it's okay to publicly be Jewish and wear
a keep on campus and why it's necessary
and why Israel is necessary because
there was a holocaust and we need the
safety space and please
understand why do we need to explain
this to the world if we are comfortable
in our identity I'm not saying we
shouldn't explain this to the world I'm
saying we shouldn't feel like we need to
explain it to the world for their
validity
because we have a stronger sense of
validity deep down
inside I reflect back on the story of
The Exodus of
Egypt the night before The
Exodus Hashem commands the Jewish people
to paint the doorposts with blood Jewish
people should remain in their homes the
angel of death is going to come and slay
the firstborn of all Egyptians
and it's important that Jewish people
stay indoors shelter stay at
home I remember when the shelter in
place during Co four or five years ago
took place it was around the time where
it was around pesak time and everybody
was referencing this quote in the Bible
shelter at home stay in place for pesak
right this was the first Passover and we
were commanded to shelter at
home
why so the basic reason and this is the
reason Rashi brings is that this angel
of
death you know get out of the way the
Egyptians are out and about the angel of
death is going to kill them and you stay
at home and just don't don't get in the
way one of the commentaries known as the
abarbanel one of my favorite
commentaries really lot of fun a lot of
interesting explanations by raise of
hands have you heard of the
abarbanel his name is
ranel Abel originally lived in
Spain um I know I'm going on a little
bit of a tangent here hope you're okay
with
itel lived in Spain in 14 1500s he was
an
accountant and a rabbi you know whose
accountant he
was King Fern fer Fernand Fernando and
Queen
Isabella he was their
accountant and when it came time for the
expulsion and all the Jews are being
kicked out of Spain he's packing his
bags and they say we're going to offer
you the opport to stay because we're
you're a good
accountant and you get to stay he says
no I'm not leaving my
people if the Jews are going I'm going
and he ended up leaving and
unfortunately as a result of that he
lost a lot of his writings as well um he
then moved to
Italy fascinating okay sorry my that was
all in
Brackets um brackets closed the
abarbanel says why shelter in place the
angel of death doesn't know and God
doesn't know that these are Jews these
are Egyptians kill these people don't
kill these people it's going to get
confused remember the story of Kamar
coma we discussed a couple weeks ago our
last Tom class right so he gonna get
confused he doesn't
know so the aranel says there's a
different reason why we needed to
shelter in
place what's going to happen the the the
angel of death is coming and killing the
first borns what's Pharaoh going to do
guys get out of
Egypt and we're going to be tempted to
run out of Egypt because Pharaoh just
gave us permission shelter in place you
don't need Pharaoh's permission to leave
Egypt you're not leaving Egypt and
you're not going to be free because
Pharaoh says you're free you're going to
be free because God says you're free so
shelter in place and you're going to go
out not in the middle of the night when
Pharaoh releases you out of out of
pressure but when God redeems you in
broad daylight the next morning that's
when you're going to get to go that's
when you're going to get to
leave in other words the validity of our
freedom is not coming from Pharaoh it's
coming from God the validity of us being
the Jewish people of us having a
connection to our promised land does not
come from the UN or from CNN or any of
those any of these
people we don't need their validity we
don't need to explain it to them it
comes from
God I'm sorry if I'm getting a little
political here but um and I might get
canceled for this but what the heck no
I'm
kidding just
yesterday Candace
Owens was you guys saw this Candace
Owens was on the Pierce Morgan
show um she was debating with another
Rabbi yeah exactly I see the comment
there um she was debating with another
Rabbi who was also uh controversial for
other reasons which we won't get into on
the
air um
and she's come out as an anti-semite as
a Jew hater I mean you listen to her
opinions she's just her comments about
the Holocaust her comments about and
when the issue of islamist
extremism was raised that this is
starting to show and emerge in the US
her reply is there's also extremist
Judaism and you have to be careful you
have these crazy kabad people they're
followers of the
laab and they have crazy extremist
views and they're following this Rabbi
who died 30 years ago and that they're
continuing to follow his path and
they're digging tunnels at their world
headquarters and throwing benches and
she starts ragging on about kabad how
just like there's extremist
Islam who wants to kill people in the
name of jihad because they don't believe
what you believe well there's also
extremist Jews be
careful right they might give you some
good cholent and chicken soup I don't
know what's they'll ask you if you've
wrapped today yeah exactly
it's I
feel and the reason why I mention this
is
because the initial
reaction from any uh any Jew who would
respect the would be to be
defensive and to start explaining how
she's Incorrect and how she said some
horrible things as well which we don't
need to get into you can watch it on
YouTube um but to explain why she's
Incorrect and why that's a lie and why
she's misleading people and we have to
explain ourselves have to justify our
existence and then I read this story in
the
talmood of this Pious person who has a
connection and doesn't care about the
officer why do I need to justify my
existence to Candace Owens or to the
world watching her who
cares the best response
is to feel very strong about who I am
maybe we will respond to her maybe
somebody will respond to her but the
moment we feel the need to be
defensive is the moment that we've lost
focus on who we really
are and that's a
problem the moment we're very focused on
who we are like that Pious person in
prayer I'm using this Pious person in
prayer as a model to understand our
general connection with God which is
inseparable and the more comfortable we
are with that
the more we don't care about these
officers bothering us from the
outside reminds me of the story of
porim um Esther was afraid to be proud
of her Jewish identity she was afraid to
serve as an advocate for the Jewish
people right morai says go go in there
she says I can't I'm they're going to
kill me they're you know the king
doesn't respect you he says this is you
think you ended up in this position by
accident you think you're a Jew who
happens to be the queen and the Jews
happen to be in trouble and you happen
to have the ability to save them and
it's not your job he says
go and she ends up
going and the first thing she does first
of all she fasts she does t shua she
does which is not usually the best thing
you want to do before you know fasting
and stuff before going into a king after
you haven't seen him for 30 days and
it's not going to impress him but that
wasn't her goal her goal was to become
more comfortable with her Judaism her
comfortable with her relationship with
God and she walks in and she tells the
king uh after the banquet and you know
after a series of of various events that
there somebody who wants to eradicate my
people and um this is causing a lot of
pressure on me he says who's your people
who is this he says it's h on he wants
to kill the Jewish people and she
reveals that she's Jewish immediately
she earns the respect of
she earns the respect of the king the
moment she was comfortable with her
Judaism was the moment that the Jewish
people were
respected the moment we feel that we
need to respond to Candace
Owens because we need to be
defensive the moment that we feel that
our freedom comes from Pharaoh rather
than God the moment that we feel that we
need to
start justifying our connection to God
to this officer who's bothering
us we're missing the point
we're not connecting
properly the solution to
anti-Semitism I'm not saying that we
should not serve as advocates and throw
these things in the garbage but I'm
saying that if that's the starting point
I believe that's a problem it's not
going to work if we want to remain
strong in our Jewish
identity and shut down
anti-Semitism um and anti-semites and
Jew
haters we have to be very comfortable
with we
are very comfortable with who we are I
want to share with you another story
I've shared with you this story in the
past but I think it's very relevant to
our discussion right
now in the 1920s there was a mentor Mas
in Thea system his name was
kman kelman was a special special
teacher in the Yesa he would teach and
he would Mentor the young students
Inspire them and for bring with them he
was very
committed to the extent that the Yeshiva
was constantly on the Run constantly
moving because yiva was actually illegal
in communist Russia and and had to move
every few months and he would move with
it it went from laich to Rav to I don't
know it's a bunch of different places
eventually it made its way to Israel and
eventually it made its way to America
he's teaching in the evening a Tanya
class to Young students maybe teenagers
I don't know underground in a
basement and they have two students on
the outside watching to make sure the
KGB doesn't come or to inform him should
the KGB
come and at some point the KGB got word
that this Tanya class was taking place
in the evenings so they had sent an
officer to come beforehand go into the
class in the basement hide behind the
door and basically surprise make a
surprise
arrest so in the middle of his class
he's getting all into
it and and passionate and he's really
just people are soaking it
in and the officer pops out with his
rifle and says now what do you have to
say without skipping a beat ROM looks up
slams his fist on the table and says my
let's pray evening
service right class is over that's what
I have to say I totally dismissed the
guy he was so comfortable with this
Judaism he was so comfortable with what
he was doing he was so confident that
what he was doing is the truth and it
can not not do it because this is what's
going to bring light and goodness to the
world he didn't care about that officer
he was like theid in this story just
praying and I don't care about this guy
dismiss
him and the guy respected it you know
what the guy did he let them finish
myff then he
arrested kman ended up getting a
citation he had to do community service
he had to do street
cleaning kman used to wear his shab his
clothing the street cleaning because to
him it
wasn't um something he bickered about
and like why me it was a badge of honor
he knew why he was doing the street
cleaning it was because he was so proud
been confident with who he
was if you look at the end of the story
what was the officer's ultimate reaction
he didn't just leave this Jew
alone it says when he heard this the
officer was immediately appeased and the
pious man returned home in peace and the
commentaries point out that the officer
started off as an
enemy and turned out eventually to be an
advocate to be a supporter to the point
that this guy was able to leave in peace
with
protection because when we're
comfortable with our Judaism when we're
comfortable with who we are when we're
proud of who we
are nothing can get in the way when we
have a strong stable connection with
God what what could be stronger than
that okay that's my story and I'm
sticking to it
I'm waiting for the recording to finish