Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Welcome everybody. I'm sorry for the
traffic.
Really?
Okay. An accident on College Road. Okay.
We're grateful for everybody who's here
and everybody who's here virtually. So,
thank you very much and welcome back
after Yamtiff. May all of you, all of us
have a healthy summer, a beautiful
summer, blessed on all levels for you,
your families, all your loved ones, and
all of our people in the Holy Land and
in the whole world.
Okay, there's one source sheet. So, if
you didn't take it yet, you could take
it on the Beimma. It's one source sheet.
Today's class is dedicated in the loving
memory of
Ben Shalom Davidid Winstone
dedicated by all of his children with
profound appreciation.
May his soul continue to be an eternal
source of blessing and light and
inspiration and love for the entire
family and for all of the Jewish people.
And thank you very much for your
friendship and your blessings and your
heartfelt wishes.
Sometimes
tiny little small
nuances could seem insignificant
especially when somebody reads something
superficially.
But in terra even the order is precise
and meticulous. Every detail, every
nuance, even if it seems not very
significant, sometimes contains
layers and layers of profound messages
and themes that can even be
life-changing.
In this class, B is Hashem, we're going
to identify such a detail really just a
change of order between the same mitzvah
uttered twice, transcribed twice, just
with a change of order, it would seem
insignificant, but upon deeper sign upon
deeper reflection, we see the
profoundity of it.
The title of today's class
I think will be appreciated especially
by many people here and that is
self-care is not a crime. It's a mitzvah
that's the title. Okay.
Very good. You should give the class.
You hear what Hindi says? Depends. What
type of self-care? Depends. Very good.
She said depends what type of self-care.
Depends what self-care means. Depends
what the self is, right?
We should go on a trip. Let's go.
Huh?
We should go on a trip
together with Rabbi.
Well, well, Hindi, Hindi, Hindi should
lead the trip.
Okay. So, so let's begin the journey.
Hashem is barak.
Everybody knows about the ten
commandments
which are recorded in paras
and two of them are about chabas and
respect for parents. So let's see the
first source in your source sheets and
by the way the source sheets are always
loaded on the yeshiva.net so you could
see them later as well on the computer.
The book of Exodus chapter 20 verse 7.
This is the fourth of the ten
commandments. The fourth of
remember the day of shabas to sanctify.
These are also verses that are recited
by many in the kdesh of Shabas morning.
But the point is you should work for six
days. The seventh day is a day of shabas
dedicated to your god. Dedicated lashem.
Don't do any work. Not you, not your
son, your daughter, your servant, your
maidervant, your animals, any foreigners
that live with you. Because six days,
Hashem created the world. In six days,
heaven and earth, the seas, and
everything contained in our universe,
and he rested on the seventh day. And
therefore, this day is blessed and holy.
Great. Right after that comes the next
commandment, the next
Exodus 20:1
respect your father and your mother.
That's
so we have the mitzvah of Shabas
following the mitzvah to respect one's
father. Following that is the mitzvah to
respect one's mother.
Now let's forward from paras to parasam
paras yra is the middle of the book of
exodus in the middle of schmiss parishes
of course is closer to the end of sikra
the book of leviticus usually read
sometime later because there's quite a
few parish in between and parasim opens
up with these same two mitzvah the para
opens up with these same not two three
mitzvah shabas and our relationship with
our father and our mother But the order
is changed.
Leviticus 19:1, this is the opening of
this week's parad.
Hashem spoke to Mosha saying,
Holy shall you be because I am holy. I
Hashem, I'm holy. That's the pre that's
the that's the premise, the catalyst,
the foundation of all the mitzvah that
are coming in. You should be holy or in
another translation
in Hebrew means you shall and will. So
it's a it's an instruction. It's also a
prediction. You will be you shall be
holy. You will be holy.
Next,
a person should have reverence
for one's mother and for one's father
and preserve my shabas, my in the
plural, my sabbaths.
I am Hashem, your God. You see the
interesting thing in paris what comes
first
shabas then
respect to your father and then your
mother here the order gets completely
reversed it stops first he says
reverence for your mommy then fori and
then
and then keep shabas so you say what's
the difference this order that order.
But it's fascinating. The first time
it's shabas, tatam, tat mama, shabas,
father, mother. The second time it's
mother, father, shabas.
It seems like only a change of order,
but as we will see, this change has
extremely profound significance.
In order to appreciate this, we're going
to change the subject completely or
almost completely, but not really.
And here we're going to go to a
fascinating and challenging
scenario that is described in Garis
Mitsia. Your next source
talked mitzia page 62A.
And here's your homework. If you have a
husband who learns dy and certainly if
you have a husband who teaches daffy.
Okay. So your homework is you're going
to listen to the story and the dafi
learned this a few days ago. So tonight
by dinner you're going to test him to
see how well he knows his material and
he's going to say how do you know this?
You learned this in school. You don't
have to reveal the secret. He could
listen himself but you'll be able to see
right how well he's learning. I'm just
joking. You don't have to test your
husband if unless you want to. So here
is the case.
We have it in the original in the Hebrew
and then also you could read it in the
English.
Two people took a hike and it happened
to be in a hot
sunny it was a hot sunny day and they
ended up in a desert or in the
wilderness
and one of them has ketone. Ketto is a
canteen. A canteen of water, a jug of
water.
One of them has it. And here's the
situation.
If both of them drink from the canteen
mason,
both will die. They don't have
sufficient water to irrigate and hydrate
both of them until they're going to
reach a place where there's water.
man. If one of them drinks,
he will have enough water to be able to
reach a settled area where there are
people, where there are wells, where
there are sources of water. What do you
do? So, if everybody has a canteen of
water, but beautiful. Now, you might ask
why they didn't take their cell phones,
why they don't call somebody for an
emergency, why did they end up there?
Good questions. I don't know why they
didn't take a phone.
Oh, there were no phones at the time.
Okay.
No reception. Very good. Why they ended
up there in a place where there's no
water with one canteen? All these are
good questions. But this is what
happened. They're stuck.
There was a shipwreck. They ended up on
an island. They ended up in a desert.
The sun is scorching. They desperately
need water. And they only have one jug.
And the jug is not large enough to
give them both so that they can both
survive. So here is an option. And it's
a very difficult option. If they share
the water, which we ought to do, they
will both not survive. Of course, there
is a chance that something may happen.
You know, a caravan of people may meet
them. They may come across a source of
water. But according to natural
circumstances, if they both drink the
water, they will both maybe live a
little longer, but they're both they
both won't make it. If one takes the
canteen of water and drinks it himself
or herself, he'll probably survive cuz
he brought enough water for this
journey. I guess they knew where they
were going. They knew they needed water.
This was an intense hike and this is
enough. But it's only enough for one
person.
What do we do? This is the question in
what does the what does what does Jewish
law dictate in such a difficult tragic
and challenging situation. So as you can
guess there was a debate a huge debate.
Who are the two people? One is a person
not so known. He's mentioned only a few
times. His name is Ben Pura.
Ben Petura which literally means the son
of Pura. What did he say? Benur Ben
taught
it is preferable that both of them drink
and die and let neither one of them see
the death of the other. That's his
opinion. His opinion is for me to take
this water even if it's my water and
drink it and watch the other person die
is unconscionable. It's not what a Jew
does. I if I give you the water I mean I
can give away the water but then the
other person shouldn't watch his friend
die. So what happens? Give share the
water because I cannot watch another
person die. That was his opinion. Ben
until came along
and he taught something else. He said
there is a verse there's a fascinating
in two weeks
of Leviticus 25:36 it says
make sure that your brothers shall live
with you. What does it mean? Your
brother shall live with you.
This indicates that your life takes
precedence over the life of the other.
Because the says,
make sure your brother lives with you.
What does that mean? First, make sure
that you're alive. Your brother should
live with you. So, my obligation to make
sure my brother or sister, brother here
means another Jew, my fellow Jew, lives,
is let him or her live with you. But the
premise is that you're alive. You know
what they say on the airplanes when you
have to put on the mask, right? Put the
mask on you, make sure you get the
oxygen and then give somebody else
oxygen. So is not under all
circumstances. It's it's with you. With
you he could be you could give him life.
So once you guarantee that I'm alive
now, I'll do anything to save the other
person. But if by giving making sure the
other person lives, I'll die.
says, "You're not obligated." Now, of
course, Rabbi Aka would agree that a
person can voluntarily, if he or she
wants, say, "You know what? You take the
canteen of water. You live and I'll
die." But that's an option, a very, very
selfless option, altruistic option that
a person may do, especially if it's a
close person, if it's a loved one, etc.
But we're talking now in terms of
obligation. Benetura says, "I'm not
allowed to take the canteen for myself,
even though it's my canteen of water. I
brought the water. It's mine. I have to
share it. Even though by sharing it,
nobody's going to really live, right?
But I can't watch somebody else die.
That was his perception of Tory ethics.
Rabi disagreed till came and learned,
"No, that's wrong."
His words are
and in fact, this became the in Jewish
law is
your life takes precedence. So, if it's
my canteen of water, you can't say, "Oh,
this person is a murderer. He's
careless. He's apathetic. He's
self-centered. He's narcissistic."
That's not true. If a person wants to
give away the canteen to the other
person, a person can give away the
canteen. The other person may then give
it back and give it back. Give it back.
Give it back. Give it back. Benur says,
"No, wrong. Got to split." But Rabaka
says, "If it's my canteen of water, I
have an obligation. Your life comes
first. If there's extra water, of
course, you need to give it away.
You're not allowed to watch another
person die. But
this is a very famous debate in Mitsia.
The two sides are Ben Petura versus Rebi
Aka.
And here
we want to understand something
and that is
we all know there's a famous PK also in
parad
everybody knows this. What does it say?
Take a look in your next source.
This is Leviticus chapter 19 verse 18.
Don't take revenge and don't bear
grudges against the people of your
nation.
You shall love your fellow your friend
like yourself.
I am God. And from all the sages made a
comment on this very famous comment.
Rashi quotes it from the
zlat.
This is a fundamental clin. This is not
just one mitzvah of 613 mitzvah. every
mitzvah being critical and indispensable
and vital. But this is a meaning this is
a fundamental central premise of
it's interesting what does this say? You
should love your fellow exactly like you
love yourself
says this is the foundation of now let's
go back to the scenario who reflects
more Benura or Rabaka
it seems like Benur is saying
love the other person like yourself
right I'm not going to huh
yeah share it
share it I'm not going to live while
you're going to die no way sorry
Huh?
Or at least he says, "I can't watch
somebody else die. If I can't if if that
person can't live, how can I live?"
Right? That's basically logic actually
argues. He says, "No, there are limits.
There are limits even to kindness."
Again, we're not talking about a
voluntary act of sacrifice that a person
does. That's a different situation. He's
now talking about what is morally right
and ethical. Ben says what's morally
right and ethical is don't watch the
other person says the opposite
says
but here it seems like he actually
seriously argued with this premise
there's another very interesting thing
here
that would be the same thing
it's a very interesting questions.
Of course, doesn't agree that I'm
allowed to take somebody else's life to
save mine. That's not what he's saying,
right? I'm not allowed to steal. If
somebody has a canteen of water doesn't
say steal, take the canteen away from
them. What happened is I have this is my
canteen. I brought it. Right? Now, if I
share it, I'm giving up my life. It's
incredible thing to do. If I split it,
we both don't live or at least know
those that's what it looks like. Chances
are we don't live. Says, but won't argue
right that I'm allowed to
take somebody else's life to save my
life. It's one of the things that we
don't do according to one of the things
that a person is not allowed to do. Rab
is not talking about that. But he's
talking here personally owns this water.
The question is when says give it up or
give up 50% of it says no, you don't
have to.
Another very interesting thing is
usually the whole Talmud the whole
Mishna Gomorra is filled with arguments.
So for example we'll says
this and Basil says this says
this one says that one says here the
language is not
Benur says and then
it says like this Benur Ben taught it
until Rabi came and taught something
else. You would think it should say Ben
Petura says this and Rabi Aka argues.
The language here is different than in
most other arguments. Ben Petura said
what he said and that's how it remained
odd until Rabaka came and what this
indicates is
that huh?
No, but there wasn't an argument the
story of Pes
until they came and told him it's time
for here it's actually two opinions
right so but over there it's clear why
he says because says I don't have a
source to say until I learned it from
Ben here it just seems like a classic
argument between two people but the
Gmoria changes the language completely
instead of just saying no you're wrong
which is how All most arguments are
phrased. What this indicates is that
Benetura actually his opinion was
maintained until Rabi Akiva came. Until
Rabbi Aaka came nobody had the guts or
nobody had the audacity or nobody had
the idea or the insight to argue with
Petura. There was something here that
was different than any other argument.
said this, Raaka says Petura said this
and it was held on to until Rabi Aka
came maybe even a later generation or at
a later point and he shifted it and the
indeed was accepted as Rabaka. What is
the meaning of all of this?
So in order to appreciate this we have
to see another story of Rabi Akiva.
And here you see how everything is so
interlin and interconnected and every
person who speaks
in Mishnay among our sages each one has
a whole background behind them and a
context in which we can appreciate their
words. So this argument
can't be fully appreciated until we know
something else about Ryaka.
And here
let's for a moment
think emotionally about the position of
Benetura. I mean intellectually and
emotionally.
What is Ben Petura really saying? Benur
is saying treat another person like you
treat yourself literally.
That's what he's saying.
You know we have the story of Hagar,
right? Hugger and were sent away from
Ara's home. Aram gave them a jug of
water. The water was finished. Yeshal
was sick. Rashi says and he drank a lot
of water and Hagar could not watch her
son die from thirst. It says she went
away.
She sat far as it is to shoot an arrow.
In other words, quite far. The the span
of usually of shooting an arrow. Very
interesting expression why that's used.
Because she said,
"I cannot watch my child die." That's
the mother's instinct. Until, of course,
she has this revelation that there's a
well. Open your eyes. There's a well and
Yeshal is saved.
But the feeling is how can I watch?
Hugger says how can I watch my child? I
can't. I just can't and there's nothing
I can do. So what did she do over here?
There was no canteen of water. Obviously
she would have probably given away her
canteen but there was nothing. So she
went away. She couldn't watch it. Benur
is really saying that notion. How can I
watch that's the words he uses such
emotional words.
How can I watch somebody else die? I
can't. So you'll say, "Yeah, but but I
know all the butts." This is a very,
very deep emotional experience. How can
I do this? I can't. I can't take water
knowing that every drop of water I'm
drinking, it's at the expense of
somebody else, even though it's my jug.
And even if I warned him a 100 times to
take water, and he didn't listen. Okay.
Ben Pura says, "Fine, I hear you. But I
can't do it." So Benur is saying, "Treat
the other person like you treat
yourself. So if I have one canteen of
water, how do I have a right to drink it
while the other person lies there dying
from thirst and dehydration
and if I give it to him he's also is
going to look and say how do I have a
right to drink this water while this
person who was just selfless and gave me
the canteen is going to sit there or lie
there and die. So what do we do? What do
we do? So Betura says it's actually
better that both of you die as long as
you don't watch the other person die.
What do you think about this position?
Understand what he's saying. It's better
that both die. Why? As long as I don't
watch another person die in his mind,
this is this is the fulfillment of aa.
So you'll say, "Yeah, but practically it
doesn't make sense." Like, so now you'll
have two people dead instead of one
person dead. He says, "I understand the
law." He could understand that logic.
You don't have to be a rocket scientist
for it. But he's saying that what?
Better that both of them pass on as long
as one doesn't watch another person
suffer, another person die. Yeah,
I said that before. Yeah. That's the
second position disagrees. You're right.
Says, "Put on your mask.
Make sure you have oxygen before you
administer CPR." That's what you mean.
Yeah.
[Music]
Now, here is the issue.
People, Jews felt emotionally compelled
by what Bmpeta said. There was something
emotionally compelling about it. Even
though intellectually you can argue it's
my jug of water. What are we going to
gain that two people die? But people
felt their heartstrings were like so I'm
g really going to watch this happen.
Even Hagar understood I can't watch it.
I have to go away. So how can I watch
this? I am also going to die in the
process. What should I do? But I can't
see this part of suffering. This spoke
to and the harim. This is an insight
from the harim was the first
mayor alter from G. He was a student of
the Katskarb. After the Katskarb passed
away, he became the greatic master of G
is not far from worse gur as it was
called. And the kadushim says this. He
says naturally Jews felt compelled to
appreciate bmpa because how can I watch
another person die and live just because
there's only one cantina and it makes
sense logically. Maybe it makes sense
logically but emotionally I cannot
tolerate this. I cannot be a witness to
such pain to such suffering. This was
their emotion. Until
Rabbi Aaka came, nobody argued. Until
Rabbi Aaka came, there was that's why it
doesn't just say Rabaka says Ben Pura's
position became entrenched in the
emotional psyche of Jews. There's also
something deeper here and that is the
sages had a fear of arguing with Betura
and there's a reason for this and here
we have to understand how ala works. Not
everybody knows this. So it's important
to emphasize the prerequisite for
deciding what the view of Tyra is. I
must truly truly eliminate all bias.
In other words, if I'm making a decision
based on my emotional needs,
on my emotional stereotypes,
then what often the danger is that I
impose my ego or my insecurities or my
fears and I say this is what God wants.
That's why the is so cautious about
bribery. What's the problem of bribery?
Terra calls a person and but bribery
will distort everything because I'm now
emotionally invested. The Gmorian tells
a story about a great sage and somebody
came and helped him cross the street,
cross the bridge and he says, "What are
you doing here?" He says, "I have a
court case by you tomorrow." He says,
"It's over." Well, he helped him cross
the street. He helped him cross the
bridge. He didn't do anything.
There was another sage and somebody came
over to him and and and uh
uh his jacket
cleaned his jacket the label of his
jacket. He said, "What are you doing
here?" Or have I didn't tell you about
you tomorrow? He says, "Sorry, I'm
disqualified. What did I do? I didn't
give you money. Didn't save your life."
But it's basically I'm on your team. It
showed how sensitive they were to the
slightest forms of emotional bias.
That's why you could trust them.
In fact, the Gomorrah says fascinating
that they had to decide which year is a
leap year. Today we already have fixed
in the calendar every few years there's
a leap year there's an extra month. It's
because Pesak needs to fall out in the
spring etc. Ramadan follows the moon. So
it could be any time in the year but our
our our calendar follows the moon but we
also follow the sun because pes has to
be in the spring. Spring is based on the
sun not in the moon. So we have to
adjust the calendar.
But in the ancient times the tamuric
times every year they had to decide it
again based on the calculations. So the
garra says two people should not be part
of the committee. The king and the
kayang god the high priest the king
wants a leap year. You know why? Because
he paid his soldiers based on the year.
So if he can get an extra month it's a
very nice profit.
He paid them by the year. If the year
has 13 months great I get an extra four
weeks of work. So he can't be he's
disqualified because he has an agenda.
Even if he's a great king, the god also
has an agenda. What's his agenda? Mor
says the he had to go to the mikvah five
times. And he wants that the water
should be warm, not cold.
If it's delayed another month, right,
winter is starting, autumn is starting,
the mikvah is going to be cold. Now, I'm
going to ask you a question. Is this
what the kip is thinking about? And how
much colder is it going to be? You're
not not difference of four months.
You're not talking about September
versus February. You're talking about
one month, but yet
a mikvah,
a cold, a colder mikvah is already a
personal bias. It shows you
how profound bias can go. It says by the
daughters of they came to Moshe and they
said our father had no sons.
Our father died in the desert. He was
not part of the mutiny of
why shouldn't we have a
so it says
said I can't deal with this he gave it
over to God and God told them they're
right they're right they're not married
they don't have a husband's estate their
father is not alive there's no brothers
they get everything soay says when they
came to Mish about pesi the people who
were impure they couldn't do the carbon
pes
Mo doesn't say Moshe gave their their
their case to God. It says Mosha said
let me ask Hashem and I'll answer you.
Why didn't he say the same thing here
said because the moment they told Mosha
our father was not part of Kyak's mutiny
moa felt that this was he could not be
objective because their father was a
good was on his team. So
40 years 40 years after the mutiny he's
and still he understood how distorted a
person's view can become even such a
great person because of something that
seems subtle. This point is not to tell
you how corrupt people can be. It's
telling you how authentic one needs to
be with our blind spots.
My brother once told me that somebody
came to him for advice. So he asked him,
"Is it possible that you have a blind
spot?" He says, "Of course I have blind
spots, but I know exactly where they
are."
The problem is that blind spots, I don't
know where they are. That's why they're
called blind spots.
So that's why when we decide when when
ha is is is decided, when Jewish law,
what does Hashem want? What does the
Tyra say? The prerequisite for this is
MS MS MS MS MS authenticity
through and through and through because
by a human being knowing how inauthentic
I can be and not because I'm a bad or
malicious or evil person. No, but
because I have bias, I have needs, I
have my emotional fears, I have my
perceptions, I have my preconceived
notions, I have my paradigms, things
that that that influence me in one way
or another way. I have to be made aware
of all of this and ask myself, can I
transcend it or I can't transcend it?
So, and here we come to something very
profound. The sages were afraid
that maybe they're arguing with
Benetura. You know why? Because of a
selfish reason. Maybe they don't agree
with Benetura. It's not because of
integrity. Maybe it's because survival
of the fittest. Maybe because I I care
about my needs. Cuz if I'm in a desert
with another person, I want to live. In
other words, maybe they're arguing about
Petura not because truly truly this is
the divine most ethical thing to do, but
because we all have the deepest instinct
for self-preservation.
I will do anything to save my life.
And that's why they held back because
Benuru was saying something so radical.
Don't save yourself even though you're
going to die, but don't let another
person die in front of you. Share it.
Wow. That's
they said you know what maybe this
doesn't make sense to us but maybe it
doesn't make sense to us because we
don't want it to make sense
we want to disagree with them we want to
say no I come first and maybe there's an
ego piece here and it's not the truth
it's not the real divine blueprint for
life and therefore there was a little
stalemate
until Rabi Aaka came
so there's two issues that we're dealing
here with one is emotion Ben Pura's
message was very compelling.
How can I watch another person die? I
can't. Even though it means I also die
and he's anyway going to die. She's
anyway going to die. Logically, I get
it. But I can't watch it. Sorry. Sorry,
I can't.
One issue, they couldn't argue with him.
And the second issue is, is our argument
coming? Truly because God's will is
different or maybe because at the end of
the day, we are selfcentered
creatures. Survival of the fittest. I
want to live and that's why I'm going to
argue with Benetura and then blame it on
God. Don't people do that all the time?
They have an agenda and then they
already find how the Tyra agrees with
them, how Hashem agrees with them and
don't dare challenge me because I became
God. And that's very very very
disheartening.
In fact, it can create sometimes havoc
and destruction because sometimes what
was presented in people's lives as Tyra
and the view of God was really a
reflection of people's own stuff, their
own wounds that they then imposed on
Tyra. Sometimes a person doesn't work on
their mid I don't develop my character
and suddenly I uh I use T as an excuse.
Somebody told me that he heard from
Rabbid Feinstein. Zatal Rabbid Feinstein
was a son of Mosha Feinstein. And he
said it says by Pinas that when he saw
Zimri and Cosby have their public
relations,
he took a spear in his hand. So he asked
why does it say he took a spear in his
hand? Obviously he took it with his
hand. He probably didn't take it with
his mouth or with his legs. You take a
spear with your hand.
So it says thehatis he said that
sometimes people when they go out in the
morning from their house they already go
out with a spear and they're just
waiting to use it at the right time. He
says was not that type of person. He was
a son of Allah was a son of he was a
person of love and peace.
He now took the spear in his hand
because he had a certain mission.
So these were the two issues you
understand the two challenges. Number
one emotionally and number one int
number two intellectually. Emotionally
can somebody argue with Benetura? Am I
really going to watch another person
perish in front of me? And then I'll say
but I lived. We call it survivors guilt.
Survivor's guilt. Number two,
idealistically
is this what the Tyra really wants or is
this what we would love to say because I
want to live. I don't want to die.
there was a stalemate until Rabi Aka
came
changed the equation he taught
and that became why what was it about
Rabaka so for here we need to learn a
story about the says what's the story
look in the next source
you have it in the Hebrew and Englishman
was already an elderly man. Rabbaka
according to tradition was 120 and the
Romans took Rabaka out to be executed.
This is approximately
65 70 years after the destruction of the
second Bamdash. Bara staged a mighty
revolt against the Roman troops. He
wanted to rebuild the third Bamdish. He
wanted to liberate the Jewish people.
Bara was very successful for a few
years. The Bam Mikdash was destroyed
approximately the year 70 after the
common era. Bar was staged his revolt
approximately in the year 132 after the
common era around 62 63 years later went
on for a few years. He was mightily
successful until Bar was defeated. His
greatest supporter was Rabaka
and then they came the day came that the
Romans also arrested Rabaka. They
incarcerated him and when they took him
out to be killed it was the time of
keshma which means it was early in the
morning when it's a time to say keshma.
And the Gmorrah describes in this story
in braus
the methods that they were using. And
the contin
and during this process
was accepting upon himself
the yoke of the kingdom of heaven.
meaning he was saying
the student said
even now even now under these horrific
circumstances you could say
like look what's happening
where do you have this courage where do
you have this energy this is what
they're asking their teacher imagine as
he's being led to his death and he's
saying
what does he tell his students
He gives them not just a coherent answer
but he gives them the answer that
defines the story of his life.
And this is his last teaching. He says
to them
says this. All the days of my life I
have been troubled by one.
Love Hashem with all your heart and all
your soul. Mean with all your soul even
if he takes your soul. In other words,
I'm ready to give my soul for the
ultimate truth of oneness. I'm
ultimately ready to give my soul. And I
was aggravated by this verse. Why was I
aggravated? Because I said to myself,
when will I ever have an opportunity to
do this? And therefore, it troubled me.
All the other verses didn't trouble me.
I had an opportunity to do that. But
this troubled me.
Now he says, now that I have been
afforded the opportunity you want, I
should abandon it. That's what you're
saying. The students are telling Rebea,
Rabbi, how can you say Schma? And what
does he tell them? Guys,
my whole life
I was upset that I couldn't fulfill this
PK. And now that I have an opportunity,
this opportunity was afforded to me.
Obviously, not by myself, by the Romans.
You want me just to look away, look to
the other side, you want me to neglect,
you want me to forfeit when this has
been something sitting on me, call all
the days of my life, this is what I
yearn for and now I have an opportunity.
You want me not to do it. What happens?
He prolongs the uttering of the word
until his soul departs from his holy
body by the word.
A voice comes out from heaven and says,
"Happy are you
didn't die a miserable man. He died a
happy man.
How happy fortunate are you rabbi that
your soul left your body
in one? What was telling his students?
Aka was saying that my whole life when I
said
I wanted to live it. I wanted to
experience it. I wanted to embody it.
But I knew that my mandate is to stay
alive. And
there was a pain in me.
What was the pain? The pain is I want to
be able to experience
the ultimate ultimate dedication, the
ultimate,
the ultimate.
That's what I want. And
now they're telling him, "How can you do
it?" So he says, "I was under wondering
says, "Ah, now you know who Ra was."
His entire life as he was alive in the
physical world was a life
of miser.
Even when he was alive, what was his
craving? What was his yearning? His
yearning was absolute unity.
He wanted to he had s he had pain. He
was worried. He was perturbed.
In other words, for the meaning of every
moment in life was complete oneness and
alignment with Hashem.
No dissonance whatsoever. No separation
whatsoever.
Lublin has an incredible interpretation
on this story. The garra says
his soul went out during the word. He
says it means something deeper. He told
his students every day when I said
there was a part of me that was ready to
expire
because a soul is divine. It's a piece
of divine. It comes into a body. It
continues to be divine. But it's still
it's defined and limited by the body. of
an AU for example says how did they die
they wanted to kiss God they wanted to
touch infinity they didn't want to be
contained anymore that's how they died
says they kissed Hashem and they
departed like the electricity voltage of
infinity was so intense that it couldn't
be contained by the kali by the body
soak says every day I'm ready for this
that's how deep my yearning my
aspiration my craving to touch the full
truth I don't want to be blocked by
anything not even by the containers of
physicality
But I know that that's not the purpose.
The purpose is I'm supposed to be alive.
A soul in a body's
act as holy as it was is considered a
sin. It's a noble sin. It's a holy sin,
but it's a sin because a person is
supposed to live
says now today I see that my job is not
anymore to live because the Romans want
to kill me. So today I'm going to
actually do what I want to do every day.
And he says that
he didn't die because of the Romans. He
died because of
his soul departed from him because of
the experience of his
was so visceral. That's what caused his
soul to leave. At the surface it looked
like he died. He was just killed. He was
physical. There was actually something
internal in Rabbi Akiba that happened
that he allowed his soul to escape.
to escape its confinement. That's what
happened to at that moment.
It's not just the time when it happened.
It's how it happened through the his
soul went out.
[Music]
Very good. Very good.
That's why when came and said
your life comes first everything was
different
till Akiva came
because nobody can say to Rabbi Aka oh
this is a bias
you love yourself so much at the expense
of other people oh Rabi Aka you believe
in survival of the fittest the gene the
selfish gene by you is so overwhelming.
Of course, you're arguing with Bmpetura.
You don't feel the emotional pain that
Betura feels. Nobody can say Raaka is
coming because he doesn't feel
emotionally what Bmpura feels or
idealistically there's a a selfish
self-centered bent over there a bias
because what was Rab who was Rabaka Ky
his entire life his physical life soul
and body was what it was one big story
of Mr.
Even when he was alive, he saw the
entire
purpose and experience of life as an
opportunity for us, an opportunity for
oneness, for intimacy with Hashem, no
separation whatsoever. That was what he
lived. That's what he embodied. That's
what he breathed. And that's why he
tells his students, "My whole life, I
was aggravated by this verse."
Why is he craving that every single day
of his life? Because even as he was
alive physically for him the meaning of
life was absolute veos absolute
connection with absolutely no
dissonance. Finally when the moment of
mysterious nefes came he didn't even
flinch he says this is this is what I
was waiting for now you want me to
neglect it. So when said
your life comes first, nobody could say
anymore this is coming because he can
watch somebody else die and it's not so
aggravating for him. Benetur is more
Jewish or more holy or more selfless or
more spiritual than him. Nobody can also
say that Akiva has a personal agenda
here because he wants to live. What did
he tell his students? My whole life I'm
asking I'm praying from
So when says what does he mean? Your
life comes first
is actually coming from the place of
Raka is a life of Ms. It's a life of
complete oneness. It's a life of
complete transcendence. There's no ego
there. So when says what is he saying?
He's saying this has nothing to do with
selfishness
because not that person. This has
nothing to do with after everything said
and done. Emotions, emotions, emotions.
I want to live. I got to live.
It's not like Benur is holier than Benur
is more Jewish. Benur is more
emotionally connected.
Whatever is saying is
your life comes first.
Not because you're a selfish person, but
because you have to understand that if
this jug of water was given to you
and you can live by drinking it, that
life is sacred.
That life is divine. That life is holy.
When one life can be speared says it
needs to be spared.
Not because I don't care so much. Not
because I have a bias, an emotional
bias. Here
says, emotionally I understand. Remember
to emotionally you may not want to see
another person
pass out, perish before your eyes. And
if I give him the water, he may not want
to see the other person perish in front
of his eyes. Ben Ptoria says, "Just
split it." Ribbaka says, "I understand
you might feel guilty for the rest of
your life that you lived and this person
died." I get that. That's why everybody
was so hesitant to argue. But comes and
says, "What is at stake in your life?
What is at stake in your life is not
just your selfish desire that I want to
live."
That's not what's at stake. What's at
stake is that God needs you in this
world to serve as his ambassador.
Rabi Akiva could say this. It's not even
your need. It's Hashem's need. How do I
know it's Hashem's need? Cuz I was born.
I was born. The day you were born is the
day that Hashem declared not only that
you matter, but that you're
indispensable note in the cosmic
symphony. As the Mishna says in
Sanhedrin, every person is obligated to
say Clearly, because of me, the world
was created. What does that mean?
Because of me, the world was created. I
say it and my wife says it and my
mother-in-law says it and my
father-in-law said it and you say it.
So, we're all a bunch of crazy
narcissists. It means that Hashem needs
you. It means that Hashem says,
"I created you for a purpose."
It's not. I like it. It's good for me.
It's comfortable. I like having my iced
coffee and I like sitting on my couch
and I like when summer comes to New York
and all these things.
So says, "But you have to understand
that what's at stake in your life is
that Hashem needs you in this world to
serve as his ambassador. And as long as
your time has not come, you have an
obligation to live."
When said this, huh?
You could listen. You could watch it.
Yeah. The yeshiva.net.
Whoever owns the water or
Yeah. If I own the water, says it's not
a mistake. It's not that you're a
self-centered person. He didn't look at
life that way. When he said it, it was
trusted.
Cuz everybody knew Raba, it's not coming
from a lack of emotional connection.
It's not coming from personal bias. He's
the one who said
I'm looking.
So how does say your life comes first
watch the other person die emotionally I
may not want it but there's something
sacred in your life your life is not a
mistake and if one person could live
that life needs to be sp of course
concedes if somebody wants to give it
away to the other person that's their
choice and then the other person could
say I have it you gave it to me and that
person can live but he's talkingly don't
think is a compromise of ethics it's
because we don't care it's because we
have a selfish gene it's because we
believe in Darwin survival of the
fittest. It's because fight for yourself
first and everybody else can go jump
into the Hudson River or die from thirst
is not that person they can trust. This
is coming from this is the ultimate
truth of thee that
because your life
because it's a divine mission. It's a
divine need. It's something sacred. It's
not even about your decision. God says
if a life can be spared, you need a you
need to spare it. Does Rebecca even know
about survivors guilt? Of course he
does. He knows about it
and that exists. Why did I deserve to
live? Yeah.
It's a galda mitzvah. The question is
obligation
would say it's heroic and it's an
amazing mitzvah and people have done it
throughout history and it's happened now
in the war of October 7th. I was just in
Israel a few weeks ago and I went to
visit
um uh I went to visit a city called
and uh Ofakim is the famous house of
Rael of who gave the kamas terrorist
cookies. You remember she baked them
cookies and for more than 12 hours she
kept five terrorists at bay not shooting
her or her husband for more than 12
hours
feeding them nurturing them. She said I
realized I realized that they are they
can use a mother and they miss their
mother and I beca I mean I became their
mother. I mean the wisdom, the
ingenuity, the the the emotional. She
bought time. She was saved. Her husband
was saved. All five were five. It's not
one of five terrorists against her and
both elderly people. Her husband just
passed away by the way. I think Dovet,
right?
Right. Yeah. Yeah. The mother who was
here, you remember from the mother of
the hostage, her son went back. So I was
sitting there with a father. I was
sitting with a father there. He lost his
son. His son's his name is Nadav. And he
said his son was in near Lebanon at the
border of Lebanon, a soldier. He showed
me a picture, a strong kid, handsome,
beautiful kid. And uh he called his
father a few weeks before and he said,
you know, I'm here for a long time in
the north and the anxiety from so
powerful. I need to take a week off. I
need Do you think I should? His father
said, "If you need to, you need to." So
he decided to go to the music festival
to give him, he got permission to take a
few days off just to be able to relax
and then he'll go back. And he went
there with a friend. The father told me
he went there with a friend. And this
friend was had some social challenges
and had uh some difficulties, you know,
motor skills that set back. He had some
difficulties, challenges physically and
emotionally. So he really was like a
shadow for him. He was taking care of
him. when the rackets came 6:30 in the
morning by the festival and then the
terrorists came. So his son, he says his
son was a really capable capable person,
he realized how dangerous the situation
is. So he called his commander in near
Lebanon and he told his commander the
situation. His commander said, "You
can't now think about anybody else.
You have to go run." He said, "I can't
leave this this this friend alone." He
called his father. His father said, "I'm
going to come get you,
but take care of yourself." He said, "I
can't." And what he did was he dug a
grave, a fake grave for his friend. He
put him there. He covered him with
earth, but in a way that he could
breathe
and he put him there and he left. He was
killed. His friend was saved.
Imagine
Yeah. Really?
He literally he put him in a grave.
So they're not going to go undig a grave
to kill a Jew who's dead. And he saved
his life. This this boy, his friend of
his. So here is a classic example,
right? Where he on his own decided in
this precious few minutes where he could
have taken care of himself, he decided
not to.
So this was it's beyond the mitzvah.
something that's unfathomable in its
heroism.
you're allowed to
but the Rab was saying what's the what's
my so if a person is now going to give
away their canteen of water right you
remember the story of Rowi Klene he was
a commander and they threw a grenade at
terrorists he said is he jumped on it he
was killed and he saved his entire unit
few years ago there was also now October
7th somebody was in a room and they were
throwing grenades he caught seven of
them and threw them back the eighth one
killed
Huh?
What?
Yeah, the bus stop.
But it's different when you only have a
little bit of water.
Right. Right. No. So here Yeah. Here
here you're right. Nadav thought that
he'll also maybe be able to escape. But
he first worried about the person. Here
it's very it's in a way it's very black
and white. In other words, if I give
away the canteen, I'm not going to be
able to live. Even if I give away half,
I'm not going to be able to live. If I
don't give it away, I'm going to be able
to live. If I give it away to the other
person and he gives it back to me, he's
not going to be able to live. So with
nobody could suspect emotionally or
idealistically anything but bit anything
but complete dedication to what is the
true will of the creator in this state
in this state and that's why when said
it it became the forman
didn't mean you're alive because I
couldn't care less about anything else
or you're alive because at the end of
the day I got to be selfish. No,
because God needs you here. And if this
jug of water is yours and you have an
opportunity to live, it's a sacred
obligation. It doesn't have to do with
anything selfish. It has to do with the
fact that you were chosen, your soul was
chosen to be here on a mission to be a
channel for infinite love. How it works,
when it works, when is one person's
time, when is another person's time,
nobody knows and understands that.
M
vice
versa
beyond.
Yeah. The gariah says harug lud to where
there were two people in lud and they
gave themselves in. Somebody killed the
king's daughter and they wanted to kill
the entire community and there were two
people they said we did it they never
did it and they were executed. The
gammorra says that nobody could stand in
their makita. In other words, their
their their spiritual state is beyond
anybody.
Nobody could stand in their spiritual.
But this is a complete this is where
somebody voluntarily
voluntarily
uh uh does this and it's incredible
beyond. Ben Petura would say even if I
give you away the canteen, you can't
take it. You got to give half back to
me. Let both die says no that's not the
truth.
Now if I choose to voluntarily give it
to the other person would say that's
incredible but when he says everybody
knew this is not coming from a selfish
this is coming from pure nefish because
how you look at lifeand
you heard of vice mandal
he was sent to Awitz with his wife and
children he jumped out of the train he
survived he moved to Mount Kisco passed
away 195 58.
He never recovered from the Holocaust.
Especially he was negotiating with
Aishman for Hungarian jury and it was
unsuccessful. So he felt guilty for the
death of close to 1 million Hungarian
Jews. Very very tragic story against
what?
I interviewed one of his closest
friends. He said every day for five six
hours he would bang his head against
Yeah. Yeah. He suffered tremendously for
hours. because he would grieve the
Holocaust every day until he died from a
heart attack. I think in 1958
he remarried and at the bris of one of
his children he said something
incredible. He said, "We say, you
remember what we say in
different.
We will sanctify your name in this world
just like your name is sanctified in the
heavens."
And he said, "Some of my children
are there, but now I have a child who
was born here, but
there's not going to be a difference.
His life is going to embody holiness
just like the life of my children who
were killed by the Nazis in Awitz who
are already in heaven. There's no
difference." And he said then something
very powerful. The Mishna Gamar says
when you brought up meat from the
offerings to the Misbeh to the altar and
it was placed on the fire. So it's it's
it's already a carbon. It's it's a
carbon. It's a carbon of Hashem. So what
happens? They brought it up to the
altar, right? But there was not enough
space. So some of them were on the side
and they would push it over later and it
fell down. It fell down. So it was it
never made it into the divine fire. So
it says it has the same holiness even
though it never made it into the divine
fire. Why? because it was already
brought up there. So said we were all
destined to go into the gas chambers. So
even those of us who fell out of the
equation, we jumped out of a train, it's
exactly the same thing. So he looked at
this child that was born and he said
this kadusha of the kadesh in heaven,
it's his kaduca, it's my kadusha here in
this world. What he was trying to say is
don't look at the physical world as
divorced from the spiritual world. The
same holiness
is saying that was
my life here is that level of holiness.
It's not because I'm in love with my
narcissistic
needs and therefore I'm saying
no
my life here is one story of
of being one with God. It's just
expressed in the physical through the
physical world because that's my
mission.
Wants me to transform my body, my animal
soul, my physical world and manifest
holiness in here. It's not just my need.
It's a divine need who gave me a mission
because there's something in history and
there's something in life in my home in
my family in my own story my soul my
body that only I can accomplish and this
so my soul was sent here. So according
to Rabaka that is as selfless as Benatur
perhaps even more is focusing on
survival guilt. Beet is focusing on my
emotion which I understand and Rabaka is
saying ask not
what God can do for you. Ask what you
can do for God and he needs you to be
here in this world. When I was 14,
here's a personal emotion. When I was 14
years old, our camp, we went on a camp
trip to uh King's Dominion. You remember
King's Dominion, a big amusement park in
Virginia, near Virginia. On the way
back, we were in a van. We had a
horrible accident.
And uh our van went down a cliff
and uh a very close friend of mine was
killed on the spot. He was 14 years old.
This was August 1986. Baze of Thursday
morning. B of Tamev. His name was Label
Khan. We grew up together on the same
block. We went to yeshiva all the years
together in camp. We were actually in
the same bunk bed. Huh.
The second day of of Yeah. They stopped
the trips.
But uh he was killed on the spot and uh
my mom I grew up with him and you know
today he's buried in the Montafury
Cemetery in Queens not far from the
Labava. So sometimes I go visit the
grave and when I go there, you know, I
look at the grave. We grew up together.
He was 14 years old when he was plucked
out and killed. And I ask myself,
you know, why did I I was in the same
van like him. I was in the same van with
friends. A lot of people, a lot of kids
were wounded, wounded badly, but he only
he was killed. And I asked myself, you
know, why did I survive? Why did we
survive? Why did he not? A few years
ago, I think a year ago, my class had a
reunion. My cl my class had a reunion.
They became 50. So they made a reunion.
So we went together to visit his grave
the first time as a class and we were
all standing there and Davining and uh
they sang a song because in camp they
made a song in his memory. So we sang
that song that was written uh it was
very very moving. It was very emotional.
A lot of us it was it was the first time
we did it as a class. You know people
went individually and you know and I was
looking around and thinking here's
people everybody grew up got married
children some of them zadas
some of them very you know each of them
made a life for themselves and his life
was interrupted when he was 14 years old
you know how does that work why does
that work and of course there's no I
don't know that we don't know the
answers for this
and really it ultimately comes down to
the question of do I have to understand
They don't have to understand. But it's
really every soul has a mission and that
mission is mysterious. Nobody knows how
it works, when it begins, when it ends,
why a soul is taken when it's 14 years
old, when it's 19 years old. Who knows
these things? It's completely beyond
comprehension. And vice was saying at
the bris of his child. He says, you
know, why are some of my children in
heaven and here is a son who was born?
But I'm not going to differentiate and
say you know that is the holy life and
this is the unholy life. What a is
saying is when I look at my life the
deepest way of looking at life is that
it's not selfish at all.
taking care of oneself, taking care of
one's true self as Hindi said in the
beginning of the class is not selfish at
all because if this is indispensable to
my mission in this world so
that's part of the
when says it's the same who said
what does it mean to live with all my
soul it means that in this world the way
I can I want to experience complete vas
complete oneness in this situation
Now it's true in very very powerful
ways. It's also true in more subtle ways
and maybe in more simple ways. You know
sometimes
in life we have what's you know maybe
it's a martyr's attitude
and probably Yiddish imamas know very
well what I'm talking about but it's
generally it's an instinct. Sometimes uh
a person may feel you know if I take
care of my needs.
I remember once I was giving a lecture
it was to women a few years ago and a
mother came over to me afterwards and
she says you know all my children are
miserable. How do I make them happy?
So I asked her I said I don't know how
you make your children happy but I think
your question has to be how to make
yourself happy because when a mother is
happy she radiates that in the house and
each child is going to have to go
through their journey and figure out
their happiness. But if they have a role
model of happiness, it will show them
what it means to be happy. So she looked
at me like I fell off of Mars. And she
said, "That's not what I was expecting
from you. I want you to tell me how make
my kids happy." I said, "I don't know,
but I think you have to focus make
yourself happy." She said, "My me, I
gave up on my happiness 30 years ago."
So I said, "So that's what you're going
to teach your children, too. You're
going to teach that to your children.
And you're going to model for your
children to give up on their happiness
and to worry about their kids'
happiness.
And then their kids will learn that from
their mother. And then the question is
which generation is this all for? You
know, it's always which generation is
allowed to be happy? Any or no? It's
always I'm going to be miserable but you
be happy. Right? There was a Jewish
comedian who said in my house we only
had leftovers. We're still looking for
the original meal. We're still looking.
Where's the original meal? When is when
are we going to get the original meal?
Who's the generation? Right? So so here
here's the good news. Our generation is
the last generation of golas and the
first generation of gulas. So this is a
generation that it was all four
makabatees.
But sometimes we I should be happy. My
kids are struggling. My husband is
struggling. I'm struggling. My brother
is struggling. My sister's struggling is
struggling. You want me right now to be
happy. You want me to be serene? You
want me to take a walk? You want me to
exercise? You want me to radiate joy?
You want me to radiate serenity? What am
I, a self-centered narcissistic? A woman
once told me, "In my house, if you sat
on the couch and you picked up one foot
and another foot, there was a sense of
you have nothing to do. You have nothing
to do. The world is falling apart." The
of you sitting on a couch with one foot
up and never mind if there's a coffee in
the other hand.
And this person still I don't know I'm
probably it's 60 years I don't know
whatever it is still when they sit down
on the couch there's a sense of inner
inner inner guilt and it's often seen as
something religious as something holy as
something divine
because like the death instinct like
you're not allowed to that feels much
more religious and that's why can be
trusted where says he says no you got it
wrong
Hashem wants I should be able to serve
him with all my heart, with all my soul.
That means if I'm enthusiastic, if I'm
in joy, if I'm angry and miserable, so
my shabas, my pes is not a real, it's
not a divine experience. I'm I'm giving
2% of myself. I'm like a robot. I'm like
a zombie. On the contrary, self-
nurture, self-care is not a crime. Often
it's a mitzvah. It's the greatest
mitzvah.
Why? Because actually if I could fulfill
my mission in this world I can actually
give much more to others. You all know
in your house when a mother is truly
truly in a good place in a tranquil
place aligned connected
happy celebrating life you think you
give more to your children or less to
your children. What do you think?
Ask your children especially those who
are adults and are outspoken and will
tell you the truth. When you when a
mother in her the name of selflessness
becomes miserable because she
experiences the anxiety of every child
does that help the children or to the
contrary I think there's I think it
could be said today in truth that most
children when they see their parents in
a happier state it's much easier for
them I once heard a son tell his mother
he went through a heavy journey
so he was tell his mother said could you
give advice now after you went through
So he says, "Yeah, that you shouldn't
take on my anxiety when I'm going
through an experience cuz then you
become part of my problem. You can't be
part of my solution." It was very
profound. Now you say, "What do you
mean? What am I? I'm I'm going to
unblend from you. I'm your mother.
You're part of me. You're me.
How can I?" But the truth is,
as they say on the airplanes, when you
have oxygen now, you can give your child
oxygen. If I'm choking
and I'm in such a difficult state and
the reason I'm so difficult is because
I'm so selfless because I'm worrying
about everybody else besides me. What
type of mother am I giving them? What
type of father? What type of person am I
I'm not agree? I can't even be here for
you. It's like when a husband or a wife
don't have an identity and their entire
identity becomes codependent. Whatever
the other one is feeling, I have to
feel. It's not only a miserable way of
living. I can't even be there for the
other person because I'm busy being the
other person. How can I be there for the
other person? But when you're rooted in
your own identity, when you're rooted in
your own core, when you understand that
self-care is actually a mitzvah,
it's a form of real holiness. Real
holiness is that my vessels are
expansive.
that if my body is a basikdash, the bame
mikdash needs to be beautiful and solid
because the bamed is the place where the
dwells, you're not let it destroy a
stone in the bikush. Why not? Cuz it's
the house of the
so if the goof is a bikdash and it is
and the nama is the bame mikdash also
needed protection you know with why
because it's the honor of the body needs
protection. Why? Because I'm
selfcentered. because I'm a horrible
person. No, because I it can't be a ba
mikdesh if I don't respect the divine
presence in this sanctuary.
It's not I'm not a martyr. I'm not
selfless. I'm actually detach from the
truth. Real selfrespect
often people think is a form of
arrogance. It's a form of of uh
narcissism.
It could be that way, but very often
it's exact opposite. Real self-respect
means respecting the divine mission
that is invested in my being. If I
squander that, I'm not doing the world a
favor. I'm not doing my kids a favor.
I'm not doing myself a favor. I'm not
doing God a favor. I'm actually
neglecting the world from my light.
Imagine if you're plugged in and you're
plugged in and your plug is channeling
the electricity and then you you know
what? You're always thinking about your
your electricity. You're in it. Let's
pull out the plug. What happens? The
room grows dark. You need to know how to
keep your plug connected cuz then the
room grows light. Say what? I'm going to
think about my plug. It's not my plug.
It's me being a channel for the divine
light. And if I unplug it to be able to
appease this one or that one to be able
to satisfy what I think are other
people's demands or needs, what happens?
There's no light in the room anymore.
The house goes dim. The mother goes dim
in the name of this beautiful, beautiful
uh holy anxiety. What looks like anxiety
is not always holy. And what looks like
happiness is not always selfish.
Sometimes it's the opposite. Anxiety
could be coming from a complete not
understanding of who I am and what my
role is. And it feels better for me,
more selfless. Like Benura, Ben says, it
feels better if you die. You know why?
At least you will die and the other
person won't die in your presence. Aka
says, "Excuse me." It sounds very good.
But now you have two two dead two dead
Jews.
So what feels like emotionally if I'm
dying at least you're dying, I'm dying.
We're both dying. I'm not talking about
emotional stuff. I don't mean
physically, but I'm just using it as a
metaphor. Rub says the opposite. You
know what? But if you drink and you're
alive, maybe you'll be able to go find
water for the other person. Maybe you'll
have strength and you'll be able to run
fast and find water. Maybe you'll be
able to scream and find help. In many
ways, Rabaka is not just being more
pragmatic. He's being more pragmatic,
but it's also much more idealistic.
Actually, if you're in a happy place,
you'll probably be able to help your
children infinitely more. If I'm
attached, if I'm plugged in, if there's
energy coming through me, I could show
up. There's a heart, there's a soul,
there's a body, there's a mind
what I'm saying is resonating,
huh? Big time. Hindi, you with me? You
agree? Okay. Cuz I asked in the
beginning, is self-care a crime or a
mitzvah? So Hindi said, depends what
type of self-care.
Do sometimes people misconstrue this
idea and everything is just me me. I
couldn't care less about anybody else.
We're not talking about that. And with
the mother sitting in this room, we're
not even worried about that. Even if you
try doing that, you won't be able to.
Too much Jewish guilt, 5,000 years. I
don't even think you'll be able to be
successful if you try. Maybe there's a
few exceptions. I don't know.
It's really a much deeper form of
understanding that it's not a neglect of
responsibility was
aikesh means how can I be connected to
the source in the most powerful way to
serve as that channel for infinite life
and love and hope.
Based on this we now conclude with the
order
Paras Shabas father mother
father Shabas
because mother father and shabas
represents
three dimensions of life. The mother is
the most connected to the child. In fact
the child develops in the womb of the
mother. So there's no differentiation at
least for a significant amount of time.
Let's hope at some point there's
differentiation.
But in many ways you are your mother.
Your mother is you. I don't mean it in a
negative way. I mean in a good way. We
are molded and crafted within the
ammoniatic sack of our mother. Right?
The Gmorra says the fetus is part of
mommy. So mother really and mother is
the ultimate nurturer especially in the
primal most formative years both through
food especially through food nursing
shelter emotion. There's that n the
mother is the quintessential nurturer.
hopefully a healthy mother, a loving
mother um who knows how to do it. Father
already represents our connection which
is outside of ourselves because father
is also connected to us. But father is
represents especially in the ancient
world you know the father gave the child
the discipline and the father gave the
child the vocation and job and position
even in le is based on father based on
father Jewish or non-Jewish identity is
based on mother. So the father already
represents our expanded connection
outside of ourselves. We're part of a
family. We're part of an ancestry. We're
part of a community. We're part of a a
larger a larger tribe, so to speak.
That's father. Shabas represents our
respect for the creator. That's what
Shabas is. Shabas is there's a creator.
My mother and father don't live in a
vacuum. None of us live in a vacuum.
There was a there's a creator who
conceives the world in love. And my
mother is part of that. My father is
part of that. I am part of that. So in
many ways respect for mother, respect
for father, respect for shabas are three
dimensions in development. One dimension
of development is I focus on me, my
nurture, my being, my existence which is
what mother is concerned with. Father is
my respect and my connection to a
community to an organism whether it's
family whether it's tribe whether it's
community whether it's clal the Jewish
people what's the family of humanity and
then shabases my duty and my loyalty to
the whole plan of creation to the
purpose of creation one of the great
mistakes it's very easy to make in life
is to make that these three are very
different if I take care of myself it
means it's at the expense of come on you
don't care about your You don't care
about your family. You don't care about
you. How selfish are you going to be?
And if I take care of if I care about
that, I'm not really caring about
myself. And if I care about God, it's
not about me. But here we see the TA
puts the three mitzvah together. Respect
for mother, respect for father, respect
for shabas come together, but in a
change of order. In paras,
it begins with the cl. It all begins
with Hashem. There's a hierarchy in
creation. Hashem, my divine soul.
My divine soul. Let me just
Yeah. So, Shabas represents begins with
a creator, right? My father and it says
my father and mother are partners with
Hashem.
There's three partners. So, it begins
with Hashem. It continues with the
father. continues with the mother. In
other words, it begins with the clown
and the proud. There's a cosmic plan.
We're all part of that and then we
become manifestations. There's the
manifestation represented by the father
and there's the manifestation
represented by the mother which comes to
me individually in parad
says to you be holy.
Understand how holy you are. Now you
realize my mother, my father, my shabas.
Now the order is it actually begins with
self.
Have awe for your mother, which means
have awe for your own nurture, for your
own identity, for your own development.
Have awe for your mother. Have respect
for how you impact other people. Have
awe for Shabas, which is how you impact
God. And the three are really one.
Because in the deepest sense, it would
be like I'm saying, I'm going to eat
something that my taste buds are going
to like. Potato chips, black and white,
donuts, right? But the rest of my body
is going to suffer from it. So it
doesn't make sense. It's not good for
the taste buds either. If I get anxious,
if I get depressed, if it's not good for
my sugar level, if it's not good for my
moods, if it's not good for my blood
circulation, the fact that my taste buds
like it doesn't make it beneficial. And
therefore, as a result of that, taking
care of myself means taking care of my
entire body. I can eat pizza and
cheesecake in the morning and I like it.
But what likes it? My taste buds like it
for six minutes and then the rest of the
body for a few hours is in a bad mood.
So, it's not a contradiction. You say,
"Oh, you're going to sacrifice yourself
because you want your blood circulation
to be healthy." That's not called
sacrifice. It's called being normal,
centered. The same is true. Our body is
part of a larger body. My body is not
just my body. There's oxygen I take in
from outside of my body. So, just like
feeding my taste buds at the expense of
the rest of my body doesn't mean I'm
taking care of myself. It means I'm
damaging myself. Feeding my own body at
the expense of the larger body is also
not helpful. And feeding the larger body
at the expense of the ultimate truth of
the soul of existence is also not going
to be healthy. Let's say I feed my body
but I abandon my soul. I couldn't care
less about my soul, my emotions. It's
not going to work. A healthy life means
that all the parts are taken care of.
What are the three major parts of life?
Mommy, tati, and chabas. So in it begins
from the source the cl to the prat in
par's it begins from the individual once
you realize to you so true self- nurture
true taking care of my body of my
existence it's not a contradiction to
father and chabas on the contrary it
begins with that and then it goes to
father then it goes to shabas even
though where hashem is revealing the ten
commandments he does it in the order
from top bottom the hierarchy of
creation but here when a person
understands how holy they are then
self-care is not a crime. Self-care is a
mitzvah because the true self is a
channel for the divine light in this
world. Have a beautiful and wonderful
week.
Next week, Tuesday, 9:30.
Sure.
Take your