Let’s Daf with Rabb Yoel Gold || Zvachim 6

Today's we start from the two dots. It's around 15 lines from the top. Yeah. We learned in the Mishna that um any carbon that was but the doesn't fulfill his obligation of whatever nether he made to bring a carbon. Suppose he said I'm going to bring an could still bring it onto the but he still needs to bring another yeah whatever brings it just to bring another but it served as aap what do you mean if it was why would I have to bring another one right that's So if it's not so why bring it at all? Yeah. If you're going to tell me that it's not then I understand. I can understand why you have to bring it anyway. Why? Because it was originally or let's say. So now that you changed it, it's right since it was hooked already for a carbon. So you still can can bring it even though it's the second one. But if you're going to tell me that the first one is also even though I don't need another one. Okay. So is that the first one is not [snorts] What happens and for any so suppose he didn't put on one day then after the goes another day without he wants to know this of this could it also cover the other say that he So work only whatever you did before the yeah two as well. No, it's not similar to why because you see there's a very big distinction between theap of because in every you have to bring another right. So that's why it doesn't work um from before to after a few [snorts] that you violated before. Once you see that you can bundle together a bunch of and a bunch of them. So maybe it also works for any anything that you after as well. So the sh again [snorts] if a guy is he wanted to cover a couple of that he had done before the and then after he violated another. So now he wants this which is even for the today. There's a mitzvah that say when you bring the says so what does the mean referring to a guy who didn't do means im wasn't made he didn't do considers it as if this didn't this uh wasn't the scapper with the love which means what does mean keeper keeper keeper means it was for whatever you did before the but the you didn't do you violated this or you didn't do it yes so that it can't for because that was so that's the no it's not such a you want to bring from the as long as [snorts] you didn't you still have a to do so so when when the when did you violate the right only once because up until there's no sha we're Whatever about uh about this carbon whether it could be for a you did after before that for sure or not. Okay. So that's not a that's the case by definition from the fact that you could that that you could still do the up until the last second before means that the violation happened once the happened. So then it's not about that it's not going to be after Gomorrah says we can differently. What does keeper keep means? Rash says in the end in the bottom over here last last few words on the which means the get from which means that Rashi says again it's not a Gar says I'll bring you a for this interpretation this is sometimes how you can understand the lotion of keeper and loke keeper milan needs the on hisapar works only if he had the she and the coin put on the [snorts] lefto right and so has a even without it But it's considered as if he doesn't have aap. What does that mean? If he has aapo, what does it mean? It's considered as if he doesn't have aap. If you're going to tell me he needs to bring he said it works. So over there what does it mean? What is what is the uh what is the mean when it says you don't need. So in other words, but which means you didn't do the mitzvah. So here too says no don't uh don't be that way when he says keeper keeper it means keep us means that you it worked for the behind right you have like a half a for the behind us but not for the you have to do the rush again so which means also it's keeper for any that you violated it before before but for itself it doesn't work. Okay. Yeah. trying to be push somebody's map for and then he's could the cover of afterl Right. It's coming to Sorry. What's not coming at all? Okay. So now says like this. Why do you need two two goats? So if you have the first one, if you're already the first one, so you have you already have aap. So why do you have to be the second one? So between the of the first goat and the of the second goat, somebody might have might have walked into the meetap. So really would need constant but is the money really the you don't need to bring it but the second one one one back up you know between the first and the second one we are and that you that's why you bring it over here If somebody walked in between the first Z and the second Z, right? [snorts] You're telling me that the second Z would be for this guy who walked in in between the first and second but could the second for that period the second that Sawyer was already hr. So you see that that was up until this whatever a person does in that time. says, "No, don't prove it so quickly. If both at the same time, then you're right to prove from here." But here we're talking about that there was the first one and then there were the second and then there was the second. So you don't have a riot in the second. Okay. Well, you really gonna that this is the case. It's in a case where there weren't you're limiting narrowing down the in other words the is referring every that's what happened. No, it doesn't make sense. Okay, I have a different answer for you. Why you can't prove it from is different? Because you have lez the heart of bez they make a old that the the the classification of the carbon shouldn't be right up until the point of Um whenever the second is yeah you pull the sack and you're about to that's what's uh the the of the carbon it's going to be what kind of carbon it should be. So, so that's why when you have the so, so uh when you the first one and your the second hasn't been set as a uh for the because of up until the last second it's not uh it doesn't become it doesn't get that shem of a and therefore whatever whatever aus happened up until That point can still be a sculper with a second saw. [snorts] Yeah. So, uh is if you have leftover you can't you can't use that was bought with from last year money that was raised from last year. So you have that funds you put into then you buy for that year the you have leftover can't use it for the next year. Yeah it's has to be new every year. Uh so what do you do with those says it's not right? You can't be po because he already has so why because doesn't have until the last second before it but argues says it has and he doesn't hold. So how could you say who said that that even if you want to answer that the talk about if you take the in two separate right once you The reason why you need the right he asked he asked he asked the told him the whole is only right once he did it both. So now the sh is before the can they can it still cover any a sounds like it's um it would cover any says no that's not really was topic even whether the s can cover so why is that it could do it. In other words, it's been says that it's still maybe is referring to a specific case where the AFA didn't happen yet for the second. Okay. So now I have a shila what about what about uh between and so the gammor never was push this sha of can right cover the was never so we b with a shil okay we'll stop over