Liquid On Shabbos - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

loofa my boy Emma shame a t-shirt uh Tyrell doctor welcome everyone to today's here from of Yaakov Zev Smith Selita on the topic of liquids and Hilco Shabbos whoever would like to have the grapes co-sponsoring a share called arrogance you retire at seven one eight eight five one eight six five one recently had an interesting Shila with someone here the Shabbos sudha and they forgot to put the soup the chicken soup onto the fire so can come Shabbos and the chicken soup is in the refrigerator they're having guests and it's you can't have a suitor with that hot soup but you can't serve cold soup so the question was is there any eights to somehow to warm a cold liquid on Shabbos so this led us on a journey to learn the the sucio the halacha of vishal regarding liquids which has we see as we'll see includes many other shy lists about besides we warming soup but questions of hot drinks and many other shila's regarding liquid specifically liquids on hills of Shabbos so we have to learn is basically a Mishnah and hopefully once we have that that's a bit of information that we could have proceeded with all of our Zyliss the Mishna says interceptor Shabbos cook from Haman BAE's Kolsch Ababa Hammond the Erev Shabbos so trashy whatever was cooked any food that was cooked before Shabbos Shirey no Sabre common be Shabbos the muscle you cook the potato we cooked it Easter chicken and Erev Shabbos and now it's cold and you want to rewarm that cooked foods supplements now as long as it was cooked before Shabbos you're allowed to be warm a cooked food on Shabbos in other words for example you have a piece of chicken that's cold you want to make it warm to serve the children you could take the chicken put it into the hot pot of soup when it's off the fire leave the chicken and the soup by time you finish serving the soup you'll find the chicken nice and warm to serve the children the question is how could you do that the American your test thief tests says that a Cleary shine a part of food even if it's not on the fire is fully capable of cooking a hot pot of soup even without a fire is fully capable of cooking so how could you put a piece of cooked chicken into the hot pot and we warm it the clear yishun is able to able to cook it the answer is that's the obvious silica since the piece of chicken was cooked already now you're not be cooking it it's cooked already what you're doing is you're rewarming that's the concept of a missile at abyssal once chicken is cooked it's cooked what you're doing now is you're not you're cooking it ain't basillica Bissell you're rewarming it that we know is the logo of a missile exhibition but to put it very bluntly a missile exhibition is not just on how lava it's a Mateus this piece of cold chicken is fully cooked if it's cooked you can't make a second cooking so that's why it's multi la casilla to put the chicken into a hot pot even though we'll get steaming hot because once it's cooked you can't be cook it what are you doing you're rewarming if rewarming is not bissell now you're wondering so if you such a braid to mcurtin if you allow to rewarm chicken why do we have to put it into a hot pot of soup that's off the fire take the chicken put it on to the left or put it into the hot pot cooking on the fire so that's something that we all know that's the issue of Hazara and of course there's no is that the casio kumara that's a mitzvah but Hazara is an important word for today to take any food even if it's fully cook even if it's still hot and take it from off the fire and put it on to the fire that's the issue there abundant of Hazara we don't do so to take any food and put it onto the fire into a pot on the fire is awesome we're talking about today you're taking a piece of fully cooked food putting it either on top of a cholan pot which is on the fire or putting it into a creation that's off the fire once there's no it's of Hazara you're allowed to rewarm the food if you look in the raj without member maibaner Maskull me come welcome he explains the Mishnah just as I told you that you're allowed to be warm a cooked food but Hazara is still awesome now so let's talk calculus our cold soup that's in the refrigerator why don't we say the same idea since the soup was fully cooked you'll out to be warm it put it the face on top of a cholan pot put it on the side of the bladder if you have a radiator you could take the pod and put it on the radiator that's not kazar because that's not very official on a radiator and can end the Huayra presumably if you put a pot on to a radiator it might cook this it might warm the soup significantly and the MS is the pastor's of our Mishnah coal Shabab becoming the Erev Shabbos whatever was cooked Erev Shabbos you allowed to rewarm the Clara would include even soap even liquids and indeed the RAM and Africa Bay's with a fair if and the Razvi that I mentioned all make this point any food liquid or solid as long as it's fully cooked you're allowed to rewarm it on Shabbos as long as there's no it's of Hazara however we know that's not the case and this is based on Raschi and Amidala Damascus Asia and the RAM that I mentioned quoting Urbania ena that make an interesting Philip a solid food RW of Asia a dry food chicken kugel some tequila etc and this'll exhibition but a liquid lamashtu a local soup that yes miss chihuaha bishop even though is fully cooked before shoppers and this something that we seem to remember you can't rewarm a cold liquid but the question is managed Donna if we just explain that once it's cooked you can tree cook it so why is a liquid different so the answer which is really these that we need for today is let's start from a simple example water is fully drinkable as it is and that's why if a guy cooks water there's no waste official outcome because water is fully usable as it is you can't take raw water and make it cooked water that that doesn't make sense like chicken you make cook too raw flavor from from from so I brought the cooked clay look water cooked why is the background Bissell by water the terrace is you make a hot cup of water that's a whole different Mateus the Bissell by water is not making it from raw to cooked the Bissell by water is making it from cold to hot in other words the Bissell is warming it now you have a cold cup of tea so the lambda will say it's not a cold cup of tea it's not tea I mean today grab do they have the India tea iced tea so if the motion is a little harder to relate to but I think we all appreciate that a cold cup of tea is not T what is the Bissell buy chicken you made it from water cooked even though now it's cold but it's still cooked chicken ain't Bissell artificial isn't matías but when it comes to a liquid hot water hot tea the Bissell is not cooking it and making it from raw to cooked the Bissell is warming it now that it got totally called if you re warming you are actually being my vassal it so will say the same reality ain't Bissell exhibitionism a tree is made by salad and yes miss Eliza Bissell is the reality by liquids because if the if the cold if the water became cold it's no longer Bissell now you are warming it you are actually cooking so the basic Killick is in the fact that once it's cold it's no longer hot drinks now of course you'll ask but my cooked chicken soup it's still chicken soup so that didn't go away that effect remains but the boshin explains that we look at liquids as one group and liquids a special exhibition but we can't remember can't forget that Duran and the rajma hold even by liquids a missile arc abyssal I guess when you cook water you have a certain effect that remains you sterilized it there's no longer germs so we have a malaika's beside him if he aged bissell official by liquids how do we pass skin so that's important question so two places the macabre and see you access dollar and see you test tes love postions lajas mir that when it comes to a liquid gauge basilica be so presumably if you rewarm a cold water its molecular ice the rama brings the Makela the nog hula jaco implying it's town and lagoon ree if the liquid is still warm allowed to rewarm it sucks the mr. brewer mr. death e ramo argues on the macabre and he holds that biood of allah ain't bissell alpha bissell boy bazaar you look IRA our cold soup you have no problem take the closed loop out of the refrigerator and put in any place that it will get steaming hot on top of a radiator on top of a shell and fat the side of the black but that's not true you look at the lush another on ma the remote akka says no hago la Jaco employing its tan name lagoon ring if the soap if that the liquid is still somewhat warm lukewarm in other words you can't take it out of the fridge ready me warm it if the soup is somewhat light in its down of a Gumby that not cool entirely then aim basilica Bissell but a completely cold liquids Brahma also agrees it's awesome so our soup is cold you can't we warm it but the question is what did that mean line it's done on the gallery if it's no longer yatzee letters by dr. macabre yeh special exhibition there are more says way next analogue army which means a lot less than Yahtzee lettuce it still somewhat lukewarm what does that mean how love is those thing is latex found on the gallery so the simple shot under armours Optima Gannavaram and this man from early Raceland gimel a medallion that there are more really halls that if is kintyre Lee called yes Basilica Bissell is innocent ERISA taking cold soup and warming it is a molecular Isis but the way the price can explain if it's low in its tannin the gallery if it's still somewhat warm so we could say the first Vishal is still in existence well it's still warm the way the Rav learns its new home at Moscone Moosa it still considered hot soup ok bid the effort but you would still consider the hot soup uh-huh in other words the first Bissell is still here if the first Bissell is still here we'll go back down your side aim Basilica Bissell because look at this the first Bissell is still noticeable but if it's Knicks fan and lagari then the first Bishop is gone then the remote would agree to the muhabba yay specialist official is innocent horizon and pack of the Rav stunner from the sitter Lukas Arab see he says if you have some gravy rewarming it it has cold is an SS killer don't forget so it's a tricky business if it's completely cold it's a melaka there Ison if it's Lyon expanding gallery like there are Maas mutton but there's a different shot which has a tremendous impact on our sugar the Prima Gotham irrational demos of tests and shineth has llama tests but most specifically the has an ish spells it out in Lambeth irineu damo says a totally different shot Durham all hold me it could didn't like the restrain him ain't busy locks official bit of a lock which means even if the soup is called there's no dinner vishal because once something was cooked ain't vishal after Bishop novice if something is totally cold people will think hey he's been Mahalo Shabbos look he took cold water if you wanna get the section is that this is no longer cooked so as a protection has I'll say don't re warm cold liquids it's like a magic innovation but the Iike didn't its motor to rewarm cold liquids it's still awesome then if it's down on the GAR me but it's not because full is to their eyes submission so let's be clear before we apply promise' if you have a salad food that's completely cold all agree allowed to rewarm it as long as no is the Hazara a liquid that's lying its timing the shock collar holds a saucer norma hoses motor once it's mixed on ain all agree you can tree warm it the question is the macabre holds its ministers erisa and there are most questionable if ethnicity i saw not now a bizarre our cold soup which is from refrigerator all agree for practical purposes you're now allowed to rewarm it on Shabbos well soon see maybe a possible eight sir but let's go right and let's try to apply it in the numerous shyness you had unexpected guests and your short a little bit chicken for the Friday night soothes it but you have chicken from Thursday night but it's cold so there's no problem take the chicken from the refrigerator considering that it's there's no liquid gravy put it into a soup pot when you take it off the fire put it on to the side of the blast put it on top of the Cholan pack put it on the radiator as long as dissolve is the Hazara allowed to rewarm a piece of cold chicken you remember to make the kanae left the kreplach but you forgot to warn them before Shabbos they're sitting in the refrigerator and you're in trouble yeah you can't serve cold Canadian love crap look simple eight sir when you're ready to serve the soup paper soup off the fire put the Canadian prep book into the hot Cleary showing steaming the oddness with soap and Bissell a habitual as long as it's not mr. Hasan the big question that everybody asks is listen I mean chicken kale of kreplach are all good examples that are basically add of your age but it all has some moisture to it Lucas so how could i rewarm any of these foods and a phenom ii the salad is motor but there's some moisture why don't we say yes Miculek official on the moisture so the Animus it's a good cancer but then what would he do the Mishnah i mean today in our microwave era we know every food has a liquid content so how could the Mishnah allow rewarming a solid food every solid food has a lot Luke Asst the carrots for us is push it because really this is a solid food it's not that you go but row even mIET the food is identified as a solid once this solid food is cooked and Bissell exhibition isn't Mateus the so he says ocean and cook Club dolls have caught my Messiah he says that a little bit my look is attained by mama SH the egg late out and see for cotton and hey boys dollar has a very lovely support and he says they're really the luck Lucas is always not directly being cooked it's a pray sure that's cooked but he goes with that with the sight that really by by double life ain't Bissell habilis motor it's just a homework so the former of situation with the former of a Musharraf official is too much of a homeroom that's what he explains but I think the most positive shot is the way the husband is explained they're really by double act ain't Bashar exhibition just we perceive it looks like Bissell know if you take a piece of Canadian kreplach chicken no one sees them did no one focuses on de la Lucas so it's not Mexican move a so and that's why you allowed to rewarm it so basically a food that is really a wh although there is moisture the moisture is negligible consider the next question approach with caution someone made luxe in the cover Chavez and again they forgot to rewarm it before Shabbos so now this cold option in the frigerator so okay what's the difference between cradle of crap local auction the problem is that the Macias is that after you cook Luxan you rinse it with cold water I never knew but someone told me why because if you keep it warm it gets more cooked even if it's off the fire okay so now you learnt something about cooking but mom I see you always rejoice rinse cook Luxan now the Luxan has cooked LOX intro and uncooked cold tap water that was that you use it to rinse an air of sadness or on Chavez steal out of Vince's but the question is now if you put the disruption into the hot soup you're cooking two things the Luxan is okay but you're cooking the uncooked cold water I'll say well Lucas we just learned that Lucas as motor this is motor state sugars madaba first of all the closest is part of the chicken this is not part of the election and number two that Lucas was once cooked when you cook the chicken this is cold water that was never cooked so 1/8 sir which is not practical is if you dry all the Luxan but if you dry the election please don't serve it to me I might as well you know you learn you lose your appetite drive luxan what is the practical aid sir so the very simple aid sir and his ways amidst all the fires from this because it helps in many forms basically then the Gemara says a Cleary showing is incapable of cooking but there's something called Collier Bissell some foods get cooked even ackley SHANY but a cliche niba derek law cannot cook the good news based on a Kimura mm alpha and a fan base and the homeric and see if your base Pascal's like this water is definitely not Kali abyssal in other words water never gets cooked in a cliche you could take if you're interested take a ice cube and put it into a hot bowl of soup there's no it's official because water does not get cooked in a cliched the bowl of soup is a cliche water cannot get cooked in a cliche so if you if you don't have to dry all that reflection take the hot pot of soup put it into a serving bowl which you do anyhow generally and then you could add the Luxan with all that cold water uncooked water why I the waters getting cooked but this water is in a cliche me the soup is in a cliche knee and cliche knee is incapable of cooking water so you don't have to drive the Luxan put it into the serving bowl or put it into the soup bowl as long as it's a cliche how do we define the word loin it's down in the county let's say you have soup what's the definition of Lading it's down on the Camry so we have a pretty good idea what that means the whole slaughter while and it's down on the Gumby is multi is because the first Bissell is still noticeable it still felt so it makes sense and talk of the Rob and see you at rest Eve test says this lotion shiroi you Italian level Mama's commie muesli in other words this piping hot soup there's hot soup and there's passable lukewarm soup Supt arrived as long as this soup can be served as hot it's considered hot and what's not piping it's not steaming but if it's passable as hot that's enough that it's the first Bissell is still felt the Pima Gotham inching in Tesla I'm attest as a lotion Shan Roy you laughs well that's what can sit and sound on the Camry but thus far is very push it as long as you could serve this soup is hot even with the other taught the first Bissell is still effective so once the first vishal is still felt an bish so exhibitionism at Sears now I know some people are they have to have hot hot tea you know you pick up a cup of tea Billy could hold a cup of tea the person drinks it at its account you know it's cold he can't drink it okay so there are some people that need hot hot hot but the bioship is quote famous now misquoted him or ashabi Hey look I love olive gimel that says we look at right people right people have hot and have lukewarm okay next question is an interesting question someone asked me when he has stole the chicken soup he doesn't want to just put it back and serve it on Sunday so he puts he pours that into the hot Charlotte and I'm not taking a cries for the recipe chicken soup and Sheldon but this what he does he mixes the hot beat leftover chicken soup with the challenge so Myra he said I have no problem because the chicken soup in the Clery shine is still fairly hot so I'm not worried about Michelin abyssal but this is an oversight because Friday night where is your challenge generally where's everybody's show on Friday night on top of the fire so you're taking the pot the hot pot of soup from the table after you took it off the fire and you're putting the hot pot of soup into a Joanne pot that's not a NIST official as mr. hazhar so you know again it's either it's always two factors he avoided this official but this is an issue of hazard in the rare case that the chicken soup was on the fire he served it from the fire or whatever he did and then you gotta take the soup from thee from the that's on the fire even though it's somewhat cooled off if it's ladies found I got me then his assumption was correct I'll give you a more common case you serve a child their bowl the soup not only doesn't touch he doesn't look at it no he doesn't want it now when I see a short soup you have guests you want to serve the soup but this soup ready is is not as hot as used to be so there's a simple agent take the bowl of soup pour it back into the Clery shine into the hot pot of soup that's off the fire then you could we serve that soup because the soup that the child left over was lying it's down in the gallery it's still somewhat lukewarm then you could add it back to the original hot pot of soup to make it considerably hotter and then that's a bit chillax official by a lobster laying its tonic someone had a question Friday night he took too much talent and he when he realized that he's gonna be caught because there's not enough charm for the next day he wanted to put back some of his cholent now this is a mitzvah of a ship a sec sailors micaiah Mon Java so he said he was a big London he says the Chell and his child is already dry so even if the chalant is completely cold imbecilic abyssal by a wh so assuming that's true but he has another problem could the child that he took off he probably put down so now it's an issue of Hazara another friendly reminder besides the it's official you have to be focused on the issue of Hazara a good example of child that's mota to be returned on Shabbos by the Shabbos Sudha you have the child in the Clery shine that's off the fire it's still very hot you want to pour the leftover children from your table back into the original Chellam path so even if there's a big difference in temperature but if the child is dry ain't black abyss you can put it back into the Champa if the child is moist is it's liquidy but again as long as latex down on the gamma you could put it back into the big Cleary shine even though it gets much warmer because ain't Bissell our habitual byline it's down on the gummy summer one's asked me this goes back many years ago but a very Lum Ducie question but there was little of a mistake to it this goes back to years ago when we still have incandescent bulbs which means above a light bulb literally around bulb that used to give off light by a the the heating element the tungsten the filament so we spoke then that putting a light on Shabbos is a contemporary example of the Rambam mr. branch in your festive beginning quotes it I'm humming mattress if you cook up mattress until it glows so if the ROM is an it's official because just like you cooked chicken is our source of cooking a metal and a metal glows until it's glowing is Vishal so all the hectic pace scheme actually the place in the free the previous generations of hoisin said you put a light on you're making the piece of metal globe that's why it gives light so someone asked in his eyes lung district question since the light was on before Shabbos and it went off why don't we say ain't Bissell official by a Davidovich because the filament is not a liquidy it's a solid so a mistake of course is that the meadow is not like the piece of chicken it gets cooked it remains cook the only reason why it gives law of light is because it's glowing so once it's no longer glowing even though it's the salad it's like a dove er laughs and yay special exhibition so the two star was mine but there has an issue the inside that's how you Adam in clown coughs Eve has already rights it'd be shy type that ain't ilaha bishop i wh but if you if you heat a piece of metal i feel the mayor comin they still the easter because that's like a double life but such a nice eyeful not to give him a rewards I told you know like you're smart I'll tell you another finish desire says if someone gets angry on Shabbos he's or even they serve our age for home is racism because truth as a person gets sick off like we said he's boiling mad I said according to you once you get angry once you're on you're angry a second I'm ambitious official but they're both not you don't get angry once and enjoy Shabbos okay now let me tell you a beautiful our other mice of this is based on a has initial I'm Italian you'd get mo if you ever wonder the shear of Bissell when it comes to foods the minimum share is Michael been through sight which means it's edibles slightly when it comes to cooking liquids the shear is yacht sir lettuce boy what's the silic Michael Bendis I he's not yaks writer but why do we have two different children so the fee what we said and that the hazards explain is this beautiful the Bissell by foods is making it from water cooked so once it's cooked edible albeit vicious attack might have been destroyed its fill considered cooked but when you cook water a liquid you're not making it from water cooked the Bissell is now it is a hot liquid uh-huh hat is defined as the answer lettuce boy it's not a altogether it's a warming therefore the shear is not Michael band aside the shear is and yacht Scylla but let me tell you a beautiful Shila that has many NASA community but I'll tell you how it was presented this is a rear Shila but it's a very good insight into the circular someone had a urn typical urn of hot water and the plug was pulled out so basically the shabbos will not be the same me and mrs. hot water but he wanted to capitalize on the mistake she has a big urn of hot water he's not going to have to use if you too much longer it's gonna cool off so he decided to make a brewed coffee on Chavez I was losing fuh he took regular coffee that's the powder coffee and paste his choice you know an instant coffee and he put it into the urn and the assumption was it's gonna have a different flavor to it okay are the addition that's what he wanted to do but the question that was unique was can you take coffee and put it into a clear yishun into a steaming hot pot of water now generally there's no shower you can't do that because if the urn is still on so it's like a boa if you can't put anything into it but this you have a rare situation that it isn't hot pot of water there's no fire the question is can you take instant coffee instant tea sugar or salt and any of the situations and add it to a Cleary shine that's why I Gaby H can you take salt and put it into its shell and part that's off the fire so you're probably wondering while coffee and tea and sugar certainly shouldn't be a Schuyler because as we spoke a number of times instant coffee is all fully cooked they take the coffee grind they cook it they make it into a thick a coffee soup so to speak then they remove the water either through heating evaporation or through the freeze-dried but at the end of the day all instant coffee and tea and sugar for that matter are all previously cooked so I bizarre what's the problem you'll how to put sugar into a clear Asian you had to put coffee into a clear Eastern so this fellow could put his instant coffee into the earth now if the plug is still on if it's still boiling it's an agar bas hazhar but here we come to a unique question because coffee tea and sugar you ever notice we put it into a cup of hot water you no longer could find the coughing you can't even find the sugar why not the terrorist is busted coffee tea sugar and salt our work will refer to as a soluble which means when you put it into hot water it liquefies it turns into a liquid now the word liquify is a very significant word liquify is like the words liquid laughs in other words coffee tea sugar and salt are used as a powder true but when you put it into what you want to use it with it turns into a liquid and is used as a liquid so now we have a very important question powder again coffee tea sugar and salt are right now a link a salad latoya and when it's dry to powder it's used when you put it in too hot and it liquefies into a liquid do we say it's considered a double laughs because it's used as a lot or maybe now when you put it in it is your vase then Africa mean is could you put coffee into a clear Eastern can you put salt into a Hot Chelle that's off the fire so they didn't have instant coffee at tea but they had salt that sugar and the sherry to mention your dress if cotton club crest and the master shekel more specifically if cotton lime and olive says that since it's used as a liquid we treat sugar and salt as a liquid even though and in this moment you're putting it in it's a dry food but it's used as a liquid it's considered a liquid the mr. brewer and see if cotton iein olive seems to be freshest for this look in the shower etsion that any power that liquefies is considered a double lock there are some that I make oh and they say wait a minute I put it when I did the mice quote the mice official whatever it was putting it in it's a it was a dummy evasion but we could say that the mr. Brewer is maximum and that's why to add salt into a Cleary shine even if the salt was previously cooked which some salt in America was previously cooked but since it liquefies it's like a liquid yay special artificial by a devala generally this doesn't pose a problem regarding coffee and tea because no one takes coffee and puts it into a Cleary sign we are very firm we put the cup we put the water into one cup and one cup into a second cup so the second cup in our lobster is a clean solution the urn is clear we shine first Cup is cliche nee second cup is qcc so definitely definitely there's no problem of adding coffee or tea or sugar for that matter into a cliche and theoretically I mean technically say even a cliche nee the first cup once it's in a cliche nee we could assumed aim beshallach official and especially you could rely on those that hold it's considered a wh question it sounds as no science in stylistic if it's very much scientists I will sue you someone had a chunk of silver dated either one on a fire and the fire was extinguished the wind whatever now he has a hot bowl of cholent or soup that's there's no fire orphan he noticed it when the soup has considerably cooled off is there any a table to serve the soup Friday night so the question is can I take the soup and put it on to a neighbor's bless let's say you have a neighbor with an A or whatever we're down says upstairs whatever the case is we allow to carry Clara you're taking from a blip and putting it back onto someone else's a black eye under your black there's no fire there's no H but you didn't take off the pack you didn't close the fire so the place can say you could rely on that that there's no Zarah because you made a fire before service so there's no problem moving it from your left to your neighbors clan but here we have to worry what is the what is the temperature of the soup if the soup is no longer yatzee let this boy because it was the fire one half an hour ago so if aspired them you can't put it on to a different blood because the a special exhibition of the devala but for their asking a zipper there are morphs as long as it's long and it's found on the garment you could take the soup put it on to someone's bleph directly on to the fire if need be and bring it up to a high temperature i should mention you don't have to run to a neighbor if you have an oven that's on you could take the hot pot of soup the blame is down and pot of soup and put it into the oven because for all practical purposes it's the same hepa may h the age and line its town and Lagonda people often ask this question they make the baby battle those days though they're still making it remember but they basically take hot water and you add baby the the formula and you serve it to the baby but the baby didn't want to take it so you don't want it to get spoiled you put it into the refrigerator now you have a cold bottle you want to serve the child you can serve in my a cold bottle so there's a very simple 8 sup you put the bottle into a shizzle and take the kettle and pour the hot water onto the baby bottle that in the most eerie is my bachelor cuz they khlifa it will maybe warm the bottle cook the bottle but it will not cook the intent they dig the contents the milk inside so it's going to rewarm it but it won't cook it if you that doesn't work there's another 8 sup you could take the bottle put hot water from the urn from the kettle into a cup sisal that's dry now you could we warm the bottle by putting it into that cliche knee water why is it multi the bottle the milk is totally cold from the fridge but the milk is made up of water and water does not gets cooked in the crease so to rewarm a bottle you could put it either into a cliche knee or pour it on from a kettle to totally immerse the bottle into a sisal where the bottle is totally underwater that would be a problem about tomorrow but basically this is the aside next case which is also out very much a low sodium and that is the use of tea essence on Shabbos tea sense so basically tea sense you pour water on two tea bags and then generally the water the tea sense gets cold so the mr. Brewer and Steve Karlin but des is concerned about this you're gonna pour this into hot water it's the question of the official last official why is the official official very possible because the tea essence completely cold it's found on the camry and now there's a question the official official so the mr. Bourg recommends what people have this many fedoras you make the tea essence in a china canned a small metal container and keep that shining on the black keep it warm as long as it's warm somewhat ain't boishakh official so you could do what you want with that tea essence what I want to mention is we keep on saying that the tea was cooked before Shabbos it's very possible that our China believe it or not with the essence was never cooked what do I mean many people typically take hot water put it into that China that's their metal container and then they put the tea bags into that what's the status of that quote cooked tea essence the Chinese already cliche me right so hallelujah Cugini can't cook so the tea essence was never cooked illogically the only thing is you want to say that we'll consider a tea bag to consider Kali official so County officials does get cooked in a cliche you see Lorelai and Kali abyssal in this case as a cooler so it's much better to if you use that China take the China k-- afterwards after you put the tea bags in and put on to the fire then when you put it on to the fight it cooks before Shabbos because it's on a clear each then it's already on the fire then you could add that the essence as you like let's say someone has a cup of coffee a cup of tea and he made it to mahajan minute Mahajan he wants to add milk to the coffee or lemon juice to the T so la jolla this is a prom official but the good news is that our milk at least currently I'll soon see why I say that but our milk is pasteurized our lemon juice is pasteurized if so ain't pasteurized reaches a temperature approximately 160 degrees 160 degrees is yacht's ìletís point so we'll say coffee the milk and and lemon juice is already previously cooked and bissalameh' Bishop the problem is the night to be who the in the dresses in Jerusalem but Volvo writes very emphatically adding milk to a hot coffee is a shot of Cielo because it's a question of Bishop now why is that I do the so concerned about milk the terrace is the pasta Terrace is his milk was not pasteurized so it's regular Bishop but then again our milk or our lemon juice that was pastor I should be mother but wait a second where do you take milk from with lemon juice from the refrigerator it's is this an its town on the gambling so our milk and lemon juice would be like the night of you with is milk yes miss Eliza Bishop McDevitt laugh so the possible head to which today is the mini Kamat we make coffee we use two cups so you're adding a milk into a cliche see after the anime you have nothing to worry about yes LOX abyssal but not by a cliche see the truth is even adding it to a cliche need as long as we understand that milk is not a Calais abyssal what's the problem and the emesis there's a rapture on earth in in senior class see your days the Rav says just like whatever not Kalia Bissell who are then any liquid is not Kalia Bissell according to this Rob you could add milk never uncooked milk into a cliche the problem is the Navy who that says milk is a sea of hot dose he held its only water or oil that's not Kalia Bissell other liquids are collie abyssal so a very beautiful - in the case of a Forte the gimbals in the mem that explains this the question if other liquids milk lemon juice our County official or not is a mock like is the RAB and the noid the biota but your voice say our milk and lemon juice la santa is already cooked so it's only question of the age special officials you can add it to a cliche she our hot tea coffee generally the cliche she and there's really no problem someone wants to be maker with a cliche knee yes show me miss me I keep on saying that our milk giveaways actor is pasteurized because they're implementing a new method of pasteurization is called irradiation with a pasteurized without any heat of course everything is to save money but there is a a technique of irradiation that pasteurized without any heat at all so when that will be typical in milks so the milk will be will be mohnish like a regular liquid that was never cooked and we'll have to reassess what the procedure is someone had a Morita cane felt I say that with quotation marks he likes to have freshly squeezed lemon on Chavez how do you have lemon on Chavez he squeezes a lemon on to sugar and add it to his tea which the mr. Brewer recognizes it as a solution but I asked the wait a minute you that lemon was never cooked that's a fresh lemon yeah but since the Hector of squeezing lemon onto sugar is habala ISIL cocoa so it's like a nautical ain't Alaska Bishop I said wait a minute there are two mistakes there first of all it's not it doesn't become Macias that the lemon juice is an oil it's merges with an article but more so even the sugar is not so posh that's annoying for the sugar is a soluble so he made two mistakes maybe I could be Mama's course anus to how ELISA so the whole thing was wrong but certainly that's it's only a healthy regarding Sita but certainly the lemon juice has never cooked that's a very serious problem of Bishop question someone had asked this question he wants to he's noticed at Shaolin smells like an easy issue its its drying it's burning so he's a very firm / sales what he's doing he takes the or takes off the cover from the cello that's all the steam the vapor dissipate then he takes the chill and Pat brings it to the urn and he adds hot water to the cholans pot or he pours from the kettle into the cello part Macari that should be no problem why because there's no problem making the kennel Flay shakes because he let the steam dissipate and he's taking water from a clearly shine urn or kettle and he's putting it into Cleary's and Schoelen pot but here we come to another application of our tsuki believe it or not a typical urn reaches a temperature of on your 1670 even a kettle if it's not mamas on the fire it's on the side of the black also reaches that temperature but not much more when you pour the water that's 160 170 from the urna kettle into a solid and the tones are gobby-o h the water now will reach a temperature of boiling which is 212 so here we have unto interesting Shila bringing water that is one that's 160 170 which is beyond Godzilla that's true but bringing up to a temperature of 212 is that a problem official on Chavez so a moisture in the Fela dhalsim annoying galaxy if cotton alef says one something is Vishal of Yahtzee let this boy more than that is not disel and it brings an unbelievable ride mal Vasuki because the rav shuffle Nara writes and show your classic test that for smarty as long as the liquid is Yahtzee let this boy you allow to warm it and wasn't that the only problem was for the muhabba be a special exhibition is when it dipped below Yahtzee lettuce but from Yahtzee lettuce to boiling is immortal holidays circulation what do you see from this once at the axle a display ain't boishakh official the Oz mid grew and test you Dallas as a cloud Bissell is the answer that despite more than that is just improvement but the men can see it suck inhaler good sim caucus as many other place Kim say wait a minute that's not true there is a certain type of tea that's hot that's about this boy but a boiling tea has a whole different flavor hold if English maca now by Yasha quoted the oysters a Shabbos writes that this question from bringing from Yahtzee ladders to boiling you're talking about a difference of sick could be a difference of fifty degrees this is why in this bar but pies given we have to be maxima so here we have an interesting question bringing it from yotsuba this to boiling is that Bissell now what sort of miser who could be my Korean these could only apply skim but let me tell you what people have on a weekly basis I think it's again amid Salaf arson many people still use a kettle now Friday night this soup chicken on the fire you can't keep the kettle on the fight you keep it on the side but Friday night you want a nice hot cup of tea so you take the kettle put it onto the fire leave it a few minutes you bring it to boil and you have a cup of tea now we see it's not so posh it but there's a very simple eight so for that question before Shabbos when you boil the water boil it literally keep it until it reaches a boiling point then you could put it on the side of the block and keep it hot that is mortal holidays why because that water reached boiling temperature that ain't boishakh official holidays even though now it's only a suit like this boy but that's motive might them ha and this'll a dorama so boil the water before Shabbos and then you could bring up the temperature at your liking as far as adding hot water from the urn so some urns they fluctuate but if the urn at any point reached a temperature of boiling then its motor to edit the holidays next important question is we speak about two categories there's a w of H and the guevara what is the status of mayonnaise ketchup margarine congealed gravy so one thing is push it every food has a little my closest that's considered of a elvish another thing is push it and relation says is in the children and it's actually earlier PI scheme as well merchants embassies cotton Zion of that chuhwa but if you have chicken and gravy so the chicken is WH but the gravy stuff a lot and helps us brought this it's one food it could be tougher but has no scientists if you have a discernible amount of Rick woods so the liquid is double mass and the chickens that we average so you could rewarm the chicken but not the gravy moisture in that chuhwa was asked regarding ketchup with the shale felt that ketchup since it's so thick it's considered a duffy evasion sir muddy she says then i think that chicken that i'm sorry that the ketchup the criteria to decide if it's laughs or your vase is when you put it on to a plate does it continue to pour or does it just sit in one place lamar so if you put a sticker mod on a plate it doesn't pour but if you put ketchup on a plate it continues to roll it runs it pause so if Myesha says that he could feels that ketchup is considered a double line then i looked into a little further reps name is solomon MRI shabbos kayla calif mix of olive olive he says american finished he says ketchup is cooked tomatoes tomato we all consider wh ID is the juice inside but a tomato is every Amish ketchup is just a transformed tomato and wh Rep slain yes daba daba llaves now by Yossef in the same our Sabbath para glove I see a giant has an even bigger finish and he says that really a fool a liquid that was cooked and called lost assemble but the disel of ketchup makes it ketchup ketchup tastes the same with it's cold if it's hot then you know it's still it's still ketchup so if the fact that it was cooked didn't lose the same cooking and therefore you treat it like awh ain't bissalameh' bristle so that means and I've said mention of slim the Salman himself in slam you see your crest in the harem M Zion about him he says the second cooking of ketchup doesn't make it any better so for that reasonably Mazama Yasha felt that a ketchup is considered a dove the elvish so let's put this Lamesa to take someone wants to spice up the kin his chalant he takes the Champa off the fire he adds ketchup into the hot steaming cholent light of Ayasha primers ominous motor it's comfy evasion laughs abyssal Micronesia that's the problem this is a double life yes Oaxaca bishop but if you want to have your ketchup your challenge there's a simple later take the shell and and pour it into a serving bowl mix the child and then you could serve it Kizuna hey one thing I will mention red moisture inhaling down ironed out if cotton Hey he says to put ketchup on to a hot steaming piece of meat is also mutton I dove agar she's like a Cleary shine some races here we have two summers that overlap first of all the clear Eastern is a muscle a kiss at my skin and number two even though ketchup is a govern but it's only a former age Alaska by devil alkylation the she toss thing so if you have two covers overlap you could be Mako so you could put ketchup on too hot potato hot meat the holidays butter or margarine is interesting because butter or margarine now please don't put butter man you don't of course I'm talking about on crazy I have a hot pair I shall show this during the summer but butter and margarine are right now are definitely a salad I mean a congealed salad but it it's when you add it to a hot food it becomes a liquid so the question how do we look at a butter or margarine so the Morgan I promise if cutting them is clear that he's talking about this congealed food in Fonda whatever it is like type of a kugel that has a congealed part of it he says it's considered a wh because when you're doing the miser of putting it up near the fire its salad so according to the mug on a drum and the mr. Brewer chief cotton cuff and has initial ins that lines my emblem assigned your Pascal's like this butter margarine congealed food is considered a Davidovich though paths if cut and off to the woods if cotton test Bob insists that's not true because when it falls apart when it liquefies it's a liquid so basically we definitely have worth to be say makanda since the mr. Brewers make oh but one thing I will say and I saw this in the earth casabas on the test verb and I think is very missed Avram if you have cold soup when you put in refrigerator it's sort of hardens that's not considered of the others why because you don't use it in that state and I save Araya imagine this iron fell imagine I take boiling water I put it into the freezer and I make ice cubes so I'll say ain't bish last official by wh Ice Cube's a salad but that's ridiculous why because you're using it in its liquid form so when something is congealed la muscle perch on we use it as a a a salad even though it's only congealed that's the malaika's mugging of rum and time next group of questions where the Schuyler is where someone had a good cup of coffee or tea and hit the spot he wants to have a second cup of coffee or tea so he wants to use the same mug same cup and pour hot water into that cup the problem is the droplets of the previous tea are totally cold have this time of the Garbi or a bigger question where someone used a that someone previously used what was rinsed so the cup has droplets of uncooked rinsing water that was never cooked so this is really part of a difference she as well see because it has a whole different twist to it but basically ramesha and seed cotton your tests makes a pasta silica my mother says that if the tea has droplets of a previous tea me it could add in there's no more laying like a bishop at the Villa so you could be makos to add water to that because the tea was previously cooked it's only a homer up so he says but in this case there are others tell them to be make up now the truth is that's part of a difference here but really and not much haven't to cook those droplets it's very little and it's only an evilly from a Cleary shine sir moisture says to pour hot water onto droplets that were never cooked that's bishop the port on the droplet that water cooked there is what to be same occur the men cause it's like insists that this should not be done you should dry even a previously used tea but some are make especially if you shake out the cup all you're left with is my emissions or something that's a microscopic that's part of a different to help to do maybe next month but basically the excited of it is when you have droplets disability if the droplets were ever cooked or never cooked the same question is when you reuse a ladle for serving soup of like if there are droplets of soup that were previously cooked the Clara it's miss Panama Gondry but this case a little worse because the later is going back into a clear reason and Cleary showing is more of a problem of Rio Bissell the urn with the indicator level you open the spigot and the water level drops so those urns are a big problem because the water level that drops it's not magical the water level that drops when the water is consumed goes back into the original urn that's the Mitzi's doesn't fly out so this is getting part of the second the next year hope to do maybe next month already but basically if you haven't earned that the spigot the water indicator level was once called even though with cool can school considerably then we have the basic header of eh aim dish life abyssal by a governor shall lighting its fan and Lagaan we ask when club limits feel something that's absolutely beautiful the question we began with someone had soup he forgot to we won't make before Shabbos now he has a problem but listen to his I felt he's a very aggressive London he will take the soup take the cold soup from the refrigerator and put it next to the radiator or during the summer put it outside in the Sun what's he doing he's going to make it slightly lukewarm then he'll take the soup and put it on top of a cello part and make it steaming hot hi what are you doing well it was later found the guy me ain't vishal official so the Emmis is it doesn't sound right but then again why not so the truth is if you go with this I have a better idea why do you have to work so hard take the soup out of the refrigerator put it on top of the shawl and pass a bunch low though I know what I'm doing give me a minute I'm only gonna make it Lyon it's donal economy and then I'll let it go because once its finest an ambitious official that that really doesn't sound kosher but why not but I make it mortgage smack the morgan afro-eurasian and gimble sees caught in their mouth discussed the following question he's pouring hot water from an from an urn from a kettle onto a plate that's third he wants to wash dishes on Shabbos but there's a there's a layer of congealed gravy on the plate so the monodrama said you can't pull hot water on to the congealed gravy because it's Moylan you were changing the gravy the solid to a liquid frag the halyard give a go on the page you worrying about morality rabona this is victuals their eyes but listener be keeping a good eye go anus the first pour of water makes the congealed gravy into a liquid right it makes it into it a lot the second pour is cooking - what's the Hector sir please say this is mama shall be Shilo I became a and room key Vega hold it the problem but the Magana dramas Mako abiquiu egg is makeup will soon see why so now we have a double problem what's wrong with our two-step process making it when it's fine and then Bissell and if it is wrong why is it motive give a good case to pour hot water on to conceal gravy so let me tell you civil city nav system was worth coming just for this your site what stock to the shot why units down in the Gamma is mutton I am Bissell it doesn't find on the map doesn't count the terrorists like we explained earlier if it's light its time and the original Bissell is still noticeable this hair ain't Alaska may look this or I think of JPEG it means to sing if you take water and pour it onto congealed gravy this gravy is a govern your vase W of age the first Bissell is still here and Eliza Bishop I love you so you pour water onto it is perfectly motor now that a liquefied it's lighter motor why because the first Bissell is here and it's still warm Masha Inc in our case you took out soup from the refrigerator and you put it next to the radiator it's lying if sinulog army Mazel Tov fine now what do you want to do sligon it's fine I want to put it on top of the the pot wait a second the first Bissell is totally gone even though you may just feel with my unit stand on the gummy right because that's not that Bissell the first business gone what do you want to do you want to make a new Bissell yes miss Alaska Bissell it's only when it's the silent evacuate this makeup and the RV nays and cook contest is the exact same your site what bothered me to no end after this golden alumnus of Cahuenga says about Dianne serafian he throws a monkey wrench why then saw him solely be Emily maybe the PID is because since the congealed gravy is used as a and whatever that case when you little heat it it becomes a lot maybe it's like powder but one thing I will say for our hot soup that you need an eight so I'll tell you to eight system concern 180 I saw that scene in Lambeth gimel and Elsa Shabbos Mashav espresso over 111 say take the soup out of the refrigerator and you'll have to put it into a place where it will get below yotsuba display you lot of warm it but not to cook it I we don't usually put something where it could get cooked but in this case since really ambitious official is mutter making it in its only a home run you could be makeup to do it until you get the art scene like this using we don't do that when it comes to visual manage but this is not visual mamas you could do it Midway to take out the chill to make it look 1 and the second date switch to be a look and the integration and gimel says you can have a good actually we warm it are you care of a guy cook on Chavez but here will say that really ambitious lots of issues with double my it's only a home run the mock inside if you can rely on this I go to talk to you or shame here you shirt I like give a big issue characters miss for today's shared dismissal says seek remove today shoe in five minutes if I'm not even a cashier months ago Kazakh success oil figure here but I nutrition I mother knock off a cement safety goggles area [Music] [Applause] [Music] whether they said sure [Music] everyone please take your coffees and all other liquids then we'll have a cecum of the liquids and Shabbos take a few minutes just a short summary learn tape as I said one thing is closer than a mission to buy a wh buy a dry food ain't miss Alaska Bissell once it was cooked the understanding is that the food is cooked the chicken is cooked you can no longer be cook something that's cooked it's a Macias that ain't Bissell artificial there is no subsequent Bissell of course you have to make sure not to put it on to a fire that's the itself Hazara putting onto a black flag onto a fire but basically allowed to rewarm a cooked food as long as it no it's off Hazara when it comes to a laughs all agree that by allah said it's done and lagari both the muhabba under am all agree that there's an issue of bissell the question is like Mohabbatein is that ERISA like their mark could be the rice that could be their opponent but basically even though there are some hold a business official entirely by a lock but we are fascia CH bissell akka Bissell so to rewarm a cold soup is also the holidays if it's natural mac must coming musa if it's still considered hot it's still passable or be into the oven so for the spire them macabre sheath is still yes Vishal my official as long if it's not God so lettuce buddy nowadays then once it's now called Marcus come EMU say the Roger says that Lawson then it's considered hot and aimed Basilica Bishop to rewarm cold Canella kreplach is okay as long as no Hazara Luxan that has uncooked water either you could dry the water but much easier than to put the election in to put the soup into a cliche knee into a serving bowl and put the locks in there and then serve it a there's always a little bit of natural last Lucas that doesn't count that's really part of the food the definition of Lena Steinem the Camry is Nehemiah's kami Musa because then the original Bissell is still functional to pour soup into her into the leftover soup in the child is not a prime official it's a problem of Hazara the poor leftover soup into the hot soup then that's not--that's not hysterical off the fire and then then there's no problem official as long as the soup is still learning it Stan and the Camry by a light buy a piece of metal like any type of scenario where the vishal is not cooking it but making it glowing so by a piece of metal yay special exhibition so putting on a light on choppers of course is awesome powder coffee tea sugar assault is questionable as if it's considered a wh because now it's dry but it turns into a liquify is it soluble someplace we treat it as a double life but today we have cups of different cups but coffee you want to cup two cups so violet smooth there's no problem to move a soup when the fire went out if it's laying its tannin Megami this and there's no history of kisara there's no it's official we're warming a baby bottle you could immerse it into hot water or pour hot water onto it as long as noticed about Amana that's fine tea essence should be kept a gobby age or close to the age to keep it still laying its down on the gallery or better yet would be to cook it before Shabbos entirely and then you have a stand on the camera you can add it even to a hot cup of tea adding milk and lemon juice if it's pasteurized then ain't bitter life official it's only a home run but you continually add to a cliche knee if whenever they start using milk that was not pasteurized so then it's a serious problem if it's could be going tonight who the question of Kali official and you will not be able to add had a cold milk that was not pasteurized even to a cliche knee so then when you have two cups that would be they had to lemon juice on the sugar cannot be added to hot tea because the lemon juice was never cooked a hot water to add hot water to a dry cholent is okay if the hot water once reached boiling temperature the eight of the four chávez's you move to boil the water in the kettle to a boiling point then you could move it on to the fire off the fire as long as it once reached a boiling point its aim like a to the holiday is once it was totally boiling then you could bring it from God said let this boy up to boiling ketchup is malaika's a poison if it's considered logical of age but practically you could add up to a hot food and you could edit to a cliche knee so basically is not much of a feeling butter or margarine or congealed food is considered a w of H to pour a cup pour hot water into a cup of uncooked droplets should not be done to pour into previously cooked droplets from a previous tea is there a different sheet this it's gonna be possible to drive to dry it but if not the summer may go the best 8/2 Greta would be to put the hot water into a cup and then pour it onto the droplets that's not to even uncooked droplets because the water it cannot be cooked in a cliche knee to put a ladle back into a soup pot if it's letting it stand on the garment is fine the water indicate indicator level is an issue hopefully talk about it differently more viruses but basically soup that was left in the refrigerator you can tree warm it on two steps because that's the problem of Yage beshallach abyssal the 8c is either to put it to a place that it could reach passable temperatures but not yachts ìletís bite or have a guy put it onto the black on top of site blog to rewarm it not on the block that kaiser but three warmer on chances okay