Manipulating the Calendar? - Gemarah Rosh Hashanah 20a-20b

the yeshiva dotnet so right before the half Amidala threat before the wide lines the last line of the now reminds the line begins on my Mahalo linen to you've done okay suck the good Mario it'll be a lot of music today how low is glad to we're gonna learn about the sky - and I'll celebrate your side dish okay so now the gomora continues and tells a story after the previous sukiya we learnt about other first out there and the second order how many days they were and how it worked so now the Gemara tells the following story he us Allah when Allah arrived what does it mean when Allah arrived who arrived from air to Cyril he arrived to bubble to Babylonia although was one of them Iranian who would often travel from air to stroll to bhavo and he was one of the people who would therefore transfer transmit the traditions Colossus that they taught in a tea stall to the Shiva Sambhav oh so when Allah once came to bubble Omar he said abu allah ello you should know that the best dinner Nightsister all the son had written made ll 30 days now we learned before that rafts that from the days of Ezra limits in Olo müber that's arab-speaking till this time hula lives after Alf and he says I want you to know that this year besten made ll 30 days Emilie's Moberg he notifies them Amarula on Ola said yah be covered in Buffalo MIT versa of de nada you to our friends in Bothell and Babylonia even know what good we did for them by the fact that we postponed ll for another day and hence Rosh Hashanah was delayed instead of Rosh Hashanah being day 30 it becomes day 31 do they even know our Havana man Bravo mighty Vasa I told him the news but they don't need they might may not even understand the benefit of it well what's what's what's the Havanna here so toy Service says the first toy service on copper metal might've was a sham my Abra mellow in other words they were complaining they were complaining about why my Tivo system Abra mellow the month of July yeah broke additionally a tray I mean me suffered remember for the blame of all that would have been this marker if they could know that L is not moreover L was always 29 days and therefore they don't have to do two days Rosh Hashana miss Suffolk they don't have a Suffolk if alo becomes could become 30 days then they have to do two days miss suffered according to Rashi they'll all do with the wrong day because they don't know what it is so their formats have their perspective it's much better if they know ll is not mobile suddenly all the says we did you a tremendous favor you don't even know what a favor it was stop criticizing it why something where my Tivo what's the favor what's the favor what no that's what I said Rav said that from Ezra till his time mellows number but this is after that yeah of course before that the elbow wasn't no band he's telling a fact he's kicked above all and he's at this year I was mobile my Tivo so what's the favor mullah omar Allah says Isaiah the faith mission we are kaya for the vegetables what's the issue with the vegetables so let's see - a yogi hovering above Lloyd seen a she middle of the page kolima nice then lave Oaxaca Aisha is cinnamon a exersaucer brew a salad do they have anise in a sleeve do they focus their heart to recognize to be marker time to recognize the goodness that the people of register albany exalt did for them by making ello one more day what's the issue Allah says er kaya vegetables so crashy well halfred Shabbos reiatives Ebenezer to separate Chavez hang up the phone from the other Kadesh Allah is moisture uroko-sama Hollis Shane Zion Bashar Bashar yontiff I beyond of chakra Shabbos in order that the vegetables that are being eaten when they are raw on Shabbos that comes after Yom Tov or yom tov that comes after Shabbos shouldn't experience Kamisha they shouldn't be decomposed and wrapped in and decadent so what is always say yeah let's say Rosh Hashanah was supposed to be Wednesday let's say in other words lol is 29 days I love Tishrei supposed to be Wednesday cuffed SL is supposed to be Tuesday if fresh Hashanah is Wednesday automatically when is him kippers going to be Friday right that's my point that's my point that's exactly my point it would have been if Emma was 29 days Rosh Hashana would be Wednesday right I love tisha will be Wednesday so Hester say would be Wednesday right eight days later test issue would be Thursday you to say em kipper would be Friday if your kipper would be Friday now you want to eat vegetables on Shabbos when do you harvest these vegetables you can't harvest them Friday Fridays in a little harmless not Friday afternoon not Friday morning not Thursday night you have to harvest them Thursday right not like a regular Arif shops so now the vegetables stay out Thursday night they stay out Friday no refrigeration at this point they of course stay out Friday night now Shabbos you want to eat them and they're rotten they're decadent this is a fish Hashanah was Wednesday by postponing Rosh Hashanah making Wednesday the 30th of lol and wishes Shawn is Thursday so now everything is it then later so it's not a problem if kippers gonna be on Shabbos so therefore it caught your vegetables on Friday you're good I mean you can't eat Shabbos anyway but sorry Shabbos what did you not get the information before hula is coming in standing there mean we did it when is Kevin is coming he started the day after ocean we're talking about the communities in bubble where they had the ready the messengers before Yom Kippur and before circus before um kept him before circus yeah yeah you're right with the slaughter of Basden come to the bubble and tell them what happened before Yom Kippur and before circus right in other words that it was pushed off by a day they have a tremendous benefit this is what all the said mission our Chi [Applause] so this actually says yump different shoppers shouldn't be together so if it was supposed to be Friday it gets postponed to Shabbos if it was supposed to be Sunday which would be the same problem they guests respond to Monday so you have a break in between and you can harvest your vegetables the day before for the other holidays right no but for Shabbos after Yom Kippur if you keep as far as your son is Wednesday and kippers Friday what are you gonna do you can harvest it on Friday you can average that Thursday night your vegetables are gonna be wrapped the baka baka Minami baka baka nice s mature Messiah the benefit is for the dead again if fresh Hashanah is Wednesday Jim Kipp is gonna be Friday if you Kippur wouldn't be Friday somebody passes away on Shabbos you bury him it's a Shabbos not a problem okay if somebody passes away on Friday you bury him on Friday when you have um Kippur coming before Shabbos William Kippur coming after Shabbos so what's your problem your problem is the person passes away Thursday night usually you would do a live eye on Friday even Friday night you can do all over I am it's re Shabbos Korea matter Shabbos but here Thursday night you can do it Friday you can do it Friday night you can do it I obviously can't do it you're leaving the maze for two days he's gonna rap he's gonna decompose so therefore if you make L oh one more day Yom Kippur is delayed by a day so instead of yom kippur being friday let's hear if your son was supposed to be wednesday made Rosh Hashana Thursday so instead of him killed being Friday if it becomes Shabbos somebody dies on Friday or Thursday night he's buried on Friday somebody dies Friday night you just leaving him one day leaving him Travis my sorry Shabbos you burying him you don't have two days of delaying the corpse of being buried that's what Ibaka says all the said vegetables Rebecca said Messiah Rashi says Messiah Lahav Shabbos video market problems amnesia two separate Shabbos on Yom Kippur solo yes Reformation was very hard man a mace that dies in one of the two days Shabbos oh um Kippur keep his Sunday or him keep his Friday and Mays dies in one of them she hey we should the logic of rely on Berlin Moscow he dies whichever one is first if he dies on the second day then I don't mind if he dies on Shabbos him keep his Friday so it's like any shops right about Missy d'Artagnan Kippy died Friday morning or Thursday night and now you're delaying it solo you cover liya he won't be buried today meaning Friday valet the market not Shabbos yes the way they're still midsize shop isn't the mace good run okay clear render your mother might be knife what's the difference between the two reasons sounds like all learn and and about arguing if first Shauna was supposed to be on Wednesday and they delayed it to be on Thursday what's the difference between the two reasons my man I love my enough commitment stammen argument both reasons a good reason he said there is an argument why you in Kippur the holiest after ashrams if recession is Wednesday you're right there's no argument they both agree because there is your son is Wednesday so then Yom Kippur is when Friday they're keeping us Friday have a problem with vegetables and you're a problem with Mason what's your problem with vegetables you want any vegetable on sharp as you can't cut them on Friday night it seemed kipper happy Martin I the Shabbos you can't cut them Thursday night at 7:00 kipper you have to cut them on Thursday and you have to leave them for Thursday night Friday and Shabbos and therefore it's gonna get ruined ok the same problem is with a mace but what about if you kipper something in other words or Shoshanna is Friday your son was supposed to be Friday lol is 29 days last day of ebiz Thursday your son is gonna be Friday but Shawna's Friday so past history is gonna be Friday and test is gonna be Shabbos and your there's gonna be sunny and Kimmy's gonna be Sunday here is gonna be a difference what's gonna be the difference mondo mama show Messiah the world who says her back who says the rain reason is because the dead mob Rima Basden will say we gotta add a day to Ella why because if we're gonna leave rich the Sun on Friday and we're not gonna delay it to Shabbos Yom Kippur is gonna be Sunday and the Mason are going to get embarrassed and denigrated but mondawmin me show me our kiyah but although maintains that the primary he's in his vegetables he's gonna say what's the problem Jim Kipp is gonna be Sunday okay so what's the issue your issue is he gonna leave your vegetables for two days but for Shabbos yeah vegetables cuz he cut them Friday Friday is a regular day right so for Shabbos you have fresh vegetables it's not two days on your problem is Sunday your vegetables are gonna be wrapped in scissors the Amos Cabello when do you need the vegetables to be fresh Laurita at night Sunday night when the fast finishes lorta at night para mi see who exert himself not the most comfortable situation it's dark before Thomas Edison you have to go harvest your vegetables Academy but it's not it's not a major player you're not starving am I so you bring vegetables you'll go cluck the vegetables you'll harvest the vegetables and you'll bring them why do you have to add another day tell that would be enough commander practically that's why there's an argument there's an argument if recession is supposed to be Wednesday they both agree not good for making it Thursday but efficient Shawn is supposed to be Friday according to their one opinion may SIA Friday's not good why Jim Kipp is gonna be something we have a problem so we have to delay it is your son at the Shabbos according to the City of York is in session and people will be Sunday you'll cut the vegetables Friday my beautiful vegetables on Shabbos Sunday don't rap you don't need vegetables for Sunday your fasting look if it's a fast day at night you'll go get your vegetables yeah let's say you're responsible I'd say still could have the situation we've had - they jumped in the Shabbos yeah things like that Pesach well it wasn't a problem because yom tov shana shall go Leah's they let them marry right so it was no problem and even the first day of Yom Tov you could bury through a non-jew Shabbos on Yom Kippur not as we'll see in a moment we sat the vegetables eat a Venetian ah yeah we're gonna discuss it we're gonna discuss it yeah yeah well not they didn't have shiver they had a small shiver something very short yeah yeah yeah stop know if the person dies out of him Kip it's not a problem if you have Kippur is Sunday if you Kippur is Friday and the person dies on Thursday it's fine problem isn't the person died on Thursday night or Friday morning so usually you would bury him yeah same day well you can't seem Kippur so what do you do you want to pay the next day the next night its tapas so when do you have to do the la vie a with Sambas without freezers that they have in the morgues today the mace is gonna decompose they wrapped they didn't want that this was a this was a common thing this wasn't tips are if you keep us on shop as it's not a problem is just like Shabbos the problem is of Yom Kippur is on Friday and kippers on Sunday so you have a two days stretch we don't care for holidays on shops that's fine that's one day the problem is the day before the day after you understand yeah Frank the Gemara okay so we have an argument if him kippers after Shabbos if you Kippur would be after Shabbos would we delayed Rosh Hashanah Messiah would say yeah your Chi you would say no hug to your mother but I don't understand l'amanda are my master miracle a blemish on Messiah even the man who holds that it was done for vegetables he also understands the logic of masive so he should also say if um kippers gonna be on Sunday you have to delay Rosh Hashanah by a day for the mace why would all argue with that nobody dies the sivadas are smarter you're telling me one who holds min-suk vegetables would not make ello 30 days in a situation where as your son is supposed to be Friday because he doesn't care if your kid prayers on Sunday it doesn't bother him because the only issue is vegetables you not feed on Yom Kippur fine but why is he not worried about me some may say why would he disagree you trying to explain the hillock of the two sisters why would he disagree with the second shift there's still a problem of mason and therefore yom kippur should be delayed by a day make rashon on Shabbos so your Kippur won't be Sunday of kid will be Monday so if somebody dies on Shabbos you can three immature shoppers somebody dies on Sunday you burying my son's if somebody dies on Monday because it kept very a Monday night well first we wanted to bring out the practical and - come in in between the two his standing Africa min that he says there is enough come in and they would argue in a situation with his son is supposed to be Friday he'll say leave it and he'll say don't leave it he says why would he disagree with him on this yeah in other words it could be their stump saying two different reasons they completely agree and I says what's the point to say there's two reasons you want to say this a hillock what would be the pillar you always want to see how local am I so to see what's the real difference when it comes down practically you could see what the difference is if not it's time abstract so the Gemara wants to know my benign who cares yak I am a sci-fi is there a difference yeah there's a major difference and situation is your son is Friday we should show no Wednesday I'll both agreed to delay in a day just on the Friday no way there'll be an argument he says the white Hawk very good more white Duncan and therefore the governor rejects this hillock the Kamala says you're right this is a strong argument today there's no reason to disagree he will agree yet it's ugly sight and I'm inside their climate son Messiah neck and we'll see right now okay you saying that it's a question there's a famous question in Raynham if rebou Acamas Makaha a ho cerebral echoes malaria commas if quantity Trump's quality or quality Trump's quantities you saying Mitsuru ruckus it's an issue of the masses nobody's gonna have what to eat right but it's vegetables they can maybe eat something else won't be so good smack my second Messiah is not affecting everybody it's affecting those individuals but it's a serious thing that the mace is gonna decompose is gonna run as a serious thing so that's the question what's the what's the that goofily very good you say saying what's the swatter writers and the commo summits of ales the child is my bay niala my enough come in it would seem that they both know in others it would seem that there's no mouth come in who knows is there a difference because Lamoille both don't want you keep and shoppers to be together near each other fine but might be now you if we're both agreeing that you kipper and shoppers should not follow each other so mine of kameena we both agree you say that the result is the same let's do come on this boy very good you're right that's what the come on say the result is not gonna be the same but now the come on is asking another shine why would Annie hold of them sorry miss fine but what you're right it's only a few people but it's light a very serious trash it's lighter why not why would he not care about your telling me that he holds that commerce is more important than a house but doesn't mean it doesn't mean anything it should mean something that's the shot so the mothers gonna say talk of something else well it could be night the reasonable way to do it as different the difference is as follows young how some of the Shabbos I'm sorry auntie for some of the Shabbos Beimel phenomenal aha if it's the young tip of Rosh Hashanah that comes out near Shabbos weather before sharpest or after Shabbos mr. Sun is on a Friday or a Shoshone is on Sunday now remember a Clow mr. Sun is on Friday um Kip is gonna be Sunday where Shoshanna is on Wednesday and Kip is gonna be Friday and kibbutz is always two days after a shoe shop the first day of so cos is always gonna be the first day of Rosh Hashana at the same time so fish' shun is on a Friday the first day of circus is on a Friday where Sun is on a Sunday the first day of cook is on a Sunday so you have against Shabbos in yontiff right near each other he says that's gonna be the difference Monda my mission we are Chaya the one who says it's a vegetable Mabini he says he have to delay dushashana by a day why if Russia shun is let's say supposed to be Sunday ll 29 is Shabbos day 30 is Sunday what's gonna happen what's gonna happen Yom Kippur I'm not worried about the ins gonna be on a Tuesday it's perfect but circus is gonna be on a Sunday now you're gonna want vegetables for your Sunday meal your vegetables are wrapping because you cut them from your garden on Friday because yakshakas on Sunday Masumi Eric I am a breather the later Shoshanna by a day instead of Rosh Hashanah being Sunday Latricia Shauna be Monday so the first day of circus is Monday so you cut your vegetables for suckers Sunday afternoon you have wonderful vegetables you just let them want the left hand one night Mandana mission Messiah but the one who holds which some may say he says you don't have to delay it you know why f shabam ami you could use other nations or mummies from the word I mean you could use Gentiles we talked of learn to miss X debates and evolve you remember that yump if you can use to do the burial so therefore it's not a problem what's the problem is your son is Sunday okay so so coz will be Sunday so what's the problem somebody died on Shabbos you don't have to let them mess right I mean sorry stop is your breathing we do the burial it's fine yom tov Shanee as we said you could do it it's like huh but evening I'm definition we're talking about yom tov addition you could do it with goya yom kippur not in Kippur not so that would be a killer yeah that's what the first killing the Gemara rejected what was the first film like um Kip is gonna be Sunday that the kymaro reject it because even if you're not afraid of vegetables you should you should care about mason week I don't say all that doesn't care about mace I'm not gonna say that yeah this is already a different Hitler this is yontiff not in Kippur this is Yom Tov that comes out say after Shabbos or before Shabbos well for now lock her out so now my problem is your raucous I don't have initial of Mason so therefore although would say make make Rosh Hashanah a day later rubato would say don't make resume when would the backers say makers on that day later if you're gonna have um Kippur it on a Friday or um keep it on a Sunday in the words if fresh Hashanah falls out Wednesday cm kippers gonna be Friday or is your son is supposed to pull up fallout Fridays and kippers gonna be Sunday tobacco says now you gotta push it off now you gotta push but if it's a situation where you have yontiff coming out before after Shabbos it's up Mason I don't have an issue just use a guy what does it mean Yom Tov coming out before after Shabbos it would mean what it would mean that reshawna say is Sunday Jim Kipp is gonna be Sunday here we have a sickle problem Joyce says Beimel fenelby mahira ribbon the timely got a small for now I mean the time I had a problem with the word the free Shoshanna comes out before Shabbos why the Impala Shoshanna the circus will for now typically mission a scientifically I'm a computer in back of the shop in other words this only works if Richard Shana comes out on Sunday you get it so then the first day on circus is on Sunday first day so good on Monday now there's a McLucas Rebecca says somebody dies use a guy Ulla says vegetables vegetables vegetables granted but the fishes Shauna what's fall out on Friday so the first day of circus would be Friday so you're right I'm inside the Mesa month circus I have no issue but if it's on this Friday in Kippur is Sunday you get a fish your son his son David Koepp it's Tuesday but it was your son is Friday and Capri Sun emits up masive you still have a problem so there wouldn't be an argument South illegal Morris a bait mill for nabe Malacca I think I might have to say yum to for some of the sharpest me la Carrera in other words Sunday not Friday so have a the time to cut the word Bengal for now Joe Bennett um couldn't be going as this couldn't be glad you understand cuz cuz there's a Shana Friday they would both agreed not with such sucks woman sucking kipper there's no might be now you that might be nah he was only fishes Sean is supposed to be on Sunday hula says delay it to Monday ibaka says no need for a delay to Monday I'll just add the toasters haroche here says you could be going too smooth for now why could he be graceful for now he says it's not talking about the Rosh Hashanah it's talking about pacer or schmooze if you see a situation that pacer is going to fall out right before Shabbos the first day of Asaph is going to be on Friday so Shabbos you won't have vegetables they're going to delay responders missin by your day that's what it means yumm TIFF doesn't say Rosh Hashanah toy service is learning to Bennett Amazonian young to mr. marish neshama see he says if Richard Sherman is live for now you have to delay it because I've made some onion Kippur he says no young too far some of the shoppers is talking about all youment either like you asked before they saw Lewis now remember slowest is a funny situation huh you mean now okay we'll see in the mosque honor who see the most colors so that's why you could say look for now another dress Hashanah tackle of fun Ned there wouldn't be an argument but it's a pace that would be an argument Rebecca would say why you pushing off the white British tradition it's and what's the problem basic who's gonna be on a Friday okay somebody will die Aubry you're going to bury him much sad all your darkest is a problem I want vegetables for pace what's going with my campus what's coming with my mind okay Basin yes the vegetables basis you really need vegetables although the vegetables are the night so there's good fella we're talking about the day probably because you have to wait longer ah right right okay so that's gonna be the might be nice it's an interesting are you good as for funnily enough Greta slow for now now we have still the opposite problem we rejected the first might be now you because Allah would not be active Evek and insensitive to Mason now go the other way around will Amanda murmurs show may scilab remission pyaar kiya the same ice the one who all's that you'd the later Shoshana only when there's a problem with the dead why doesn't he care about who's having vegetables well why doesn't he care about it you're telling me for sure Shauna's Sunday he says I don't care sook this will be Sunday you'll cut the vegetables on Friday I Sunday your vegetables are rotten he's trying to sit in a Sukkah and eat the vegetable he can go send out a go to harvest vegetables on suckers why don't you care about the answer is f Shibata me me the Barker says with vegetables as the eight system with mr. cases vegetables means it Ashley says but how many means you could soak it in warm water there's an eight so you could soak it in warm water since you could soak it in warm water Sosuke is is on a Sunday the vegetables are packed a horrible they're dried out you take the vegetables you put them in water on Yom Tov and they get some vitality back they get some vitality back you can eat them or the same as well other way around will be the other way around if Yom Tov is on a Friday no Shabbos you now that is soaked Shabbos you now let us suck them in the warm water but the shot would be the Huayra that what that onion TIF right before Shabbos he made a native tough shilling you soak it right before Shabbos and therefore it's like you're harvested right before Shabbos even though you're harvested it on Thursday okay so it's gonna work every becoming me all the want to juice should be comfortable it shouldn't have to rely on soaking the vegetables it should be fresh fish market vegetables fine exhibition adjunctive and the basket is set for this we're not going to manipulate anything in a calendar every becoming me for a mace I have a problem and if it is an argument if wish your son is going to be on Sunday there's going to be an argument Allah says delay it Nabokov says no need for the late vegetables omens hates again but my problem is Mason that's dish okay that's the might be not you Rashi says bhajami me show you them Bahamas just look up more Sun you soak them in warm water and they go back to their cut Muslim cut Muslim means their original state their original state in other words fresh they're fresh good flag the Gemara ERC okay if this is true if all and the baths are right I have a question why is he saying the people of bubble don't know how thankful there should be to us Meisner what's the difference in Buffalo night sister all lived on that frost is a favor I feel lovely to do Nami for them it's also a favor I don't understand the B'nai artists all don't eat vegetables the B'nai aerosol don't have any dead to bury why did Allah say our friend and Bob will never even understand how appreciative they should be for the Binet Otis all for making the ABR the blades should be appreciative oh this is a benefit of the community and for the Gemara for this you have to understand the difference we'd be done for us the babylonians Avalon Alma the ear is very high very the climate is very warm bava bava is in valleys in a deep place is not a lot of ear and therefore Mason decompose fast and vegetables rot fast that he do for them and I just always cover a little Alma it's not so hot it's a mountainous land the Bostick says Eretz Horan some it's a land of mountains and therefore there's much more here and the problem of decomposition after two days is less likely Rashi says lead lead on hvala now Manu been above oh come on Delilah the world is a hot place for us Vilano heaven there is hot air the fish above Olomouc ahi bubble is very deep the aina in other words it's in valleys the inner area tournament was character surveying shuttle is bother so the ear doesn't rule over their ear doesn't come in so much marimba narrative short strips in my abdomen show me some machinery our kaya ellaby shreelane oh so that means they were thinking about the Jews in bubble they were not thinking about themselves for themselves they didn't need it that's why I always spoke about the graciousness de carros after that the B'nai above will have tasks you can't cut them you can't cut the registers in it you're asking if it's molasses cycle nefesh why can't you harvest vegetables an empty just like you shot down yum TIFF and you cook on Yom Tov why can't you harvest the answer is melaka so you could do era of young if you don't do one young tough as we learn to miss a debate sir there's a question of that's an incident i certain isidoro bonham that's a big mouth like a sarah shiner but generally will now let it do such malakas okay food right right and to say that this year they should let you harvest it because the food is gonna get ruined like plug they made it economy you don't cut vegetables you don't cut vegetables on or fruits or grain on onion right but even at Mossad Nyland but luckily you could do add a VM if you don't do any amitis even if it's an office you can also do a review on TIFF but the meat is gonna get decomposed it's not fresh cooking you can also do baking you can also do but it's not gonna it's gonna deteriorate the nature of the food yeah what yeah but once it is muttons it wasn't changed today no because if it's Friday it's fine most human time it's not Friday it's only in these year no usually it's fine one day is fine promise two days you have this every shopper centium kip prather Macy can't bury right but it's fine it works two days and bubbles I promise even it just you know that's not so badly says one or other the Gomora said at the beginning might be now you the B'nai you would be if um kipper is gonna be on Sunday right if your son is gonna be on Friday hula would say delay although would say don't delay it why don't delay because the only vegetable stream Kippur right and the basket would say the late because of mason look I'll you know we still have a problem why let's think about it if you and Kip it is on Sunday when was Richard Shana Fisher Shana was on Friday but your son is on Friday when is gonna be the first day of circus the first day of circle is gonna be on Friday so you have in the same is true with Sweeney at saris remember whenever you have the first day of circus Joseph Smitty at Sarah's with Shoshanna the first day of superstition is always the same day always good to know that first day versus Shawn the first day took a swing at saris always the same day of the week so Fisher Shawn is gonna be on Friday um Kip is gonna be on Sunday scientists am it's not vegetables for Yom Kippur I don't care because you're not eating vegetables on Sunday and with Sian Kippy you can go and cut Sunday night go caught but there's another issue what's the issue Fisher son is Friday so kisses Fri nation we need sizes Friday no your vegetables on sharpest are gonna get ruined all the dozen old hula doesn't know that sharp is you don't need vegetables you keep me honey vegetables but sighs eat vegetables so the slider right how is that a mighty now you in the have them in how's that I might be Nile it's a pellet the config the fun of my pain I you what did the good mothers same it's out Mason if um kippers on Sunday you got a problem how do you know Chris you don't got a problem okay the Kumada rejected it because even always should be concerned with the mason but what's even the half a minute if it's your son is Friday and Kippur his son the earth worried about suckers for captain kipper worried about sucka since minions said is people won't have vegetables there's Thomas Friday suck this is Friday if to cut your vegetables on Thursday by time of Shabbos afternoon Shabbos morning meal comes they're all rotten certainly shallow should this comes they're all wrapped in you're not gonna eat if you keep his sunday means wash your son is Friday remember right so besides Ben kipper you're okay but it's a circus you're not okay how could all the ignore them but don't tell me all has to worry about Mason even MIT sadly raucous you should worry mr. Lucas this episode difficulty this is a difficulty in the Gemara do is showing them have a very a very hard time with this so just tell you a few of the buna that they bring their it was says that [Music] then it was says as follows he says it's not such a problem why he says you could cook them on Yom TIFF what's the problem the problem is Shabbos you're not gonna have vegetables he says you'll cook them on the yom tov you'll make an air of tough shilling and then you'll cook the vegetables onion tooth circus you'll cook the vegetables on Yom Tov for Shabbos and they won't get ruined which is how he touches back huh me me he touches back her memory you cook it Ashley says becoming me you take it and you soak it in warm water he says you actually cook it the problem is only if Yom Tov comes out on Sunday then you have a problem if Yom Tov comes out on Sunday then you have an issue why because younger comes out on Sunday you can't cook it on Shabbos that's why if young turf comes out on Sunday then all the says I got a problem with your aqus why cook it on Shabbos so for young Tiff's it's all gonna be ruined do you understand but the other way around would work for your office that's how they did followers so it worked that's where the tomorrow says although would say fish your son is on Friday I don't care why what's the problem problem is so cuz is gonna be Friday God she'll cook it on so cos for shoppers and by cooking it it won't die you'll have it cooked that's how did it's far did it fall learns that system the fiducia ran says a little different he says that at this point the Gomera holds that Allah who holds vegetables says that this is only when Yom Kippur falls out on Friday that's what he's talking about William Kippur falls on on Friday but taça young tiff that comes out before Shabbos he talked a hold that you could soak it in warm water and therefore since he could soak it in warm water it's not a problem at this point that's what he holds that's what he else summer Mela it could work when Rashi seven the beginning that it's Mossad Yom Tov and Shabbos it's according to the conclusion of the Gemara according to the mass none of the Gemara that is even young different shops that would be according to the conclusion of the Gemara in other words that all that doesn't hold from the bhajami me in the conclusion of the Gemara allah doesn't although happen to me he wants it should be by Harkavy if become a me means Kakinada for networks because you could cook on young teeth on Shabbos you can't cook onion if you can cook if you make a narrative show right yeah you cook on Friday and if it's la Corral you cook Okanagan if you try to come in these cooking the works yeah it works in my kitchen the women always do it with roses and flowers I said we could still save it that's what he's saying the cooking he understands it actually says you soak it in hot water I guess it has a similar effect something about a white potatoes they didn't have them but you're giving an example okay something about a fight to a me so Allah is telling it we tell this is all based on a story this is based on a story that alder came to bubble and he said that ll was thirty days and what was the reason L was thirty days one reason either vegetables are dead in other words mossad the fish - L really was 29 days so what's the head that ADA scum that eight is not commonly the mother na wants to figure out how did this work how did this work this game to ask them so many questions ah nobody want to understand how it worked dr. Hamada Amy look hide this concept that best in delays Rosh Hashana by a day for the desire of the de sibour is not consistent with the truth with Allah why ha Tony Roberts more rabid the son of small tortoise of rice and if he taught us a price that means it's a tradition that comes from the turmoil it's a price that was taught what did the price is say your focus shame shame happiness Hashanah the traditional aside you might think just like we make a leap here when we have a need we can also make a leap month when we have a need that's what you might think just like the sanhedrin the central best in has the authority to add a full month to a year and say this year is going to have 13 months why map Nats are not stopped because of a neat what are the needs that may need is of it you needed the grain should be ripe by the time of Pesach yet to bring a carbonara on Pesach you needed that it should barley should be able to be ready number two the kufur you need that Pesach should come out after the co first listen after the equinox right when of it begins when spring begins in astronomical terms when the Sun hits the point of what we call Mazel clap it should be that makuta of spring that's when paster should be and if not if it's not gonna happen if string is gonna bring a desire Nissen they're gonna add extra four weeks an extra month so pastéis is delayed it should be in others another thing they need is the fruits should be right by Luis this fruit should be right by and then there are there are different such - small things that they used to add a support so you would think you could do the same thing with a month and you would even make a cover sign my MA does best and can add a month for so they can add a day they can add a fall they can add 30 days they can add one day that's what you would think yeah Tom with Lloyd Myers as the Bryson or the pauses are ahem retribution was feather finish assemblage reductions of harkaman said Kosair Ava Kadesh look at something like this and sanctify the new month remember the pasta can boy ha ha - ah zealous camera shutter the first Mitzvah that the Jewish people received mamma's the first Mitzvah that Claudius row receives when they're still Imaginarium is Hashem says this month should be the head of the month we shinola Hamlet Rosh Hashanah the question is the pasta cos a redundant posit says twice this month should be the beginning of the months it should be the first of all the months why do you say twice so cuz I'll said that pasta means two separate things the second half of the PASOK is saying that Nissen is the first month is muharram the first half of the plastic is saying AHA luck the law says how high their shaza Hashem points to the new moon to the Maya there was a tradition assistant and he points to that tiny tiny little moon that appears in the skies on Rosh Chodesh what we call - hi - in other words when the moon is starting its orbit again and he says how high - huzzah la hemorrhage reduction when you see this kiddush when you see this huh - when you see this new moon this becomes the new day of the month ahead of the month cause area a when you see this with cabbage making a wholly different renditions of holy done because la vaca - what is the price - trying to say the price is trying to say when you see the new moon you have to make reciters that day and you can't push it off I have a need you have a need so here's the problem if ella was really 30 days then you don't have to tell me vegetables and dead people don't know what people LMI you telling me they saw the moon they saw the moon real therefore ella was supposed to be 29 days they finish your sermon and then they said but we have a problem problem is nobody's gonna have vegetables mr. Sun is going to be on your son is going to be on on on what's it called on Wednesday let's say let's say she was gonna be on Wednesday we'll do both reasons and if we have a problem of mace I am your problem of your kiyah fine so they're gonna delay it to Thursday what do you mean the bride says this doesn't work this way I'll leap here yes a leap month now that's the big question on this whole story that all is telling us that they did ebrill why did the weeper for the benefit of madoff on my rather other is shine rabbinic enamel is going to see rambo will soon see why because the robber comes in later so we'll say on my rabbit rabbit said like gosh there's a big difference no contradiction con la abre the con la Cotte choi there's a big difference what they allowed in the times of allah to do is lob Roy to make ello 30 days the con la Cotte saw when the Brice's says Bethan doesn't have a right to do it it's not to make it a bore it's the beard Makabe SH on day 30 when there's no reason for it right one is passive and one is active good another in other words if the aid this comment there day 30 they could say you know what let's keep them quiet and the fact though restore this will be the next day as long as benzene is not my cottage the side dish then i'ma cobble they this okay records will be the next day so to delay it they can delay it either Bryce's said I played this I said look I'm cause a raver Kaddish so cuz their David Cottage means I can't turn day 30 and ternary this without seeing the moon saying there's no move we didn't see the moon but we're doing it anyway that not the brightest us but here they dead see the moon they're just doing it a day late they dead see the moon cuz they're a vittatus we saw the new moon it's not a spirit to cuz they're they've accomplished if we make the month on day they're trying to date 30 when it's not supposed to be day 30 for example the moon is not visible there was no conservative accomplish if we do it on day 31 okay we delayed the Kidder's but we saw the moon at least as a new moon cuz they're a and the cottage we made cottage the next day so it's already not as steady to the pasta that's the big finish in the Gemara robbers ants they saw the moon say 29 at night say they saw the moon 29 at night or 30 in the morning early morning so you're saying if what's gonna happen is respecters your son is gonna be on a Wednesday date 30 is Wednesday so besten comes and says we have a problem young Tiffany sharpest is gonna create a crisis people are gonna be hungry people are gonna be hungry so we'll tell the aide this you know yeah go thousand by the coastal for the day the opposite would be for carrots right now yeah if rich Hashanah is going to be on Thursday if Richard Shawn is gonna is gonna be on day 31 ages are not coming or maybe they don't see a new moon it's cloudy or maybe they know you're not gonna see the new moon based on astronomical calculations that we're gonna learn soon yeah they say there's a problem what's the problem the problem is if we let things play out naturally which means we're sure Shawn is gonna be a day late yeah sorry Shoshanna was supposed to be on Tuesday if everything would have been normal but because there's no moon moon is gonna be Wednesday I say oh my god this is a problem days 31 is what they say you know what let's make some a day even though then it come we'll make it this Bryce sir holds no there's gonna be other too soon this is a big argument here but this is what this Bryce Saul's rap is saying there's no contradiction wise no Conan the bracelet says you can't make it a day early cuz there's Khazaria Ava Kaddish but a day late it was a video Sullivan that's the finish of robbing a big fish catching that's the difference Carla a break on the cutter the Opera means to add a day to ello laqad Sri means to minimize the day to sanctify day 30 understand looking a cuz their David Kaddish cash aemsa madness our Sun ellipsoidal they are others at Kufa for pay to Sri lon readings conducive a tachometer Sun Hadron Aviv means what it should be spring the grain should be growing of course means astronomically it should be spring - you need two springs needed practically spring so Habibullah you need astronomically spring that's called the Topher right the next thing is pay Rasila cuz they David Kaddish keyboard Shakira cottage Bible and for the kumarila abre alas this is a custom male let Cyrus mutton to make the cost sir male to make a missing month of full month 29 30 you're allowed to if you need to even though they came Lacock shabby unsliced Shambhala vonda Lanier's Lacock say on day 30 when they didn't see the moon the immun t new game idea in my car and if you wait for another day a shoppers name I could put him solution kaval shoppers and people are gonna be near each other why because the Sun is gonna be on a Wednesday they said let's make it Tuesday in Makhachkala soda this is the finish of the Bryce see you can't I was gonna be problems with dead people and vegetables you're right we can't always fix all the problems gonna be a problem point to this done to delay yeah to make early no that's this okay 10 10 lines from the bottom huh from okay let's recall the sugah ulla said when he arrived from Eric's assault above ho he said to them that bez Dan decided to make ello thirty days and our friends will never even understand do they do they really understand the benefit what was the benefit so the tomorrow explains two opinions either food element vegetables dark ayah or Lobosco said Messiah either for the living or for the dead but there was a tremendous benefit for the been above all as the tomorrow says at the end with his less ear then in the Holy Land and therefore things rot faster they decompose in a Swifter pace due to the climate in Volvo which is very low LaCava air too strong so the fact that Rosh Hashana was delayed by a day which as a result of that what happened was there was a break between him Kippur and Shabbos so no dead person would decompose by just laying around lying around for two days and there was a break between Yom Tov and Shabbos so no vegetables would be ruined this is what the tomorrow Sept and discussing the differences between the two the two views are Caio Messiah because according to the view of Messiah he's not worried about vegetables he says you can ultimately soak it in warm water it's not the end of the world it's not like people are going to starve and therefore he ultimately and therefore he ultimately feels that when you're dealing with young TIFF and Shabbos which by young - there's a hectare to use a Gentile to bury the dead so you don't have an issue the issue would be Yom Kippur and Shabbos stahma ha Arella halacha we assume the second opinion that it's Monsieur may say it's for the dead and therefore were worried primarily about the impure coming out before Shabbos or after Shabbos and keep it being Friday and Capri being Sunday and thus in our calendar the way it was established permanently we say lo you do rush Rosh Hashanah will never be on a Sunday or on a Wednesday or on a Friday if vicious um is on a Wednesday automatically in Kip is going to be on a Friday it's gonna be right before Shabbos if your son is on a Friday that means him Kip is gonna be son because him Kippur is always two days after right summers olive Tisha's of Jonah's Friday so the next Friday would be chastised right a week later plus a day the eighth day and then Shabbos would be nine and Sunday would be in Kippur would be 10 Tish I am Kippur is gonna be on Shabbos we have um kept it on campus but we don't have Richard shun on Wednesday or Friday which means him Kippur will not be Friday people will not be Sunday if Risha shun is Sunday so Rosh Hashanah is always the first day as circus as we said now if we say there's no problem of your kiyah that wouldn't be an issue so circus is the first day of Sunday I'm not talking about today when there are refrigerators and we're not worried about the vegetables I'm talking even then when they didn't have refrigeration before they discovered the electricity and everything that came with it in the whole industrial revolution in the 1800s but the issue with he say Monsieur may Sally we're not worried if circuses Sunday why because even if there's a maze Hustler shalom on Shabbos you can use a guide to bury him on Sunday and therefore the mace won't decompose even before the morgues and the freezers but there's another freshman here that's brought a moussaka suka and that is that the human did not want that her shiny robber should be called the Shabbos because if Hashanah rava would be on Shabbos so then the Minich of my shyness would be bottle called yama rava it would be bottle and if Rosh Hashanah is going to be on a Sunday yeah so then you'll make the measurement the first day of sickness is gonna be on Sunday the seventh day of suck this is gonna be on Shabbos Hashanah Robin because they didn't want yo mi Robert to be bottle they were very Mac bit annoying my rather that it should always be there's different reasons for it one reason is our people shot because it's Duke and fought it the Sadducees fought it because it doesn't say clearly and Himesh the concept of bringing they would bring their office every day to the base on microfiche and put them at Emma's birth and they would circle the miss Bayer with our office and they shine a robber the seventh day which we call a shiner up they would circle seven tons just like we do as Asia for this ensure we circle the bill once with our dollar dominium and then a Shannon Abu we circle seven times and we clap I rather okay that's a minute in the VM but they did not want it should be in this battle it should be nullified on Shabbos it would have been nullified and hence state matrix on it should not be Sunday so from this is the freshman lie or do rush as we'll see later there's a whole different reason why they don't wander Shoshanna to be Sunday Wednesday and Friday according to the Rambam and that has to do with pure astronomy nothing to do with vegetables nothing to do with that people nothing to do with her shiny rubber absolutes astronomy in other words it was inherent to the calendar wasn't stopped for social search bonus they decided to manipulate the calendar no food market the whole head all these cash bonus are extra extra credit why they it works out this way but for astronomical authentic purposes we're gonna learn we're gonna get to this the Rambam explains its credit that's why they may discuss okay but I'll pop on them here the way the Gemara explains it is this was the con man this is the P side of Leia do - of course if going to all the British onna can't be some because then Circus is gonna be on Sunday and if circus don't suddenly have a problem of vegetables go to the second that that wouldn't be a problem Kamiya manner of the not a row vindaloo of a rubberised acceptance of my semester after sucker they were fighting it they once hit the robbers they came to there is some meters to the Morrisons they hid their office under the stones and their merits came and removed the stoves and took out our office it was it was a lot with the comic like this it was a leopard - kibosh so the gomorian now addresses the problem what's the problem uber says galactica hate that the haha man added the data L why did they added the Sun Hat they tell and there was a tremendous benefits for the community and the people in bubble should be thankful apparently if you say that they were muhabba yellow which was a hitter's because usually ever Elmo was not more but the mother says la jolla there's a problem it sounds like the reason they did it was not because witnesses didn't come right because of the reason is the witnesses didn't come and Ellen the woman wouldn't say that people of Bothwell should be so grateful which they'd be so grateful we didn't do anything for that we had no choice we were mob Adela it's Marsh mother this was intentional they delayed it intentionally they didn't have to delay it astronomically or according to the basic principles of conditional fighters this is already a big hitter share so that means there is an intervention here with the regular process which is basically what the SU gear deals with how much how much intervention is how much intervention is allowed now this is a very complicated thing because if you if you sticking to the strict rules to the strict principles ok witnesses come they don't come and that said there's no other fish bones but suddenly there's other calculations here there's other motives here you know what are the limits what are the limits that's the SU gear so the first question the Gemara asked some will live that robbed of our small brought a price and the price is set don't compare ibrahim is to brush sana a leap year they can add a month when there's a need for it let's remember adding a month doesn't play with astronomy adding a month just adds another month you're not playing with us try nominal calculations you're using another orbit of the moon and you're just keeping it in this year right you understand when you add a month you didn't manipulate anything in reality so we have a second order it would have been missed and we're calling it out there okay right the Mitzvah is not affected yeah you're not doing so the crisis says don't compare it to if you need to add a month and a month if you need to add a day if you need to do able to fade this that we don't do why cuz they're a the Kaddish you need a moon I've heard your shows all of em cuz they're they've accomplished this is the problem here we suddenly see no they added a bit so Rover said and as I said there is so many to showing am I going to see robber robber set the bracer says what the bryson means is they can be makka - they could be my uber meaning they can turn day 30 into the straightest automatic without seeing the movement but if they need to add the day that works what's the catch but Rashi says cause they're Ava Kaddish you're sure - has to be after you see the moon I can't say you know today is day 30 I want it to be destroyed - there's no moon you can't see the moon perhaps there's no witnesses that they saw the moon we're doing it anyway that not the prices cuz they rave at cottage but once I saw the moon okay I do it a day later okay I'm not doing it the day I saw the mall I'm doing it a day later that can work of course not because they woke up in the morning and they don't like the day for reason for example this reason of your tayo Messiah so male it works all the story does not contradict this Bryce we have a consistency in in in Halawa that's what that's what that's what the robber said so that's Cena on my rabbit rather like I should come got a break on the catch Mojave comma this is how you have to explain the price you also save some happiness at some nervous I call this it's as though words are missing in the original Bryce it said the awful shame shame a penis I saw no let's say the cash - ahoy - let's sign it no way how crazy shows a look at rappers saying no you have to read in there's like missing words in the Bryce it's like we often say in surah max are in a Mishnah doesn't mean the words I'm missing but it means like there's a gap you have to but that fine how can I forget it you have to put in some words your whole cachet scheme' a Brina sauce on of si hoy dish with soy de cosmic action si hoy - Latoya I would think just like you're allowed to make a leap here if you have to and you're allowed to make a leap month if you have to you can also sanctify a new month if you have what do we mean a bore means adding the day kiddush means taking off a day a day earlier though we don't have a basis for it because the moon is not visible witnesses have not come and what if even if possibly it can't be visible according to calculations that you can't that you would think you could do that to Tom with Lamar I've heard in Schatzi look Amrish whole dish has to be only when this whole dishes Rashi explains already in partials boy has I'll explain that heyday or could Asheboro full of moisture judicial Ivana Jerry Boyd initial of them shows Marcia hi dish how's that whenever you say how's that as rashly says it's Mario bets boy vitamins there you pointing to something right Zen means right here like Zack hailey Vaughn vo etc so Myra beds boy vitamins a is pointing to this new moon and he says cuz that Ray you see something like this but cottage that's when you make your new month I can't make day 33 straight this if I didn't have the Kosair david package according to this Bryce that's gonna be the next soldier that's half a mad bass how it works in terms of the mullet if I can lose one day I can fix two days right so we know we know restricted to know the beans day 30 a day 31 not like not not not before now if I if I'm allow you to do it something with oh shoot I'm giving you permission to try to smell like a macaron oh if you allowed to move one day why not today usually if I said the cabbage coming it matters right away you come home find out now you make it it because this is what he said cuz la we can actually come home you see the house but car that should make it nobody said Tom should have a whole different I don't know what he makes kids take a look in gosh II take look at the dashi yoga shim-sham Ivan will say the textbook optional service Tom with lemon cousin Ava cabbage great healer Baraka Calcutta SH for C and then Bhima Kaddish don't be my cottage without saying I have accepted my eyebrow Leiva khadisha if you're making recite this a day later you saw and you did the kiddush you know that cuz they're Ava cabbage means firstly then kamesh so you can't compare import to kadosh kadosh I'm doing without her a unless add witnesses I can't do that with soda I I want research on it to be a day early I don't want it to be a day later why let's say your son is gonna be on Friday I wanted to run with me on Thursday I don't want it to be on Friday I can't I can't make Christmas on on Thursday day 29 is Wednesday I can't make restaurant on Thursday I need my witness says I need to be able to see my move but if fish Hashanah is gonna be on Friday I want to make it on Shabbos that I can do why Rashi says according to this Bryson to be shot is the a has to come before Kaddish I heard this has air before Rashad awesome Rashad dishes based on a lady Sansa cuz they're a and then is cutted here do was Ray and car - it was just the Kaddish was a couple hours later or day later that's so explains according to this right I can always there that I do my best I do my best but I can't in other words there's a Shana is on Friday I want to make it on Thursday no Hebrew is Friday yeah I want to make it Thursday I have no moons of course it is glass you wouldn't be able to that's how the camel is explaining Allah although wasn't just saying they do whatever they want now you also have to remember even when we say Ybor you can do it for two days there's a system of 29 and 30 that system is based as we're gonna see in the next Ahmet on the orbit over the moon the orbit of the moon doesn't finish after 29 days it finishes after 29 and a half days so it's not so simple when you're supposed to make recite this if you make a restraint this every single month on day 30 which seems like the right way to do it you're you're being dishonest and you're missing a half the base not true the orbit did not finish the orbit is not finished at the end of 29 in the beginning of 30 that's not the case you need another 12 hours Rashida's the theresa's can be a half a day I can make affidavits finish after day not recharge so essentially in the ideal perfect situation it's six months twenty nine and six months thirty so you do understand that Ibrahim is part of the astronomical necessity right it's not like they're making the straightest ten days later because they want to show their it's all based on the LaVon Plus and chain and change [Music] we're gonna see in a few moments according to this bride see you want to know according to this price of what they would do with months after months after months of singers right this is gonna see a whole moon under Scottish you want off this 12 months which cloudy so they're always the way delaying the lake according to this blase single coin it could be that he would home it could be that he would hold that if it's possible to see the moon based on the astronomical calculations even though in physicality you can see it's already - Ava caddish it's already afternoon that will be every month so in other words if not if you couldn't see the moon after the mileage know that I'm saying yeah that I'm saying sometimes you can't see it it's too soon it's it's it's in the position where even if the weather was impeccable you wouldn't be able to see it or it's a situation where you would be able to see it your vision is blocked saying it's a very big difference that it could be that's other price so would learn in such a situation you could rely on that even though there's no ADIS right to solve this problem it's a big problem he's saying you have bad weather again and again and again and again and again you're gonna be completely off what are you gonna do now so forever you're gonna be off suddenly your strategy's gonna be middle of poram and those days today you could not go into an airplane you said the witness says he sent to wait this on an airplane mushiya comes we're gonna go back to finish I heard you sell period it won't be an issue go into a spaceship you go you send them to the moon and they'll cable back from the moon I don't know if they could be a goddess ages from the moon they'll say it is you don't believe me here's a moon but then when one day you say you have to be away from the moon to see the movie and over there it's always full it's not a mile in anymore slide it out that's how I would same shot so this is the of this Bryce so Robert gave an answer okay but Nancy says okay so Oliver Mellor Lula is right it's not a problem in Halawa that they were what they don't my a brass ahoy - ahoy - with so fine their home can do that even they know with that closet the calculation is it's wrong according to calculations yeah there's witnesses who's saying we could tell you there's a boom and there's H no we wanders you're shot a day later that's that's what the prices say go davon and come back say tell him and then you'll come back the medicine already be here and it's over remember once the day 30 ends now there's no I'm glad to say this anymore right now it's automatically move so if you could just push over the 8 this a little bit now they're not doing this because they're in a bad mood they're doing this the play issuer asks we did the Khazar even invent this concept that they have such an authority the toyota says cuz they're Ava kaddish so why don't you just stick to the base of principle like ok there's a problem of vegetables and dead people what we're like where did they find in a pasta anywhere ahead there oh so we're gonna learn later that we learned that whatever they do this makuu dish with the oven right in other words at could they cut it even if they make a mistake and we know it's a mistake we know it's on this thing's gonna be a whole story doc Coffey I'm not Mira back in freedom issue I got some ice they sure knew was a mistake and Rabbi Akiva said it's fine you could desecrate your kit because best in the solder on the MCAT but that's bit the of it our best doesn't sit down and say let's make mistakes but the ever a real best put them on a real Sun Hedren that's that's how Peter makes a mistake Tyler says the same God who said cuz they're rapin cabbage said what's best and says is good but asking our tailor when we're sitting that we don't want to make mistakes we want to do it we want to do it make it a dinner so he says we did this his sight come up from so the play insurer says here in the Gemara he says he seems to him that if eight this actually came on day 30 and they testified there's nothing you do about that there's not they testified they testified that it's that they saw the moon they testified that's gonna be when you make on on Monday or Sunday you'll make Rosh Hashanah whenever whenever your maker some if that system happened you so to speak forced by it of course you do it that way he says that Floydada vibora ella my LMI sometimes you have a situation that that didn't happen there's no ADIS or the ADIS of the late or they delay the a this intentionally they know still mathematically and astronomically that there could be a this today and they this are not lying because they know that the moon is a visible moon because it's enough time that you would be able to see the moon whether there's no clouds or there is clouds but they could see the moon so now the collider here yeah you would think since they know that this is what's supposed to be so you're forced to make this Rashied dish that's the finish that if there's a siren you could say you know what even though we know that your installation how logically is the right dress tightest why because we know that the moon is visible or even more than that ADIS are already here and we could listen to them we could listen to that they haven't said anything but if we see there's a major side earth in this situation we say my abran SI hai - Latoya you could delay in a day but once a this came and said I got to say this he says then you wouldn't be able to do anything you want to be able to manipulate that al cabone that's his R so now we have this price that is answered according to robber you can delay it you can make it a day early the P hard armor to be sure but lazy this is consistent with a statement with immeasurable AV what did it be sure the lady say ma I mean al ha Adam ala hi - Anita biz Manila a bro my Ayman means how does he say my man you threaten interesting you intimidate witnesses I'll have hi - shanira bizminer who come for the month which was visit was to come for the new moon which was visible in its time what's bisman night day 30 29 at night library because you want to delay it they'll be sure that lady said you can intimidate them so crash it wasn't even Tim they'd be young solution they saw the moon and they 30 say our issue they should be quiet miss Villa abre because he wanted to lay it you can intimidate them to remain quiet because you have it so but that rubber may be said the aim by I'm in Allah aid them Allah hi - the Lightning of Ismael Akasha but you can't intimidate a this on a new moon that did not show up on day 30 because you want it to be on 30 doctor actually says if an a my I'm in beyond solution on day 30 Allah a them solo role our witnesses that did not really see an accurate moon but I'm not sitting in the car sorry high empathy laughter Chavez ma'am I could put him and we're desperate the today should be reshawna why let's say we should shun is worth on Shabbos I mean Richard attention Sunday is on Friday and so if your son is on Friday and Kip is gonna be Sunday and we're desperate so we want to make research on on Thursday so we tell the ages you didn't see you did see sure your anew we do not intimidate them to say we saw really do Schechter and they should testify what is good question at least here it says not to do it the problem is gonna be in a few lines with there's gonna be another that you do do it that's gonna be the crumb so let's discuss to them at least here we say don't do it seems like a joke exactly what do we say they were very good what is it is they're actually saying my name and I weigh them where where you tell two people you go to the supermarket you say come come let's let's a let's lie I mean little but at this point at this point what are we gonna show believe he's saying let's understand the limits the limits are a this came we say Shh intimidate them what do we mean intimidate them intimidate them doesn't mean through terrorism intimidate could mean two things either you create a situation where they're quiet or you create a situation with investigation is so intense the day they say you know what forget about this I don't know what I saw they doubt themselves they doubt themselves that's what intimidation doesn't mean in other words they want that Ava's should not say clearly because the edges have a coil that we're discussing the word is to to sow doubt that they should be uncertain say I don't know once they said oh no I don't know fine so this is so we see here every show but maybe makes the same distinction so Ola works because all it didn't say they make mr. Shawn a day early so the magician are didn't check the Gemara now we have a very different which becomes difficult Amy this is not the case you're explaining a price that was quoted by who by robber bar Shmuel and you explained all of this way Amy it's not this case it's not this way vishal aw who didn't see you later balmy review who then this SIA not to confuse with remuda ha no see the editor of the Mishnah because this is generations later it's a great you know it's a descendant of this so never you who the button is SIA sent a message to rub Amy listen to his message heavier than you should know should call Youm of collaboration throughout all the days of ramayana hajima lambda know the abuse shannon is the first generation of a Miriam in Eric's sister all who's the editor of harmony rashon me repure Shannon used to teach us my I mean if you need to my I'm in our a them a la jolla shallow near abysmal in the CAPTCHA pom fire cat poop it you can intimidate ADA's that they should come to testify on the high dish on the new moon which was not visible in its time the capture to make it holy I felt peace a lawyer who who your Nora Engel even though they didn't see it they should say we sought and they thirty should recover its Riteish clearly the bi-xenon was marketed to be my cottage to hide this before the right time I'm day thirty instead of only one if you need to the exact opposite of what rabbit told us Robert just explained or rather just explained there's no way you can do this if you're sidin all of his life taught us the other way so we have air contradiction but now we pushed have to understand the words of review what does this mean what's the point first of all if you're having them wanna do without a this.right do without it what is this does this mean that you're simply inventing a lie not according to our law sense and the commode is putting it in as a locker I mean we do you have a constitution that say by the way we're lying but this is what we do a 4pc later a marine and but wow we are these atheists we are a descent who are these eight is there behind me not in the first case you have a this who come so you say you don't want them to speak till tomorrow who are they so a banal phenomenal you ever been Hana on the left probably in small the last line Robin Hahnel you see matha lies on the first line of of the wide lines animated phenomenal you see the first one of his wide lines it's narrow and then it becomes why he says with me harder I'm gonna be a sharable AV you see my I'm in a lie you could they laugh as her behind below you sky motive rain the Abreu it's there's là-bas do you want they should retract their words this is every show burn levees they should be uncertain so we could the later stylish next the aim I'm in a la ADA malahide the shoreline near abyss man I've hula Alam it kolima listen to his words a mime in Iceland we don't intimidate then like Marlon he's our be careful they either testify Yahoo's shanira love MK Inka visa halav oh no sir the atheists are like you know we saw something it could be it was a clouds so best and says no no no it was a moon that's what my minh means it's not the pc go take from the street a you take a this and they themselves if you would just ask them a few questions they would just back off they came to me because the british but you know sometimes you see a witness you know professional lawyers know this witness you know within a few questions he's done so my monoi son miami no some means for care you not you intimidate them you intimidate them by encouraging them in other words you want to you lead them to that way that way why because they want to strike this to be this that that's abstract Miami noise that's what he says on the cops you know say inflation in what's the best in the sister day a lighter hidden on a lie you could in the culture Bachelor native is monocle in Milan has a savvy shopper maybe the other shitty reputation of is know you could do this so when the Gemara says lawyer who after Isha Lulu it doesn't mean they didn't see it right they saw something but they're going to they might easily tell you that they didn't see it on this we encourage them we lead them we intimidate them to say we did see it so we can make it a shot oh yeah they used to courage these to convert everybody the Congress used to cut your butter in a cup so this is already a different house so the bailiffs a mammal gives us a fight in this Gomorrah it gives us attached without this you're making people lie first of all this is how Jewish look this out Judaism works I mean who ever heard of such a thing God says you need a new moon on making people lie and if you making people I don't do it you don't need the largest do whatever you want if it's if terrorism right not terrorism if deception range do whatever you want and don't must make me how lucky and Gomorrah how long is that we obviously understand the desire I'm up I've been a mother's mother I just want to add another voice that the familiar issue I adds him to be it mom take a little more panini schewe adds it's not just they manipulate a this you saw you saw you saw even though they this themselves may not be so sure or at least you can easily get them to doubt themselves because they came to besten because they have some certainty suddenly they came to benefit to do with their lives they came but you could plant seed in them so you could plant doubt in them so you're saying don't plant Downton he says it's even more than this it's talking about a case we're according to the astronomical calculations they knew that the moon is visible that's what happened maybe it's cloudy maybe very few people saw maybe it was difficulty maybe it showed up for 20 minutes you know you have those situations but they knew that the my earth happened already I'll be a husband so the players sure says if that's the case let's understand you dear this is large media high radio career when it says Khazaria Ava Kaddish what do they say they say seeing is believing right but knowledge is a form of seeing it's a it's not seeing physically but if I know the moon is supposed to be there I know that everything is set up in heaven to make it recite this so he says it's like seeing so Basden would have the Cuyahoga into this to make a destroy dish that's his Vaart it's better mitzvah-kah disappear here mitzva lacan disappear it's better of course if you have a this because you have physically so he time is that the Epson best in has that coil Terry McAuliffe if they know for sure that there's a real moon even early not this of reputable airship a lady says now right you don't even fade this come you don't need not my I'm on them but but here they have an opportunity they know it UD ra o career that's the Vaart now they usually won't do it they usually will not do it the agents are not sure they're not sure but here it's talking about saira again they're not that happy to do this enthusiastically they would like to do to the most ideal sense a this calm their investigated they say for sure without any intervention but if it's an issue of Latoya so here you'll have a situation they will rely on their calculations and then a this who may say we're not sure they will encourage them to say that they saw in order to be able to make it yes exactly they have that to the player show ads very interesting horror so they have to know for sure that this is a real recitation astronomical and I can't they have another name on them anyway coil you mean from exciter you're right look at the silver you need a this but it's not my active but the effort that's the point you're right baby divine that's why today we can average strain this there Bobby if it would be more actively be evident have to we want to be able have noticed today we don't have a this I'm saying but they don't have a this for every month so it's not my activity never that's the voice look up hill you're right of course we want we always one aid this because they've accomplished that's what they thought yeah if ages don't come they don't come but if they come we don't want them to one no fade this would not come at all according to him if the effector slightest without anything else without anything else you saying according to this Accord to the play of Sharia they have that Christ we makanda to hide this based on it just like we do today again not like a pillar with the effort here you have a this and they this could ruin it for you oh so right when you're gonna do a real investigation so they won't make it worse because all you'll have is you having aid this don't say okay this to come for the ages to come so the Rambam says in oh--this Kadisha hiders the reason is cause a land where their share my should tick Royce symbol Maya dumped whenever it says but Moya done it's toys for Shabbos so therefore those months when it's Maya dim when there is Mary the missin until a McConnell a massage shoppers for every year side dish because because my diadem of the Harvard because the colors are carpet but even after the base I make this missin and fish sick was Maya dice Maya this so that's a dinner since the tire that does wander should be a this that's the Mitzvah and that's those the Shabbos when there's an Indian of motifs that's how they're animal touches analyst condition fetish Rashi said here the marsh monster Nash's that since Nissen and tissue these days of human toy him they wanted to make it as accurate as possible the the non attack it should be it should be in this monomer islet so when you have vision and that's the way to do it not the way to do it is with a this you're right you're right but they always try to do it with a this you don't make de 30 without a this that didn't happen theoretically they know yet we don't man you want to know if mom is no aid this came if they would still make it doesn't seem like it yes many aid this always they always screen them could be this is part of so the question here is does this not undermine robber robber said you cannot make restraint - a day early only delay it unless you really had aid this I'll excited I don't care about unit cider and ablation and all of his life taught otherwise all of his life photo now you could say robber has a source of you sure been Navy mr. Fowler you could say although did it first says that the lotion all of his life it sounded like there wasn't an argument about is like this was a dove Roberta rabbit clearly has a whole different opinion or the prashanta is the way the dutiful lines of shopton is how does Ruby listen to deal with the price the price it clearly says a - ahoy - Latoya so rappers said I have a shot in the Bryson the Bryson means what you can't make it a day early to make him a day later recorded of Joyce women he's contradicting of rice the rising Lily said you can't and a business as you always could they have a problem here and for the Gemara Amira buyer like Asha hub in this in the Tishrei of the Shia the Burien was talking about listen and Tishrei will be sure ballet V robber is talking about other months what's the vort Rashi says Vanessa petition Ashley before hyoma lambda new miming amano tricky unless I said huh sir again this is not stomp because you want to try to stay 30 you need to make it closer because of issues that are Vanessa Leticia Shambo just flew in behind the couch on the side of Nissen initially I will tell you my taller than them so therefore they made me the pastor's therefore there may be a problem of yar kye and Messiah so then the coxal messiah then you can make it a day early if it's your son is gonna be on Friday make if day Thursday huh you can also make it later of course that everybody says you can make it early that's what I hear some of it Bashar keloid are the man's no so there's no problem the bride's attacker said you can't make it a day early that was putting my other month's reputation and said you could make it a day early that was talking about missile until a always not a prop well anyway said they made it a day later that's all not a problem of course everybody agrees to that but even a day early they don't have a major problem first of all rappers not disagreeing with their various phenomena basically one this initiative is not disagreeing with the price it's completely fine now the problem is why would you want to make in other months a day early not Ashley the in timer might say as long a professional massage will happen I understand wishes Shauna I understand listen I'm afraid Yom Kippur is sharp is dead people vegetables I got it what do I need Tabas what do I care first-rate this is a day later so so what so I started with tables will be a day late what do you care nobody's gonna have me to fold for the money later I'm thinking now about later know if this husband is your kya and Messiah so that's what has been listenin today what do you have to worry about that in kiss lovin table what after cashing I did two months three months to you are you - three months 31 I want to go back to 29 because okay so let's see what - she says could go in oysters universe after Eric and the answer is it has an air can be purchase in my boss Hadassah mom Oh Barbra Jean de Boulogne real ah a brioche de la semana you don't have less than four months müber in a year you can't have less than four months there are 30 days and you don't you shouldn't have more than eight that have 13 for hustling a freshman in our town they'ii be Bruce minor if they already had I think what's up y'all yes yea verily 25 25 every month you're gonna see the moon it it gets very derailed yes V me blue shmouna what happened if they already had eight months with 30 days well Bozell loin eaters be on shlush now you have a month it's all a discretion if I just kiss love it's day 30 you want to make it you don't see him okay not kiss ofcourse it's already at the end of the already did eight months so it's at the end of the year let's say it's of ello and you don't see a moon a day thirty nemesis on nutrition la I am la my marina beach villa cottage so now we would think we want to intimidate the witnesses to make recharge they don't have a ninth month of researchers from day 31 that's the finish no other months don't do it and this steel pack have nine months the seals that have nine months in that case yeah if you ever hate you have a nice now you know you're not four days off you have to have six months like this six months like this not four days no no so that's what we say other months you can do it you would but oh sorry Archie Lloyd's record actually why would you even want to do it so rash she says I'll tell you why you would want to do it I bet know I've been fun we're talking about what took my house what's wrong with us yeah I'll tell you it makes all the sense - fight it so that's a biosensor revoir MA rava says ho the tawny da Babar Shmuel rubbish I'll give you a different part a different answer to the problem with Ola the problem on all the from a price Ola said you could delay and the Brice's says you don't change so we said the price it means you can make a day early you could do a day late and at the end we say the price is talking about when other months not in the sanitary she says you're aware of as a different approach harder Tony have a very small price of never much more that what and Ibrahim is not like he brush on a favor me his Brice follows the view of a fade and which is usually associated with rib mayor the mayor had Bilal a whole different approach to Kadesh a fighters the tiny with enterpriser Hayden minor and I hate him says it's really not about witnesses ain't may not set a slot said us you will never have between one choice and another shoes of ambitious on alliteration something one our son our son L our boy Amin bull watt only four days meaning refresher Charlotte this year is on Sunday automatically I know next year it's four days later Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday refresher Shona is on Monday next year I know it's Friday Richard Shan is on Tuesday next year no shops no it's always four days we must show no more Baris if it's a leap year it's Commission it's gonna be one what's what is what it may is saying it made it making the following attachment this is an important question he hopes that the way bez did made the Munsters very consistent one month 29 days one month 30 2930 2930 since the orbit of the moon is 29 and a half days so essentially they split it up six months six months six months they kept a month 29 days which is a half a day early after days short and six months they kept a month 30 days which is a half a day extra and that's how they evened out and they did this consistently this is the of LeMay if that's the case the mayor tells you that you can always have a simin of how the calendar works how does it work if you have 12 months 12 six of them twenty-nine days six of them 30 days you have a year of 354 days how many weeks is 350 days fifty weeks right how many sevens are the ends three hundred and fifty fifty weeks so you have always four extra days so therefore if fish Hashanah is on Sunday count 50 weeks 50 weeks 54 weeks the next is your summer should be on Sunday not you need four days later cuz its 354 days and it may it says there's never a question about this cuz there's no issues we always do 2930 2930 way we don't care about anything else witnesses yet witness is Nishant we will always do that system Caserta AVA cottage La Jolla according to this means cuz they're they've accomplished that you have to know that it's potentially visible the calculation has to agree because there David can touch that it has to be Laroy to potentially visible in other words you don't need your evap oil but rather it has to be consistent with the times of seeing the moon it has to be consumer the times are seeing them so it's not through a physically because if not it's not gonna be like this you're not gonna have 354 days you'll be two months I'm sorry two months as yes yes yeah yeah yeah so therefore what about a leap here a leap here you add one more month that month according to the mayor was 29 days 28 days is four weeks so you need to add one more day so in a leap year you add five days not four days before this so between shrewish and slowest between a Shoshana Shoshana of one year the next day will be that day put four days later or leap year five days later that shouldn't know this is the Big Finish he holds us no mistake I disappear here it's basically a system is like it's like ours it's like almost our system yeah well Fida so now according to this according to this this price so that we learn confidence it may it may says you don't manipulate anything you don't delay you don't make a day early know such a thing Houston that's the price so there's no problem but there's no question on all that price is according to the mayor there's no spirit of the ocean to the price that Bryce is talking that mayor is not talking of me that's how we solved the problem this is Rovers explanation you see since your other says this that's why many are going to slobber earlier no no again alia you're not manipulating anything you know do you understand a leap you're just adding for weeks so what you know nothing will change nothing astronomically changes in a leap here the moon doesn't have years the moon rotates a month you could when you play with a month you're playing with astronomy not when you with a year you know playing with astronomy you just took a cycle you add it to the year you call the tops 9 signers - that's big deal you understand it's a whole different Indian Ibrahim it's not a small thing and I look it's a big thing but it's not like Ibrahim in different this a question of man it was always 29 days well pile we do other issue 30 days you're not calendar yeah I believe 30 other ition is Atticus other Shana we do Porter if we do put him in the other so other ition is the added one that's usually the other the other this pod we have recorded history and what do we have the chorus - what know that mayor doesn't care if witnesses come he just says that's not the didn't have records of that I'm not with this government when the Gemara was when the mission was written they were still doing this you mean our mayor no they all disagree listen up mayor it may just says you guys are doing it wrong no it may just take the secret listen of mayonnaises you're doing it wrong yeah no they're not arguing him at Seijas yeah no that Matt was saying he's doing it wrong you don't understand tell us the Gemara says that the halacha was usually not like it up man like a cup in line with ourselves no he was saying this is how it should be he's not saying this is how it was he is the author of the Bryce who says don't compare months to years years best and plays around with months nobody plays around with anything it's boom never come no that's that's how we interpreted the price initially initially we interpreted the price that for later he yeah he picks it out he goes back to the original price so we don't play any games exactly in the stability now that you can see the chicken Tinga Sunday was before no other have different they did months of the calendar February has 28 this yeah because they have a longer year you'll see that your English birthday will not be like your jewish birthday why not let's say your birthday's restraint is Thomas Wright and that's July 4th the store example you would expect it should be next year July 4th it's not it's gonna be 11 days off your English birthday is gonna be 11 days off your he / birthday why I know what because the Hebrew birthday is going according to the moon every 19 years but every 19 years with our leap years they catch up and once in 19 years your English and Hebrew birthday will be on the same day cuz it's 11 days off because the moon orbits 29 and a half days if you make that 12 months it's 354 days the Sun orbits 365 days so between 350 for 365 11 days you understand that takes to Sun another 11 days so let's say it's our Scottish Thomas and the sun is shining over my yard yeah and there's a particular particular place that it's shining yeah and I make a scratch here and I want to see when the light is gonna when the shade is gonna be on this place again it's not gonna be your straightish time it's gonna be your I love Thomas in the stem it's gonna be 11 days later why because for the moon to get back to this place it's gonna need 365 days and your Scottish tombos the next red summer is not 365 days is 254 days unless there's a leap year now in 19 years we have enough leap years to straighten them out that they become like twins and then the song will be there straight there's Thomas you understand if it was year 18 and then year 19 354 days is only if it's even six months twenty-nine six months thirty that's why so now you your birthdays or straightish Thomas that's according to the moon the next year you want your birthday to be July first it can't work that way you understand July first can't be restrained there's Thomas to get from July 1st to July 1st you need 365 days there's trade this time with Larry Summers 354 days you need an extra 11 days to gather your birthday but once you add leap years within 19 years we have 7 leap years so we have many more days for the moon so it straightens out so now forex traders Thomas tourist riders Thomas will be 300 every few years they used to add a month that's they don't have to fix it they don't need to bring together the song in the mood we have to we're the only ones who need the Sun and the moon to make peace the muslims only use the moon Ramadan will sometimes be in summer and sometimes be in winter gradually but we have an issue because it says summer asteroid ish loveth you have to guard the spring well say staff to guard we have to guard the spring you have to put security guards that the Sun should come up with such rubber as good as office but even though we follow the moon we have to make sure that Nissen isn't off if the problem isn't as soon as a moon so if we wouldn't do anything to our calendar what would happen is one year Pesach would be Nissen the next year Payson would be other season the next year would be the spot season after many years will be in the Chanukah season and the middle of winter you're gonna have pace and is pre our carbon am I supposed to find grain in the winter this trees are orphaned it's snowing outside what so the Jewish counters very complex yes because you have to make peace between two different orbits the secular the non-jewish calendar is the Sun the Muslim calendar is the moon the Jews make peace between both so that's why every few years you need a catch up so every two or three years you add 30 days to the moon every year it loses 11 days two years it loses 22 days three years it loses 33 days every two three years you add among the moon so to speak caught up so Tufts ngayon Zion is a long knocked off nine sign but when you have a leap year it becomes a longer year so the Sun is not so ahead of me you understand so the English my English birthday won't be so ahead they'll be closer to my Hebrew birthday because I added more days in my Thomas countrymen 19 years is the cycles of the calendar of the Jewish calendar goes by 19 years every 19 years the Sun and the moon have a perfect year and then it goes off you know this is days of the month days of the week that's why not if it's no that's oh you only add four days if you have exactly a year of 354 days no you can have three you can have 353 days you can have 355 days and you can have 380 plus days but with a leap year and you have to have if kiss live and Tavis if both Cashman and kiss till about twenty nine this this this one way yeah yeah that it becomes even its mamas even weeks it's an even I don't mean even I mean divided by seven Augustus because if eight this don't come knots of eight this testify for follow but the lockers of eight this don't testify so since everybody is honorable to be a day later so they told the eight this be quiet because the trader says that when the eight is testified but numbers are childish you have to make me say says if they testified best in the stuff if they didn't testify you understand they didn't testify they're not Maalouf to it so for the sake of that simple they said let's keep them quiet let's say a this don't calm there's no question that research on it becomes a day later right I'll be tighter even though the moon was visible okay but it's a different type of game so he says that's where the Pinay issue says if they actually testify that if they saw the moon and you didn't and you question them and they're accurate then he says if I follow a lot of what now you can't say be quiet anymore because I feel it to be quiet oh you could make such an investigation that they get confused that's fine they don't get confused and besten can't manipulate that okay let's call from Morales three lines from the bottom so the summation of the sig is after Allah said that in his days they were Morello and they made Rosh Hashana none on day 30 but on day 31 which was a hideth and he explained how grateful the people of bhavo what to be for that since it was done for their benefit so the Gemara got into a long discussion about the whole logic mechanism to be able to do that if it happens that way it happens that way because the witnesses came late they didn't come on day 30 so it happened that way well what was the locking mechanism to do it the one who first brought the price which created a problem a price that rabbit bar Shmuel quoted the Brice's says that you can't compare making a leap here to making a leap month one you could do the surra one you can't do it sir one is based on the needs of commas wrong but so you're and one is based on the facts of Khazaria Eva Kaddish I've heard you chose alpha which obviously would undermine what all's said they did in there too so that was the big problem that the Gemara address so the first distinction L was made by rober according to most cases Rama is that there's a difference between delaying the month delay English Hashanah adding a date of the month and taking away all day in other words making the month twenty nine days to make it thirty days that's not problematic even according to this price why because it doesn't undermine the Khazaria a the Kaddish doesn't do that as Rashi says they're doing kiddush a high dish after they saw the moon they're doing in a day later but they're doing it after they saw the moon and therefore it's not a problem of course only if it's with siren as both the players showing the Oracle and they explained that if atheists would come and say on day 30 that we saw the moon then so to speak Vesta would not be able to do anything cuz that the day that has to begin a chef i dish what they could do is as he explains that it was sure burn lady said my man our aid them you could cause the aid them to be quiet and not speak and burn mela on day 31 automatically becomes recitation if the a this would explicitly come and say a this that there's nothing you can do this mom is nothing you can do nope no even a lot even all the such brightness of vegetables and dead and lawyer do rush and so forth which is how the autocollimator answers how people shout the question how can it be that from the days of Ezra through the days of Revlimid see no LMAO ber if whenever a Shoshanna is supposed to be on a Sunday or on a Wednesday or on a Friday whenever the Cashman is you're gonna push it off you certainly gonna have a richer shot on a Sunday and a Wednesday and Friday right that was taste versus question so what's the chart upshot is that know if a does come and say ages there's nothing you can do if the actions are kind right factors who says that are clear anything says the washing of the washing of relishable maybe is my min our ADA my wife edition abysmally macabre you intimidate the ADA sue come because you want to make a bore what says you intimidate versus you intimidate you investigate there's so much cross-examination at one point a say you know what maybe tacit maybe right right so DARS Lynette says why don't you just say you don't accept a this don't it says no we can't do that my I mean in other words if the aegis actions are fine they don't get intimidated island all right right look I sent you yeah Mama's hundreds and hundreds bubble let's take a dyke he says that the son had to didn't want to do a type of a bother because they wanted they wanted to shine back you saying after the corn burn already you saying they were upset at the B'nai ball moment in the time of the race emitters they were presented since it's only for been a bubble not I just saw nobody debate I said the game artist says it that you saw there's more ear and your cuz I'm a somebody yeah but the Gemara says was been a buff so he's saying that may become invasive it was a special session they wanted to blame over should make aliyah they didn't wanna laughter the Corbin so I'll call ponder if the a this would not be intimidated for father nothing you can do mr. Shaughnessy Shoshanna it's not like endless liberty to like a filler manipulate what you want well why can't we said it understand that Allah is talking yeah astronomically he was supposed to be the day to day 31 and they find an excuse they said and we have more power because we also have Jews okay but he says my mind means you have a tea soup and say they saw society that's that's nice soft if you'll take a look you know what it could I could take a look at Amanda phenomenal on the top you see the top on the left dr. Morales Peola armored Abreu Allah Allah Allah comes and says they made an e-book level you see the way to come on you have yes he says like this Colima it's today Kathy I'm a scientist shall is to be at best didn't Veeru Allah Elmo has all different part they needed based of the tradition that there would have been tradition there's enough how you have to calculate astronomy that they were experts in they decided that Allah has to have 30 days Bipin a he says Chikara soy de Bourgh this is called we'll see soon in the Gemara the secret of he board the secret of adding a day rippen asia beds didn't like how Yuma gala noise say L aluminum Manan why is it called a secret talk about it the answer is because la polla was a secret they would not share the information with everybody only limbus aman and people that were invited by best and to decide about making leap years making weak monkeys now right right the same freshmen right perhaps not mahalia Isis Shana this is volatile Isis on a young la Midler ello y om are some of the Shabbos been more phenomenal Akira it happened to be that that year the 30th day of ello would have been a day right near Shabbos either a Friday lafawn now or lockira Sunday it would have been that way in other words if Rosh Hashanah would have been la Modelo that way with so many years that would have been right before chakras right after shows vicki von Schirach will look he brew best and Lallu when Allah saw that best in a night shot made elbow 30 days need to man law it seemed to him Shabazz did Muhammad not Sahaj our layover - on a bed of Shambhala becca-boo Shabbos the purpose is they don't want that recessional should be on a Friday or Sunday with Natasha serve Hashem means a temporary needs a temporary needs so loyal of harbor base conditions careful they didn't want to connect to Holy Days as one meaning Friday sharp and stop a Sunday why make white Mason either because of respect for the dead right or you could go in simplest jumped if Botanica ruckus okay it's a bet either the covet of the Mason office simcha something they should have the pleasure of vegetables but then he says verse Halima well I be ll a Mercedes to Masuda be under my motion event don't think they're making leap years only Bayes they're only doing it based on the Messiah that they have formation remain of how you have to make the search bonus to keep it consistent with the realities of astronomy that's preposterous what he said I will make sure loin is gallo ha a crib when somebody doesn't know these principles these fundamental principles behind behind the counter yeah kalila that they've stamina a burr even just for the vegetable reason right there was something behind it there was something behind it I wish Elena's gala were occurring for people who don't know these principles be clear my like the principles the Assizes McDormand PR called Silas Marvin they think all there was is in other words that was a freshman it was a head was a false husband but that wasn't the before yeah we really know it's supposed to be this way but you know what the omen needs this let's do it he says no there were a secret exponent but that wasn't the conversation why was it a sign the pastor's so different before should say the reason is because this was you know the calendar by the Jewish people is like it's the it's it's one of the keys of Jewish existence you know pasted some Jewish Scriptures Helen kind of everything everything all the old institutions of Yemen toy from etc so therefore they kept this only four beds in and the top experts because they were afraid that if everybody knows it so then a person huh they're gonna make you make their own Chris voidness and then challenge and I becomes mark locusts in the disputes and so forth once you don't have a best in anymore and you don't have a this a you don't have this centralized Authority of 71 people who can decide together so then they were already Mikhaylovich bonus that to make a calendar and they had to do this for thousands of years told me as summer she could have shop it over they didn't know but as long as you're gonna have to have it they won't be killed shop here here that's releases rehab after Bowser my ruler ain't some so dazzled over television even about Commission is say oh this is a must like this so he's myself on move art the new Vaart is it's not just that if the a this would come and takest say today we saw the moon bears the would have not a choice the only thing they can do is intimidate them to be quiet or cross-examine them so heavily that they ultimately create uncertainty and therefore they're quiet and then you make rich fudge the other then the only reason they would do it is all me why mid sod maracas and Messiah but he says actually there was something even deeper it was an element of side a which - do you mean I was in rashes on our that way right to do with the reasons [Music] the practice for pastors the pastor's ah pastors this of course if we accept this remain a phenomenal it gives another answer to the question of theis vez how is it that for hundreds of years of Shoshana would not be Sunday Wednesday Friday hundreds of years so this gives an interesting perspective places what what when what see no elbow but if this is a reason for it born the answer is it's not them it's not some be a raucous amazed and that's it what size of a bush those were the masses right and perhaps and perhaps you can add there were certain ways you could manipulate things and maybe they chose it this way because there was this added benefit but this was not the exclusive issue it was something like thank you know yeah but then the Rambam says something impossible been awesome Lena I'm Cameron shoppers just say they need your wisdom for the nation's aside [Music] well it says a demon bajada you say it happens to be a favor it's not the only reason was for a favor that's this point and Ivania Donnell says kalila why is it kalila by him kalila means because it's not stops you know a joke absolutely yeah no clue so this is uh another part another void that semantic thing another part yeah she the pastor says that it's not a student to consider a countess because at least you didn't take offered them you didn't do it before they saw them or that's how a she puts it actually puts it that it was shot in my eyebrow ray vittatus hood it's just the conditions a day later so this is the first this is our rabbit explained it that was a stupid show up on life this mother brought a second grocery dish maybe who didn't see I told him I sent a message to her mommy the tabulation and his whole life said that you could be my I am under a this and to say they sought even though they didn't see it in other words you could make recite this a day early even though the haters didn't see it you can intimidate them to say these sorts it's sort of like they seize the moon so you have hundreds or maybe thousands of years of a new king correct well there's a missional later we're going to learn that they're obviously people if not if that was service where people okay so what's your question so give me that took timethat a lot of people you know they have no food in wine to get drama they don't but they would make meals they wouldn't know he's saying article owner says you couldn't not accept ADIS you couldn't say we're not accepting this year my I mean you have to accept them and investigate them to say when I'm a cop away there's none already under kappa latest so mary brings are dire that if they're stubborn and they say we saw always saw some attachment we saw fences okay doesn't know his work doesn't always work it can and then you waited another day if you wanna know you ask one other question how 400 some years you want to know we're never cloudy and the night of Rosh Hashanah yeah he's asking them at sea is for hundreds of years it was never cloudy and aid this were always there day 30 to say that his elephant right to say that it's a dish by dish accepted did they miss their mother which liked ice was that to the recently went see no a loom over yeah why would it be in the future that way because maybe a this won't come that means for hundreds of years ages came didn't over 500 years there was not 129 ll at night with a cloudy night the night surround the whole of Arts is strong but nobody could see in working dissolution I know some people out walking yes not make you go on a donkey in yeah you've known a donkey and a horse yeah yours because it could be much I was happy Mikasa feels fat and you go with the time to smartphones right no trust one up right because you need more time but even if you if even if you're 12 hours even if you could have to walk a whole night and a whole day before spear you come yeah that means anywhere Nexus know where you could get there in 23 22 hours you go that's pretty far may not beat sauce but yeah but it's pretty far and yeah I think I could take a donkey take a horse remember you can be Mahalo service for these guys you know the Qataris II think attack see even though this is Silas you know come Shabbos home and of course all the shows some of using an animal okay so the abuse women Center was the biggest that you can even go backwards in other words you can make the fighters 29 days after they carve and that's the my Ayman my aemond to say to the atheists that they saw it even though they didn't see it and again as I've been a phenomenal explain here to see your banished animal is mixing in here to say that it's not so far it doesn't mean they see anything it means they saw but they're doubtful or he complained about and you intimidate them you lead them to say that what it was the moon in order to be able to make sorry disarm day 29 which was hybrid there's no cos na evocati sure at least as a suffolk because the ADA's have a doubt and on this we added with a play insurer says again he's mom ticket that this wasn't done stamp they couldn't do it stop can only happen if astronomically through their calculations they knew that threshold is supposed to be Dave thirty another word that it's already after the Moylan that the moon was born even though the agents themselves would back would retract but best didn't already knew it and therefore as we know when there's no ages that works in other words it's not the way to do it it's not the Mitzvah it's not the look I feel ideal way of doing it but with the evidence there's nothing right if there wouldn't be the concept of ages like we have today they could be my cottage defenders on day 30 because as he puts it you dehydrate you Korea the to the ocean of the peninsula so that's what happened and that's why the Buchanan allowed it how do you reconcile the beautiful nun with the price or the Buchanan with Rama on this a buyer said it depends listen and Tishrei or other months the patched us listen and tisha where they have the Yemen Titan so therefore they allowed them to do it they allow themselves to do it other Yemen are the mums they would not allow themselves to do it to go back according to this Raisa and therefore there wouldn't be a contradiction between the vehicle and the bryson there wouldn't be a contradiction between Rob and Rubio similar clothes of yours haven't allowed it only in this initially that's how a buyer a body explains a body explains the answer some it's interesting entices happiness in a petition a he says finish my conscience sham Maya the still young man macaques Inlet Saira mushaira feel a missile initially with the a vehement even then you could be Mikado CH - hi - Latoya for the need even though the atheists are hesitant why cuz the Maya this Attali why is that a reason of them the satola with either you have the issue of your kiss and Mason but not other months but yes for some it doesn't begin with seitan right these are the facts it's just a factor so this of the Moya destroy in behan so therefore here they do it the actual first room is some safe something in one is the exact opposite missile initially they would never do this the other months they would do it in other words missing in Tishrei because the Moya this are probably they didn't want to play around yeah for carat if this anus if there's no wages on day 30 there's no way this they just say you know what we're not so sure okay we'll push it off for that because the midis are taller and you can add for an ad that's gonna other months they said okay well we'll use this mechanism to to adjust it to make it a day early other months we'll do it if we have to do it father months another reason you could save shout out what the reason you wanted we doesn't say cuz they're a the condition about which one missing like this as a little hemorrhage the distribution or lashana right so the afford is a swatted to say that African listen you have to be marked a bit because they relieve the cottage that's where the possible set this was said about rich tradition is that was the first prescribed this of Jewish history a high this as a lock em so maybe here has to because they're a the card is you know manipulate ages T she also says pico bhai this side from a castle am hanging on you should blow safer behind ish so that could be the second smother anti so it's not like an action that's proportional obscure the Tish Tennyson you want a real cuz they're David Carr dish and therefore they this are not certain you're gonna wait till day 31 you should have for sure he is Alabama Marsh ain't Kane the other months not but a she did not look like that actually learned not shot business in and Tishrei I mean with the money this at all oh you could manipulate my think another months you did not go back a day but certainly who was right that they could be my a bordello they could certainly add a day that's almost like was only about taking off with it then there was a of Rover and Rover said this whole Bryce's but mal following a dicey then that sort of mayor of Maine has his own way with the calendar as we said it made had this consist of the husband of one week one month twenty nine one month thirty 2930 2930 he had his perfect years of 354 days and that's where he always knew when you had dressage don't know when the next session son is gonna be four days later Elite P it's gonna be five days later and he is the author of that Brice so he is the man that on the bind that Bryson says we don't play around with anything only eBrush Anna not even a Kurdish we don't add we don't take off we don't increase we don't decrease no sir there's nothing this is how mayor viewed the halacha even though most of the timonium did not perhaps it probably did not agree with them and therefore this McLamore is true there's no problem from this price it to Allah this price is only sister mayor Allah is not holding sister may like most time I am there's no problem to be a senator beautiful certainly doesn't all that to sort of may and talk gonna be sure believe me and repuation and they have their own you can add you can take off you don't also have to say the difference of this identity and other months based on this right because you don't have to reconcile the two sources we put the Brice in the world of rip mayor okay that's that I want to learn the toys via my stash Honorable Barris Commission it's a very interesting tasters remember the mayor's Cashman a year has 354 days three hundred and fifty days makes up fifty weeks yeah how many sevens the oven 350 you have 57 so if the year would be three hundred and fifty days flat without change if Richard Shana was Sunday next year is your son will be Sunday right because if a year would be seven seven seven seven it's a much higher just like we always know for example with Spheeris various 49 days over several weeks so therefore the first day of Spira yeah whenever it begins but you're gonna have several weeks flat so if you would have 350 days you would have fifty weeks so Fisher summer was Sunday the next new it's gonna be Sunday Monday Monday problem is it's four days extra whatever you made says not problem just push it off four days of finish on the one year with Sunday the next year it's Thursday Monday the next day it's Friday Tuesday the next day of shops what about a leap here the mayor holds you add on other and how long is that are there 29 days 29 days has how many we so that's four weeks in one day so you have to add one more day so if you have a leap here so fresh Hashanah was some day the next day our son is gonna be Friday they have Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday you add five days and you are done this is a painless and he says you can always rely on it why can you always rely on it because we're sticking to 354 days why are we sticking to 354 days because every month is gonna be 2930 2930 consistently this is a I it says Cosette you're a vittatus he olds because they're Ava condish means they have to do it based on the time when the moon is visible based on the cash bonus the time when the moon is visible but so you have to do it and therefore we do 2930 2930 it works and it's consistent the moon never changed a quality of mayor a qualitative man earlier in the Gemara we had different this right if it was me 30 then it would be six not five yeah so ty service says this in my session I'm embarrassed if it was a leap year then it has to be commissioned you see the last place was on Navajo Amidala sucked oysters bare Cain in the city Amari my secretary conduct as part of the Gemara asked a question Bonnie Kay Yaya I'm just gonna read it according to the final gift for iki Joyner that Lawson snin Haider every three years you have an extra day what shot what is he talking about he makes a very interesting mix of the coal Shana a deficit by Amon - is tough tough I invoke Allah you see if the moon's orbit would be perfect 29 days and 12 hours exactly after 29 days a period of 24 hours 29 times and then exactly 12 hours the moon would say finished house ousted the Pacer I'm done let's start over again you're great one month 29 days 1 month 30 days and the 12 months you got it covered you're perfect with the moon you want the phone right the problem is that the moon is not so kind to us it's a little more than that it's not exactly 29 days and 12 hours huh yes yes it's an extra right so he says at the end of the year if you make the hedge burn you have 354 days and eight hours and tough tough I involve 876 Calaca now what happens she says but are you so - I saw is these eight hours that you have every year you said big deal what you want to get it he says no oh you little so the shaman Lee iMac Liang Shan in three years it's gonna make up a day that's an extra day that's what's gonna happen why how much is three times 8 24 8 16 and 24 so every three years you have one more thing if every year I know that's right I said I'm doing it according to the right gear so you see ice okay now one second why does it say chelation so that's why if you see this Duffing guess so now let's add for our son hahahaha lock him the 876 parts MIT styrofoam Lee Jung Shaolin Lesage solution Shama at the end of 30 years he could have another day another day besides yeah at the end of the year you have extra eight hours plus tough tough IMO so tough to find buff doesn't look like a big thing which says eight hours right 3 times 8 is 24 so 24 hours every three years you have an extra day besides every day of an extra 876 columbian after 30 years you got another day three seconds and a third of a second let me tell you why how it works this way they make it actual 876 Caloocan in 30 years okay you have a thousand and eighty hello come an hour a thousand and eighty a locum an hour yeah that's how it works okay look is is three seconds and a third what we say three seconds and a third that's ok look you have a thousand and eight eeka lokka min an hour okay if you now over 30 years multiply each year we have 876 help him you end up with twenty six thousand two hundred and eighty halakha twenty-six thousand and two hundred and eighty-two locum over thirty years okay take twenty six thousand two hundred and eighty okay and divide them into a thousand and eighty halacha which is an hour and you have 24 hours and thirty three coloca 24-hour MS twenty-four hours and thirty six that means after 30 years you have an extra day so after three years you have an extra day this mean that if mayor's husband is not true is not completely accurate right after this - after three years there's another day you have to push it off another day so toaster says you're right oh my shiny little more explains masoom the less typical Samba like the caution it's not that it may didn't know about this since it doesn't happen every year he's not making he's not putting it part in his henchman it has to be accounted for you it will be so when he says between the church Sunday and Sunday this four days he doesn't mean there's always four days so when he says a leap here this five days he doesn't mean that sin in there is if it's a thirtieth year it's gonna be another day if it's after three is it's gonna be another day since it's not a consistent thing called some elective option it's a harder right jump to good martyr you want to ask something 24 hours we have a thousand and eighty for welcome in an hour vitamin D ruff did me okay comes the commader now and brings another brings another sit in the meantime we had how many shits is 3 shitless we had the of the Bryce so that said nothing is up for grabs nothing is up for grabs best in that's never marbled insider mama the fiendish latina the way we're tripping it at the end according to the mayor we had the shiva to be sure burn LaVey there my man our aid them for what to be a Wyatt to add a date and we have the of Ljubljana you can that all those years he taught my man I laid them even to make destroyed should they early and make the month 29 now comes the next riff D me Menard da Mosta if you see where we are yeah one two three three lines from the bottom cuff format all of the last words on the line riff d me Mina Hamas me if rep D me who came from the city of nard dog in bhavo he used to teach the opposite of Libby schäuble AV every Sherman lady said you intimidate ADA's can silence them because you want three straight just to be the next day remedy me is mastery if that's the different is because opposite of let me show up in levy what's the opposite he said my I'm an ally them you can intimidate the people who come to testify Alec I dish shall I need abyss money the ADIS on the month on the new moon shallow near abyss mana which is not clearly visible in its time on day Licata you intimidate to the a this that they should testify about this moon that it's not so clearly visible it's not a blatant obvious reality you can intimidate them like actually in order to make restoratives that day they ate my I'm in a la a demolition in abismo night but you do not intimidate a de su came to testify that they saw the moon on day 30 there's no way that you intimidate them library because have a black eye just because you want a month to be a day later so in other words his svatah spooked his dinner spoon-fed to be sure but maybe says to delay Niska fella to take off that's a big problem no Bo Sherman disagreed first we thought maybe missing and Tishrei and other months there's no argument right the calling Tobiah pointed oven now there's a real man like us here and then you have the over them didn't you says the opposite to make a day to make a month 29 days that you can do to make a month 30 days even though it's supposed to be 29 days that you don't do that's what he says maha shiva maha shiva my time' why why the sivaraman sha'ban lady we understood cuz I read the Kaddish right to make 30 destroyed dish is more severe than to make to make 30 destroyed this when day 31 is supposed to be rich like this is far more problematic ostensibly than the other way around to make 31 there's choices when 30 is misguided as well actually said because to make third either stylish when 31 is supposed to be destroyed is there's no cause I rave accomplished but to make 30 wondrous squares one day 30 supposed to be is the work because I rev it up fine coming in your husband so that's what we explained something a phenomenal yeah that you have to say but what's my I'm in LA that we who you intimidating they didn't come they didn't come there's nobody even timid it you take two people say come I want to intimidate you I mean you have to understand right even though it actually doesn't say this actually just says tell them to lie so to speak I mean what it would be appellate the Khazar correct this famous Lamarque shall our now she says he doesn't understand he says if bez Dhin hazekiah to him a card is destroyed it without ages so stop threatening people just do it what are you kicking but telling them to life so that's Rebecca mama tells us they saw but you can easily you can easily get them to doubt it so Miami that should word behind man means mind means you lead them you you pressure it you convince them you verbally convince them but remember you're not lying that this is a very nice sort of the planes do it astronomically best in is right it is the day but but this doesn't mean they saw it or they don't have doubts right sometimes it's cloudy you may see something for a second and look at the moon not bei this yeah but it's not like Bezdek is manipulating them to an event ash a qualitative technique seems like all 12 months and it we show but maybe also said all 12 months maybe show maybe the opposite all 12 months yeah so this is the village of limit and if you open and said everything Osuna be excellent said both ways the bersonin said both ways he didn't care trainee where my time but what would be the reason for the Bedini still like so he says a whole different work tomorrow says I met as it could could highlight matters edition one looks like a lie and one doesn't look like a lie what job so let's see that hi Mexico sugar shanira's bhisma know when the moon appears Huff Huff from a base when the moon appears in the right time what's the right time I shouldn't say the right time when the moon appears in the time and the time means it's not a delayed birth in other words when the moon appears on day 30 internet cloudy and right vena meetin higher bay the enemy did and the atheists are not saying a this.y they not saying gay this because besan is like Shh oh say tell them and then come back and it's gonna be skier or they make investigations to the point of the ADA's back off it actually says hi Bay I hate him yes your oh there's many many other there may be thousands and thousands and thousands of people the moon doesn't belong to a certain group everyone could see the moon so many other sorts the nitish salsa curry brutal so when they hear suddenly that there's traditions that they laid there like who's running the show here it was his politics era who's running this show and so I saw the mood 29 I saw a beautiful moon and not beautiful I mean it can't be beautiful but that's you know the sickle the little the little sliver has a little sickle was not cloudy you yeah and suddenly destroyed dishes add a lake which show that this interest rate is date 30 not day 31 it doesn't have a good flavor actually says neither so secondly but not that they were sacrament not that they did it was second yeah I there was a husband of of site de Bourgh was was that they have the permission to do it because the ages lapel didn't say aid this and there was excited about Shalu vom Rua Inu ain't a second either he calls it a second he says when they didn't see it nobody's see it and this to aid this who said they saw it nobody sees a lie there's no lie that's known what's the Lord took I saw I didn't know look and we have a cluttered a know and I I didn't see them who means there's no moon if I saw the moon it means it's a moon if I didn't see them when it doesn't mean this normal that's the clock right if you saw something it means it's not the opposite if you didn't see it I didn't see it so he says this is matters a curricular this is not mass efficient in other words it's clear that his - is that beds and everything is mud - just like ritalin beds and everything this but you can make it 29 days if you have the authority for it if you have the mechanism for it he can make it 30 days look pile this we did this we didn't do because this appears like a lie and it's counterproductive and this doesn't appear here you see how the concern they are that people should not think should not be able to interpret things as just ah no just immoral unethical what arbitrary yeah it's a joke no it's Mexican Shitler you you want yours right it does not do it Toyota it's not MS the moment it's not MS you undermine trust when you undermine trust it's a terrible shame a shame a second Ida a nice Shack tonight does it actually mean that they asked the a this tool I would be a big fella because what do you what do you need a this for yeah it's just clearly a not shaken right that's not what would be another meaning why are you looking for another meaning but it's Marsh mother made in Tyler yep did me would hold that it could be my a brother Tyler just like even my cabbage let's I know it's not a problem right so the male or the Bryce where Robert said you now louder look higher he would also say like it's lip lifecycle it mayor so that would work how would you do me explain the price he would explain it according to that may Butler still you would have to say that by other and Elmo he's miter that you're not afraid about Massacre shaker why because Allah said that they were my a Borel look another they pushed it off a day but says Misaka Shakur last efficiently so could be that here you say you have to say in order to reconcile it with hula what they did in a gesture all that if did me with all that maybe for Evelyn other when it came for tissue and listen MIT salads I recover the Maya does they would they would they would they would do it the fighter that's that that's the marshmallows Zog the gimana on March 4 small came and he threw a bomb shot what did he say your Filner listen a look cooler gala I could fix up the situation for the entire exile sacra she was trapped you're homeless hakuna below urea seda I don't need witnesses to come and tell me when they saw the moon in order to establish her latest keep Bucky on me but told us olive on the look up must say that I was all cities next yeah so that's all we're gonna see who's that I'm an expert and tell the Silvana - Silvana it doesn't mean the history of them with me the birth of the Moon the Milo the he Luca its orbit its movement and the third thing is saying they're Hamas always say they're the masalas how is that connected so we'll soon see how that's connected with her why we deal with the masalas Lomb because that's connected to this whole harsh small was a top top expert in astronomy the gomorrah says that small said right that shrill leader up here and hearing leakage shielded in a heart dog he lived in a hard dog he says I know the pathways of heaven just like I know the paths here in the city in our dog just like you know for che and how to get to your house that's how he knew the highways that have in other words in other words small was saying he was such an expert of how it works so for the whole Binet guy that he could fix up the situation why fret ah certainly face he's talking to the hevener small lived in bother in Babylonia the time of small but pastors they were still McAllister high disappear which Moore was a colleague of RAF this is the first generation of a Miriam remember Kitty sorry disappear here continued till according to most Dalit Allah from Co few tests that would be three hundred and no but they had a bastard and a this would come till 358 until the middle of the fourth century so you're dealing with hundreds of years after corn based on meekness it ended after the generation of a by a robber who generations after average four but nonetheless the Vinayaka Allah who this Lucien did not arrive to they all had to do there two days there two days Yemen toy him or one day darshan according to Rashi or two days Iran and other ailment paper because he didn't know so small comes and says since I know exactly when destroy dishes about I know exactly how the moon works so therefore I could tell the B'nai ago the when destroy dish is supposed to be similar to what we do with our calendar which is based not on witnesses coming but based on astronomical calculations but this is a very long time before a man named room Hilo makes the calendar and small says I could be moussaka and everything a fixed up the situation of all the been a gorilla by telling and making the system every restore this one that's supposed to be and following that pattern without aid this coming another I don't even have to look up I don't need anybody coming that's what's most us now what did he mean practically what did he mean practically he was just like trying to say that he knows astronomy or he was trying to it wasn't just trying to say he knows a secret I've said I know astronomy which he did say he was saying something that he would like to do at least theoretically was Hallman Angela basically in the McFarland is three different interpretations which more meant practically one interpretation is that what he meant was that he can actually do it he can actually do it even though it's not air too strong even though there's no best dn't there's a best but not an exit song nonetheless ah what nothing we're in Volvo yeah nonetheless sOooo felt that he has a right to do it in other words why similar what the Rambam says the way the rebel explains could shock Irish that this two options if you have a best didn't ever son had room they have a this then cuz i rave accomplished and if not the Ramban believes it's a local emotionless you know that what you could do with based on astronomical calculations so he said we're stuck we're stuck just like in the time when you don't have Sanhedrin you're stuck and therefore you do option B he says we're far away and we're stuck we don't have that we don't get this look I'm coming since we don't get this looking coming so therefore he would make his own institution now that would be a very big finish because that would mean that theoretically right they would they could be different times and it wouldn't be it wouldn't go crazy off but there could be different honest but instead of us doing two days we're gonna do one day so this would be much like a breakaway - a breakaway you this guy but a breakaway minion literally yeah that's how the cosine ish learns the Gemara they're doing this my own abuse shock effect that will later be sure you call me mister keuner it's under the second home that's one perspective another perspective is no no fine but they were but they didn't do a but they didn't bother yeah yeah yeah no they can't they can't substitute air to straw that's the place to do it if ye near come over to straw then that Lawson is you can have a best in huts Lords do it all there's lying whoever the Sanhedrin was they move they moved around a lot of places they were in Gavin er anything they weren't supported me they weren't osha they had to leave after the harbour they couldn't stay near alliances they moved to Yavana and then they moved other places sensual authority of the jewish community this was they made all the decisions there was no more locus about kidneys none was fired in ashkenaz was like I said about anything they decided and I was it there was a vote and that was it okay ah so that's one orphan that mamas complete independence yeah another another other before some say it's not much more meant which war meant was that you're homeless hakuna look open Angola to be able to anticipate what they decided in 8 sister all even without slaughter that would be her that's much more definition plat not so radical to be able to anticipate through my face - what they would have decided what they would decide that's what I could do that's a whole different that's a different vibe well actually the curly the schooner Bolivia said that I could get there you are yeah that's that's that's another that's that's that's a possible option that's what he means I don't need a this why cuz I know how it's supposed to be I could figure it out right right right yep right but I can anticipate what they're gonna say we're gonna say and then looking up in a kimono the top of government base he says keloid Meyer you see calamari I should because lavish of cash burnished on them will the sack and Asia summits Russia Ybor I can tell you which year needs a leap here the same but reduction is registered is less a burn I'd be a Seagal with Sascha Maassen Hydra I can do this to be a cigar once an ad from here it's Marsh ma the brisker of rights issue disagrees rights that there been a phenominal believe that small was already after condition I disappear a year not like we usually assume and therefore he said I'd be as go outside that till you gonna have the Sun had read in other words that he was already talking post that's a whole third interpretation that he was talking already post condition finish up the area and he says I can decide everything tell me Shia come and we're gonna have a new son Hydra which is a different interpretation completely because the Rambam says that till i buying over yet catastrophize ish so this would be a different interpretation this Bovada me it's additional come on in other words he's basically saying he can make our calendar you'll see what happened why let's just assume in the camel it's just add beer Segovia's yeah shove a son hydrant according to the first interpretation now what are the first update is a son had read we don't just we just don't have contact with them so I'm gonna make my own Chris - a better son I'm gonna say something unseen right right my shaking raashi Rogers you filled with sinless Acuna below yes aid them from rashly it's maxima that there is Reyes Aiden I just don't have it right a hole very a whole a whole different part I didn't know or you say below he ascended because of it but the common denominator is that small was thinking about the Jews living in gala the solution we're not coming to them and therefore they did not know when kiddush a conditions so he says I can I can do it I can do it for everybody let's just see one which one line here this is what he said on my leg I by who was it up similar leash more I but the father Ripper similarly told small yoga meyerheim Ilsa the Tanya beside them you say you know it all right do you know could you explain to me what we learned we learned a brighter insider Ybor what soy dave was a grouchy Bryce's new you berry Muslim there's a brighter that was written in code language so it's called soy de Bourgh brighter it's a price about the moon but it was written in sight in the cold language yeah yeah and and till tell me since you're an expert tell me what it means in that bright so when it says these words know that them cuts oil and oil advocates us there's a difference if the moon was born before hot size or after Rashi says caps on Reba that's the text remembers by Almo it's a code lime mark item cuts are is how look man I love our cat sighs huh rather than say there's a difference if it was gone before on my life small tells small tells the father of Reps employee lawyer I don't know the difference I don't know what that means on my lay suribabu tells swallow me the hollow your damar if you don't know this it can be laughter in the US of the layout of mine there's probably some other stuff you don't know and therefore you cannot do this now she says your damar my hillock yesh you don't know the difference of the school of therefore you're not capable of doing addition addition in other words the Boehner phenomenal says what's of what what's the Vaart what's divorce family was telling him you don't know small says he does not so where been a phenominal says what he was telling him here that there's certain things that are not based only on astronomical calculations through certain things that had to come down through tradition from generation to generation that best in got all the way back Lamantia Messina and that's that you have to not do McAllister fighters and others you know everything that you could know with your hands - but the certain other things that you had to receive and therefore you can do it and that I guess put the lid on schools plan to do it the next the next so key of gomorrah is one of the very very fascinating and complex suga's not only a vicious Shonda but of the whole shots where the Gemara is gonna try to decipher what these words mean how the mullet works how the moon orbits and the mid-session we're gonna do that we're gonna resume that on Monday night this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot a yeshiva net / donate