Murder At a Purim Feast?! | Rabbi YY Jacobson

the yeshiva dotnet [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Laughter] [Music] Oh [Music] some stories in the Gemara are uniquely perplexing today we're going to learn one of those stories which at first glance and even at second glance and I think even its third glance seems completely inexplicable and literally incomprehensible how do you explain such a story let's learn it inside its your first source it's in the Gemara that's dedicated to the festival of Purim which is of course mastectomy Gila DAF Zion on midbass page 7b says the Gomorrah on my rava Ravi said valuev in mikheyev initially basu me burp urea a person is obligated to drink to become some is not only to drink Rashi says least occur by ayan to become inebriated to become intoxicated through wine the puri on Purim add to the point Allah yada he does not know the difference been our Ramallah Boris Mordecai between cursed his Amun and blessed as Mordecai that's the extent to which rava says the obligation of intoxication on Purim is that's the end of rava statement now the Gemara tells a story rabid observer of do Sudha's Purim Baha da da dee - of the great sages the Babylonian sages robber and rubies era made a festival a feast of Purim together if some if some means during the feast Nesta crew they both became intoxicated come Robert Shaw still it is a lie Robert stood up and he slaughtered he killed him sailor lamothe car the next day boy alchemy Vasya he asked Ramona she prayed beg - em and he brought the Azalea back to life with Shawna the next year on male rabbit algebra NASA Mar when avid Suda's pool in Baja da da dee let the master come and again we'll do the sudha of poor him together on male dubs area told him LOI Bacall site of a site the misra fishness miracles don't happen whenever you want them to happen and therefore as we say in English thank you but no thank you I'll pass this time I'll just do this soda with my wife and my children without your participation that's the end of the story the Gemara goes on to another subject in the halacha of the suitor of Peru the wonder of this story is quite obvious it needs no elaboration any Jew any human being sitting at a meal drinking even to a point of inebriation is it really possible that robbers stood up and killed he slaughtered she shafted herbs area because he was drunk on Purim this is dummy murder is considered one of the most Cardinal greatest grave criminal sins in Judaism and really in every functional civilization Leutze and here a man who had a little too much to drink murdered another person another Jew his own colleague this question would be on any person and this question would certainly be on any leader and any great mind at any great scholar but it becomes even more perplexing considering robbing the gomorrah says about robber in my sector brofist of some mcauliffe that robbed they were talking about a bay ninny right so robber said could going on knob a ninny I'm AB a ninny Amalia byah byah who was a student and his nephew says leche avec ma high a little barrier you're not letting anybody else live because if you're AB a nanny if you're only a bain and if you own a intermediary man that means we're all wicked we certainly can't compare to you in not letting anybody live this is the esteem that robber was held in the gomorrah says above Mencia they're rabble I posted pullin my gears he never stopped learning for a moment to the point that the Angel of Death had to could devise a whole strategy how to take his soul and when they took when he took his soul they asked robber than a question there was a debate the gomorrah says mcqueen should coach a brittle and miss iftody Rukiya between hashem and the heavenly shiva about a certain form of leprosy if it's pure or impure if it's Suffolk if my hair is quite a mess let's say a loved one a sale of academic lemare is a whole discussion there about a certain form a doubt if the person is pure or impure Hashem is arguing with the heavenly Academy and the Gomorrah says they decided who are we gonna ask robbers man tasks cuz he said on New York had been a guy money I'm the man task and as his so left he says to her he says start so you're talking here about a person who is literally considered one of the Gedaliah door the greatest of his generation you're going to tell me that I'm poor him in the middle of the stood that he got inebriated and he murdered his chef that he slaughtered his colleague him sailor why from watch from drinking besides this major question there's a few other questions no less perplexing the governor says Lamarr carboy alchemist out here even the most drunk person you just slaughtered somebody wake up sober up Lamar Nam still a long night tomorrow robbers decides you know what we have to do something he brings him back to life he went to sleep he went to relax he took a break he went to davon for sicken in the morning it's so strange dis Lamar of course perhaps the most perplexing questioners with Shama habo the next year he invites him for another suitors Porter I would expect the Gemara to say a whole year he was asking the Hillier every day he went to plead forgiveness to repent for this terrible terrible mistake no there's not a mention of asking forgiveness there's not a mention of remorse there's no mention of true ver of repentance there's no mention of sake vatan ISA man the harsh made no issue not not an ounce of regrets what yeah the next year he comes to me said we had such a great time last year didn't play Pierre vaccinations Marvin Eriksen is put about that Dorothy how do you even have the guts to come to him and invite him for another service for him you know what you did last year it was as though it was the most pleasant tranquil experience within Pope do we put him so many years we'd such a great ambience our home wanted to come back we'll celebrate again perhaps even more perplexing these ribs ADA's response libs aided them kidnapped on cooking with a bargain website it should have given as an apple it's a joke Nevada doesn't say that I'm sayin you know what I've been principal not a problem I would be loved I would love to come to your house for so this Porter I have just one technical problem Navajo scientist recite the Messiah miracles don't happen every day what should I tell you if I knew miracles happen every day go ahead go ahead let's do it all over again this is a response first of all what do you need the whole problem for even if miracles happen every day this is what you need to be slaughtered number two listener evil a admitted show how could you put somebody else's enough that puts somebody else in a situation of doing this in any sin ever monstrousness dumb a murder and equally perplexing is the way the Gemara tells the story as they say in Hebrew Adi should count what the K hate straightforward simple no issues it happened almost like matter-of-fact two lines next this robber who we learn about constantly in Gomorrah one of the greatest sages and one of the greatest masters of terrible pen his generation and forever for all of Jewish generations we're learning about podium you should know by the way this is not happened to murder who reps ADA so over the generations many of them are for sure many of the commentators have naturally addressed this story a mastectomy Guillory there are various answers or attempts and answers that have been given huh okay one is one is that it doesn't mean he slaughtered him you could have guessed that it doesn't mean he slaughtered him the Gemara is using dramatic language to describe the fact that robber gave him too much to drink this happened still today you're sitting with somebody knock out drunk enough to know no such drunk you know how to drink your fellow your fellow your colleague doesn't know how to drink and observe it becomes terribly sick terribly ill they think he's going to die this is the view of none other than the Myers shot the Myers shot in his fiduciary goddess on Magilla this is what he says and the truth is we already have it in Erie showing him the me Erie Rubino Manasseh mama Erie in his commentary base up here I'm a sector Magilla already says this you'll take a look at the me Erie Charlotte Amy Lawson sceeto saw shot a he squeezed him he squeezed him it's only Lima je ma fight me ether he squeezed him Sita that's how you have to read it not shocked day but Saturday the a creamy lotion huskily main Eva Hakka a knee in Tanith we have bring me back to health bring me recovery he asked Rahman is that he should recover because in the process he was perhaps wild he squeezed him there was a form of violence but it was not an issue of death DeMarre sharp goes in the same line although a little bit differently kang shot it was like he slaughtered him meaning the ad where a camera he gave him lots and lots of wine abundance of wine Vic Vic for coffee a list I see I see me die he compelled them to drink too much you know another look I am another lifetime come on knock allah kiya access allah he fell ill vin not the lamas he was in danger of death so the next morning Robert sees what he did and he's like I give a degree by National Oil I'm help this man and absurdly recovers that's one what one Mahalo one perspective of course this solves a lot of the problems wasn't murder was insurances dominant and may have been a mistake it was a bad situation it wasn't good but of course it leaves us with the question why me back next year we had such a great time I almost caused you to die he's coming back next year even this is a pure prohibition of known as hive Ibaka very harming another person in any way including through giving them to drink in a way that's not suitable even if it's a mistake you come back next year but this certainly is one perspective the biggest problem with this perspective is the Gemara certainly doesn't give off this impressions shock they suck they it looked like he almost shafted him he got sick the gomorian says he stood up and he slaughtered thumbs in and the next day after he brought him to life there's another interpretation the other interpretation comes from the Malbin the malbim in a similar fashion is Medaille ik something interesting he says the Gemara should have said come robber this shocked a little Xena robbers stood up and slaughtered of Xena says robbers stood up slaughtered ribs a de there's a vomit there's an end missing over there come robber robber stood up he slaughtered the bazzetta should have been come robber Vishaka he stood up and he slaughtered him so the malbim says they were drinking a lot Epsom they both became intoxicated come rapper rabba stood up to go to retire shocked a little Xena the wine killed ribs eight or almost killed it up sailing come robber if it would have meant a rabbit stood up and slaughter dibs and others he stood up to kill him should have said come rabbit v shocked a little Xena so he says divide the story come rap rapper stood up and he had the physical prowess the physical and ability to hold to hold the vodka to hold the wine so therefore he could go retire but Sharky this event the event drinking the experience slowly dip sail which again is the Malden's interpretation similar to the marsh are similar to the miry although it would be difficult somewhat to understand why the Gemara writes it such a objectionable and strange fashion when it completely doesn't mean literally the unique shocking interpretation comes from to some sofa some safer ave no moisture safer in his not in his commentary and Gemara but in shyla such over some ciphering or a high in two places in two places in shouts of trivial some say for Italian he interestingly brings another Gemara to explain this Gomorrah says that some safer looking at my Rishabha scuffin and vomit Aleph the Gomorrah speaks there about people born on different days if you're born on Sunday you're going to be an eccentric if you have any Sunday's here you don't have to raise your hand you go either to one extreme or another extreme light or dark it's very hard for you to live in mitigation if you live on if you if you are Monday bad temperament you get angry ever short fuses any money you don't have to all raise your hand at the same time the humor goes through a whole a whole list I was born on Sunday but this is not a this is not a therapy session at the moment yet then the Gemara discusses not the day but the hour you were born every hour has is under the influence of a particular Mazal and the camera then discusses somebody who was born in the SHA in the hour when madam madam is which one is madam you know huh Mars right somebody born under the influence of Mazel madam which means red madam from the word autumn so the camera says Shabbos confident of high mandible madam a person born in that hour it's basically a change of seven hours the shiver coil Efes the seven planets as they understood them have an influence every hour over seven hours somebody who was born in the hour under Mazel made him he gathered ash Adama he will be a man who spills blood Amira boshy boshy said 'i'm 'no he may be a doctor who takes out blood from people Egon 'va he may be a thief a killer eat Ibaka he may be a shake it he may Allah he may be a mile but he's going to spill blood on my robber robber said another madam Hawaii I was born in Mardan and I never spilled blood rabaah she died but didn't die but didn't say this to the bastion while she lived later but robbers said I was born and madam the good nothing before Dabashi the gemara says if you're born in Miami gonna spill blood Robin said I was born in madam I never spilled blood Amira byah byah said excuse a moi mera naam me unless ricotta the master to punishes people or as Ashley says people who don't listen to you you also punish them you also penalize them so you're not so detached from this this is a Gomorrah that is extremely fascinating but of course it begs the question rapper says I was born in my them and I never spilled blood really Robert it's so bad you forgot what you did I'm poor him you yourself had to bring him back to life what is this they say denial is not only a river in Egypt right it's part of people's lives how could rather speak like this and then I Bayou says Mar Nami on this V Cottle you also punish people by you could have said something far more poignant and to the point and accurate and that is rapper not just you punish people you spilled up sailors blood so you might say as the some sofa suggests that this happened afterwards rob has said this before it happened okay but that some sofas says now you could understand the Gomorrah because robber had this issue he was born in Mazel made them that's what some sofas us and yet despite everybody knows the greatness of the some safer I think at least for our minds it seems incomprehensible you were born and Mazel my demand here for you murder somebody because you're not a mother because you're not a Shia therefore you end up murdering somebody some cypher learns the story literally because he was born in my zone item they Raman famously the Gus's and hostess dais admission to Tyron that different people are born with different dispositions we know there is nature besides nurture there's the impact of nurture there's the impact of nature and nature includes many things nature of course includes genetics nature also could include the time a person is born the space a person is born the circumstances in which a person is born besides their education and nurture and parental influence and communal influence and so forth people are born with certain very very powerful dispositions but as their album puts it one of the fundamentals of yudish kite is that they're not ever completely forced to behave in a particular immoral way they ultimately have choices even if for some the struggle may be far greater than for others and that's why judgmentalism is really out of place because as the Mishna says I'll tow the noskov Erika Archer tequila and Klima don't judge people as you did not reach their space the famous expression of this famous Willie McLane myalgia and you're never going to reach somebody else's space I'm never going to be wearing your shoes I'm never going to be wearing your prescription of glasses I have my way of seeing the world you have yours and therefore judgmentalism should usually be suspended even if the person is doing something wrong but there's no there's no point in judgmentalism it comes from ignorance from primitive certain sense of immaturity this doesn't mean the person is right but the bottom line is even if he was born in Mazal mind him this explains the Gemara shocked a little in fact that some cipher was not the first one to associate it to gamora's it was done a generation earlier if two generations earlier by the IVIS robbed a new Yaakov MD known as the I've it's yeah Cubans V the son of the her country Rebbe Yaakov Emden in his a Garcia verts in his commentary on Gomorrah known as a Goss diverts says was shocked at I'm Amish she didn't slaughter him Ella bath Jesus a nyan it seemed that way it seemed that way people perceived it that way herim are you sure I'm sure chocolate Obamas the situation was that the revs ad was in a situation it looked like he was gone Alfred in this foul man and updating himself was affected by the impression it made lovers Harada he started to tremble when this Aleph arrived AG and he fainted from stress and anxiety and it looked like he was dead Avel damn vadoma shuffle grab a firm hire bam and there you have it says even if he was in madam I am certain that rabbit did not did not spill blood so we have this perspective that it means he almost killed them he gave him too much to drink he squeezed him he heard him he made him too drunk he fell ill or that some cipher who says it was a literal catastrophe a literal tragedy because of mazel madam there's another perspective in cifra ha Cibola and that is it's a metaphor like you said it's a parable in fact there's a whole sugan baa baa baa stratifying gimel no one as a values they robbed a barbaric honor robbery the son of bar Khanna has there many many experience that are completely supernatural and extremely strange right he's going on a ship and they decide to rest and they go off on an island and they make a barbecue and suddenly the island turns over what seemed like an island was really a whale and if not for the ship they would have all drowned many stories like this interesting creatures he meets different types of people including stories of intoxication he even finds the place where heaven and earth kiss it's a whole it's a huge sue Ginga Mara so the marsh are already in Zoya are many in the first room say it's a metaphor it's a parable rabbi Barbara hun is telling stories in order to convey ideas convey messages we know in Qatar these two sections Ingemar itself halakha and a god how law is law Allah Allah has a mere creation with a peashooter what it says is what it means a God is the hoe melodical ideas not how logic ideas all melodical ideas there sometimes stories are told as parables as metaphors as illustrations to convey ideas through stories even though the stories themselves physically are fictional so some want to say if you look in syria Cibola the kumar is telling a metaphor rabbie represents something there's a safer mayor ami for coming by rebel feel mytable feel mayor of Ostrava famous Rebbe of Ostrava he passed away in the 1920s rebel in Poland our structure ever remains safe and many how come I saw moderate in Jana brothers I saw he explains this story metaphorically rabba represents something represented represents something there's a safe alacrity let's work on kabbalah explains it metaphorically interesting the record Java gone it's often a Spanish by if he not cabbalistic Allah explains it also metaphorically the Gomorrah says that robber was a was a was a I care Haram the Gomorrah says at the end of hurry his rabble was an Ikea harem he uprooted mountains rep say there was a mock shove a car if he was very sharp and that's the meaning of the story so this is a whole different perspective if so we don't have an issue nomad not murder and not spilling blood they're not violent and not he came back the next year it's all anyway a metaphor but of course their explanations are true on a spiritual level but we have a major problem problem here is what do they say in real estate location location location this Gomorrah is placed smack in the middle of an entire halakha discussion about how the meal of Purim has to take place when it has to take place how it has to take place right before lover Sarah halakhah high of English lip summer before yada-yada been our home Allah borrows Martha ha and this is not a halacha in Kabbalah in spirituality it's broadened tor it's brought in chef Canora in hooker sport in health is the halacha support i'm samantha fresh Sadiq hey the halacha that a true is obligated least acted by porter model a other right after that the camara tells the story so today and then after that is more how office all wars not not metaphors about poem it sound like Larry Roberts honest stories are in a section that's completely dealing not with a logic issues here smack in the middle of laws before and laws after comes a story and suddenly you have to understand till now we were speaking about literal meals and now we're not talking about a little room my literal people went out there my little roll wine when I talking about literal slaughtering it would be very very difficult to impose this interpretation and the Gemara and say this is the only interpretation even though certainly the physical story Shivan Panem Latoya every story in Toyota can be understood on a level of passat on a level of ramus and a level of additional level of salt in fact there's clear proof that it cannot mean only allegory and allegory of metaphor and that is take a look dear on and the Baha Moira a balloonism and the bow hamari mastectomy Gila say something very very interesting and this is quoted in the base Yosef in Torah hi I'm Simon tough reached our decay it's quoted in the back it's quoted in many of the commentators of torrential Honora all from rebellion ISM and Balamory rishonim and this is what they say heard the costs of our ever frames are Rubino Ephraim who was a student of the reef Ribbit's hook Affairs repeats local Farsi writes mayor who did the calm robbed of a shaft Allah loves a day it shall a memory there other the Gomorrah tells the story in this sequence to tell you that robbers law was rejected by the sages valets Hill qussuk ever say this is robbers personal opinion the law does not follow Raghava the LAV sharper mm avid hockey it's not a good idea to do what the robber said that's exactly how to understand the Gemara first the Gemara quotes raava and says a person is obligated to become inebriated on Purim until you don't know between curse to summon embark modify and then the Gemara says before you start doing this let me tell you a story and I bei know if rhyme says you know why this story comes in right here to tell you that of course raava's opinion should not be acted upon it's his opinion it's not the hollow the majority disagreed with it why because they saw what happened with Robin is a de obviously if this story happened on a metaphorical spiritual level debate know if Ryan wouldn't be so disturbed by the story to say that the whole reason it was broader is only to reject over it's quite literal and the hello is quite is quite rejected which of course brings us to the final question we want to address this Rubino a-frame hold the lock has not like rava but the halacha is like rava in other words a quarter of a newer frame Bella has not like rava but according to most other out logic authorities the halacha is like rava and that's why if you open up at oral tomorrow if the basic code of law and the laws of Magilla the beginning of tougher each other k tells you exactly what Robert says in fact it's almost a verbatim quote you have it into evidence of Connor if you take a look in shulchan aruch yoreh hi I'm Simon tough rosada k the macabre the author - bass Joseph writes hi of initial Ebisu me but parabola yoga been our humble embarrassment right person is obligated to become inebriated once a year and put him not before put I'm not after put him but just um put him this is not about a kiddush club this is about poor him until you don't know between our home and embarrass Martha comes there and MA in his hog on his foot note and he says Vieira Miriam some say they ain't sonically stock here called cow you know what there's no need for this LS she used to your simile mood oh you should drink more than what you're accustomed to the Ishaan and then hopefully you'll fall asleep I added the word hopefully for you son and you'll sleep OMA titration and when you're sleeping ami a day obey not at home Allah Boris Martha fine automatically you don't know the difference if homeowners cursed if Martha is blessed you're dreaming about something else the effort on my record I'm at above actually have a libel assure my whether you do it more you do it less the main thing is that your mindfulness should be directed towards heaven and not towards the alcohol these are the words of the Ranma some commentators say that there are ma is qualifying the words of the Shannara based on Rubino Ephraim even though he doesn't say it clearly since Robin our fry in hell that raava's law was rejected so therefore the Rama says I know that the author official Qunari or abusive karo said to do what Travis said but some people say no need for that you could drink a little more and sleep even though there are mothers say clearly by sleeping you won't know the difference in other words he is still including the view of rava but the truth is that this view of there are Mars already brought in the Rambam the Rambam and hillcrist Magilla which we're gonna quote a little later says the same thing that the mitzvah is he says it's much stronger than the Rama he says the mitzvah is to drink until you're drunk and you fall asleep in your drunkenness that's how their emblem defines a mitzvah Lucy will soon will soon learn the diamond because there is a profound message in the Rumba so it's fascinating they learned that the story happened literally robber slaughters of zeta and yet and that's where the bane of a frien is alarmed and he feels the halacha was rejected and yet most Halawa Kythera tease mainstream normative illogical thirties torrential corner of the most sensual authorities just quote the words of raava even though there are ma makes a qualification but in this case even the Ashkenazim some of them follow follow the macabre this friday the oral - the Oracle son in his commentary in his stroke on Oricon his in his in his he'll curse because every time the ke says this and he says woohoo Tamura he cannot understand how they all ignored the pain - a frien and just said that you should drink a Delilah been our amala bharatam are that high seeing seeing the mitchell the obstacle of this story which the base joseph himself who is the author of Chicano rock brings and warns against drinking excessively on poor him base of seventh brings to adultery it brings to murder it brings to to avoid Azura it brings to to terrible negative things alcoholism is quite is quite a serious problem that's a person who drinks regularly but the base Joseph says even though you're only talking about the person only drink some poor term and I'm talking here about an alcoholic I probably don't have to mention this who's now latter drink Emporium that would be an issue Gummer complete prohibition to somebody who has a real alcoholic problem to drink emporium with rabiner frame without there being a friend with the Shannara can understood they now they even drink kiddush four cups of wine i mean a lot of poskim okay it's not for now but the point is we're not talking about on alcoholic even though it's an important topic so the concept here is that despite this the best choice that brings the caution and yet in Schalke Nara I'm not gonna say he forgets to the basin's didn't forget but he just says the Poseidon straightforward there's one very interesting Duke in the Gomorrah and Gomorrah the words are very meticulous I ask you it says they got drunk if some they both got drunk come Robert Schoch Dilip sailor Robert stood up and slaughter Dobbs Ella why is the word come necessary and what if he did it sitting and what if he did it leaning come Rob he stood up why is that part of the story you might say that's what happened he stood up with a knife and shocked a little Xena why is that however integral to the story the mine of kameena if he was standing if he was sitting if he was laying if they were both on the ground the fact that Gemara makes mention of it even though the Gomorra doesn't say every single detail how did he slaughter him when did he slaughter him did he say anything before the word come means there is significance here in fact we learned before with the malbim says that come is integral to understand the story come robber r-robber stood up and went away that's what the malbim says he went away come Robbie went away shuffle it up sailor the Wong slaughter dip sailor huh yeah but the camera does say if zoom which is plural if so means they both were inebriated which is also interesting what's relevant to the story really is that the robber was inebriated I assume if ribs ada was sober he would have ran away right I mean that's what I would have done but but the Gemara does say if some which is plural Russian Robin if some in in aramaic means they both became intoxicated i want to share with you today bei Zi shed a new explanation of the Gemara an explanation that combines two opposite extremes on one hand it's apparent from the Gemara that it was a literal story that rubber caused ribs Eider to die chuckle it absurd on the other hand it was not a story of fishermen of what we would call spilling the blood murder in ribs ada which would be beyond absurd beyond unbelievable for any Jew for any great man certainly for Abba this explanation that I'm going to share with you I heard myself from the lubavitcher rebbe the Shabbos after Purim Tufts in mem dalla 1984 it was a Shabbos fibroin I was a boy at the time it was a Shabbos for bringing after Purim it was Godzilla verdict and the Rebbe then gave a talk explaining this Gomorrah I have to tell you the suspense in the room when there ever gave this talk the sense of awe and mystery and sense of suspense most people were glued to their seats with mouths open mesmerised as the Rebbe expounded in a very creative and original way that shot the meaning of this Gomorrah and unlikely of him he shared three stories I guess it was more of a Purim ambience he wouldn't tell that many stories generally but he shared three amazing stories to try to illustrate the explanation that he wanted to give him the Gemara and I still I could still see it and hear it that's what an impact that left on me and I want to share with you a few nuggets of what I heard them from the rabbit to explain this Gomorrah and I'll try to elaborate on a few items the way I understood it the way I comprehended it it starts off with another story that goes back far earlier and everybody knows the story and it's usually the parshas around the time of Purim partial Schmidty the story of Na da Vanna via the Kairos says the day that the Michigan is erected with radish Nissen Klaus Rahl is on a high ecstasy the scheana comes down to dwell among them the fire comes out and burns all the offerings and then what happens tragedy strikes the two sons of are another van vo offer a strange fire in front of God but Tate say H a fire comes out and consumes them and Aaron's two sons die on this very same day that the Michigan was inaugurated we can understand or not understand the depth of the tragedy to the point that Aaron is just silent by he died Myron and Moshe says who are shared ibrahim lamer Bakr via Kaddish now I understand what Hashem told me I'm going to become sanctified through my closest people Moshe tells iron I thought it would be you or me and now I see shame deulim me many Omaha your two boys were greater than you and me they were the ones who sanctified the Mishkan this rash she brings in parish Minnie from the Med Ridge from Kazan okay what happens right after Hashem tells Aaron yayan will shave her I'll taste there's no drinking wine when you enter into the sanctuary to do that void in fact it can cause a death penalty so rashly tells us right there on the story and he gets it from Madras rabba parish mini suea yayan miss masala McNish another vana vu died Rashi says why because they went into the base--emitter suyai which in english literally means Unga Trumpkin I said in English and you dish on gets drunk and mad vine when it saddle other so you dish in English siren or I guess also the same they go in drunk and therefore they pass away I ask you a question not the van of you are greater than motion are you go into the Mishkan drunk surpassed even not for another van of you even not from motion are a regular jew people drink we know that unfortunately sometimes more than necessary and sometimes more often than necessary and not only once a year important we know that but even a person who's drunk you go into the new Michigan on the day was inaugurated to this place of the Shema drunk suyai and this seems like very brute and barbaric behavior and moisture says now I know there greater than you and I really motion I don't would have us upon this and they're greater than motion are what's the meaning of there's an Irish Heian era fiim parshas after a merger of a new high in Benatar it's one of those are our Hyams that is as the Rebbe expressed himself then nifflas Shaban if Allah does the words of the rock I am demonstrate to you what certainty have certain people operated directly in the beginning of after a Moyes discusses the opening posted by average ml moisha lamer after a moist Nibbana arabic of awesome of Nash and William oosoo via Musel Hashem speaks to moisture after the death of the two children of iron when they came close to Hashem and they died and he tells Aaron don't come always to the holy of holies only with certain offerings on yom kippur partials after a mas says Dada hi and what's the sequence here he speaks to him after the death of the two sons of iron when they came close to God and they died the story was already in partial Schmidty what's the point of repeating it here and adding new details says during a fight or your emails AHA they're AHA very moist Ibrahim the moisture there is nice Osun here finally a sham tells much how they died so how Charles era there is no curve awesome lavinia Shem Peter Shanice Carville if naolia Elian but he bizarre co-leadership as a Mason you want to know how they died because of Awesome love Nash and they came close to Hashem they came close before the supernal light in the love of holiness and that's how they passed away Rama's huh cost of half loss he busts at Siddiqui the tire here is intimating the wonder of the love of Siddiqui chagum Shalimar G Simba me saw some even though they felt that they're going to die listen to his words line em new me crave with vehicles new emus arreva CD disc Aviva's cache Chico's mis hijos at ploys not scheisse man and you could see their home was experiencing what he wrote they did not prevent themselves from coming close how am I supposed to translate all these words with Vegas with intimacy with sweetness with pleasantness with friendship with affection with craving with sweetness to the point that their souls expired from them waha vain understand this open a zoo a mockery who saw this expiry a regular person doesn't understand this quality the humor solace may occur a lame EP mean a new Shiva let me peaks of a this is out of most people's consciousness not in their mouth and not in their writing they don't talk about it nor can they write about it for like 2 Sigma artists musk allegation it's very hard to be comprehended by the mind of a mortal physical human being to even understand what they went through oh the Catena zoobi panini you say tiga a nephesh as a boss server yuck system a EEMA of a shovel I'll be severe when the person really experiences what they experience such intimacy with the reminder shall i l'm such closeness the soul cannot deal with the confinement of the flesh it just wants to soar back to the bosom of its father this is the experience knowin in holland and many farmers cloyce a message closer nefesh means the soul so to speak expires it leaves the body why does it leave the body it would be like the electricity voltage the electricity power is too powerful and the wires are not calum the wires can't be receptacles for it and therefore they just they just burn up we know even in our own in our own life sometimes you hear something overwhelmingly joyous or fantastic extraordinary and it's almost like you can't catch yourself you're you're overwhelmed what if that is sustained what if that continues for hours and then for days so they came so close and they knew that it's dangerous why do they know it's dangerous because they knew that this world is based on concealment the body is based on concealment and to really experience the true light of God's presence which many of us don't even know what that even begins to mean we live because this such concealment so we could feel comfortable we feel comfortable in our skin why because the presence of truth the presence of our shame annoyed malvada is completely eclipsed even if we talk about it and we can intellectually philosophize about it but the rare I'm told is talking here about experience not cerebral so ebrill logical explanations so Hashem says because awesome with NASA now I asked you a question Tyrel Heim did not learn Rashi suyai in Minnesota Mukesh they had a drinking party they got drunk who was recitation it that's how people learn it was her spiders nest every buddy was in a good mood they worked hard for this Michigan yeah the heavy brother at the Mashka and nothing remember you had too much to drink and they went it doesn't mean something that's wrong there are a high I'm suddenly we have her a whole different experience a whole different story so this shallow Rob a new you Shia Horowitz the famous shallow the shallow cottage lived in the 16th century in Prague in Frankfurt and then in your show Lyon buried in Terraria the hey Lucretia Laura Boehner Shia Horowitz has a safer Schnee Lukas a bris with a lot of different sections section called Shara Isis roof he speaks about kedusha Sahil about eating and drinking and he has there a whole section about the concept of drinking and of course he opposes it he opposes it but then he brings a very interesting Gemara and I have anything tomorrow the governor says in some head and I'm at a summit Aleph you Huda have to be a uu hood have a history urban area hava you're bad history with the sons of repeat y'all sleep is so das a chimera Debbie they were sitting at a meal in front of Rebbe Rabbi Yehuda Hanasi the law you have a comer evil enemy D they were not saying anything they were relatives of Rebbe I mean over here I'm sorry they were relatives of reverie Debbie was a relative of Ripley a nephew of Ripley and they're sitting at a meal in front of reviewed an Aussie and they're not saying anything so what do you do on my lahu Rebbe tells these two boys you don't Ischia a Capri roof camera a dar Dickey he hates that the lamrim Milson let us give some extra wine to the children to the youngsters so that they should say something in other words literally let's lighten them up they're shy they're timid they're reserved let's give them to drink so they open up even the if some they started to drink here again we have the word if some they became tipsy paschal viondra they started to say in band of it bar it will stay but the others mister all the a loujain rosy ownership above all the nasturtium ancestor mushiya will not come until two families lose their power they rose gold the head of the exile in Babylonia and the Nazi the president of the son Heather nature is strong when these two families finally become simple Jews Machir who's gonna come on Moll ahem Rebbe says bon night coat Samata Matilda Bay night you came here to drink and you're putting thorns in my eyes cuz who was the nothing at all it was reb you than us see this is what you tell me machine is gonna come basically when I retire on my line up here up here says Rabi Ali a de Bain uh-huh don't be upset yeah I you Nitin Bush even my sis the site Nitin Bishop in my sis miss miss yang nyata site the iron has a numerical value of 70 you this tenure this 10 noon is 50 so altogether at 70 the word side sama valve down at 64 and 4 is also 70 why because when wine comes in secrets come out you wanted them to speak what do you want them to speak about the weather you gave them to drink you wanted them to speak they spoke about the secrets what's gonna happen in Bend of it but don't get upset they were shearing the true deeper secrets comes to shallow and he says something very fascinating he says this Gomorrah tells us Kniffin sei in your society when you drink secrets come out we know when people drink their guards go down there less closed up they open up the question is what comes out which secrets come out which secrets come out that depends what's inside your depth the children of Revere you hood then fish kia when they spoke up as a result of the wine yachts a site deep seaport secrets deep secrets came out about ain't been david bow he brings a Gomorrah and Shabbos some of Zion rabbi akiva at the wedding feast of his own son was giving wine and on every drink they were saying it should be for the life of their opponent and he explains at length this that the doily Masha Boris there were great great men who used to drink why would they drink not because they had an addiction to alcohol not because they wanted a run away from anxiety and they like being drunkard inebriated but at certain moments they would drink because yachts aside it created a certain openness the guards were down the guards were relaxed all the defense's were away their body and their soul experienced a more heightened sense of consciousness and what happened then the deepest secrets began to flow not of anivia suyeon if Missoula mikdash they were drinking but what was the nature of their drinking they weren't drinking just the party in a sense of excessive narcissistic materialism just to get drunk tsuya I admit Missoula mr. stark I am says not of an RV you were seeking the deepest intimacy with Hashem the drinking was simply a tool an instrument for all of their secrets to comment on which secrets came out sometimes what's lay in a person is animalistic repressed feelings and some people get shrunk they become violent they they speak nasty they're vulgar I mean I don't have to evaporate on this that's what's inside another than a V you drank and what came out what came out from them was an infinite flow of secrets of life secrets of terror so the cetera as the shallow puts it to the point that they experienced a closeness a transcendental experience of oneness in the world and in them and with God that the physical bodies could not contain and could not experience as he puts it in the in Mosca vivos adidas Nashik oozma seekers are close now tracer mayhem so what happens afterwards Hashem tells ayran don't drink why because it's an ages aura the objective of life is the soul should remain in the body loss Chevis its aura to live in this world not to escape this world the famous Gomorrah hagigah are born in Isola paradise for people going to the orchard also on orchards which is of course a metaphor rabbi akiva ben azzai Ben Zoma elisha ben avoid Ben Zoma loses his mind Manasa dies hits it's of a mace Huggy Gaddafi Guillermo Alicia Abhinav ouya loses his whole sense of morality he becomes a heretic he loses his faith he sees too much rebbi akiva nifflas mashaallah Murat super so on he comes in in peace and he comes out in peace they walk into the war channel once you taste orchard reality is transformed norther than a view like Ben as I went very very close and they passed away there a hyeme says most people don't even know what I'm talking about what kissing what closeness but this was the experience of not even avi you imagine all the veils of existence are removed even with us we know that our brain filters out most of our unconscious emotions and experiences what do you know about yourself you know about yourself that which your brain allows from your subconscious to flow to your consciousness and it lets only a few trickles some trickles to come down what if we would be exposed to everything that's going on inside of us what do you think you would look like if you would know everything mama Sh everything in yourself thankfully our brain is a very good body garden it doesn't let most of our unconscious drives and motives and feelings and emotions whether positive or negative to actually trickle down to our conscious self what if the veils of existence were removed what if a person would really be able to experience the true presence of the underlying the Koyuk appeal the underlying presence of Hashem in matter and in the world and in his body and in her soul and in life not of an avi you wanted a kiss God face to face mouth to mouth and the soul completely expired which we which we are clueless about because we are comfortable in our own skin because of our ignorance and we have to thank God for our ignorance because sometimes too much knowledge and too much experience exposes you to a reality where everything everything changes and this awareness that I am says is a humbling awareness this is what mauritius says but car varsham says but carve awesome love nourish them you should understand it may have been a sin but there are different types of sins I would say there are ugly sins and there are beautiful sins in other than Ivy who committed a sin because the purpose is to be here not to go there the I inverse a car I'll taste but don't think it was just two peasants who wanted to get drunk they wanted to have a party if this is the case come back to our story this is the story robber says it's poorab what's the fee of important guy Avinash lip summer before you Adam the other been ar-rahman the Barack martyr gap and now let's learn a sticker album a sticker album he'll kiss Megillah Payard bass but first I want to address a big question everybody knows poor him we celebrate the survival of the Jewish people the Gomorrah says something astounding in my secular Shabbos - play chess when the Jews accepted Tyra they were under a mountain you know the Gomorrah call foul aim higher - giggy's hashem took the mountain and he put it over them like an overturned VAT a gigas said if you accept our good if not you'll be buried right here so the Gomorrah says week on my door a below rice basically Jews could say it was coerced we didn't want this relationship on my ruther rava says ha dirty blue of America's rage the times have put him they accepted Tiger again willingly that's why it says in the Megillah Kimo Vicky blue how you hood them Kimo magic he blue Kivar they affirmed that which they already accepted they reaffirmed their commitment too tired at this time not by coercion but with full voluntary will and volition this means that purium was essentially a second Matt and Toyota and a greater Matt and Tyler the bow Allah has no less rights or they've put in preemption it Naboo Tyra poor him is like Matt and Tyler and yet in all of the experiences of Purim we don't have any Zaheer for this any memory for this aspect that poram was like a second Jews basically collectively recommitted themselves to the Covenant of Tyra to the Covenant with Hashem with pyramid Smith's willingly even deeper and greater than by Matt and Tyra or perhaps there is a major commemoration for this unported they got behind this that sheeta's Haram bomb is that Adela yada is exactly this experience take a look in the words of the Rambam he'll kiss me gillip Eric base Cates at Havasu desu what's the obligation of Porou sure your kielbasa you should eat meat via seconds to denote a fish at MC other you should prepare a nice meal according to your financial capacity no need to borrow money and make shalom on arson that will make prince charles blush we show you say yayan drink wine actually stock air until you get drunk via NBC crew say and you fall asleep in your intoxication we all will learn the words of the ramen quite literal drink and drink and drink become tired and exhausted and fall asleep i have to say i always wonder that this is the halacha of Perham drink get tired and fall asleep how meaningful is that like what's the what's the meaning of this I want to sleep I can go to sleep I can sleep without drinking I go to bed I fall asleep pretty fast then the ramen continues would to Vlad them were hydras with my opponents have you animal hybrids beside us it much less - Lee Reyes if you have extra money instead of buying more shallow smallness more expensive bottles of wine filling up the shallows - not with one chocolate one hamantaschen one orange and one piece of chicken or gefilte fish or sushi but the shallot - baska has to have 20 courses inside of it every conceivable type of candy to kill every child in the family so there are mom says instead of increasing the soda and shallows manos banner Mitama Slovenian gifts Dhaka Shan Shan simcha dilemma for our Ella Sameach clave I namely as Simon baumanis Brigade there's no real great beautiful sim only to bring joy to the heart of poor people orphans widows strangers Shama Sameach leave home low in my able demolish finish in M Allah Hafiz aroma has led me to fight somebody who brings joy to the heart of these people who are in a state of agony become similar to the sheena says about hashem that he brings life to the humble and he brings spirit to the crushed people it's interesting in Iran bomb Hill has stuck a health is madness on name he doesn't say this that should be the place to bring joy to a poor person your diamond lishchyna he doesn't say this in the wars of charity where does it come up suddenly and he'll his Magilla in the Wars of Purim but take a look and he'll see see soy de Italia repaid Roxana la cabeza their diamond speaks about prophecy she says with Cullinane ROI in Marana vuela Baja loin because you know Lila I buy your him after shitty oil alayan tyre de ma tired Dame are the same words like in health is Magilla all the prophets do not experience prophecy only in a dream or by day after they experience at are de matar dima means you notre dame 'as a sloth asleep a snooze come back to he'll kiss Magilla he says you stock here the rod aim be chic Russa what happened by Matt and Tara was essentially a de la de the camara says in Shabbos alcohol Deborah Deborah parka knishmas on there so left why did there so leave them why did her so leave them because again the veils after a solid ask a chef well the Kim a night malvada the electricity was so powerful the body can't contain it they melted away in the sweetness in the oneness of the unity of Hashem the soul leaves the body which is based on a physical container that eclipses infinity somebody once said if all the doors of perception were cleansed everything would appear as is infinite the problem of course would be that the sense of I is based on a sense of finiteness on a sense of ego what happens if I lose my ego was blighted my soul remains but that sense of ego is lost which is why death was created through the eight sadhus because before the eight sadhus the soul and the body were one like the light bulb and the light so the body didn't have to die because it was part of eternity they said that's created a partition between soul and body the soul never dies the ego dies because it never was alive the ego dies because it's life was only delusional it never really exists separately but the real true conscious no person doesn't die so now by Matt and Tyler where they are experiencing for the first time that Shrew ultimate wisdom of a Shem a person cannot remain in his own ego and experience infinity what does it create it creates Bittle Bittle Hosko Sherman creates an absolute self nullification and that's how they absorb Toyota it's just as the Gomorrah says in Shabbos Hashem brings them back to life that's what happens by Martin Toyota on Purim we have shalosh Mona Smetana Slava I am so desperate Magilla all to commemorate the miracle but we have one more detail the same rather who said in my sex the Shabbos that I'm putting they accepted the tailor again says poor him you have to do that another Martin Taylor what's Martin Taylor an experience of transcendence a de loyola to be able to drink to go transcend my normal sense of egotism and self-consciousness and therefore self-centeredness to the point where I can send my other so the Rambam says not you fall asleep like a Bahama the chinks the foul stocks often you start snoring at the table kate's of havasu desu it's the clay versus odor what's the ramus a show you see I'm actually a stocky ve Robin busy crew so you fall asleep in your secrets which is the description he uses in hookers you say di para as the receptacle for prophecy that's why the Rambam says if you have a choice between shallow from honest so this parameter honest love your in him you know what you should give my honest love your enemy know why because then you'll become doing militina he says there's no joy bringing joy to another person really most people would say the greatest joy in the world is when your joyous yourself that's not a few demolition when your demolish kena when you become a reflection of the sinner so now suddenly helping another person becomes even more significant than just adding my own meal and wish laughs - here in houses Magilla there our mom says that through my Thomas love your enemy become similar to the Sheena which is basically the reenactment of Martin Toyota with the Jew experiences intimacy and one is with the Sheena and therefore the Rambam says that for a person to be able to experience the plight the fate of another person more than himself this should be the greatest joy is only when a person is operating on a soul level on a divine level and a transcendental level when being there for you is as meaningful as being there from me because I sense our organic oneness rava says on Purim hi Avinash lip summer before you add the lawyer debonair Ramallah Buress Martha comes the Gemara and tells a story Robin Deb's ADA are doing a meal if soon they become drunk so everybody learns they drink and drink and they become drunk sue a yayan Kniffin ursula McNish it's not just they were drinking there was good wine old wine and they were drinking such a hung a decent side the cetera the wine was flowing but the secrets were flowing the secrets of Tyler were flowing without any limitation Abdulla yonder beyond even a level of regular das what happens calm robber robber stands up and this word these words come robber are extremely significant even rapper elevates himself to a place beyond this rapper and Observer what does a rapper mean rather large what does it observe I mean small in fact the euro solemnly calls him represent a Rizzo a which means small and observer was small the Gomorrah says him of Mencia daf pay hey he once went into an oven you know the story and his thighs were we're singed were burnt he shrunk they called him nibs area small person small he was also morally spiritually the Gemara says in Sanhedrin there is a durwood Hyde said nobody should give him Smitha he didn't want to be acknowledged he didn't want to be ordained the Gomorrah says he would hide so he shouldn't get Smitha until he found out that you've forgiven your sins and then he wanted then he wanted to get it but this was a de xira means small he was small physically but also in contrast to Rapa he felt small he felt humble so you have rabbit and observe it together they're both in a state of if 'some not only robber Oh syrup Zeta it's critically important calm robber robber himself stands up physically but more importantly he stands up spiritually he himself elevates himself to a place that transcends his experience and here is the difference rabbit comes from the word derive which is greatness nepo Zeta Zeta which is smallness what happens shocked they lit up Zeta he shot subside he shocked some Zeta what is shocked inland obtained so there's a gomorian : so of the gomorian huland off llama diamond base fascinating tomorrow the Mishna says in hole in a famous mission everybody knows the halacha if you behead an animal it's not kosher you need even if you take the knife and you just squeeze it you put you put you you put the knife into the neck of the animal what's called Russa you squeeze it to the point that it dies it's not good what do you need what to means the knife huh hey luck of Ivar you draw it back and you draw it forth that's the love says the cameraman on Amelie how do you know what's the difference you just stab stab what's the difference a marsh mold on micro the plastic speaks about the plastic says in your Mia hates chocolate leshawna Merman some people's tongue is so deceitful it's like a drawn arrow when they open their mouth it's like somebody taking the narrowed get back and shooting it out you know they know when they're gonna start with their stories the question is one person is gonna be killed 10 people 20 people but some people you know they start opening their mouths they don't stop hate shuffle astronomer their deceitful tongue is like a drawn arrow gates off withdrawn partner debated be small it says vishakha ain't we shock art Ella Oh Mushaf you don't even need the Kinnear Mia the word vishakha means to draw so shocked at slaughter means moisha come rabble rabble stands up for shock they lit up Seder in Vishaka ello Marshall he was moisture cribs ADA to a state that's completely transcendent of his regular physical mental spiritual intellectual capabilities what's the result of that the Brasilia passes away why does he pass away because he experiences the intimacy that knot of an RV you experienced he experiences the curve a Versailles Rivas you did do some sickles not just the Prophet who falls asleep to become an avi but the prophet who falls asleep completely Parkash mas and Abdullah yonder completely robbed Arabs ADA was so intoxicated with yay Michelle Tyra with cider cetera with Miss Messiaen yacht society that the spiritual ecstasy elevated even robber but robber had the vessels to remain in the physical world represented in a state of Zahra when he was elevated to that space when he was open to that space shock day he was elevated to a different domain completely and his soul leaves his body how because of course on a fish why it's poor him if some if so in fact I saw I was looking so I saw this shallow in passion stirred Sava fascinatingly the shallow and partial stirred Sava says something mamas almost verbatim but kids and numerous take a look I put in the shallow yeah the last last source listen to the shallow bozell soit Marmara mastectomy gila robbers shuttle in of zeta be super Sayan rot Salima half shot ass her femur key english raw bahar Cena the climber was divested the sense of materialism was removed like the Jews by her Cena King neatness II might Otesaga gorilla he entered with him to tremendous comprehension and again we don't mean comprehension an intellectual nice year that doesn't create clothes on effort hisagi here means comprehension and experience a full experience of intimacy with Hashem the F sure mama she eats its amazed cabin aza the shallow saying literally maybe Mama's died like Benghazi who gazed at the orchard Omashu Dibble Asha why did say she did to means a knife we're not talking about a knife and misuki prosciutto it means literally by you shutting by mid bar is a pasta can / moisture says the nation's are gonna say you slaughtered them in the desert for our shampoos were taking a knife to slaughter them that wasn't the plan shallower your shitty team Amish Rock missive it did return to collosseum but nothing same there was an initiative item Coshocton what are they saying some circles shots Amita Brava so I don't know if that means with a knife kalila but the concept is initiative he shafted him with words show law says it's an expression the Carla Harvin F sure saw it corner of Asia to Mordecai Bahaman foolishness by straightish are some addict hated now you gotta figure this out Mordecai and Haman represent basically the esophagus and the trachea the food pipe and the windpipe which is the places where we do and Robin and Abizaid er went to the source of the corner and the veget which is Mordecai and ha maan and that's the idea of Asarco navaja version this he doesn't elaborate upon this - Allah leaves for the sudha of Purim for you to elaborate on when you're in a state of if some but we learned here that vishakha is not just an expression for socket is the story enrich our Otello Masha he was moister than my king and Misha your moisture he drew him into a different realm and absurd a physically did not survive if this is the case what happens rep Zelda has passed away it's poor him if some Lamar the next day after poor him Robert says I ever say file page dear boy initial item doesn't want a soul in heaven as long as you're giving your life here this is the place this is the place to be boy you're after me but I yeah he brings his neshama back into the goof why does he have to ask - well it's not easy once the soul leaves you know a soul doesn't want to come back it's not simple for a soul to come back into the world because the soul is in the bosom in the bosom of a sham it's hard to get a soul to come down it's a painful journey an expression of Gomorrah Gaddafi may agree Ramallah beer I mikta from the peak of a mountain into a deep abyss it's not easy at all a year passes a year passes they're getting ready for Purim again comes roberta tubbs ada and he's just tired at of Zeta they said Marvin of it so this puddin behind the other thee not only does Robin not regret what happened last year put him he wants to re-experience Martin Taylor he wants to re-experience a delay yonder he wants to re-experience the intimacy that gilja Lacoste the revelation of godliness and Ruth Gnaeus to the point of complete oneness and intimacy he says let's go reenact so just put him of course I know what happened last year it's poor him I've developed let's go do it never say that looks at robber at first glance you would think an obscene who would say 9-1-1 what's become tobacco you come to mouth you should be run away from the country i'll driving out go rotates its row in fact representing when Tetch is still not robber it was a toe left at you so not for this reason he wanted a lunar night since early tomorrow says he fasted a hundred faster forget Tom with Bob Lee to be able to open himself up the Talmud you rashon me Nevada says stood up of course neither that was unforgettable or quite there's only one problem I would lovely as we say neither she's Voltas 'get on Geddon Mitzvah game again I would love to do it love behold shy to recite them astonish Missa last year my soul came down I'm not sure the miracle is gonna happen again and what if I don't come down again it's improper not even RV you were great great men greater than my shine iron but we still consider it a vehicle I hate a mistake an error a spiritual error a holy error an error of its addict there are errors and there are errors it's a different type of sin but an error it was a certain type of hate relative to their level it was so therefore represent fuses now when rabbit does it initially when that but doesn't initially perhaps he doesn't think ribs ater will expire just like he doesn't expire so he doesn't even know the consequences or perhaps he thinks I could bring him back you can have the cake and eat it too and he does that too the next year we'll do it again maybe also the next Theory thought over the year Deb's ADA's vessels also expand it so the Vedas says no they did not I still need a miracle or he thought maybe they didn't but let's do it again ribs a reject sit not because it was evil and criminal it was not evil it was not criminal but lava Hall shite they were shite - mr. Krishna sir if this is the case the Gemara is literal Robert cause dibs ADA to pass away come Robert Schoch Philip Isaiah Dahman murder spilling of blood evil criminal that completely was out of the question for Abba it was not the story even though the story happens literally and that's where that beef ryeom says because such a thing happened you cannot do it anymore most poskim say let's face it most meals will not look like Robin Abouzeid his meals somebody will say of art then the Megillah somebody will say a little high and they'll have a comes it will have somebody with a guitar the experience of Robin is a de we don't have to worry for most people and therefore they don't agree with threadbare they don't agree with rubber fry now the rebus says three story to illustrate the concept he said he wants to illustrate it in our generations the first story he said about the moderates arriba remember he said then there's a de from the hind to curmudgeon said this was 1984 the outer moderates he actually passed away that year I think in year this was de Sade of the of the moderator of 84 this is the first module a rapper who was a rebus roll tab rebus roll tab the d'Ivry is wrong The Bistro tab the first modular ever was a great great brown moderates he said that margins was no is known for its Claire honey Gina it's a unique talent and skill for music for melodies Martin had grown until today are legendary the Beast Royal tab the first moderates Arabic composed himself hundreds of melodies most of them were forgotten with the Holocaust but I think we still have around a hundred melodies of his and the the the moderates Arriba was born in 1848 tough race casserta fresh tests he passed away he passed away in the 20s he passed away in nineteen twenty nineteen twenty you'd gimel Kislev tough rachet aloof 1920 in Varsha he lived in moderates in Poland but he passed away in vile she's buried in Warsaw he's known as the first Mudgett celebrity degree is wrong solo bomber should ever said the thing ahead for polish at Sydenham i heard from the Sydenham in poland that the module Serie B the div reinstall the first module sir rabbie needed a surgery it's a known story in 1913 tough fresh iron gimel he needed a serious surgery I think it was on his legs and he went to Berlin Berlin was then one of the great medical centers of the world and the doctors agreed that he must have a surgery to save his life but there was a problem because of his age and his physical state they said there is no way that his body would be able to endure the pain of the surgery anesthesia was too dangerous for him and therefore they didn't think he would survive going under the knife so the margit's arriba told his physicians in berlin he's going to see when they're ready for the surgery they should tell him a few minutes before he's going to sing anagen one of his own songs that he's composing or he will compose or he composed he's going to sing the song they should wait and when they see that he's in the midst of the melody in the midst of singing the song and he's completely entrenched in it they could perform the surgery and Keshava this is what they did they performed the surgery he was a middle of singing the song he was completely in a different place in a different realm he was not screaming he survived and he lived for another seven years from 1913 he lived 1920 he lived another seven years by Mudgett circus idiom they say this was a known as alias kara it has 32 stanzas 32 stanzas I heard it once it's a brilliant brilliant and I mean from from a point of view of composition of a melody it's extraordinary song and margit's they sing it only once a year on his yard site it's like a very sacred song for them because this was his song in which he you know lived through the surgery they sing it on his your tie which is you'd gimel kislev as I mentioned so here the rebus says here you have an illustration of a Jew a gray Jew living in our times and his times who didn't pass away but here you have an experience he experiences something and he simply does not feel as Homer he does not feel his physical body and not just because you know he doesn't feel his hunger he's busy but in a surgery which should cause tremendous amount of pain and agony without anesthesia he's capable of becoming one with danijon with a hiss at Sloss so one to the point he didn't feel his agony his pain story number two a generation earlier Rabbi Avraham Allah the magician maggot of dovabear the successor of the Baal Shem Tov had a song they called him rabbi rom the angel just from the name you can figure out what type of person he was when the bow Hispania came to miss rich to learn by the halacha market the ballot annular person is almond of Lee Adi was a Mendes gone he had a choice he wanted to go either the Vilna or miss rich sometimes so got a Tale of Two Cities not London and Paris but ville man miss rich and he said as follows Landon and Kenneth abyssal I know how to learn I don't know how to davon in Vilna is gonna learn how to learn by the gun in his rich they say you could learn how the dominie goes to miss rich it's one of those Forks in the road that really changes changes history in many ways and he goes to miss rich becomes the great student of the magnet becomes the author of the show sonorous and Netanya he comes there the market makes a have rousseff for him with his song three hours and three hours three hours niggler three hours mr. dubov Rama Malik is going to teach the ballot on Europe snares almond mr. Kabbalah the ballot Anya is gonna teach his son Nikola ballot an Arab of Rama Malik was a very abstract person so he used to say that he used to move the clock back appropriate for today he would move the clock back so about Rama Mallis looked at the clock and he thought that three hours weren't up and he said those were the sweetest Toyota he learned Miami ovum um taco stolen water is sweet and he said the desire says lo signa of this up sick after lie because when it comes to Tyler some people teach lie but sometimes signals but he tides when it comes to Tyler well the trader you could steal so to speak you should steal still from your time steal from from from any possibility to add entire once they were learning for hours Kabbalah when they finish about Rama Moloch walks out of his surf of the room where he was learning the basic magician he sees the ball Tania is sitting and he's eating I remember his words asked a bagel myth Potter he's eating a bagel with butter the Brahma was astounded to see his Caruso was quite a shock Adashi Magana going him eating a bagel with butter so he says what's this so he says when I finish to share with you if it get filled as it'll hub and close sunl fish I felt I'm gonna pass away and I needed something very fatty very physical to hold me down so therefore I couldn't only eat a bagel had to eat a bagel with butter so the question is and above rahamallah himself but here you have the same concert Labov rom was a mala he was an angel C operated in that level in that paradigm he didn't need a bagel and butter he was used to this the bhava Tanya his main avoiders main raison D etre was mabini das to bring it down to permeate the mind to permeate the heart to penetrate the physical it a different way than above Rama mala very different so therefore because of his avoid that he had to stay down this was not the regular experiencia te de bagel and butter third story this year drum his father-in-law there are sharp one was the moderates a rabid livin a shot above Rama Molokai now the third one the last one the rebel said he heard from his father his father-in-law was there ever I asked the six Lubavitch Allah but his father was known as the rishabh the fifth Lubavitch Arab he once travelled with his son to Vienna in the early 1900s to Vienna they stayed in a hotel so his father dear ashab had one room and his son Darius Rubio Soviets cook had another room he comes into his father's room once one day in Vienna and he sees that he's sitting on the couch and there's a towel room and he's entrenched in his thoughts and he can't make conversation with him no eye contact he saw that he's like in a trance so he left his father alone he comes back a few hours later his father's in the same position with not moving immobile steering and midair and completely seemed not there comes back a few hours later same position this happened for hours and hours throughout the day finally his father so to speak woke up and he started to ask him questions and from the questions he understood that his father did not know what day it was what week it was what month it was where they were which city which location which circumstances almost they had to tell him everything he was asking him he said side questions neither ever said that yes I'm him that those hours intellectually he laid the foundations of his famous Hampshire Hampshire tough fresh iron base which means one of the deepest deepest works in the world of Kabbalah and Hasidic is not as a three-volume it's hundreds and hundreds and hundreds thousands of pages of the rishabh that he began writing in Nice began saying in 1912 towfish iron base it's known as Hampshire tough fresh iron based a series of 1912 of towfish iron base in which he revealed some of the most fundamental ideas in mister and attested this especially hibakusyas those hours he was intellectually entrenched in laying the foundations of that huge set of volumes which is very very difficult very very complex and even those who are entrenched in the world of houses really get to that book it's it's it's really it's a lifetime it's a whole journey that's safer what do you see here again he was sitting on a couch in the physical world but his sensations were so transcendent were so beyond that in many ways there was a semblance of what we call off shutters are flamer in which the material experience is gone and therefore the person is in a complete transcendental state so even in our generations by great Jews you have something something of a semblance of this idea that the Gemara says what happened on Purim come raba for shocked a little zina that robber slaughters he elevates them zeta to a place where there is complete intimacy with the divine Liholiho we pass him that rob a know if ryeom's rejection of rava was not accepted we accepted others halacha because it means that i'm pouring the time of Purim everyone according to their level has the power and the ability to experience something of this concept of a delay yada and the whole drinking of Purim is not a fest just to let loose the drinking of Purim is really the one of the most serious experiences of the year in many ways more serious than Yom Kippur it's like Matt and Tara where a person on his or her level has the ability on Purim to truly be able to let go of all the defenses and experience intimacy with a rabona shel olam even beyond das even beyond knowledge have a wonderful week a friendless entire dish i Fralick emporium [Music] [Applause] this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot the yeshiva net slash donate