0:00 / 0:00
Parsha Perspectives for Today (Acharei Mos)
404 views
The Torah and its messages are timeless. Join me as we draw from the weekly Torah portion to extract lessons and inspiration for today from a wide and diverse range of sources and personalities. For more content, visit http://www.rabbiefremgoldberg.org.
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Thank you for joining us as we continue
to learn virtually together taking
advantage of the incredible technology
the gift of technology that we have so
glad that we are together and hope that
you can hear clearly this morning so
many of the privilege of studying
parshas acharei mos to give me a try to
incorporate some thoughts of the theme
of Yom Hazikaron today is a day that we
join Jews around the world in thinking
about
commemorating memorializing
those who gave their lives for founding
of the state of Israel and for the
continuity the protection of the state
of Israel victims of terror who died al
Kiddush Hashem and we join Jews around
the world and thinking about them our
parsha series this year is generously
sponsored by Becky and Avi Katz and
family in memory of Becky's father David
Grossman leilui nishmas Dovid ben
Menachem Mendel thank you so much for
your generous sponsorship and your
leadership in so many different ways
acharei mos is found in the Artscroll
Stone Chumash on page 636 as always it's
best to have a Chumash with you to be
able to follow along preferably even a
Mikraos Gedolos as we'll see some of the
Meforshim inside together today if not
it's no problem you can listen carefully
and we'll try to explain so our parsha
begins by the Moshe acharei mos
because of some of the musar the parsha
begins by referencing what had happened
recently the tragic premature death of
Nadav and Avihu Aaron had suffered a
horrific loss on which in the happiest
day of his life the inauguration of the
Mishkan opening day of his serving as
the Kohen Gadol instead he tragically
lost his two sons inexplicably so much
so the text is absent and our
commentaries debate exactly what they
did wrong and here we introduce our new
parsha and the story of Aaron's role in
leading the Yom Kippur service with this
reference to acharei mos shnei benei
Aaron after the death of the two sons of
Aaron we're not going to get into but I
leave it to you or I challenge you to
think about why does our parsha not
mention their name why are their names
not deserved to be acknowledged they're
simply known here as acharei mos shnei
benei Aaron after the death of Aaron's
two sons why not mention them by name
but moving on to the next pasuk vayomer
Hashem el Moshe daber el Aaron achicha
speak to your brother the ayavo el
hakodesh mi beis la paroches you cannot
come casually you cannot come whenever
you crave to the kodesh al pnei
hakapores asher al haaron v'lo yamus ki
b'anan era'eh al hakapores you're not
allowed to just approach whenever you
want you can't approach the bench
without being summoned similarly here
it's only when there is a cloud that
will appear that Aaron will know he is
eligible to approach otherwise he cannot
come close he cannot come close why
bazos ya'avo Rashi says v'av lo b'chol
eis k'vei Yom HaKippurim and even this
is not talking about all throughout the
year we're talking about the holiest
person the holiest place and the holiest
day of the year only then can he
approach it's a very interest
interesting instruction we're going to
examine it more closely in one moment
but I want to first ask a simple
question God speaks to Moshe and he says
daber el Aaron speak to your brother
Aaron only here he doesn't just say
speak to your brother Aaron he says
speak to your brother Aaron
achicha speak to Aaron your brother the
text could have simply said speak to
Aaron if by acharei mos you don't know
that Aaron and Moshe are brothers you
have not been paying careful attention
we all know that Aaron and Moshe are
brothers so why not simply say hey Moshe
speak to Aaron and tell him this rule
you can't approach at will at whim you
can't approach casually you have to be
invited why is it introduced
specifically as Aaron achicha here this
question is asked by Rabbi Meir
Druck in his wonderful sefer Eish Tamid
on the parsha I've been sharing insights
with you from it recently I was kind
enough to give me a set with a beautiful
description great yeshiva in
Yerushalayim Ir HaKodesh and he asks
this question why Aaron achicha here and
he asks it not just here he points to
several places throughout Torah and he
says sometimes Aaron is simply
identified as Aaron other times Aaron is
identified as Aaron achicha for example
for example
when Aaron hesitates and refuses to go
Hashem tells him Aaron achicha halevi
daber
hu v'gam hinei hu yotzei likrascha
b'rucha u'v'simcha b'libo he's going out
with you don't have to worry Aaron your
brother we have similarly v'eina elokim
v'Aaron achicha v'yanvuacha v'ashto
achicha kach matah v'achas v'Aaron
achicha the story of the main reva when
Moshe hits the rock instead of speaking
the instruction is to take his staff you
and Aaron your brother u'mos parasha el
Hashem v'aseifa el amacha k'asher meis
Aaron achicha you will ascend the
mountain and you will die there just
like your Aaron your brother so Rabbi
Meir Druck wonders why sometimes
is Aaron identified simply as Aaron and
by now we all know who he is his
pedigree and other times he is
identified specifically as Aaron achicha
so he gives a very interesting answer
first he references the Or HaChaim
HaKadosh and the Or HaChaim HaKadosh
says the following
says the following the Or HaChaim quotes
a Midrash here the pasuk says daber el
Aaron speak to your brother shamati
l'cha I told you halo Aaron achicha
halevi b'rucha u'v'simcha b'libo the
pasuk says that your Aaron your brother
is the Levi yada'ati ki daber daber gam
hu
there is your brother Aaron the Levite
he I know speaks readily v'gam hinei hu
yotzei likrascha b'rucha u'v'simcha
b'libo go and meet him and he'll be
happy to see you when Moshe demurs when
he hesitates when he feels in
when he feels
inadequate to be able to go be the
leader to redeem the Jewish people
Hashem reassures him and says don't
worry you got Aaron
so what's going on why is the Midrash
saying that here u'viur Or HaChaim
sh'lamadnu ki
achicha u'l'zeh daber achicha shamati
l'cha lo Aaron achicha halevi v'hakavana
ki af kidush Hashem k'Moshe yelbonav
v'hatzad shemimenu yiskav amar lo ki
zehu l'tzad yeshuas achicha ach v'nachon
u'v'ne'emanah
why is why is Moshe has to instruct
Aaron go and you're going to the Kodesh
HaKodashim it's a very risky proposition
as the Kohen Gadol you may not walk out
alive Aaron may worry look what happened
to Aaron's sons my two nephews they
acted they entered inappropriately
without being invited and what was the
consequence what was the result they
they died tragically what about my
brother so what drove Moshe's concern
and worry was the notion it was his
brother and therefore he has to give
this instruction lo ya'avo el hakodesh
he's speaking at Aaron achicha as a
brother with brotherly love with
brotherly concern with a brotherly focus
that's achicha the fact that Aaron is
his brother is what is offering that
concern and that's what the Torah is
telling us Moshe is giving Aaron that
warning you can't simply enter whenever
you want but Rabbi Druck gives a
alternative shita a very fascinating
shita and it's at length I'm just going
to summarize it for you Rabbi Druck
basically says the following not only in
this pasuk in this circumstance but
applies it every time Aaron is
identified not simply as Aaron applies
it every time Aaron is identified as
Aaron achicha and he basically says the
following Aaron and Moshe had an
extraordinary quality and that quality
has a Yiddish term today and that term
is the capacity to fargin another fargin
means to be able to share in the joy to
make room for the success the triumph
the happiness the accomplishment the
achievement the prominence the esteem
the admiration of another we live in a
time that struggle to fargin another to
be able to share in the happiness of the
joy of another you know the sefer Orchos
Musar points out that the quality of
nosei b'ol chavero one of the ways in
which Torah is acquired the Mishnah
Pirkei Avos tells us is that a Torah
personality has to cultivate within
themselves the ability to be nosei b'ol
to feel for another we've spoken about
this at length in other contexts and
normally we think about nosei b'ol to
feel for another in the sense of feeling
the pain of another seeking to relieve
the pain to carry the burden so it's
lighter for the other and we've given
classes on practical examples of being
nosei b'ol in the time of need in the
time of struggle how can we help those
but the sefer Orchos Musar and many
others point out that we're mistaken if
we think nosei b'ol the capacity to feel
for another is limited to feeling pain
it's a very Jewish and a very Torah
concept to also be able to feel the
success the happiness the joy of another
to a degree it's easier to feel the pain
of another than the happiness of another
the Alter of Kelm points out why because
when you're going through suffering or
pain when you're going through an acute
crisis of course I'm so grateful I'm not
going through it I'm so happy that
that's not affecting me that's not me so
I channel my happiness that it's not me
into reaching out to help you but when
you're having joy happiness success when
you're still getting a paycheck when
you're getting nachas from your children
when they show them in your bias when
everything's going well so then it's
hard because I say why them not me I
deserve that happiness I deserve that
joy I deserve that simcha I deserve that
windfall why them and not me it's harder
to be nosey but simcha in chavero. It's
harder to feel for another when it means
to participate or partake in their joy
than it does even in their in their
hardship. Nosey but in chavero. That is
Moshe Rabbeinu's wonderful quality. He
exhibits it as a shepherd with the
sheep. It's why Moshe it's why God
recruits him to be the quintessential
paradigmatic leader of the Jewish people
in perpetuity. But it's also something
very special that Moshe and Aaron share
with one another. The ability to be
nosey but in simcha chavero. Aaron is
older than Moshe.
And Moshe is deemed greater. One of the
13 principles of our faith is to
subscribe to the uniqueness of Moshe as
the av navi'im. He's categorically
different than all other prophets. He
ultimately succeeds, exceeds
Aaron in his greatness. And yet, Aaron
has no feelings of jealousy or envy.
Aaron has no ego or arrogance. He's able
to share in the joy and the success of
his younger brother Moshe. And Moshe
too. Moshe, as much as he is successful,
he's limited. And says Rav Druck, that's
what's going on in our parsha. Because
after all, Moshe says, "One second.
Aaron's the kohen gadol but I'm greater
than Aaron. And I'm not allowed to go
into the kodesh hakodashim. Only Aaron
is." So in this moment when Moshe's
reminding Aaron about what it takes to
enter the holy of holies, it is
specifically as Aaron achicha. Because
Moshe had no jealousy. Moshe Moshe had
no competitiveness. Moshe didn't look
and say, "Why is Aaron allowed to enter
and I'm not? Doesn't Aaron know the 13
principles of faith of the Rambam?
Doesn't he know I'm av navi'im? Why is
he allowed to enter and I'm not? I
should be allowed to enter." Moshe had
no such thought, no such feeling. He
simply experienced the joy of the
success of Aaron, his position of
prominence and distinction that Aaron
was the kohen gadol who was allowed to
enter
the kodesh hakodashim. We don't have
time to develop this fully now, but this
is replete in midrashim. The pasuk in
Tehillim tells us that "Kashemen hatov
al rosh yored al hazakan, zakan Aaron."
Like the fine oil on the head runs down
on the beard, the beard of Aaron. The
midrash wonders in Shir Hashirim Rabbah,
"Why do I have to be told it runs down
the beard, the beard of Aaron? If it
runs down the beard, whose other beard
is it running down?" This is the
anointing oil that's elevating Aaron to
that position of distinction. And the
midrash tells us, "Kacha amar Hakadosh
Baruch Hu l'Moshe, Moshe,
k'shem she morai yelach, kach yimorach
al achicha." "V'hu lo asa kein."
"V'ahavta l'rei'acha kamocha." "V'ahavta
l'rei'acha kamocha" is "Israel." And so
on. Says the midrash,
"She'hadain yasameach zeh bigdulah shel
zeh, v'zeh bigdulah shel shel zeh." The
beard, when it went down Aaron's when
the oil went down Aaron's beard, it was
it was as if it was on Moshe's beard.
Moshe took such joy. He shared in the
happiness, the success of Aaron. Aaron
shared in the happiness and the success
of Moshe. We see it similarly
in the midrash on this pasuk that we
alluded to earlier when Hashem tells
him, "Aharon achicha haLevi." Your
brother Aaron.
"V'ra'acha v'samach b'libo." He's going
to see you and he's going to go out so
happy to see you. The midrash says,
"Amar Rav Shmuel bar
Nachmani,
yavo v'yismach v'yilbash urim v'tumim."
It's in the merit that Aaron shared in
the success of his younger brother Moshe
that earned him the position of kohen
gadol and that enabled him to wear the
urim v'tumim. That's the word, the
capacity to forgive another, to share in
the joy, the happiness, to not be
competitive, to not ask, "Why not me? I
deserve more. I deserve better." But
rather to see what someone else is
having, not only to share in nosey but
all in the pain and suffering and
struggle of the other and seek to
relieve it and make it lighter, but to
share in the success and the joy and the
happiness and the achievement of the
other and to be able to simply be happy
for another person. And that's why I
suggest Rav Yisrael Meir Druck over here
that specifically the instruction to
Aaron to enter the holy was preceded by
Aaron achicha. Moshe, there was no
competitiveness. It didn't matter that
Moshe was greater for this just simply
happy for Aaron.
"B'zos yavo Aaron." B'zos. What does it
mean b'zos? There are several
interpretations that we know are famous.
One, um of course our parsha, the
majority of our parsha is dealing with
the laws of Yom Kippur. The service of
Yom Kippur. Today we experience Yom
Kippur differently. None of us know how
we're going to experience Yom Kippur
this year. We hope that we'll be back
together, led by a chazan, hearing
Moshe's moved, elevated, enriched
together. We and we pray, please God, by
then and much sooner. But in the time of
the Beit Hamikdash, Yom Kippur was
essentially and primarily led by the
kohen gadol, rendering the rest of Klal
Yisrael essentially spectators to Yom
Kippur. And the kohen gadol was the main
protagonist. He was the centerpiece of
the Yom Kippur service. That is the
majority of our parsha. So b'zos, which
Unesaneh Tokef,
which is arguably the most moving moving
and stirring part of our liturgy both on
Yom Kippur and Rosh Hashanah. In
Unesaneh Tokef we culminate, we declare,
"U'teshuva, u'tefila, u'tzedaka
ma'avirin es ra' hagzeirah." If we want
to emerge from Yom Kippur successful and
destined for a year of blessing and
goodness, then what we need to do, the
behavior that will yield that is
teshuvah, introspection, tefilah,
heartfelt davening, tzedakah, generosity
with our resources. On top of those
words in the machzor, teshuvah, tefilah,
and tzedakah, what do you see on top of
those words? Tzom, kol, umamon. Fasting,
the sound, the voice of tefilah, of
prayer, and money.
What we do with our money, our capacity
to share our money shows everything
about how where we know that money comes
from. Sitters snippets, we're learning
about "Vayevarech David" right now. And
the Arizal had a minhag the Mishna
Berurah quotes, when we get up to the
words "Ha'osher v'hakavod mil'fanecha"
in "Vayevarech David" at the end of
P'sukei D'Zimra, there is a minhag to
give tzedakah. Why do we give tzedakah
specifically there? So we're up to that
in Sitters Snippets today or tomorrow.
We'll give several reasons, but one of
which, the one that resonates deeply for
me is the whole paragraph "Vayevarech
David" is David Hamelech saying, "All
the wealth and all the success in the
battles I fought, the material
possessions I've accumulated and
amassed, l'cha Hashem hagdulah, it all
comes from you. Ha'osher v'hakavod
mil'fanecha, the wealth and the honor,
they're from you." So you know that's
lip service. To look at your house and
your car and your portfolio and your
health and your success and say,
"Hashem, that's all you." It's lip
service until you demonstrate that you
really believe it's from Hashem. So when
you stop and you give tzedakah, when you
say "Ha'osher v'hakavod mil'fanecha,
Hashem, you know my wallet, the money in
my pocket, whatever I I have, really
it's from you. It's all from you. I'm
demonstrating it's from you by my
willingness to share it right now with
others. Ha'osher v'hakavod mil'fanecha."
So teshuvah, tefilah, and tzedakah,
tzom, kol, umamon. And many point out,
I'm not a huge gematria guy, but this
one's a famous one. Tzom, kol, umamon
are each 100 and 86 136.
Times three is 408, the same gematria as
zos. And therefore what the pasuk is
telling us is, "B'zos yavo Aaron el
hakodesh." If you want to come into the
kodesh, you want to come into Yom
Kippur, you want to succeed in Yom
Kippur, it has to be b'zos, the gematria
of 408, three times tzom, kol, and
umamon. You have to come in with that
attitude, you have to come in with that
mentality, you have to come in with that
behavior in order to succeed, in order
to be able to emerge. The Imrei Chaim,
you knew we'd get to an Imrei Chaim. The
Hilchos Avodah Zarah, the Imrei Chaim
says differently. "V'lo yavo b'chol eis
el hakodesh." Don't worry, he quotes
that one too. But then he offers
another. "V'lo yavo b'chol eis el
hakodesh." "Lo yavo b'chol eis." You
cannot enter at any time is gematria
b'atzvus. You cannot enter holiness with
sadness. You cannot enter holiness. The
gematria of "Lo yavo b'chol eis" is
b'atzvus. You can't in holiness if
you're sad. The prerequisite to being
holy, to being elevated, to being
enriched, to being spiritual is to be
happy. The sad, somber, depressed,
despondent person can't find holiness.
In order to strive to reach, in order to
find holiness, it has to be based and
founded and built on happiness. That's
what the pasuk says, "Ki b'simcha
tzeitzei'un." You know how you get out
of whatever predicament you're in? You
know how you get out of the tzar, where
it's a narrow place, where we're
restricted to our homes, where we're
fearful of what will be? And how do you
emerge? How do you escape? How do you
elevate and transcend above that
hardship, that challenging time? It's
b'simcha tzeitzei'un, with a sense of
simcha. So "Lo yavo b'chol eis el
hakodesh." "Lo yavo b'chol eis" atzvus.
B'atzvus. You cannot enter with
sadness into kodesh. If you're trying to
get to a place of holiness, trying to
have more kavana in davening, you're
trying to be elevated in your personal
behavior and conduct and your speech and
your thought and your and your
interactions with others, then you need
to first happy. Put a smile on your
face. Smile. Smiling is contagious.
Smiling releases dopamine. Smiling is
what Hashem wants.
"V'avdo b'simcha u'v'tuv lev."
The pasuk
the tochacha, the horrific consequence
the Jewish people face is a result of
"Tachas asher lo avadeta b'simcha."
Because we don't have simcha. "Ki
b'simcha tzeitzei'un." You don't feel
like it? Don't wait to be happy to
smile. Smile and it will make you happy.
"Lo yavo b'chol eis b'atzvus." You enter
any relationship in your life, you
cannot enter kodesh, holiness in your
life with a sense of atzvus, with a
sense of with a sense of sadness. He
then offers another p'shat. He says the
gematria of b'zos is ga'avah, which is
arrogance. You cannot enter holiness,
you cannot enter meaningful
relationships with arrogance, with ego.
You have to put your ego aside. You have
to be able to submit to the other make
space and room for the other. That is a
prerequisite to a meaningful to a happy
relationship. But I want to end our
study of the first passuk. Aren't you
impressed so far? 20 minutes on the
opening passuk with um
the beautiful insight of Shmuel Evitz.
Shmuel Evitz wonders, "What do you mean?
I have a Is that a kodesh?" Frankly,
Shmuel Evitz, the great mashgiach of the
Mir, the shivah of the Mir, he wonders,
"Why? Why is it that I can enter anytime
that he wants?" And Rashi tells us, "The
reason I don't care enter at will is
because the shchinah, the divine
presence, dwells there." Okay, good. But
Aaron is the holy. Aaron is the kohen
gadol. If anyone is eligible, if anyone
is positioned to be able to enter, it's
Aaron. So, why can't he enter? What is
the What is the meaning behind this
mitzvah, behind this instruction or this
warning that Aaron, even after he
purifies himself for 7 days, cannot
enter without being summoned, without
being invited? And listen to what he
writes, Shmuel Evitz. Lamentations Zion.
He says the following.
You know what the enemy of holiness is?
Familiarity.
Familiarity, comfort, casualness is
enemy, the gadol of any of any feeling
of holiness or his aroma of being
elevated.
You know, the first time you visit the
Kotel, the Kotel overwhelming, the sight
of Har Habayit. But what happens when
you live opposite and you wake up to see
it every day? It's a challenge. It's
hard. Familiarity robs us of excitement,
the joy, the passion, the enthusiasm.
Familiarity breeds contempt, we know.
Mixing things up and interspersing and
keeping things fresh is what allows us
to be able to bring a certain level of
enthusiasm. And that's what he says.
Before he can even enter.
What's going on here? And he quotes many
other sources in a really beautiful
insight by Shmuel Evitz. I don't want to
dwell too much. I want to move on.
What's going on? This is
instruction for all of us that
familiarity breeds contempt and that the
antidote to familiarity is
to keep things fresh, to keep things
real, to introduce novelty and newness
and innovation, to take a break and come
back. That is the source of holiness.
Without it, you can't have holiness. And
this is a message for us. It's a message
about our davening and keeping it fresh,
about our learning and keeping it fresh.
I spoke the other night about I gave a
talk on shalom bayit when you can't
leave the bayit. And we talked about
this insight of Shmuel Evitz because
that's a danger. We're living on top of
one another 24/7. Newlyweds to empty
nesters, we're on top of one another
24/7. This is the ultimate incubator of
familiarity. And God forbid it should
breed a contempt that there is no space,
that we can't ever retreat, that there
are no bounds, that there is too much
familiarity.
Shmuel Evitz is right. If we want
kedusha to our kedushin, holiness within
our marriage, then we need to be able to
navigate and negotiate how to have a
sense of closeness without breeding a
familiarity which would undermine that
sense of closeness. Okay, let's move on.
Here we have the introduction to the
story of Yom Kippur.
How does he approach? How does he enter?
He enters the
He comes with a bull for a sin offering
and
And then
And then the Torah goes on tells us
passuk Zion, skip ahead.
He takes two goats.
And these two goats, how are they
identified? When
Aaron goes, he does a lottery on them.
One is for Hashem and the other is for
God. And he goes through this very
peculiar ceremony. He draws lots,
distinguishes which of these goats are
exactly identical. One of them is
dedicated to Hashem, will be offered
sacrifice, and the other will
be be pushed off a cliff. And again, we
feel for animals. We have love and our
sensitivity and love of animals, but the
role of animals within our service and
personal growth, they serve as the
leather of our couch and our shoes and
our belt and the steak that we eat and
the carbonos that we offer in this in
this service serve. So, it would be a
waste and it would be cruel if we didn't
understand what it's about and what
we're meant to get out of it. So, what's
really going on over here? You're
pushing an animal off a cliff and who is
Azazel? Azazel, what is this name
Azazel? So, the kohen gadol takes these
two goats and stands them before Hashem
and places these lots upon them. One
will be offered and one will be pushed
off the cliff. One is called Azazel. The
goat to God, I get. Hashem, we
understand. We know Hashem. We're not
too familiar with Hashem. We don't have
a familiarity or a casual relationship.
We have a sense of awe of Hashem, but
we've heard of Hashem. We know Hashem.
What is this Azazel that the Torah here
is referring to, which is so critical to
understand this whole section of our
parsha? And frankly, it's critical to be
able to experience Yom Kippur
So, make notes for Yom Kippur. Why is it
called Azazel? So, the Ibn Ezra and the
Ramban on our parsha both reference the
Gemara in Yoma on daf samech zayin amud
bet.
Azazel is a combination of two names.
Azazel is machaper, pushing this goat
cliff atones for the act of the fallen
angels, Uzza and Azael. That makes it
much better. That clears it up for us.
Only it does. Who are Uzza and
Azael? What masa? What is the episode
they went through? Why do they need
atonement? And how does this atone for
their mistake? Again, many of you, many
of us have lived many Yom Kippurs and we
read the avodah in our machzor and we
read parshas Acharei Mos. But we don't
begin to understand what the
significance or symbolism is here. And
it's so critical to understand. Who are
these angels? What happened to them? So,
where both the parsha and even the
Gemara in Yoma leave off, the Zohar
parshas Balak picks up. And the Zohar on
parshas Balak tells us that when the
Ribono shel Olam, when the Almighty
created the world, nobody objected to
the introduction of the trees and the
clouds and the ocean and the sun and the
moon. No angels no objected to any of
the creations in nature. Beautiful. What
a great background. What a great
backdrop. But when man was created, when
proposed man, and remember he consulted
the angels.
Nasa in the plural, the angels took that
invitation to an opinion and they
staunchly objected. And they said,
"What is man that you're mindful of him?
Who ben Adam, and the son of man that
you visit?" Passuk in Tehillim perek
ches passuk aleph. Man is frail and
fallible and imperfect. Why is he worthy
of your creation and attention? The
angel looked at God and he said, "You
know, the rivers and the streams, the
Grand Canyon, the Swiss Alps, psh,
they're magnificent. We got it. Thanks
for creating them. But this pathetic
reject nebach is worth man. He's filled
with mistakes and temptation. He's
inadequate and unworthy. He's frail.
He's fallible. Why in the world are you
creating man?" Hashem said,
"Thanks for the input, but it's not
really a committee." And he went forward
and created man nonetheless. And when
man made that mistake, when Adam and
Chava made the mistake in Gan Eden and
got them expelled, and yet they obtained
a pardon, two angels objected. They came
to God and they said, "What do you mean
you're giving them a pardon? What do you
mean you've expelled them and you're
giving them a second chance at a
continuity of this experiment called
humanity?" Uzza and Azael approached
Hashem and said, "We were right. Man is
frail and fallible and wrong." And
Hashem looked at the two of them and he
said
to these angels, "Had you been with
them, you would have sinned equally."
And he cast them down from their high
estate in heaven onto the earth. He
looked at Uzza and Azael and he said,
"Had you been tempted, had you been Had
you been
solicited, had you been recruited, you
would have made the same mistake." And
with that, he took these two angels and
he threw them down from the heavenly
abode down here to earth. Where did they
go? Where did they go when he threw them
down? Ad kan, the Zohar. The Zohar gives
us the greater background. Azazel
machaper for the masa of Uzza.
Now,
who were Uzza and Azael? These two
angels who were the prosecutors against
us, who objected to our creation and
then threw it in Hashem's face and said,
"Told you so." When we made our mistake,
Hashem says, "You would have done
worse." And he threw them down to earth.
Where did they go? Ad kan, here the
Zohar
leaves off.
Says the Ishbitzer Rebbe in his Beit
Yaakov,
the Mashgiach of the great Ishbitzer
Rebbe in his Beit Yaakov, he says, "You
know where they went? Uzza and Azael,
my dearest friends, they went into each
one of us.
Their voice
of of prosecution, their voice of
indictment, their voice of objection,
"Man is pathetic and unworthy
and incapable and inferior and
inadequate and frail and infirm and
fallible. Man is insignificant and
inconsequential." Those voices are in us
and they continue to haunt us. And says
the Ishbitzer Rebbe on Yom Kippur, on
the holiest day of the year, on the time
designated for a fresh start and a new
beginning, you know what we do with that
voice of Azazel, of Uzza and Azael that
are inside us? We thrust them and throw
them off a cliff.
And we say, "Voices of negativity, voice
of unworthiness, voices of being
incapable, we're throwing you off a
cliff. We're getting rid of you." You
see the philosophy of angel Azazel has
crept into our psyche. It rings in our
ears. It tells us we are impo-
and we have shortcomings and
deficiencies. We're not the strongest,
the most best looking, the most
creative, most capable. And therefore,
we underachieve. So, we take that voice
that causes us to underachieve, and what
do we do with it? We throw it off a
cliff. Listen to the words of the
Halacha Yishbitzer.
This voice is makatreg. It tries to
bring us down. You know, this is
particularly true. I've been reading
articles of people who have been acting
out, and I've been talking to chaverim
who were benei aliya, who in outside of
the quarantine, before this all struck,
were striving and reaching and aspiring.
And then, all of a sudden, we've been
knocked out of our routine and our sense
of normalcy, cast into roles that we're
uncomfortable with, that are difficult,
that are are inconvenient. We have been
broken out of the
platform that helps propel us forward,
and therefore, people are acting out on
the internet with what they're looking
and what they're doing. They're not
davening the way they could, learning
the way they could, behaving the way
they could. They've stopped exercising.
They're overeating. You've seen the
countless memes and gifs supporting
that. And that voice inside us that
says, "I can't and I give up, and I'm
not capable, and I can't grow in this
environment." Comes along the avoda of
Yom Kippur. We take Aza and Azael.
Take this Azazel, the combination of
these two angels represented by this
goat, and we throw it off a cliff. We
are capable. We can
We can strive. We can reach.
We should not give up on ourselves. We
should not feel we can't do it. Push
that voice off a cliff. Get rid of it.
Says the Beis HaMikdash and says the
Ishbitzer, "Why don't we move on?"
Because, you know, when you say the
vidui on Yom Kippur, you clap the al
cheit, what is not in our parsha, but
our modern day observance of Yom Kippur,
you might say, "What do you mean? Vidui
testifies to the Uzza and Azael are
right. I did this wrong and that wrong
and the other thing wrong. I'm pathetic.
I'm a nebach. I'm a reject." No, it's
saying the opposite. The reason I clap
al cheit and say the vidui is I'm
saying, "Look how much what I does
matters. Look how what I do has impact.
It has cosmic implications, and
therefore, I have to apologize. I have
to atone. I have to stand up and be
accountable." Why? Not because I'm
insignificant, but specifically the
opposite, because of just how
significant
That voice that says you're
insignificant, you're inconsequential,
inferior, that's the voice of these
angels that Hashem threw down to earth.
He put them in us, and we are supposed
to purge them and cast them from us. We
throw those voices off of a cliff. That
is what is going on here in this entire
avoda. So, critically important. Let's
keep going.
Oh, page 642 if you're in the ArtScroll
Stone Chumash. We're continuing in this
entire episode of the
The inside service, the lots, the
confession, the ego
What happens now? Aaron Cohen Gadol, who
succeeded him, immersed themselves in
the water. Where? Bemakom Kadosh, in a
holy place. Vilavash bigadav, and
changed their clothing. We know that
this is the ultimate fashion show of the
year. The Cohen Gadol is constantly
immersing, coming out, washing,
changing, and he's wearing not his
ordinary garments and vestments, but
rather the ones specifically designated
for Yom Kippur. He goes out, viatza,
viasa olaso, he performs the korban ola,
ola sa'am, and hichiper he achieves
atonement ba'ado uva'ad ha'am, on his
own and on behalf of his people.
Elsewhere earlier, it said ba'ado uva'ad
beiso. And in fact, we have this in our
liturgy. In the avoda we read in Mussaf
on Yom Kippur, ba'ado uva'ad so uva'ad
ha'am. And I also spoke about this in
the shalom bayit shiur the other night.
He is included in his family, and they
are included in the people. Why does the
pasuk waste space and time to tell us he
achieves atonement on behalf of himself
and on behalf of his family and on
behalf of the people? Just say he
achieves atonement on behalf of the
people. On behalf of the people includes
the family, includes him.
We see from here a critically important
lesson.
That the greatest way to change your
family, the greatest way to change the
people, is ba'ado, to begin by changing
yourself.
It's easy to point a finger. It's easy
to blame others. It's easy to see
ourselves and cast ourselves as victims.
But if we want to change the energy in
our home, if we want to change the
atmosphere in our home, the answer is
not to blame, and the answer is not to
change others. The answer is to model.
Ba'ado, uva'ad beiso, uva'ad ha'am. It
begins by changing ourselves, and then
we will see the result is our family
will be inspired and changed, and then
we'll see hopefully an even broader
sense of change that comes from that.
But it has to start ba'ado. It has to
begin with ourselves. We have to take
extreme ownership and say, "What could I
do differently? What positive energy can
I contribute? What smile can I put on my
face? What words could I be using? What
actions could I be modeling? Ba'ado,
ba'ad ha'am, uva'ad beiso, ba'ad beiso,
uva'ad ha'am." It begins and it must
begin with us. But in this pasuk it is
described
Cohen Gadol is changing first vilachatz
bisaro. He
He washes his his flesh. Essentially, he
immerses. Where? Bamayim, in a mikvah.
Bemakom Kadosh, in a holy place. What
happens when you don't have a makom
kadosh? I believe the men The men's
mikvah is closed. COVID-19 coronavirus.
It would be unwise. It's unnecessary. A
men's mikvah is something which is
extra. So, what do you do and what
happens? Oh, comes along the Halacha
Imrei Chaim. Says the Vishna Tzur Rebbe,
"Mikvah Yisrael Hashem."
You know,
the mikvah of the Jewish people, we can
immerse ourselves, we can transform
ourselves, we can cleanse ourselves, we
can purify ourselves. Mikvah Yisrael,
the mikvah of the Jewish people is
Hashem.
Ishbitzer.
Bay anarochetz. You say baruch shemei
the same way again. Bay anarochetz. He
teaches. He translates Bay anarochetz,
Bay, in you, anarochetz, I I cleanse
myself. I clean myself. Going back to
our pasuk, "Vilachatz bisaro bamayim
bemakom kadosh." I cleanse myself in a
makom kadosh means I can go to the
mikvah. But what happens when I'm denied
the pride of the mikvah?
Then, bay anarochetz. I can immerse in a
mikvah and I can immerse in you, Hashem.
I can immerse in feeling your presence,
your warmth, your guiding hand. I can
immerse in my davening. I can I can
immerse I do this with you. I can
immerse in meditation and mindfulness
with you. I can immerse by singing,
having a kumzitz with you. Bay
anarochetz. Bay, in you, anarochetz.
Bizov vilachatz bisaro bamayim bemakom
kadosh. Bamakom
Kadosh Baruch Hu. Kishaim Havaya baruch
Hu ola makom. So, that makom, like
"Hamakom yinacheim eschem," and like
"Baruch Hamakom baruch Hu," we just said
at the seder, that term makom is a name
for Hashem. So, therefore, says the
Vishna Tzur, when the pasuk tells us,
"Vilachatz bisaro bamayim bemakom
kadosh," even when you don't have a
mikvah, you can immerse where?
Hashem Kadosh, who is holy. Mikvah
Yisrael Hashem. Even when we don't have
the physical mikvah, we can immerse bay
anarochetz. In you, we can be rochetz.
We can immerse ourselves and cleanse
ourselves in you, Hakadosh Baruch Hu.
Okay. We continue.
Conclusion of the service, and we have
the continuation of the the korbanos
that were offered on Yom Kippur.
And the Torah continues, and it tells us
the prohibition against eating blood.
Blood is the definition of the soul.
This is one of the key sources in the
big debate, how you define death in
Judaism. Is it the cessation of
spontaneous respiration? Is it the
heartbeat and the ability for the blood
to flow? "Ki nefesh habasar badam hi."
There's a correlation between the blood
and blood flow and life and the soul.
This pasuk is one of the sources why not
eat blood, because blood is the source
of the source of life. Okay, continuing,
we have a mitzvah to cover the blood.
What is the nature of this mitzvah to
cover the blood?
There's a whole story Not for Not for
now. Okay, perek Yichus, the next perek.
Now that we finished the story of Yom
Kippur, Vayidaber Hashem el Moshe
leimor, God speaks to Moshe. "Daber el
benei Yisrael ve'amarta aleihem, speak
to the Jewish people and tell them 'Ani
Hashem Elokeichem.' Remind them who I
they are. Remind them of the categorical
difference between I am the omnipotent
being who has created the world, who's
designed the world and designed them.
And here's what I'm telling them. You
ready?
I want to spend time on these next three
pesukim, probably the remainder of our
time together on this beautiful morning.
Torah tells us, Hashem says, "Listen I'm
God, and I programmed you and I designed
you and I created this world, and I know
what's best for you, and I know how
you'll get the best and the most and the
greatest pleasure in life. And are you
ready? Listen carefully. Here's the
deal. Kemasa Eretz Mitzrayim, Mitzrayim
that you lived in, lo sa'asu. Don't
repeat and don't emulate and don't
imitate. Kemasa Eretz Kena'an, don't do
what they do in Canaan. I shouldn't
maybe this is from Shammah that I'm
bringing you there losatsu. So both the
place you're leaving don't imitate,
don't emulate. And the place that you're
going to
pick up their habits. We will have to go
same loss of
don't follow their decrees and their
traditions. We have a specific
commandment to be a Jew and to live like
a Jew, to have Jewish lifestyle, Jewish
hats, Jewish routine, Jewish behaviors.
We cannot emulate and emulate the other
nations of the world. Of course
we have much in common with them. And of
course we derive the beauty of what they
have to offer and we contribute to
but on the whole we are informed and
inspired by distinctly and uniquely
Torah values, Torah ideals, and Torah
behaviors. What is this talking about?
Can my say it's the time? What is it
specifically talking about? Can my say
it's the time that we are not supposed
to imitate? So open your microscope
let's go to the microscope
and look first let's see. Can my say
it's the time Dr. Lottie
These
are the most degraded decadent and the
most morally corrupt of all the nations
of the world. The also market share
and that place you were living in they
had lost their moral compass. They were
morally corrupt. Don't be defined by the
morals and the ethics and the ethos and
the values of where you're living. My
dear friends we too have to be careful
where we are living is incredibly kind
and it has offered us beautiful
religious freedom and prosperity. And
it's inviting us to be able to integrate
and assimilate and that in here is the
danger. We have Jewish values and
perspectives on all areas of life and we
do not follow it's the time we have to
not follow that which is deemed corrupt.
I shouldn't maybe this is from Shammah
and when they get to Canaan the nations
that they will conquer who call me cool
and they too are the most corrupt. Same
loss of
you cannot follow their
I am
their their their their stadium their
their their um
their entertainment sources. It's not
who we are. Their styles and fashions
that is not who we are. We have to
elevate. We have to elevate above it
says Rashi. The clear cut expands here
and I want to bring your attention to
this beautiful clear cut. Clear cut says
can I say it's the time
what does this mean? Why does it say I
should be shocked and bow? We don't know
we from there. When God tells motion
motion is telling the people that the
people of Egypt that you came from. What
did that we came from? They don't know
where they came from it's stamped in
their passport. They know exactly where
they just came from they suffered there
for 210 years.
And so on.
And and the the clear cut therefore
comes to the final conclusion.
You know what the problem was? Don't
emulate what you did in the time and you
know what the horrific thing you did in
the time was? I share you shaft in bow.
You settled there.
What happens? Where's the clear cut
getting this from? When they left Egypt
and they're in the desert this
incorrigible people continue to complain
to motion and one of the things they say
is take us back to the time. They had an
unbelievable buffet. The salad bar there
was fantastic. The lifestyle there we
miss it. Why did you take us out in the
desert to die here? We miss it and we
want to go back to the time. Craved
settling in Egypt. They wanted to
identify and walk like Egyptians. They
wanted to assimilate into the Egyptian
way.
So the clear cut understands what's
going on here in the
and here we come to a
good message. And he says you know what
the problem
I share you shaft in bow. It's not
extraneous to say that you dwell there.
It is exactly the root and the core of
the mistake and the problem of what we
are being enjoined to avoid. Can my say
it's the time I share you shaft in bow
low satsu. What's the low satsu? What is
it you're not supposed to do? I share
you shaft in bow. There are reasons to
live outside of Israel. There are
legitimate reasons not yet to make out
there. People have financial, family,
health
serving the community there are
legitimate reasons. But there are no
legitimate reasons not to be struggling
with when we'll make out there. Not if
when and how we can fulfill this dream.
We are guests we are here temporarily.
The only place a Jew has permanence is
in Israel it's where we belong. And as
tonight and tomorrow we'll celebrate the
religious significance of a
performing miracles that were literally
as great as the splitting of the sea and
plagues to give us back our home land
and to give us back a sense of
sovereignty and the ability to protect
ourselves. Look at
what's going on in
the statistics. There are roughly the
same number of people who live in Israel
as who live in New York and New York
City and yet look at the difference of
the casualties. Look at the difference
of the of the behavior of the social
distancing that's led to not to suggest
that we're better or deserve better but
the behavior and that's because we have
that ability to govern and to rule
ourselves. It's a miracle for which we
have to express gratitude and whatever
we do.
No whatever you do the pause and take a
moment say thank
you for this gift. Thank you for this we
should just be able to fly and visit and
ultimately move there again. So says the
clear cut can my say it's the time you
know what it is that you did in the time
that low satsu you shouldn't repeat I
share you shaft in bow that you settled
that you thought you were there
permanently that you want to be just
like them that you didn't move and make
a move to be able to come to
because that's where we belong and
that's what the clear cut continues can
my say it's the time I wish you all the
best
they
wish you all
the best
they love they crave they were
magnetically drawn to the land of
Israel. But here says the clear cut the
Jewish people
they were fine living in Egypt. They
were perfectly happy living in Egypt. So
much to orchestrate events to be able to
bring them and drag them to Israel.
So what's the master Canaan I shall I
need
low satsu. What we should not do that's
like master Canaan the low satsu there
is I shall I need
that God says I have to drag you. I have
to drag you there by by increasing the
anti-semitism in
where you are. I have to drag you there
by making things so inconvenient or
uncomfortable that you realize it's time
to go. We're not supposed to redeem
these
repeat these patterns of history. So you
hear this of clear cut fantastic. The
that we
is I share you shaft in bow. That we
settled there. And the
Canaan that we're not supposed to repeat
low satsu is that I share I need
that we have to be dragged there. Says
the clear cut of shits
writing a long time ago not with
Zionistic
underpinnings that these two this
which is telling us about how we're to
behave and what we're to not emulate is
essentially our our mission statement as
a nation of a people of how we're
supposed to see ourselves when we're in
and that we should be driven not if but
when there's legitimate reasons not to
make out there there are no legitimate
reasons not to be struggling with when
we will be able to make that out there.
Another understanding of it's the time
is and the more
says all the time he said it in our
school several times in fact that
time was known as a place of
of superstition.
It was governed by
superstition and horoscopes and magic.
And
says can my say it's the time I took you
out of there. You're not supposed to
look at or worship or subscribe to
horoscopes and superstition and magic.
You have me to
be telling with
means it's prohibited to turn to or to
look for answers elsewhere. In fact
says Rashi you're not allowed to go
the
says you know what
is? A red band. Tying a red string
around your wrist the
right is you
think you're going to misbehave you're
going to speak
you're going to
you're going to cheat in business you're
going to
oh but I tied a red string around my
wrist I'm good to go nobody can harm me
nobody can touch me. That's
that's not a Jewish mentality that's not
that's going back to Egypt that's my
I took you out of Egypt why are you
going back? Tying a red string. We just
ate a delicious color.
Those who subscribe to
I'm not going through the history of it
right now I'm not railing on it. Someone
made me and I ate a delicious
it's a school of when everyone bites
into the metal key. But the
is if you think that you know what I
don't have to have virtue or merits I
can act out behave
I put a key in my or I shaped my like a
key the is going to flow this year. Then
you've gone back to
then you're simply walking like an
Egyptian then you're subscribing to
silly nourish superstitions. But if you
say when I put a key in my
it reminds me that the
is reminiscent of the man. And just like
the man descended from heaven
is the one who's responsible for my
this man
or not man legitimate or illegitimate
reminds me that the man descends from
heaven my also descends from heaven. It
therefore reinforces and promotes the in
me
okay then it's beautiful. So we have to
measure and we have to evaluate each of
these behaviors. Is it silly
superstition then can my say it's the
time it's taking me back to Egypt. Does
that have greater meaning? Then it's
something which is okay. Says the Sfas
Emes, kamasa eretz mitzrayim
Says the Sfas Emes, what is this talking
about kamasa eretz mitzrayim? Which
behave
Which behaviors?
Listen to the Sfas Emes, the Ger Rebbe,
Reb Yehuda Leib of Ger.
When the Torah says don't be like an
Egyptian, it's not talking about things
that are prohibited, eating non- kosher,
violating Shabbos, wearing shatnez.
That's not what it's talking about when
it says don't be like an Egyptian. And
how does he know that, the Sfas Emes?
Because the Torah explicitly tells us
those prohibitions. So, obviously that's
not what it's talking about. So, then
what is it talking about? It's not
talking about things that are already
prohibited, it's talking about even that
which is permissible. The style, the
fashion, the ethos, the mentality, the
attitude, the behavior.
Don't be like the host country in which
we're living, but rather fashion
specifically a Jewish way of life and
the Jewish value. And thirdly, I want to
share with you on this pasuk kamasa
eretz mitzrayim one more upshat, and
this is a beautiful from an article from
one of my rebbeim, Rabbi Yaakov
Neuburger, shlita, and he says the
following beautiful insight, quotes from
the Rebbe. Kamasa eretz mitzrayim, what
is this ma'aseh? The practice of the
Egyptians. So,
according to many of our meforshim, to
the nature of social interaction, that
we're supposed to study, learn, and
deplore, and distance ourselves from. We
don't hang out in bars, and we don't
follow certain behaviors. When it comes
to social behaviors, we have a Jewish
standard, a Torah standard. Rebbe
explains that the word ma'aseh in Torah
indicates social conduct, and ultimately
the attitude of a people toward justice
and civic life. It's certainly
reasonable to claim masters could state
start out as individuals whose entire
world consisted of themselves and their
needs. Perhaps that's why we are
reminded in that pasuk that we must not
emulate the Egyptians among whom we
lived. Apparently, it's precisely
because we felt the awful sting of a
society built on self-focus that we
should seek to protect ourselves from
the behaviors that could have
contributed to the development of that
culture. In other words, we are who we
live with.
We are affected, nature and nurture. So,
we've been nurtured in Egypt, we might
behave like them. That's what we're
being warned. Kamasa eretz mitzrayim,
when it comes to our interactions with
others, don't be like them. It's not
okay to gossip, or to judge, or to
negate, or to ostracize. It's not okay
to marginalize. It's not okay to extort
or exploit the most vulnerable in
society. Kamasa eretz mitzrayim, just
because we so long did that in Egypt
doesn't mean it's okay for us. And here,
Rabbi Neuburger quotes a beautiful
insight.
Reb Baruch Halevi Epstein, the author of
the Torah Temimah, has a beautiful
sefer, we use it in Seder Snippets,
Baruch Sheamar, and there he says the
following. What is the pshat when we say
in Hallel, we said it, when we left
Mitzrayim we describe it now as beit
Yaakov me'am lo'ez. The house
left me'am, a people lo'ez, who had a
strange language. That was the big
miracle, God took us out. He took us out
from an oppressive people, persecuting,
torturing us, people who were killing
us. He took us out, they had a different
language. Why is that significant? Why
is that important? Why does David
Hamelech choose to describe our
oppressive, our oppressors in this
non-descriptive term? You know, even
people who treated us well could have
had a foreign language. Why is he
describing them me'am lo'ez, a nation
with this foreign language? And listen
to what the Torah Temimah says. The
Torah Temimah suggests that the
Egyptians are being referred to as an
evil tongue nation, not a foreign tongue
the nation, but evil, as perpetrators of
la'az. La'az is lashon hara. The
Egyptians, even their moral code, had
absolutely no problem with gossip, with
negativity, with slander. They had no
problem with being verbally abusive.
Me'am lo'ez, that was the vernacular,
the vocabulary, the language of the
Egyptians was la'az, was lashon hara,
was negative. It was a tool the Egyptian
leadership used against us to try to
marginalize, and to torture, and to
abuse us.
And that's what we're being warned, and
that's what we're being told. David
Hamelech is saying beit Yaakov, we have
the ability to come out and elevate
me'am lo'ez, to use our power of
language so differently, and to rise
above. And that's what the pasuk is
teaching us, says Rabbi Neuburger.
Kamasa eretz mitzrayim, what is the
behavior in Mitzrayim that we're
supposed to elevate above? Don't talk
gossip, and don't negate others, and
don't judge, and don't be verbally
abusive, and don't slander. We are me-
beit Yaakov me'am lo'ez. Kamasa eretz
mitzrayim, we are not supposed to
imitate or emulate that behavior. But
what I want to spend our last few
minutes on
is really contrasting the last two, the
next two pesukim, which is all we'll
have time for.
The next two pesukim seem utterly
redundant and repetitive, and even so
out of order. What's going on? Perek has
chapter 18, verse dalet.
Carry out my laws and guard my decrees,
and follow them.
side of mishpatim and chukim. just said
mishpatim and chukim, now we switch the
order, chukim and mishpatim. Asher
ya'aseh osam adam v'chai bahem. And if
you do this, if you safeguard them,
v'chai bahem, you will earn life. And
how do I know that? Ani Hashem. So, he
tells us in two successive pesukim, he
tells us he's God, we already knew that.
He tells us to observe the chukim and
mishpatim, he just told us that. He
switches the order of it for some
reason, and he throws in, by the way, if
you do this, then v'chai bahem. What in
the world is going on over here? So, the
Or Hachaim Hakadosh, Or Hachaim ben
Attar, tells us that here we have a
formula or a prescription for personal
growth. Again, if we had time, I would
walk you through Rashi. Rashi has what
to say on each of these. And the Ramban
has a beautiful insight. But the Or
Hachaim Hakadosh, I want to draw your
attention to, says the following.
Ushmartem, asks the Or Hachaim our
question.
Why are we repeating what we just said?
So, these are repeated again. Shamru
v'chai bahem ushimartem. Shim tzu lav
v'halachas Hashem ya'aveh v'ya'aroch.
Here we have something that we are all
fulfilling right now. What does it mean
v'chai bahem? We have a mandate to live
by them. To live by them means that
Torah, all the laws and rules of Torah
are there to enhance our life, to enrich
our life. And if they would cost us our
very life, then what is the point of
them if they were not here to enjoy and
benefit from them? And therefore,
outside of the three cardinal sins,
murder, promiscuity, and idolatry, we
are supposed to violate Torah law rather
than sacrifice or give our life. And
sadly in our time, we are fulfilling
this mandate, this mission of v'chai
bahem, regularly. In fact, Rabbi
Soloveitchik comments and talks about
his grandfather, who is being referenced
a lot these days, Reb Chaim of Brisk,
who was very, very strict on v'chai
bahem, that pikuach nefesh, that saving
a life
And therefore, we are forfeiting
minyanim,
the rules of Shabbos, and people being
able to drive, to donate plasma. Left
and right, v'chai bahem, we are
fulfilling chaim bahem all around us. He
tells a story that his grandfather, Reb
Chaim, disagreed with the legal view
that on the day of Yom Kippur one can't
feed a sick person small amounts at a
time, each amount less than the
forbidden measure. He instructed those
who were taking care of a sick
individual to serve a regular meal just
as they would on other days. When my
father was about to travel to a town
close to Kovno to take up a rabbinical
post, Reb Chaim turned to him and said,
"I command you to follow my view if a
sick person is in danger on Yom Kippur,
for it is an absolute halachic truth."
Reb Chaim was very strict. He said, "I'm
not being lenient on Yom Kippur, I'm
being strict in v'chai bahem and pikuach
nefesh. This is our mission, our
mandate. And those who play with it have
the status of a rodef. This is not a
time to play with it, or to be lenient,
or flexible. We are strict like Reb
Chaim Brisker on v'chai bahem." So, says
the Or Hachaim, coming back to the Or
Hachaim,
Ashlosha varim sh'adam chayav leharog
v'al ya'avor. There are three areas that
you have to give your life
So, the first pasuk is referring back to
arayos. We have the whole section of
acharei mot that tells us about the laws
of promiscuity, of licentiousness, of
immorality, of all the relationships
that are out of bounds. So, the pasuk
that is adjacent to that section doesn't
include v'chai bahem, because you have
to lose your life rather than violate
And therefore, we repeat the pasuk again
when it's adjacent now to the next
section. When it comes to the rest of
mitzvos, now v'chai bahem, one should
forfeit the mitzvah in order to ensure
their life, because the whole mitzvos
are there in order to enhance our life.
That is their purpose, that is the
reason, that is why they are, that is
why they are here. Rabbi Soloveitchik
says something very interesting.
On es mishpatay tasuvu es chukotai. He
says this word chok,
really chukim seem to be irrational. If
not for the divine imperative, never
observe them. We assume a divine purpose
and value, but we cannot fathom them.
Mishpatim, on the other hand, reflect
cultural humanistic considerations. Yet
the force of the divine command applies
to both, demanding observance and
unqualified commitment. In other words,
what's the difference between mishpatim
and chukim? And we repeated and we
changed the order of it. The mishpatim,
we understand, they serve humanistic
considerations, they're intuitive,
they're rational. The chukim seem to be
a divine imperative beyond our
understanding. Rashi cites a ben a
comment on parah adumah. It's a decree
ordained by me, you have no right to
question it. This suggests that chok can
be defined as an absolute norm and an
ultimate command demanding total
submission without reservation. It is to
be affirmed even if the sudden in the
nations of the world taunt Israel
ridiculing its irrationality. The
observant Jew accepts the Torah as a
patient follows the prescription of a
doctor, taking complex medications,
submitting to required super surgical
procedures. The chok has two
characteristics, universal immutability
and the fact that a chok is independent
of situational factors.
Etymologically, the root chok, ches,
kuf, kuf, signifies the act of carving,
engraving, making incisions in a hard
surface like stone or metal. And that's
the idea of a chok. It is it is engraved
onto our heart. It is within us. And
what the Rebbe suggests here, I wish I
had the time to go through it entirely.
And in fact, if you look on the bottom
of the Artscroll Stone Chumash, this is
one of the places that it quotes Rabbi
Soloveitchik in the Artscroll Chumash.
The Rav says, "Even a chok comes from
the pintel Yid inside us. We think that
the mishpatim are the result of our
rational thinking and a chok is beyond
us. It's not beyond us. The word chok,
chakak, engraved in us means Hakadosh
Baruch Hu put up within the pintel Yid.
He put it within our Jewish soul that we
don't arrive at it intellectually, and
yet we can sense we have a familiarity,
we have a comfort with us with it
because Hakadosh Baruch Hu engraves it
within our hearts and within our and
within our soul. V'chai bahem.
I'll just end off with the Kotzker
Rebbe. I bahem. Says the Kotzker Rebbe,
"V'chai bahem,
v'lo she'yamus bahem." V'chai bahem
means V'chai bahem means the way in
which we're supposed to do the mitzvahs.
"Shmartem es mishpatai, mishpatai,
observe Torah, v'chai bahem." How do you
earn life? Do you earn
If you're have a pulse, but you're not
connected to Hashem, to his world, to
his prescription for how to find
meaning, purpose, and happiness, you're
not really alive. And how are we
supposed to do it? With a sense of
v'chai, with a sense of hislahavus, with
a passion, with an energy, with an
enthusiasm, with a with a zeal, with a
sense of with a sense of joy. So, we
should merit v'chai bahem to be healthy
and to be able to live without having to
sacrifice mitzvahs, and we should merit
v'chai bahem to do those mitzvahs with a
sense of joy, a sense of fervor, a sense
of a great
Thank you so much. Have a wonderful and
a meaningful day.