Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
recording in progress okay good morning
dear friends how are you we have
uh Dr AI we have R Michael we have Dr
Lewis and R yosua is here today yeah
welcome okay so we have a special she
very interesting topic let's begin
with says
in sh
that's 1,10 look where my icon
is it says I swore and I fulfilled to
keep the laws of your righteousness
which seems to indicate that if D swore
to observe something that we're allowed
to swear to observe something but
says nowadays you don't swear
lest you
violate but the earlier Generations even
if that you would kill them they
wouldn't violate their so basically
nowadays you could swear to do a
Mitzvah I'm sorry nowadays you cannot
swear to do a Mitzvah but back in the
day where they would never violate an
oath then
they were allowed to swear meaning in
the times of D it was reasonable to
swear maybe in earlier Generations it
was reasonable to swear because they
would never violate their Shu but
nowadays where that you might violate
your shua you cannot follow the G's
advice of swearing to be like the says
on
and the asks what do you
mean a person's allowed a swear to
energize
himself so what's interesting is the
says we don't
swear
in Chua Maya Chua Maya are the respons
of rebelar FAL
the to be at his
inag he asks the following
question he
asks why do what's the difference
between earlier generations and later
generations the is not anyway so if the
is not who cares if you'll violate it
the only reason you did it is because
you wanted to misar yourself but if it
turned out you couldn't keep it you're
not violating a because it wasn't anyway
right Yeshua Yeshua is into it so uh
what's the reason why the says that
you're not allowed to swear B to
encourage yourself what's the problem oh
because maybe you'll violate it who
cares the is not anyway yeah that's the
Kasha of
the take a look in
that we don't do
it is only for
and the
asks and
answers so if that's the case if you
violate
the all you're violating is the Mitzvah
itself because is only is not it's only
it's
only and the Mitzvah anyway you had to
observe
and the that that's now is not so what's
the saying that we don't do this only in
earlier Generations well what's the the
anyway okay that's
theer wrote notes on sh
cha and rer points out that we have to
examine the gar more carefully because
let's take a look at the ran
and let's take a look at
Tois the ran
learns
that the gar Kasha is how could you
swear but the sh is only for things that
are discretionary not for things that
you have to
do
only being carbon is
a only I'm sorry onlyb is a for a
discretionary thing but
for even if it's a but then why do we
bring the of and what's the's answer Co
to the r take a look
inside like in middle of the page on the
round
says you're allowed to energize
yourself definitely this p is is not
needed to
say we don't need this to say
it's how do I know it's a h to swear
to even that are that refrain from
they
swear now according to the ran is the or
is
the it seems like the shu is
not meaning I don't need the PK to say
that I'm sorry yeah what would you say
according to the r is or
is it seems like according to the ran
the is the ran says I don't need a p to
say of
to say that it's why would it not be I
only have the of by but I don't have it
by is that even though the how do I know
it's the right thing to do oh we learn
out
from so according to the
r that
the with the comments of the hold true
you're going to
say I'm sorry the with the question of
the Chua be a good question the CH Maya
asks well why wouldn't we swe B it's not
anyway no no that's not true the would
say it's not but
it's so since
it's is saying very good we will not
swe because you might violate it and
that would be going according to the of
the
that
however learns if you look
in if you're not m
look at
toala
prous mu
so RBI kager quotes
tysus
that let's see if I could see it inside
the Tois to Ella
I don't see it inside in the
tus maybe in the
rush let's see if you look in the rush
the rush learns the is at all and the is
the and it's not considered
being if you're
or if you're
not it's not considered
being so bottom line is we know what the
ran holds it seems like other disagree
the r holds the is
not but it
is other it's not
even so says the question of the on the
who says that we don't swear because you
might violate it that only is a good
question according to the that say the
is so you could ask since it's why why
should we refrain in our generation from
making such a but according to the ran
that the is
just but it
is the would not have a question at all
by the
way there are like the who explains that
what thear is saying is
is not
even but if you're
not you will
be so even though the is
not it's not that if you break it you're
over you would not be over but you would
be swearing
falely what's interesting is if you look
in
brings that it's to
swear and none of the say anything that
implies that they hold not like
the and you would be able to swear that
you're for example it
says you're allowed to
make or if you're afraid thear will make
you violate an A or not being mitzvah
you could
swear that seems to be not like
the what that might mean if you look in
the theam says if somebody was
mael to do a Mitzvah and he's afraid he
might not fulfill it you could make a NE
that you accept upon yourself you're not
going to eat
until you fulfill the Mitzvah so it's
not like you're making NE to do the
Mitzvah you're asking offering yourself
to do some to eat let's say until you're
M the
Mitzvah however says the bottom line is
uh you should be very careful with not
to do this because he's seen many people
be so that's that implies either like
the ran that the ne is to some extent or
at least like the Mei that even if the
ne is not not for not for but violating
it would be
a
okay just a short thought on okay have a
great day and um stay tuned for this
week's schedule
because probably the Wednesday night
show this week is going to be Tuesday
night we're switching things up this
week the Wednesday night show will be
Tuesday night so the Tuesday night gor
have to figure out when we're doing that
okay
everyone have a good day
record thank you call bye
