Rain On Shabbos - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] like to welcome everyone to from 718 851 8651 email.com I don't know if you notice but the past it was raining someone told me actually the past eight ches it was raining besides a shab sh but 8 weeks in a row it rained this is the first shabas it didn't rain but raining today just for our year talk about raining but the truth is as we'll see today the sugya of the rain on chabas is a big sugya and I'm going to start with fear cases four question that we had that really will wet your appetite to try to figure this out simple question someone told me one of the let's say it's a moderate rain like we have now it's drizzling and the person's is wearing his winter coat on chabas and whenever I say on chabas I mean without an a obviously and he's going to oh it's it's going to my my coat can get ruined so he wants to put the the plastic rain coat over his winter coat so this P officially said it's because you're wearing it just to protect the coat you're not wearing it if it's a heavy rain and you might get wet so it's m but here just to protect the coat it's like many P can hold it's also to wear a hat cover that was one second question we had today they made new types of coats and M and and even spring coats that they have a hood that's hanging and when you if it's not raining you roll it up and you put it into a pocket is that M to go in shabas wrapping up rolling up the hood and putting it in then someone asked me a question he would had a very expensive hat and he want to know is it is there to wear a plain rain hat the cover the plastic rain hat cover that that has been worn I think the question that really was interesting to me someone said he was by and it was a heavy heavy rain that chabas and someone walked in a little late and obviously he didn't have a rain coat and he wrapped himself totally around with a plastic tablecloth so he came and looking like obvious like a ghost but he was wrapped around to keep dry and the r says I have to be this is was an ad but he felt this wasab so if you think about it we could reduce these questions and many more to one simple question question you to wear a Mal because it's obviously B of the let's say you have a let's say this fellow don't want to get wet he'll walk from his house to the Sho and a in a a tremendous mobble he'll get wet so maybe tar would also legitimize doing something which is not a malish necessarily that was the question that we began with but as we always hopefully see but today I think it's clear the sh that everything is there in we're going to find the most interesting sources for the most contemporary new type of shus the gar says in the D you to go out with a sack cloth yes as as crude as it is like you know went out when he was in Aus you allow to go out with a sackcloth and a different type of cloth sackcloth Bia with a she onab in other words it's raining and you're get wet so you're allow to put even on a cloth a sackcloth or a a a regular sheet to protect you from the rain oh this is what we're looking for here we have beish that to save you from rain is M and the rush explains since the D to go out with these type of cloths these sacks it becomes a I guess it's a malush and it's not a Mas now don't forget they didn't have plastic in those days what did they use use they use these type of material so here we have that if you're wearing something to protect you from the rain it should be but it can't be because the same Rush adds a few words this sack cloth is so much M that even if it's not raining you're allow to wear it the you went to SCH you put on your sack cloth it was raining you want to walk home and it's not raining but to leave it in SHO it'll get mixed up everybody else's sackcloth so what do you do you want to wear it home so if the only is ques this so there must be a bigger and that's what the one word the key word for today and that's called malush Mal all the same whence when something has the status of a malush it's mut unconditional rain or shine day or night as we soon see when something is considered a malush it's m that would explain that this sack evidently it has a din of a malush and it's m across the board the word Mal is the Easy Pass even without a that's the we see from this and I'll prove it because the very next word in the here is the same scenario it's raining they don't have they don't have the plastic coats so he decid to be creative Tava is a chest Koopa is a basket is a mat so either he puts the box or the chest on his head or over his head and it's also even though it's says is the is and this is a he going to get very wet apparently as the rush explains so the difference between a and a box we call box I mean t is one's a Mal and one's a I'll tell you why I saw this it was I was I was in Camp once one shabas it was pouring and one of the waiters had to run to his b bunk house to get something so he's a creative fellow so he grabbed one of these trays that they carry six bowls of chant and held it over his head and ran to his bunk house so I told him gently afterward says it's a good thing that there an Arab you're not can't be but the problem is malush I'm sorry the problem is oil he's holding an oil over his head why will soon why is it different than a umbrella so we'll get back to that soon but had this been even though he's taking this tray to protect from it's not a malush a t is not a malush so tray and box and cop is all the same but we see even more we see even more to this magical word called Mal the says same in other words the average person does not wear sack clothing that's not done because of their their situation they do it here the gar is expanding the head of a Mal Bush if there if it's a malush for one group of people it's M for all I normal people don't wear a sack but once it's a Mal it's so here we see the unusual of the word malash in when explains he says that is for for the it's for the rest of us now he doesn't mean the he means once it has the status of a malush malush is M unconditionally shabas weekday rain no rain D of you or not as long as and this is quoted in and says because so we see three on the word malush first of all it's mut Without Rain it's mut as we said even if you're not a Roya and that's not your type of clothing and even in the case the other cases that we said when it's not really a it's and all people now let's go expand this word Mal a little further some told me it's a true story he lives near a and someone knocked at the door early shabas morning I have a message from PL a friend of yours can you come to sh with two pair of socks he said sure well like can I know what's happening well your friend's in the Mikvah and his socks fell into the Mikvah he has no socks for D you can't come to without socks so come to you look close by and you'll make the exchange in so how do you wear two pair of socks during the summer so here we have another another this is in also you're allow to go out with two some say two or more as long as it's the in other words the argue about wearing two belts CU not the but who holds two belts are awesome that why so the explains some people are cold they wear two socks so now we see a further expansion of the word malush Mal is M even for two even during the summer when you don't need it before we apply this I want to to make one more point the in speaking about someone who bleeding and it's a it's a moderate bleeding it's not going to you know cause s but it's going to stay the so the person wants to WearEver but to weara will soon see to stop to prevent the bleeding to go and stain the clothing so the said that's called you're not doing it for your goof you're doing it to protect the bagot and that you can't carry because it it's not bottle it's not a baged it's a piece of material and it's just not enough to become part of you says that you allow to go out with a to protect from bleeding if it's a very light bleeding and it's only that's awesome but the m is talking about that it's heavy bleeding that will dry on the skin and cause irritation ah that is s is even this what's the it's not a real bed but it's one quote unquote we soon see a bandid is a good Marshall it's worn on the go and if it's done to perfect and that's in fact the says but if you want an evenly put on a regular bed cuz on when something is a baged it's m even even if you don't need it if you want to protect your so here we see Crystal Clear when something is a it's without a suff even when something is this in between like a bandaid then and that's the there and explains because it's once you made but if you make it into a b that is a which is M so the word Mal is very very powerful and I'll read the in the next that crystallize the point and then I think we could really move on why once it's a Mal it's one you look in the B One Source is interesting and that's ques this if someone wears a a a sheet a material and he wears it wrapping in those days they WRA like you know we were at tus is a SLE wrapping but they wore like you know like Arabs we today that's M that's it's on the body so therefore reason the one something is and then he has a second to his and we'll appreciate that and that is Sak Sak is not your typical but it's a beg for it's beg for all of us so there here we see this you saw it beautifully one point I'm probably wondering so one second why is it us for the fellow that has no raincoat to wear a not to wear to carry a tray or a box or a Mel this is SAR he's going to get drenched he's going to get spping wet no we're not doubting this is s the answer is it's not even worn a Band-Aid is worn is warn this is carrying it you not to carry something so has to be it has to be a Mal at least carrying something like carrying an umbrella so we have let's apply this we'll start with a interesting question and we'll go in order a malush is muta across the board a good example a spring coat in light weather in light drizzle I'm sorry now let me just remind you cuz it's a different world today but when we were growing up there was a they called it a rain coat spring coat which is basically a rain a rain repellent material but you wore it in this in between weather not winter not summer and that was the rain coat of a they started manufacturing these new ill coats which is very convenient but we're talking about a ring raincoat that's a regular malush the question is you're about to walk the sh it's not so it's not cool outside and it's drizzling slightly so you want to go back home put on this spring coat for only one reason it's not cold just to protect your suit it shouldn't get wet so this is because a spring coat without doubt is a regular Mal and a Mal is even that's p in fact act the second might be I don't know if this the D but would be that some people wear two coats then you could go home and you got an SOS someone needs a a rain coat in the Sho you could wear two rain coats as long as it's the D but one thing is clear it is a malush malush is M across the board so this is that case of a d of a Mal Mish question interesting question and that is someone got a cut on the finger to wear a Band-Aid it's not a but this is as says in if a person has a cut and any type of calls it but the point is you're allowed to go out with a Band-Aid G Pad etc etc if it's today typically it is not protect the B it would be it would be the and that would be okay Bel that's not a Mal in the literal sense but that's nursing pads that prevent of the Goof is question someone asked me this question more more but he had an let's say it's a very heavy rain and if he walks he has no raincoat if he walks to Sho and get sapping wet certain so so he was thinking before shabas open umbrella so he's opening the umbrella on not making an oil so there are two problems on umbrella of today is like the case of the of the S and the Koopa and this not in the end of he has this is the oldfashioned umbrella he says that it's why because it's this is the the the the what we said earlier in other words let me be clear there are really three categories that any sh can fall into one is the word malush malush is M unconditionally period non Mal not mal box T umbrella is also even the in between is it's worn not a full malish we we'll soon see a band cotton in the airs the says says M why is cuz that's worn it's not carrying like an umbrella so Tak the prim is the first to speak about a umbrella that besides of course as the his famous we don't use umbrellas onil it but no doubt about it the umbrella the tray the are all even if it's very very uncomfortable for the Goof cuz it's not worn it's not a malush question true story someone had a very good winter coat it disappeared he looked for for weeks he didn't was one hot shabas after daving he noticed his coats right there in in the in the sho's coat room he wasn't he didn't want to leave it there left the shabas because it's disappeared it's going to and I don't want to get into the details but there's no to bring home something to protect it that shouldn't get get lost but can you wear a winter coat during 90° weather that's not typical so that's not the problem that's once something is but here we have a different problem which is a and that is based on if a person does something that causes others to look at him and laugh at him or be surpris at him so he's going to feel self-conscious and take it off and carry example is walking with one shoe he only has one shoe so one is better than nothing but when people look at you and laughing at you and they wondering what you're doing you're going to carry it that's and it come to carry you see it's not enough to keep shabas you have to be and this is one of them so here the question is walking during 90° weather even 80° weather with the winter coat is it you know and found says this I'll give you similar to his sh someone came to sh and forgot to bring his St heard this supposed to be a true story and he too lazy to walk home so he said to boy from the sh go come go to my house and come back with my stro the boy walks in the sh a suit a red tie wearing a stro all over 12 years old so speaks about short jacket Long Jacket but it's who this is more this is but it's just you know ridiculous it's ludicrous and he adds in that same stickle he adds that would be an issue that is of wearing a winter coat during the summer is fine but the prise you might come to laugh at you why you wear wi to in this weather interesting sh someone as I don't know where he's coming from this is please keep that in mind is it to wear a Woolen during a hot summer shabas so he felt that no one wears during a hot summer day so says first of all if it's a beg during the week it's a beg chabas and also he writes I can't I can't understand it he says many people har go on shabas even on a hot day with a mantle how's that mut par is it's accepted and no one laughs at them now today I know what he means you know see them go with a black overcoat even during the Su is that was that the same in I don't remember that not for my times but maybe that's me but interesting his is you allow to wear man even that's so we coat during the summer that's no them but to wear winter coat St in the street that's a problem told me he had a cast and he was and the whole weekend chabas he wore plastic over it it shouldn't get dirty he was a little of a you know pH want to keep it clean and he said one shab someone stopped him and says you know you're not to do that and you know something the person was right he's only wearing the plastic to protect the cast it's not for for his goof he's not going to getar so that would be a problem of M someone last week P asked me this I'm happy the next week she fits in he want to know can you wear a tal outside on shabas now the story was make a long story short he came to his regular Shool Friday night and he remember that tomorrow he has an offer the other direction he forgot to bring the talus home or the other Sho before shabas so he you have to go from house to the Sho put on the tow and walk a double distance so wants Friday night he'll put on the Talis and go home with it or he he left the tals there and this Friday night he's there again so a goodar house to the right time he wants to wear Talus home Friday night so the EM is no one in America we soon see better no one in America typically unless they re we tal Friday night so maybe Tak it would be awesome and indeed is except now this's a because a Talis besides that fact we wear it but every day we wear a Talis weekday and shabas once you go with FR night also this and he points out that himself says we sh T coton and weekday and shabas even at night so it's a little we have no problem with saying that to wear T Friday night would be m only thing is if you March through the streets without a coat they might laugh at you you know maybe there are some that wear it Friday night fine but here in America it's not done so if you want to we cut over it so that's okay but if it should be it shouldn't be a situation question some woman wanted to help her who's making a and wanted to come prepared so the woman put a apron on her own house put a coat over it and came here I am I'm I'm ready to help don't worry I'm going to I'm wearing an apron I'm not worried about getting dirty I'll help you with the question is are you allowed to wear a apron in the street an apron is a classic example of and this is a problem but the only thing is if you remember earlier we said that a is which is typically Ted as a apron but you look at the say you know why sin is because it's worn in the front and the back so it's a real malush but today's hour aprons that worn just in the front just a little bit and it's color indicates it is done so all the P of today say The Sinner the the The Sinner the the apron is a baged of and however there is is an interesting factor to consider so once it becomes a beged sometimes why different but there is a because the regular aprons are colored so distension show out this is a Visa a very Crystal white beautiful color and also this is this has a different Sur to it it's much more elegant so it's two different so maybe but not the typical apron that's one big bag of T unless again it's war and that will make it a Mal someone asked me he get he sweats a lot so he likes to put a tissue under his shirt color between his shirt and his neck or someone else had to put his he puts a tissue under his y he both are examples of it's not a regular bed it's just how can we not mention hope she never be a gay but during Co people wanted about wearing a mask out so the EM is the mask for those that needed it was a real I wouldn't call a mask a beged but it's at least like a so a mask certainly was M the only issue was when someone was not worried about his health let's say he had antibodies he had whatever he's not worried about himself he's doing it because of so I must mention is a great Factor you make but that's not carrying on if it's not a then you have to know if there's a but definitely if he's wearing it to protect his goof that would be the classic example of the category number three that it's somewhat worn he's not carrying a mask and therefore the go now before I start part two which is the questions of raincoat and raincoats and I must apologize you look at the chart I anticipated speaking about much more than just we're going to do today I about but the raincoat and all these things were such a big so I'm going to have to leave out part of it for another time you know I the question of is is a problem but then again if I go over time that's already but is definitely so we're going to have to leave out for different but what's fascinating is the part two the rain and rain related childish regarding and again you'll see the sh of all the so as we said earlier let's start with the pit a spring raincoat in other words the old fashion that a person wore just p in between raincoat in between winter coat and nothing that's Mal you allow to wear it even though it's a drizzle why a spring coat is a days therefore if you came to sh it was raining you want to wear it home and it's not raining and there's no problem you don't want to leave the coat in sh so that would be M because a malish is M even if it's no longer needed like the sock is M when it's not raining so this is okay question if someone asks you come when you come you sends your message come with two coats two two spring coats I'm stuck in SHO without a spring coat so that you have to know is it the D I don't know it's even to put on a second spring coat but it's therefore could be its worse than two socks but if someone knows that's the okay now let's talk about the it's a thin plastic this is it if any never saw it I'm sure I saw but this is theil a thin plastic and it's worn to as a raincoat in fact someone told me I'm not sure but I heard two gearo that they call some call the chain coat because they don't want to stress rain it's it's a coat Shane coat but then someone else told me that the one that designed it his name is Shane so is you know what the name is but basically we'll call it a Shan it's all the same but it's made to protect you from the rain the question is this partic this type of coat thin plastic that's worn weak day chabas to protect you from rain does it have the status of a Mal G no different than a spring coat and the answer is does this is a malush it covers the Goof it adds a degree of warmth no don't forget when it's hot sum and it's raining people it adds a degree of warmth it it goes over the whole body it's worn with sleeves and everything and I saw all the agree that there's no sh that the of today is a that's very relieving so therefore a person could wear it to sh even though it's a light drizzle he's only wearing it to protect his coat his his jacket I'm sorry in other words a today is category number one Mal also if you go home from scho and it stopped raining and you're afraid to leave it in SCH it will get mixed up with all the others that are in scho you let War at home why you'll ask what about people going to laugh at you so I tell people he's not going to laugh at you cuz he's also wearing his meal home is you know I always wonder what the G think like 11 12:00 you know when it was raining and now it's sunny outside you see just throngs of Eden weing wearing raincoats why is that P because they want to wear at home but not because they have some religious observance but it's interesting you know yeen walking through the streets when it's stop raining everybody's wearing rain coats why to leaveing in sh is going to definitely get lost mixed up but this is a [Applause] Mal now what could be more of AA if you got bring I'm stuck in so to be done and it's probably more effective because sometimes on Heavy Rain it goes through the first M but if it's the the next thing I want to share with you because it's interesting you have to be careful someone told me one of of today that he held he holds that if you go during the winter on a cold winter day and you're wearing a heavy winter coat and it's a very light drizzle and you go back to your house or decide to wear me just to protect the coat in other words you're not walking too far it's not a downpour that might penetrate your coat jacket shirt it's just to protect your coat he held it's also to do that because it's no different than which we'll soon see you can't wear a a rain a hat cover on top of a hat cuz you're doing it of the hat so this is of the coat in fact the person told me that he would see people walking in the street he would tell them you're not to do that a tremendous because if we establish what seems you know POS that is a Mal so Mal Mal M and this fits this is done and it's wor and and maybe it's even like rubbers that will soon see his M so I said maybe he holds malus I couldn't I called him and I said I would like to hear I don't want to misquote you like some people do to me tell me what you said about the the M he goes what do you mean I said you somebody said you said you can't with the mill over the the coat I never said that I said but they said you stop people in the streets so he very adal you know that's not his type at all he says I never did that so you see once again the truth what the says they say things in his name that he never said he never said I mean he never stop people how this came I don't know though but I'm not surprised you know this happens all the time but I was very relieved because it's it's it's Unthinkable to say that if you assume that a is just the category number three not a malush just in between and you're doing like that's awesome but the assumption is the of today is a regular now I did see the say according to maybe a plastic rain could Overcoat his so it could be held it's not the malush but this is written many years ago today it's an accepted malush now the next question is which in comes both in Spring coats and in the you see we'll soon see when when you need this hood for the hat is very helpful and I should mention all agree as soon as you allow to wear the the the hood over the Hat cuz it's part of the malish so that's P it even if you hold a hat cover we don't wear but this Hood that's made and designed to go over the hat and it's part of the raincoat it's attached so if the raincoat is mut always so is the hood and that's the question is let's say it stopped raining we said early L to go home with the but you're not going to cover your hat because it's not raining so you're going to go home just like this with the raincoat with the meal being worn the hood is hanging and basically not functional so the sh is is that m we could compare that to you the tal because the rest of the ti are dysfunctional and therefore are however there's a big because there the ti are dysfunctional you can't use them here the M the could is functional you don't need it it might rain you will use it and even it doesn't rain but it could be used and not talking about a raincoat but he's talking about a hood today the children wear these hoods during a cold day that has a a hood we call it a hood but has a hood in the back and you're allowed to wear that windbreaker Hood with the hood hanging why P it once it has the status of a malush it's m in anyway just like I think all the agree person goes out with shoel that are untied that's dangerous you should you know correct that but there's no by coat that has a a might fall off there's a in the P but if don't fall off and the same is true regarding a hood of a raincoat that just like the the is a malush and the hood is part of it it's m even if you're not using it it's not like it is a valid B but recent years they started doing something which is very appreciated because if you're walking in the street with the raino habitar but if you're walking with a hood hanging in the back you look M so they started making one of two solutions either you f roll fold up roll up like I'm doing this Hood this rain hood and you put in a specially made pocket that you could zip up and then you put the the the collar over the zipper and you look like a mench so you're not dangling with the hood some coats like my my my spring coat taka it has a big pouch and you don't have to roll it up you stuff it in it goes all the way down and then you close it and you put on your you put your your your this part of the jacket over over the part of the coat I say the collar over the zipper and you don't see anything it's a beautiful spring spring coat so the question is are you allowed to go out in chabas when with the hood folded up and tucked into a pocket or pushed down into an empty hollow space that it lays flat so the EM is why is what's really the problem this should be a new example of aalis not what this means is if someone takes a regular Talis God he wears it properly is fine if he wraps it up and makes it into a scoff that's CU all that material is is you're not being used so the sh is will we say that this folded up Hood that's tucked into a pocket is a Tal which so some say what do you mean not this is the D the D is to fold it up and put it into the pocket told me is the D is in a way to carry it in a respectable way but is a d it's carrying it's it's designed D to carry So Lisa he had another problem when you when you roll up or fold up the the hood itself so this is similar to the says that person that folds up material isave which Rashi explains that you make as if you're making a new pocket because you could put it in this folded up material and the quote this of folding something up that you could stick something in you're making a functional pocketa originally said that folding up a shirt sleeve one the cuff fold one on top of the other is so he felt maybe if you fold up the pocket the the hood says we don't like this bring it so the mar is questionable but what I thought is and he agreed if you like the coat that I have you could tuck the the the hood in as it is push it there a Big Hollow cavity there that's the length of the coat why not you push it in flat so it's not a marave and it's laying in its position you say what about so yes what i t it is if it's dangling behind you look like a bin that's okay you put it into a special design pocket and it's flat what why should that be worse it's not any worse than if it's danging in the back so that seems to be the right folding up some say some other say but if you just basically push it into the pocket and it lays flat that's not a that should be the next question is wearing rub so the EM is assuming a person has a good pair of shoes waterproof and there's no holes in the shoes he can walk a distance many a big distance and his feet will not get wet so the question is why is it m to wear rubs so why you wearing the rub Tak protect your shoe however the all agree who holds that a hat is aome he says butash gashes are malish for two reasons number one they add a degree of warmth and don't forget there's a fundamental after here you see it's so P the Hat cover covers the hat but not your head it doesn't add warmth it's going on the Hat the rubbers go on the foot on the shoe so it adds a little more warmth so say first of all the rub is and also for those that don't have good shoes they have holy shoes like I say or or shoes that leak through after a while it's going to make you irritated so it's and so that's why it's m to wear rubbers even if your cavana is just to protect your beautiful new shoes and even to wear them home after the rain stopped where it's only to transport it but it's Mal Mal is okay that is some people wear boots during a big snow and it's very hard to get on and off the boots so what's what works you put a plastic bag over your shoe and that gives a little more traction and you could pull on the boot let's say you finally got the boot on then you say uhoh I have a problem the plastic bag in the boot is doing nothing it's like carrying a say that you can't go that big it's not a Mal it's not it's like a convenience so you have to find a different way to get on the bu on CHAS I I I don't know if that's enough okay I hear that point but enough also not not war a blizzard don't forget is is for the of the Sho not for the what we what I think might be more M if someone is stuck in SHO and it started snowing it's a blizzard the a foot of snow and he has no boots so makes sense to put two bags want to get matching bags if you want but plenty of bags and Sho put them all the way up your foot and then put your put your shoe on that will might keep the the plastic bag to give you protection for your goof see that's more of a of the Goof you shouldn't get wet now some say it has to be only it covers the Goof something go with that but at least there's a to say that much better than wearing the boot to help wearing the plas to get the boot on the real issue which when it came out I remember still it was a big issue taka is this plain oldfashioned plastic hat cover now today it's not as popular because the mill is functions as that but if you think about it you could argue both ways very convincingly question the plastic hat covers is it a like rubbers that's M or is it basically a beg to protect your hat so the M the Hat the name hat cover is pretty indicative what it is it's a hat cover number one plus it's not on your head it's on your hat it doesn't do anything anything to your head also your head will not get wet unless it's a very heavy rain because you're wearing a hat varah when you have an old hat you don't even put on the hat cover plus no one ever wears just a hat cover and this is why many prominent also held this that had is now could be an earli the end of with handkerchief you allow to wear a hat to protect your head from getting wet but you can't put a onto your hat ah that sound like a plastic hat cover you're doing it to protect your hat so here those this it's not aish it's a question of a of the hat but it's not a malush however there are equally impressive list of and they look at the same hat cover with a different eye and they say that basically this is worn by all people and it goes very nice fit onto the hat and it's a way of going why is that a malush this is a new malush that that's worn by all people okay good I understand that but rubbers also know we plain rubbers okay I understand I understand but the he says since it fits the hat perfectly it's bottled to the Hat becomes part of the hat but nobody wor it with when it doesn't rain okay but when you're wearing it is bottled of the Hat I hear I hear I'm just I I'm tell you what they say now of course one thing I will say the has no no to this hat cover is wearing a shata handkerchief this if you hold this part of the the Hat it's B of the Hat in he says I hear in America everybody wears this hat cover it's a Mal now he's looking at it from a different angle it's one robbers are one this is one but the truth is the riot from robbers is a very poor riot rubb is a malish on the go protect the go this no doubt like you is to protect the hat but this question is something that we could say it's but one thing I want to add I mentioned earlier says you're allow to wear two one example is and another example in the is you allow to wear two hats because the is to wear K God over K cotton oh so maybe that's a riot to the Hat cover but it's not true the M talk about the following scenario a person has a very expensive yamaka L he doesn't wear a hat but it's raining outside so he wears a hat on chabas to protect the yak that's kab or a small ski cap and a big hat over it but it's a normal bed but if we're assuming that a hat cover is a itle hat then there's no hat so here the question is the mum hold it's legitimate bed once it's a bed that's the Easy Pass everything is M and it's something like rubbers the would hold that this is not a beg it's it's a hat cover now who be but if someone ask me but if someone has a what's interesting I'll tell you an outdated shil but it's very relevant those used to be more of a to wear a straw hat so I a St hat already says this because after a little bit rain you're going to get wet so the Hat cover which goes on a straw hat is is all to save you from now himself you should know in in the end of K he says if the if the hand or the rain is so intense that it will penetrate your hat you not wear rain the Hat cover cuz then it's but typically it does not go through the Hat now I like I like to make sh I saw again I don't have experience but I saw some say that a stal some stal is also because the rain goes through so hear this hat uh straw hat and stal are on the same page least I that if now some it's not true theal are so thick so I don't have experience but if indeed the plastic hat cover is saving if the stal will let the rain through then now the new type of stal cover that covers the ears part of the and back of the neck so that is because it covers part of the Goof even like the now again if you go with the p this of the of some some early that has to cover the the that wouldn't be he quot rash that did not agree to this new type of hat cover but the EM is if you go that covers the Hat will soon the head that would be one side to be mled now someone is stuck in sh without anything and it's pouring and has a good hat so and you always could find a plastic bag to cover the Hat but this this not even a Mal this doesn't go on the hat you don't wear that unless you really stuck also women's rain Bonnet so let me give you a little background it's basically a plastic but it goes over the entire head and covers the ears so the EM is typically it's worn by women to protect the but again I don't have the experience but the but but the say that even single girls also wear it because when you're rain when it's raining and you have nothing on your hat on your head you get wet so this is something that has two miles over the plastic hat cover number one it goes over the head itself not just the Hat it's on the head like a ski cap MUSC and number two it's worn to protect the Goof even if you have a shato but it doesn't protect it forever the rain will penetrate much quicker than it does through through a regular hat so this I saw although he says we don't allow plastic hat covers but a rain Bonnet is okay that the also is M so basically once it's m because it's a malush then you could wear it if you're anticipating rain but it's not raining and you can wear it home after it stop raining because once you get into category one that's the Easy Pass to go beyond okay someone asked me to shot he was walking in the street no warning it started pouring so he's was concerned this going Ru is no have so he had a masle that he was able he had a coat on so when he was still wearing his coat you have to know how to do it you could pick up the coat and it will cover the Hat now it's much more common when a person's walking without a hat and it starts pouring and then he picks up his jacket and he puts it over his head if you remember your Yesa days when some people want to get a little of a nap they would put their jacket over their head put the head down and then they started ligging and larning if you remember that that was done I'm not saying it's a Mal but it's more easy to put your jacket over your head than put a coat but anyhow let's talk about both of those so this is interesting I'll tell you why because it doesn't sound like d but wait a second this is the opposite of Talis mellis Talis melles you are negating part of the talus you're folding it up and you're making it dysfunctional so that's a problem here you're getting more for your money you're using the Cod to protect your head so it's more of a malus and also if your head gets wet it would be considered so this should be okay certainly to protect your head will soon come back to the but it's plus you're getting more for your Mal and then I now if you look at the he's not talking about I understand it I think he means you're taking the whole coat and putting it over your head on top of your head or over your hat cuz my case you're not putting col my case you're just putting the top of the of the jacket I think that's what he's talking about because the it makes sense to say that if you put the entire coat the top of it over a hat if it's a malish so it's a malish then I saw again Whoever has a safe I try to find this that's the end of his sheet about this what does he mean does he mean taking the I think he means taking the whole me something like an umbrella but it's soft so it's not it's not an umbrella and it's going on the head that's why but I would I can't understand if you do like I just did if it's raining heavily you don't want to get wet and you put your coat or jacket over your head it's a real malish it's still being worn normally if I'm mistaken please correct me so said this what I think certainly to protect your head would be and it's and the last two questions are absolutely delightful this is a true story it happened a number of years ago when was like this year say remember like yesterday sh was had the he did something then he asked me afterwards he decided he wasn't going to stay in the dorm after he's going to go home to sleep but then the last minute he wants to go sleep in the dorm so he told me like this he has no there's no Linen in in the dorm he took it home from B so to without a blanket that he doesn't need it it's warm not no problem but out pillows he'll manage because he's tired after C he fall asleep but he needs a sheet so he took his sheet that he puts on the bed a bed sheet wrapped it around his body and put his jacket over it and went to Yeshiva when he got the Yesa he got a A Hero's welcome like what are you doing so he said what do you mean it's malush it's soft material I wrap around the body that's what they used to do in the olden days so what's wrong in fact it could be our what's your a cloth a a a a heavy cloth sack is is also but this is s this is the material that we wear shirts with and everything else so has a good point this is worn on the go or over the go but it's like in the way they used to wear this so what's his problem so we could almost tempted to say for this also and that makes sense it's a cloth of a malush worn malush not in America but worn the way they used to wear they would wrap themselves with a with a cloth however he to go with a and therefore it's also so I think that person should be told it's it's you got be careful in other words this see in the olden days this would be M because it's like two pair of socks you have a shirt and a sheet is like two pair of socks if your person's very cold he would do it I mentioned last time last week Kish would wrap himself with a blanket to keep War during the day so if the D would be like that this would be M but puts in this factor that it's a problem and last but not least the question we began someone came the very heavy rain he has no rain coat he came to Sho with a plastic tablecloth wrapped around so this has first of all the previous case he's doing it to carries a this is a also it's wrapping himself and also the even believe it or not the plastic material is Mal do you know how many you don't even realize how many are poesta n Nyon Ron all these names are plastic we wear the lining of jackets some suits are poest so it's even the material of a bed and and he says this is considered wrapping the what's the problem but again here the problem is if you go with that this is not the he says that putting a plastic bag over your head to protect you from the rain is like a t aopa it's not a so I would imagine the same would be regarding this plastic bag the plastic table Club but the is any sh is one of the three either it's a Mal Mal that's unconditionally or else it's a the other case when it's not even worn and not help the in between case something is worn but not a real Mal Bush that's questionable talk you I this no for [Music] okay not to rain on anyone's parade but Mon and seek Him of the sh rain and Sh that wor is it's not it's not a group of people okay we learned today first of all a beged a definition of beg is it it's worn for warmth or protection and that's m in all cases all the time something is not a beggar just to prevent staining is also unless it's to prevent pain that's mut if something is not worn at all he holds it to protect them from the element from rain so that's also be the case of T and KO one Su is a Beed then two are two or even more if that's the just has to be the in other words two belts is two sacks Etc is M to wear a spring coat to protect from the rain is fine that's a bed where winter coat during the summer is fine but the problem is they might laugh at you wolen c a bag overcast to protect from dirtying is is also a as we said that even on you allow to wear it because it's a beg the only concern is if it's not an apron is a problem if is okay theed A M during Co is consider to wear home any bag is M even if the sole intention is to carry it but you're wearing it is a Mal in our times said that seems to be P to wear at home if there's no which there isn't is okay a to protect your coat is also m a hood hanging but not being used is okay that's the the question is the new type that rolls up you fold up and you put it into a pocket is Highly Questionable if it's just stuffed into the pocket that's okay someone I for to someone show right before the Sher he has one of these new rain coats and there's a pocket attached to the coat you fold up the whole coat and put the coat into the pocket when it's not raining so you're carrying around the pocket for post rain so I have to think about that that seems a little worse that's not functional now during the rain it's hard to believe that a pocket of a raincoat becomes part of the raincoat but again I like to talk without thinking so we'll leave that as but it's interesting there's a pocket in the rain on the raincoat not the typical meal you fold up the raincoat and put it into the pocket and you have like a little uh Little Packet whatever it is so that lead the the the question of rubbers rubbers is V malish even to protect your shoes is okay to wear at home after rain is okay also a bag that helps that helps to get the boots on is a problem a bag over the foot should be unless you hold it has to be the plastic hat as we said straw hat or St where the where the rain penetrates is like a regular hat when the rain penetrates and it's m even likea a plastic bag on a hat all agree is awesome a rain Bonnet for the women is mut a cast a a a a hold the coat over the head to protect the head but the coats being worn should be about to protect the hat but a sheet around the Goof or place tablecloth around the Goof since not the great sporing call 718 85 8651 or email ist janet.com [Music]