Safed Vs. Jerusalem - The Semicha Controversy, The Grand Finally

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com we're completing this Indian of you shalim versus the restoration of sneaker which was innovated by Rebecca varav last week we discussed the complaints of the mile back we expect we uh we learned through the radvaz's uh tainus and his kashas on the restoration of smika which uh primarily they were for number one that the Rama himself who who innovated this concept Iran himself was not so decisive because this matter still needs uh clarification number two the rambam says you need the consensus of all the and the mariaco um the malbach said that even if you want to say you follow the road you only follow the right if everyone sat together and then you follow the right but if you only take the real the relief and they convene when you know there's a mean of people who are protesting that's not called following the rights the me had never participated in the deliberations and even if you're going to bring in the myth after the fact well the wife has already made up its mind there's no point in bringing in the me and after the fact also the maldath was afraid that by reinstituting the original Sanhedrin it would yankovios and it would bring the calendar back to alperia which he was afraid would abolish the minigame so let's see number 16 the response of the Mao bah to some of the tightness of the uh the response of excuse me the maribe this comes from uh this is what again number 15. number 15 on your sheets number one regarding that which the mailbox said that the ramam says the rambam was not going back on the ability to restore smiha the round number is going back on a different and namely that is that if you only have one of the three members of the court with the original smika that's good enough to which the rambam says that matter needs but regarding the main issue at hand whether you're allowed to restore this definitively that it is permitted to do number two when the rambam says you need to get all the Kasam what are you going to do you're gonna go knock on the door oh by the way are you you know are you a secret you'll never get everybody so all you need is life so you don't have yeah the random said everyone and it seems like even the malba was not so sure you need everybody was that you don't need it you need everyone to be there in the the deliberations no the same way you agree that you could follow the rise if the majority agrees to the process so the maribe said the same way you could follow the wife you could originally only convene with the rife regarding and he brings down to this we mentioned last week why they didn't join in the mailbox in the process to begin with because they know that malbach would not be a fan of this would not support this so better not to get started with the trouble from now back in the in the first place let's get the ball started let's get the ball rolling and if he has tightness he has tightness but if he's going to come with questions before we even get this all you know started it will never take off and regarding what the malbach was worried about that they're going to restore Murray said that was never my intention I have no intention of abolishing yamtuff Shaney shell galios and now what these were the responses of the mahabass to the questions of I haven't had any Justified saying I have no intention once he establishes an engine it doesn't matter what his intention was anymore so he I guess he had the confidence that since he's the leader of the Sanhedrin he will only take it to where he feels it's needed at the at the present moment which maribe rasa what do you mean like you're saying if you establish the sun hedging then to restore The Killers to the way it was so take a look we're going to conclude with this number 20. the the math like is finally settled and we're going to learn if you read in most books most people think the reason why the Mac like is settled is because you know they couldn't stand up to the accusations and the questions of malbach they were very afraid of all of his caches and therefore to you know they didn't want to start with the process it's the clown not true first of all they did start with the process rev maribirabb gave smika to at least four people according to One account to 10 people including the basically safe himself who even the basically saved then continued the Smitha too so it did continue and it didn't stop because they were worried about what they were thinking it stopped because the um the government came and Scattered Cloud Israel many of these gadam had a flee from sauce had a flea Artist as well once you're not an artist as well you can no longer continue to give smiha and because of the pisor it was not able to continue let's take a look at number 20. foreign that during their period it was a great confusion it was uh that there were others one was namely and also foreign for many years we don't have hear one word of protest and even their advised he came to thrust he didn't say anything he is very influential in Egypt he spoke out he constantly it doesn't say anything here's the memo of the he made peace with the situation um about that is possible to reinstate this foreign speaking about nowadays and he writes foreign not they didn't blow in a place of bezden on Shabbos what's the ram I'm talking about best then but you need a bezel in summer the Riff holds you don't need a bezen summer but the ramaphosa if you need a business what's around I'm telling me about the halacha of when you do or don't blow in front of Beth then there is no best in summer the ramam is the answer is the ramam clearly holds that it's possible to restore even I love him it's because of the constant attacks of the arabsu the challenge they put a prayer they oppressed us to collect taxes to collect fines they made up made up accusations and life in erit Israel at the time in the end of the 16th century became impossible and therefore we had to scatter now says but nowadays we could gather all the the rabbis in Israel and and get unanimous opinion right so he says even if you want to conclude that the ramam had no doubts and you won't accept the wizard of myself himself admits that the reality of such a situation is very unlikely because the rambam asks if it's so easy to reinstate Smith risking his life that the gunship pierced him in his hamidam run away we'll just bring it back foreign the answer is what that the ramam is saying that it's really not so practical it's really not so likely and that's why the Roman says that when will we be able to reinstate Smith the ramam doesn't say like this the rather say you know when we're gonna be able to reinstate Smith when we're going to have the fortunate opportunity to get the unanimous decision and agreement says this is going to happen prior to the coming of mashiach why does the Ramones say this will only happen before mashiach the ramen should say this will happen you know at the right time the answer is because the likelihood of any other period in history of everyone getting together to agree to this is very unlikely Just One Last calligraphy in Europe I'm in Williamsburg what the ramans means is because I mean we don't care if someone's in khosaras he has no say in the matter he's not considered one of them for the sinion doesn't mean in location means an opinion this has one opinion on the matter that supplements another opinion the the the various ideas and and and opinions that the head about this are impossible to consolidate he understood that it ain't happening until and therefore therefore what we need here is the consensus of Allah but it's possible that rubai kukulai now you know when a guy says just a formality it has no halachic meaning just means that if a person is with the permission of his Rabbi but until then we wait for the great day of our Shiva the attack and then you shine will be called to have the true you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you like torahanytime.com