Shabbos Chanukah In Halacha - Rabbi Zev Smith

foreign [Music] and as we see it's Unique because as the truth is as we'll see that the the zimana of Arab Shabbos are fundamentally different let me explain to refresh your memory this man of says what does it mean so there are as many sheets that hold that the right time to lightener Hanukkah is I'm just going to choose a a time even though it's inaccurate but just the lasagresa oyzen right Maisha says that 10 minutes after shkia is the right time to lightener Hanukkah so let's assume 440 is the earliest man for near Hanukkah okay again it's not accurate some door Barons man I'm just using it to keep a number that we could relate to now that's one cheetah but there's another cheetah and that's the sheet of the foreign approximately 5 45. so those are the two you know difference is don't forget like every other bits that you have to keep to this man you can't like too early or lie too late the going was very Macbeth a nice Arab simulator and after the half hour you can't make a bracha that's how important this man is base that since today we lied for the banana bodies we like indoors not outside so this man am I not that important you could light later okay does caution toys so we do have a leeway as farring the slaves man but no doubt about it this man is this man even Ramos says You must try at least to light zuise demon to light in the right time so we have two Magnum of 440 and 545 those are this man now next this coming Friday Nobody Does it right no one likes 545 that's Shabbos and even 440 is ready 10 minutes after skier so the holidays we've been we're violating lawyer mcdemon it doesn't sound right plus we have the notion today our lighting not just 15 or 80 minutes before skier but there are different hug them to make early Shabbos and earlier Shabbos and no today like let's say at four o'clock even so you have to light 10 minutes before four late to go in it's almost two hours earlier than the rights man I've said that for them it's two hours before the earliest man will soon see also no one likes in the right time so it's a player two days of the eight days of Hanukkah we don't keep the rights man and if you have if you have two sub bosses Hanukkah three out of the eight days over 35 percent of the time for lighting the wrongs the wrong spot what's going on here how could you light solo so so early on air of Sabbath Hanukkah so it comes to mind is the famous Hector we call it the hector the plug this is but there is a shita that if a person has an ironus he could light from plaga mincha onward and again imprecisely I'm just choosing a number approximately 315 it's an hour and a quarter before skier so this the the does sanction lighting from approximately 3 15. now this is a major extension so instead of lighting uh 440 or 5 45 you could even start at 3 15. but that's not so Good As It Seems because first of all the solution is very powerful many were showing them hold there's no such thing as lighting early this man is scarier you can't like plug plug is not Lila also there are sheeters that hold even if you want to rely on the plague you don't make a bracha it's a bit it's a Pity everything is a man it's really like a layaway plan you light early you put enough oil that burns into the night now Mr bro does say that you can make a broken but it's very hard to accept that every kid since the midst was given is lighting up the event a yashmi on Arab Shabbos and it's esophagus doesn't sound right so I'm going to tell you a fascinating Truman sedation and Allah he has a question nothing to do with Hanukkah someone's pigeon at Ben they came out on Shabbos and we can't make opinions so this fella wanted to keep it this man so he had a brilliant einsteinfeld he's going to do the pigeon I've been on Friday with all the pictures of course that's the income and then he's going to say that the Kenya should be khalan Shabbos so he didn't violate Shabbos he made it on Friday but the pigeon was khalan sharp is bismano I with sivano how could you say if it's Ivano on Friday it's not yet this man of pigeon at Ben so he wanted to compare it to Nerf Hanukkah on Arab Shabbos listen to an einfeld the minute is relied very early Friday afternoon ayat before this man must be you do the myths for now and it takes effect later so too pigeon I've been says the tumor suggestion I don't get that it's EFS we have to light early so if we say but pigeon are Ben what's your problem wait till Sunday and he sends you to the early YouTuber of his in Simon cuff bays and but there he uses a very crucial word very disgusting as we'll soon see if you lit it Friday in yours Man four o'clock before even and the wind blew it out ever think about that do we say cuffs because you lived very early so he says no you didn't lie early you lit BisMan I it's early so he says this is considered a hexham Mitzvah and yoladolai and make a bracha during this now this is a very crucial word what he's saying is when we're going to like this coming Friday Herb Shop is Hanukkah at four o'clock or whatever time you light it's a hexham it's not the Mitzvah like you know making gun is this is like a person that cooks a meal for his father even though the Mitzvah culminates when the father eats it but what's the Mesa Mitzvah cooking for the father so the trauma sedation is saying that the Mesa Mitzvah the hexa Mitzvah is four o'clock or whenever you light but pigeon I've been it's too early so that gives a little more meaning to the heir of Shabbos man since it's so that comes out it's a little like a sad that throughout Cloud throughout the world every year since Hanukkah was given well lighting a man that's a hexham it's not the proper time but you have to do it what makes sense is to say something much more powerful and that is when they made eight days Hanukkah they realized that there's always going to be an Arab Shabbos so what were they thinking that every ID foreign but this is even a bigger problem because the babies came out the first day circus Thursday Tesla of History so if you don't do it on Thursday you have to wait until Sunday I'm gonna push it off almost you know three days to make it earlier that that's einfeld the layaway plan and also compared it to near Hanukkah so Dr Sam Cipher the company the demon is no good because he says he says although the chumba sedation says it's a din of Mitzvah I don't know why you have to come on to this delegic because since it's EF sharp chanukkah without an Arab Sabbath Hanukkah make it lies since its Inception was to light as soon as you can before skia you have to leave time for the nursing to lighten their their Shabbos of course [Applause] this man is much earlier so he's saying you're not to come on to an EF sir that is man beautiful Insight it's not what but the evidence since the midst was given this is the originals man and I found the in Perkins I was having to the same idea someone asked him light the rambam that holds you can't rely on them we have to wait till this so what does the rambam do with the Arab Shabbos Hanukkah so he says like kashimidi because you have to have a shot must be that does Shabbos is always much earlier so it's very relieving very reassuring one or two days a year of Hanukkah could be air of Shabbos Hanukkah and that's not to be but the evidence that's the correct man that's the davaito so now we have the following that basically this Madam have to be kept whatever your mind is keep this manam air of Shabbos and we'll soon see my toy Shoppers also has its owns man now let's apply this La Mesa and sit back and enjoy let's start with an interesting Shayla heir of Shabbos one year comes out occasionally that is Hanukkah so someone likes his wife likes to lighten their Shabbos at four o'clock okay so he's gonna will soon see Sheldon by it's important he'll like 10 to four and he starts thinking I'm gonna make a sheikhiana at ten to four it's safe it's not yet Hanukkah there's no such thing I'm sorry you know I told the bakum if they would beat this perm and you probably make this effus perm starting from Hanukkah but there is you're making when is at four o'clock or even earlier right now he says this it wonders about and you'll and you'll notice I'm sorry if it's even more questions will all do it this coming Friday let's say four o'clock whatever time close to that the question is is it awesome right then and there because you might reason it's not yet it's not yet this man I'm doing it sort of in advance like you know a layaway plan I'm programming it to it should be there for the right time but the answer has to show them this is the right time Variety in the beginning says let's say a person is honest and he has the light from plague on a weekday see lights with a bracha is so we're going to say which is not even so the holidays as soon as you light it question he had an idea he said really we should say hinaris hello right after your lightning some people like it some even say it as the lighting but he felt that maybe it's still early so he wanted it he had a minig that he had the same God he writes that he sang I never said as soon as he came home from sure I guess before Shalom aleichem because he wanted us to sing it to say it when the neighbors are burning bismano dude I don't like that for a few reasons first of all when you lit it Arab Shabbos it was the rights man what's wrong with saying they're slow then and we're gonna We would add and of course later some sofa it's even more posted you you say it in the right time don't feel guilty and then he says varias will soon see the German Sebastian says if you lit it that's four o'clock and it went out coughs and Soccer Club so you did a real Mitchell what are you what are you feeling guilty like you did something inappropriate and he says and plus the fact we make when it comes out on Arab Shabbos and he says to be first and then their Shabbos and then he said which is probably his main tie you know don't start with the name and hug him you're not the first year in Yiddish guide you know you had to know him and I'm running before you and no one thought of this idea so Michael Davis but the truth is it's a gesund to have honor when we light air of Shabbos early we're not doing with the evidence this is the rights man so do it right don't forget the the the the the the what we sing Daenerys from them goes back to the time of Tanaya so why is the tax death from the my summits my sister a young couple where they live they live locally and the parents live locally didn't have to travel so what they did is they lit their Hanukkah and their Shabbos at home went to eat by the parents and they came home when he came home to the great dismay daenery Shabbos was still burning so that was great they had enough in the nearest on Shabbos but the narconic already burnt out and they were concerned maybe they want you to the mitzvah so the truth is that if daenery shop is burned up before they came home and they never had a gnaw from the nearest Shabbos on Shabbos they left very early it's a problem just like a person lit this man and it blew out right away sir so if you if you hear even better you lit this man and you went away what's what's the problem the fact that you left the house has no impact on the Shiloh I should mention I should please to realize this leaving a house just with naira Shabbos make sure it's very safe I know my eyes saw the house burning down I lived at one of the homes right next to my house they lived there Hanukkah they left and they came back the house had burned down it's unfortunate it happens too often we have to be much more attentive to this problem your lighting their Shabbos usually it's safe Hanukkah has to have the same focus of safety question a person written there Shabbos and it was blown out right before Shabbos the wife is home alone the husband already they have to call someone to be light it after all it's still not Shabbos we can get someone else delighted do we say cough says regarding Shabbos so this is not surprising this we had a German suggestion who says even regarding their Hanukkah and Arab Shabbos cups and soccer club sedation okay I should add the Marshall and the truth and pay hey and all the police can pass out that even on a weekday and even though Allah it's a hinder to be light it because you're adding more pisuminism so we'll say if it went out Arab Shabbos but it's a mildly lighted but I must tell you there's a little more to this question the ties and see if cotton tests after quotes and he says it's true when you light air of Shabbos you were yoitza why because this man is now for later but let's say that candle went out so that candle never could be now for later the reason why uh TV light early is because it's going to light into the night but if it went out there's no end to the night so the task says something incredible if you lit BisMan mamish cough sane you have to be lighted it's only ahead but if you let it air of Shabbos and the reason why because we went into the night well soon as you have to have enough oil to light into the night and this didn't then you know it's unless you related and this is quoted by all the mainstream policy in the back all say the same beside now according to the Taz it's not a hint to be lighted it's an ichadin because this didn't end up lighting into the Lila now we would want the quarter is that true foreign must tell you that although the Magna Rome has Mr Brewer say if it went out Arab Shabbos you have to re-light it but don't forget the Mahaba calls the trump sedation so we would say the following if the man is still home I've had they should be light it if she could get someone else to be light it a man that didn't yet macabo Shabbos it's kadai but for her to go lighter they have to shoot their Shabbos is wrong so what would you do you get nothing what could you do you can't be like it's my father a big question is for for us that we light early Arab Shabbos how much oil or how many can how big of the candle does it have to be when you to make a broken so you'll say come on be a sport use a lot of oil big candle that's very nice but I've heard this more than once people have uh the older people have the Anika coming for Shabbos and they have 20 minutes burning they're very nervous you know it's Arab style kids running around like so many manures that they rather have the children lighting the small uh half-hour candles they're fair thing but you know for the nerving of the of the grandmothers it's just not it's not good for them how much oil how big a cancer have to be so if we understand that they had Lotus near air of Shabbos is similar to plaga minha age but you have to put enough oil to burn into the night and this is so the question is is the same applied to Arab Shabbos that understood that lighting air of Shabbos is a form of but really the thela so you have to put enough oil to burn to the night and we could even say later Sam Cipher you have to put extra oil because I'm sorry for not saying you light it Friday and Friday fed you light it now but the macroven is Friday night especially according to the task that cough Suzuka of Arab Shabbos we're comfortable to say and talk at the Prima got them all say You must put enough oil that it burns into the night now grab the Prima got them in toughration base if cotton Olive this is maybe take with less but the police say do you have to put enough oil that burns into the night I did see an incredible hedis the baryakov Hezekiah very practical question speaks about an oil which comes up you know once an arrival the person has to like me from is every year they have to put enough oil to burn into the night it's much more common than plug it's every single shop is for every single ID so he says that what's the reason we have to burn into the night actually regular people on the street but based on Rashi and parishai Friday night people not on the street so there's no particular egg I'm gonna shook she holds me icky then you don't need the lady's man on Friday night and the Riots of the sukhanarak's omission of saying that you shall light until then [Applause] today the streets are full even a Friday night but one thing I will say that Mr Brewer does say if it's difficult to light all of them with a big sheer it's like Mr interface are intensive cotton base one candle is enough and of course the kavachian points out which candle should you make the brachan of course on the first one that should be the big one so we'll say I'll divide with all and oil for all the days for all of the neighbors but if a nervous but grandmother is worried about the fire so let the children light small ones and one big one to make the broken what is the preferred time to light near Hanukkah air of shop and this is a tricky question should you leave it to the last minute could you stop by plug should you rush should you tell the women to light a little later on air of Shabbos so we could lie closer toshia so their branding practical and as communities but it's important to clarify this so the MS is so let's keep close to this man but it's made me make sense even according to that because I'm sorry for it's not like uh air Shabbos all of a sudden this man is close you can't use man you could like 3 30. maybe keep it close to scared either the closest time to skia which maintains your Shalom bias and don't make people nervous saying let's hurry you know let's let's get a light blade later push it off keep the rights man foreign there's no reason for that try to keep as close as you can to skia in fact they say a half hour before skin but not not the earlier than a half hour before the embassies but today there's a problem I mean it's not practical because and the women don't like 15 or 80 minutes before they have been hug and to light even earlier make more Shabbos so now the question is so what are you going to do are you gonna tell them no this Herb Shop is Hanukkah you have to light after 10 minutes before ski or 50 minutes he says don't change the time of near Shabbos and he says since Arab Shabbos no one Collide in the practice man because it's too late so initially if Shabbos has its owns man is also good he says the truth is once you're not lighting for 40 or 5 45 does it make a difference if it's four o'clock or ten to four so Maisha takes the same approach like this that this man air of Shabbos is UNIX man which is not limited to of course this man so Lamesa that's what I would say if they have that hither oh yeah keep it Airship is Hanukkah don't feel guilty it's the rights man for this air of Shabbos Hanukkah what happens often is a man the women have a problem here because they want a light let's say there's Man 4 15 or 410 whatever it is four o'clock but they have to wait for the men the man is always delayed he's the late Mr so and so and especially in the back of his mind he said what's this Michigan's lighting just like burger at like 10 to four so she's not saying no no no and he's I'm coming I'm coming you know he's one of the Yes Man and what happens I don't tell you what happens there goes with the Arab Shabbos and his mom is a tragedy I'll tell you why because the whole nearest shop is statement was niskan bias that's one part of the story but it's more than that says devotee whole semen I'm sorry a whole symmetera fresh that a person has one candle so what should he use if puts it very bluntly in the end of Hanukkah he says we erase the same ascenta to keep Shalom bias Dr ambam Godless is foreign the two superpowers of Sheldon bodies come together mayor Shabbos and their Hanukkah and punked that's when the most Vegas comes out because the Suttons it's always the shortest day of the year don't forget this this time is the shortest Friday of the year there's the most to do this their family is coming so much to do so little time and she wants to light early and he's not so excited about it so it's it's it's terrible and they come into an area of Shabbos the nerves are frazzled and they're all wound up Mr Burr quotes that the park and Race pay Steve cotton gimbal be careful of Shabbos they keep showing and keep having the house and and avoid mahlikas and pump the Arab Shabbos Hanukkah that's supposed to be full of Shalom bias becomes a a potentials so I guess you realize my point be accommodating forget about an extra dish forget about that hitter the wife wants like uh 10 to 4 10 of the four lights four o'clock but be on time please it's not the time to make uh you know a Solomon bias issue the next question if the wife knows her customer and he's always going to be late she decides you know what I'm going to keep selling bodies I'm going to have my own idea she decides to light their Shabbos first now you could do what you want you're on your own you want to light four o'clock well then I don't care I'm Lighting First so of course the problem is how could she be yoitza if she put her Shabbos already to make it to light Shabbos but tonight that is not in the Cobble shop this is wrong you only got to do it foreign but the embassies is a player because she's not yaitsu with his ad look like this is and even if you have to come on to sleep because there's a famous side of the samsaifa the the also the base Maya says this on Shabbos even if it's but it is it has to be that you're resting so even if this works but doesn't make you hella Shabbos because that it can't be there's no din it's not a din of that jazz so the mice she is Yates with his even though she made Shabbos already but it's not ideal first of all says goes first because it's Shabbos first and the way explains I'm telling you the words comes down and their Shabbos is all the way up so once you first have to go down and up but once you go up the sharp as you can't go down for Hanukkah whatever that means but no doubt about it it's not the way this house should be that she's frustrated and he's unreliable let's make it right the husband lights you know he accommodates her that's that's talacha there's no difference if it's ten after four or four o'clock or ten to four so she his whatever she wants to light light a few minutes before and coming to shop is the way the burnstone wants to come into shoppers you know it's unfortunate but sometimes she's he's so late so she comes to the first snare and she runs out on light snare Shabbos so Mr Brewer says as long as you know one there is enough if she has to run out of his lighting to catch this man let's you know be organized and be there on time the question is interesting where this comes La Mesa in your because in shalam Dominic is to lighten their Shabbos 40 minutes before so that already some say well that's takamanic which is beautiful the whole year but Arab Shabbos you have to trim the time so attack Islam on Arab Shabbos Hanukkah will not light 40 minutes but some will still keep to this manner 40 minutes about labels that was extremely fond of the heir of Shabbos meaning so basically that we leave it to the anshig Daily shalayan but in America here whatever she wants to do with that to keep this man you are Hanukkah before if someone mistakenly lit near Shabbos I'm sorry this coming Friday before plug so la maesta United says now you might say well maybe heir of Shabbos Hanukkah has special leniencies and you'll add lighting before plug but that's irrational there's no reason to say that ROM says as if cutting base you'll add a light air of Shabbos earlier but not before the plug it's not like you know anywhere anytime you want this man was close enough to skia that would leave the white women enough time to lighten their Shabbos so this is again the uniqueness of Shabbos Hanukkah this man really depends on the notion when they have to lighten their Shabbos a few minutes before I can tell people you know zerizos is a big Milo but behala is a big Hassan especially Arab Shabbos that's not that's the opposite of Manuka so do business reasons but not with behala question someone asked this question he let let's say he knows Arab Shabbos he's going to light let's say at four o'clock when is the isahila that that's how before the midst of their Hanukkah is a half hour before this man when is that when does the is begin so you might think well if you like early maybe half hour before that's not true this man is yours man so if you use the light at four o'clock half hour before the the you always man is if someone was really fast-slept and he missed Kia now it is his wife knew her customers she lived in their Shabbos and now he's stuck without near Hanukkah so the pr the question is what could you do so it has been suggested an einfeld and that is to call the guy and like now what's the point because really as long as it's still been as much as but you're saying a girl you should like Hanukkah is unheard of but then again let's let's talk about a case where an issue was delayed and especially so that the mother of gimmel says that as long as it's been a she could call a guy who will light in their Hanukkah their job is for her the image of RAM and the rav in kunjab explains in detail not only does it help the guy lighting for the Isha but the Isha can make a broken because it's a valid adlocker okay Mr bird does not let's see if the cotton clafal does not like the the makeup but all agreed that if it's still banished the guy could be enlisted to light the near Shabbos for the woman so why don't we say s yes but it's hard to accept and I'll tell you why because Nair Shabbos has three purposes Shalom bias cover Chavez and oinek Shabbos so the nearest Shabbos is not the the Mitzvah is per se it's the Tait saw it's the outcome so if a guy lights you have neris you have solemn bias so that's why a guy said Locker helps and could he make a broccoli di magana from it's not to have a um if you have an 80-day yard you light it is except for the first day you have to lie to Bismarck so how could the guy light anytime you have burning candles and you could say you're presuming Isa but it's not it's not and raise a Pelham I don't know why the rap why the the genre doesn't quote is the rambameters because fundamentally narcanic is a different type of Mitzvah it's a Mitzvah Locker so what can I tell you you know the the downstairs must have held that if you light in a one day for eight days there's no mice at local businessman but if you light basman to a guy so maybe as long as it brings bisumi Nisa maybe that's Hadlock is but if the ramam says not to do it Avada it's not an idea question that living alone she has no husband and she has two minutes what's the order of these Mitzvahs so that's simple for Horizon has to go first besides the fact that presuming Nissa is more important but she has the macabo Shabbos with daenery Shabbos so that's question a man that's living alone and he has to light near Hanukkah and their Shabbos what's to order for him so we might say oh their Shabbos is taught them but then again now you look in the Mr Blue the main reason seems to be because Shabbos afterwards and I thought you saw them because she's thrilled in in racial and Zion quote he quotes that both say let's say it's a man that's lighting and he typically does not makeable Shabbos when he lights near Shabbos he should lighten their Shabbos first because it's toddler and then they're Hanukkah he said he always not be keeping sharp he's trying to shoot but the greatest is that the mice has been so earlier Hanukkah always has to go before their Shabbos and also once they misak in it I'll uh the the concept of their of of pursue my Nisa and taka the poisky most Pious game seem to say that even in this case a man that's lighting has not been macabo Shabbos it's near Hanukkah and then their Shabbos you might say let him do their Shabbos first so then they could push off closer to skia that's a pretty good husband but no one says it so I'm not saying it either so it's now a person that woke up interesting I woke up he was resting and he woke up a minute before this mom Shabbos you can only write one near near Hanukkah on their Shabbos which goes first everybody knows their Shabbos first right but the truth is the magnav rum and see if cutting base already says that today we lied for the minute how bias so if we light it inside so even if you're like you have enough light and their Hanukkah goes first plus some points come High ticket price can say I saw this player has nothing never stand back because they say today we have electric lights at home there's no problem of showing bias but of course don't keep it to that of course not maybe it's a good business venture one wants to make money is really is before near Shabbos partially because of a summonism but then again so the people got them in Olive rights matter of factly don't set up daenery Shabbos until you you finish lighting their Hanukkah why because let's say you have the nechanic of by the window it's a door whatever you do and you've never stopped us on the table you should go first to the nearest shop is Australia but you have no choice you have to go to their Hanukkah see and end up being my Vienna mitzvahs this is better with v live there Hanukkah and then set up their shops so there's not my feet and I'll admits this or he says listen to this he says you if you're going to lighten there Hanukkah first you're being Mathias then it goes first you know that's like that we cover the khala air of Shabbos before kiddish to pass now the mice I never saw anybody that prepares the near Shabbos first afterwards maybe because worrying about this man ish no one does like this being a garden the Kenyan terrification but if you want an idea maybe it's an idea to pay the nearest shabbataka First and put a nice sharpstick cover over the near Shabbos so then first of all there's no Boucher and maybe also in my vein if it's like you know covered so I know people buy it but if it's a good idea to Market a new product the Arab shop is Hanukkah decal for the near Shabbos but again the Supreme God doesn't suggested so I'm not gonna do it either but but really important is the sensitivity you know soil levias the nearest the wife on Arab service because it's certainly not within the framework of yetiskite interesting question is the old question about minha what's this man of mint of Shabbos so there are many early minyanim where is that coming from so the amethyst one and but the cash is even bigger because if I see them across the board come out his regular time so on a practical level I would think it's partial because for those that died if you're going to dive in Minnesota you're gonna have to leave 20 plus minutes before so you're gonna push off push up near Hanukkah extra 20 minutes right then you have to have so then you're gonna have to have it their Shabbos first it's gonna be much earlier so practically three o'clock so you have more time to lie close at the skier many minutes is not part of the equation so everybody's following their own mini but the truth is it's much too much more to this mimic but let's go back a moment what's the head to the light four o'clock 3 30 quarter to four and their Hanukkah it's still day my honey highlighting by day the turrets is is is a man also in the mishnah holds flag is foreign foreign because it's after plug and it's considered Lyla lagabi legabe now so then you're considering Goliath are very good afterwards what's your location so please discover this he finds attire to disaster foreign a big part of classes but the Kasha is what about the tattoo disaster what we said it's not a problem at all when we dive in when we lighten air Hanukkah before skia it's not that we decided that it's considered Lyla but we follow either Sam say for even the term sedations is you saw it that this man of American is when was given that's the rights man is it and the truth is if you think is that the disaster what's the hector for the wife to go ahead and light their Shabbos after he like lit near Khan again made it Lila is worse than Lila the Terrace has to be it's a newsman now I must mention there's another myelin Lighting in first this is the the early advice can say because afterwards so that's why many people are Macbeth which AGA shows that somehow Arab Shabbos in our home it becomes like a base hamidash with the minority being the menorah so don't make a Corbin based amigdas little some bias issues but this is another reason the light that I've been here early and see them now the whole double to be compared to base and this would not be different and the last group of questions is the matoya Shabbos so right away you realize that we have a built-in problem because every imitation we can't keep probably enemies man like me but we don't keep this man of the going that was 4 40 and a half hour afterwards is too late but even if you keep this man of 5 45 so many people that have a my first at 5 45 till they get home until they make half dollar so back to another problem that one out of eight days we are lighting at the wrong time so no one speaks it out it's probably push it it's the same side of either of the samsife since when the Hashem initiated the midst of their Hanukkah they knew there has to be a matai Shabbos so what is this man this man is as soon as possible so what is the earliest man so that's Taka because whenever you finish my earth when you finish half dollar will soon see if you make a dollar first or not now the mice are available he says to hurry up because he gave it a half an hour after the this month the earliest Advantage Collide so taka gronicks are much more Missouri's but for most that don't go with the girls minig it would be as soon as you can after my earth now let me give you a few points a little regarding this someone will say you know I want to keep this man so I'm going to dive in Missouri Shabbos early with the earliest minion and they diving like someone told me they die with lights and Sirens I said what does that mean he goes they're running running like you know I'm running on a telephone call with lights and sirens and the David like yeah but I'll get them earlier you're gonna dive in early to light and this man that Suffolk Lila is that's reason so no nothing to talk about we don't light before it's Vada or his Shabbos that's number one 72 then keep Dominic even though I'm always in the same two varieties that he thinks there have been with Thomas man in America is 50 but the oven 72 and keep you as me and go home and then light if I can understand it because the the this man was made the earliest you can do it may is 172 families and I'm coming home I'm writing as quick as I can now to rush Meyer of course is inappropriate I saw the upside the velitsky writes that he wants to one of the Lux that to make it perfect Davin Davin mayor of 23 minutes after Shia because now it's well it's much earlier she writes oh thank you you gave me 12 minutes for my room okay what kind of highway robbery is that 12 minutes in my area so the might have can't be at you know abbreviated just to get home earlier that's not that's not his reason my demon in fact I saw myself someone told him you know this is a man this man he goes who told you to keep this man on my sorry Shabbos he felt like this man is as soon as you finish married go home a light so the mice again if you could be early be on time good if there's any equal you know some people when the belts feel the sauce to sneeze they're getting all nervous hurry hurry hurry hurry it's not healthy they come home and the wife forgot to pay the Abdullah it's bringing a tense attitude in the house that's not the the so basically we're going to say the earliest the Rights Management Services as soon as possible with Jesus without behala after you finish now at home what is the order of the two misses so this is an old story that really in their Hanukkah should go first because the presuming Isa and that's Taco Dominican Rambo and tough race payables however there are reason to say half dollar goes first that's typically tadir so many Israel used to be granted much more that people made nirchanic and then have dollar I think it's becoming more popular to make of dollar first and then their Hanukkah what's noteworthy is one of the reasons to make nechanica first is because you want to delay have dollar as long as you can to keep Shabbos longer and the cash is a plea you would have been married what Shabbos do you have what are you keeping Shabbos so it says a trace of a rayach of Shabbos until Abdullah and for that trace of Shabbos is kadai to lighten their Hanukkah first and how about a moment of Shabbos of that but more than that what I think really is kadai to mention a practical later let's see your minutes to make Abdullah first so come on from from taka prepare the neighbors Hanukkah this way you kept more of the real Shabbos as much as you can you don't want to change the meaning you want to make Abdullah first but you come home from sure prepare the nearest of Hanukkah whatever's needed then have dollar and then there Hanukkah but let's be clear this man is as soon as possible with you know zerise is not behalo it's not kadai to come home and bring it at a tense you know feeling because it generates a certain lack of show and bias different question which is also kadai Dimension it's also a a Shabbos Hanukkah question the guy by lights Masai shop isn't sure like like every other night but he realizes that the shul after my rheumatoid Shabbos is probably one of the emptiest times of the year because everybody's running home to lighten their Hanukkah now during the week some lit before my so you could have some people remaining but maturity shop is after my there's no one there so the question is what's your head to the light with a broker and then you're gonna leave no one's there and if you're gonna blow out the candles it's even worse and taka someplace can say if you're not going to leave it burn for half hour you're not allowed to make a break and he basically says that since in shul it's a different midseumenisa and built into the matai shop is no one's there you allowed to make a broken they put it out which is really the same you say that we began with it's a difference if it's a question of safety Avada lighting with the broker and blow it out and we have an old Mini we give a little bit of a you know something to talk about uh I'm gonna give you just four quicker hours to think about question number one the Gabe comes to school this coming Friday and as always foreign fall for the walls for the spinner we'll make the broken so can you make a bracha when the shoe is empty and no one's there so taka they're a poiskin that says if there's no one there Bishop mice you can't make a Brother's air of Champions as long as there are people coming soon enough there's nothing it's up to my shopping bass clifying base or golden every area of Shabbos we do just that we make a broccoli light now for later so why can't agave in the shoe use the same Hector that Arab Shabbos is a different Mitzvah so you see again our side we're playing itself regarding the garbage lighting for those that make half dollar first and then they're Hanukkah you have two questions someone asked me interesting questions how can you drink the wine of Abdullah before near Hanukkah now that I eat or drink before a Mitzvah so plus you'll say if you drink only a look move so there's no Shiloh but even reveals it's not a crease and also it's a Mitzvah so that's not a problem what the police can discuss believe it or not after you finish your reviews and you go to that Hanukkah what goes first foreign so that they want to say in svara is first because the reason like demon but how do you walk away from you might forget so Dominic is to make another get them but last but not least this is really fascinating let's imagine that Shabbos is the first day of Hanukkah is so a person his minute is he doesn't have an early okay wonderful we saw the meaning of sanctioned by poison but this year might be a problem because let's let's replay this is Dave you're at home and you like Hanukkah you make three brothers including then you come to school will you say alanisim in that minha because Hanukkah when it comes out the first day Shabbos you must have a minha first and talk to some see them including taco and Stalin when it comes out Cafe don't keep that mimic and I think it's as far as posture because again the shakiano is not on the Yom tip it's on the Maison Mitzvah and that's how now is on the the Mitzvah not on the yamah couldn't talk to you all the reasons do we put out a new book it's for sale in the back uh the new book on the halacha foreign [Music] foreign [Applause] [Music] foreign oh he's saying a summary now okay okay above the end the list okay um I'm very excited we don't want to be Mathias they're seek them so we're starting right away here anyway just we learned today about Hashem as we saw the I think the inside of today is that the Arab Shabbos and the matsei Shabbos has a difference man to it even though it's the same Mitzvah but since every every Hanukkah has Shabba says one day sometimes even you have two Shabbos Hanukkah it must be this man is different both Arab Shabbos and material Shabbos this man is as soon as possible with ziz tried to keep it as close he can toshia when it won't interfere with the of course the Sheldon bias but Soy Shabbos as soon as you finish uh if you can come home and then Abdullah first or not depending on and hug him could be said heir of Shabbos Arab Hanukkah even though it's not yet because it's still the the Mitzvah the is and it is starting as soon as you lit the neighbors obviously even though it's early Arab Shabbos we say our nearest level right away don't wait till later because it's now is this mine now it's the mid to you could light bizman and leave the house Arab Shabbos if it's safe of course and you don't have to be there as long as you let sometime of course in the right time sometime before people is always to be lighted but we did say that if Arab Shabbos it went out and it's still time to relight it like many cities he should light it a second time you should put in you must put in I should say enough oil that it should burn until the end of the regular man if one if you want to keep just to one big Nair that's also good but there has to be enough oil to burn until the regulars man we should be accommodating for the at home buyers and never bring out tension in these two halik emitses when they took they too coincide the Isha the one slide a little earlier before the 18 or 15 minutes it's fine and work accordingly never light before plug even air of Shabbos it's probably not even good even with the Avid there's an is a half hour before the anticipated time of your lighting never lied even if it's a minute after skier by through ayid to ask a guy is it saraki and goddal if you want to do it you could do it to the main near Hanukkah of course the is the the the what we do the near Hanukkah is to do with this man and Shabbos has to be a different man the Prima Gotham says to keep the Nero Shabbos either in a different room or or set it up afterwards but it seems that's not the meaning I'm not sure why but maybe takes to if you can to cover it but I haven't found that many through a different hug him regarding minska before has its owns man ASAP without behala that is not to Russia I tackle got to mention I wondered why we don't make a minute that would satisfy all problems and that is if this wait wait till this man say even make Abdullah and then like and then go to school so it's not done but someone told me attacking the meaning of gear is to do that and I understand why this way you could keep the closer to the actuals man of Missouri Shabbos the at home the Melaka says what goes first Hanukkah or Abdullah the orbit come out of it Lighting in base if need be allowed to blow it out even though it's not a half hour lighting air of Shabbos you light a mic with a brock even though the shoe is empty you'll add a drink to wine and make another girlfriend before Abdullah and as we said Arab Shabbos although there's a good reason the government first but it's not my active because