Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
when actors play a role in a script to
make a movie none of that's real
everything in heaven is almost as if
it's staged by God it's God doing it all
in heaven but on Earth the Mitzvah is
called on our name it's our Mitzvah it's
our accomplishment it's our Torah
because it comes through the work and
the sacrifice that we give and invest
into
it
Al which translates you have ascended
upon
High shav Chevy and you have captured
what had been held
captive you have taken gifts for
man that even Rebels May dwell with
God you you you went up to the highest
of of heights this is a reference to MOS
Ascent onto Mount Si let's appreciate
when mosenu went on Mount Si this was
considered according to MIM that mosu
went into heaven or went up to heaven so
let's just be a bit precise really
Heaven came down to the top of Mount Si
and mosha went up the to to the top of
har SII and over there Moshe met with
the Heavenly hosts and of course God is
also there on whatever level of
Revelation this means and there's a
whole discussion up there so the har SI
became a place where Heaven Was and
that's what it means that mosha went up
to Har it means he went up to heaven
okay now the next part of the verse it
says that he captured what was being
held captive right shita
chevi right what is what is that what
what did moshu
capture from the from the angels on har
what did he get what did he have to take
from them that they were holding didn't
want to give it to him the tah it's a
famous midash that the angel said to
Hashem what do you want what do you want
to give the Torah to Bam Flesh and Blood
putrid yud Isa you know what is this
human being and first what is a human
being doing up here in this heavenly
realm we're Angels here it's perfect
it's beautiful it's unbelievable Sublime
spirit spiritual level why is Moshe here
in the first place and why do you want
to give him this Torah that you have for
so many thousands and thousands of years
give us your Torah we will keep it and
fulfill it and your glory will be
expressed through us give us your
glory so obviously what are they arguing
why do they want it why don't they want
to give it to mosha there's a lot
happening over here but be as it may
what comes out is that that he had to
according to the verse shita he had to
capture that which the angels were
holding in captivity from him
okay
now the next part is that he took gifts
for mankind because we know ultimately
when God gave us a Torah so it says that
he gave us many mitv right
um that he wanted to give a lot of so he
gave us a lot of but let's be honest at
the end of the day who are those mitzvot
for who are those mitzvot for
they're they to help us like re mayor
says does God care when whether you she
an animal from from the neck does what
does how does it affect Hashem if you
eat milk and meat not eat milk and meat
the answer is that all of the MIT are
for us to have and for us to be to and
our our our goof our it's meant to
purify and exalt us to elevate us that's
what Torah is for so ultimately it's our
gift Torah is our gift the Mitzvah that
we may seem and feel like our burden
sometimes the Mitzvah they're our gift
we benefit the Torah is for us it makes
us better it makes us more purified and
exalted this is connected to a statement
from uh reab Yosi re Yosi says that
there's a special day called the holiday
of sh the the the
high that this day made me into
something special because if it would
not be from Matan Torah
what would I be I would just be and I'm
going to speak in English and paraphrase
I would just be another Joe in the
market another Joe in the flea market I
know a Joe that works in the flea market
I could have been another Joe that
worked in the flea market what's the
difference between a a Stam Joe that
works in the flea market and Rabbi yose
which is the English translation is Joe
Rabbi
Joe this holy Sage rosi what's the
difference between these two entities
cuz he
says I learned Tor and I became exalted
because Torah changes you Torah changes
your Torah changes what you are into an
unbelievably exalted
being now that's what Torah is and so
therefore when Moshe went to Har and was
successful in taking the Torah and
bringing it down to us it was
unbelievable because now we had what we
needed to become exalted to become
angelic
to be even greater than Angels so now
let's look at the end of the verse it
says that even among Rebels God will
dwell this is a very difficult P what
does it mean that God will dwell with
Rebels it should say that Rebels will be
in geham what do you mean God will be
with the rebels God should be with the
sikim and with the rebels and the
criminals and people that go against him
he they should be in gam so what does it
mean that God will dwell even amongst
Rebels so it means that God will dwell
among human beings that have both good
and and negative inclinations that could
Rebel but he still gave us a Torah that
is an ability for us to connect with
hashem's ratson hashem's Divine will and
divine wisdom and have a connection with
him that he can dwell with us he built a
mishan where he dwells in Among Us so
even though we sometimes behave
sometimes misbehave God still chose to
dwell with us with his potential to
Rebel as opposed to the Angels because
he gave us the Torah and he decided to
have his sh his divine presence rest in
the lower world not just in the higher
Heavenly Realms exactly the opposite of
what the Angels were suggesting and were
ultimately you know asking him and
telling him that give us your glory give
leave the Torah with us dwell with us in
heaven forget these human beings they
they're they they're Rebels they they
have an evil inclination they're made
out of physical come born from a woman
they're putrid they're nothing they
can't compare to the beauty and glory
and refinement of angels and that's the
the the debate between Moshe and the
angels when I speak about Torah right
when we speak about Torah that existed
for thousands of years up somewhere in
the heavens right it's hashem's Torah
before he even made a physical world
there was a Torah so where would you
think the Torah would be at home where
is the home of the
Torah I would think the Torah was at
home with God above in heaven what would
you think what would you think
wasn't the Torah at home with Hashem in
heaven depends on what you understand
the Torah essence or close to Essence is
okay fine we're going to explore so
that's what I want to get at because it
says in the verse that that Moshe had to
capture that which was being held in
captivity now unfortunately we all know
too well today what it means to be held
captive you're not at home when you're
being held captive when you're in jail
when you're being held as a prisoner
you're not at all at home you're you're
you're out of your element and you're
trapped and the Torah is saying through
this PK that mosha came in and had to
take that which was being held and
trapped in Heaven with the angels and he
he had to fight for it and grab it and
Conquer it them and take the Torah for
us for mankind why and how is the Tor
being described as trapped in some type
of prison state in heaven where it came
from that's question number one okay
everybody here
appreciate okay question number two we
really said we'll just repeat it again
how can the Torah how can the verse so
to speak flaunt at the fact that Rebels
are going to be with Hashem rather than
in geham Rebels should be in Hell
suffering for their rebellion and for
the rebellious nature andik should be
with Hashem in in in heaven wherever and
and P certainly shouldn't fla that that
guess what even the rebels even those
that went against God even those that
betray God Hashem is going to be with
them also then what what's if whether
you behave or don't behave God's with
all of us then why behave again
obviously this is just this is just the
question stat that we'll hear the
answers in a
minute so and also we want to appreciate
right now what was the nature of this
argument that the Angels were trying to
keep the Torah and instead of letting
Moshe take it why did they want to have
a hold on it they they they had an
assumption that that they can fulfill it
better than us somehow so what I want to
give you guys now is a story it's uh for
the sake of this class since it's it's a
teacher training class so I feel it's
important that I mention that this story
is a is a madeup story it's not one of
those Rabin MIM unless you call a story
that I made up a Rabin mushel sounds
fancy but here here is the story okay
you'll see from the way it goes it's not
one of those classic uh old rinic
stories but it goes like this
imagine there were these two kings it
does have the two kings like any good
story has to have from the olden days
two kings friendly Kings they conversate
they they they they interact and one of
the one of the occasions they're like
you know they're getting into this
debate which king is better who's a more
powerful King whose King's country was
has a better country a stronger country
which is who's the better King who's got
the better the greater Kingdom so
they're like listen we can talk all day
how about this you come visit me and
I'll show you my kingdom and I'll come
and visit you and see your kingdom and
in the end we will honestly as two great
honest Kings we will decide and agree
who has the greater Kingdom so the
second degrees so they go to the first
Kingdom he takes them to the Palace in
the capital city and as they're
approaching it's awesome and and
beautiful and glorious with soldiers and
everything's beautiful and when you get
into the actual Palace it's unbelievable
and you see the the Army of the king and
the soldiers and how there's a a feeling
of awe everywhere you go of the of of
this great king and the king of course
proud of his kingdom and what he's able
to accomplish feels like you know this
is going to be heart the top so he they
leave that Kingdom and one of them is
very satisfied the other one says okay
no problem very quiet very calm come
with me now we'll go to my kingdom and
they go he's like but while while
they're on the way he says do me a favor
please indulge me instead of taking you
to my my uh my Capital City and showing
you that that City and the and my
Palace I'd like to take you instead to
one of the outskirts of the of my
country like in in the north to a small
town there it's very small town very far
away from the capital and my Palace so
the king is thinking to himself what is
going to be so impressive so far away
from where the king lives but okay we'll
go so they get there and it's you know L
towards towards even they say you know
what do me a favor let's ride around the
the the my this town through the night
with me without letting them know who we
are we're in this Carriage nobody knows
who's in it let's just watch and observe
what kind of town it is at night so they
drive around the town late afternoon at
night and they're watching and
everything and Dawn is approaching and
right around then the first king that
who who whose town we visited at first
he like he just shouts out he says I
swear by my life your kingdom is greater
than mine he had to admit the truth he
said any
Kingdom that the people follow the rules
of the king at night so far away from
where the king is where he never shows
his
face is a greater Kingdom than because
everybody understands that in order to
have people that listen to you so it's
not a big K it's not a it's not such a
big deal that if you're standing there
with your army that people listen
go where your army doesn't go go where
you never show up and people have the
real freedom to do what they want
smuggle in things
Contraband do whatever you want where no
they're not coming on a daily basis they
might come once or twice a year to check
me so I can do what I want and there
they still listen to the king what a
what what a powerful King what an
unbelievably beloved cherished powerful
feared King that is so the kingdom that
was greater was the one where obviously
that they listen to to the king far away
this will help us appreciate the
dialogue between the angels and Moshe
and why in the end Moshe won that
argument and why the Angels agreed to
give Moshe the Torah ultimately the
great the greatest
glory and honor for God and how awesome
Hashem is and how beloved he is and how
powerful he is and how feared he is and
how revered he is and how unbelievable
he is that he takes care of his of his
Nation it's not in heaven
where his presence is so powerful and so
revealed it's like the king is always
there of course heaven is going to be
perfect and beautiful and Angela are
going to be so spiritual because they're
in front of Hashem every minute every
second but go to Earth where Hashem
created a dark world this the Earth was
created through a manner of concealment
Heaven is a re revealed everything's
revealed in heaven on Earth it's
concealed give them a physical body with
a lot of different addictions that
they're naturally born with a a coarse
body physical needs and evil inclination
their own desires give them all of that
plus freedom because again God's
presence is not felt or seen in the
world it's as if people are so crazy to
even believe that there is no God so
imagine such a situation like that where
you have all the freedom in the world to
do whatever you want and you're never
going to get
caught okay so now we're going to answer
this final question that God dwells even
among Rebels as this by giving us AAR by
concealing his presence from us allowing
us to feel as if we exist all by
ourselves without anyone watching anyone
keeping track of what we do and we can
live any type of life we want with all
of that freedom when we choose to follow
the ways of God Hashem and his Torah we
bring the ultimate ultimate glory to
Hashem and so it's because he created us
with an ability to Rebel when we will
overcome all of that and choose with a
free choice from within our Essence to
serve Hashem and to do his Torah so that
is the greatest accomplishment and the
greatest glory for God much greater than
listening and following God in his
Palace now well this we can answer our
first question had the Torah remained in
the hands of the angels that their
entire life experience is equal to just
being a spiritual robot because when
God's presence is revealed the the
intensity of that Revelation is such so
great that all Angels could do is the
will of God that's why they're
considered extensions and emissaries of
God they're not free people that have
their own identity and their own plans
and their own desires and their own
Temptations they are a just a spiritual
manifestation of the will of God they're
robots nothing that they do is real in
essence
it doesn't come through hard work and
struggle or choice and so had the Torah
stayed in the hands of the angels in
this lofty realm of of of Heaven that
we're speaking about it's true that they
would never have messed
up but nothing they would have ever have
done would have really been done of in
and of themselves so they wouldn't have
messed up but they wouldn't have really
ever have even done anything that was
their own and real but when human beings
do a Torah it's real it's Ms it's their
accomplishment because it comes through
the struggle and the the the Conquering
and overcoming of darkness and all the
negativity that hashm put within us to
conquer and so had the Torah stayed in
the hands of the Angels it would forever
have remained
trapped and imprisoned in that place
lacking forever any real expression of
accomplishment and fulfillment so that's
what it means that the Torah was trapped
in Heaven because there was no real
fulfillment of it a robotic
mechanical performance of a script when
actors play a role in a script to make a
movie none of that's real that's not
life that's not real that's not
accomplishment that's fake that's staged
everything in heaven is almost as if
it's staged by God it's God doing it all
in heaven but on Earth the Mitzvah is
called on our name it's our Mitzvah it's
our accomplishment it's our Torah
because it comes through the work and
the sacrifice that we give and invest
into it and so we give the Torah the
real we give the Torah a real
fulfillment and without it it would have
forever been trapped in Heaven with the
angels that's what it means that MOS had
to take that Torah from the angels and
free it from the Captivity of that high
spiritual place that it was because over
there would have never been a real Torah
the Mitzvah would have never been real
it would have forever stayed God's
mitzvah but now on earth when we do the
Mitzvah it becomes our Mitzvah that we
accomplished together with of course
hashm who's the MIT and it's that
partnership where we invested and have
accomplished on our own and it's our
Mitzvah also in heaven it would have
been only hashem's Mitzvah not the
angels angels don't have a name in that
regard only we have a
name okay so that helps us appreciate
this uh this whole approach and the
greatness and the glory of Matan Torah
is this opportunity that we can rise
above angels in the Fulfillment of Torah
only the way we can do it here with the
struggle with the imperfections with
with with being afraid with feeling that
we haven't accomplished all of that is
part of what we offer Hashem at the end
of the day and what does Hashem say
about what we offer
him when the Angels do it's Hashem
causing his Ron to be manifest when we
do Ron hasem hasem says that you you did
my ratson you physical human beings that
could have done anything else much
easier and you did my Ron that's a for
me that it's pleasing to me that makes
it all worth it for Hashem because it
gives Hashem the greatest Glory and
Honor that he could have ever dreamed of
and that's why it
says he wanted this world
and it's very logical think about it and
with this will
conclude if the higher worlds gave
Hashem more than what this world gave
him then why did he make this world he
had a better world already the idea that
God created higher worlds and continued
to create worlds lower and lower and
lower means that those worlds had to
give him something that the higher one
wasn't giving him the fact that he
stopped when he got to our world means
that he saw that this world will
ultimately satisfy him in the complete
way that no other world can and so he
was done creating worlds when he got to
this world because it's what we
accomplish that is Al it rises above all
that he gets from all the worlds and
that's why it
says that the essential essence of God's
presence dwells in this lowest of
Worlds to my personal private place that
I choose above all other places in the
world
this place Earth together with with you
and me with
us it's not coincidence that we read par
midbar every year right before mat Torah
it's par midbar what's so special about
par midmar so parar really is is very
similar in theme Hashem left all the
heavens and the highest of Heavens
everything he said I want to be with you
even in the desert and we left
Society in Egypt and we Faithfully
follow them as the verse says
in we said hasem we love you and we will
go anywhere with you and Hashem said I
love you
back and I want to be with only you in
the desert we don't need anything if
it's just us together in in in in in the
desert and so the safer B midbar that
begins now as we are going to speak
about Matan Torah is all about this
Torah the Jews and it's it's all one
it's everything and that's all we need
CU that's what it was all for