0:00 / 0:00
Sukkos: Satmar Simchat Beis HaShoeva – The Secret of the Etrog Revealed
273 views
Subscribe and hit the bell to see new videos!!! • Visit the Rav's site: https://www.rabbidg.com • Have a Question? Contact the Rav: https://www.rabbidg.com/contact • Order Rabbi Glatstein's Books: https://www.rabbidg.com/rabbi-glatstein-books Date This Shiur Was Given: 10/12/2014 #Torahstudy #Judaism #Jewish #Torah #Spiritual #Rabbi
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this torah class is brought to you by
torahanytime.com
okay
thank you everyone for coming through
the simchasa this evening
um
we begin with the gemara massachusetts
for eight days
and they would tell the person who
poured the water on mazda they'd say hey
pal
be careful
when you pour the water on his back make
sure you pour it into the bowl and let
everyone see you pour it into the bowl
but don't pour it onto your feet says
the mishna one time
a guy poured the nurse
obviously this guy was a heretic
obviously this guy did not believe in
the uh
shabbat we know this
is not mentioned any in any passage in
the hamish right martin tina says how do
we know this
and therefore when the person was
managed when a person poured we said be
careful make sure you pour it into the
bowl
and one time a guy poured it on his legs
and guess what the people did
they were so upset at him says
the people stoned him
with their s reagan it's recording
you see the people stoned him with their
esragam
they stoned him
now that's a very interesting thing
they stoned him with their asteroid him
i mean they're trying to hurt him
and my experiences very interesting i
got my kids little sets of love and
estric but you have to get you can't
leave anybody out otherwise you know
they feel jealous
i i find in my experience the lulav is
much more dangerous than the esrak
yeah
with the
there were much more injuries with the
lula than the essence so you want to
injure someone maybe maybe the lula
would be better why dafka did they stone
him with the airstrike
in fact the gemara says later
that the coroner nifkama kane hamisbaya
the coroner of the mizbayach was
breached it was a little bit ruined it
was really cracked you know why
because they threw stones at him
so you want to hit someone you throw a
stone
right in gullah on kika shabbas nobody's
throwing a swag
right you want her you throw a stone
what's the indian that they threw a
strogan
right what's in here
now the
a very interesting thing
that from here we see
is in the morning
why because they did it at the time of
the s rag and ester is only by
so therefore we see from here is only
beyond from the fact that the mission
says
but but still the mishnah didn't have to
say their estrage could have said any of
the meaning why does the mishnah
specifically say the strike okay now the
positive says about the dal and meaning
take the asteroid
take the lulav take the hadassim take
the aerobics who smacks them and rejoice
come on
does that make does it make you happy to
shake your loving
it makes you happy
you want
but exactly what kind of kick do you get
i mean you get more of a sim card of
taking the down meaning than any of the
other mitzvahs that the torah says
you ready
for those of you who stayed tonight
it's the hour is late so you are privy
to secrets okay
tells us the big secret a big sight
and he says
the indian of the dal and meenim he says
the number four
says
he said this
on friday
on rosh hashanah hashem says do whatever
you want you don't have to keep the
torah just do me a favor don't eat from
the fruit
and all the marisha made from the fruit
so in order to rectify the sin of adam
marishan we have a mitzvah that take the
luvaness which is basically about the
same time of the year anyway
because you know other regions sin on
rosh hashanah it's only two weeks later
so therefore we take the dalai medium to
mahaprabhu for the sin of admiration
but
very interesting what does one thing got
to do with the other how about taking
the dalai meaning how is it
for the sin of the it's hadas what do
the meenum have to do with the eight
sadas and by the way this idea is
mentioned in in many sources he remember
franz allen margolis writes very
interesting
what is the word right before pre-etz
what do you mean take on the first day
it's not the first day it's the
fifteenth day of the month what does the
matter say on that word allah resign
that the first day of sukkos is called
what reshane
it's the first day god begins to
calculate average
because
once we have yom kippur there are no
more sins although your slate is wiped
clean so the first day you could sin is
what sukis and all them are fascinating
the first day you could sin is the
eleventh day of tishrei but still sukis
is known as
it's the first day you could sin
says rebel friends on margolis you know
what it means
why do you take the asteroid
because of adam marie shine what did he
do what he did was re-shine maheshwa
noise
what other origin did was the first
averra that was ever counted by god
that's what it means
only sinned with the etadas
so we daf could take the eso then we put
it together with the lula the lulu of
somehow as he ate sachayam
also very interesting idea ravjak of
emden writes about this in his siddha
in his introduction to the mitzvah of
louis vanessa this is also elaborated
and the safer ir miklot
now i'm going to tell you something
because
without you
i would have no one to talk to
so i have to tell you something very
interesting
the uh the safer year miklot is a very
unknown safer
it is written by
we have david lidda
lida is virtually unknown
he gives you
annotations and sources for the
david
was the wrath of amsterdam
he was accused of being a follower of
chapter
and he had to leave his post he was they
ousted him
the vad la alba arosas got together and
they cleared his name
but just because your name is clear
they're not taking you back so fast he
didn't he couldn't get the job back
he wrote a safer called
mcdonald
he says like this
that this safe air is plagiarized
yaakov
criticized with david leader of
plagiarizing the safer
the
in his
clears
from this accusation
because he says if you look clearly in
the introduction to
leaders commentary to the migdal david
he writes you know where i got it from
he says
so if someone doesn't read that
carefully he would think it means he got
it from a wellspring of life in other
words he got it from his torah knowledge
no
he got it from refrain cohen
cohen was the author of tor barakas his
name was khayim khan he was a client
and
is acknowledging the fact that this
safer
he gained and he
understood and he copied it from the
safer of reprimand so he didn't
plagiarize it he writes exclusively that
where he got it from okay so he does
clears him but he brings up the same
idea that the purpose of the dalai minim
is to rectify the sin of other marijuana
now what does one thing got to do with
the other right sammy what did dal and
meenam just because admiration ate from
the etadas
so how
you know it's one thing if we take the
eight zadas
but
just because we take these four species
and we shake them how does that rectify
the cinema of the marisha it's not like
other marichon shook
the eighths had that other region just
uh
he ate from it well you know what is one
thing got to do with the other
fasten yourself
there is a feature and a facet of
asteroid that no other fruit in the
world enjoys there's a certain
phenomenon about the aspect that is
different than any other fruit every
other fruit in the world
doesn't matter where it grows it could
grow in america it could grow in russia
it could grow in afghanistan they're all
the same the fruit tastes good the bark
doesn't
the tree you can't eat
you can't eat the table you can't eat
the tree you can eat the fruit
but there's one fruit
that you could eat the fruit and the
bark and the tree also tastes good and
that's the esright
because i'll say on the pasta pre eats
hadan a fruit
and a tree that's beautiful
now a fruit is beautiful it tastes good
how's the tree beautiful the answer is
the tree the tree of the asteroid you
could bite into it and it tastes like an
asteroid it's the oh what all of them
supposed to be like this all the trees
that's how it's supposed to be it's the
only fruit
it's the what
we didn't say anything about sending yet
the asteroid is the only fruit that the
bark tastes like the fruit
now
there's another facet of the s-erg
that's unique that it's the only fruit
in the world that has the following
feature the gomorrah says
number nine
what does the pasta mean
hashem says is like an apple
in a forest
hashem says
you jews to me you're like apples
right what's apple stock at now it's
very expensive no that's not what it
means right you jews are like apple an
apple ketappua what's a tapuak
an apple
why is claudia like the apple
just like the apple
the fruit grows before it leaves
so too claudius all said nasa before
nishma
just like the apple is the only fruit
that the fruit grows before its leaves
every other fruit in the world first the
leaves grow and then the fruit the apple
is the only fruit in the world
ever that first the fruit grows and then
the leaves grow
but what's the comparison just like nasa
nishma is out of order an apple is out
of order
that's we need to come up with an apple
as a muscle for something that's out of
order i know a lot of things in this
world that are backwards that could
serve as a mushroom to nasa vanishment
what the one thing
the one thing the gemara says you know
what kalisto saying
is like like the apple because the apple
grows with the fruit before the the leaf
that's the only thing in the world that
grows backwards
but this just asks even a better
question twice it says
this it's not true
the apple tree is slices i saw apple
trees not one apple tree in the world
does the fruit ever grow before the leaf
every apple tree the leaf grows before
the fruit so what's the gemara saying
that cloudy so it's like the apple tree
they're just like the apple tree the
fruit goes before the leaves soto guys
doesn't have it's not true the fruit
doesn't grow before the leaf so it goes
it says twice this
when the gemara says tapuaca doesn't
mean apple
it refers to the asteroid
it refers to the aesthetic because if
you look at the targum on the world on
the words
says
who the rush says was god
that it's not an apple where the fruit
goes brothers yes right okay so listen
that means there are two features of the
asteroid
that there are two unique features that
no other fruit has number one
the bark tastes like the fruit
number two
the fruit grows before the leaves
very interesting no isn't it interesting
that every other fruit in the whole
world
and they're all the same apples oranges
cherries
mangoes they're all the same old food's
the same except the s-rug sorg has two
things that are different number one the
bar tastes like the fruit and number two
the fruit grows before the leaves
is it just coincidental
that the s-roc has these two unique
features
or perhaps
is there some common denominator is
there um
is there a sarah
between these two features the fact that
the fruit grows before the leaves
and the fact that the
bar tastes like the food
or it just happens to be that the
is strange in two ways
by the way the gemara continues
there's once at suduki who saw rava and
rava was sitting with us sitting on his
hand he was crushing his hand and he was
gushing blood so that sudoku says to
rava am apaziza you're a
impatient
nation
you're you're
have no patience
your mouth comes before your mind you
should have asked hashem
first tell me what it says in the torah
and then i'll decide if i want to keep
it or not
and not only were you impatient then not
only were you impetuous then you're
impetuous now that's why you're acting
without any thought now you sit and
learn and you're crushing your hand so
just like you were
backward
back then you're backward today
listen carefully to what rava says
rabbit says no
we walk the slam us
like the passage says tumas yasharim tan
we walked wholeheartedly
yahshua's
straightness
but you walk with crookedness in other
words we have simple faith in god if god
tells us to do something we don't have
to ask
yeah but
what does it say in the torah and then
we're thinking is it going to be good is
it not going to be good no we just walk
wholeheartedly
okay bear that in mind somehow that
middah of saying now before nishma
is comparable to the s-rogue
where the fruit grows before the leaf
says
why do they have zuhama
what zuhama
know what zuhama is
a kind of poison it's a kind of internal
impurity filth impurity
habit jews don't have it
you know why says the gemara when adam
sinbad
we the all of mankind had became
impurified with zuhama we all became
zuhama filled
if you stick a zuhama thermometer in
somebody
it would register that this person has a
lot of zuhaman
but claw you saw when they stood on har
sinai their zuhamo is removed
never stood on har sinai their zuma was
not removed so the question is what in
the world is this
and how was it removed when the torah
was given
again it's a certain impurity a certain
tomah
where did it come from
and how did we get rid of it when the
torah was given
but what is this
okay you ready get ready for it get a
load of this
let's go to parishes voracious does
anybody know what is this week's version
this week's parashah is
pastor's voracious so good news is
you're not behind yet i'm being mad et
cetera okay right now you're up to date
okay
parish is voracious hashem
let the land proliferate with urban
zera
grass producing seeds eats puree
fruit trees oyster pre producing fruit
vas mainte what does it mean aids peri
isepri fruit trees producing fruit if
you're a fruit tree you obviously
produce fruit what's eats paris i said
pre it should say
ate soy supreme trees producing fruit
what ates pre fruit trees oyster free
says rashi
ates paris
the tree should taste like the fruit
or
and it should produce fruit when god
created the trees
his command was that every tree should
taste like fruit
eats puri the tree should taste like
fruit oyster pre and the chip producer
says rashi the heel i also saw kane it
didn't listen
the trees didn't listen the pasta says
well one second hello that toy saharans
it's oisa
right
so
the land didn't listen the tree didn't
listen they didn't follow the command of
yeah
instead of eight periods what does it
say about
the eights
so here's here revenge on imagine
imagine you're a tree you know from the
tree
just follow follow my directions yeah
i want you to taste like a fruit and
produce fruit
theresa you want me to
i'll let you know what i want to do and
the tree didn't listen the tree produced
food but didn't taste like food
and says rashi therefore
when adam was punished for his sin
hashem cursed the land together with
other mashems
very interesting
when the trees didn't listen to god when
the land didn't listen to god what did
god do to it nothing
but when adam sinned hashem said well
once i'm in the mood of punishing all
them i'll get the land together without
them either the land should be punished
or not if it should that hashem should
have punished it straight up and if it
shouldn't why is hashem only punishing
it together with other maritime and what
does it mean the trees didn't listen to
hashem why didn't they listen to hashem
says
at number 16 and the second paragraph
third line
oh
they had good kavanah
the sovereign mitzvah of the like every
avarian in the world
they the tree thought it was doing a
mitzvah
so the explains are kabbalah what was
the mitzvah that i thought it was doing
so the tree said look hashem created
light
but though hashem had to put away part
of the light
because he didn't want the roshan to
enjoy the light so hashem
hid the light for that sadiq and lost
the lovely
so then you show around yeah but they
were coming they're coming fast and
furious
yeah so the left so the tree said the
light doesn't want to be around to
hashem neither do we
so you know what we'll put ourselves
away we'll our bark won't taste like uh
fruit because we don't want the rasham
to eat it
says like this
he says these trees they're good guys
they're elected guys
god fearing trees god-fearing grass
they're always shuckling their grass
right they're god-fearing
yeah you ever see you ever see a grass
standing still they're always slavos
right
so
the proof is god never told the grass to
proliferate lamina by their
by their kind and even though hashem
didn't command them to do that they did
it anyway so we see they want to do
hashem wants
says
ready for this
their kavanaugh was like this god told
the fruits and the trees
spread proliferate
have more descendants
so the tree says i don't understand
if my bark and my tree
is going to taste like fruit
then how will i ever have descendants
because guess what
just like people will eat the fruit
they're going to eat the bark also
they're going to eat the eights also so
if they eat the eights also
we'll never be able to reproduce so it's
not going to be
eights how could we be proven how could
we proliferate so listen to what you did
so listen to what the trees did the tree
said i know we bunusham said aids pre i
separate
but we buttersham did it for a reason
why would they revenge on one uh me to
produce fruits and to taste like fruit
there are someone there to be more
fruits in the world the more trees in
the world
so the tree said the tree was in ibrahim
the tree said
it would be better if i don't listen to
hashem fully
in order to listen to hashem i have to
not listen to hashem
so the tree made a heisman the tree said
i know hashem wants me to reproduce and
reproduce and reproduce
so therefore what i'm going to do is
i'll produce fruits
but my bark won't taste like a fruit
this way there'll be more trees in the
world
because if you really want to be at
sadiq and listen to hashem you have to
understand why hashem commanded us
to
to be its priority supreme and therefore
the kavanagh says
the kavanaugh of the trees was the shame
chamayen in order to produce more in
order for there to be more fruits you
can't taste like a fruit if you're a
tree
trees
none of your business why hashem
commanded you
don't be an ibrahim don't outsmart
don't be too smart the reborn said
follow instructions the instructions are
taste like a fruit produce fruit
yeah but hashem said tastes like room
produce food in order to spread no no no
no don't start analyzing and being
figuring out why hashem commanded you do
what you're told
don't make
noise the ebola says to do something
follow instructions right you ever see
you ever tell somebody do something for
you
they did
why do you do it like this but i thought
it would be better listen hey pal
i told you what to do just follow
instructions
don't don't do it your way do what i
told you
that's the meda
that the trees were lacking
just wholeheartedly follow the rats
that it was the abdomen the trees that
came from then okay so listen to this
there's a big secret okay
if you were a tree
okay i'm not saying you're a tree but if
you were a tree right
if you were producing
you produce fruits
and leaves
what would you produce first
a fruit
or a leaf
what would you do
i wasn't told about it
you only talked about fruit
so
it's very interesting we don't find
anywhere in any madrish or any gemara
what the role of a fruit is what the
role of a leaf is
in the safer malaria tyra or the brother
of the village
he points out something very interesting
that what is the function of a leaf on a
tree
the leaf protects the fruit
is a shimmer on the fruit it's a smeara
on the fruit you have
an insect the leaf covers the fruit you
have a bird you have a worm the leaf is
the shimmer of the pre so if you were a
tree would you produce fruits first or
you produce leaves first of course you
would produce leaves first you need a
shimmer you know you don't bring a
treasure to your house
you don't bring a treasure house unless
you first
have a house have a house
oh no you don't produce
you don't have a treasure until you have
a guard otherwise it's gonna be removed
it's going to be taken away
so therefore very interesting
most fruits in the world what comes
first first comes the leaf
and then comes the fruit
first why
that's the logical way to do it you have
the shiny mare and you have the pre
and that's what every single fruit in
the world does that's what every single
tree in the world does there's one
exception
the s-rug is the only exception
why
because when hashem told the fruits
that the eight's pre-or supreme
that it's not enough to produce fruits
but you have the bar cast that tastes
like a fruit and every other tree in the
world made by noise and said well
hashem only told us to do this because
he wants fruits in the world so it's
better if the bark doesn't taste so the
asteroid right every fruit in the world
made a heisman made a calculation the
aesthetic didn't make any who said
hashem said eight pre i supreme
the s works said i follow the command as
is i take my orders at face value
the asteroid is the only fruit
that the fruit
grows before the tree you know why
because hashem told the asteroid
produce fruit so now the s we're going
to start may start making hajj noise
first i'm going to make a leaf
to make a production and then i'm going
to produce a fruit
of course not
the esrog takes orders at face value
hashem says produce fruit the asteroid
produces fruit
it's every other tree in the world they
make boy noise
we're not going to do it's pre-order
supreme what are we going to do we're
going to make
eights isa
every other we're going to make eight
soy
supreme so it comes out
that the two unique features of the
asteroid
are one meda
and the media is
while every other fruit in the world
made calculations
and try to figure out what's going to be
better for me
for me it's going to be better if i
don't taste like a fruit for me it's
going to be better if the leaf comes
before the fruit the asteroid follows
orders at face
value thank you very much the asteroid
follows orders at face value it's the
meda of tomimus of the s rug that is why
it produced
aids puri or esepri
it just followed the words of hashem
without making hezboi noise and that is
why it grows with the fruit before the
leaf it's the same meda
it's the same
characteristic characteristic of tomimus
following the rats and hashem without
being in ibrahim
so very interesting
no we see in many cases in uh
in mycebrationist that the the tsar or
the malek that represented the various
things that were created
apparently had some kind of free choice
whether to uh
well
so listen to this this amazing thing
so it comes out
it comes out
that the asteroid is the only fruit that
has this middah
of timimus
of
not having to make hajj voice will it
work out well and not work out doesn't
make sense for me does not make sense
right that is why the gemara says that
when hashem offered the tardical you saw
and they said nasa the nisma what fruit
are they comparable to
the answer why not just because claudius
oil did things backward just like the
eso does things backwards no it's the
meda of the esrog when hashem offered
the target of the jewish people they
didn't say
let's make khajbay noise does it work
into my schedule does it not work into
my schedule is it easy is it hard is it
convenient and i mean claudio said if
the creator of the world is presenting
us with this body of information it's
for our benefit the media of tomimus
that is why they are compared to the
asteroid not just because the asteroid
grows in a
different way it's because the asteroid
has this
of timos of perfection of not
questioning the will of asha okay
let's come back to the sin of the
itzadas okay
if we had a pinpoint
what was the sin of the itadas
what did adam ahrisha do wrong
what was the underlying problem with
what he did
in the hamish it doesn't really identify
it
that's always troublesome but
it says like this
there's a pasta in kahalas listen
carefully
look at number 21
accept
look what i found
god made
man straight
fahema vikshu
but they seek
many calculations
very interesting
god made man straight
but man perverted himself
man made himself crooked man searches
for his voice
says rashi which man did god make
yahshua
adam
but when adam was by himself he was a
yashar but fehema
but
when he became hema when there was
another party involved
then
why did he eat from the tree
hema bikshu
noise
he started making all kinds of
noise why even though hashem said not to
eat from the tadas but really it's
because of this and if i eat from it it
will be better off and really some would
want me the only reason he didn't
commanded me not to eat from it is
because he didn't think but other
mauritian maybe if you look in revenue
he made a whole husband he made a whole
calculation but
what
he was tricked but why did he succumb
why do you fall for it
he came up with a rationalization he
came up with a kejbang he came with a
calculation but bottom line is what in
the navi in the in the tana what does it
identify the problem about the marijuana
the problem was hema bikshu
noise
he became an ibrahim he outsmarted so to
speak he's gonna outsmart three bunch of
he's gonna make all kinds of complex
calculations
ah
so now we understand
now we understand
what was the sin of the trees
the sin of the trees was according to
his kuni
they didn't listen to hashem
why why
because they made all kinds of
they made a husband they was a husband
the frenchman was well
if we if we don't make aids priority
supreme we'll be able to proliferate
able to make the siddhasham greater
ah so hashem said that avira in and of
itself i'll let it go
but now other mauritian is learning from
you
now other mission takes your example to
be making these khajbali noise and he
sins with the ethadas so hashem says
when i punish adam i punish you along
with it because it's the same common
thread however
there's one fruit
that was immune to this problem
the s-rogue the s-rogue was above and
beyond these cashboiners the s-work
followed the order it's pre isa pre the
asteroid
grows the pre before the ulum the fruit
before the branches and that could be
why rabbi said
does anybody know
what was the eighth hadas
so the different opinions you know when
you drink when you drink a wine when you
drink wine
you drink wine so you give your friend a
bracha what brother do you give your
friend
because there's an opinion
and that brought me salailam so now when
you drink wine you say we hope this wine
won't bring miso and we hope this will
bring the cayenne
that's why some people are mad but to
drink schnapps
because there's shita there's hita
right
you have to say
[Music]
[Applause]
was good
what tree is not only the pre good the
eights is also good the asteroid
so it comes out the asteroid
no the tina the eights tastes like
eights it doesn't taste like opinion
there's another opinion of thanos yeah
why do you think the one fruit that
hashem told them not to eat was the
esrog
hashem was trying to teach others a
lesson saying adam
you're going to start making
why you should eat this fruit no
learn the lesson of the fruit the lesson
of the fruit is
it's pre i supre
follows orders this is a fruit that
doesn't make
hashem was lending the fruit the ability
to do what
to teach adam not to succumb not to make
the nice
okay so it comes out very beautiful the
two features of the escort really stem
from one meda
and now we understand why this mida of
the asteroid that the fruit grows before
the leaves
reflects na seven ishma it's not just oh
no solution is out of order fruit before
leaves is out of order no the media of
nasa and isma is tamima's not making
don't make too many calculations follow
what hashem commands without trying to
outsmart him
okay
what is this zuhama
and how did we correct it by standing at
harcine okay let's try to explain this
briefly
maybe i always thought
that when hashem gave us the torah the
torah purified us from this impurity
this poison
but yet the masham
tells us
to look
the commentary of the kalbai on the gada
kalba is a re-shine we don't know who
wrote it
the cowboy says on the words
had god brought us before our sunnah
fellaini
without giving us the torah dayenu
it would have been enough
yeah
the question is what benefit is there to
go to harsina and not get the torah
that's like rabbi if i came tonight and
i'd even hear a shirt it would have been
enough of course because you had a big
meal
right but
but if you came to har sinai and you
didn't learn torah they weren't serving
food at har sinai
so what benefits we get
says the cowboy says abu dhab just being
at harsinai would have rid them of the
impurity
so you see from there
that it wasn't the giving of the torah
that rhythm of the impurity it was
merely standing there on arsina that
rhythm of the impurity exactly
just being on that holy occasion so the
question is
at what moment of that holy occasion did
a rhythm of the impurity
rashi says
that when they stood on har sinai
rashi says
they were
fixed and corrected from any mum
now when the torah was given when they
stood on harsh night rashi
the madrid says you know when they were
corrected from every mom
when they said nasa vanish
so putting two and two together
at what moment of time were were they
cleansed from their zuhama from their
impurity
now when they got the torah because it
says hashem bro
had not given us the torah we still
would have been closer than purity
so at what moment of harassing would we
have been cleansed of our impurity
apparently the madras says when we said
nasa the nishma
at that moment
hashem healed all of our moomin
and rasheed azara says the moment we
were healed from our movement we were
rude from our impurity what that means
that when cloud israel said nasa venisma
their zuhama was gone
not when they got the torah they didn't
need the title to get rid of their filth
and their impurity when they said nasa
and ishmael that's when their impurity
was gone
how does saying nasa nishma massive
rhythm of the impurity
you ready
where did the impurity come from the
eighth hadas
what caused them to sin
the hema bikshu is vinoys
the poison in them was
this scheming planning plotting always
making
noise and we all know about ourselves
that often when we do the wrong thing
we have all kinds of complicated
rationalizations
and complex
explanations for what we do
we make khashwa noise
that was the impurity that was the tama
that's the zuama
what corrected it
what's not
no
no calculations god
you gave us the torah
we'll do it we're not going to even ask
what it says in it
the impurity was
big
how did we rid ourselves of that
is the exact opposite
so here we have
what is the esrog then
the esrog is
the meda of tomimus
the media of god the way god created man
before the sin
god created man before the sin how
yashar without
and there's only one fruit that stayed
that way
that's the esrog no no it remains eighth
period
it's a pre-eighth hada
that is why sister of david cohen
taking the aesthetic is the tikkun for
the sin of the
what's the sin the sin was
yeah admiration was scheming why coming
up with rationalizations why it's okay
really to eat from the fruit even though
hashem said not but under these
circumstances he didn't really mean it
of course you're not allowed to do yeah
the says you know how to do it but under
these circumstances for me and my
situation and for me it's a mitzvah of
course right that's that's that's what
we do right that's the biggest trick the
oldest trick in the book of course
you're not allowed to but for me in my
circumstances on this situation hashem
wasn't talking to me
that was
so what do we do to rectify that
we emphasize the aesthetic the essex is
the only fruit
that does what
aids pre-or
follows the command of hashem
how am i going to produce
right why did every tree in the world
not taste like fruit because they made a
calculation that how will they ever
they'll become endangered endangered
species
what did the asteroid say
not my problem god told me how to be
i'll be that way
hold aside whether i'll be endangered or
not
the way to correct the sinai is to
emphasize the media of the aesthetic
what meter is that what does the gemara
compare the asteroid to
nasa venisma
just like khai so said nasa then ishmael
they're like the s rug where the fruit
comes before the leaf it doesn't say
well if hashem wants me to grow then i
have to develop leaves before my fruit
no the midday of the aso gives bilith
very interesting when rava explains his
behavior of sitting on his hand
and learning without making any hajj
voice
he says what meda is this
tumas
yasharim
the media of yahshuas
how is
how is not making
noise
answers we see in the passage
yashar means without making
us
the need of straightness is not to make
corrupt calculations that's the media of
yahshuas that was what rubble is
emphasizing the middah of nasa
vanishment is the media of yasuos
that's the esrog the s-rogue is going
back
to
adam before the height of
him
yasha
okay one last step
why does the eso make us happy
if there is one meda in tanakh that we
find engenders
in order to have happiness in this world
you can't be crooked
if you're crooked
your own
psyche
detects
that you're not real
and it's hard to feel joy joy comes
to simcha and therefore the s right
which is the media of tumas is
you're happy
said to the sudoki what
you guys are crooked
you guys are full of calculations that
sudokum say yeah the mitzvos are not for
our times they're archaic they're
ancient that sudoku marmala
so how do we attack the sudukin
we take the esrog
the asteroid
creates upreef
the fruit grows before the leaves we say
to the tsunuki you're a corrupt
mechashave you have all kinds of deviant
devious schemes and
we don't throw rocks at you we throw a
sri gem at you the s-rig is the nasa the
nishma the eso gives the
and that's how we teach the lesson to
the tsuduki because very interesting the
mishnah didn't say the guy was the
suduki
but if you look on the bottom of the
page on the gemara the number 40
the gemara says tana rabona myself
he wasn't just a regular guy he's a
tsudu god suduki we know those sudoku
rava said we have the middle of nasa
so we bomb
now with tomatoes now with potatoes with
esroygim and we teach the suduki that if
you want to be happy in this world you
have to go back to kisame
you've just experienced another torah
class brought to you by torahanytime.com