Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this Torah class is brought to you by
Torah anytime.com
okay good morning rabai this is the last
time we meet in
ZEM gave us the health and the life to
be together for this year and we
hope we should be together gide for the
upcoming year and for many years to come
so the tells us something about tomorrow
tomorrow of course is the last day of
the year rash my birthday yeah ran
Bish's birthday also and there's
something very important and significant
about um AR Rashana and
that is the last day of the year and
have a tradition that if somebody does
Chua One Day in the year it's considered
like they did Chua the whole year
wow so you know even if a person was
laxed the rest of the year but if we
take advantage of the last day of the
year will be considered as if we did CH
the whole
year therefore the custom
is everyone
fasts and they get up very
early before the
day and they say a lot of
and they
say and therefore the is telling us the
custom is everyone fast and gets up
really early well then the
continues a person should be learning
involved in mitzvas the whole
day it is worthwhile to immerse in a
mikah or a river
one should not be earlier than an hour
before and not to divert their attention
from cha the whole day so is teaching us
that is a very important day especially
in light of the fact that if you do Chua
one day of the year it's like you did
Chua the whole year okay but the
tour um explains what exactly is the
significance of I mean if if doing Chua
one day years is like doing Chua the
whole year you could really do CH any
day why
da and the tour really hiend to us the
our appreciation of the tah says the
following rash for everyone to fast on
rash
the and they rely on meaning a to this a
hint to this is
it says about
the you should take for yourself on the
first day and the question is it's not
the first day the when you take the it's
the 15th day of what do you mean you
should take the first day
says it's the first day of the
calculation of sin says the
med it's a parable to a
country that is obligated to pay a tax
to the
king and they didn't pay it so what
happens the king comes with an army to
collect
it as the king
approaches 10 par within the
city
the the prestigious people of the city
The Honorable people the leaders of the
city approach the king and they tell the
king we don't have what to give to
you so the King overlooks the third of
the
tax the king comes
closer the average people come out to
greet
him the king overlooks the second
third when the king gets
closer the whole city comes out to greet
him and the King overlooks everything
who's the
king who are the
people they amount they amass the whole
year the great people
fast and the King overlooks a third of
their
sin the T days the average people
fast and the King overlooks
2/3 everyone
fastes and they're involved
in in and they don't do therefore the
first day of suus is
called the first day God could calculate
sin because sins by the time Kipper
comes all has been forgiven and in the
intermediary days before between yum and
Suk there's no time to sin therefore the
first opportunity to sin is the first
day
of said there are a lot of questions on
this med number one the the B asks
according to this
then is equal
to forgives a third and R forgives a
third and that's quite a Whopper of AES
to say that AR rash is just as powerful
f as y especially in light of the fact
that the T doesn't say a word
about how could it be that one day of is
equal to the
entire to the entire Y where on an
entire third is
Forgiven well says to answer that
question the first third is always
easier than the second and the third
third the first third is the
easiest the first third of sin is the
easiest to forgive okay interesting you
know maybe we could explain with a very
simp oversimplified mus we've been
learning from the Shar Chua that there
many levels of chuva and chuva is like
uh a process of whitening so if you get
the chillun on your shirt so the first
step is get the bean off get the kishko
off the next step is you take a wet
shata with hot water and you try to get
out the stain and then what whatever
doesn't come out that's the tough part
you got to put in the washing machine
with bleach and detergent and maybe send
it to the cleaners so RAB said the first
step is always the easiest you just take
it off the you just take it off your
shirt so that's always the easiest uh
part of it but that's what the says the
first third is the easiest and therefore
um AR rashash is not as great as Yumer
Yumer obviously is much greater but the
first third is very easy but comes a Taz
and the T asks also a very incisive
question and an obvious
question and that
is if Hashem wipes out the first third
Ona
shashana then it says Hashem wipes out
2/3 what do you mean on during wipes out
2/3 he only wipes out
one3 what does it mean during CH it says
um
God overlooks 2/3 he doesn't look
Overlook 2/3 he overlooks
one3 because the first third he already
overlooked and then what does it mean
hasem overlooks everything on Yumer
there's nothing left on Yumer the first
third
is
two3 comes yum there's no point of even
fasting I mean according to the Torah
was call Yumer well maybe it's two3 of
what was left after the first so first a
third and then 2/3 of what's left so
just look that's a very complex
mathematical formula why would that be
that means basically yum Kipper is the
most insignificant of all three days of
chuva but the also says that the first
third
is right we don't have that so maybe we
don't go in with that one3 so they but
the what does the medish mean the medish
says on forgives overlooks 1/3 and the
second one he overlooks 2/3 I thought
only
one3 and as we're going to see there's
another major question over here and
that is just how do you read the tourah
the tourah says the minan asaz is for
who to
fast everyone fasts rash and then the
Torah says like the med says that just
like when the king is approaching to
collect the TX
first the go out to greet the king and
likewise well if the says clearly
the why does the Torah say that
everybody fasts the med says only the
fast we're going to have to address that
question as well well the T says as
follows when the medish says that on
hasem is m a
third he's not m a third he's M third
what does it mean he's M third he so to
speak puts it on the side says okay
we'll deal with it later I'm going to
give you a break I'm going to give you I
hopefully you'll be able to remove that
later but for now I'm going to overlook
that for now temporary reprieve
basically you're out on bail deferring
deferring exactly the first third is
deferred then comes the era rashash and
you could say say the then comesa the
second third is
deferred maybe that would answer the B's
question as well maybe 2/3 are deferred
and now everything is deferred but
you're going to still have to pay the
price for everything comes yipper and
everything
is everything is completely washed away
meaning what happens on yum Kipper is
it's not it's not deferred it's not
pushed off it's not stalled but
it's not until
Yer we count the first two thirds with
the final third and now maybe you'll say
Weller
also as the Taz asked
that again what was the question of the
T that if hasem is M the two3 so there's
nothing left on yipper so therefore the
medish points out that no maybe you'll
say that yeah Hashem defers the first
third then Hashem defers the 2/3 maybe
they're never maybe it's always a
process of being deferred no therefore
comes the med it says the first day of
suus
is um it's the first day for you
meaning you should take on the first day
what do you mean on the first day
the first day of is the beginning of
calculation meaning it's
not until Yumer but once Yumer comes
it's completely wiped away and there's
no Reckoning until the first day of
sukus so what's the purpose of the the F
CU it's not is it meaningful in any way
it's very meaningful first of all we
would never reach the level of complete
forgiveness unless we are able to defer
it to some extent and it gives us an
opportunity to DAV in otherwise to stand
before God with that really looming over
you we would never have that opportunity
so just in order to be able to Davin in
front of Hashem we need the to be
deferred but from this Tas we see a very
interesting process that a person could
gain VOR without
M so interestingly there's a Chua in
the in T
Sim where the says that based on this
Taz we could explain a difficult rashi
rashi tells us that mosu went up to Har
another two times after the first 40
days when he went up to get the T and
then he came down and he still the AAL
he went up another two sets of 40 days
and Rashi points out what was the
difference between the first set of 40
and the last set of 40 the says in
in like in the
beginning 40 days and 40
nights during that ascent
I waited there 40
days the second meaning the intermediary
period of 40 days ended on the 29th day
of because he went
up
that was a piece
to so what did he
do he did another 40 Days
they ended
on
that hasem was appeased by with joy now
listen carefully that means he came down
after the first 40 days so they broke he
goes up
again
and that that 40-day period ended on the
299th day of a which means on the 29th
day of hasem
was so of what significance was the
final 30 days where he went up and came
down on and was to them what do you mean
he already was to them
on why do we need two additional period
periods of 40
days so it says based on this Taz we
could explain that there two two levels
of
atonement
after when we say was to them he was
only as a as ay as a
deferment
however he did not Grant complete
Kap until Yumer in other words what
Yumer added was it was not
only removal temporary removal out on
baale but it was complete
forgiveness with this we could explain
another very important concept and that
is
us a very interesting and that
is cannot do
CH only a do a cannot do it
says what about it
good question so Mr Caro ate his weedies
this morning and he he's making like
it's not a big question it's a very big
question why did if G can't do Chua so
what's the whole Seer of Y there's
something called the trasar and one of
the TR sa for y and the whole book is
that Y is told go tell the people to do
chuva and it seems like they did chuva
and they were saved he was just a FM
didn't give him complete exoneration so
first of all why is it that are not able
to do Chua so the brings down from The
Rao that the way chuva works is you need
now the's relationship with the is the
relationship of a so he's their
King so
therefore are not able to do because God
cannot forgive them however our
relationship with Hashem is that of
Father and Son
but the question
is what in the world happened in
nve how could they have done chuva and
says they didn't they didn't they're not
able to do Chua and ultimately they were
not able to wipe away their a says the
that the guy
by their sin always looms and the decree
stands against
them only it was only temporarily so so
you'll say what do you mean only
temporarily they were about to be
destroyed and then Hashem didn't destroy
them it seemed like it
worked so I remind
you um
of the Mal
in if you remember y tells the people of
nve well says the
Mal is
gatria
80 is 40 and in fact in 120 years later
nve was
destroyed oh
could also mean a
year
CH can't do cha so so what did they do
def
deferral so you got it
what 120 years is 120 years I mean you
know there are probably people who live
much longer who actually
were it's not
Chua you know their sin so they lived
out their lives and the Next Generation
it's temp right it's temporarily
overlooking uh the wrongdoing and giving
some patience to what happened okay Chua
if you do chuva but it's not accepted is
that you're still doing Chua if you do
Chua it will be
accepted
automatically without
reservation if you do chuva it will be
accepted real Tru real Tru not if you go
through the
we said
because says so now here's the question
question
is the tour starts out that the Min in
ashkan is everyone
fast and the M the Torah gives is when
the king comes to collect the the taxes
the fast so it's
like the the r is not to the so this is
the question of the
himself look at number
10 even in the we say
that fast what but that means not
everybody
fasts is for everyone to fast
why because this is a very interesting
idea when we say that um G should do
something is anyone allowed to do it
usually no what would it be called if an
average person does something which is
reserved for
G it's arrogant it's it's this is not
for a regular person this is for someone
of a greater standing so says the
concept that when something is for other
people should not do it that's just a
regular practice but when it comes to
paining oneself and afflicting oneself
and making yourself B then anybody who
wants to compromise their comfort is
allowed to do it it's not considered GIC
to sort of compromise your own Comfort
if it's a matter of let's say taking a
keyo an honor or doing a practice which
is extra religious so then we say no
this is not for you this is only for
great people however if it's a matter of
anyone says is all to puts
interestingly the asks on the that if
this is the case this is a s in the
himself that
if um theor is
inar that not everyone is allowed to
fast only the are allowed to fast so why
when it comes to rash does say everyone
could fast because this is not g because
this is a matter of of painting oneself
but when we talk about when the is there
we only allow the to
fast differentiates between the two inan
over there we're talking about when the
so you're fasting to ask for mercy on
theor who are you to request Mercy for
theor what you're a big you're just an
average person we don't let you
fast what are you fasting for you're
fasting for yourself for your own so
everybody has a right to say even if I'm
not a great person I'm authorized to
fast to try to get out as much as many
of my as I would
like this question on the tour that why
would the tour start off by
saying and then bring a from a from a
story where only the G fast this
question is addressed by the in at least
five different
places where gives at least five
different answers to this question of
why would the tour begin
that and then end off with we're only
some of the people fast why do you have
to come up with five differents he
wasn't happy with the first why because
five is always better than four
well according to the Torah it's the
whole day even today in the
yeshivas they many tell me them fast
half a
day but the original
custom doesn't say it half a day it's at
least most of the day until right before
the
end are also Jewish people do they fast
on I don't know what they do I don't
know so again the question is why would
the T
say if in the only some of the people
fast not only that says not only does
everyone fast even children fast on AR
rashash so here the the tour is
saying and means even the and in the T
only
the answer number one take a look at
number 12 this is the first answer in
the page shin
me well says in the early days we knew
who the were we knew who the mediocre
people were and we know who the little
people were meaning in the olden days
people wore name cards some people
say my name is y I'm a God and then
other people would wear name cards they
say my name is barl I'm a regular person
and then other people would wear I'm F
I'm a nobody just joking they wouldn't
actually wear name cards but but it was
known every the social standing not the
so the spiritual standing of a person
was recognizable even
though who could really know who's a God
and who's a k but back in the day when
people were more legitimate and more
sincere you knew what was what
but the are sometimes nobodies and the
nobodies are sometimes somebodies and
the average people could either be
nobodies or somebodies
and you know what it depends on the day
today this time is a nobody tomorrow
that time it depends on the hour it
depends on the minute nobody knows
anything about anybody therefore it's
not GIC for anybody to fast because
there's such confusion and lack of
ability for anybody to know where
anybody stands that
b everyone has the right to fast I
only well we don't know who they are so
Hashem will decide hopefully everyone
fasts then we'll end up being the G will
be fasting but if we don't have everyone
fasting we're going to be in trouble if
only the people who we think are fast
and the regular people don't that's the
first
answer answer number two it used to be
there were a lot of good and therefore
if they would fast that was a big honor
to the king and he thereby would
Overlook a third of the
a however Bim
they're very few
people as a who qualify for that Char
for that status
status very doubtful you'll even have a
minion
says very doubtful you even have a
minion even in the time
of and
therefore in order to get the king to be
appeased it doesn't work anymore just to
have the everyone's going to have to
fast and says you could even read this
into the of the we say like
this so we read like this when it
was then what was appropriate would be
that the great people will Fast and
honor you but why is
it why nowadays everyone's fasting
because because what could we do we
don't have the same quantity of that
once
were okay that's answer number two
answer number
three says the on
Page in the
the whenu is told to
address he tells
them say these words and Rashi
says not less and not
more what does that mean not less and
not more so says like this
it doesn't mean don't add more words or
subtract more words it means the level
of is the highest possible level that
any entity could reach even angels
cannot reach that level to be a kingdom
of priests and a holy
nation means there's no one too low even
the low even a regular person even the
lowest person is always able to attain
that level meaning there's no higher
level and no one is too low from
attaining that level
therefore yes only the go out to the
king so listen
carefully
says only the
fast but someone who's not a godal
should look at that godal and say why am
I not a God I could have been a God no I
couldn't have I was born in into this
family or in this place and this time I
could never have been a g no it's not
true anyone could be a God could have
been a g should be a God so either you
fast CU you're a godal or you fast
because you're not a godal why aren't
you a
godal that's why everyone fasts on AR
rash either because the fast or because
if you're not a God and you're not
fasting you should be fasting that
you're not a
God we just say we should just say and
even talk about it doesn't matter so
yeah that's idea you know like they said
the somebody once went
to what should I do if I can't cry on
Tish so s says cry that you're not able
to cry so so too who should fast on on
aash the big people and what about me
I'm not a big person I should cry that
I'm not a big person and you should fast
because you're not a big I should fast
cuz I'm not I didn't make it to be a big
person fine next answer the Apparently
this this tour uh really occupied the
attention of the so says in on page
Shin why does everyone fast why not only
the
gum
question
says in the Mas
why does a third of the people the big
people come out first 10 parts away then
the average people come when the king is
closer and then everyone comes when the
king's in the city the mush should be
when the king is coming with an army to
collect the taxes everyone should come
out immediately to appease the king so
it doesn't have to come to the fact that
the king is right by the
city yeah but then if he doesn't do it
you're stuck CU you have your you can't
do
any right you know you can't impress
them anymore wellam Sur says the real
answer is not a good negotiating
strategy the the the answer is of course
you should do that the thing is in the
case of the king apparently the regular
people and the small people they're
dismissing the whole event and they're
saying nah the king will never come it
will never happen he Overlook the taxes
I never pay taxes I never got caught
they ignore the whole thing so therefore
the first the smart people go out and
and they understand that the the king is
coming and then when the king get closer
the average people start to sweat and
when the king's standing at the door
everybody's sweating it's the same thing
y who's preparing themselves you know El
and it's the people that have more of a
a feel for the T people that have more
so they're approaching the king and
they're worried about what's going to
happen everybody else they either wake
up a they wake up AR rashash but of
course it's much better if you wake up
AR of
Rashana uh just like in the case of the
king it would have been much better if
everybody came out to greet the king
initially when he was far away so too of
course it's better if everyone comes
down in it just the reality is that most
people don't feel it but therefore the
custom is for everyone to go
out in order to try to do things in the
best possible so that is the fourth
approach of
the and here's the fifth
approach
says what does it mean that the first
day of suus
is means like this that if a person does
Chu then basically the AA is downgraded
from maed
to and so on and so forth because some
wants to know what's this business that
a third a third a third why why this you
know many stepped
program well says if you do
CH then we're going to have to start
counting well you did CH so it's
downgraded from and then if you do CH
more it's downgraded more so the process
is a many step process but if you do CH
where it turns into mitv there's no at
all because everybody is equal because
all everybody's AOS are transformed into
mitv say when we say the go out
overlooks a third that's talking about
most of the time when people
do so therefore the a is downgraded and
therefore there's something left and it
has to be taken away more and more on
but if you do and the turned into MIT
we're not asking V the whole are turned
into then everyone could come together
and there's no difference
between and and so on
and the fact that everybody
approaches to fast that's an indication
that what we're trying to do is CH May
and not
CH let's end with the
following why
should have a suda she have a suda yeah
what
fast that that would reduce the level of
concentration and conviction to do the
Chua you're going to
have we said before you have to you
can't have when you're CH the whole day
you're going to go stuff yourself you're
going to
lose okay let me share with you um one
one last segment over here with SCH
muger and his d explain something very
interesting why thirds why a first third
a second third a third third why is it
broken up into thirds he says something
quite amazing every a has three parts ma
turns
to is Forgiven and finally it's turned
into well
therefore when the ma it is downgraded
to the is
Forgiven we become
and the are turned
into very interesting
comes
andin the author of
The and he says a very interesting
thing he says wait a second there's one
last thing over here what else is over
here what else are we missing it says
that
what's that
word the V teaches us on the that
says and what's and what's says very
powerful is you
spoke Z you wor Shas zap you screamed at
someone we're going to nail you so now I
did so I'm off the hook no you're not
off the
hook is fine you spoke you're off the
hook but instead instead of speaking you
should have been learning you should
have been doing mitv so is for the A and
is you should have been doing a
mitzvah for example says when you
speak yeah because instead of speaking
you should have been learning so one is
a for speaking and two is a for not
learning so you could get atonement for
the sin but you still got off the but
you didn't get off
the so says the yes like
this turns
into
disappears Yumer maybe the a itself
turns into a Mitzvah but you're still
missing something
you know what you're missing you could
have been doing a Mitzvah during that
time and you can be punished for not
doing a Mitzvah during that time
comes and what do we do on we
do when you do that gets you off the
hook for not having done mitv at the
time that you were doing the a what is
that called you get off the
hook therefore the first day of suus
isine
still doing no in other words all the a
that you did throughout the year that
you're being punished for the past one
you could have been doing mitah during
that time and you'll be you're
accountable for that therefore the first
day of sukus and throughout sukus when
we
do that gets us off the hook for what's
to is during the time that a person was
doing that they could have been doing
they're liable
for the here is that is a very
significant day on the calendar and in
some level and in some way it gets off a
third what the significance of this
third is this is what we learned about
today we should be to take advantage of
the last day of the year we should be to
take advantage
of and and should be all of you with a
year of good health G
you've just experienced another Torah
class brought to you by Torah
anytime.com