The Debate between Chana & Eli - Likkutei Sichos Rosh Hashanah #1

the yeshiva dotnet okay today we're going to do something a little different we're gonna be learning today and tomorrow before then afterwards Thursday there won't be a shear and we'll take a break till after a Shoshanna cuz Wednesday I'm traveling so we'll have a shear this morning and then tomorrow morning so I just chose a sister a talk of the lubavitcher rebbe but that he gave on Rosh Hashanah that's printed and look at the surface and that's what we learned we'll start it today and based on our chamblee nether we'll finish it tomorrow it's a fundamental concept in that's connected to Rosh Hashanah and davon Inge and the beginning of the year Shoshanna Yom Kippur etc so somebody made copies here just distribute the copies beside them so we could they circus hey look your test page 291 the lubavitcher rebbe has said this syphilis tortoise in yin and affa bring in on rosh hashanah the second day of Rosh Hashanah tops and Lomb evolved youngbae's the restaurant of Salaam evolved which would be 1975 and it's published in his look at the surface volume 19 under Shoshanna it's in judicial translate Rosh Hashanah of of Tichenor Aleph in there after you finished integration Shana Villa safer small but it Selva Ganesh's all carnivals at Ocean is as free as lejana angel Laden or they're not good of hit fill the scientific in Chile but Michigan is significant when I met Azam small on Navi the first day of Rosh Hashanah is a special half Toyota from the beginning of Shmuel the opening of small the book of small small Aleph as he brings in footnote number one from the Gemara Magilla diplomat I love the Commerce's mysterion bacana after of Rosh Hashanah is the story of Hannah so so tomorrow I am Simon tough cough pay Dalit what's the story - who's a man named Al Elkanah he had a wife pnina pnina had a lot of children he had a wife Hannah Hannah the current Hannah was Hannah was not blessed with a child she was very hurt and she grieved it and mourned it and as the pasta continues Ailee the Mishkan at then there was nobody some big fish at a time the Mishkan then was in a place called Shiloh where it stood for 369 years for the first few centuries of the Jewish people in arches throw most of the time the Mishkan was in she light besides a few other locations very brief and then later Schlemmer dovey that slimy would build the first base of McNish but this is before that kana would be the mother of small who would be the one who would coronate shoal as a king and then later dove it as a king so this is before the basin McNish is built and a li her husband would go to Shilla to the Mishkan with the family and one year that's what after he describes is how kana when they went to Shilla she went into the Michigan and she prayed she'd Arvind at length as we're going to describe soon the coin goggle a li thought she was drunk from how he was dominating he gave her most severe buked her you don't call you don't come into the Michigan drunk inebriated that mas I touched a car in are seriously a mesh my life get sober and then come back here and Hannah describes to him that she's not drunk she's in pain because she never had a child and she's pouring out her heart Asha Emily OH Ailee blesses her and indeed the next year she's blessed with a son and she named that boy little baby named small and she says because she made a promise in she Lloyd that if God gives her a child she will dedicate him to Hashem and his service so she names him small kima hashem Schilt if he's like borrowed like shuttle with a mem Shailesh mo l I borrowed him from Hashem like a loan from Hashem because his he really belongs to God that was a promise and Schmuel grows up to become one of the greatest Jews of all of history when the greatest prophets yo Mario says moisture Byron but high enough or small but Karishma he was an equivalent for the status of Moshe and IRA and he becomes the prophet of the generation the leader of the generation and ultimately he would coronate soul as the first king of the Jewish people that didn't work out he would coronate of it and so forth so that's the haftorah of the first day of Rosh Hashanah we do the story of Cana praying being blessed with a child and then giving the Shira saying a song after she was given the child the makovan from clear soft Arabic our game there by a laughs Titus is a data quickly cetera the objective of reading a half tied on any Yom Tov and really all the half toyotas any Shabbos it's just like clear satire what's the objective of cleaning cetera it's me Larsen hi-yah this lawyer says as he says in footnote 3 star the word traitor doesn't mean law the word trade actually comes from the word high raw which is lesson a lesson the purpose of Korea's Authority is to learn from it to glean a lesson in life from it half third is the same purpose like Lisa Taylor she says in three share in the capital urban crime a bar of wood Rahab after it initially was created in lieu of Chris Athena there was a time that they didn't allow the Jews to read the Tyler so what do they call him dude they chose every week you know the inertia cop chapter in na'vi to compensate there was no clear subtitle when i've tied her started they did it because they weren't allowed to read the title fine so they read the na'vi what later once the decree was nullified such a douche maka thing then I've got an olive one so we stayed with both we have the tree citator we have enough trade so the objective of the Australians are just like the objective of Korea cetera as I eat all their food up Lenin are hearing them are very different I even in them shamisen and I'm shocked the objective of the creatinine State is that a Jew should learn from it a lesson in the avoid in the life of a Jew whether it's in the Shabbos that after it is being read well the yom tov is being read no it's not just Tom like Terry Dubrow it's not just a book of history to learn some story that happened that's what the Sawyer says sorry says the word trainer tells you the genre of the book if it's just a book of history then it fails because of Rama being who lived 480 years how many stories do we know about him over hundred eighty years I mean 175 years he lived on genady is Yaakov lived on during forty seven years I'm gonna we know a few stories six story seven stories eight stories nine stores all them lived close to a millennium how many stories do we know we know that he aged from a tree that's know we know that he ate from a tree it's a kind of good rate then the age from a tree and it was it what did he do for a thousand years I don't know he was busy with what Christ I don't know okay the point is so it's not stomm Jews were in Egypt for two hundred and ten years the traitor sometimes the whole part shows relations based beginning to end is fifteen hundred years fifteen hundred years in a parsh the point of trader is it has history in it but that's what the Sawyer says toyota's begin the oily it's a lesson it's a blueprint for life that's what it is it's a roadmap for the human journey through a difficult world through a challenging world so the half theta is also the same objective we don't read it just to read a story or some other navara but rather as a lesson in life zoe has been your Nino our four PS the time for husbands of nafta evolution is well Hannah sniff could give an additional aunt out a bit after that come over Camaros in there a very definitely diminishes shana or knoweth comma become heroes belong the Casals say why did they Institute hang on Rosh Hashana why this story the Gomorrah says a megillah' la muralla that we do have so Rashi says over there Rashi and Iran because has all had a tradition that Hanna was good she was remembered under Shoshana the Gomora says him a sectarian interfere Aleph learns out from sukham that three people were blessed under Shauna with a child now that the child was born in Russia China but under Shauna as whereas she puts it there in Gomorrah the Gazzara was establish that they should have a child this was an Sora and Rocco and fauna and that's what all three we mean under Sharma the story of you saying everything is Nix under Shama so what's the finish so you can read any story you sing any story you're saying any story could be neshama it's an interesting harder Rashi says over then the Gamora I think Rashi says that there's a Koren came before sham inertia Shana and there was a sailor established under Shoshana decree that they were going to have children I guess there was something special on Rosh Hashanah by all three the Gemara learns a lot from sook him from the the notion that says there's a share and pocket varsham pakka so talkin the curious afraid of Rosh Hashanah we read about Sora having a child and and it have try to read about Hannah having a child the second of Tydeus have about Rahul Rahul move a carbonara from your Mia so McCoy that's the correct connection the connection is that Sandman was somehow remembered on Rosh Hashanah he says that's true but like everything in Toyota the flight is not just the story shoes nomination but it contains many lessons in the void of a Jew ferocious Sun and many lessons in generally the Gemara says in prophecy says in 6 footnote 6 commandments as well karma Xhosa sagara-san Akhil amar shamanic Rider car the Mars has many great Huaraz you could learn out from the circum of the story of hunters finish on its general movie bowel does the avoidable Sanjay Brock - pika - Hannah but doesn't then you could accuse from that after Idaho solution Kanishka ll is given it Phillip shili his mr. Brell i'ma as the limit equally from that after I'd have been again evade the phone in diminishes Shawn isn't Willis Connor over flatly the day of his brain surgeon shallow as Phyllis Kahn is given below Shoshana what was the avoid if the main objective enough trade is a lesson and I avoid and avoid over drew the service of a Jew what was the main avoided that brought the Hannah being remembered it was heard Avenue she came to the Mishkan hurts feelers prayed and that's the home that could the why we weeded understood Shana because she was remembered under Shana through her prayer so it's logical to assume that the main lesson in this after know about that void of a Jew in recession is connected to what to tiller and that's we're you learned a great lesson of the a freighter from Phyllis Kahn especially there's a very interesting opinion in the shallow and the reason we read in addition is cousin happen on their shoe shop not only she was remembered under Shoshanna snaps I what says she was remembered not just like you say everything is remembered under stress honors honors look at the day of the head of the year Hashanah is the head of the year the marce is missing no so Shalom lemon Rosh Hashanah Yom Kippur British on ecosaver Yom Kippur your Co same oh so there's a law says it's much more than that she was remember next to me closely actually dap in the register on the story happened on rosh hashanah she came to the Michigan on Rosh Hashanah she went in so it was actually a traumatic a story so we're reading something to happen and return an exhaust she davon whenever she'd Arvind and Hashem the sudden initial shortener to accept a prayer this is this what the shell losses in seven miss Xterra Shoshanna shall I deflation who the Likud Russia's Castle y'all cut Romania opposite Valerie Shah who shall obey Sally lyrical that's why he says late today in Gao could sure money the meddler says on the plastic that Alcona used to go up from time to time to Sheila that it was alia Borrego that he used to go for Pesach and truest and soukous and there's a whole story at that time many Jews would not be overly regal but al Connor would go with a whole inter arch with whole family and he made it very exciting and he would stop in every community and there was a lot of food than fanfare and celebration and it inspired and it inspired all the Jews to make Ali lerigot and in that context Rhonda came to Michigan so from that Madras it seems that kana did it during one of the three among type in pace actuals and circus and the Madras Tucker says over there that it was I think at saris Lewis but the shelah brings another repeater but deposit doesn't say clearly when it was but there's a lot brings another repeating that it was actually on Rosh Hashana and that's the track she was remembered under Shoshanna so this is the introduction that objective of the appetite is to learn something and here then it could is that feel of ham that mean is for staying back to my beard in them supervision Phyllis kana as free at a Leah Cohen Iran denominator Shakira while its fillers given in an - from a debater Saliba who noted fr-s cadet at mas eightish the current game on hannity of him cannot in moved em can fit lawyer Dhoni the Ashby has now she live near sham as I write so first we have to explain the story that happens in the end a half Tyler what's the story the Navi says Hana is a broken woman she's broke she's a sad woman she's there's more swaram if anybody needs is more mother three copies the doves page 291 page 291 in that safer and we have another two here page 259 for you oh yeah okay if anybody needs us more copies so Hana is very very sad she doesn't have children she comes into the Michigan and she's darvany and it says Hanuman de Barras a Libra she's speaking to her heart with her Hardwick I love Louisa May can hear her voice Ailee looks at her and he has this impression that she's drunk she's intoxicated and Ailee is very upset and the additives to rebuke Atmos esta : how long are you gonna today's day and age you would say how long you're gonna be an addict how long you're gonna get wrong coming to the Michigan drunk a serious yesh may life get rid of the alcohol get rid of the wine connoisseur as Loy you making a mistake ke chakra surakameth I'm a woman who is a broken person yah in which a hellacious CC I did not drink wine I did not drink beer did not drink alcohol the Esprit has not she live now huh I'm pouring out my heart before she and that's when ad responds that our gem should fulfill his request and give you a child De La Hoya is knit fresh standing the whole story seems very strange Aleph V come to us as a leha Kyon's a la buena Sato's mina court sir ellicott sir you don't mean I cut silicates it means a person can make a mistake but sometimes you make a mistake saliva Dada doing it's from one extreme to another extreme and started their Canon as he's missed Parliament as vicious and nefesh hurt a Gorger main toesies are Shakira how is this possible Haley's the Kohen Gadol of the generation it's a great person he's looking at a woman who's pouring out her heart Asha so sometimes people make an error in judgment it's a normal thing we're human were subjective we don't see the whole picture but how is it that he could make such a mistake from one extreme ton of extreme somebody is pouring out their Davenant ashram with a thesis on nefesh he says the expert is now free and what does he see on earth all these seasoned nurses she's drunk she smashed his inebriated she's intoxicated start telling her why he coming here drunk how that such an error happened we all know we sometimes see a person who's broken was very introspective was experiencing a lot of grief a lot of pain they're pouring out their heart even if you just have a basic sense of sensitivity you can recognize the difference somebody who smashed and drunk frivolous somebody who's going through something very serious now this is how the such a mistake happen and he adds and foot not knowing something very interesting la hired the alienists mana you see how I'm so fertile you sit all Rashi says in the story that that day a Li was appointed to be the chauffeur the judge turbo as man him who you man he gaya at that time they were the man higham they were like the leaders of the generation so a li wasn't just a finer yield a Korean a coin gobble he was considered the ma'aming of the generation the gam Chaffetz Tom had a dyin solace Lea's done de nemours lammeter Shabbos da feud Shekar shouldn't even be Maha Shiva son didn't I'm battalions of our Vasu even star much - what's the main quality of a Seifert to be sensitive to truth to examine who the person is to tune into the issues at hand that's the aside dawned in MS lemon tea always looking for the MS never just to judge something externally with your own bias with your own subjective lenses that stammers - certainly when you're in the show fertile degeneration the manic of the arm is as English Alice chauffeured should be a master you flirt with Turkish more but they say me like demonic so even a regular person you would expect to have better judgment certainly I'm a strong to be able to look at a woman who hasn't been blessed with children and as a result of that is so much in pain and she pours out art to God no Lika teller is drunker get out of here oh yes very good very good that's the taste is very good taste is more basta ya face western Shabbos yeah and Bob us Aloha a decline in Bellagio communion among Chava davay Dawson Lee Baca Shari Abruzzo deliver and Sawyer it says that cryin him generally are connected to the world of thought there avoiders silence and with rocks and olive the love iane were musical they would sink the cayenne him there avoid that was done without a sound it was done bahasa which represents more qivana the gamma p nicola had a in Jana Marshall who've do Lula Vedas a carbonyl shemar shava occur baza hula shame she should very massive Elizabeth while there is a Bashar avoiders improv they were designated for the car bonus buy car bonus it's one of the voices that Amash of a' is fundamental some slight discrepancy a microvia disqualifies welcome you don't have that with other avoid this of russia i'm colleen is making a carbon right and he thinks that he's gonna eat it Tuesday boom ice ice carbon the marsh of is a fundamental thing and says I wish after carbon has to be l'chaim she should varam and the other avoid this is reka Locker Kabbalah causes for major avoiders so that's also part I up acai acai Alpine Ziggler the Cayenne is very much tuned into my server and yet here Haley displays the opposite the opposite the opposite of anything that we would expect from a chauffeured from a client base I feel them as Olga finna nas bother me as a alien tamaak tum' toes even if you'll find an explanation how a person like a li would make such an error okay you'll find it's not alternate movement for was that self moving in them in Tara see the ha Filipinos Bahama Tamayo they did better cost of Alaska's come of a camel are Valbuena gay a Lea kaya in trader generally were very careful not just to embarrass anybody even a Bahama the Gemara sedima vastra even a disgrace of a Bahama - Mia the Taylor didn't want to say says in Paris no yes by a machine nano tahiry's beginning up so can we learn tomorrow you have to have a good reason some lesson some important fundamental issue that the trader has to say it why is this relevant just to bring God that Ailee was clueless Toyota wants to teach something gimel they bothers reactionary Lila Shakira Ailee thought she was a shaker for us at Ailey up give right boots on ace busy and estate filler we - she touched up a leash a meter spear washing ham toner and the lighted aftermaths examines a missiles areas feel of a base of iron you know let it come into a Myshkin drunk Haley didn't talk didn't interrupt it says a leash O'Meara spear Rashi says he watched her mouth he waited like it says what other summer aside over by Yaakov Yaakov waited for a leash Raymond doesn't mean he watched her mouth it means he waited till she finished her hold Arvin incas cana da van for a while she spoke tosh em there she made the famous nether that if you're going to see my pain I will dedicate this child you'll give me as Arron Asham you'll give me a child that will dedicate him - um all the days of his life and after she finished a li turned to her really see somebody came in and toxicated you say heaven please madam this is not the right place I can't comment to the Michigan she'll a drunk he didn't do that he waited gimel from them Alamos Musa from all these questions it's quite obvious as a li attended Barack has a Liautaud petrovna thoughts recorded in portions in that are Shakur in Dominion at Villa for more this you could see a Lee didn't just see a woman and thought she was just drunk she went to a bar she finished a bottle of Zechs a nine-second 96% alcohol were two bottles of French wine and she came into the Michigan it's not what happened because then you would have all these questions rather when it says he saw her drunk it's a particular type of drunkenness a particular type of intoxication thus mayn't it will be who's going to explain this maned the Baathist it's filler function is given in an - from here basilica's Paulo is this at Philly it's a them in a medium assisted caned overheard sorry the means I'm midlife na Hashem be based on sham Candela commence if tests he saw that she was diving in a specific way it says here bacillus bowels she was dominating excessively and a leaf fell that the way she was Davin Inc was something that was inappropriate and that's what he was expressing with the words shickers when commas and furtive them is Vespa this novel inertia Connor told daily you're wrong she understood what he meant I'm pouring out my soul when they're here bacillus Paulus abundant mcswish's on a fish is this Netanya for sickness and filler not added are by diagonal isn't Villa Haley felt that her Davin is inappropriate it's called an impact sakata Dominic I secured the key domina it's a chickadee Kedarnath not the right way to Davin the way he saw darvany so can explain to him what was going on and this type of governing it's not a she christened Avenue on the contrary it's a very profound way of governing when the city - Isis with Phyllis Hamlet's addition Shana while the Tino - emission a Leah Cohen and Hanna that in the motion at Philippa based on Sam get refreshed and in them token Chloe fulfil the scanner for cometh full of British Hashanah once we can understand this will be able also to understand the connection of Phyllis Hannah to Rosh Hashana not just in the sense of that she was remembered in Russia Shana or it happen in Russia Shana but rather as a blueprint for the void of Rosh Hashanah because they exchanged the debate that goes on between alien Hannah it's not just a debate between two people it's a debate that actually captures and gives a perspective not only on the Domenic of Hannah but also on our Dominique on Rosh Hashanah and many - kiddo look come on as will be explained right right yeah it says here bacillus species so that here bacillus Paulo yeah we'll come back to it this is just the general bloop the you know the build the foundation be negated Phyllis finishes Shana give fitments way in yharnam half clip if you look at it philosopher Shoshanna you see a paradox Rosh Hashanah is the yahud enough outlets our co-domain be looking him Ashley's your son as the day of judgement about all the needs of a person whether its needs in roughly a spiritual start of spiritual needs or fill matter illness via state says into Hilla click Abbas Haider chauffeur my castle am cargando he quickly is Rahul Mishra clock a akov on this day you blow Shia and he says it's high clear all who wish but lilica Yaakov from here the Gemara learns out of mrs. Terry Shoshanna that Rosh Hashanah is a I'm Amishman but it also says hi clear although what does hi Clarissa Harlowe literally it means it's a statue it's a hike it's a law for the Jewish people but there's also the interpretation holy is slow for Martian actually a knee lesson cookie is an expression in miss Leigh give me how to refrain Lee give me the bread that I need made that Dino mich birth of miserliness Cal oh it's awesome gosh mom so Huckle if I clear all not just it's a law for the Jewish people that's the day that the hike the amount of bread which includes all material needs money and pernessa and sustenance and health and all that in terms of housing every person's physical life all the material aspects that's the day of high cholesterol and then this mishpat lakea curve is the Dino Mishra Tiffany marushin him before Sun Empress Menen gilja look who's been option so the pasta concludes both quickly as Rollo is the hook the hatchery fini like some hooky the amount of bread every person gets and bread here is a metaphor for all the needs of a person miss faithlyn decay a curve is a miss but how much Eliquis will be revealed in the purse alakay Yaakov missed with lelik a how much Allah caused the gilja look husband that's also a dinner Shoshanna how much I love course you'll be able to experience during the year that's basically the spiritual life of the person the two are of course connected Hobart alia but it's 2 sets 2 and young one is quickly so on is miss Berkeley archaic with the fire Bettman and the philosophy Shoshanna I've burner hyoma Zena or nicer animal that's why if you'll open up the what does a Jew ask he asks for blessings connected with children all issues connected to family Shia which is all issues connected to life health life and misery which is all issues connected to sustenance Varna Kaiama Zion which basically includes that these are the umbrella issues that most people have not most every person asks your family you your children life sustenance bonus high Amazon but we also ask Krishna Shan and others for gashes also farts Locker and everything connected to ruin is mish with lilyc a active for the Gili Allah curse but not generation under a whole year yeah yeah yeah mish mythology Yaakov is that you Scioscia to be able to have transparency to be able to feel this year oneness to be able to feel a little close to be able to feel the oneness of the world yeah that when you learn a mind man look at the Toyota cheetahs also play again it's as the source of mother ah what in the Land of Nod yeah the land in life yeah and when you're in the airport - yeah when you're in the airport - when you're in the office - we're trying to make a sale - in other words a person should be able to have the gilja look husband option to be able to feel the connection and the oneness in their life that's a gift and as we always learn these layers and layers and layers and layers and layers and layers endless so that's also missed with lilica Yaakov yeah Lee does that s'what element of Rosh Hashanah and in many ways that's the classic Rosh Hashanah at least from one perspective that will be discussed it's yeah I'm Adam is a day of judgment the judge is deciding what the year is gonna look like so basically you want a petition you want to you want to ask you on a beg you want to ask for compassion you want to dive and that's one element of Russia shot but the interesting thing is if you look at the at the actual text of the Hazara Shoshanna what are they discussing Rosh Hashanah take a look at this - Trish - oh you always know what our young - focus that's the text and Rick Mercer what's the theme of Rosh Hashana there does it say once you had did doesn't say from one same I didn't minister the theme is the sim our malloy Allah eylem collaborative Aida leader is to be a do as the Nicholas Ave de veau cicadas b'stilla for Nisha Shana by stating mocked masters and the members to not smell on the other hand it's knowing didn't main avoid the racial genre and the primary avoid is expressed in the davines of Rosh Hashanah it's not just in the Domini it's the whole issue Shana but it's expressed primarily the Avenue is that some aesthetic used to call the night of Rosh Hashanah core anoxia not the night of Coronation the Jew coordinates the burnished love them as a king blushing huzzah the Gemara says a mastectomy Shoshanna dr. Zion and a foie modality Shakuni Alicia Hashem tells the Jewish people I want you to make I'm asking you please make me a king over you only miss off with Phyllis Rosh Hashana Molloy Harlem coolyback vadhaka hey now Sarah Lawrence bicker bicker Arthur wife about dagger you know Zack evade the COPO key at the PLT we see what's the theme of your McCullers in a sum of a professional occasional mellow smokeless tobacco masala and how do you finish the brush you always know how do they finna borrow Fatah shrimp Mela I'll call orit's Makka dishes OVI massacre so yes there is in the most of of Rosh Hashanah there's a few references you have a thorough search as a thyroid nurse right that everything comes everything comes in front of you and you remember everything and you decide everything it's not ignored and we have a 20 peuta Maher and all of our be cautious but but you see in the in the breakfast of when Esther themselves in the might've in the chakras in the minister most of includes much more cozy of the mouth ears of corn is dry for us and even in Musa you have the theme of mouthiest and was gonna let any of the theme of Shaffers Vitalis hemella the Cibola smoke who seized after dissimilar from little bita close the theme of coronating a king and accepting his mouth hose always comes through a lure it requires a movement emotion an experience of bittle of submission of surrender to the king the rest embers memorizing gansan hunted sumela bisman filled garnered the ignited sinus who dare bit aloof nowadays by mellitus on anima - tada what causes what inspires the king to accept the coronation what is the coronation of the king it's basically the nation says we want you we're here for you we want you to be our leader the king recognizes the absolute submission and surrender of all of the subjects if he our MELAS as they would they would scream you have it in the HTML of David Loy lamb and their Navi or other times that order represents the time that the whole nation looks to the king and they say we want you ain't la nawm ella ella ato to the point that the person at that moment is not so conscious of his own desires in his own needs the focus is I want you as the king but the unions and the started assassin so it looks like you have her two themes that are contradictory what is richest Rama what is vicious honest it's not about me the Jennifer got base mistaken a bit Obatala sumela his men need be gathered subtracting on bettin making Aidan 18 it's Elohim for society nor Donvan my hot ignited sinus well dusters are a fillable a distribution is the Kazakh Alaska's commas are coming again gosh means the Cabal cautious for saves is the akela didn't finish Hashanah came over by Gauss my - what can you do / state in two canoes I her as divas baton Bahama to keep order I've Messina kappa hiatus way no Lahiya this is from Zoya pretty sharp design and Vaclav inverse Ryan have have never saw dog asking for food Gib Gib was attractive in zip or needs a conditioner I believe there is sending the back cautious of Turkey or the my language dog given a noose except villedieu disguise el Caminos Oh once I send my virus there Moses this man Watson if Millie Abba cautious with hooli was for them is for standing as the Bokashi stuff on Zion nitnem it's at Kabbalah cell to about the a burst of gas and as Eden veterans and its lost him I eaten better than a combination to today's a blow his book they commit crimes and I'm not Sonali not in there Nathan hot i Robson where hair edition it's awesome of a caution the safe for names I have monville enormous cavern Zion in them telephone davon and as the a burst ozone gedman's einat's Rafa was there by father dismissal filling the egg in him it sees migration versus felt in on since I'm in the mid Daffy resigned Duda tsunami them didn't fit in them tumbler Sunni alaikum was father to foolish then they can Biddle was a struggle Dagenham Aziz ah yeah yeah yeah we have our two completely different experiences given even know what we go given even a metaphor it's not a perfect metaphor but just to illustrate the idea we don't have today really the concept of mouth hosts you know we live we live in a democracy but for most of history people grew up with a king was an absolute ruler well we don't even understand what it means even in England you have the Queen but it's not the it's ceremonial you know it's good for tourists for Buckingham Palace tourism and you know it's ceremonial it's the people it's the spirit it's not the absolute power all the other places you have kings or queens but in for most of history the monarch had absolute power but even today by us you don't have a king you have a president who's democratically elected and four years later he's gone we could still I think understand the marshal just just understand something we just uh give it again it's not a perfect metaphor but I think I'll illustrate it the president the new President of the United States of America is nominated the go to elections everyone votes and the victor emerges victorious and it's the inauguration day their celebrity come frailer in washington or wherever the country and the city with inauguration of that particular king or queen or president of prime minister or leader and the person gets up and everybody is cheering if he hemella or whatever the appropriate expression ah save the whatever the appropriate expression of that culture is in huh when after he delay crawls up comes up there's a way mr. president mr. president you know i'm my block in front of my house there's a pothole and every day i trip over there okay if you're the leader of this country could you take care of the pothole gotta fix it okay so let's hope that he comes out you know but shane VI and he comes out of one piece something is off what's off he's my president he's responsible for the country doesn't want to do it himself get somebody you're right he's the president he's ultimately responsible the buck stops here but as I say everything has a time and everything has a place today is the day of inauguration today is not the day ask not what your country can do for you ask what you can do for your country today is asked not what the king can do for you ask what you can do for the king that's the focus tomorrow coming make an appointment with the bureaucrats hopefully you'll have Mazel the bureaucracy won't be that bad and get all the potholes on your block fixed and if you can already change the sewage system and the cesspool system and a lot of other things might only get a few lights up it would all be nice and good it's not just its off time in a tough place they don't just come back tomorrow the Tyson is a different title it's a different experience the question is if it's about you or it's about me it's a very different question what stage am I in you come to a come to a hassan by his my wedding under the hope or dancing yeah you go to the circle in Aqaba say by the way yeah the investment you made last year you still owe me you have to give me seven thousand dollars in this right you may be a thousand percent right you may be a million percent right but you just wolf you just walk like for ten minutes don't think about you not yourself not that you're bad not that you don't need to $7000 you do you do it's as hopeless as wedding it's a different word what's a start of a melody coronate a king what's the focus the focus is on the mela millions of subjects would come that's how it was in in mouses busts of Adam and again we're not getting into the king was a despot or a nice person many of the Kings were crazy tyrants that's a different I coulda but even if you have the best most beautiful King there what's the focus the whole nation comes together and say we want you long live our King what's belt at that moment is the zeitgeist of the nation the spirit of the people embodied in their leader especially when it's a genuine leader who's a selfless leader sure I mean I still look Sam after Sonny nice look something Morris hasn't heard is what's a real leader leader somebody he captures the spirit of the people the soul of the people that's what meet real leadership is real leadership therefore is selfless leadership is not I'm gonna control you that's not leadership that's called dictatorship that's not a malice that emotion MAOIs is really Broxson it's that this person really lives the people the rambam says are Mellor who lave kolka hollister oh he's the heartbeat of the nation at filter high he's the heart of the people waha still there were great great tyrants and dictators some of the worst in history who understood this so well yeah what did they manage to do they managed to manipulate the nation and they became the embodiment of the nation and the whole youth was enamored by them and captured by them and swallowed up by them they became a replacement for Tati mommy God religion truth morality ethics and they used that nation pride and stolz and identity to do the worst things the pinnacle of this was Germany in the 1930s yes but Germany more effectively in terms of the youth the pride of the youth yes but Russia Russia didn't do bad he's not saying you shouldn't ask God for you requests you shouldn't ask but the record of Kabbalah samasya is when the nation loses its individuality and they become connected to that one unifying reality which was random anarchy again an our culture we're very suspicious of all these things because of what happened in history so we are highly we focus very much on individual we don't want to give up our individualism I'm talking American culture Western culture I'm not about individual communities right and people who are become very suspicious because this could be manipulated very easily there's a there's a corrupt guy and of course everyone gives up their individuality so that's why I understand this the the suspicion that it conjures but I want you to understand in a CUDA in the most ideal beautiful way right a real leader galvanizes the spirit of the nation and in that moment in that moment when he is coronated or when he is living up to that moment of being the great leader what's experienced by the people is not themselves and their needs what's experienced by the people is their oneness that's embodied in the spirit of the nation that comes to their connection that comes from their connection with this leader who brings them all together and represents a certain ideal when somebody now emerges and says but I have a pothole you're right you have a pothole but it's extremely inappropriate it's mama SH out of context it's means you you really don't get it you're not part of this so that's the question of Rosh Hashanah on one hand what sirisha Shawna Chatham Lee honey Elisha Malloy column kaliba hidaka what would be then you could then avoid over there then I couldn't have read over there ask not what God could do for you ask what you can do for God that's the nuts not it's not about minutes it's not about them it's not about minutes it's what's what's the most of Rosh Hashanah when a person is in a state of complete bitl to the king so it's not about my wills my desires with what I want even Rashmi is certainly not gosh but even luckily it's not that's why this lawyer is so short and we're gonna have to understand what this all means this is says that people under sunny and kipper are asking for their food it's like the dogs that's what he calls them clover what did the dog wants one thing more snacks more snacks more snacks to stop thinking about yourself start thinking about this you know so it's very interesting Ziya but who's the one who spoke about that Phil is for personal things also this has all the same sense I'll put it into the text so you could say just do it the percussionist achievements at Cibola in other words Hashem says ask for your needs are a Shoshanna but that's not the preferred abstract is that a person they what they want it's not just to be like a robot and do it because Hashem said and you really don't feel your needs that's not the havona they said that this is us man erupts and familiar about cultures in other words so time to feel it and to experience the need so what is what is Richard Shawna is about me was about him on one side you want Assumption give you your needs and that means you feel yourself you feel your voids you feel your passions you feel the potholes in your life you feel that you experience it and that's what you're asking for and for that you have to experience yourself and your identity on the other hand you say Western Accord of Rosh Hashanah chat omelette annihilation table honey alaikum is the complete submission the complete surrender you're my king it's actually not about me well how you to come a flagon this all Bashar Lisbon again that's Phyllis for color so Nakula now you could really ask the same question about the whole year by the trilla from Serena Esther is the misspelled we'll call a midlife Nahum Ella the Gomorra says in Shabbos that basement asks are you standing in front of the king different than a whole day than the rest of the day but stay Indyk Philomela determinate arrays verizon came to newer from aghanim at sears personal stands in front of the king it's not a time for self-expression bhisma Geffen and Gomorrah as I feel a massive above market cardamom Alka is that wealth has come to Englishmen I prefer higher the Kumari says a story in mississauga that there was a fellow who is making signs in front of the king and was considered treason in other words not only speaking disrespectfully but even just doing his own thing why because in front of the mela there's a complete sense of reverence of war on saddam in the middle man cave a given Fayed in Eden in Osaka trilogy in base blockers and Soyuz 4 station Australis struck off and yet there's 12 middle breakfast of smyrna answer is all about your own needs so you're standing in front of the king and that's a very real experience that's what da Vernon is i'ma the Phenom L looks different than the rest of the day and as he says in 27 racial sonars admirers are consuming coma the fella ain't losses mum came the moment of Schwinn Astra's like a moment of awe and reverence you're coming in right here and you lose yourself but said no no don't lose yourself you gotta talk about your needs and its market laner you could discuss anything you want whatever you want from your dentist appointments to your anxiety from your bills to your stress from your children to your job from your marriage to your health situation and everything in between and every bra so really you can add whatever you want by the way as long as it's part of the theme of that process that's a logical tomorrow this is not like a robot just ask for you need just say the words it's about a person feeling and experience me my passion my needs my feelings a guerrilla fighter the same paradox openness is fair my grace is sufficient Phil is mr. Sherman's Phyllis collar shop but there's really a big difference between the Domenic of Rosh Hashana and the Domenic of all year but so uh Sean not that after definition is the a barista caballos of the MLS for spirit on meta Medina the fight is done the bittle for the banana dinner - militiamen - as as heretics honest is Dada mad series and it's Rock'em Khalifa Dan Hsia Medina Bosmans a fight on the mellah as his nervous Bashar's man state mom-ish Laflamme Ellis that was a nickel as the guns amid scenes from the Madden isn't it Kings upstanding nose isn't river from the mela Bashar Assad man died first masters and the members do not smell then there is now a rumor man up catering of an another sama Lucia father died grass Adair brittle AB it'll be tactless in Vulcanus hurts it I said the Melek Elaine stoutish deshyla we came in in Nizam lots of bettin the melons Megan egg in it silicon meaning a whole year it's after the coronation in our Marshall it's the day after the president Lahav de was inaugurated so now there is of course still a relationship and a connection but now you're running a country you're running a country this is what the country is say don't ask what the country needs just ask what it what do you mean you're a leader the day after I come in I tell you a this is what I need this is what I want I got that true when you're standing in front of the King mom-ish that flex - era it's recognizable that the Macias of the mid dinner the mid sees of the country is not independent it's under the king so there's a respect as a reference but why did you come into the appointment you came in to discuss your needs I can understand that that's the day after the coronation Richard Shan is something else Rosh Hashanah is the day of kabbalah samal house mr. sean is the daesh atomic annihilation then the focus is what not how the mela is a dean in the country how the mela has a leader of the country the focus in kabbalah some alkyls is the mela himself especially in the NEM show because you have to inspire the king to become a king he's completely aloof like we always learn a mouth loose is it symptom Malthus is a dissent Varsham to be a mela it requires a tremendous symptom a tremendous concealment of energy to be a mela Comella means there's a world is a relationship with the world that summated movavi saints of Calaca make a legend like we always learned in the my Maruyama look at the Turner so what you need to inspire inspire the desire for the relation what inspires the desire what as far as the desire is the complete connection the complete authentic relationship with there's nothing outside of the relationship itself I want you so I ask not what you do from rather the focus is autonomy local art not how you can help me or you can treat now you can enhance my life which is all great stuff but that's the next step and yet we see so that's why the paradox of dominating a whole year exists but it's but it's it could that be explained and more easier terms than Rosh Hashanah when you have mama SH - polar opposites that seem one extreme to another extreme okay we'll stop here we'll continue measure sham tomorrow's first and then the conscious - cancel sighs Beth mallacoota zackin okay I mentioned the air because I was in the airport yeah you have to know what Kabbalah some alko's means we're not used to that concept we always think in terms of me what I want what I need what I want you understand you understand Kabbalah hemolysis is a it's a very a delirium a person is not thinking about his needs is that possible yeah this is the 12 Broca's the 12 middle Broca's his personal requests the first three and last three knots first three we praise our M the last three we thank from RIT's say till the end and till hemella Tillich a Lacroix - American but from at Aquinas hwadam das yeah the next 12 Broca's they're called the 12 middle Broca's I'm sorry is it's all Bokashi ostraka individual and collective with the wisdom or forgiveness or redemption or health or par NASA or gula or anti-semitism - hatred so this has the same paradox you should ask about every German Astra you're standing in front of the cane you know that even make movements with your hands gestures that represents any separation and then you start talking about yourself and yeah you're feeling it so you'd put the deposition it's not the same Shiloh Lucretia sure cause a whole year so ready the king there's an office president is in office yeah you're coming for an appointment you're right you're standing in front of the king you're not just an independent person running a show but you're asking for your needs that's makes sense makes much more sense but if you're Shana is the day of Coronation it's the moment of Coronation the moment of Coronation I told you the marshal the King gets up and everyone is screaming long live the king and you come and you say I have a pothole it's such a stimulus winner the whole issue Shana is caballes amaavas you have all the pure terminus there's plenty plenty of stuff so they know heimeau saw so much left personalization is like a really safe place look Isla Lahaina we're not we're not done yet but the soil is so sharp the Sawyer says all ocean it's like a dog in other words the dog when he says a dog he's not cursing he's like look basically you're just like on a level of an animal the dog is very loyal but for one reason he wants food I mean you have dogs who say you have dogs will do acts of sacrifice for the master personalities but he says the point is the dogs loyalty at least in many cases is just give give give half half half so basically my loyalty to guard is I know you're the master you're the boss you have the Paycheck you've got the money in that count of course I'm loyal to you so the Sawyer is very disparaging of that it's like really that's a relationship and yet now that we say okay yeah you're right but many of us who are in a low level that's what we that's true our relationship with the car is just because he's the boss you're right I have no loyalty outside of them but he says that's not the case cuz the Khazar themselves establish this they put this into the fabric of rosh hashanah that it's the right time to ask requests and it's likely so although I'm rich mythology aku and there's different things we do for that then we speak about it so that means it's it's part of the nobility of Rosh Hashanah it's not just you know but the oven if you're not on a higher level okay so that's the question where how did the two really converge that's the the tension that we remain here with that we will address to disperse no no not yet not yet this current no the coronation happens every year every Shoshanna so to speak God says we're done yet brand-new presidential election every year not just presidential monarch monarchy we have a presidential election every year a VHS roll is very similar to the Jewish system so they do it very often that's why I was just saw there's so many elections so I once heard a shear from review a bessa love a check of a JB salivate check your shibori he said a tape-recording she said that when he was a child he learned in a city called he lived in a city called a Slavic cos Slavic ha Slavic it's a it's a slaw which is a city in belarus belarus lithuania his father was the robber emerges elevation was the robbed of her Slavic its rakaat oh so he was the prime seller matrix part but the city was a hobbit ski city but the the rob was a seller a miss Sullivan emerges elevate Rick was the oldest son of a Bryan brisket lady came to America became the receive of a Benedict economy when he passed away his son will be are Chabert took over her be achieved of was his song grandson of her Khayyam he was named after his great-grandfather debase I'll a view of crimes father abusive life so he took over his father of mush but her moisture was a double-cross Slavic so rubbish a bear I heard this a recording from him he said that his Muhammad was Alabama to malama so he said interesting thing he said the ones that his father caught the teacher learning Tanya with the boys he's following a very upset and his father told her I am they went days ago young tough to doc I am too brisk and he told her Brian he said that the Shyam called him in after and he says do let and Tanya Civet it's and it's coming hi I'm salivate Rick told his grandson you make sure to learn Tanya you're gonna need it interesting huh - father used to teach look at the tale in the summer in Boston yeah I heard from a beggar neck huh yeah you went yeah this pressure plate have a special place in his heart no questions so uh so he said so he said in this year he was talking to Tom made them that before Shoshanna he said that he said like this he said I learned about Rosh Hashana in all the soiree I know what it says in Russia Sean and Bob Lee and you shall me you know he's like literally Shiva I know but babbling son I know you saw me Rishi darshan Sharma I know it by heart almost and I know what they were showing him series your son I know what the huronian say Rosh Hashanah I know this Ephraim was the same as your son I know the Rambam I read and he went through a list that he you know he read everything that says it Hashanah but he says but the appreciation of what Rosh Hashanah is I got from Lakota Toyota and he said from that teacher when I was eight years old that teach this is our teacher at every Shoshanna in class looked at us and he said what's happening tonight so we said it's Rosh Hashanah so our teacher said that someone said Vic used to say this is why you heard it when I said before I heard it from him that it's a mother used to say that it's coronation night so he would turn to us and say who is who has to be coronated service of aces I was a smart boy as I said Nicholas the Tsar of Russia was Nikolai Romanov he was ultimate ultimately killed by the Bolsheviks in 1917 him his wife all the kids they murder them but he was desired nicholas ii so one of us allergic was a little child early 1900s Nikolai was the Tsar she says Nicholas she says my teacher and her slavich look at since I submit I connect which means he's no king he's no king which is interesting you have a little of poor Jew and a shtetl doesn't have a few ruble probably to spare you had the Tsar's in there Hammett arch palaces and Petersburg were the wealthy from the wealthiest families in the world yeah they are canning he says besides he was already here ready we already coronated him as a couple of years ago what do we have to coronate him again so he was not impressed with my with my answer and then he said tonight we're going to court with every session tonight we're gonna coronate the master of the world a chef and he says and who's gonna coronate them who's gonna coronate he says my Mohammed looked and said come Yankel de Schuster come ankle the shoemaker and Szell Szell leg the Schneider's Elling the tailor and he went through the names and the baker and the innkeeper is he went through all the RMA he the Lahaul the poor Druze and how slavich he says they're the ones who are gonna coronate the king of the universe so missile range exert Cara Knotts enacts coronation inauguration idea inauguration so that's a feeling of complete complete oneness complete Bibble complete surrender complete submission but then there's the opposite focus look higher yeah yeah yeah the crown you put on the king and and the whole nation so to speak become subsumed in that moment of oneness of oneness which as I said we're set we're allergic to these concepts because it's been so exploited by dictators but in the ideal world we're talking about Hashem and the ideal world this is the this is the real power of a people the unifying spirit of a nation when it's really based on oneness not based on manipulation and terror and exploitation and abuse and etc so I'm saying the West went to the opposite extreme the other side of Rosh Hashanah though as we say yeah that that's the question that's this question of the circle will continue tomorrow okay is Russia this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate