The Subconscious Sin - By Rabbi YY Jacobson

[Music] Pasha's vayikra is often a parsha that people recoil from because it gets very complicated and much of it seems completely irrelevant nowadays but really if one takes the time and the effort and delves in to parshas vayikra the beginning of safer hacker bonus the book of sacrifices and offerings it is not only fascinating on an intellectual level but also on an emotional level on a psychological level and on a spiritual level and one can really glean infinite insights into elements that are practical till our very Melin our very day life because although we don't bring physical sacrifices or offerings today we haven't for close to 2,000 years the theme that the parsha represents verse-by-verse still challenges us and speaks to us today and today I want to employ and discuss one example of that and partially ikura generally a brief introduction is necessary there were different types of car bonus different types of offerings that were brought first in the Michigan and then in the base hamikdash basically all car bonus can only be brought from five minute from five types of living creatures no more than five number one you have the Bakker the Ox number two you have that sign the Sheep the chemists number three you have the A's the goats whether female or male but you have the axe you have the Sheep you have the goat and then you have two birds Tyron and been a hyena turtledoves and young pigeons those are the only five living creatures from which any carbon was ever brought besides of course meal offerings brought from grain there were only four types of car bonus four types you have a carbon Ella a carbon slummin a carbon catus and a carbon a shaman on isla of hatas an ashram and a schlomit those were the four types of offerings which had different procedures and different laws governing each one there were another three that relate to an individual higher my sir and paisa altogether seven so you have oil or slum and cantos ashram which can be either communal or individual and then you have another three individuals called my sir and pacer which are another three types of Carmona's that have their own laws governing them today we're going to explore the carbon Coty's which in English you would translate as the sin offering okay so you could all look in that Marone so layman nefesh key sector go go Macomb it's visage oh my shall I say a cent of us Samantha's Mahina a person who commits a sin in advertently and the trailer goes on to list different categories of people who may commit this sin inadvertently and the result is the law is that this person has to bring a carbon hot dose during the time of the Michigan of the base oh my gosh you made to two pages there's two to source sheets okay thank you Thank You Ravana's how many Kaplan there's a second sheet one if somebody bring over the second one too I have the first this one yeah the first one starts with a pasta the second one starts with Hulan I guess it would have been easier to number the pages but that's modern technology the first one starts with a pasta grade average M and the second one starts with the word : the Martin : okay everyone has the women you got the men have thank you thank you very much for bringing them okay so take a look at source number one by Abraham el mozole a marine Bayou Klaipeda Dollard pasa Calif de Bourbon a la Mer nefesh key sector by Chicago Macomb it's recession Marshall ascent of Awesome Atlas Mahina speak to the children of Israel a person who sins inadvertently and commits one of the commits a sin violating one of the commandments of Hashem Hashem said not to do it and this person did it and the tire goes on to discuss the law that this person as a result of this inadvertent mistaken sin which we call a show Gate Bridge Goga must bring a fattest offering what does the cat is offering consist of it could be one of two things either a female goat or a female sheep the Karthus is always the fattest of an ordinary individual who commits an inadvertent sin is always a female animal either a sheep or a goat that is the person's choice the Rambam sums up the halacha in hillcrist gagas para caliph in the ram mom's mission the Torah the laws of inadvertent sins the first chapter the opening Halawa this is what the Rambam says calebrage goggle our cosmic mitzvah slice our society bomb Isis a high of an Aloha chorus every word here is precise somebody who transgresses inadvertently doing one of the mitzvot slice' sir one of the mitzvos that the tire says you now let it do and this person does it by mistake and it's a type of Mitzvah slice especially Sheba myself meaning it doesn't involve thoughts or verbal or a verbal declaration it involves a my son action should I of Analia chorus and it's not only something that Toyota prohibits the penalty for it would be death being cut off from heaven a heavenly death penalty such a type of sin and he does it but or she does it by mistake I raised a high of logic reef carbon cockles this person is obliged to offer a sin offering or mitzvos I say he acted courtesy of physical ashleyandustin it's a positive commandment that in this case he should bring an offering for his or her inadvertent sin and the Rambam continues how many how many sins warrants such a type of offering how many think there are 365 negative Commandments but how many of them qualify for a carbon caucus based based on the qualifications it has to be a mitzvah slicer it has to be a mitzvah splice especially yes but my sir action right somebody for example who gossips or slanders you now let us say lotion heart but there's no mice abogado if somebody who curses cuss for song lyrics on there's no mice and has to be a super chorus there's a death penalty for it so how many are there anybody 43 43 myths 43 sins can warrant to carbon cutters and iran mom lists them off from the Mishnah minsu called chris's shebar ayahs shisha the estrogen or Bashara evaders shiva assay of all the Mitzvah slices when it comes to immoral relationships there's a possibility of 26 and all other evaders 17 the Rambam lists 26 and 17 and around them list them all off and you have the list Velo hey however the Vedas are over mice somebody worships idolatry with an action not just verbally or in thought in an action by mistake I know cinemas are Allah my Allah he gives his children to another desirable or value don't even mice of different types of sorcery I'm a catalyst a Shabbos classic example somebody violates the Shabbos somebody goes and lights a fire and Chavez somebody cooks on Shabbos somebody big Sun Shabbos somebody plows plans builds on Shabbos rights on Shabbos carries on Shabbos but it was a mistake how can it be a mistake could be one of two ways either they didn't know the fact or they didn't know the law either you forgot at Shabbos or you forgot the law there you know a lot of cooking Travis you know its job is but you forgot are you similar come here my kappa rip you work on Yom Kippur you forget it Jim keeper or you forget it you're not allowed to do this Malone Yom Kippur how are you coping shyster Yom Kippur it just happened too many people you're right you wake up your Kippur in the morning you take a drink you forget it Jim Kippur Oh it'll come as my pacer you eat comments and pacer again you forget it spacer or forget you now let it come Mesa Michael hey Liv somebody explain that what is hey Liv there's certain fatty parts of the animal that are permissible to eat we call those Shuman the fatty healthy parts of the animal and and then you have the tail of which other forbidden parts of the fat and you eat it I fell down somebody's blocked and the Rambam continues I have my Saroja pickle and he continues he finishes a day a loose shoulders my boy in my veins should move in Austin in Austin Carter school these are 43 sins that if a Jew a man or a woman commits them inadvertently by mistake and then of course he or she becomes aware of their mistake so in the time of the base time if fish and the Mishkan they were obligated to bring a carbon cantos a sin offering on these 43 sins either as I said a female sheep or a female got borrow hitomi nailing a mother home schakal nearby Torah the Torah in vehicular considers four cases of people who have to bring the hottest the anointed priests Akiane Messiah which is the coin goggle koha ADA the Sanhedrin the Supreme Court makes a mistake they also bring a carbon cantos the prince I shall not see after the king and finally the ordinary Jew man or woman who commits any of these are various brings a carbon cap does the female or or male or male sheep a female sheep or goat not male now as we see from the Rambam the sin offering was not brought for any sin it was brought from major sin which means those that were in the penalty of car is being cut off and it had to be committed unintentionally or in advertently right so this can happen either as we said the person forgot the law or the person forgot the facts now when we speak about a show yet we have to remember unintentional sins stand midway between intentional sins and the other extreme intentional sins if I knew what I was doing and I knew it was wrong we call that a maze it then you can't bring a carbon a carbon is only a total meant for a showing different inadvertence in maze it has completely different issues for example in these 43 sins if the person that had the maze that there's a penalty of chorus of course only the person doesn't do Trula the great idea about choruses since it comes from heaven so heaven knows if you repent and then the sin is forgiven but if it's amazing the carbon the offering will not help anymore so it has to be a show that has to be inadvertent on the other hand it has to be a mistake an act it can be involuntary action which we would call an honest somebody points a gun to somebody's head and says eat the blood that's not called a show yet they didn't make a mistake they work enforced to do it in order to save their life or somebody does something as a result of a reflex action so this is completely involuntary action involuntary actions don't need atonement the sin offering the carbon happiness is confined to the middle range of cases you did wrong but you didn't know that what you're doing was wrong even today there's no base on Victor so there's obviously no carbon hatas the fundamental idea remains the same when a person commits a sin by mistake they need atonement in other words it's not just xavius our cost of you have to bring a carbon if you make a mistake the fundamental idea is you need atonement how do we know this so the Rambam clearly says it take a look first of all in Rashi Rashi shoe is that based on a tile of Deborah Maskull toilet okay it actually says should call her show you against regime Caporal Akasha hey do any person who does a sin by mistake needs atonement when he finds out the past success in Noah it's a very interesting puzzle the access dim-sum when after say from edgar schmatko hey a jewish enemy and honda me on each octave enderchest officialdom the blood of your souls i will demand from every living creature i will demand it and from a person and from his brother i will demand it the soul of the person now the structure of this bus ik is a very fascinating structure but let's see the interpretation of Rashi Umayyad ha Adam miada hi Reba mazes vein a domani address I will demand the Bloods from a person who killed somebody willingly and there's no witnesses so nobody therefore will punish this person me at each of if me actual are you like aqua her gosh I gig and the editor Shimla Eagle Aviv a Koosh olive oil a little lemarchal shaft show us our escape our somebody actually who kills his brother in other words he loves him he's a friend but he doesn't my mistake it's inadvertent he too needs atonement and therefore if he doesn't go and seek forgiveness for what he did I will exact it from him so clearly Rashi says shrieking sorry Kapur a person did something by mistake near atonement the Rambam says and hookers true ver peyrac i love the next source colum it's Roberta Bain s CB Moises in Morada Marcus Mahan baby's ugly baby Chicago Shay asset server vo shows may set a high of Lisa vada sloth neck el borracho any Mitzvah positive or negative if a person transgresses them willingly or inadvertently when the person decides to do children repent this person is obligated to confess before God and express their remorse for the past and their resolution for the future clearly the Rambam is articulating a hollow ha a person may commit a sin by mistake inadvertent they didn't realize they didn't know they weren't cognizant of the law or of the facts and nonetheless there is the mitzvah of chuva irrelevant of the base--emitter should not have a cementation fact around them here includes every Mitzvah sessio Mitzvah slices which of course even in the time of the Besame flesh would not warrant a carbon cantos excluding those 43 that we spoke before about and here we come to the obvious question what's the obvious question why should unintentional sins require atonement at all why does the person have to go and purchase a sacrifice and bring it to the base hamikdash and go through the entire procedure or do chuva what guilt is involved I mean it seems so unjust and so on fear the person really did not know we're not talking about a fake showing a staged surrogate we're talking about an authentic shaking God knows the truth like you know the truth there was a show you you forgot that sim kipper you forgot that Shabbos you didn't realize this is a forbidden piece of fact it just looked like a good fatty part of the ripp steak that's it it was in a lovely kosher restaurant which is usually Glatt Kosher Mahajan minima hydrant the person was as innocent as one can be why is there any guilt why is it called a sin why does one need atonement that is the question practically speaking had the offender knowing the facts and the law at the time he would have not done what he has done the only reason he did it is because of ignorance of the facts or of the law so why does he have to undergo a process of atonement how can you hold a person liable I mean in our own relationships can you really hold a person liable when he had absolutely no intention of doing anything wrong there was no malicious intent there was no abusive attempt there was no act of content there was no act of rebellion and it didn't come of laziness of apathy of carelessness of immorality of promiscuity at all it was what we call an innocent mistake how do we make sense of the carbon hottests so today we want to go on a little journey and the journey is through generations of the forum of commentators from different worldviews from different perspectives of Jewish thoughts of Jewish masiva and see how the sages and the rabbis throughout the generations dealt with this question why do we bring our carbon caucus let's begin with one of the most fundamental works - safer - Allah safer Akeno you probably know but I'll say it is a fascinating work it's the first encyclopedic work on all over the 613 minutes if somebody wants to know what are the 630 mitzvos you open up the safe rack in of the Book of Education he lists in the order of the parishes every single Mitzvah and discusses its reason its basic laws and its basic objectives it's an encyclopedic brief summary of what is the Mitzvah what is the root and the idea of the Mitzvah and some of the basic laws around the medicine that's thus a freshman challenges we don't know who authored a safe erection on one of the books whose author remains mysterious till today although many historians believe it was a man named of Aaron halevi was often referred to an elephant literature as DRH Aleph hey Reb Aaron Alavi one of the great sages of Spain of Barcelona in Spain who lived in the 13th century in the 1200s and the beginning of the 1300s in Barcelona many believe he authored the safer of Hinnom if that would be the case it was a subsequent work that came after the Rambam safer mitzvahs with the ramen also made a collection of all of the 613 mitzvot safe remits was a brief paragraph or two paragraphs for each Mitzvah the advantage of Seraphin aglow as he discusses the reason for every Mitzvah he finds the reason often the hushka fairies in the spiritual reason the educational and pedagogical reason the safer end of discusses this question and purchased rumor mitzvos SH Sadiq a when he discusses the base--emitter let's see what he says how are you my new we have said they say foreigner says this many times ke ke ala vulvas through you metropolis fascinating instead of this a fraction of your heart follows your actions it's not that your actions follow your heart your heart follows your actions which means when you keep on doing something you develop a connection to it emotionally action creates dents in the soul action redefines emotion sometimes people say I have to wait till I'm emotionally ready and yeah in some cases you have to wait till you're emotionally ready but sometimes if you wait till you're emotionally ready you may wait for eternity because actions often are what define emotions this is a you sunny in safe you know well okay in Kiev the age when a person sins inadvertently llahi Tarly boy alphabet var Visayan LaVon sure you're in my bein oil acai so interesting expression caught a steely eye so fight when a person sins inadvertently he shouldn't only cleanse himself through his lips by turning to the wall and telling to the saying you that's ativan speak to the wall and tell us Sam you know I sinned I won't do it again I'll be more careful I have about suing my son God levar Hetty Lacock Osman miss la cerva - Demetria clavier Malibu I'm not gonna lie Colleen McCullough my circus of the car bonus I hate him McCallum I sang God la única Abhinav Sharia head to the evening Amanda Palmer cares what they say for a famous really is saying is the whole Sturm the whole effort around the carbon caucus is really to teach them to be courses for next time all I'm asking you is I know you were innocent you made a mistake be cautious so therefore you don't just tell him okay he made a mistake he brings a carbon he brings an animal he goes to the base--emitter she takes some of his possessions and he goes through the whole toil and effort and a carbon demands both in terms of finances and in terms of personal time and energy this will inculcate in the person the seriousness of the action and therefore in the future he will or she will be sure not to do it again very practical straightforward idea of the safer ah he knows it's an educational objective the Ramban robin immersive enactment the 13th century great space-age of Spain as well of Barcelona a physician a doctor a philosopher one of the greatest rabbis over the time who wrote a commentary on homage asks the question in persons vehicular there am ban says you could take a look in your next source Rambin here pay a dollar posted base of a accrue nefesh kiss after when a soul sins inadvertently of the Rambam is it something I'm saying or something you're doing or it's disconnected to all of the toss I guess every market she wishes on himself to bring the house down or to bring the roof down huh so the Rabanne Rambam I said mom lived in the 12th century and in the 13th century the Ramban says let's read fascinating insight by URI URI samokov a beneficiary here Sergei guess history conifers why does it say nefesh kiss after a soul that since it's a rear expression and Hamish nephesh kiss after he says because the issue here was awareness thought in other words his mother Shover he didn't realize so therefore we call it nephesh which is attributed to the person's consciousness the time a carbon a cell on a freshly a gas what's the reason to bring an offering for a soul that makes a mistake Monisha Cola avoid noise uhreally New Guinea benefice Bahama Moomba the light iskele a huggable teenager not be a tyrannical hate the Rambam is saying because there is an objective effect of the action irrelevant of my motivation or consciousness or intention in other words sin in any form intentional or unintentional makes an impression it has an impact it has an impact on the person and it has an impact on the world and therefore the person is not guilty in the sense we're blaming you because you are evil no you're not evil you're completely innocent what we're saying is you made a mistake true but the mistake has consequences the Rambam seremban says you're a lean Dugan Ibanez it creates a stain in the soul the person ate comments on page says the person violated shoppers the person cohabited in an immoral relationship inadvertently it leaves an impression on the soul that creates a blemish in the world around it's a stain on the soul and therefore as their Ambon says the soul is only fit to encounter its maker when it's cleansed what what's his words like Tuscola how to open a yard straight out to be a satire in the coal hate to have Drake us to be able to have a relationship with my Creator even in this world one has to be pure one has to be cleansed one can be dirty one can be so soiled and if I made mistakes I have to make amends I have to fix it the Lula's are you tipsy I am sorry some la pila funnel if not for this all the fools who make mistakes constantly but they're always sinning by mistake would all have the same relationship it doesn't work that way voloshina nefesh asha Gaga's hashtag as talkative carbon chat iskele a carnival a leaky martian is sana who before is a gunk in his skin nefesh and that's why the inadvertent soul brings an offering in order to come close and cleanse itself from the sin from the blemish to be able to come close to God who imbued the pure soul in the person our Sharon asana and gave it to us pure Tahiry he and it was blemished I have to clean over the blemish and that's why it also says nefesh because the word never explains why we have to bring a carbon catalyst because you have a soul and the soul is so pure and as a result of my actions even by mistake the soul experienced a blemish therefore never cease after there's a soul if you wouldn't have a soul okay you made a mistake you made a mistake but you have a soul here and there's an objective impression that is negative and therefore one meets cleansing this is what there ambon is explaining to us so the safe return of gives us an educational point of view that's basically for the future there are mom says it's not only for the future it's basically even for this time because of the objective impression that any sin makes whether it's Mays it or or it's SH I get I guess if somebody has a you know one of the oldest jokes is they say that Moshe Dayan who was Israel's defense minister remember Moshe Dayan had a patch on one of his eyes there's an old joke he was once driving on an Israeli Highway 150 km/h which in Israel is not that fast especially in the week before elections and and a policeman stopped him and he sees Moshe Dayan behind the wheel and he says general Diane you ought to serve as a role model for Israeli society lammott on ahead c'mon Meshuggah you're driving like a madman I should quadruple your summons because you know me men ohyeah over hey awesome so Moshe Dayan supposedly looks at the office and he says listen I don't need short-term idea of us oh look at me I have one eye now what would you like me to do with that I look at the speedometer look at the highway if somebody has a impaired speedometer somebody has a faulty speedometer you're driving on the highway and you don't realize the speed as a result you crashed into another car and you wreak havoc and damage the person certainly was innocent the speedometer was broken I thought I was driving according to the speed limit but there was damage done there was damage done and I'm the one who caused that damage I didn't mean to I'm not a bad guy I wasn't malicious but I caused the damage I have to take accountability further and I have to pay you for the damages it's true how logically and we all understand it rationally and logically there Ambon apply is the same rule when it comes to one's spiritual life when it comes to one's moral life when it comes to one one's ethical life the Rambam is very important nowadays because there is a trend in Western society and I believe the first one to have really brought in this trend was Immanuel Kant that intentions and motives are the key factor in the moral life the key issue in the moral life is what you were thinking what you were feeling what your intentions were and as long as your intent were Noble then you're Noble and what the Rambam is bringing out is that of course intentions are very important and of course motivations are extremely important and of course a showy gig is not amazing and the laws are different but you cannot escape responsibility from the power of actions I said something I did something that hurt somebody even with the best motivations I have to ask forgiveness I did something even between me and God it leaves an impact even if I was innocent and I have to take accountability for it so the Trinity does not fault us for mistakes there I'm gonna say the tyre is not telling you you're a horrible person because you made a mistake that's a horrible idea that's not what the traders say the Train is not demanding perfection the Toyota is demanding accountability not perfection we're all surgeons we all make mistakes but nefesh casaba realize your greatness you have a soul and you made a mistake you were innocent you know some people things happen to them and as a result they do things to other people not knowing better we all live life with the tools that we have and sometimes those tools are very limited and suddenly a few years later this person is in recovery or this person develops maturity or this person becomes more sensitive to life or or develops more confidence more wisdom whatever it is and I realize are you how could have I been so foolish okay don't be perfect and don't blame yourself for being imperfect but be accountable nefesh key sector you have a soul and other people have a soul that's what the ROM bond is telling us somebody once sent me a line he said if you don't make mistakes you're not working on hard enough problems and that's a big mistake people make mistakes while one person hesitates because he feels inferior the other is busy making mistakes and becoming superior there was a physicist Niels Bohr very famous physicist and he once said an expert is a man who has made all the mistakes which can be made in a very narrow field and when you make all those possible mistakes you become an expert you know there was a they tell an old anecdote it says for the Azeris notion a man once told his wife that she has to listen to him so she said why he said because that's how it works she said why what's the logic so he said because men are superior to women so she says who says so he says it's obvious look at God he created men first why why did he create men first because men are superior its wife told them that you're a shite - you're a fool God created men first because we learn from mistakes so mistakes are inevitable their inherent to the human condition the question is not if I will make a mistake the question is when I will make a mistake and the response is not guilt and blaming myself forever that I made a mistake but taking accountability and making menace I want to point out something fascinating when the Turner speaks about the four categories of people after being a carbon Karthus speaks about plane goggle speaks about the Sun Hedren speaks about an ordinary Jew and it speaks about the Nazi the king the leader if you take a look on each of them it says in II micaiah namashivaya if the coin got those sins in color that's Easter all years ago if the son hadron makes a mistake I share no see yet when the leader will sin not if so the HSU partner says Rebbe a nevada surfer no says Matsushita it's not a question if it's a question I share means when Rashi also says it means ASHRAE actually fortunate is a generation that the leader is accountable but it's not a question of if it's a question of when why if you're a leader you make mistakes if you have the privilege of living in a cocoon on top of a mountain the hatched from people then you could be immune of making mistakes when you're a leader sometimes you don't have a choice whether to make a mistake or not by definition you're involved in an imperfect world with imperfect people and any choice you make is a mistake take the classic example of the gomorian get indefinite tsiyon you know you know what I'm talking about scar your binoculars what happens there's the story of calm Cimber Kamsa the person who's thrown out of the party and is insulted says I'm going to Rome goes to Rome and says the Jews have rebelled against you how can you prove it send an offering they won't offer it in the base I'm English right he sends an offering and what does this do do he blemishes it it's not this qualified the car come him see this what do they say we have to offer it we have no choice it's peacock nefesh it's the emperor of Rome it's the season weather sky herb enough killer say it's one of the great sages of the time he says people will say that you're allowed to offer a blemished animal in the bay stomach dish we can come to say okay there's only one other choice we have to get rid of this person we have to get rid of this person it's too dangerous he's a monster he's endangering the whole future of Kali Stroh Sahib enough killer says but then people are gonna say that for blemishing an animal that belongs on that that says Carmen there's a death penalty we can't do anything what does the Gomorra conclude was recreation of exactly say I'm Vasu so so sorry binoculars that River I speak - a new surface base a no the eagle s we saw the adversary translated the not humility the piety the PIA t thats it ghosts the humility the goodness the meanest hasidism Simon of killers that's what caused the harbor now what was he trying to say scribe enough killers was trying to be an elephant you don't kill somebody from blemishing an animal is it wrong yeah but he doesn't die he can't kill somebody for that and you can't offer a carbon that's blemished in an ideal world he was right but this was a tragic world this was a horrible world this was an imperfect world this is a world where the Roman lion was on your throat since Pompey already came in before it is 60 before the Common Era and this was the next century so you make the right choice you're making the wrong choice you make the wrong choice you make the right choice and when you make a wrong choice it's still a wrong choice even if it's the right choice I should not say yes not if it's a question of when leaders who are involved in real life in a very imperfect and blemished world make mistakes and this explains a fascinating thing a fascinating Gemara take a look shoppers deafening hey I'm at Bay's jhagadu Kamara Turner upon on our bond may Sabathia shamash four people died for one reason as a result of the serpent enticing have landed them to eat from the tree of knowledge that's the only reason they died the Elohim Benjamin Ben Yaakov I'm removing Moshe Yishai Aveda of it color band Ovid for people being young and the son of Yaakov Adam the father of Moshe he shied the father of David called the son of David what strikes you about this Gomorrah anything what strikes our know about these forts our Dickon who were untarnished unblemished there was only one reason they died the only reason they died was because there was Xavier beyond my house humming men or mice two months from the day other man kava ate from the tree of knowledge death became part of life till the day when Bill Ahimaaz Lunetta himakajima the Kingdom a male component but since till that day this earth you shall ah hush there's a partition between the soul and the body and essentially the person had to live forever because the body is an expression of the soul and the soul lives forever the body lives forever but when that partition was created as a result of a theater lovers that's how the shock minister explained it there's a concept of death what strikes you about this Gomorrah who is not in this list who's not in this list moisture is not in this list a broom is not in the list you see the panelist Jakob is not in the list Dublin is bad in the lists it's almost anonymous figures right you didn't even know the dove it I'm Alec had a son colours did you didn't even know how much do you know about Yishai how much do you know about I'm wrong Ben yummy and it's interesting and the Gemara makes sure to emphasize their father's name we all know who he/she is everybody knows who I'm room is I'm rum every Masha one second why don't you tell me who I'm rums father is you tell me Benjamin Ben Yaakov can the AMRAAMs father you tell me he's shy I've read of it why don't you give me each day father we all know he says father was of it we all know how honoring his father was so we see what does the tamar trying to say the Gemara is trying to explain something and that is these four people were very different than either their son of their father moisture a Boehner was a Nazi he was a leader he was involved with the people he stands up to the revolution element he says for adventitia thoughts of him I am attaining a mr. Prakash a cassava of raw meat sacking a Kiev were changing the world I'm wrong Binyamin Yishai color they were fantastic people but when the gomora mentions them it makes sure to point that either the father of the son to show the contrast that in order to be able to dye bath you shall not hush you have to afford a life of complete transcendence and segregation and then you make no mistakes and you're capable of never sinning while some of us even when we're in segregation we can still sin I should just emphasize that so with their greatness there's also the component that teaches us a share no siesta as the Safari says I'm Nam dove or Matsui after a human being a human being makes mistakes just be accountable for the mistakes this is the of their unban this idea of the Ramban introduced a fascinating idea in Halawa which has been heavily debated let me first begin with the practical example we all know Shabbos there's a domain called rooster Robin and if you take out an object from your house into your shoe sir album it's a biblical violation but many properties especially in today's they are called karma lists are caramel this is a place that biblically it's not forbidden in other words if you take out something from your house we're shows I offer to a caramel is it's a rabbinic violation it's not a biblical violation because it's not a public domain what's the qualification of Arusha Sir Robin it's not so easy to make a rotisserie album according to some opinions it has to be a street where 600,000 people walk daily I mean there's a McCoy curse about it but a real issue sir Adam and I Toyota is often complicated to where to find to discover so here's a question let's say you have an ear if you have a native here in Muncie and the area of is covering properties that are karma listen our intercessor album which means if the a roof is broken there's no area then people are caring they're carrying from their home into the street they're carrying in the street it's not a biblical violation it's a rabbinic violation the area breaks on Shabbos they do breaks on Shabbos people don't know whoever carries is going to be what a show you could write a real psychic they don't know that what they're doing is forbidden am i obligated to notify the people that the a roof is broke you'll say certainly they shouldn't carry not-so-simple based on this idea of the RAM bond in a simile some misfits introduces a gevalt the conditional aha take a look sucked in a silver Samish Petrossian mich patrasche lama down would sift cotton gimel in his beer the basura trader a fellow Aslam bhai geeks are escapar a Chuvalo hog in our history the Isidora bounine ain't sorry some kapoor okay / dummy machine can be standardization Makabe I know some are saying it sucked in the service when we speak about a blemish an objective dent that a sin creates it's only by an Easter of trader then even if I did it by mistake but I didn't and it creates a blemish in my soul and in the world around me and I need atonement however what if I did it mr. Dearborne on here if I did it willingly then I violated on it sir you're not allowed to be overdone innocent or abundant but if I did it by mistake he says there's no need for atonement absolutely there's no ignition Estonia okay you love our dummy you're completely innocent nothing happened why what is this based on so the greater of of Lublin the Toyotas guests said Dominic or nippers Amandla blender was a hospital that some ascetic one of the great going him and then went to your shall I massage the troopers terrorist has it she explains in the civis Charles the troopers to discuss an error hi the arm shot toilets if symbol of the lace especially lava relatively safe for him what do you mean the toilet is says like saucer Menard over a shaggy - look are you - smile you're not allowed turn away you're not allowed to reject the commandment of bez Dhin when the sun Hedren it when the common when the canal is 2/4 a commandment emits or tell you your now letter do something the Toni Marie Shura Boehner gave over that the Jewish people are obligated to listen to the haha moment every generation of course we're talking about Kaka man who are ordained man to man all the way from Russia Rubino and our true representatives of Tyria and that's why when we read the Megillah we say I said could this shuttle beam its vice of its Yvonne or micro Megillah Bharatha Tasha Malik animal hello my tractor the son of emits voice of it's even la Hamrlik national Shabbos where did God command us to light Shabbos candles there's no such a commandment entertainer the answer is Hashem told us Lord saw sermon our daughter shared in the look ah you're obligated to follow the instructions of bedzed in in every generation so the Terios message says what do you mean you did it by mistake but you violated the TV and for the traders hazard Macomber coin is reserved our Kirk after the gatherer so utterly Lavra a lubricant common have a lawyer Eastern after the bees rhetorical my tale of a damn child over absolutely awesome in Italia Oh mr. Markey Asha is Labiche a guitarist Khepera chalet auckland VAR e super psychic i will be history Rabanne on in easter toyota hard over bats lou sorry velorek allah allah ma ma omaha key culture shaking me like even lav without dementia coming like Awad is surah clown let's explain what the tourist has said is saying when a person commits any transgression the right sudra bond biblical or rabbinic there are two components number one I violated the will of my Creator that's number one I violated the will of my Creator that's number one number two it's not I violated the will of my Creator it's the objective impact of what I did every Mitzvah creates purity in the world every evader creates negative energy in my soul and in the world I Brit if I lie if I like somebody puts their finger onto a hot stove they may do it by mistake they may not do it by mistake it burns the finger it hurts somebody goes out when it's freezing without a coat they get a cold even if they didn't realize how cold it is why because there are natural physical wars to the universe with cause and effect when a person lies it has an impact on my soul - ummah is not the same some dirt attaches itself to me and it disturbs me that's the idea of the Rambam the objective impact of the mitzvot suck the terrace hazard when I do something by mistake is the first component here that I violate a shams will I'm asking you was there an act of betrayal when I do it by mistake what's the answer no so that's gone when is amazing this betrayal and is the objective impact of the sin when there's a shy geek there's no betrayal was a mistake what's left what's left is the second component what's the second component that the cleft sir the object of this food or this act creates an impact and it's a negative impact it creates a blemish in my net fish in effigy sector dr. Turner Spencer the shittim then the service is that could only apply by an incident ice because by innocent or ERISA that Chaffetz becomes forbidden the blood is a type of Chaffetz that for a Jewish soul was damaging like you're allergic to it somebody is allergic to carbs and sugar like every good Jew according to your wife at least you could say I was at a fast and I was mama shaking I saw the Viennese table and I was so involved in synthesis custom color I didn't realize that I just packed down you know ten pieces of part of a cheesecake with some ice cream complete circuit but does that mean you're not gonna gain ten pounds does that mean you're not gonna be lethargic that night does that mean you're not gonna feel obese does that mean you're not gonna need some help with your nutrition shake again I'll show you going in you ate the food and it's not good for you you're allergic to it because the food the kayfetz of the food is not good for your body it's not good for your blood type but we're not gonna get too much into nutrition I don't want to ruin the breakfast subject areas tested by an instrument at Tyler it's an Easter crafts so what means it's a FAFSA the object itself is redefined based on the blueprint of the Rabbinical elementary on Eastern Arab or non he words he puts in very interesting where these as Easter occurred after the gatherer that have come him said you're now ready to suit you're not gonna drink this drink you know how to do it Lisa your now letter do it the Cohanim said but they didn't change the status of the kayfetz so if I do it the maze it I violated I betrayed the Rutzen of my god the Ruxin of my creator of course I need a copper but if I didn't be sure you get betrayal there was no betray the impact of the heft said there's no impact of the fafsa because the heft sir wasn't the farm redefined so therefore then a civil submission but says you don't need kabbalah you didn't do anything wrong so if somebody is carrying in a community where there's no areas by mistake and the only is sir of caring is with Arab or none and they don't know do I have to tell them according to the service what's the problem but many said they're not being going on a drive on and they don't know that the era of broke write an instrument not trader there's no we assume in attire here it's just that see women to Ramona I crafted the Gamera according to the December Sun wish but there's many who say you wouldn't have to tell anybody get it they either broke this is not the praça locker I should just never say that but this is a although many hold like that but that's well Susie there's a major argument about it Reb Yosef angle the abusive anal as a famous safe recalled base of a tree and Osmond a ricer and he dedicates many pages to discuss this question are 'soon a turban and a surah heft sir or Asura gavurin when the rabbi's prohibited something is it a problem on the person or does it redefine the object itself and he explains what's this farah he says last Shama ordered some lawyer Hashem created the world when he says this is a sir it defines not only the person it defines the object it's his world in fact desire says its fact I'll buy rice of our alma which means he created the world based on the blueprint of Toyota we created the world based on the blueprint of Tyra so basically the world is a mirror of Toyota so if traitorous says this is forbidden so it's expressed the very object is a double Oscar meaning inherently it's so to speak it's it's chemical and spiritual makeup is an ism at CES of Easter Adira born on perhaps they don't have that power it's that flash Samar at some lawyer they instituted the Easter even though for was based on their power that was given by Hashem so therefore they have the power over the Jew Hashem tells the Jew you have to listen to Kazan but do they have the ability to redefine the kayfetz itself that the kayfetz should become something that damages the soul replace of Engel says perhaps not that's how the Terios cus it explains dinner service and therefore there's a big difference between our eyes and under a bond and however many points Kim disagree with dismissive astonishment and abusive Engel brings a very fascinating Gomorrah to prove the opposite point if you take a look at source at the first source of your second page the Gomorrah says in Hulan davao vomit Aleph a story the positive in Abbas de closed-loop andhaka ribs area area bossy they came to hotel I saw the Kamiya Bates imamat sumac is biiian abs are illogical a bossy off they brought eggs roasted in wine this wasn't a Jewish hotel they brought them eggs roasted in wine herbs area does not eat the eggs grab a seat sit I'm only herb is a little bossy village Irish Marlatt I reversed mine I'm sorry I said it wasn't Jewish it was Jewish however the issue wasn't a question of consciousness the issue was a question of de my meaning there were many Jews known as a maja Eretz who did not keep or at least there was a great question if they keep the laws of my Souris of tithing their fruits and their produce the way it has to be done and therefore cuz I'll instituted what we call denied my is a combination of two words which means da my what is this and therefore because there is doubt if it was tithed or not so if you purchase produce and fruits for somebody who is under that category where there's a question if he gives my sir or not they have to give it even if it's for a second time this was this type of hotel they bring them or eggs roasted with wine the wine comes of course from grapes it's a Suffolk my it's it's tie reversed my meaning they're eating eggs eggs is not a primary enough to give myself from eggs it doesn't grow from the ground that comes from chickens however the eggs was roasted in wine so therefore there was a taste of wine and then in the wine comes from grapes and perhaps they didn't give myself from the grapes so how can you eat such eggs this is what represent asks her bossy how can you eat it I'm alone of us he says lava that toy I wasn't thinking I wasn't thinking I'm gonna be Seder if she goes through all that I Rufus do my or miss dianna listener of ArcelorMittal Asura fascinating response is it possible that a ha ha man made a decree a hospitai reverse of de mai that even when something is mixed with my like in this case it wasn't wine it was eggs still it's forbidden and if I see ends up eating it inadvertently harsh the be Hampton Schultz said they came in a college Baraka maybe tackle a yard on such thing came out small like whole chicane cuz I'll say that even an animal of tsadikim Hashem makes sure that they don't stumble this is the whole story because vineyard the animal even didn't eat food that was not cultured that wasn't eyes so they came themselves the reboiler slalom allowed Abbasi who's its addict to eat such food that's forbidden not for cribs Arabs Ana went out to do research dr. ashcoff and he found out that there was no giant I reversed my and indeed Abbasi was completely fine with eating this with eating these eggs so they're abusive Engel says look at the russian on the Gemara miss tire mill syndrome a coelom a how is surah woodruf bossy eat something that's a sir says what does the Gemara me in other words if the Casal said it was forbidden ribs are calls it something that's austere eating something that's forbidden yes perhaps you could say the Gemara means that since hazael said you now let it eat it so therefore it's called is sir not because the kayfetz is officer the havens is not ulcer but the Galvez now that i eat it but he says a literal straightforward reading of the Gemara does seem to indicate that even something that's forbidden complete we buy huzzah like my is on Easter chefs and irony Sagara even though then he offers another adaption and that is since the my is a soffit that maybe there was no mysimon hot area so therefore it's a Suffolk maybe that men have toilets not myself that could be another reason it's called is sir the like after it goes back and forth whether than a similar mission but Savar about history there a bond and being in this regard only is authentic or not authentic the earth Sameach remains in cocoon and Ranma Milkha's garish in Perry Calif Oso Oso quotes this nasira's on my foot and the earth Sameach puts it beautifully I'm gonna quote a few of his words he says doubler officer medieval I saw him a knight austere the Etzel Meloy saucer the Kim inshallah amazed it it started the matter all right what if nations like Shambhala David a stain him like me Sebastian law your lover Zulekha a very cloud there is Sameer says in garish when he does it inadvertently he didn't not listen to the how come he didn't know it was a mistake and the only problem is my saucer you have to listen to kazow he listened he just didn't know he thought he was listening so there are some answers let kuvira Clow but then there is some a approves from Iran bomb for my Rambam that this is not true and he rejects the entire as far of than a sieve astonishment and he read he redefines the ha'la'tha it's a longer along Earth's American health as garish in which you could look up and many therefore argue with in a silver Samish but and believe that even a terrible on would need car para even if it is a psychic why why if you say it's an assert after I understand if you say it's an Easter Guevara why would you need Khepera even if it's a show you so here we come to yet another interpretation we discussed the henna we discussed the Ramban now we go to another reason why a show gig may need Khepera and that would explain that even other abondon if you hold it sinister gavurin would still need Khepera even though there was no blemish objectively from what you did Toyo Sodom la Habana hog ball the next source Duran bong has his famous shower hog mole in his safe return asada and there he says her a shock all hail admission igniculus later if somebody eats forbidden fat my mistake is called the COI - I can correct a debacle macaron Oh Mouse cat toy what's his sin so they're on bang says shall line is our box my for the higher your a hurry the Librium muckenberger who shall i yaw velocity over actually give Nike off a offer if he is gondola a diversion whatever royal oil thing zero social ecology borough who vowed Erica zoo Tom a fetish Gaga whole hotel what the Rambam is saying is ignorance is not an excuse in life a person ought to be fully reflective before everything they do before I other words before I eat something before I do something I have to research and make sure I know what I'm doing a person cannot say I forgot I forgot it Sunday I forgot it's Thomas what do they say how do you how do you remember your wife's birthday if you forget it once a person can't say I forgot I forgot it's him Kippur I didn't know its blog I didn't know it's Haley I didn't know the law ignorance a fascinating idea ignorance in Judaism is not an excuse it's a fact but it's not an excuse there are bound says here a person ought to be cautious before I eat scrutinize it dissect it find out of what you're doing right now consists is consistent with God's will or it's not consistent with God's will and he says this is the reason for the heavens Gaga buccola tire I had to find out have to be alert to live means to be present to be conscious to be alert to be focused and to say I don't know find out go find out for Eid and there's another reason she cold oven or a thermal affliction nefesh a meta Mirza exceed one attempt and bomb all the fish moving it made some bumble efficient Icarus a good height a and then he gives a second reason and this reason we know cuz this is the reason he gives in Hamish and Hamish he gives the second reason what's the second reason that everything that's forbidden soils a pure soul it's not because of ignorance it's because of the impression of what you did fascinatingly there's a rumba in halakhah that says almost the exact same thing Rambam who has got this peyrac a al-ahqaf of a barley specially Bashar's Vesta morose and ambitious etosha mish hurry a looper to Lima carbon factor stations that conducive alloy shake if somebody is together with his wife not in the time of the cycle and then suddenly sees that there's blood they're both exempt from a carbon hattis why is a mitzvah slay sister Jaya Shiva chorus yes my mice why he should be no carbon shoppers he made a mistake he didn't realize the Rama says no he's an honest he's an honest it's not College like why dr. amber shy shy gig how am I lived I equal the doc take the shy gig I have a tiny you should have checked you should have been me tactic the illu baba ki off for your fervid dick dick be shameless or how you're bothered a Chicago if you would have screwed tonight if you would have researched if you would have asked questions if you would have asked where am i who am i what am i doing you would have never done it well officially product B do is show Bettina the Africa assets or escapa you know what he needs coppola when he did it there was a mistake but why didn't you ask why didn't you question why didn't you take responsibility for yourself and for everything you're doing in your life that's what you bring atonement for MS you didn't know but the fact that you didn't know this itself or you're guilty for I will say molasses but what about this case what about this case he's a married man it's not the time of the cycle Mallory losses tell them do research before you do so ok let me do research he asks his wife is everything fine everything is fine is everything called everything is good according to how long what is he supposed to do ruin her kinda she doesn't have a profit it is not unexpected it's completely my way law says Harry to Hydra is Sir shall I push as masterball Eames alumnus this is not called a shiny this is called a - it's a complete involuntary action it's coerced he was almost forced somebody ties ties your hands behind your back and feed you blood that's called a Shogun what are you supposed to do you know it's blood it's annoyingness everyone understands it's not a shaky here nobody forced him to do it he did it but as far as his culpability he was forced he's among us and therefore the rebind National Oil of completely absolved of course this is not in this of the Rambam and the of the Rambam you would say there's an objective issue it's not as full but as an objective issue being carbon trapped us but the Rambam is saying it's about research ignorance is not an excuse and therefore as a result of that the show gig needs a capper the preemption Rafal version is commentary on VII crew says show you GU hai T Maximus HESA Hadas hi new initiative beretta Hodge Goga ain't no no Sun but Holly believe enough sorry Lizzie Hiroshima say you hear Qatari with a mitzvah almost pyrophoric quoting these words of them even though he doesn't quote it the sinners has cicadas well Jessica das we don't think of it as a SID essica das means I'm talking to you and you're texting your child is asking you a question and you're busy texting that's called a cicadas s cicadas means you're not fully present in life what sayst you're not fully present when you're doing something your heart is not there your soul is not there you're not completely focused where you are what you're doing boom a state for them in my state that's the expression we're you standing and before whom you're standing has the hadass that's the issue of Shogun that's why it needs car that's why it needs Coppola so we have the perspective of the safer he knows it's for the future the perspective of the Rambam and Himesh it's the objective impression that a mistaken a still makes and we have the perspective of the Rambam rambin and in later generations of sumption Rafal Hirsch and his contemporary or somewhat of his contemporary next generation of Dove it's V Huffman of her Shinra Huffman were both great Rabbani man Germany in the 19th century in his commentary on by ikura he elaborates on the interpretation of rehearse in the same in the same vein they say the my see you know the old an adult they say there was a Jew who knew better but he spent his life more or less in a very promiscuous fashion and every sin he committed he could commit he commit it and whenever they asked him why are you doing it he says I have no issue because when I was a child I was diagnosed that I can't really read dyslexic and all the good diagnoses a DD and ADHD and illiterate and therefore I never learned how to read so therefore I can't read a sinner I can't Davin I can't read himesh I can't read halakhah I can't listen I can't read I don't know Hebrew so therefore I have a you know it's not my fault God created me that way and therefore I'm good to go okay his day comes after 120 years old then he comes up to heaven and they take a look you know they print out google prints out a database of everything you did and you didn't do everything you thought everything you said they start looking and they see this yield you know really you really had a good time and he took it to the limits he lived quite a hidden istic life and he tells the angel he says listen it's not my fault you know go to God ask him I couldn't read I still can't read I can't read a heated weird of Hebrew I can't be I can't be an observant Jew they take a look and they see taka he can't read he goes straight to GaN Eden he goes straight to go Nate he is excited I'm a hyah you know it's called you have the cake and eat it too since his whole life and he goes straight to go Nate comes the grenade in come on al it's long as it's the millennion it's not for him they're sitting and learning this is the second agent this is Gannon so he goes to the angel at the door he says you know I don't know how long I'm gonna survive here but this is my place can I go check out the Gehenna I think I'll have there much first of all a lot of people I know be interesting company probably more fun you know there's things going on - there's action I said listen people usually don't leave for me you know it's a one-way yeah once you've it's very hard to get in it's a whole long long process he begs he begs do me a favor I'm a good guy man I made I want to go for a visit you know what do me a favor it says just write me a note the notes say that I'm from granadan I'm visiting your Henan and when I want to come back I show the note whoever is the guard and I'll let me in my looks there's no price idea that's fear right some a beautiful note there's I got Navy heat he's just visiting your Hanlon he has a place he has a seat he has extender so good and he could come back whenever he wants I'm a high it takes the note he goes into Gehenna and indeed he sees it's a party happening I'm a Shire the smorgasbords the pool tables the casinos celeb they can frail-looking a henna and he sees everyone he knows everyone he spent time with suddenly five o'clock p.m. there's a clap the fun is over and now he sees a new picture of Gangnam suddenly it's getting very very hot now it's time to go back to GaN Eden so he runs back to GaN Eden and with full confidence he comes to the door runs in the garden way we're wait you don't go and we're coming from coming again you can't go in there I have a notes gives him the note looks at the notice I'm sorry I can't read so there the Egyptian Rafal Hirsch is making the point and that is ignorance in life is not an excuse unless it's really an excuse why because you can educate yourself educate yourself they once asked to do what's the difference between ignorance and apathy and he said I don't know and I don't care well ignorance breeds apathy and apathy is not an excuse because ignorance is not an excuse now let's go over to one last Mohammed and for this we have to learn another Stickle Gomorrah take a look at the fourth to the last source kaduche andhave Aleph amid base soak the hey look at Amara the tanya fascinating tomorrow we learned in Paris Malthus the Brice's says the can purchase matters ish off a rhombus on his luck law huh but mid burp ashes mattresses in Bamidbar pay requirement of by mid Boris partials mattes a woman takes a vow to do something that is difficult right impulsively perhaps so for whatever reason her husband has the ability to be able to nullify the vow and she's absolved so the toyota says a shahe failure husband nullified the valve assembly slack law and God will forgive her for everything tomorrow by Mack custom man that but why does God have to forgive her her husband nullified well and for the gomorian odd ribbon aza here a woman decides she wants to become an Aussie no less I am anymore no kiddush no wine or grapes ah no cutting here no tumor complete life of complete spiritual segregation for Shama baile her husband hears about it he says there goes my marriage for her fellow Toyota said you know he tells us in Evanston listen you mean well but tell me that I've I still want to live in this world with you he nullifies the Val Vila yard the show for love violence she doesn't know that he nullified it forces che CI enemy Tommy la maison the next night she goes for a drink she thinks he's an ordinary so really she didn't do a sin there's no Val no pledge he know the fight but she doesn't know that so now does she need an atonement or not so that Terry says he shahe Fame bash on his luck law because in her mind she's sinning even though she's not so you think you're sinning and you're not do you need atonement or not objectively mid/side the catheter you didn't do anything wrong it's at the Galleria right you remember him it's had the shaft so you didn't do anything wrong she's not an Aussie it's not the gatherer the fact that she is betraying her God and her soul that's still there because she thinks she's doing the wrong thing even though she's not doing the wrong thing I shall miss Leveaux God forgive has to forgive her about Kiva Kiev a Mithila hype cyka v Bakke where every Akiva would reach this PASOK in mattress he would start crying oh my he said Oh mom mission is Gavin laughs whoops I'm sorry wallaby elipse arkla I'm retired Smith hiccup arose Lissa machinist Calvin let hope Sarkozy for all of the other browser a lot has come over come mother somebody who had intention to eat pork and when they lifted up the piece of meat instead of having hazard they lifted up a kosher piece of meat Tyrus says you still need atonement like this woman Sheila pale she didn't do anything wrong but she wanted to do something wrong you need atonement so somebody who has intention to eat pork and eats pork for sure they need a cup para rib Akiva was crying the Gomorrah said there's one more place that he cried coyote Vdara timer now come to my Ikra says in baqara below your dog watch them but not solve only know a person does a sin and he's ignorant he doesn't know that he did it and he's guilty Shaheed about Kiva Magilla passes are your boy if they're lucky we used to cry and this is what he said oh my mission is Gavin Lasell Schumann vallah be of the Calif on return of Allah your devotion - ah bueno mission is Gavin little hey lovey Allah by other hey live a life has come overcome my dark have song that he wanted to eat shuma Schumann is the fatty parts of the animal that are kosher and by mistake he took a piece of kala which is non kosher he needs a Coppola that's the holding of carbon Tatas you thought you were eating Schumann which is kosher by mistake you HEA love you didn't know you need a coppola somebody wanted e-tailers and ate a live for sure they need a car part of this amazing Amish link rabbi akiva cried by these to pursue now maybe a Kiva wasn't the crying type how do I know the camera at the end of Marcos when everybody was busy crying what was he doing he was laughing by the base of meters behind safe and everyone was crying and even then rebbi akiva was laughing he already saw the future you know I've read it sign in are you serious sign they see a fax coming out of quite a shocker - and everybody's crying maybe I keep his laughing he says till now I wasn't sure about the ideation was kinda masconi's Bashevis reliant but now I see see your son to take courage that Zion was plowed like a field and faxes are coming out of Korea Shaka - Ian I know that every last module of our Yeshua scheme him Ascanius beside mr. Shah lime is also going to be fulfilled in the Gemara finishes blushing as an unreal like a varnish I'm Tononi calm tunnel Ruby akima saw the good he saw the positive the camera in Brussels the famous Gomorrah his chicken died and the fire was extinguished and his donkey was killed and he kept on saying the same where it's called the other drop on the top of it but at these two he wept so the metchnikoff m'a there is a mayor in his commentary on Malthus asks why was there be a Kiva the one who wept L Jews learned these pursue criminal mesh all the time I am an old army Ryan it was Ruby Akiva whole web why rebbi akiva and I want to ask one more question if I may and that's a little deal there are 43 Vedas for which you bring a carbon catice rebbi akiva chooses one which one does he choose me Shanna scarve and let's assume on the allobr kala he wanted to eat Suman and instead he ate calif that's the example he beats no other examples you could say he wanted eat matza my mistaking a comet's doesn't say that he want to eat liver by mistake he ate blood doesn't say that not so let's assume on miss Campbell message of Allah be on a Calif it's not the first one of the 43 some one of them and in good motoring Christmas when the Gemara wants to discuss the carbon cactus this is usually the example that's brought in the mission also Chris's deaf enzyme there's many examples but this is the first example you want to each human and you ate calif so now we come to the final perspective of why or carbon Cantus needs Khepera what's so fascinating about this perspective is that at the same time that this explanation was sheared in the world of casa dos in the world of mister there was a Jew by the name of Sigmund Freud Sigmund Freud lived in the early 1900s his name wasn't Sigma and his name was Sigmund his Jewish name was schlemiel schlimazel freud although most people wouldn't know him by that lived in Vienna was a neurologist and became what's considered he's considered today to be the father of psychoanalysis Latoya voula motive and one of the most common phrases even in today's culture is that was a Freudian slip what strata Freudian slip we all make Freudian slips all the time what Freud often discussed was that there's a whole layer of human experience and emotions and instincts that lay beneath the conscious you don't know about it in other words the primary aspects of my personality I don't even know about I'm completely ignorant why I'm not conscious if you ask me Who am I so even if I'm being honest with you I can share with you my thoughts my instincts my craving my fears at least some of them but my unconscious layers I don't know they're unconscious and my brain doesn't filter my brain is a filter and it doesn't allow most of them to come into the conscious only in my dreams which is why he was obsessed with dreams because the dreams is a portal to the unconscious so you say this was a Freudian slip meaning you just slip it and you said something you didn't realize what you were saying but your unconscious was speaking through your mouth and you just revealed what you really thought now his was a complicated one which presumed that the person in his unconscious is pretty bad it's pretty dirty it's pretty filthy but the concept that there's a whole unconscious self that expresses itself in different ways and we may not be conscious of it that will suddenly see is the basis of the carbon catalyst thousands of years before SH lamella freud introduced psychoanalysis and I found this in two sources one in the Shamus school by Arabs Osaka covered the Shamy small was authored by a small barn and stained Bornstein the son of the Avenue nazar revived Ron Burns day he wrote a safer called Shane mission all the Hasidic master lived in soccer club in Poland and the same rules on Hamish and invited and more in South he highlights this point that's one similar and quite in a different language which I'll soon read I saw in a shoe is an accession a talk by the lubavitcher rebbe ascend Costera tuffsy nude base 1951 published in his lakota sis's vol 3 v Akira where he's actually explaining a random and he'll kiss my sire bond is based on this and a similar Mahalo let's see what the shame is small says this to Sheamus rules invite you Korea and serve we'll have them both shame a small South Tory Shayan Aleph the mahkum are said to chakra to oiler Takata Hafez the Torre says the oil add to be slaughtered which part of the Mishkan soften in the north and the trailer says inside the same place we bring the oil you have to slaughter the hapless and suffer the mean one says why can you just say Vishakha thy sake so far you know just like you do it by the oil or not but same place where you do the oily of do the hottest why such a roundabout way so we all understand who the Train is trying to say the reason you have to do it in something is because the oiler that's why doesn't just say do it in suffered it's because dial dr. shame wish more veneer RP Masha cassava no shaking in are shaking she's nominees she's fail a very lovely das the shaking that did you commits without knowledge he doesn't know whom a smash Aviv and I'm acquire his stoic a cloistered over he really has a craving to do that he has a great really he does not crazy I've sure how you saw him unless I see much mysterious I mean is Boris he never did it could he's a good show God said not to do it but he wants to do it he just doesn't know he wants to do it but he wants to do it he never did it so how did he how do you do something when you want to do it you make a mistake who makes the mistake you're unconscious Macomber can me after she stoic Lazare Harry Ashley he bores ahead over there is an unconscious connection between him and this reality volcano misdemeanor lovey-dovey rosella virile of Michigan it happens to him now this is a fascinating insight you didn't choose it you forgot you forgot you don't know the law the blood happened to be here the hail of happened to be here you thought it was Schumer consciously you were completely not involved unconsciously saying you have a deep connection you have a deep craving and therefore somehow you attract this reality and it happens to you the Capote Hiyama she stated I love Claire the atonement is not that he did it now the atonement is because basically there is a deep connection there's a deep craving the in cane sugar capita Irish a fetch the hay balers ever hear my shovel alkane to inertia itís often possession through you but Ali Laurey sketch artist Nami a capital hero a lathe Kimmi Euler the oil of the Gomorrah says in svaha MS Muhammed I'll hear her lave it atones for thoughts of the heart craving of the heart that's what the carbonyl atones he says what's the fat dose it's the same thing it's not what you did what you did was my mistake it's the heater I lave it's the internal unconscious desire and craving that the person has that is what the person needs a carbon form via kurta fresh I an olive 1911 via days au Vanina not sure you get may I involve miss demolish a leash she is giving money civil Amaterasu opera how can I do make a mistake and why does he need atonement who had over Shi Ishi eighths ahora see me as English taking with Marisa this is a man that he ate Sahara blinded him and he has a craving to something else actually allowed I tell us I say Bassianus Rama Lama is PR chef he never thought of doing it because he's careful to do with God what once mccormick i'ma a fresh herb is missing I am a mistake okay love quietly simple devadasi a cooker by days a misdemeanor lava De La Salle Avril of Michigan the Seamus rule says he has a craving to it now the shameless moooo apparently he has a conscious craving to it not an unconscious craving but he never did it why did he not do it because he's a good shoe he doesn't want to do it but he has a craving he's connected why does it happen him by mistake he attracts it because he has a conscious craving so the shame is small actually doesn't it seems doesn't say that they're craving this unconscious he may be aware of the craving but he would never do it but the fact that it happens Tim as but as a result of the craving that he had earlier which may be conscious that somehow puts him into this position that he makes the mistake his conscious craving causes an unconscious act an unconscious relationship in ways that he's not in control of and that's what he's bringing the Caparo for the chuka which is similar to the oiler that's why it's often and he says elsewhere it's often comes from the word hidden it's often Devon Ezra says why is it called soften because the Sun is hidden there the Sun is hidden cuz it's the north it's cold so it's often is the place of hiddenness in other words it's the hidden craving not the action but the previous craving that may even be hidden at the moment because now it was a mistake you weren't aware of it now now I want to bring you the second source I'm gonna read two paragraphs in Yiddish and will be understandably akiva I'm going to read two paragraphs and Yiddish does gopher but the Manship you can't begain unavailable shogi is above eyes as neatly as daft design well they've all given via staff design but we need to dust the file in our filler in our gig via stapler you ordinal its article oven the fact that the person commits a show gig which is my mistake means that there's something in the soul that is tainted because if not if there would be no connection this would not happen to him the mistake would not happen to him when does first in my surveillance given our Bechet gig is up in an aggravation plant that gun from our gig that's evident how nice of amazes in a way the show gig demonstrates a spiritual issue that is more complex than amazing why why well then I managed to topple the back of anomie ditoy vice Anita far zarifa leave them Tiffin for boon from the management as adversary katana as kenzan is the gun society's enemy they pull the cook mauritius hacia who Norman's Ankara Garcia Underdark Ivana Vedas by welfare Halton Alberta Paul Oliver stood side by infancy Helene is he doc abhava saves an mo hosts as the meat is for bun design if forces differ from qivana Vedas on deliberate citizen instinctive to turn a deep hole as soon as our each tank businesses I replica member majse of a pile when I do something but maze it which part of me is involved in the Avera my conscious self I know I'm doing it I'm upset I'm angry I'm mad I'm lazy I'm not in the mood I hate whatever it is I do it so what's involved my revealed consciousness when I do this I get my consciousness is not doing an avail I don't know what shop is I don't know Jim keeper I don't know it's a live I don't know the blood I don't know it's a sin and yet I'm doing it why am i doing it because there's an unconscious connection between me and that act if not well your honor what Sadiq call over there is a craving there is a relationship there is a connection but I can't even identify it in fact it's unconscious and if it's unconscious it means it's rooted in my vette the essence in my very eye that deeper then might count yourself and therefrom unaware of the relationship and it's coming out in a mistake that's the Caparo of the psychic and in many ways it's more than amazing which explains a fascinating thing and that is the Gemara says in some of him the Gemara says in suaq him that an awesome thali in many ways is more stringent than a carbon hatless the kumara says in Svartholm that man has an ashram thali what's an ashram thali an ashram table is if you have a Suffolk if you did that very Bechet gig meaning you ate something and you're not sure it was hail earth you may have eaten hail of you may have not eaten Caleb you bring an ashram Tolly it's not you sure you're a trailer by mistake and that the Gemara says isn't a more expensive carbon than a hatless why it seems so strange here you're not even sure the shot is that here you're so deeply connected you can't even identify that you did it so it may even be deeper in the person and unconscious of the purse so this is the idea that the show you it needs Khepera because the show you get is a window into what's happening in my essence and the trailer is allowing me and saying you have an opportunity here to figure out who you really are you have an opportunity to figure out where your unconscious wish Marcus you didn't just do it by mistake this is a Freudian slip it was a slip I know but the slip came from somewhere it came from your essence and you're unaware of it that means it's deeper in you it's beyond your das it's beyond your cough honor it wasn't filtered through your consciousness and that's why instinctively you can behave in this way you need you need the kaepora according to this it becomes crystal clear why the primary example for carbon hatice's always you want to each human and instead you ate kala from all the 43 that's what rebbi akiva uses and that's where the Gemara usually uses when you have an example of campus you wanted to eat Suman you ate faileth why because essentially that captures the essence of the carbon Karthus every carbon Coty's is really about that why so let me read one more paragraph of decision we bound as the Austral Decapolis ceviche gig come on Dom it's a de guiche Mack Vassar Houghton's a hasted us as verse philosophy is raised only design is there in out for them Suffolk in versus anti-node season fire Gilligan is a motor day care others anti-node is Rothman Alex Lannon a serdica on the river Blanc de Guevara the dogma of our team Tolly Suffolk Calif Suffolk Shulman while hey Larry Sherman comin from Tainan the fatty parts of meat Shuman is of course associated with pleasure with the light there's two types of tie nope it is a tie no gov Calif and there's a pleasure of Schumann Schumann is permitted pleasure and caleb is forbidden pleasure when I commit on a very buggy cosmic solemn I wanted to eat Schumann and I ate hail of what's really happening in every situation whatever it may be it's basically revealing where my pleasure is it's basically revealing that I may think my pleasure is Schumann but really my pleasure is Calif every carbon catalyst for any one of the 43 thins is essentially metaphoric it's expressed in allegorically in this in this point you want to eat human but really you a tailless you thought your time of your fat is permissible but look at that variable show you get means that you ate a live in other words that there's an underlying unconscious pleasure and connection the things that may be contrary to the true design of your soul so what's the Caparo of the show you good the Caparo of the show a gig is or shoddy gig is a window into the unconscious which may reveal much deeper components about your true personality even then things that you did be maze it because you did it by mistake you didn't plan to do that Vader but it tells you much more about who you are and the carbon hotness is a window into that which now explains to us why rebbi akiva wept by these troops of and this is what the master customer says in Paris mattes he quotes two cameras one is an omen earlier conditioned off by Allah from an Aleph and one is Messiah their hair it's a mess after smokers let's take a look the third source from the bottom kaduche andhave Aleph Emet Aleph rabbi akiva have a Miss Lloyd sits bravely availa your back Eva used to mock people who sin with immorality he used to mock what did he say he said I don't understand how people have such little self-control I don't understand how can a person fall so low uremic odd in Malay Sutton kiss asseveration tickler one day the Sutton appeared to Rabbi Akiva like a woman on the top of a palm tree knocked Ayla dikhhla the Casal it was Arabic Eva was Toso taken by the sight he started to climb the palm tree swiftly enthusiastically and energetically to go to the palm tree to meet this person came Attila Paul needed ickler softly as he reached halfway in mid palm tree chovka the suddenly left him alone meaning he stopped feigning the image of the woman he went back to his regular self arabic eva saw that there was really nothing there and that was the end of the sag Marda Sutton said he loved democracy by rakia he's our uber about Kiva Vittorio sorry CV seal Adama tired tamale if not that they announced in heaven be careful with rakia and hysteria I would have reduced your blood your value your dignity to two cheap coins in other words I would have proved that the great trivia Kiva is also capable of immoral behavior so rebbi akiva don't mock and are very rare and say yeah why can they control themselves because in a moment of truth when one experienced such a powerful urging where would have regretted me Akiva it says the Mexico comma now you understand why he cried now you understand why he cried in Paris Marcus what happened in Paris mattes she was drinking wine she thought she was doing something wrong really she wasn't doing anything wrong Hashem used the fleshy meat sack apart where every Akiva was climbing up the palm tree says the master Karuma he thought what is he climbing towards climbing to a woman really what was he climbing towards have a love all a sudden who will just make games so essentially there was nothing wrong going on it was just a test so every Akiva wept from this PASOK realizing that it applied to his own life what about the second posture compassion vehicular and this is another Gomorrah massage cetera ferrets pay exile on Rebecca Rebecca versus coyote Lakshmi she lifts make a comment this is this is how I began serving the hakama Pamela so you seem Hollis Madera comatose amazed Mitzvah one day I'm traveling on the road and I find a may submit so what's amazing it's ver a corpse and there's nobody available no relatives no friends we'll take care of treating the corpse with dignity and burying it and a logically every Jew encounters amazement was obligated to tend to the mace mitzvah and take care of its final needs of burial etc when it's Paul T boy car boss mill and actually Macy lahmacun quarters become art I worked with this corpse for four million approximately four kilometers I walked with his corpse until I brought it to a cemetery and I buried the maze mitzvah shahboz severe it's a sad normally favorable as a very really sure when I came and I related the events to my rappers rebellious in AB you are the great Hanoi who taught to me Akiva unruly they told me these words I'll call COC airship Asato my lucky Lucia factor damn lucky every step that you took to the cemetery it's considered like you pour an innocent blood why the answer is when you're sure I came in Texas roll one of the institutions was mace Mitzvah kinda McClane my meaning when somebody dies there's no relatives there's nobody to take care of it there's a halakha that he owns this place what do I mean this place wherever you find them you can bury him right there even though it's not a public cemetery mace Mitzvah kinda mikuma whenever akima took this mace mitzvah and he carried it for miles it was compromising the dignity that this mace mitzvah deserved and therefore they used this strong term of sh a factor damn lucky pouring innocent blood even though the person obviously was gone the person has died already but compromising the dignity of the body that's what they told her be a Kiva a mighty lehem I said Raboy sigh my Devi's llama Wow in bashar SanDisk avanti looseness high ft bashar shallowness Kevon Tila soos Allah has come of a comma in this case what was my intention my intention was to be there for the mace mitzvah to do something good and yet I was guilty because I made a mistake so if somebody doesn't have such intentions certainly my oyster surely is a steam it lays a steamy love Shama Shama Shama at that moment I knew I cannot move away from being in the present serving being attentive to comedic a common and I'm a sexist Marcus he adds pain technology tests show you I am Davos Elif Laribee Akiva Hyori mizzou is Achilles who see wherever Akiva was ever told this thore and people told the Star Trek he always said this was the beginning of my schools this was the beginning of my merit when I realized the need for shimmers tell me the hakama realized their blessing to be sure didn't tell them Keva you violated a halacha maybe a Kiva it's not the din they said something else I'll cope they made it very personal I'll cope coz it's a fact that I'm not be they realize they didn't know they could ascender be a keeper that's not the hello sir they made it very personal on every step that you took a fact that I'm lucky that's what she was tell me that's how much you mean the common means doesn't mean you go to a sheared ever ever of your shiva shiva tell me their common means there's the personal relationship their ever doesn't tell them the halacha is different I'll call see you see every step that you took only somebody that you trust and somebody who trusts you your confidence you could speak this way it's about you and every step that you took with such harsh language Rebbe akima obviously the receiver was a gala for this he says who I should kill us Cruces dr. Sameach wherever you keep a limp ashes vehicular about the carbon cars he started to cry he said mad dogs if somebody wants to eat Chaumont and he hates eats hailer in other words he wants the kosher meat and it made me even a mitzvah to eat it maybe and still he ate Halen by mistake he needs Coppola he started to cry why did he start crying because it was his own story where was it his story the secretary ferrets his intention was to bury a mace mitzvah and yet he compromised its dignity inadvertently it caused him to weep but what's fascinating is when they told the story to rebbi akiva he always said zoo heisuke lassoo see what Stila susi rebbi akiva saw the mistake as the beginning of a sauce because it became educational it taught him about the need of shimmers tell me there's a common it taught him of the need to have a real River it showed him what he was lacking so it became a source it was transformed that's the carbon hot dose the carbon cthis is not your unconscious is rapping decadent and therefore you're a hopeless person on the contrary the carbon catalyst is don't be afraid of your unconscious of course there are demons and skeletons and ghosts in the unconscious thus as immense as share no siesta especially if you're a leader thus as I meant they are there here the urban hotness is the opportunity to identify it to expose it to put light under it and to turn it into asked us to use it as an education to figure out who you are and what you're capable of becoming have a wonderful week next not sunday image session there's a shear will do on Pesach ah about pay Sophia Bruce until you are dying yeah banka banka banka banka banka thing thank you thank you so much so that's prattler your ulna let's add the call oven inna cutters borrow homemade meat accommodate subjective our unconscious knows more than we think the unconscious doesn't work black and white he wanted to carry without a native it means there's something about Shabbos that is not wholesome in him doesn't mean he wants to carry without a native the NOI eggs are harder for them that means there's something about Shabbos that's unwholesome there's something about Shabbos in him that's not full understand it comes out coming all fighting and slips you don't say with us it comes out in different ways and since it comes out of different ways since it comes what happened everything it's fine it's since it comes out in different ways so you're Mengele Watson the unconscious if you shop did something you didn't explain it be sure we cover myself this is the human fallacy this is the char but still there the shmita whatever there's something there - right right but you understand what I'm saying it's not that he has a tither - carry on Shabbos when there's no hater it means that there's something in his unconscious about the concept of Shabbos that doesn't sit well with them to some the some something in his consciousness something in his consciousness that he has to work through something that is unwholesome in his consciousness about shoppers that he has to work for no we're not blaming the person for having unconscious issues that's not the issue that's the whole point they we're not blaming it could become a source it's the honesty don't be perfect be accountable don't be afraid of saying I have to look beyond the surface I have to go and deeper and see what's really going on don't be afraid of it that's the carbon conscience that's often with a bigger battle well the small time is that he had a stroke occurs and he even knows about their psychic us that that's what's much more from him but mainly he did it he ended up doing it right and look at the cities that's more yeah that's more even though there - there - it's not stunned because as a result of their cyclicals now is a mistake it means unconsciously you got into this situation so that's that's itself is very Freudian so to speak and they look at the Citizen of art is that it could be the whole desire is unconscious it's completely unconscious and it may even be deeper in many ways than the arsh um yeah and and the are subtly is sometimes even more harsh than the softest because over there there's not even a wake-up call it's called repression and the ocean Poland is repression and repression is worse because you're not even aware of it ah ha how do I know about Freud I don't know how do you know about who wrote the paper you're a psychologist okay give me your kind thank you thank you for joining us Chikara so you have three penis you have a carbon awesome that's amazing you did something amazing thank you thank you Tuesday morning in recession here in 9:30 you have a carbon our show needed something but may is it consciously you did something wrong you have a carbon hap us you did something to show you good but now you're aware of it so your unconscious has emerged into awareness and you're accountable for you do a Khepera you have an ashram totally here is refreshing depression is it unconscious and it's repressed because you're not even allowing yourself to figure out if you did it for sure this is DISA Suffolk there's a Suffolk so you're still struggling did it happen they're not able to wrap the Gemara eat cotton the future says that when a person is next in something right so either he did it or he did part of it or he had episode Shuker of doing it so he has a Suffolk this episode shyness but he's not letting himself become aware of it in other words there's repression and repression that's even worse and that's why it's state of course mossad the hate mitts are the thefts of the state right what's up the Tate the fact that there was a married on a conscious level you can computer show you two amazing right here because an hour then I went and got the cheese but we keep us right right I think there's two different premise in other words Mossad the world of his galas of course the Maison de maíz it is far worse whatsa the world of moments are the world of essence which I avoid this ashamed eponymous the show gig is something concealed so I think and also with a sham I am in the person Malaysian mind with the person yeah I think that's the Milo yeah that's the my lon Binyamin Amram you Shayan I'm was the God Ladakh I'm Rama's the God Allah Daria but it's a good China why these for the new couldn't but all these four were crucial Amram relative to moisture was a part of she was the God Lord are in the sense that he was the teacher right but I'm Ramos from Chavous LaVey he wasn't involved it doesn't seem like it was involved in that I'm Hager he was the God Lord are incensed that he was atomic Aachen he was he was the leader in that sense as far as godless of Tyler moisture nabe know a dying can bank backup singers backup somewhere yeah yeah yeah yeah Felicity Rice's a heft it's still only for juice why because the theft sir is always relative to the governor you understand yeah in other words if I have a certain blood type so a certain food is not good for me it's the hefts of the food but only my blood type is sensitive to that type of craft sir so that's a Marshall by a guy in a Jew the soul of the Jew is sensitive to this type of heft sir the soul of the guy is not sensor this type of craft sir you understand Master Karuma I'll tell you the measure hakama is in per mattes he just says this happened to him looking condition this happened him look at Eric Harris he's not doesn't say more he just says it happened to him [Music] you [Music]