Time Zones In Hilchos Shabbos Vyom Tov - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

a crime of illusion in real higham tells an amazing story the TAS was giving a once and a woman barged in he said help my son is dying please help him so the ties with his great another said I'm not through buying some how could I help him he goes no I don't mean utah's I mean your Torah discussive Tyra could the pass success but davara dava has that I really am him and the tasks is fine we're going to give discuss about learning to this child and miraculously immediately the child had a recovery obviously Tyra is Keohane Calle envira Camino on a very literal sense and it's very reassuring and it's a great physic to see didn't want to learn even in such trying times and I hope I will learn he should be as close Fagin scleral especially a Sequoia tabla Sbarro bald sympathizer keeping the tire going and to a wonderful you did David pine who came to my house it was willing to record this so close well could see it and let's continue learning and holding onto the a time of Tyra and will certainly see the end to this epidemic it is hash soccer practice as it always is when you deal with it see birth at the sugar that I prepared to learn with this week besides being Nigeria Allah Allah mice besides being a quiche Miccosukee is asougi we could say tang liqueur can be el comité a very big a very broad saga so I'll try to give the basics and each person the time that we have now there's more time for learning because of this situation we could take advantage of harnessing more the car you have Tara discursive tire so I'll say Taylor Holcomb but yeah come on I'll give you the outline and each person on his own in his own time could delve into it to Ed and certainly they want to call me with questions I'll be glad to hear the question is a very basic question a very fundamental question a certain sense a global question I am in my house and Friday afternoon and I pick up a phone and I call a guy a guy you should work with narratives row and I start talking to him is that a problem after all for the guy it is Shabbos proper energy cell I'm telling you what to do is that a mere lockup for the great job is for me it's Friday or how about I go - err - selfie Optive and as we know a Ben Fullerton in your energy cell has to keep you up to Shanee so I have to keep all of the Ilocos of um - Shady but - my Israeli relative it's already is - hug or hala might can I ask them to do Malacca for me or a more timely question and I was looking forward to the summer months this many people make early Shabbos if I made early Shabbos and I'm ready after kiddush after my roof can I ask my neighbor to do Malacca for me if it's still day if it's still Friday afternoon it's still before skia and these and many other questions are the focus of our share this morning but if you want to reduce it to one simple intriguing and maybe it sounds like a funny question but it's certainly not is it possible for me to be Mahalo Shabbos or Mahalo your motive on Friday and that's basically what it is or is it possible for me to Mahalo Shabbos by having someone who it's Friday do Malacca for me I am talking to a guy for him at Shabbos but to me it's Friday how could I be i Yvonne's little Shabbos so that's the question that we're gonna have to try to find a precedent for this question so it comes to mind there's an absolutely fascinating question imagine ah he spent Shabbos in England and after Shabbos I boarded a Concorde I guess we could say he's the cradle of Rockets no longer in existence but it was feasible that I got onto a plane after Shabbos in England and I flew to America and it landed in America when it is still Shabbos okay it's also possible with the various time zones and a person crosses the the from one country to the other and he goes over the International Dateline but the question is simple I kept Shabbos and now I land in this in a country that it is Shabbos again and the poised Kim seemed to agree it's a very nice tool but c'est l'homme okay like dollop a gimbal that I have to keep Shabbos even though I already kept job as I land in America I have to keep Shabbos and maybe I shouldn't even do that trick because I'm flying into a Shabbos zone okay it's you doing the Gary ABBA in the milk debate Tyrol I made hay and it's called in the Pisgah chuva simulation and base felt that if once you've kept your keeper and you fly into a zone that's not that you Kippur again you don't have to keep a second Yom Kippur but the post-game seem to agree that if I keep Shabbos and I fly into a country that it's still Shabbos I have to keep Shabbos again uh-huh is that what we're looking for because I already kept Shabbos so why do I have to keep Shabbos again is that Araya that I could be McCarl Shabbos on a weekday the answer is of course it's not Araya the reason why the pace can feel that I have to keep Shabbos in America is because Shabbos depends on where I am so it doesn't help that I kept Shabbos once I wasn't yet sir Shabbos is wherever you are so I kept Shabbos but I'm sorry for - a second job is wonderful but our case is fundamentally different I'm in America on Friday and I'm talking to my god on Shabbos where's these little shoppers if it's still Friday for me I am in a total Friday zone so I'll tell you another question and let's consider this you need an imagination but I'll soon tell you a better muscle imagine I'm sitting in my house in Brooklyn Friday afternoon at six o'clock Erev Shabbos it's an hour and a half before skia but I have a very very long string okay you need an imagination for this and the string goes all the way to an old fashioned apartment and mage to RM that's attached to someone's light bulb with a little chain I pull my long string and I put on a lie in arity stroll an apartment in Asia Orem is that full Shabbos I'm in Friday zone in America and I do Malacca in arity Cyril effect now today you don't need imagination for this Schuyler imagine I'm sitting Friday afternoon or my house in Brooklyn and with a remote control like I activate a factory to start working and arity stroll on Shabbos that's the little Shabbos so the pace game seemed to agree it's not why not because you can't be makalah Shabbos on Friday but again that's not Araya to our case because at the end of the day there is no Hill Shabbos taking place on Friday I am in America I do Malakand America who cares if the melaka takes place in Eretz Israel but I can't be mahalo Shabbos on American and America on Friday but our case is fundamentally different because the guy that's doing the melaka is doing melaka on Shabbos in Eretz Israel or the ye'd that's do Milazzo for me when am i early Shabbos is doing melaka on my Shabbos so we need another precedent perhaps think about this I am I have a vending machine in a place in a camp and they are going to shoot workers so we once spoke about this according to most place it might keep the vending machine open even though going by soda on Shabbos uh-huh why is it motor the answer is if I'm not doing anything why should it be awesome so maybe the same applies I could call a guy inherit Israel I could ask my neighbor the Milwaukee if my early Shabbos if I don't do anything I am NOT held responsible but again it's not a Ryan because here there's no human being do maloca I set up a machine and the Machine does melaka so that indeed is a mellitus base on a base Hill and my sector sharpest a few Italian the concept of janeshia shop she says Calum and weep askin that there is no fear of services Calum just like I could put up a roach island right before this man Friday afternoon and it cooks into Shabbos it's okay because I didn't do any Malacca so - I could set up a machine that does Malacca on Shabbos so that's why those cases are muta of course you have to worry about Kenyan on Shabbos and maybe start Shabbos if initial but the basic gist side is if there's no human doing the lock on Shabbos there's no Hillel Shabbos but our case I am delegating a guy or Lahav to my neighbor to do Malacca for me on Shabbos this is a Malacca taking place by a human being so then I thought of a well known some safer in our time Samantha's love the muscles sue some cipher has his tremendous you cite its quoted often some cipher says that many mixes you can't delegate Ashley oh I can't tell some of the put on tefillin for me because my body has to wit fill them the same is regarding our various are various I am now out of doing availa said that Sam safer when it comes to Shabbos the midst of Shabbos is uniquely different Shabbos my good I have to rest and therefore said to some safer if I have a guy do Malacca for me on Shabbos the concept of sleepless doesn't really apply because my goof was not I rested on Shabbos and that's the basis of the myths of Shabbos so if I'm not violating Malacca personally there would be no fellowship as their eyes even if I delegate Ashley F and even though even if sleepless would be effective and the base mayor in a Vanessa Simmons a Steve dollar has the same aside because Shabbos is all about goofing off oh this isn't lightning it doesn't make it different if someone else does Malacca the quest is me was I resting or not now perhaps we could apply that to our concept I am keeping sharpest of my early Shabbos or I am keeping Friday who cares if the go does melaka iñárritu stroll on Shabbos but the truth is although that some safe and the base mayor said it but it certainly needs some fine-tuning it can't be as it is that if I do nothing I'm okay because it's a plastic in the Torah that says differently it's actually necessary said Idris the Torah says I have to keep Shabbos Lusaka melaka at Benza vltava my young children have the FIR the hem tougher in fact my animal can do melaka on my behalf that's the concept of shri says be empty needless to say my animal is not Jewish and is certainly not Hickey Allah FINA so why is there a problem if my animal does Malacca why is he a problem if I instruct a cotton to do Malacca my behalf the answer is part of my Shabbos extends to my children Lahav with my Bahama and as will soon see even to a mere lockup so definitely even though my GU fight what my good was not it's still possible civil Shabbos if something that's an extension of me does Malacca and again the greatest rally is I can tell a greater do Malacca for me on Chavez I'm I goof is enough but we look at it as if it's me that's doing that skill of Shabbos so now we're back to our group of questions can I call on Friday afternoon ago to do Malacca for me on Chavez Narcisse row or I made an early Shabbos or a young to Cheney question how do we classify this unique situation because of different time zones I could be Friday and my delegate whether it's a guy or a year dinner to throw is doing melaka so similar sufi knobs to come let us have some similar satire in this time is in crisis let me tell you a Gomorrah that seems outdated but a reality it's extremely relevant for our subject Saldivar and Shabbos Cookman Aleph Mottola autumn la ilaha very smartly perishable mhmm now let me explain it very simple imagine it's me and you and Orchard in that order like ABC I live to the left you live in the center and on the far right is an orchard an apple orchard that belongs to me now this the logistics is simple I could walk to you on Shabbos because you're within my areas but my orchard is out of my thumb I can't go to my own watch it I could go to you but here's the catch you are closer to the watch it than I am and you could walk to the orchard so says the Gemara I could walk to you on Shabbos and tell you please go to my orchard and watch might watch it now the question that's obvious is what's going on here if I'm our to go to my orchard because it's out of the tongue how could I tell you to go there on Shabbos I'm instructing and doing it so for me because to me it's absolutely awesome either I wanted to go to that orchard more so I'm now at a talk about Malaka even if I don't do my walk I'm I want to say tomorrow I'm going to paint my house that's the Easter dura born of a debate over I'm not I talked about my little Shabbos even if I don't do it so how could I tell you go to my orchard if I mean that's cooked at home so it's an asura bonham so I am talking about a clear-cut essa and indeed the rajma on that Kumar asked this question but let me read the answer because his words are the assay that we need for this morning dr. Abbott rajma the Kevon Shalom what early Israel Kaveri LeSean ROM ain Bamie rasoi clung since you the me eat living in the middle is allowed to go to that orchard because it's within his tongue so I could tell him to go to the orchard on my behalf now it seems like the raspberry phrase the question but I know it's not for my friend to go but I'm out to go a can go to see I know B could go to see but I can't so how could I tell him to do that so ty reading the husband's very push it since my friend we call him B is allowed to go to C so going to see from be my friend going to the orchard is not a little Shabbos it's a mice ejeta so I'm telling to do a head what's wrong with telling you either do a head on Shabbos I minimally it's the debate over because the because for me going to the orchard is awesome but that's the point as the rajma apparently since for him to go to the orchard is motor it is not implicitly a muscle Shabbos I'm telling him to do a head so to go to the orchard from my friend is not a fellow Shabbos and therefore not a violation of the debate over now rabbis say let's think is this relevant to our question perhaps don't forget I made early Shabbos I can't do anything but my friend is for Friday afternoon he didn't get Makabe Shabbos so me telling him to put on the light seems very similar to this camera because it's motor for him and the effort it's motivated is no with that bird over I'm as far as I'm concerned and if you said that Berkshire Covanta that's the next words of the rajma dr. Raja from here I could learn if a year Emma gave me to speak keep the same case if I'm a Kabul Shabbos I could tell my friend who was not yet in the Kabul Shabbos to the Malacca plainness Harvey NASA's beretta noise soy sir give out mommy's what we're looking for since for me it's not color shirt for him it's national Shabbos I could help to do it so in other words he's taking the Gemara of the orchard and applying it literally exactly to our case of early Shabbos I could tell my neighbor to do melaka for me now he doesn't spell this out but I think it's posted that would also explain why there's no violation of a dabber dub because true for me to put on a light is collage Shabbos but to tell my friend to put our light is perfectly motor so BS Serbia OBS Turkish Mac let me even make this mortgage Mac because if I tell a guy to do Malacca for me on Shabbos even though for the guy there's no hello Shabbos but the deeper is our sub because this action is awesome that's the killer Shabbos for me to tell a guy to do it so if that's the low Shabbos it's also the dabra dabra because this action is absolutely awesome and that's talk with the rajma says don't mistake mistakenly think that you're allowed to tell the go to the Malacca on Shabbos because if it's Shabbos for everybody it's awesome but this case where it's not Shabbos for my friend the Rajab is convinced I could tell them do Malacca for me and the bright side this is the custom-made sauce that we're looking for our shylu for me it's Shabbos and I can't do anything but if I tell a year to do Malacca my behalf it's motor and there's no bird a bird of but here we come to the last piece of this beautiful puzzle and the ran on our gomorian Shabbos Valley a nanny going daemul awry I don't understand the rajma quotes the rajma said I understand because the case of the orchard has one redeeming factor that the early sharpest doesn't because says they're deer on if I would have bargaining now this is a sugar bush Mitchum toffee and we'll get to enough cook none of my base but even though the orchard is out of my tongue but if I would have little huts along the way which extends my tongue then I myself could go to that orchard now again I don't get into the details but it's sort of similar but it's not exactly like I put down an air cumin but bargaining is homes along the way that extends the tongue but whatever the exact details of Borg is not Nagaya but if there are Borg Ihnen even if that put on will soon see even if a guy put them on Shabbos so now I personally can walk to my apple orchard on Shabbos is up there and that's why it's awesome that's why I'm so that's why it's multa because the case of orchard is accessible even for me but tine is there on the early Shabbos true for the year that's my neighbor it's perfectly motor but for me it is never motor to do malecon shops so in other words what Tehran is introducing us to an interesting concept there were three levels of Easter 'm this one that is motor for nobody but nobody so will Shabbos on Shabbos there's no heart of anybody then there's an issue for me but not for you early Shabbos but for me it's never Motorola Shabbos and then is the case of orchard the game on Shabbos cofilin Aleph that that is taco motor for him and feasibly motor for me if I had an abortion in so dr. Ron to be motor we have to have both redeeming factors number one the other person could do it and feasibly I could do it had there been bargaining but the FO says Duran and I understand why that's looked up because the Milwaukee is not absolutely categorically also familiar even but the case of the early Shabbos for the one that made early Shabbos it's totally awesome now apparently the Ron felt that we have to reduce this to a non my cerissa objectively and if I ever had to do it in anyway it's fine but the early Shabbos is no Hector but the Razvi understood no as long as what I tell the yet to do I tell them to do Malacca it's much to for him it's motive for me but wait we haven't seen anything yet tied at the base the isof in the end of some of gimel I know the Veyrons question early shop this is also a subjectivism because had I that made early shop is not made early Shabbos so it wouldn't be us it's still an hour before skia so what's the Iran's problem early Shabbos says the base Yosef is like the case of the orchard now more than the bassist ina he's implying that to be met to be Mako to allow me to tell my neighbor to do melosa I need both preconditions number one it's motive for him and it's feasibly multitude me had I made early Shabbos however the big kasha that the back the trisha and the grace marlak all on the base Yosef in the underage sam agimo what they all ask is that understand you had the option of not making early Shabbos wonderful but once you made early Shabbos its Shabbos and it's there's no it's not revocable the Huayra so one of their saying is the whole premise is wrong you don't have to have an a way of you on me I should say I don't have to wait I don't have to have a way of doing melaka that Malacca and Shabbos because once I made early shop is it Shabbos but the point is as long as for the other person it's motive I could tell him do why is it motive for him it's not in my system and fellini for me it's not a Depot I sued now from here on in there's a lot has been written to try to understand the base Yosef the back that the tires and our semen the end of a summer chemo has a long stick he calls it a chuhwa beautiful if you have time I'd advise you look it up but he seems to hold you don't have to have both preconditions it's enough if I tell to do am i selected for him that's fine the muharram says differently they have a noise in the back has a beautiful discussion the lavash ace ROTC for cotton lamb with the master shekel and when I found really beautiful the Lu Robin sees cotton Lambeth press comes from a totally different angle and he says wait a minute even the early Shabbos is vocable how if I made Shabbos is irrevocable so we mentioned something that we discussed in a share once for the bush holds even though I made early Shabbos that's because it's a form of another but I could be shiawase Minetta I could be Martin ed and I could revoke my early Shabbos so what he's saying is that even the early Shabbos is revocable but replace we have a very big agenda still so let me just finalize this question the Shannara in the end of race Sam of chemo says clearly if I made early Shabbos I could tell you to do melaka the mr. brewer and see if economy giant oarfish elfin in cific evolved both seem to say it's motor simply because the year that's doing it is not doing a my system in other words you don't have to have both preconditions it's enough if I tell they eat the Malacca and it's motive for him even if I can't revoke the early Shabbos makes no difference the mechana problem seems to be much clearer but we have the Taz mr. brewer or cachaça and let's be very clear even though for me it's Shabbos if for you that's doing it there is no Hillel Shabbos it's motive for me to instruct you to do them alone now let us enjoy the fruit of our labor let us apply this to the numerous shyness and let's start with a simple chart that I big that we began with I made early Shabbos I need a melaka to be done I could go to my next-door neighbor asking the melaka for me and it's Motum even if I already davon my rib and I'm ready-made kiddush alright for me it's really really Shabbos the answer so what's your boss a timer as long as I you are allowed to do that melosa I can instruct him do that melaka I saw the Rav Shaul Newark and see if her face spells it out even if I didn't just make early Shabbos but I'd I've admired and I would add and I even if I made kiddush but since for you it's motor I could instruct you to do Malaga next question is a fascinating Shila let's say I am a Moroccan Lutz's I cherish every I relish every moment of Shabbos and I like to keep a very late matera Shabbos my next-door neighbor waits for 72 and then does Malacca and I decide I want to have a special binding Shabbos by Sudesh lishus and I would say I want a pizza but that's inappropriate I want a hot soup for sooo delicious can I go to my neighbor who ready-made Abdullah and say after this man and is the cooked me a hot soup that get a fish out let's do this so it sounds strange how are you gonna eat hot soup that was cooked on your Shabbos it sounds intimidating how could I tell them to do it I'm talking to an issue for me how could I enjoy the soup and how could I tell them cook soup for me it's Shabbos it sounds like there's a bunch of his serum but the boys say this is mama shower rajma since for him it's perfectly motor to do melaka now cuz they eat the main I've dollar I can instruct him to do that but I'll tell you something even more beautiful even the Ron would agree this is motor I for me it's Shabbos true but don't forget since I could say Burke I'm out of the Mikoto circle at any given moment even I could cook that soup in other words for me to tell a year to do melaka on early Shabbos Friday afternoon like Tehran is not mota because I can't revoke the early Shabbos but for me to telling it mallamma to Shabbos after he made Abdullah even like the Ronnie's mother so maturely Shabbos is more motor than Friday afternoon if you said that Burke say Covanta that that's the remote and Musa see if cotton says and there are more in chiffon eric says cause gain the might sorry Shabbos I could instruct a year to do melaka for me even though it is Shabbos proper for me and the Makarov ROM explains why is it called cane because in this case even I could end the Shabbos in a split second Ibrahim a flamenco additional call so we see early Shabbos is somewhat of a malaika's late mature Shabbos all agree it's not tough for me to have that hot soup again I don't know if it fits into the Shabbos scheme but that would be more now let me ask you an internee question I made early Shabbos Friday afternoon and I decide I want a book not a safer a book I want to read a book on newspaper talk about a newspaper allow to read on Shabbos can I tell my neighbor go and buy me a newspaper I'll get that book for me now see running what's it different but you spoke about that I could tell you to do a locker for me and early Shabbos but I'll tell you a question that I once heard from a hospital a sick what's my Hector to tell him to go buy me a newspaper I am talking about Malacca on my Shabbos I'm telling a year to do Malacca for me on Shabbos that's the debate over I we just learned to rajma the Senora I could tell you to melaka for me on early Shabbos maybe that's only at var mitzvah whence once this environment slow or it served Shabbos the east of the dabber dava is waived because there's no Vidarbha double mocha mitzvah so that's why if I need the oven on I need the lights on the egg is Iran I could tell my neighbor to do Malacca for me but if it's not environment fear it's not a real sorry Shabbos maybe it's wrong for me to tell to do it because there's an insipid I beg of ER however I must tell you that the rajma and the Shannara who are Martin be telling my neighbor to do melaka and there was no reservation there was no bed Varlamov vomit so why not the answer is very posh it because since as we explained for him to buy it a paper to do melaka is natural Shabbos so me instructing him to go buy your paper is not necessary debate over it's not a miser because for him it's not a miser when is the doubled over or sir I'll tell you if on Shabbos I say I'm going to paint my house tomorrow so that's also for guns Claro but in this case I'm telling you buy me a paper la jolla it would be motive even if it's not environments listen to another fascinating question a woman was Messiah to macabre Shabbos early and I should mention that in this trying times it's a very exclusive women light Shabbos marries earlier so she let her hair foul before the ski and then she realized that the forgot to put a light on can she ask her young son to put the light on see one what's decided we just learned this in fact I could even she could even tell a neighbor a girl to put the light on so what's the shy about telling her young son but listen to this tremendous you say that I saw I could ask my neighbor to put on the light but I can't ask my left hand to put on the direct light for my right hand I can't do Malacca for my self right since the plastic says in parishes Israel assassin Malacca at vinco Vita foe and of course that's not virtual Shabbos because that's even a young child like Lahav de la Bahama what is the Easter of Africa BAM the club and Ben Hur that's an extension of my Shabbos the mother's Shabbos so therefore reasons the covers your and the say from a car came and I was simin the underage time of gimel if a woman Cinda lift or Makabe Shabbos actually doesn't say specifically that Marshall but he says when someone's Wakaba Shabbos he cannot his instruct his own Charles do melaka because that's a part of his Chavez true you could ask your neighbor but not your own son and if Starbuck inhale again will pay base has also the same analysis he has a longer tube and he calls it a possible it's at the rice to instruct my child do melaka for me after my early Shabbos in other words a neighbor's fine my son for my daughter is like my left hand for my right hand while this sounds convincing it's hard to say because the second arc is mightier the Raju is not there telling a year and doesn't say that children are different the only question is what's the smaller the favor the crime is right how could I tell my own child that's a part of me but there's one fundamental difference when a cotton does melaka for me on Shabbos even if his lady Gila henna its pillow Shabbos on Shabbos but when the child does malach on Friday for him at school Friday it's nice little Shabbos how can I be over on Phil Shabbos when there's a melaka done on Friday says raava's man Caleb of Simon Lambeth Tess he was asked this question also doesn't quote no comic are Khayyam but he says this is not a problem because the child that's due Malacca in at slum um coil ain't or a sin melaka at slice as it's a failed exam I'm a classic n ATS Lloyd um she she there's no is to Malacca in other words it's mama she how are you site to tell a cotton to the Malacca on Shabbos it's a malefic Shabbos that's attributed to me to tell a child to the Malacca on Friday is not full Shabbos so although the macaque I am was man come here and perhaps someone wants to be my collectible car hi I'm Tommy la bracha but there wasn't as I told you in to chew visible I'm at rezaian Lambert hey is mego because for the cotton it is not yet shops now let's really enjoy simcha cetera and let me tell you two other questions but I want to make I want you to enjoy as much as I did so I'm gonna make this very clear with one case I am in America on Erev Shabbos Friday afternoon I call terror oh my god yes you work up and I tell them listen you know it's a busy season and let's assume I don't but I own a matzo bakery I say listen right after 72 minutes after your says Shabbos open the matzo bakery I really I want to do a lot of business we need to sell matzah so the guy tells you boss whatever you say goes but you realize that if I open 72 minutes after this manner it's in Israel I'm working for you on your Shabbos because when it's Saturday night well that's a great speaks in there it is row it still Shabbos for you and then the guy who's alarmed and explains I'm glad I don't have to keep Shabbos I'm just can't do work for you on Shabbos if I'm gonna open them out to bakery right if the Shabbos is over true in Israel it's not jobless but for you at Shabbos whatever you say boss but don't forget you are doing something wrong I'm working for you on your Shabbos that was the guy right it sounds strange the guys do Malacca I might say Shabbos what's the problem but here's the problem a guy who's never equipped to keep Shabbos I should shove a sky of Mesa it's just attributed to me so if he's doing the locker for me when it's Shabbos in America maybe he's rent let me talk make this even clearer I tell a girl you shoot my Gary super key here in America on Friday afternoon I want you to paint my house tomorrow for me so that's awesome even though I told him on Friday but if he does malach on Shabbos it's all your awesome so how could I tell him to do open the matzah bakery even though it's after this man in there it's Israel but for me it still sharpest because I live in America and is another seven hours left to Shabbos so although I once found a mock mirror in this and there are Mahavira I should say but there's a big sad logical how can there be fellow Shabbos if the action took place on my sorry Shabbos Amir Allah akhom is also when Malacca was done on Shabbos for example the other case I mentioned I tell my guys should work on Friday paint my house on Shabbos so the deed was on Friday that doesn't that's fine but the actual maloja took place by a guy on my Shabbos and his Shabbos but in this case the guys Oh bring them out to bakery amatory Shabbos with the collage artists but we could do much better this is mama our rajma if I could tell a lead on the early Shabbos for me to do melaka because for him it's not Shabbos so why can I tell a guy do Malacca when it's my turn sharpest and that seems to be the consensus of the pie scheme that I can instruct a guy to do melaka and air to throw on my sari Shabbos even though for those seven hours it will be Shabbos for me in America but wait the simplest area continues let's say I call from America five o'clock Erev Shabbos I have a gauge to worker in arity Stroh and I tell him ok I want you to do this and this I want you to do some melaka and my factory in Eretz Israel so the guy says very shocked you know my location it is Shabbos here I don't think it's by anionic Shabbos or by a Tish but that's exactly the time an artist wrote this is my mischievous so I can do work for you because it's Shabbos here so you snap back I'm the boss and for me it's Friday he says been open I'm a Shabbos on my Shabbos I can do that who's right it sounds funny but this is much worse because here the glory is doing melaka on Shabbos for me but if you want to really appreciate this question imagine this which is very common I pick up a phone Friday afternoon and I'm talking to a guy in every straw when it's 12 o'clock Friday night so I am mommy's stem is stimulating Malacca that's done by the guy on Shabbos for me now again this sounds really intimidating but this one obviously redeeming factor how is it shy Phillips Shabbos for me if for me it's five o'clock Friday afternoon of course the guy is doing Moloch on Shabbos to go it's possible Moloch on Shabbos when is Amelia aqua more so when it's Shabbos for him and Shabbos for me here at Shabbos for him but it's weekday for me and I would say it custom and I say fur and that's indeed why the price came many post-game I can't say all agree I did find my familiar but many place can feel that I could talk to a guy and tell him to melaka when four in a row and it's Shabbos but for me it's still Friday listen to an interesting my sister hyah Kaguya someone had a business a true story had a business in America and went to Shabbos when authorities roll for a Hassan and Shabbos ever brothers he's sitting by the Shabbos Sheva breakfast and it's rural and he realized I can't believe it I never had to question Here I am it's Shabbos for me and my store is open in America because America seven hours behind if they were a problem if his store is being run in America when he's a narrative stroll and it's real Shabbos not early Shabbos it's real Shabbos so the patella - Heil again will cook off a so that's the problem you have Eden or going more both working for you on your Shabbos he says but the mini gets to be Michael so a michael says this rag on maryland outlet cook few days and he wrote over to the potato karma I don't know what the problem is of course in your store it's in America velakis being done but who cares about your store the question is you where are you what's your location for you at Shabbos very good but for them it's weekday it's not the fact that you have Shabbos so your store becomes Shabbos you are an artiste row its shop is wonderful but you stores in America America is Friday and if you're not there come on to a military make oh there's no source to be awesome but and here's the big but sometimes this question takes a very unfortunate turn I heard this story from a ye'd be they heavy of them he was working Friday afternoon he's a Salesman he got a call from Ramat Gan and arity stroll and was friday afternoon around 5 o'clock and he's talking to an Israeli and then he said melissad once lokahi says isn't it Shabbos for you sooner princess yeah I didn't load that tea I'm amber I'm not worried so the hidden America hung up the phone he was talking to a year selling an item on Shabbos she hung up the phone then the phone rang again he picks it up and all sudden they get said foot spa he was all upset boys it's not a foot spa this is a serious lift neva because even though for me it's Friday afternoon there's no hello Shabbos but if I talk to a need the narrative throw where it's Shabbos that's a lift Nev I'm causing a year to do melaka rock monoliths lana i for me it's friday that's totally irrelevant I'm causing a year to the Moloch on Shabbos now you might say but a phone call is only a troponin but that is certainly wrong it might be their opponent but the e that causes that Fri ye to do Milwaukee's Ivan at the rice of lift neva and as Dominica spinach and Rachel on midday says if I caused a year to do is sent there are born on he didn't listen their opponent but I earnest of their I saw was my Eva because even if they're born on is at least like an aid to show you know he ganas so I must stress but we're talking about this morning was telling a guy and a guy do Malacca whenever does he eat involved or monoliths lawn you're talking about a serious lift knee Eva and somebody as to what's the eight zone so I told them what were my Yasha once responded to that question they asked them what's the age of a certain problem he said there's ox donates of faults who said there's an eight sir I can't be mad to lift knee Eva so again let's be clear we're talking about but with the year a fry year this left me Eva also I want to make a point that we spoke about the time zones America Derek's row the same is also applicable from New York to California where there's a three-hour difference of course it's not as dramatic but the same questions apply now consider the next question I am Friday afternoon in my business and I send the facts to Eretz Israel or facts or any correspondence email I do something in America on Friday afternoon that goes all the way there it is row and cause the Malacca to take place and air it is row when it's Shabbos proper so if the receivers of fryer yet we're talking about that's naive oh we're talking about either the guy receives it or there's no response suggests it's registered I send email without any listener Ava so this you wondering what's the Schuyler for me it's Friday how can I be a fellow Shabbos but you have to think about that and we analyze this question because true I'm in America on Friday but my maloja goes all the way to Eretz Israel maybe that's like my have a long your diarrhea there it goes all the way from America and does Malakand Eretz Israel and indeed melaka mom nafta beatles Oberstein and the end of Albert Cook days consider this to be the truth I can't do him a lot in America that goes all the way 30 sir but the truth is I saw many many points key and I say this can't be and even if step even the malama knife just throws out the question I don't think he held like that Lamesa because I didn't my hand didn't go to Eretz Israel I activated a Kaylie technology to do molecularity throw that's not me if I'll be able to stretch my hand from America dare to throw theoretically that might be a problem but says abstain is almani on botanical Farsi I'm enraged pay olive shaving or ladies tests mmmm oh and the way of moisture out of cook for tests and the a mokuba Simon Lama Dolloff regarding an answering machine this isn't really a problem the kanay by seven kala gimel simony adalat is also make oh he has a different problem ayan shun but I saw the mcdonoughs Elio and kala Calif could get mo correctly assumed that that's not a problem so I think we could say I could send the fax email or any melaka and again remote control be a perfect example I could remote using remote control started a melaka taking place in aren t Stroh because the end of the day I am Friday my hand did not extend there it is throw and therefore there is no Little Shop is as far as I'm concerned now the pace can do caution if you send any type of correspondence that makes noise in the receivers home with a muscle you talk on a answering machine and they're singing the singing is mera Shabbos and you start telling my whole speech that is disparaging kedusha Shabbos that's optional so which is not just a heritage to camera and myself to Shabbos it's get its capacity national creation and base and after symbols and it's a terrabona so any noise that contradicts the serenity of Shabbos or even some people say sending effects and if it comes into the person's house and it makes a noise okay regarding a fact some also say that the papers look so but that's not my point the point is the aside that I want to say is that I am in Erica Friday and I somehow do Malacca in Erica stroll through technology but if I didn't put my hand that arity thrilled that's like a long string that I pull from my house in there it's Israel or remote control or it's like putting up a Ruolin Friday afternoon and indeed to send the fax or email or anything else without the problem of option Melissa should be motive now we her - I'll up a baby was born late Friday afternoon in America and the people wanted to call the grandparents narratives role so again to call leave a message and the receivers hear the message that seems to be optional so but they had an idea they would call the guruship aide who's living with their grandparents narratives role and great will pick up the phone and they would relay the message through the guy a shade so that's fine the guy could pick up the phone even though the guy is in Shabbos but the guy is picking the phone for their own purpose but here's the question if the grandparent sees the phone ringing and tells the guy they pick up the phone that's a miracle for the grandparent because Baron arity stroll the guy's married stroll and malakas taking place in there it is room now some people like to call their parents there through I wish them a good Shabbos and they speak into the answering machine that's not really a good in Shabbos that's really sort of an optional so you're causing sound to be created in a Shabbos home and that certainly should be avoided and now we come to the last group of questions and let me be very clear we are changing the setting we're changing the story till now we spoke about Shabbos now we're talking about yom tov Shanee and here's the case one case I live in foots lurtz I'm saving to go to artist Ralphie empty so it's so young tavini let's talk in an extreme case for me our crane shall Pesach aboard Lena Latoya for the people narratives role is Ezra cog cervix of the gelt Alexa de Velde is a regular day that's no longer um t'v so picture the scenario I am by my Ariel relatives in their tannerite stroll for me it's Yom Tov Shane with all the restrictions I don't with Phil in and hide avignon Tim I'm a kiddush and for their Matisse Rashad can I ask my relative the binary Teatro to do Malacca for me for them it is too hard for me to UM to Shanee I know it's all disorienting but it's very simple I'm gonna have a day of um to Shanee in a environment that is is true hug Sarai boy say what's the shire how could it for me I can't do below how could I ask them but for us today its loss like me - this is manage the Rajah because truthfully it's um - Shane II but from of my relatives its history ugh just like I could tell my neighbor do Malacca for me on early Shabbos even though it's Shabbos for me but for them it's okay so certainly yom tov Shaney and indeed the merry cash in his Chuba Zola Yaakov Simon Sadiq was he asked this very question and he says emphatically ain't some need nerd is sir benfits larette's mu mu Lavandera to sir lastly malacca beyond of Shanee this is in Simmons Sadiq of all the Yaakov and his source is our rajma but replace a perhaps we can even go a step further maybe not only the Rosberg will permit this even the run would also permit it because me right now I can - Malik on Yom Tov Shanee but if I decide I am staying in arity throw a vecerka stroke overtakes me I am staying in Eretz Israel I'm living in there extra for the rest of my life guess what I could do melaka under Shaney so maybe this is even better than the early sharpest case with Iran had reservations because you can't do Malik on Shabbos here it's possible that I could even do Maliki on to shaney even today if I decide with a of course with a sincere resolution to stay energy strong so therefore young to Cheney I could tell my relative the Malacca for me according to all days however the Guiness Virata who lived after the Mary cash in that legit Zion quotes this Mary cash and he says I have a big problem but listen to his beautiful iron file its scaling its cloud that lets him in your Zion then I'm asked over so he says let's we analyze that point but been cuts let's never ever ever could do malawi up the shana narratives row if he decides to change his status and move there at Israel he became a been Eretz Israel then he could do Malacca but a benifits Lauritz is never able do Melania deshaney so therefore reasons the Guinness Rodham Ange some of shares the benfits Lars called a smile of Leo Shia bahattin Malacca be up to Cheney and he has a beautiful Raya the Morris says that an evident is not as not yet yes my baguette in and different halakhah ramification but and ever it has no is to get ah you can become a been hiring there is one is the BEM car is that an effort so Ben Eric such words can never do my lava and even though that the darkest the katana but you should know the burqa Joseph and Tufts are devolved Aled McKeever eager on the page tough side involve the posish ocean and based as Volvo moistened Dalek of Zion man Josh Lyman you test gimbal and this seems to be the minik Israel that have been quits Lauritzen Eretz robe when mock me should not do Malacca on Yom Tov Shanee it is a banner throughout the Malacca for him apparently it's the China of the Guiness Rodham and I would also believe it's because jump - a knee does need great physical and therefore we try to keep this control now consider the next question I am the same Bend coach leritz I went there it's well for young to the same story but I have another shine I have a business a flourishing business and arity Stroh so I'm going to keep young to Shanee with all its all office that's what the local dictates I'm fine can my business remain open for them its issue hug can I have my business whether it's hidden or Guardium continue to Rick to the gelser it to the belt it's a hug and this is very common to those that have business in Eretz Israel but the MS is dr. moisture in that beautiful children I mentioned hailing down the cookies at Cove Zion for me to tell them to be open up you got a work come on it sister cog is wrong because I can tell them do melaka sake tell network work for me for my store but if they open because for them it's issue hug there's no problem because there's no D book to them I'm saying Salman in memcache Lima I love you test is also Mako but it's more than a technicality because they are doing their thing now the happens really working for me but could be they forgot about that they're working for themselves to make Panozzo so here it comes somewhat ironic they can't instruct them to melaka and they decide they don't want work I can't force them to go to work but if they do on their own I could allow my store to be open because it's a arity searle enterprise now let me ask you a really intriguing question can I in yalta Shanee ask a guy to do melaka for me I won't ask my neighbor I want to ask my relative because you told me not to can I ask a guy so the answers what's the Shila if you can't ask yet how could you ask a guy but I want to see a bigger status even like the merry cash that I can ask my relative to the Malacca for me because for them it is suicide it makes sense I can't have a go to Malacca why because a my relative it's young it's in Surat the guy doesn't have young divyam to Shane is so sad it's the status of the eat so if I am in having yom tov Shaney narratives role so the guy follows my status so it comes out of Big Finish I think it's true that I can light the merry cash which we don't pass in that way but I try to bring at that point I can't I can ask it to melaka for me but I can't ask your guy but let me just be clear we don't we passed you don't ask you yet either but I wanted you to have that beautiful finish la loca listen to a different question I know I am but imagine I am the binary cheese roll I live in Eretz Israel I have a factory in America can I allow the factory to operate on Yom Tov Shanee in America in other words for me it is with Ag and I tell the factory yeah you could spit you could open up on its roof ugh even though nari to throw even though in America it is purely yom tov shaney so obviously if I have you the sewer Kiska leelavathi let me open that's the flavor I have Olga you see work is and I'm not talking about I have a factory in a business district it has a non-jewish sounding name no one knows it's mine there's no zil's iyong tip there's no lift no Eva see here we have a reverse scenario a Ben arity Sorrell who's an artist Ralph not Israel can he have a factory of got you work is working on yom tov Shanie in america for him at issue hug sir zalman m'intosh layman allah Fiat eskimo has only one concern the main concern is zil's Olaf Yom Tov if it's a fancy ID knock him if it's you do it belongs to the Yid that's probably as ills william t'v but our case as we outlined where it's not as also young Tim it's not lift neva it is quite possible that that's mutter as long as no one will connect the factory to the Edition how about this question I am the same person for now I'm the Benares row and Heritage Hall is roof AG paisa I called my guy you see work who's in America and I start talking to him and I tell him to do something for me so Clara there there's no problem because for me it's a suit AG there's no zero if a guy does Malacca and I found in shape it cost C and bass qualify in Zion that says just this he says like I told you that the is no reason to be mocked me herd of robbers Malcolm he does understand why he thinks it's posh it believed pick book now listen to a interesting question but I'm gonna change settings for one moment I am back to being an American ok I tell my Yiddish should work in Eretz Israel please do business for me oh my matzah bakery right if the Shabbos is over for you so that we said earlier it's fun because for me it's Shabbos I understand but that's doing it it's not jobs my only question is is this thali in the previous mark like is Mary cash versus Guiness Ferelden where we saw that the that the Guiness rodham says that even though Lamesa you could change the become a binary to throw but since you are hustlers there's no Hector to have some of the melaka for you does that same mcquaig is apply to this question so I saw in the Shabbos fish about the tough fresh tomato fries I'm a dolphin I'm I could type it a beautiful Stickle on this whole sugar and he says this case is much better because I don't have to change my status of Ben which lets the Ben arity throw because all I have to do is fly thirty swell the fourth sharpest and I could do Moloch on the same but sorry Shabbos like they do so that's much more be your D I don't have to change my status I have to just find my location in there to throw and that's why it's Moodle holidays and Afghan club let me share with you another question that seems totally on a different part but it's really the same sugan i am ahmed the muscle to keep 72 minutes for doing elohim Ettore Shabbos my neighbor is fine with sixty can I ask him after 64 him to the Malacca for me if it's before 72 for me or more commonly I don't open cans or bottles or wrappers and my friend does can I ask him to Malacca for me so in a certain sense is a little trickier than the previous quick questions because the earlier questions I'm having a guy do Malacca so a shop is good okay but here I'm telling a year and I think you should wait for 72 he doesn't but I'm telling him to melaka what for me is Shabbos or open a can or maybe since his many gets to be maker what's the problem so here we come to what's really the last piece of the puzzle and it's mom is part about was sukhiya the same dark a moisture and Seif cotton says that I mentioned earlier on the right on the Quidditch open era quotes the rajma the Kamisha asks a startling question the tour in the end of tough race have died late writes that if some tsadikim Vinci Meister kept two days Yom Kippur that's not recommended but they did it so the Torah says they you have to be safe of course but they can instruct someone that's not keeping the second in Kippur the melaka for them fragged our camera how do we reconcile these two all office you can't tell a year that's keeping them keeping the vilaça for you but the rajma says that i make early Shabbos I could tell you to the Malacca for me since dark in Maya a beautiful posture to your site I made early Shabbos but I don't think he's doing wrong I'm right then he's right show them all you throw I could ask them a locker for me but if I truly believe that you have to keep two days Yom Kippur I'm not doing it because I'm nervous I feel you need two days in Kippur so for me it's a fill yom kippur that he's doing melaka so i'm not gonna tell him what to do but having do malacca for me that's like a very serious issue because i hold it's awesome to do melaka and therefore i can instruct them to do it so a voice say based on this I saw Ravana in Chevrolet VI Laughlin gimel and have stereo and other fresh lime adalat say in response to our group of questions it depends how you view your sheet if you hold like a beirut I'm a hundred percent and you really believe until 72 is closed Shabbos don't ask in able to do falafel for you I mean he has his right to his opinion but you can ask them a locker for you but if you don't really hold it's also it's a covering or a more common case of the opening cans you hold I know the madam Aquila I like to be mock me but if it's not an insert you could ask them to melaka for you but if you old it's an it's a gobbler then we point to that dark you moisture that it's awesome so let's cause what we learned today better Shem we definitely saw tires the best to square up hopefully you have tan the hakama alkaloid but basically in response to our original question the answer is no you can be Mahalo Shabbos if it's not yet Shabbos you can't be Mahalo you um tip if it's not yet Yom Tov but as we said you have to know the story if I already kept Shabbos and I fly from England with a Concorde into a Shabbos country its Shabbos it's a bonus and other Shabbos I have to keep Shabbos if I have a long string that pulls a light on from America 30 stroke or remote control it's not a other if them it's me do Malacca on Friday and gesundheit vending machines are allowed to be left open as far as mala is concerned that she says Caleb that's motive we are the Sam site for the base main site of goofing off but don't forget there is still ways of full of Shabbos of services where my katana and akhom most importantly saw the gomorian Shabbos then I could tell my friend to go to my orchard at Adam item because for him it's within his tongue the rajma explained it's not a miser but the Ratner and the rajma extended that to an early Shabbos I made Shabbos it's meat Shabbos 100% but I could come to Milan cause it's not yet Shabbos and we also six or perhaps another heta because the fact that I too didn't have to make you early Shabbos that might give me some leverage on my own but at the end of the day it seemed that the place can say that as long as what I tell to do is not solo Shabbos for him it's not Austin for me and it's not a violation of a table Raghava and therefore even after I was Makabe Shabbos and Davin and said kiddush I'm fully fully in Shabbos I can instruct Dermalogica for me and we came out that we said even for non essential Shabbos need the heard there's no it's of a debate over and it's motive and we also saw when I keep a late with sri Shabbos I could instruct a year that already made Abdullah if it's a after this man to cook me a hot soup for shelter Sugar's we saw that acquaintance Bosna a mother could tell her young child after she was Makabe Shabbos as long as the child wasn't to do melaka for her it's not like part of her it's a friday melaka for her on Shabbos me in America I could tell the guy iñárritu seldom allaha on me Habanera to show even though for me it's Shabbos I could tell to doom O'Laughlin tear its role on Shabbos or I could talk on phone to a guy and and air its role on Shabbos because to me it's Friday and we have to have Shabbos on both ends in Eretz Israel on Shabbos a store could be open that I own even though because Lamesa it's even though Chavez for me but Lamesa even though I'm an artist role on Shabbos my stores open on Friday and hustler it's fine because I'm not to melaka whenever you have a fryer person involved there's a serious lift Nativa doesn't seem to be an aid so I could send the facts or talk to an answering machine or any other communication when it's in America on Friday and it goes there it is well it's not a Yatta Yatta the only issue is optional so I could call a guy in arity stroll and talk to him even though for him at Shabbos unless it's an optional issue a benefit slide should not tell an area to Cheryl decoder melaka for Yom Tov Shanee for the benefits larette's a Ben Eric's role could work in the fact that I belong that it's owned by a Ben foots larette's and as long as he doesn't tell him to be open it's fine me and Erica stroll on yom tov Shanie i can tell the guy to the maloca for me even like the merry cash as we said hey Ben area as a factory hood sleds if there is certainly no sizzle Shabbos which is not the case usually there is but if there's no sizzle yom t'v all of my eva the factory could remain open but Ben arretez role in America Telugu could tell a guy could call a guy in the Amish a knee and foot slits and as we said to tell a year to do melaka for me for me it might only be a homer that i could tell them if I hold this awesome Amish it's Tucker problem and let's hope that this was of Tyria of all Yeadon should bring us his sewers and invoice for guns Clairol thank you very much