Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
progress. Okay, good morning everyone.
Shalom aleichem, baruchim haba'im.
Um
I you know, you're probably wondering,
"Where is everybody?"
Well, they they went to their sinks.
They they're They had They're trying to
figure out now how to wash netilat
yadayim. So, they they went out to get
like actual netilat yadayim cups. So,
they'll they'll eventually find an
actual cup
to wash their hands with
to start their day.
For example, this cup
Now, many people
for let's say kiddush, they'll take this
cup and they'll take a second one.
But, you could be like the guy selling
caps with the monkeys. You could
literally you could pile it up. You
could use 10,000 plastic cups. You still
can't make kiddush on it.
Really? Could anybody make kiddush? Yes.
If your mother is not Jewish, you can
make kiddush. Not You don't even have to
use two plastic, even one plastic cup,
you can make kiddush on it.
Okay. And you could even use schnapps.
You know what? I'll be lenient. If
you're not Jewish, you can even use
schnapps.
Okay. Just I thought I might mention
that. Okay, we're learning siman kuf nun
tes seif bet. Siman kuf nun tes seif
bet.
V'ha ne meeli she noito derech peh
l'ma'ala
shamma she mimenu min ha nekev
u'l'ma'ala eino chashuv k'chli
v'nimtza she'ein ha mayim ayodam me ha
kli.
This din
that
you're wa- This din that if there's a
hole in it,
there's an issue,
that's only
where you're washing
from the opening above.
So, that what's above the nekev is not a
clea. So, the water is not coming onto
your hand from a clea. In other words,
we just said if there's a hole in a
clea,
then
you can't use the clea for netilat
yadaim. Why not?
Because
even though below the hole, the
vessel could contain a revi'is, but
above the hole,
the vessel can't contain anything. So,
it comes out the water is touching the
part of the clea which is not a clea
because it doesn't contain anything cuz
there's a hole
below it.
Aval, however, im lo yito derech
hanekev, if you want to wash netilat
yadaim through the hole, shari, kivan
shema achzik revi'is mimenu ulmata.
Meaning like this.
You know, it is a good thing.
Now, this is going to be very hard for
you, okay? You see this non-clea over
here?
You see this plastic disposable
non-clea? You see this thing you can't
use for netilat yadaim or kiddush? Well,
I know you're going to have a hard time,
but make-believe for a minute it's made
out of metal, okay? And it's an actual
clea. Now,
now we're going to make a hole in it.
Okay? There's a hole now in the clea.
And this
Okay, there you go. There's a nice hole
in the clea.
Now, above the hole, it can't contain
anything.
So, when you're washing like that,
then you're not yotzei because the water
is coming from something which is not a
clea.
But, if you want to wash from the hole,
you want to pour on your hand from the
hole because from the hole and below, it
does contain a revi'is. So, you could do
that.
Meaning, it doesn't render the whole
thing not a clea. It renders the part
that can't contain a revi'is not a clea.
So, if you're pouring from the top,
derech piv, it's not going to work.
Aval, im lo yito derech hanekev, if
you're going to pour through the hole,
shari, kivan shema achzik revi'is mimenu
ulmata, since it contains or a vase from
below.
>> [snorts]
>> Okay,
I've a little
the reason you could do this
is cuz [snorts] below the hole is still
considered a clay human Shamash cuz it
contains a vase the machine
because what you wash from the hole have
it come out
me bars up.
It's like washing from a spigot the
common mistake.
There's no reason you can't wash from
the hole.
>> [snorts]
>> This entire presentation is the opinion
of the
Medina as the
who codifies the Halacha the words of
the tour
of Harvey
Hogan is that many disagree with this.
Namely
and they say that if it's an earthenware
clay that's that designated for liquid
the
whole thing's considered a broken piece
of pottery. They know
you can't use it at all a few
even through the hole.
In other words, this is the
says only from the whole and above is
not considered a clay. So therefore you
pour it like that the water's
coming from something that's not a clay,
but it doesn't render this whole item
that a clay.
However, the opinion of many
shout in says the smog the smack
and the says that's the
the Rajma.
And it's a little bit away from the grow
they say the whole thing is not a clay.
I why is the whole not like the bars of
hey?
>> [snorts]
>> Because the bars and was that way
initially, but here something broke.
You could be so on the machaber to be
machsher derech hanekev.
Could you make a bracha?
Interesting. What what would be better?
A plastic cup or a
a clee with a hole in it?
Yeah, what would be better? A plastic
cup or a clee in a hole? Well, the
Minchas Yitzchak would say, of course a
clee with a hole. A plastic cup is not a
clee.
The
Orlits Zion says
lechayera a hole with a clee because he
says if you don't have any other clee
and you only have a plastic cup, use a
plastic cup but don't make a bracha.
What would the halacha be with this cup
with a hole in it? Could you make a
bracha?
Maybe yeah, not sure.
But we did point out the diuk of the
Shvus Yitzchak from Rav Moshe that Rav
Moshe's issue with the disposable is
because for kos bracha you need kos
naya.
Which is mashe Rav Moshe holds it does
have a shem clee.
Okay.
Viter.
When we come home in England clearly out
of line over clear some you can off
line.
If you have earthenware that's
designated for food
that it's sheer regarding tuma
is
if it lets out an olive's worth meaning
we saw in Sif Aleph
that in order for a clay to put be
puzzle
it needs to be not just it lets out
water has to be
It needs to be clay nice mashka.
But clay Harris has a different sheer
regarding what would render it no longer
a clay by tuma. It's
a little bit of a different sheer.
Namely
um
if
it's a clay that has this larger sheer
to
remove it from being able to cover tuma
then everyone agrees you could be come
on the cover that if it has this little
hole you could wash neck of because it
may not even be considered uh no longer
a clay because of the hole in it.
Veda.
That according to what it's explained
later on in some of some of the mall
ducts us.
If you are going to be some kind of a
and wash that
the hole has to be somewhat big.
Believe I have to get that the flow of
water is continuous.
Otherwise, it might be also because it's
a
a partial washing in a wash where a drip
and then a drip and then a drip. So,
even if you're going to on the my
camera, it would have to be able to
produce a continuous flow.
This is all in a pressing circumstance.
For sure
you should be my hider to use a clean
shalom.
He's talking about a steady stream but
he's talking about
washing
that if literally is a tiny hole and it
will be a drip drip drip but if there's
any substantial hole
when he says big hole he means
like okay
like a crack that would drip through.
Right, or a tiny or a tiny hole where
the moisture comes out literally little
by little. Yeah, but any stream
whatsoever technically could be washed.
Yeah, yeah, yeah because it's
Yes,
as long as it's a continuous so it's
it's connected to all the the water in
the yes.
Yeah, okay we'll hold it over here.
Recording stopped.
You were
