Water / Electrical Damages In Halacha - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

thank you Hashem to welcome everyone to today's Year from our Jacobs at Smith Adina Hazard water electrical damages we heard a silent with someone he left a it was something faulty in the flushing of the bathroom and the landlord noticed after when he got his build it was an extra thousand dollar water bill the water was running the weather the stopper the flosser wasn't proper and over three months it was a thousand dollar extra water bill and he wanted him a high of his tenant to pay Tennessee I didn't do anything it was just running we had a child to wear a leak caused serious damage you know someone was using his water upstairs like regular during the summer the downstairs neighbor went away for the summer and the water was Dripping and left thousands of dollars of water damage tayadua before the wiring that caused extensive damage and caused the fire and these are the shells you make a brush for your sunny rough when you hear them you know thousands of dollars of damage and it's no one's fault but then again you know do you have to pay so the truth is the common denominator of this and today's sugya is it's not a conventional damage that a person did but it caused extensive damage of thousands of dollars you know his plot his faulty Plumbing or wiring caused extensive damage but if you use that word cause then you're inviting a very important you saw it and that is the gamar says the famous east side of Grandma minisak and Potter if you don't actually directly damage someone you cause damage for example one of the Michelle gives if someone's animal is locked up and it's little area and you open the gate and the animal escapes so you really didn't damage the animal but you cause damage anything Mario says grandma belizocket is soon see don't forget it's not he's not Potter he has these under persons Blacklist so maybe our cases should be a conventional grammar any Potter now but the embassies that we have to understand this because what does it mean Grandma Graham is anything you don't do be a dying I mean let's say a person if someone stabs someone else we understand that that's a mice to be a dying How about if someone shoots someone pulling the trigger is only a grum in a certain sense he didn't do anything be a dying someone shoots an arrow so Willy but he does he released the the the the bow and arrow and it shot but he didn't stab someone of course that's not true the question is how do we understand what is considered drama and what is considered his responsibility so here we come to a shank out of this sugya because it's not only this but but as we'll see we'll touch upon in a certain sense with this beautiful you saw it here's a Shyla and you'll be a pic okay someone is sleeping next to a wall sleeping safely but it's not a regular wall behind the wall there's a tremendous volume of water but he's safe because the wall is there Ace of comes along he's in a uh mode without paying the bill so innocently moves the wall and the water shoots out with a ferocious water pressure and kills victim on contact question is definitely a racist but look how it's only a grammar he didn't touch the verse he just moved the wall and he caused the water to shoot out but that's wrong this is and I warn you this negative electricity in an extremely important way it sounds outdated that maybe even the hypothetical but it's Mama's out with sugar is it's very similar I just made the case a little more user friendly but this is the gamer someone directed the water on to a victim and if nothing Mario says he tied him up but the rashash has lavdafi tied him up our case he moved the wall and the water shut out and killed the victim he's Hive Mrs best now serite my timer this is his arrow and just like on an arrow one move the wall so now we have two things to explain first of all why is only a grammar they move the wall and now why is an arrow not a regular drum but you have to realize if he's high of Mrs bezen that means it's a Bonafide Meister question is why so here we come to the keywords for today and that is it's your responsibility there's something that's called something that a person creates a force even though he technically did not do it Beyond but is your responsibility an arrow really technically you didn't do be a dime you didn't know it didn't personally take a knife and stab someone but since he released it the string and that koi created a force that killed someone that's his kayak the camera is saying and this way the yadrama one of them explained that moving a wall and releasing the water is no different than shooting an arrow and killing someone both are it's true it's not mice to be a diet but who cares is the punchline and that's why the gamara concludes behind the camera Papa giri did moving the wall is like an arrow it's but it's enough even in with sikha so for us certainly but wait you haven't seen anything yet listen to the next question you'll be you'll be the dying expert Ace of was also an expert Arch as we know when Asif shoots an arrow it's Bullseye the victim is God for catila okay and he shoots an arrow but the good news is victim has a shield that's guaranteed to save him he's holding the shield very carefully okay Haman comes along and he wants to get a receipt without paying the bill and he grabs The Shield at a victim's hand and asub's Bullseye kills the victim immediately I'll give him four choices ASAP Harmon both or none but let's be a little more exciting let's say ace of not only an expert Archer but he's very fast he shoots the arrow and he himself runs and takes away the shield and victim is laying dead foreign has this very case someone shoots an arrow but but the victim has a shield and someone else takes away the shield and you know if not ASAP no one is high if a man's laying dead he shot an arrow no one's High so here if you think about it we'd say well this is a stereotypical more of give me delay right had this gamar that I just told you been in Erica and somebody say asteris of suggestion but the story about moving the shield is the same amid base so it's not a Stephen and the turrets is very plush it because moving a wall you didn't do it be a dying but you created not you the Ace of created or released a force that killed someone without him and he let him created This ferocious Force shooting the arrow is but the victim had a shield as Rashi explains it's navigation so Ace is initial shooting the arrow was an application what did Haman do he took away the shield that didn't kill the person no one ever died from taking away your Shield what killed him the arrow that asaph did quote not be Hector but he was he was off the hook so you have two zeros to donate up shooting the arrows out of my services moving a shield is definitely now they are both grama but nothing nothing more and that's why even if hum ASAP did both parts two zerosome and this is basically the side of the same stickle in the yadrama on that Gamora who asked this theorem and he says this beautiful turrets but the point that we have to realize is that we have to learn to be Muslim not saying to think and not everything is grammar there are things that amazing moving a wall is enough of a mice to be a diamond that's actually Mrs now although the emo is talking about again it's an agent about but it's positive if even is it considered a retailer for that Cole's gain in his naziken it's his mice yeah but I'll tell you a little more than that where this concept is and let's say a person is making uh a fire for because of a strippers comments or for like he's having a barbecue he made a fire in his own house in his own backyard but he wasn't so careful the wind came and blew the fire not now here is mamish a girl he didn't do anything I mean he did something he made a fire but in his own business the wind came but some of the Wind so this is a posse in the tire comparison we spot them we're gonna land soon and you notice the ace went on its own um so it sounds like an unfortunate case of drama something challenges that magic is gonna have to pay so you started off with a grandma kisete and the pasik calls him a Bala bear or he didn't do anything I thought it's a grandma so this is those famous words you can't forget what Yeshiva is like your arrow foreign yes because what you have the magic of age if you're not careful it's considered your fire yeah so we see and this is interesting the magic of Ace one of the Arab of the zikin really essentially is only a grammar but the tourism as the Mahaba says although it's really a grammar because it's and you're not careful if a person is not careful the age becomes his action so yeah and you have to really know and the truth is once we're at it the whole Massacre one of the our brothers naziken is also only a grammar I dig a hole who hasn't to fall in I didn't push him in why'd you walk into my bar there it says not only the terrorist said it's yours even though it's a grandma but even though you don't you don't own the bar it's there makes it as his as his bar so pretty interesting that two out of the four maziken biggest side are grammers but so what this is now I could say the next question that would hopefully we'll have enough information to apply this Lamesa someone left an item in on his porch in his house which is a normal wind came along blew off the item and it smashed someone's windshield the car that was parked downstairs more than a grammar I mean I just I left my item I was just so this is the question is which what reason is if it damaged as it was flying as it was going it smashed through the windshield High new age because age the characteristics of Ashes this item is now what who cares what that what the hezek is a partial because let's say you did a damage to Tomlin so Asia's let's say Mara it landed in sarabim and then someone got hurt or damaged in your office Kingdom essay what magic is it bar who cares if it's bar a locker cares because if it's tackle bar then you put on Caleb come over like Caleb so if and a person got hurt you have to pay the person broke his item in in the bar you attack apart but the point is the negligence makes it either Ace Uber and talk of the Mahaba says regarding bar and top view it has regarding h How about if it's an unexpected win that you wouldn't even think happened that's the unexpected happened says why is it pasta there's this whatever it is but there's no any case of anonymous so let's review briefly what we saw that basically we have to learn but I know it but the basic is sorry that there's an automatic beer diet is and you have to identify what exactly is the status of that magic okay now let's apply it we'll try to organize it but I'll start with a very insightful case because it's going to give us a much better understanding of the silkyo this is my show and it's simple a woman was in hospital boxing was a happy occasion of a child Friday afternoon she's all panicky they're not letting her light candles they're giving out an electric uh electric lamp light it and that's it question with that and they make a Brach on it so again as I told you this is our beautiful you saw it that's really negative I'll give you this example okay she was written tough very sadly but he quotes an early YouTuber that was written in tough race 1903. afterwards and then electricity was just starting and there was an Autumn godlamoid who wrote a chuva and he said he doesn't know what electricity is but the way they explained to him he held the makam and I quote welcome sir could be allowed to put on a light on how could that be so we know that Allah is now this God of felt in 1903 I said in my city we don't have electricity he's lived in a city in Europe they didn't have lectures in 1903 but the way he was explained electricity is only a grum why so he was told that what does it mean a light is on or off so I'm going to give you a very good example the electricity goes the current goes and puts on or keeps on the light what happens when you close the lights you don't blow out a candle so this little piece of metal I'm just going to be mag my paper can be magnified many times over that goes that's put down and the current goes and hits the paper and can't go the light goes off how do you put on the lights you don't like the match you pick up the wall and the electricity continues to go so this place is that it's only a grammar and my mom said the facts are not correct again he wrote together I don't know electricity he said when you put on a lot you're really connecting the wires so it's a nice Grandma but besides that he made a big mistake because he learned that it's only picking up the wall why is it possible listen to his einfeld it's like the Amara's case of removing a twist removing the shield gamara says only a grammar so opening a light moving the shields only a drama made a mistake it's not true it's not the case of the tourists but listen to this the Shanghai the silgia what is it very similar to the case of bitco de Maya you move the wall electricity goes just like he moved the wall and the water shoots out and kills someone is a Bonafide wait say yeah so moving a little wall and allowing electricity that's waiting to go through foreign now it's unbelievable and outdated the almost hypothetical case of person sleeping by the wall and the trees is mamish electricity and tough champagne was one of the big proponents who said and wrote and spoke about this that electricity is not a drama from Melton she writes this now you write about electricity but he writes some going the rain or going Israel is the steam was a unparalleled I heard from this triple going that is not gonna die the right shoes about electricity because then people say oh he holds it's more awesome and I hold it smooth I'm also among them there's no childhood [Applause] the rise of electricity now you understand it it's a bonafide maester that you're doing but the amethyst today which you see today and that is the famous rush in Buffalo with the rush almost asked it but come out he's very big kids I it's only a grandma you throw it up in the air and the wind blows away the chef why is that a grammar Terrace if that's the Derek it's becomes a mice to be a dime it's not a grum so electricity also even had it been defeat to USA your grandma but that's where you put on the light you know when you put on a light it's not a magic it's that's the way it's done in a much more severe way today we're living in the world of technology not yet there will be there is already a but see if the person claps his hands and the light goes on a person could talk and the light goes on I spoke to a year he told me he had a surgery performed by Dr robot today there are surges done by robots and they say it's more efficient which tells us if I can say it's only a grammar I mean you have to you have to work in each case individually but I'm always saying if that's it coming back to our if the woman wants the light does not know the choice but Lighting electric manager is correct it's not a grammar which wouldn't justify the word the haddock it's a nice to be a diet is a general discussion about electricity and Shabbos and yomptu and he says it's not considered a grandma it's a vadimaiser so Allah does work I should mention the Urology have a problem from a technicality and that is that electricity typically is not all stored in your menorah or when you apply it it's constantly being generated and brought to where you need electricity so they both taina both Mohamed isn't concerned when I put on electric manora there's no oil that's going to burn for the the amount the minimum amount of time it's just going the first SEC and there's more electricity so they're not worried about the word lahadic they're worrying about that it's not enough oil at the time of the program what's being generated and fed is not there because so that would put a stickle of a problem can you make it if you're not even you but the good news and I was told that in today because those wonderful organizations they are not really uh they are discouraged from using electric manures that have plugs because plugs in the hospital is not safe people tripping it so now they give out attack a battery battery says the organ scene is fine the McDonald's says it why because the power was there so I know that's why they do it but it's definitely a plus the good news a person could make on electric manager now some say it's not in there but it's really not accurate because it's not in there regarding Hanukkah because they have to have an age like in the in the basement here the point is does it is it an air like a big cover job it's an enig shop it's a challenge so yes the broccoli Nair can be said if there's nothing else to use I'll just give another example [Music] to the person in today's times he puts on a tractor and he does harisho or zeraya will anybody's right mind say it's it's a grammar he says every moment of the is attributable to the person why you myself so you see the word Arrow Gary delay is giving us clarity every Appliance you put it on it goes but it's not like it's someone else's fault that's mine sir that's Gary delay he also stresses that's the way it's done someone asked me and told me actually I saw this I also want to say for later a person does damage with remote control you know we're living in a world that you know is a very small world a person could be in his house depressed as a a button or use the phone and he puts on an appliance they want to make sure that everything is under their control they have the only access to putting on the oven he could be sitting in the steeper learning that and then if oh I gotta put on the oven he pressed a few buttons and he puts on enough in some places 100 miles away well anybody say it's Grandma this is a more sophisticated switch Molly switch light switch and Molly are you using a phone I saw a wonderful save for mishpatamazik he has a a sequel of this child must be a true story someone had his phone and he closed it but he left it on vibrate he wanted to make sure just in case it's a phone call he left about his edge of the table his friend called him want to speak to him the phone vibrated in other words danced a little bit and danced off the table and broke very simple you know I left it at the edge a little vibration and fell off the table is he a chroma which probably is but then again you didn't close it you let me call you I'm not I'm not trying to damage you so that would be annoying this gamma that is not responsible but it does end if indeed the person knew the story and with uh you know malicious intent called dafka to break the phone that would be amazing okay that's it that's what we call a long distance Magic there are many shilohs but I think it's all I want to say Manson a person cause damage with an electrical Appliance either it short-circuited it ruined the fuse ruined the appliance too much voltage they told him don't use this in this plug nah you know people have a lot of talk when it comes to appliances I someone had an afraid wiring so he decided that he's gonna put on a little tape on it you know Corbin and it did damage so in all these cases across the board you are employing Akai you put on Appliance you plug in Appliance you are harnessing the car for electricity that's not Bitcoin that's Bitcoin but basically that's that's considered his mice the Heart Tree I'll just tell you how how far reaching this is this goes back many years ago but it still was a relevant child someone wanted to clean the water of a Mikvah so they had the felt is that they had in the 50s when he wrote this juva the filter took out the water and put it back so when he says in those days the way the Matthias was that would be because it's the the human being that put on the the filter electrical filter it's like he took out the water and he put it back so it lost its status of my Mikvah because it's considered a mice to be a diet although the person didn't put it back because I am but the appliance that he used is considered zaina maisam and it's absolutely so the Geary delay electricity is well and alive that the guy that used the car of electricity to move wine that would be considered the gray moving wine because that's his mice we had a Shiloh we're summoned the the garbage compact stuff you go to a camper on the mountains a bungalow it's a huge pretty big machine and it smashes items now some was in a funny mood took his friends from the item and threw it in foreign that's considered using where do we find something similar to this says if someone takes someone's item and throws it into an H into a fire or into an ocean you might say well I didn't damage it the the ocean damage the fire damaged it but that's foolish you're using an existing kayak so today a garbage compactor any electrical appliance that does damage if someone throws it into that compactor it's like throwing into an Asia mine and a Vada he would be a magic someone had a child someone dropped his friend's cell phone into water and it got ruined awesome now you have to know other Island even even a psychic has been shiny maybe it's Potter but the point is you can't say I didn't do it if La Mesa this is your this is a person's mice we had a child and it's an important point to stress where there was faulty wiring in in the electric panel so the magic said listen I'm here to watch my age but this is my electric box and he had a sticker einfeld because it says to watch my age if the age is to watch my wood if someone bites my wood it doesn't matter so he felt maybe the same thing is here also I just have an electric faulty wiring someone used my wiring he's like using my my eight Sim you would but electricity wiring is H now we have to realize this you know wiring electricity is is a dangerous age I know my eyes saw a bungalow next door to mine during the summer burnt down to the ground what happened very simple during the night it's a good thing they woke up to the Escape otherwise would have been there but during it seems sometime that that day the a mouse ate up ate part of the refrigerator plug that was the extent of the story and that caused of course faulty wiring and electricity kept on feeding to making this fire and it's amazed they all survived because they ran out but trade wiring is dangerous 40 wiring is dangerous and this place felt that that's not like you appreciate it with wood electricity is eight a certain sense more dangerous than age so whether it's Outlets appliances electric boxes or or wiring we look at the electricity like Ace and that's the person's responsibility I'll give you another a Shyla someone lit near Shabbos on a table and they were not careful enough and a spark shadow of the near and burnt the hole in a tablecloth also got a burnt hole in the table also but does make a difference how much magic there is is that considered his responsibility so I didn't do anything I lit nervous it happened a while later a person's banging on an anvil and a spark shut out and they damaged his Hive and as capacity base now the truth is you might say well then he's banging so it's here I lit mine air and the the the the the the the gets the spark shout out afterwards but then again this is part of your Ace Ace of and the the eventual spark is nasiakis to the person and it's Hive on the on the fire damage someone gave a item to be repaired electrical applied even though today it's less than and less and less common and the repairman did a faulty job and he plugged it in and he the the item the motor burnt out and he did damage to the the Applause the electrical outlet also so it goes back to the payment it didn't work even once because I'm sorry but on my pages I I caused you damage that's it so that's wrong for two reasons first of all we have to remember what the what the gemara says now what that means the police can say it's best then we'll encourage him to pay they'll tell me that he should pay they won't be high of him but they could even announce and show Pliny is a guy ever didn't pay and I'm always more scared but they they shine them with the other but the Autumn I also my money but they share my mom and their buy some Blacklist I don't want to do that is almost like the day of them but more than that the police can tell this too to a common case you learn about the common side of Testament base if I have I I want to buy a coin anti-coin and I sell it to an expert oh yeah it's good it's good it's good investment and it's worth nothing the my advisor my expert advisori he has to pay for my loss why I relied on you I came to you and you didn't do a good job assessing the situation how much more so I give my Appliance to a official expert he told me it's good I'm allowed to I'm supposed to use it and it it burns up right away you gave me very bad advice more than that I probably could ask back for the repair money you didn't repair it you ruined it so it's not a grammar it's mighty ice ice to pay for it here's the next question I could use your help for this someone was allowed to use someone's apartment and electricity but he was negligent he left on an appliance that went and went and went and the person the owner Department had a huge electric bill in other words he's allowed to use it reasonably but he used it irresponsibly and accumulated a very big electric bill and he wants something listen that I'll you got to pay you allowed to use it but not like this but the magic says I'm only a grandma I didn't do anything wrong I put it on my head then it went so how do you look at a an accumulated electric bill that was that was really done with Shia or left on the CIA o we should say this is like bitco de Maya you put on the the now you put on the electric current okay let's see and electricity was generated later I did nothing but just myself is this so we would think this would be unfortunate you know to the uh to the to the to the music but really it's only well it's a little more complicated than I'm telling you but they gave it to us someone left on a dude Electric appliance that accumulated a Big Bill and the magic said I would I put it on beheta I was paying I was pushing I closing it so therefore my grandma so I was arisely the deposited he doesn't explain too much about it but he says it's not a ma it's not a grammar because [Applause] and he sells his soul to Gary delay in other of us understood when you put Appliance on even better every moment is your continuous action is excusable what transcended Hector and it was negligence is your mind so that's continuing and he has to pay for the big Bill okay the person says it we accept it we have to know according that it wasn't even January when she asked you put it on how do you connect that shave but one thing we will say we create another smarter besides this far that is of it's one long mice that's attributable to him but also this is Derek this way appliances work you don't put her on every moment it goes and just like as I lighten their Shabbos famous The Nair that's burning is my maisa here The Nair that's burning is my mice and I accumulated a bill and somehow we're going to say that it's considered zaina amaisa and his Hive to pay the extra bill that was unwarranted let's say a person put on Appliance at seven o'clock eight o'clock at the damage we would say well I caused the damage eight o'clock he says no if that's the Derek of them the max here goes and goes and you put on that Appliance with damn it at eight as ashamed said that's right now what's interesting is the following question someone was allowed to use someone's apartment including Frieza he used the freezer but didn't close it properly left it open you know pretty much open so after a while you know a free is supposed to go off and start again you know with a thermostat the fact that it was going going the motor burnt out but also obviously once the motor burnt out the food in the freezer it's got spoiled so I was the rights on the food he's only a grammar but on the broken freezer he's a massacre now he doesn't explain too much but I I could only explain this by saying that what when you put something on and it goes and goes it's a continuous so you put something on that broke the modem why to break the motor because it can't go so long but no doubt about it that what the the outlooking electricity is you put on an appliance it's your continuous Gary delay not even a grandma so on the food is it grandma on the broken Frieza is a mice to be a diet but I must mention the point you know today we're living in a in a more a a modern world but we have to apply the a new form of nasas that applies to tenants workers Yeshiva in a camp burning electricity will soon see running water it could be a form of a magic I heard of myself from a son of Quincy the old the Altus culinary album once went out of a bathroom washed his hands and then went back what happened so someone asked my height he says he has he has an opinion that when you close a lighter the light shouldn't burn unnecessarily so before but before he does any Mitzvah he always says you can't say it in the bathrooms he came out of the bathroom washed his hands said went back close the light and came out okay you don't have to say anymore you close the light but leaving on a light leaving on an appliance is a magic no I tell the baham you know Yeshiva is not an excuse you know you're learning you're busy learning so I told him but once learned that is the shore the ox the bar the group mother is the hey look at sadik was David father is [Applause] she says that this is a Sadiq that's waiting for the goal because you have to get a Azalea from the top shelf and you climb at a chair so far but you don't wipe up the chair and someone sits down on it so you made it to a mission you're a hey look up but was magic so you know a person could be a helical but he's Magic the point is his Haru we have to be careful today is going on on someone else's money the list goes on but a person has to be careful with the enemy's money the animals water he's a tenant or he's a bahren Yeshiva and hotel whatever it is unnecessarily burning electricity or wasting water could be a form of Hazard someone left the gas range on that's the problem how about so if it's on but the fire was off and it was just he's feeding gas and gas so it's extremely dangerous situation it could cause a huge explosion but the police can say that would be like bitco de Maya you put it on you cause the gas to go you didn't stop it so the entire gas bill would be attributed to the person now the truth is any damage a person does with water is obviously not a magic beer diet says he released water on his friend any Sky if because the concept of magic is loved Africa using a force throwing an arrow or throwing what is the same Hazard now usually water doesn't do damage but a somehow person puts on a water gun or a water hose or throws water and damage someone else or something's perhaps someone's property that's a Bonafide magic of Maya putting on a force that damaged someone's item is bitco de Maya without it's always the only issue is when does something becomes now this is an important point because the same gamorans and legends that says that when someone released the wall and the water killed the person on contact the mother said that's only by kayak mission is gram which is also bad but it's not quite what does it means when the water came out and and damaged close by if the water had to travel a distance that's right there he's still a grandma but not a retailer Frank the address but if you're saying that that giri delay an arrow never damages right there you shoot an average of flies a big distance so says the the defining factor of koyakshani is it doesn't damage in the first first the first gosh the first gosh could go and roll but still kayak Claire exchange like a second bounce it's not his mice now you have to realize that we're talking about water damages the difference of kayaking could be tens of thousands of dollars because someone's using his washing machine and the water drips and goes into someone's resource by the time it gets there it could be depending how it goes it runs on the ground goes through a hole how do we pass again what is so many reside him seem to go with the ajrama as long as it's the first burst of energy even if it has to roll even if it travels that's Geary delay but I must mention there's a of the Duran and others say this also that this concept of course any applies to a retail that's who the more says it Iran when you talk about a magic even if it's any so what does it how do you label it with zucked around we label it as garmi garmi means if something could do something that that the damage happens right away for example someone Burns he burns someone else's eye you now he can't collect so that could be a grammar but the murder calls it down me why the damage happened instantly you did a mice to the actual star and the damage is certain when you open the animal and Let's Escape you didn't touch the animal here you're burning the starchive and that's why the Iran says that even kayakshani is spotted by with sikha foreign but we could definitely say that even if someone will say that is minimally what is it gram and someone's not careful and causes water damage it could be it's got me and his minimally it's a grandma benizaka that's again we're more scared he said hey look at Sonic that does damage so again be careful with water damages in many different forms person has to be careful if he knows there's a problem with his washing machine or his or his dishwasher or any type of Plumbing if he's if he's a tenant tell the landlord but don't leave it go it could do damage that's Untold has it we had an interesting Shiloh where someone was driving along the street could have been a little more careful but we get to hit a puddle that that Splash onto someone's coat and he has to dry clean it that's a water damage but really it's not really I mean I didn't do it the car did it so that's foolish until today we'd say well it's Grandma but today we're going to say it's but it might be more than listen to this the two of us had rush and cuff out of hay has a child of someone's driving a horse riding a horse whatever the word is and he does damage with the horse so the rush says it's not my other it's not about magic it's automatic if someone's using in a force a kayak like a horse it becomes part of him and the damage of the horse is odama Magic foreign the same logic applies that someone's driving a car and he crashed into someone else's car it's not a grammar the car is being controlled by him it's considered like him and it's an automatic so if the person that was driving the car was driving along Ocean Parkway and if you slam on the brakes they shouldn't hit the puddle and get the fellas coat dirty and of course a six-car accident so you know the person should stand back but if the driver that hit the bottle could have been more careful and should have been more careful this is creating a kayak with him with part of him his car and there is 12 is a famous sponger that they take a bunch of water with a Vengeance and throw it on the ground so I heard a Shiloh once when someone didn't know that at the end of his kitchen there was a hole and on the sponge of what went down into his downstairs the neighbors uh apartment and did water damage so you have to know this probably in afghamina is a kayak question or not shiny the other Mao would hold his career and especially if you hold that there's a free of of in this case it would be very you're talking how did he should have been more careful he would have to pay for that water damage I'll give you an archaim case which is very negative especially I go to camp we have this island the bottom go and they want to have a they want to watch for a sandwich and no one brought along a case wash the hands so the child was the first time we had the Shyla they have a big water cooler there's a spout a lot of water can you wash with a water cooler which is like a big um a very very big thermos it's the wrong word but a big Kaylee and as a spouse and it's really drinking water can you use that to wash your hands so it's unbelievable how the whole Suge is really intertwined is very silent an old-fashioned water cooler you have a big jug of water with a spout so he says you allowed to wash with it but you can't just put it on and wash everybody's hands like one after the other you can't even wash your hands all at one time put it on the first bird comes out that's one but again second time then go the other end and watch the second hand why can I use the water if it's kosher water parrots is the first Spa the first spirit is foreign so using a high integer water cooler same thing put it on comes out close it put it on again second in second time second hand and one after the other the player is the next Macabre Seafood says if you have a big jug of water and you tilt it over and the water keeps on going you could everybody could wash the hands with the water as long as there's enough water left spout versus tilting over the Kaylee's portion in the first case you did nothing to the Kaylee you were Bitcoin is limited reason versus Jamie but when you tilt it over you did a mice in the Cali why is different now when you tilt to Kaylee to wash for Michaela so this would be the entire pouring is one because why can't we use our sink for Washington Terrace is the problem with the sink is that's not a Kaylee it's attached to the ground and there's no Kaylee right there a a water cooler has a Kaylee big one and as a spout a guy opened a wine barrel I took a little wine out of it does that make a lionesser the answer is absolutely shine and therefore the entire wine and this is not my fetish this is Iran the famous ramban I'm sorry then the case of question someone had a big barrel of wine or snaps the kids are someone else is in a pretty nasty mood either open the spout and all the wines pulled out or made a hole all the wine or snap Spilled Out foreign you see how versatile this Sugi is they have in Israel it was a big problem they have cows on from akibutesim they have to be Milton so the suggestion was you attached the machine to the cow's otter and do nothing else and then the milk flows almost naturally so you didn't do it maybe it's only Grandma grandma's name is not a grandma that's because you're putting something that's going to that's going to draw the milk so I guess almond this would be giri delay and it's his mice that's in the beginning of the two of them and always base he comes to our child and he says a brilliant you saw it he says when do we have a helic about the first water that comes out or the rest of the water that's when the water comes out and has to do a damage there's a damage to a person it's doing the damage outside then you clear this water of that water but if the damage was on the barrel that's one big barrel and all the water is one body of water and they damaged the entire Barrel in the entire Barrel you're doing of damage to the barrel water the barrel content it's one mice and I can use the help for this one is the the two questions we began with a person left water running and it accumulated a thousand the extra thousand dollar bill so how do we look at it is all the water considered my original damage don't we have a the hard Street to be to say that is especially some of the water that not some of the water 99 under the water that came out not long ago was Upstate New York and the never seen correctly Reservoir is that one body of water so it's really hard to understand that it's all one Mason and ravaza that held electricity even though it's being constantly generated is considered one maiser it's one long Geary delay of an extra extra electric bill and extra water bill so it's telling the original shyama but one thing I will say here the fact that the person put it on beheta he put on the water but he was magazine closing it but then again ravasna said even put on the good electric he was they all said if I had to but Lamay said it's one my Maisha that was saying this is so I think La Mesa the water damage is very similar to the the extra electric bill it would be not more than the Mazda could say Kim lay I hold even they never heard of this cheetah but he got hold like that but you have to be careful because it's still a grammar and certainly last but not least is a real major water damage a pipe burst or a plumbing backed up in helication where I pipe burst the people are not home and the water just did thousands of dollars as you and when social thing at the remodel the whole house come out so I wasn't a basically so it is the end of the day the person did nothing he's only a grammar the pipe burst I didn't bake the pipe I used the water but it's not more than a gram a very thorough beautiful tubers the noise they said the Commandos also where pipe burst he said into a maester hezek he steals to others this is unfortunately that the music you can't be the magic to pay but he says if the water is yours and he says after the water if the water goes past the water meter that's measuring the water it's in your house and your washing machine and your dishwasher it becomes more money that's how you look amazing and even though he didn't do it it's his magic of age or Mario Ace of course we put it on tommen some things in the house of tommen bar after it lands with spot on Caleb but the bottom line is we have to be careful and I want to make a point we have children or grandchildren and sometimes they're they're very negligent and they cause damage so people remember the mission says on damage is true but a gemara says if you take a hotline animal and put it over someone's food and animal eats it's considered automatic you take your child to the supermarket and he's running around and breaking things or eating things that's mine but not bad right it's my own child it's an automatic and this has to be the the Outlook with our children our grandchildren the Allah a child does damage if the parent is negligent he said hey look at Sonic goes diving for the gula we got to be careful we have to live in our homes as well I couldn't talk to you so listen yeah [Music] yeah foreign [Music] foreign the person has to be careful with his mom so it could either be a samajik if it damage as it's flying or bar but again we are responsible to watch our possessions as much as much as we watch ourselves electricity is a halitos topic in its severity it's an age mamish because it's a case where a person is using an existing a force and putting and putting on an appliance it's a mice Havelock command which you can make a broccoli National Shabbos on electric lamb especially if it's battery now what something is technology who knows what's going to be tomorrow but robots and remote control and talking and clapping that does malacha that's not just a grammar that's zainik forgot to mention tomorrow says a a rooster that makes noise and breaks the Kaylee there's a decimalsic of an animal this is considered a mice of the person in this case a we have to be careful electric electricity is not wood electricity is aged and there are so many fires that can be avoided if people realize that wiring or faulty electricity is dangerous not the you know but talking is good when you in business you know not to work at Holland but it's best we need to be talking but not lagabi comes to Freight wiring or faulty wiring make sure you repair it right away a person that left an A Electric Appliance on and caused a Big Bill somehow this grammar and some old it's a long Meister that he did it's attributable to him be a dying if a person's broke someone else's freezer he's Hive on the freezer but not on the food the water damage is a Real McCoy bitco de Maya the question is Potter but the Sita of the run is that even a question is the only part to buy a car damage in any form is Adam hamazik because it's the part of that's automatic because of if you should have avoided it he said I could pay for the cleaner of the cleaning of the coat a water cooler that you open it you have to open and close but it's considered a mice and a tiller with a Kaylee if you tilt the water to the water cooler than the entire pouring out is one long continuous mice our sinks is not a Kaylee so it can't be classified as a Nutella bakali milking cows or yeah all these various cases or mcfarious in fact we have to see electricity as a an extended or an actual and considered amazing a big water bill is like a big electric bills Kim a big damage typically I mean hopefully I should say is not this always an ointist it's never absia if it's absia then you have to reconsider but we could say that the damage is a that he couldn't it was unforeseeable he would tackle bipata again but be extra careful with katana because sometimes it's the parents because they were negative with their children yesterday why not sure if that's the case