What Should/ Shouldn't Be Done In The Sukkah ? - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] okay [Music] thank you [Music] 851-8651 or 718-853-3950 or email ist at yeshivanet.com so much to do but i want to at least focus on the basic mitzvah of yeshiva sukkah primarily what should and what shouldn't be done in the sukkah as we'll see there are many shyless but i think the common denominator of all the shyless is the fact that as we'll see it's not just a question of it's not appropriate it's not proper for the sukkah this is a sugya that really it brings us to the very tsuru's hamitzvah the actual mitzvah itself of yeshiva asuka let me explain the mystery base says the of course [Music] basically you have to make the sukkah your dear aschevan which of course sounds great but the obvious question is the suk is not my cry the 53 weeks of the year i live in my house and especially the old time sukis were very much makeshift arroy what does it mean to make the sukkah deeraskva but the question is runs a little deeper because the gemara in the beginning of sukhoda bays darshaning the positive station and here the gemara says to make the sukkah but what's more interesting with venus in sukhadav bays that you're not going to make the sukkot if you put too much on the sukkah and the rain doesn't penetrate according to any time or not you eat some in fact i'll tell you something even more fascinating there's a sheeta of the sardishin and simon savage there are more and tough rage men steve dollar quotes this asuka theoretically is crushed with zion alzheimer's if it's seven by seven twelfth approximately 28 inches and the question is obvious if you have a gracie yet a tall person six and a half feet tall how's he supposed to sleep in a sukka 28 inches so destin says quotes you'll cuddle up you'll fit in please where the turret allows you to make a sukkah then that's the sukkah and you have to make an eight so if the torah wants a dirac zainab zain is crusher your yoyo in that sukkah and ahmed style so we seem to be getting mixed messages what is the sukkah is that so the simple answer which is the assad of today is the gemara because on this mistake you have to make the sukkah the more asked the question you have nice dishes bring them to the sukkah matsuri is nice you have nice bed spreads bring it to the sukkah the key in the midst of sukkah adds a few examples a nice bed a nice table a nice chair a nice lighting system i guess in our times but you have to bring the nicest things to the sukkah then the dendemar explains you eat and drink and you relax in the sukkah of course tile does not mean going for a walk you can't walk in this tiny sukkah it means to relax madukis hanefesh will soon see what else it means but basically this is the tourism in other words to put it very simply the sukkah is not your permanent dwelling you have a nice house but the mitch is to make the sukkah for seven days your permanent dwelling make it treat it like your house like the balkan would say make a matchup out of it the nice dishes the nice this the nice that but don't keep it a matava roy for seven days live in the sukkah on a permanent basis so it's of course it's not your house but that's the mitzvah to make it into your house rashi puts it beautifully leo is called in other words i guess you could say it's a trading in the appearance of the sukkah and the gashmi is make it as comfortable as possible good lighting good table good cheers nice bread spreads but more importantly be there live there for the seven days so to then on the sukkah and then on the person to quote the rambo and dark emojis the beginning of tough rachel and bethesda was based on a real claude of course it's not your house but make the super your house for the seven days and of course a lot of ash coffee also that a person thinks he's on this world then this is his permanent dwelling realize the mitzvahs and the mice and toys are the ikka but this is the basic aside of sukkah being a diras kava for the seven days make it comfortable and be there for the seven days where does this come from emily this is the well known your side of taisho keintaduru the babalis vallasta xiaomi nanda perak bays and sukkah this is the tsuru's hamitzvah sukkah make the house make the sukkah like your house i'm sure you remember many hot lockers that are based on case game to do there's a picture of al qaeda a traveler shaun mcguinness or pardaison midstayer when it rains your potter came all these are based on taduru you occasionally snack out of your house you could snack out of the sukkah in other words as we know that's the tsurus of sukkah our gemara or our sugar today is adding a new cane to do and that is make the sukkah user-friendly and comfortable make it your bias so you'll end up living in the sukkah for the seven days in other words and i want to be very clear i think this is very important there's a general mitzvah of but by sukkah it's more than just the general exact california that's the tsuru mitsuba te suken to do requires us to make the sukup comfortable matsuri's noise and mitanoi and i'll give you one muscle for now the gemara in sukkah that's capacity foreign that if a person has a beautiful noise he could take it and put it right under the beautiful he has a beautiful design a nice cloth as long as it within four track he could put the noise on the entire length of this circuit is to beautify the sukkah it could cover all this and the raj aleph in the tube is wonders water shot because the mitzvah aimed to do that and in your house you beautify the house the same thing doing the sukhitarov yeshiva he uses so the rajv is saying the whole purpose of noisy sukkah is an expression of taisho in the dooru and it's so much part of the sukkah that even if it covers the it doesn't make a difference as long as it's close enough to this that's part of the sukkah as the rajv is saying the no yi sukkah that we make such a big deal about is another expression of te su keintaduru i saw the the in the chuvas marival in simmon of of hidden mitzvah is a kaligon value and he asked that on the marijuana but as we said it's not akasha it's more than the regulars that calibri and value this is the gruff hamitz of sukkah and one of the expressions is the mitzvah of and the truth is that it reads beautifully in los angeles [Applause] what the gemara is telling us that this mitzvah of making the sukkah user friendly making it nice making it comfortable is part of the mitzvah of te su ke en tadu now that we have that let's try to apply this the mice and i hope everything should be simple once we have that you saw it first of all first and foremost make the sukkah comfortable you know there's an old mentality if you have an old rickety table then whenever you touch it it shakes oh it's perfect with the sukkah bring it out to the sukkah if it rains doesn't get ruined a rickety table is not perfect for sukkas maybe if a tishbo of zeke or corbin but you sit in the sukkah and every time you touch the table it shakes you're not going to stay there for too long go to the hardware store get an outdoor table doesn't get ruined in the rain i'm not saying you have to bring out your dining room table but get a table that you enjoy being there get a chair that doesn't shake not an old zachary again you have to have dining room quality but it should be comfortable you know these people still have the old-fashioned light bulb the incandescent bulb one bulb for the whole big sucker you know there are so many alternatives to have safe good lighting that you enjoy learning in the sukkah if you have an old light that barely goes off light you're not going to stay too long but this is not just a tsutova hidden mitzvah this is the gemara this is the pasik hazal darshan getting to do certainly a you should make sure that the light is the lighting is attached securely when you have children or anything running around it happens they pull out the light from the from the socket and then the whole sukkah is here makayam kiesha bach hashem early so make sure it's secure and it's above the children's you know reach but make the sukkah a comfortable place to be of course a comfortable bed is a good idea you know people have these mattresses that mama just can't fall asleep on then the kids say i can't sleep of course you can't sleep i'm not saying to get again a bedroom set but there are very good options to make the sleeping comfortable in some years not this year but some years that sukkah falls out in mid october it's almost winter weather so people have the mentality okay let's go we'll brave it we'll be making episodes we'll eat quickly that's wrong if you're braving it and hurrying up and you're not enjoying the sukkot you might be much tired the aids is take out a sweater put on a coat the was often called they would install a heating system it was not electrical they had they put in a a ton or keep the sucker comfortable okay the embassies i can't tell you to go put in a fireplace in the sukkah but today there are safe heaters that are really safe and you keep them on there's no concern of a fire that's part of cane to do and i know people in the music we say before the shiva sukkah we want the shiva sukkah to be a like a goddess with ghosts but you know there's no mitzvah to have a circle like siberia it's freezing cold make it as comfortable as possible this year is faker this year it's very early in the year it might be a hot circus so there are alternatives there's a fan that's still pretty good some people put in air conditioning tavela and bracha a real cane to do but it's not just to ignore and make the sucker quick in and out make the sukkopas make the sukkah comfortable it used to be a a mitsubishi album try to put a run a phone line into the sucker i remember bianca kaminsky had a phone in a sucker all circus but today with cell phones is no longer relevant but the attitude is make the sukkah the place to be for the seven days a challenging question is is it proper to use disposable dishes in the sook in other words typically shabbos and yum if you have china nice dishes but suk is it's it's a big hassle it's difficult it's often they get broken on the way from the house to the sukkah so can you use disposable dishes instead of the typical shabbos plates that you use so push it this is the this is mama shower gomorrah caleb bring him to the sukkah and indeed many are makbid that they have this the dish they use the whole year they use in the circle and rather that's the best to do but you have to use seiko you know when you have a big family and it's difficult enough for the banaya bias to manage as it is so you know the question is is it a hum of vienes especially those that even on a regular shabbos and yum they would use disposable so for them it came to door but even those that are makbit but again in don and f shim is she efficient it's easy for me to say use your china but you have to use seiko that's the heritage someone asked him on shabbos maybe it's wrong to use disposable dishes because not covered chavez so he writes back you know cover chap is a good kuggle not plates you know it's hard enough for the male bias to juggle the multiple responsibilities they have don't make it harder you know they're going to you know snap from all the pressure so about that that's the terror decay cycle in theory of course it's better to use china and how if you could do it but there are other cashbayones also and basically you seiko and live alpi toyor just to show you what ain't the door is the ely robinson cotton aleph and the other kuffman base quote from earlier sources from the cadmium that there was a minig dafga not to cover the tables with with tablecloths in the house only cover tables in the sukkah so them to show dramatically that i don't live in this house on sugars i live in my circuit not in the house now the oyster oyemets and tough stuff raceclub saying the prima god is not like that because the maesta people do cover all tables in the house the whole year even if you don't use it and especially the women do spend time in the house so the minute is we do cover the tables in the house and in the sukkah but the fact that there's such a minute to show dramatically that i'm living in the sukkah shows us that how important the cane to do really is now let's move to the next word of the umar command the maar says he's supposed to eat and drink and learn in the sukkam fred digimore any i rather said that you're supposed to learn out of the sukkah like basically to make a long story short like the magnum writes ideally a person should live in the sukkah no for us what's living tyra is living so if you live in the sukha you learn the sukkah that's ideal and as the mahabharata says you eat and learn in the sukkah ideally a person should always learn in the sukh but if he will not learn when he's in the sukkah either because it's a lot of noise it's distraction the enemy playing there the children are playing there or some people they very much learn only in base measures when they learn alone after five minutes they are leaguing in london if you know what i mean with the emphasis on the leaguing part so they can't learn at home so that's getting the door go to the basement so basically the gemara's lotion is the eon that you need concentration which you don't have in a circuit because there's so much going on go to base measures if you're learning just superficially if you're being said la marshall or so i don't think the criterion is that ian versus the key is the criteria is will you be learning or you will be if you'll be distracted as rashji says that's a form of messiah you can't learn because you're being distracted to say that yoim one of the kadmain writes if you can't learn well and the sukkah it's us to learn the sukkah it's called brittle tire so it's a question of a situation it could be depending on on every particular day a quiet day learn gazun to hate now what i would make a point is at least make it comfortable to learn in the sukkah again a good table a good chair a good lighting if you're the lighting is poor and it's dim lighting so you can't learn the sookie you're not going to be attracted make it as comfortable as possible and then decide if it's conducive now for learning properly what i will say a tricky question is let's say a person has a quiet sucker and he's comfortable the problem is he's a big goyin and he takes out the 15 20 slurm every day with different uh marmokoimas and it's pushed a big pierce left this from to the sukkah and back afterwards maybe that's called mitstair because he needs so many swarming has to run into the house occasionally to get them so the emma says that's not mythalia in the end of tough race llama test but it's a much earlier saud mitstair means if the sukkah is uncomfortable if it's raining if there's a swarming with bugs but here the sook is comfortable what then it's difficult for me it's a terracot to bring the swarm oh that's a that's a virtue that's a mile in the mitzvah is is a plus makes the assault if you mistake it from the yeshiva if it's a terrible to get there that's part of the mitzvah i was born in williamsburg i still remember the projects the apartment buildings the halogen eden on the 15 story would take the hot coffee from their apartment and go down to the community sook on the ground floor by the time it came down the coffee was frozen but mamas they had such a simran that's not mistake that's the that's living it up so the ascites methylene means from the sukkah causes sar the fact that you have to slap this farm is not a that might be considered mistake now it's hard to understand and see if your test does not understand what kind of tour is that is not up to you so there has if you know you could learn then indeed go the extra mile bring this farm down bring it back so i think we could say what the victorian gift says a person should use and try to make learning in the sukkah work do what you can bring swarm maybe to bring out a plastic bag so keep the swarm in the back so it won't get ruined by the rain now of course you have to use cycle when things get ruined by the rain once you get all turned off so make sure that it's protected from the rain some people buy waterproof boxes they keep disarming them whatever you know people have know what to do when they when they're thinking but the ikky is try to make learning in the sukkah work again mouth etc if it's easy that could be done in the sukkah the rav says like i told you earlier if someone always learns in the base measures he's a lot of learning mismatches also so basically try to make it work but if it comes at the expense of bitter torah then go learn where is best for your learning what's noteworthy digimore gives an example of oiko and choisa frank de shiretzin and steve kottenhof tess today's starfish lambeth what do you mean still has always potted from succumb still is always alright and you're allowed to drink out of the sukkah zak the shahritzian the shot must be that if you take a cup of coffee that's mutha out of the sukkah but if you have a drink as part of a soda so even though the drink itself is not even the sukkah but the fact that it's part of the sukkah it's so the ashtiyya is part of the sudabe in fact dr b allah maybe even mayam as part of the suda is in the circle some police kim i saw the makay koi dish in aleph takes this a step further let's see a person is mocked but he's eating in the sook everything but he goes into the house to help serve in bringing out the uh talent and he wants to make a quick thai man the house to taste the children so that might be awesome because even though he's taking just a potato which is muta but since it's part of the part of a sudden then then i might also be in other words the achilles ar is when that's the extent of it if it's part of a big suda he has that sad maybe a but one thing i will say that we see that the sukkah the mitzvah of kenda duru is both in the person's attitude and making the sukkah most comfortable the next part is a little more challenging and that's the gemara in sukhadaflamid what shouldn't be done in the sukkah till now we spoke well you should what shouldn't be done on the sukkam so the mar makes the following statement mani mishtaya that rashitai says cops there's nothing offensive about empty cups in the sukkah but manny mikhla rashid says in other words cups after they used are fine but dirty plates after use must be removed from the sukkah now rashi does not spell out what's wrong with the plate that's used but from the fact that rashi said that cups are multi because it's me it's not miyus twice it says so rashi holds that used plates are awesome because it's meals in other words now we start to hear a new factor in hokusuka you can't do something that's most in the sukkah now the embassy's bizu mitzvah is a concept that we're familiar with shabbos learns from aposic that you can't do a mitzvah but there are pizzolian sim and meme it feel that maybe bizarre it's based on a policy regarding kisi adam whatever the case is there's no doubt about it that a bizarian of asuka is asa medin gemara al-gamar you'll wonder what's the big deal it's only it's only walls the answer is it's not only walls the gemaran sukhodaf tests that the walls of the sukkah are kaidesh there's a kid on the walls of the sukkah and it's a for the days of sukkos i mean it's not a klein kaitu spies and come to our sukkah and suk is gematria 91 which is exactly the gematria of sheamus hashem you with kevka and adnos exactly there's a lot to say but once they will suffice this story god is printed in the same siddha he once had two broken came take a fahre by him so the one bacon said you know what tall's friend you go first because you're better than i and if he doesn't take you he's not going to take me i'm not going to go for the hair the other boy who went and said uh not that she was not for you so the other bucker started walking out somebody said why you walk out let me give it for a hair and he took him that buck happened to be sometimes great talmud the absurd casa elisha but but the mice of the book said rebel how can you take me and not him he's better than i am he goes you're right he's very good but when he came into my office to prefer hair he walked through the backyard and he stepped on because he have to circus so that steps on no place in my yeshiva hey think about what's wrong it's only us about no seven days and they say after success and you don't put the chambers you know but the mice to the sahara state that sukkal hashem did a certain kedusa definitely during sukkis to make a bazoolian for the sukkah is what the gemara is concerned about so rashi is telling us to keep dirty plates in the sukkot is a bazoolian twice this says a different shot and that is not it's not manny mikhail is not plates but pots the toys the time what's wrong keeping pots in the sukkah the kane to do urbina the honey ain't regular is deera so toys is saying it's not the plates that's the problem it's the pots so we see tube shot and we were shining either plates that are used or pots the question is how do we apply this lamison let me explain what does it mean pat's are us in the sukkah is it only a dirty path then it's not a fidish because a dirty path is more than bizarre than plates in fact the dirty pad is much on shabbos in fact some say a dirty pad is it's not much i mean but you'll have to move it because it's graph serene so sinai mall is it bazaarian so what's nice is heading it's more likely that this is adding a pot even with food in it which is not at all muxer and it's not bazillion but a pot does not belong in the sukkah you don't bring a pot to your dining room table generally don't bring the pot to the sucker so twice is having a much bigger fiduciary of course plates are awesome but even a pot with food in it does not belong in the sukkah so this is again a big discussion in the paiskim but the interface lambda test aleph pascals like both and the bahamas says kade rice rice plates don't belong there and pats don't belong to you as martha shekel explains there are people that are very macbeth they don't bring parts in the sukkah at all in other words cain the door but they do keep dirty plates in the sukkah the right approaches both sheathes are correct parts don't belong in the suck even if there's food in it that's the minig that's the sensitivity but it's ain't a dual and plates when they're dirty are meals they have to realize that it's not just a different terminology bezoian sukkah is an isothera isa presumably kang to do is based on aposig but i can't say it's a dirac and also can't do is very subjective if let's say in my house i do bring pots so you can't say it's also to bring parts of the circle okay and the do is sort of subjective by zion is objective so this is what the mr brewer passed us he's cotton hey he says that we don't bring parts at all that's the minig and dirty plates also we don't bring mr brewer says unless someone is so poor that he has to eat out of the pot that he cooks in he can bring it into the circle like the high autumn says so i want to make a point that la maisa there are sheepish that the only issue is pots painted dirty plates are fine i mean i find but there's no issa the qurayan gifts if you've gotten your aleph and the mr brewer and the arch base we caused these shitties but rejects it and and his dominic is to honor both opinions pants don't belong in the sukkah at all even with food and plates not after they're used so again if someone keeps dirty plates to suk you can't yell at him because there are such sheets that are makel but we are like both see this now let's go a little further when exactly when do you have to move the plates from the circum so of course when you finish so you're not using the plate but then again it doesn't seem to be the right way to do things everybody has to get up and bring out the plate when they finish that's not ain't to do it's not a bazoolian so it would make sense if the site is bizarre and let's do it in a way it's not bizarre so i saw the khutsani that's mr karelson um he says when you finish eating you have to jump up and take the plate out that would make the whole pseudo like in like one big you know chaos but at the end of the the course you finish the fish you collect the plates like typically we do bring out the soup but you don't have to finish bring it out as soon as you finish the split second is like while you're about your matzah when you finish the course clean up the table the kid is what today was a big hit is to me one of the residents learning rashi he says you don't have to remove the plates until you finish the suit up because now you're going to go to sleep or you're going to relax or you're going to learn and it's most to sleep or learn in a place that there are dirty plates so the eerie has an extreme cool in this suggest that the means is not this dirty plate on the table when you're eating you might have dirty place at the table the problem is when you're about to do a different activity sleeping or learning so then it's inappropriate to have dirty plates when you're eating when you're sleeping or learning which is a tremendous cooler it's only when you finish the pseudo but as we said i don't know maybe in his time that was done but today the normal way of doing things you collect the place after every course that i sort of claim is almond also in the slime repair examiner 88 he does say i called heidler it doesn't have to be me yet as soon as you finish the fish run out with the plate you think that the entire family finished the course bring out the plates then of course not to rush a guest you might want doubles you know he's oh let me take your plate he was hoping he'd give him double take his plate that's not him so a little bit cyril and we could go with that maybe the mirrors times things were different but today this is and this would be the brazilian after the course the next course shouldn't have the plate from the previous course which parts don't belong in the sukkah so this is we saw really pastas of course a dirty pot has no making the sukkah that's much more mia's but it seems almost possible that what toys this meant the the kiddish is even a pot with food so this is easier said than done because if you have a sucker right off your house it's fine what about people that live in apartment buildings or they live in a sook in the second floor and they go the sukkah in the ground level in the backyard you'll you'll put the soup on the plates and bring it into the soup into the sukkah but time you get to the soup is cold so the best aidsa is take the pot from the from the oven from the the gas range bring it right to the outside of the sucker have a have a table outside and stir from there so this way you have hot soup and you don't bring the pot in the sugar i did see up hats cola in the microwave he was talking in williamsburg in the projects the apartment buildings and you know it was very you know there were families that ate in the multitude of families ate in one sugar i still remember this so what you can't just do that you know everybody's going to bring your partner and put it outside it's bedlam he says if there's no choice so you put the pot on your table what could you do you know he says he brings up a car maybe have one area but you know again it's all about ain't done and efficient efficient was mata to bring the pattern to the suk and eat out of the path if you have other choice so again a situation this mom has no other choice and it's not a bizarre and it's not a lack of pain to do so again apply the alarm in at the best way possible someone asked me is it an eight sir he wants to he doesn't want to get up and work so hard he has a box and he puts all dirty dishes in the dirty parts in the box and he covers it so the truth is in swara that's not really a hectare because ain't to do you don't do it on your dining room why you doing in the sukkah it's a lack of cupboard of sukkah what i told them is if you're in a situation you have no other choice like an apartment building or you live upstairs and it's no other acer so besides you could be saying ef sir that's when a box is a good idea that makes a little less of a bazin put all the dishes if you can't bring it up to whatever reason you can't bring it out at least put it in a box but a box in itself is definitely not a hetero a serving bowl a serving platter someone asked me what a locker does that have so possibly it's not like a pot you're allowed to bring a serving bowl to the table obviously but as soon as it's finished and you finish that course it's not better than a regular plate after the course is finished so you remove the plates and the serving platter bowl that's no longer needed still do this that they keep the plates with the bones on the table until they have the benching that's part of the school of a benching nose i saw the father supplies can say if that's hole points out when we finish all the students on a regular shop it's in the house you don't clean up until the toy matsuri shabbos but when you finish also this in the sukkah you're allowed to clean up right away because of the issa of keeping dishes in the sukkah the tsara and that sounds very convincing the only thing is what about kaine to do if a whole year my child should as i keep it in the in my dining room why can't i do it on circus also terraces budget i only do it because i have no other choice here i have a choice the hecta allows me to take it out i'll get out the cover of the sukkah what's positive but something you have to mention posture things also in a public sucker in a shoe and a basement dish a person should have the sake of to clean up you know i'm not one the people company leave the stuff there they leave their dirty cups their dirty cans why the guy is coming later today even at your own house you can't do that and call scam when it's been out of the cavery also you're leaving your place dirty so you can't rely on a guy it's no hete it's so basically in the public place they give you the service of eating them you know reciprocate with their carrots and clean up after yourself cops the gemara is mata beferish mani now there are two suarez why cups are different so rashi says because it's not meuse clean cut clean cup third cup is not much of a difference and the other we're saying him say ain't quality a person never finished drinking so if he's not finished it's holding by the same course i'll give you a dogma the mystery shabbos in other wash dishes but cups otherwise because it ain't quality so i guess it's a cooler also that you don't have to move the cups right away i did see a basically but it's true it has an interesting fiddle she says but today styrofoam cups where after one use they're no longer reusable that might be like a cliche that's the bezoian where you are i don't know what he means i mean i mean i would use my cup again maybe someone else but he's a little more concerned about a styrofoam cup that's not usable not reusable maybe that would be like a plate that is already a brazilian but again if you're going to use it again you might use it again look how the same hat applies but i think with is a point to mention again we're so careful about sukkah it could either mention to leave a copy after you have a coffin basmatis it should be unthinkable the basement juice is the base hashem you know even if it's not which often it is but it's time we have to know this is their burst from home you drink a cup in the coffee there's a hecta you know it's not possible but to go beyond that and leave the best magician that's not clean is definitely not the right thing people typically bring a box of of items to the sukkah which is okay they have the tablecloths and but to leave an empty box in the sukkah laksin came to do we don't do it in our dining room so you bring a box of meat and things you need empty it and remove the box as soon as possible an empty soda empty juice container again it's again a cover of the sukkah it it basically sends us a message that i'm in the base hashem have a place with your speason are here and i'm going to treat the sukkah properly and now we come to the last part of this sugiya and that is where the sukhi takes sort of an interesting turn the alaka is that we sit in the sukkah seven days on ghostlar at me at also but beyond that we don't sit in the sukkah now le maison some people found it comfortable to sit in the sukkah on sim castaro and the question is is there a problem of baltoisef i was once to go out of someone's house in history they had in the sukkah it was a warm day very comfortable so the problem is about so this is and the more says you can't sit in the sukkah when it's sorted as man mitsuk is val taysif but tonight so bring out the plates and bring out the pots whatever shot you want to learn bring out the plates and leave them in the sukkah dharmarava mani mithla bami with alta you hear a husband if you have plates and pots and you keep them in the sukkah so many of you shine them the reef and the bag use a lotion so right now your sook is possible if it's possible there's no about taser so a whole suckers we'd sit there to keep a powder played in the sukkah but keep the part there put the part there leave the plates there and the riff and the bag use a lush and now it's possible if it's possible there's no balthois okay the mice this has bearing and our sugar also because it's not just for the ninth day that would mean that if the first day you bring your pot or you played in the sukkah in a time when it doesn't belong there that would make the suk apostle now otherwise showing him say when the when the riff and the bag use the lost an apostle it doesn't mean it's possible with the heaven it means it's not does not resemble a sukkah that would be a concern about twice but it's not possible okay so the the cooler is that if there's plates or pots and soak it's not parcel but one thing i will say the kayode mccluff memsaian days says if you have plates or pots in the sukkah any of the seven days it might not be possible don't make a brah on that sukkah because like summer's time is possible again i'm talking about the first seven days sukkah that has played to a past doesn't belong there the suk is puzzled so we don't say it's possible homage but it's definitely not a sukkah enough to make a broke on it and the mr burns so we see how inappropriate it is to have plates or parts in the sucker but we also see what bizarian does to the sukkah it jeopardizes the very caches of the sukkah and maybe even the opportunity to make a bracha we don't do anything that's inappropriate in the sukkah like washing plates and parts so yeah mitzvah is basilius olive we don't want to be mavas of the sukkam incidentally you notice he gives two examples don't wash plates or pots in the circle something around why didn't you say washing cups because cups is moved to the washing the silk up you got to keep them there you got to wash them there so plates and pots don't wash in the sukkah and there are more quotes this in the end of sifa aleph bazi and mrs bazuya love don't do anything bizarre and they can suck the bach and the the makura this whole kridish is our gemara which gemara pots and plates in the sukkah since we see medina gomorrah you can't keep pla patter or play to the sukkah and some say it's even puzzled we see how careful you have to be that the sukkah should not be subject to brazilian gives an example not to hang laundry to dry in the sukkah it's just not the place for a sukkah i prefer laundry in a sukkum so here we have it's lav dafta plates and pots that's just an avua in the cooler that's just an example but any tashmish of bizarrion is wrong in the sukk now let me ask you a few questions that i've heard over the years someone has a hater to do work on kalamati he does some paperwork i think he was an account i don't know what it was but he's a lot of work in halawa he had a rob that told me should he do his paperwork in the sukkah is that appropriate someone answered he wants to he goes on a treadmill a half hour every day should he bring it out to the sukkah no problem but does it belong there not how do you qualify the concept of bazillion so i did i didn't find hookah's you know treadmill in surname but i'll tell you what i found hopefully we could extrapolate from beyond the maryvale that i mentioned earlier very soon at kedarke but he says you're supposed to learn the success he's supposed to play okay doesn't say what he means but the darkly moisture drama and that moisture and see the cotton aleph he said custom revival right because you know that's something that's possible hey this that's that's dice but there are more explain the marijuana you want to play with dice possibly so you want to do it in the circle now i'm not saying you should play with dice in the circle but but the point is the attitude is listen sukis is a time like every yom tiff to connect to the british especially don't is not far away we have to be at our best on circus we're not supposed to be playing uh dice or cards or anything on on halloween or jumped for that matter but if you feel you have to do it gain to do you know that's your thing to do you're an interesting fellow but do it in the sukkah so we see again if it better if it doesn't you don't think it's right don't do it but if you're doing it as long as it's not awesome do it in the sukkah i saw many diaries later the samba sky him and rayston hey was asked if a a playing club him i don't touch that but you know we learned all about cards if should if you're doing that could you play in the circle so he says of course you have to be careful you could do sukkah but if the mice you are playing it that's not the question we're do it in the sukkah so it seems to me that the attitude is try to do things right but if you're doing it the place to do it is a circle someone just told me an autumn goggle that i know he saw his children watching a video now i look at children and he was certain that they watched either a sheer or maybe a siama he says i'm sure you're watching something appropriate why don't you do it in the sukkah so he said it was interesting lesson that again you know if it belongs in the mig it belongs in the sukkah so that's why i mean the fact that the gemara says the mystery says methyl basuka thiol does not mean going for a stroll teal means relaxation uh recreation so that's why if you feel that you want to do it and you think it's right even if it's not a mitzvah it belongs in the sukkah that's why the place can say without a doubt if you have a guest and you're not gonna talk and learning you're gonna just dumb schmooze bring bring them out to the sukkah of course the mystery rights if wrote this with his trivia culture he put it on his sukkah he wrote it out that because kadusa suki is it's right he might and they behold and to keep it picked up so about the sukkah should be a place of torah and mitzvahs but if you have to smooth you schmooze in the sukkah la shanhara is in house and sukkah i should mention the guardian pointed out that the oysters of sukkah the samba comes from the shenanigans from the teeth versus from the sasayam from the lips coffees from the and hayes from the glory none of the letters of sukkah come from the tongue all four letters of sukkah are the shmeera on the tongue because suk is supposed to bring the smear on lash and her and an azdavar and and the boom i sure him so the sukkah is the greatest fera to dwarmasurium but smoozing if if you have to smooth you're smoothing the circle now i want to make another point this is the mata frame of the kadosh elliot can you do them in tough race cafes he writes that down to him they didn't talk any secret school in the circle whatsoever but that's only when the family were on the same level if you're going to come to the sukkah sukis and you're not going to talk a word because you can't talk you're sitting like an ovel being and your family is and below you that writes very um sarcastically and and what should they do seven days you're going to have a tightness deeper in your sukkah so you have to know there's also and is appropriate in the sukkah so you have to have a little circle also but he says don't forget there has to be a mystery that you have to provide for your you know wife and children so like everything else in this world you have to use seiko but the suk if you have to schmooze this music in the circle someone asked me into the question i quote could i read a kosher newspaper in the sukkah so whatever that means but obviously a non-coaching spirit doesn't belong in our house either but something that you're allowed to read so the same thing if it belongs in a mig it could belong in the sukkah now grab the disciple in our sorbent-based race called he didn't allow any newspapers in his sukkah that was laravel could do something a treadmill same thing treadmill if it's that's his form of teal and why not do it in the sukkah especially if you listen to a shirt as he's on the treadmill so that doesn't seem to be a problem what's a little more of an issue is bookkeeping writing in the so the ms we could say if it's motta so is mutter see maybe it's tell you a little bit if if mulak but again it's more likely to say if it's multi to do it and he has to do it so it belongs in the sukkah that's not different than teal on sukkah he says binding swarms should not be done in the sukkah maybe that's the shaft because you don't bind on in your dining room but regular paper could do on your dining room table it wouldn't be a steroid to keen to do room someone else he wants to grill in his sugar no grill i mean if mother pots don't belong in the sugar grilling is very good but not in the sukkah now to keep a urn with water in the sugar that's appropriate maybe even a toaster oven a little more of a modified type of behavior but the grill in the sukkah does not belong this silk could do it outside not in the soup there's the river surprising base he says this diaper once the sundick by a bris in the sukkah and the moral is about to die for the child so the type is no no you don't diaper child in the circle take him out very understandable because you know the sook is not a place to die for a child i saw a dove and if lemaroid it's a whole tumble which is not a gear box any longer but for well it used to be a shia lab especially when they didn't have bathrooms close by about probably urinating in the sukkah so many can answer there's some that will make them but i'm not getting into that point but what he says is how could you say it's awesome i mean a person could be mature mayor lying with phil and on so how could be awesome to sukkah so he says when you're in the sukkah he says the khalas mitzvah and it's muhammad than with philan the point is the sukkah is the embassy of the it's the tale of amenus so in a certain end it's more than with film so diaping a child should not be done in the sukkah parking a bike in the sukkah again find a better you know garage not the sukkah the place can discuss if you could lean the sook lean the bike on the wall the suck on the outside of the wall maybe it's awesome so that you could discuss a little bit but basically it has to have the right attitude when you're treating the sukkah someone asked me could he keep his stack his mattresses in the sukkah so i said why not i don't do it in my dining room i said you're making a mistake because the suka now is your bedroom and you got to keep the bed and the mattress that's where that's part of its use so it's a dining room in a bedroom but something that doesn't belong there and the most i told the dirty laundry that the children leave the socks lying around if dirty plates are rusted their laundry is certainly awesome in fact says shoes should not be brought into the sukkah so kamehameha the safe explains because those days they they lived outdoors basically they didn't have paved roads and the shoes were like sort of like boots that were dirty so today you could keep shoes in the sukkah but it has to have with a husband a garbage can does not belong in the sukkah just like you don't keep in your dining room and i want maybe in a community a shoe sukkah if you don't keep it really it doesn't work in a sukky either but if you don't keep it there people can leave it on the table maybe there's no other choice but basically the sukkah has to have that producer the price can clear if you're allowed to watch nego says you have no choice because you can't walk away so now we wash in the sugar but of course you remove it right away says but the till us you're dying for bread you can't do in the sukkah we don't do it in the dining room but the emphasis today people have installed sinks in the dining room to be more the takers and the tila bronco and taco dominic is if you have an older person that can't walk can't walk up to gouache bring out them it's a mix of keep it of but the attitude is makes with the thing belongs in the sukkah an interesting question which today we have it's almost unavoidable and that is to make the sukkah a shortcut when i was growing up this wasn't the gay but today you walk on the streets you have to walk through circus what's the sheila so we know the suggest of manal if it's gillam you can make a basement into a shortcut okay i can't walk through this door and go out that door to save a block so what are you working on i would say most most blacks in borough park this took us all over the place so all the hindi get posting discusses and basically what they all say is there's a fair share say for me arum that says there's no issa of capanjia by asuka it's a nice uh heroes but there's no such issue now what i always did before i saw this inside i'd have to walk through the circle because i have kavanaugh mitzvah when you walk in a sukkah if you're not making a buck on it that's true i'm not eating but i'm being in the sukkah now i do know the share at sea and see if caught inside the gimbal says that a person walks in the circle just to collect payment but and it just messaged them but there's no mitzvah that's because it's a mitzvah but if you walk through the sukkah to get a mitzvah to be in the suck another for four seconds why not forget i walk through the circle they're walking around i go through a circular mitzvah i can't believe that would be an issa if it seems more like a mystery i did see in rafael the sayings of lakewood is safer he points out that the mahabharata says if you were first for years you've been going this way and then some built a basement and he deprived you of your capanjia you'll have to go through the capandia because your kapandju is before the show so he applies this to what's almost unavoidable many people build their sukkah on the front or back porch to get into your house you have to go through the sukkah so if it's going to be also you can't go into your house the turret says my passageway was before the sukkam it's a very nice heart based on that someone asked me a very challenging question he has the elderly parent that have a full-time non-jewish aide and he heard this episode is that having the guy enter the sukkah so let me clarify this it's not in sukhana or earlier it's the shah allah and he says that the ushpezin give claudius they bring a guy into the circle okay avada is inappropriate but again the main album seems to be it's a bizarre sukkah you're making a social and out of the inviting you're going into your sukkah but if the guy is there to help the shiva sukkah a person needs a may and an aide some people have guys maids cleaning up i had a shiloh when someone had to call the guy what should he do the guy can come into the sook how's he going to fix the fix the light remote control fix this so if you have no choice if that's a mitzvah it's not a sphere the main thing is the sensitivity that this is a mockum kaddish and it's only for you'd not appreciate it a really geshmaku shiloh today it's almost in every sukkah and that some sukkah a lot of sukkah they say have part of it that's not really kosher the muscle if you have it on a porch so typically there's an overhang of a roof that's over part of the circle but it doesn't pass with the sucker because whatever's under the overhang you don't sit there but the wall of the house you use for your sukkah that's different akuma in other words the circus kosher as it is but there's one area even if it's a pretty significant area you don't sit under it so the question has been asked more than once can i keep pots or dishes or whatever it doesn't belong in the sukkah in that pustular area it's in the sukkah it's part of the sukkah but it's not really kashura sukkah the same sheila could be asked if i put noisy sukkah on that wall is it does it have a caduceus maybe it's not kosher so the the kuriyan gives you the cotton ew it says it depends if you have three walls without that wall that's problematic then you could do what you want to that area but if you only have with that is the third wall that's max to the sukkah then you have to treat that area as the regular sukkah and now you sukkah taka is annoying and you can't keep anything inappropriate in that area now to make a long story short there are pisces that say it doesn't make a difference if you have two or three or four walls la mysa that arie is not part of the sukkah so who cares if you need that wall the wall is along this wall but that area is possible look there's no shock on top of it and some poison take the opposite attitude it's the perception of it you look at the sukkah that's part of the second no one knows looks up this is sukham so i would say that it's not kadai to be mako unless you have a reason and anyhow a sniffle martial lets you have the issue with plates or pots this is an additional area that's the better place to keep it someone asked about the right place to light nearest on yamdev or shabbos of success an excellent question the gemara says the menorah the lights do not belong in the sukkah there are five reasons that this you can't light may race in the sukkah but what's in it for us one of the reasons is the sakana involved leaving candles having candles in a sukkah is a great danger especially if the bane buyers go to sleep and the kids are running around the grandchildren of at least when people are not there in the sukkah if you're lighted by the suit then you watch carefully fine but if a person is afraid to lie to the circle you light in the kitchen where the banane bias could have enough in the nerves when they prepare the sudden and i guess most important of cane to do this writes in the safer that a person should try to stay in the sook as long as possible and if he leaves for no reason he's over he's mavantal the halogen mitsubishi and all the later poison wonder why the whole mitzvos can aim to do to live in this guy my house i'm out on the house to rest sook is not a jail why should i say if i leave the sukkah i'm over i lost the mitzvah zalman in the safe and they say for hasuka this is a beautiful shot if i will approach you and say i'm going to pay you 500 an hour i want to make a psychological study i want to observe people and i want you to be my subject sit on the dining table and just don't do anything just stay here i'm going to watch you i'm going to take notes 500 000 an hour okay would you do it yeah now let's say your sons let's play basketball now you say not today not five thousand hour basketball game no no i'm staying here anyways let's go shopping or not today i want to stay here suck up slaying the salmon when a person sees kadusa sukkah can requires him to make a husband would you leave the house if you lose five dollars an hour don't lose the sukkah subtitle like this because the end of the day you later leave the sukkah for recreation but at least it's an attitude to take to cherish the mitsubsuka so that's most of all well it's almost let's appreciate this young foreign eight five one eight six five one or seven one eight eight five three three nine five zero or email ist at yeshivanet.com thanks a mayor foreign [Music] [Applause] uh [Music] bye [Applause]