Why Did the 1st of Tishrei Become Rosh Hashanah? - Gemarah Rosh Hashanah 8a-8b

the yeshiva dotnet the house on the Dolloff one two three four five five lines from the top after completing the discussion on why the Mishnah does not count the other research on us that seem to be included in the bracket that are included in the price namely the 16th of Nissen and the sixth day of civil and the gomorrah went through various explanations whether we only count or shoshanna's that include after Shoshanna consists of a full night and day a 24-hour period that was her Papa's interpretation or the second interpretation of shisha was delicious honest in our mission include something that doesn't require action on behalf of the Jew it just comes automatic or finally of a she's final interpretation that when it says for Rosh Hashanah it means the Foresters shown them that happened to be also on Rosh Hodesh they're not only the beginning of a year they're also the beginning of a month which of course makes it much more of our Hashanah because a year never ends in middle of a month years have to consist of full months just like a month so a year never ends in middle of a month right the year ends at the end at the end of a month so when you say Rosh Hashanah is unrestrained ish that's a much more so to speak genuine Rosh Hashanah because you can actually say it's the beginning of a new year you could say recitation at the beginning of a new year or stridor shell is the beginning of a new year tests love tests love the zionists in' or vauban as the middle of a month so yes it's Rosh Hashanah for a particular think in terms of armor but the brass she says that's not the type that's not the genre version summons that we're addressing in the Mishnah we're talking about those that are related and those are only four there are four digits others that are under straightish number one recitation listen number two is hi - hello number three - hi - Thierry and number four risque - rot Keith every base shall my light by summer of course according to basil--oh it would only be three Rosh Hashanah is that our recitation so according to everybody it's three according to baisama it would be actually four now of course there are those who hold that effort Bell also not a recession for example the velocity of shipment right so therefore there would only be two there would only be two why because there's be fighters missin and the straightest Tishrei and unless they hold like way Shammai it would only be to try this interest rate of Tish so when he says according to everybody it's three ration points that doesn't mean according to everybody in the Mishnah cuenta de Bellas Artes Amina may only be two it means according to according to put it according right according to Rebbe with bahamas if you say by Xiaomi if you say base Hillel then it would be only three Rebbe holds like this hello cuz usually we sell logic abyss hello so it would be only three because we're straight as smart would not be counted and as we explained it only gone says that's the deal in kid de vere a base shop which now brings the Gemara to the next to commissioner to discuss the very basis of the idea when we start rush a sauna for my super him so now the Gemara starts analyzing the next tickle in the machine the velocity of Shimon I'm room bilasa and of Shimon say yes your son of a my Simba Hema is a competition earlier they come already quoted this that its back on bellow and explain it that's the over him mayor and Rabi holes like anime when it comes to my sub Behaim and that's why he quotes it without a name and we got into the whole discussion of why are they our bar Commission there are Commission but now the kamon actually discusses the very concept of the date of my survey so we have a mock locus when my super him and begins the mayor holds its acid bevel and that's quoted in the mission as the first astonished nur after the elbow rosh hashanah my so vain then we have the bilasa and if shipments aids but as a petition now what does this mean before we get into the source we have to know what does it mean what it means is as we have explained a jew who has a farm and he owns cows and sheep and of course mother cows and mother sheep give birth to baby cows what we call calf's a golden and tuam which are baby sheep and the halacha dictates the pasta commercial casaya dictates that what that you have to put all of these newborn animals into a Corral and have an open a narrow door an entrance and then have them go out and then count and every tenth becomes holy our serie here kodesh Larson thank you and that becomes a carbon which we call my sir Bahama would you bring to us a lion you sacrifice in the base I mean you sprinkle the blood on them as mayor and then you're free to enjoy and eat the carbon according to the hollows of a carbon what's called conduction column the lighter carbon is in other word you can eat it in the whole region of yours shall I until with inside within the fortress within the fiber for the prescribed period of time and according to the whole office that dictate how you eat a carbon in terms of Tahara the purity that you have to have the time limits etc and the place where you eat it that is my sir Bahama clear what's in a garish Hashanah so you have my sub any advice of a Hammond I have newborn sheeps I have to make a cage with these other new babies I have to give myself if I only have nine I don't have mice if I have 15 I have one myself EFT when you have two mices have a hundred of ten my sister what's the what's the body needed research on the for wonderful when it's born it's born the answer of course is the answer is because the Toyota also tells us that it has to be year by year from which we learn that I can't give my sir from the babies that are born the baby animals born one year for those that are born in another year so for example if in Tufts and I in Zion I had nine baby sheep but Tufts and I involve I had one more baby sheep I don't give my sir I don't have my sub a.m. you know why because Tufts and I involve is one husband from Zion Zion is a separate regiment if tough should I ins I and I have many many animals and touch the naive Oh bad many and I just give myself interruption I involved also for those of touch nines and also for those of some Shania involved right I ignore those let's say tops name of a hat ten tops mind's eye and a half huh I have another ten so I want to give I want to give my sir from this new group for that group doesn't work every year gets its own my sis and other question is when does the year begin what's considered a year what's caught off time comes the mission and says it's her straightish ella meaning if huffed s of i had an animal of baby sheep Rochelle oh I have another nine and no more during that year I don't give myself if I have during that year 10 or 20 after gives to my sis I have a hundred after just ten mices comrade velocity of Shimon and say wrong daters right is Tish now the question is where would they come up with this date why would they come up with this date what's up is Ella Tishrei why not Tabas why not Shabbat dr. Kumar armored w Senator Buchanan said Bhushan am McCrea Fodor shoe both of them yet mayor who says Rosh Hashanah for my summer Hamer's of first of L and their bilasa and of Shimon who says the first day of Tishri actually are both using the same posit they derive their their view from the same possible of course everybody explains the park in a different way what's the person Emma very interesting way how they learn out their stare they're halakha there's a parsec into hilum chapter Sam I hate the hill on Capitol summer hey 44s sixty-five boss if you dilute the mission is literally to the M side the panic that chapter that capital until them is talking about the blessings of rain that Hashem gives this octopus ik lost shoe quorum had signed by a mahkum ayaat Vivar yahoo a few she wrote love Chikara matzoi means Korean hot sign sign you know our flock sheep Karim are a fact robust well-fed satiated healthy sheep love shoes for him outside the fat sheep got dressed what does it mean they got dressed they got an extra layer of skin because they became pregnant that's what love so hard about saw him they got dressed in other words they became pregnant which is as placement says a nice way of saying that they have an our baby a baby inside a baby lamb inside their womb vomer komyatti for VAR a maka means the depth of the valleys from the word I'm it beep Bob welcome the valleys yacht Vivar become covered yacht fool means they become covered like this octave this octave but since this activist Alice they become Baddeck wrapped bar with two ur bar means great destroy our after shiru history io means they they sing that you say they celebrate you I'm true or they celebrate after she row and they also sing so the pasta is talking about the blessings of the Lambs being pregnant the baby the Sheep being the mother ships being pregnant the valleys filling up with grain and the grain celebrating dancing is Rio they're dancing and they are singing what is the meaning of this posit suck the Gemara that may you suffer it may is often a must I love Shikari Matt sign when is the time that the sheep become pregnant businessman Shamu komyatti over the same time when the valleys become wrapped by the new grain of a Masai when is this very must say I'm Malcolm youthful for when is this we all know there's no question it's by other it's the month of other in the season the register all that's the time when the first stalks of grain of true we'll begin growing before that is the winter season and other you have that the amok in the valley starts filling with great therefore what are we learned from here he says now we have a fact we know how long is the gestation how long is the pregnancy period for lap anybody knows huh five months five months right the feel look it up will be approximately 150 hundred and fifty two days on your 48 days hundred and forty-nine days which is approximately five months succulent may if the park is telling me that they become pregnant when the time of a maken yachts were burned the month of other so he says Amos hammock Nats of our body Missa bras but other haste is that the she become pregnant in the month of other and therefore V odors Burroughs and then they will give birth in the month of all because the time of pregnancy is approximately five months so therefore the month of other that's usually the time they become pregnant so the afore or say even those who become pregnant at the end of all this you'll have missin an ear and seven and Thomas yes yes yes yes good question yes yes the more employers the fess goes through all the pregnancies of momentum to the prayers of many animals bahama Daka Kamisha Kardashian Bahama Dhaka is like sheep with that type of animal behavior Gaza tissue production more doctors and gases right so it Mela what's the connection so that mayor says the Mei Li says miss a breeze but other the elders were off so when is mr. Shonda Richardson insulin is hello he said I'm very practical this sheep came to the world what's their first mission Shauna what's the beginning of their first month not off because they're usually born in the month of of so what would be Irish Hashanah that begins a new month a new year for them when will I do it I do it the first episode is ready to show is it possible that you have sheep in a different time of year of course it's possible but when I have to establish orisha tion of am i some a man what's the best date to establish the best is to establish the first verse of sermon for the sheep that are born in the month of love and that would be the first day of the next available month it's not destroyed this t-shirt so that becomes a nicer summer so practically speaking the sheep that are born till then are in one year and we Shoshanna begins a whole new year astride a shell that's it mate what are their beloved of Shem you know him there this is order B I thought I'm explaining whether the blahs item Shimon say a must I love Chikara MOT sign when do the Sheep become pregnant not when I'm Malcolm youthful for the next part of the puzzle bisman show yesterday off your shiru when the grain is dancing and singing now we have to understand what I mean the grain is dancing and singing we'll see in a moment a Musashi ball in mind the Rashida when do the stalks of grain start singing anybody knows never see when did the stalk start singing something a murder business the singing starts innocent they become wrapped the valleys become covered by grain wrapped and grain other when they start singing they start singing in the month of innocent but malar miss a bris Vanessa so the time of pregnancy is this their father yelled Isabel so birth is LL because gestation is five months so therefore Hashanah shall hand Tishrei so therefore we say rebel asana persimmon Sara Shoshana is the first available month afterwards they come into the world in the beginning of the new year is a respite this dish let's see - Iizuka - she lost shoe harem outside mokuba's Seifert hilum it's a puss akin to hill in chapter 65 summer love Sahara might sign a mahkumat for voice ray off your shoe doctor - love sakaram outside means miss Lobster Shack awesome the Sheep become dressed what does it mean they become dressed should miss a Burris they become pregnant in other words they an additional layer is added to them so we call it a lavash olive which they're carrying a baby yeah - var the valleys become covered with grain Sahasra it's a Marcus because what we planted grows Vinny carries the offer and it's well recognized that's why he says yatsu it becomes covered in other words it's not just start of it starting to grow its earlier but yeah true doesn't mean that it's starting to grow yeah who means it's covered it's protect that's what actually says Vinny care is the offer you could see very well that these are fields that have grain that's the deer cover actually maker is the offer in other words it's not the early stages of growth its later stages you saw off your shoe the grain dances and also sings what does this mean so gradually Ben listen this isn't a month of miss in this and you don't only have grain growing in a recognizable way but it means something else Jia Jia's man hikotsu Nissen is already the beginning of harvest time maja - herb Akash inshallah the true already develops maturity in the cash inshallah in its stalks for ruin are cheves and the spring breeze starts starts blowing they ain't no Geum sawol Zoop so therefore the stalks of grain bump into each other no cure means they clop they pound on each other nish my coil and therefore the voice is heard vanilla ice cream ice traitorous and it appears that they are swaying and dancing and singing they're dancing because they're swaying back and forth and they're singing in the sense that you can hear the coil is from the from the banging of the two against each other so crash is money Barbara Murdoch accomplished what you have to understand in this Gemara is at the time of pregnancy of what we call a Bahama dacha a thin or a weaker a smaller animal like a sheep as five months been mayor says the mayor to Shana Chilean ello the summer click Amara is man kadosh the summer click Maura I'm sorry I'm gonna read according to the guys about the summer flick Mario who is man harsh the summer click amore rap close after it gets bored Gemara mean when it's completely gets born who's man that is the time of kadosh the ocean shall and the finish asana that is the time to describe the new year or the old year in terms of a new year coming that is the schita of Rebbe mayor love Chicano Matt sign when I'm Malcolm you at vouloir which is the month of other what's the shit's with the velocity of shipment love Sakura max Orion is only story I offer she drew in other words innocent so therefore biz man she is Ohashi Bolin how she Boylan when the stalks start dancing that's when they give that's when they become pregnant so the birth is not enough but an elbow and therefore issues are necessary the same paw sick is used in two different ways by these different 2 million to describe and to deduce one is rotational oh my so babe flag murder one second via the tsunami according to the mayor Hoxie VI efficient how can he ignore the continuation of the PASOK it doesn't only sale of Sahara Matsuyama commute vouloir it says history our fish you know that means the pregnancy happens when the spokes of grain are dancing and singing which is not an other it's innocence so how can he say that the pregnancy is in other and for the Gemara how who by a flaw saw the having business that may recognizes that there are a fluster flossin means late comers sheep that are late comers you know macaques are very savvy so they have time so therefore the attacker their pregnancy season isn't the month of nyssa so most sheep he says get pregnant in the month of other which is a mahkum ayaat Vivar and then this laughs you do which is a later stage so of course it may recognize is that there are seen to become pregnant later but that's Buffalo sir rashly says a who Baffler sir yes love sorry not mighty voice you haven't Paris Parsons Viet say right Omaha TIF hot sign so rashly says over there the story of Yaakov and the sheep and the sticks the sheep that come later a mighty voice Oh miss Acuras lockable sucker Addison it takes them a little more time to accept the mail and the relationships of the month of Nisan I'm a Reuben my other however most happen in the month of other that is what the mayor is tightening so therefore there are sheep that give birth and elbow of them give birth and of and therefore in terms of mice so we follow the majority and we described or Shoshanna as the first day of L once you establish an issue Shani establish Hashanah the new sheep that are born in a low ready belong to the new year you're right they either hanami now let's go the other opinion there blossomed of shimon who say that the time of pregnancy is missing hawk receive it says in the same posture come up komyatti over the valleys will become covered with grain which is the month of other Zola Kyle you should learn from either the time of pregnancies the month of other why do they ignore this part of the plastic and for the Gemara of course they'd know that there are sheet to become pregnant another but according to them who beccaria saw that's the contrast of a philosophy means the late comers and car Piazza means the early comers those that are more rushed car Piazza they make hard for you they make it made harpy is the early days of my life you'll often have that row animal right you've seen them in offense cream on does that cassava tea be made her fee or be made her fee JC cushy otsuma when I was young you know when I was young I had a good question you'll have often in the childhood sugars and especially by uranium that's hard Piazza the early ones the early days so those who come early the acid made other they already accept a male in the month of other and therefore they become pregnant they're not they can give birth in a little bit the majority tiny the Balazs and obscene men will become pregnant innocent and therefore love should hari might sign in the time of a mahkumat valve are which are the minority they say I your shitty which is the majority and therefore they follow the majority which are born in Evelyn therefore a bunch of son of a my surname is not restrain this hello buck British dish okay that's how the beautiful none understands the McCoy kiss between the tonneau Liam when is the son of the my son Bahama now here we have a big question that your Bobby asked which is raised by the return of the seducer a nun asks this question he says sheep are born after five months that's true but you have a Bahama gasa you have a cow pregnancies usually approximately nine months so why are you describing why you establish English a shuttle am I so Bahama based only on the sheep what about cows they also desert they also go into this category when you say there's a shuttle am I so Bahama it means all my summer hey muscle mass above in fact the puzzle says first ball car and then Sun so why do that sign get the upper hand to define when dushashana's why don't we look when the baby calf's of the cows are born and that should be the ratio sana why are they ignoring the buckle which come before sight I'm sorry what you gotta figure it out so you figure it out you figure it out so let me give you let me give you two answers one is the answer of the solution Haram and then there's answer that the tie sufficient earth gives in machine eyes the producer dance has a very interesting word he says when you look at the plastic of my Simba Hema it's in the end of partials book I says you just quote it the puss that compares both of them in the same posture the lotion is Mahal my sir Bakr but sorry how does it continue coal ash the avatar has a shave it has Syria Kurdish Russia so bucker and sorry not put together but mela you have to learn from this that there's a son of a my son Bahama should be for both of them the same time because the trader compares both of them dr sudarshan i'm since the majority of bang the majority they are much more sheep that are born more than gases more darkest abundant gasses more sheep than calf so therefore this mom to make her ashes Sunnah follows the majority and once you're making that Rosh Hashanah you're not making the new Richard son of a buck er because the tray that clearly puts them in the same posture come to the same umbrella Kumasi Berkovitz uncover chorus row you're a dreary maverick so Natasha shifter he say he doesn't say Marvel doesn't say mom will buck Korea tackle shifted because that's the majority that's what they should do shard ancestors the sagas Rea in his commentary to Ray Evan I'm a second edition which were one of the most prominent from a forum on my second edition of the two-day ever mother Jacques are you he says that the reason behavior doctors the majority is not only because more sheep are usually born than cows he says because there are two types of Bahama dacha that are high over my sir and that is cavour Simon isn't sheep and goats ah what'd ya think since it's two types of species when it comes to a Bahama gaster there's only one min that sky over my switches Bucer basically cows Bulls cows and the baby cows debate the baby of the cow which can either be a male or a female calf that is only 1 min when it comes to baby back he says you have to minam's so therefore you follow that besides the fact that Tori Evan says the baby's doctors are born more question quantity more than famous I think a sheep can give can give birth to always two but I think up to four no could it be more than four it's too but sometimes it's up to four do I've seen so that's common it's Carla and in the summer in the spring right has a bigger stronger animals this mine different birth in the winter you sink sheep usually you have to give birth in the spring so you say you saying that cows there's no time for births they do it all year so therefore you can't make a Russia shaman my shaking sheep you couldn't make a racial Shana cuz it's a time I'm saying very interesting he said sheep Tov could give birth usually in the in the spring or in the summer because they need a warm weather but cows are stronger they can give birth the whole year they're less fragile very interesting so you're saying that there for so you could make a time once you're making a time for the side we already put the Booker into that time because buckle very interesting sheep in Florida well I guess we're following her to Cyril ah the toast was young tough time is I mean pushed after know the facts he said the behave as gases often are also born in the month of of it's just they become pregnant four months before the Bahama stockist so usually the time is not that different that's what the toys jump this is very again you have to know them at sea is okay so therefore Marilyn explains the McLucas based on this plastic love should hurry might sign a mock him Yap to voice today Iowa she do do you focus on the mahkum ayaats levar which is other do you focus on the history ow after Shira which is the month of miss the Gemara however rejects this saga de Gomorrah there's a bit problem Lima little mayor I understand how this works according to the mayor who says that pregnancies in the month of other could exceed he follows the literal south of the pasta love sugar him outside the she become pregnant when bisman Sharma commutes valve or when the valleys are but Dec twist grain which is other and then the pus accessory he cannot me and then you have the late commerce you have the craft Susie have the procrastinators the Konami you say how after shooter which is innocent so the order of the parsec makes perfectly sets a little developers levels of it up Shimon a prima ballet according to them the primary time is Nissen that's the season so then the order of the pasta had to be it had to mean the opposite love so far about sewing when miss Manchester Alfie oshiro when the great dances and sings which is inocent the economy and then you have the early birds the early birds are mahkumat Vivar who come around and have relations and other and that's where they can see them become pregnant why would the posit first pay tribute and discuss the time when the minority of the she become pregnant not the majority so therefore it's very difficult to explain the passage this way Ella are my rava so rava says and of course is that a bee is difficult to hear and that is it seems also to be a Maha locust like partial timotheus when the majority of sheep become pregnant it's like you know go check it out in the farm I mean you're taking it in a plastic but go check it out so the poil lover rejects this perspective and he gives a whole different interpretation till the Kula Alma everybody holds the same thing love should hurry might sign bisman charm alchemy at vouloir yes there are those who become pregnant in different seasons but generally the time of other is a time of pregnancy which is bothered and nobody is arguing about that mayor agrees with that bilasa agrees and of shimon agrees if so we have our big problem because then everybody should have said if it's other than birth is of and reshawna should be destroyed a shallow well Harshad bhai curcuma flee they're actually arguing about shot and Apothic and it does not affect the time of pregnancy that's not a McCoy cos because we just explained a mahkum ayaat for voir that's the time yesterday i ofu cor the late comers for Huckabee hawk a behemoth there's a passage in parshas ray we read this parsha in the Yemen TV starts off a SATA a say as called woofers Erica hi yo say Hosoda Shawna Shawna this is a very critical positive one customized asset to us you have to give my sir the word - it comes to the word si esta means 10 my sir of course means one tenth we call it an English tithing which is mice asset to ask you to give myself from what cultivar sarasu all the grain of your seed how you'd say I saw the which comes out of the field sana sana year a year what does a year you mean means a year after year from here we learn a biggest site my sir works in terms of years I don't just say okay every five years take a look you have there a big pile of gray and a big part of the fruits just give my so once in two years once in three years no sana sana you have to go here by and that's where we have to know when the year begins when the ends because if not I don't have much sana sana what's wrong it's wrong that's why it's so important to have research on us for all these things now this is not talking about my so behind this talking about to us RF just Omar what we call my sir Duggan the my so we give from great so we're going to see soon when is richness under for my sir dog but what do we learn from here it says I said to acid why does it say acid to acid it had to say to asterisk all fours are F so as we already established many times the estoy dove titers about pair is that moisture a bay knows long serum are all written into the sukham the reason is because he wanted that Jews should be able to do Hazara sir shear and terrific salve is not before tarnish about that's actually after Tyra Shah Baba tarisha bakov is the record of the lectures of moisture Labe Namibia cavora but there was written in the brilliant way that everything he said in this year he contains in the plastic sometimes with an extra word sometimes with an extra letter sometimes with a gamete RIA so no matter how do we know that Nazir is thirty days because it uses the word year and year is become Anthony a thirty as the camera says but every every every vehicle will be used to explain and decide and and convey his message asked it to I said right away gets our light bulbs going there's a redundancy what asset asset passage to give my son know what my son is my son means one of that so the Gemara learns from here fish named Isis a cost of madaba deposit was not talking about one my sister my two my sis even though it says only one effort my son bahama vetted my so daughter one is my super Hema and one is my sister and I have to look what else do I give my saffron what else do you give my sir from we give myself and behavior minatoya so therefore we compare my Simba Hema to my sister dogyum that's why he put it all in one posit a Siddhartha he wants us to use the whole office of my sir dog on my set of grain to define the whole office of my so bahama now the question is what are we okay so we compared them thank you what am I supposed to do now I compared them what do I need a comparison for my sub aim is a clear welcome I said doggin is all of them what's the comparison here there's a much like this Ramaiya summative mayor says mawkish my subhanAllah my pseudo gone we jerk mawkish means compare or juxtapose you put together my sub aim with my pseudo go on to teach mom Meister Duggan's almost like Mario sir I just like when it comes to gray some oligomeric in close proximity to when it gets finished when it gets ripe and harvested and you finish the labor that's when it becomes Makhlouf in my sir that is delicious Shana from my sir in other words dog becomes McCoy you've in Mysore some mostly Kumari which is basically when you bring it into the house after you finish all the Malacca so basically you harvest it as we learned in the month of Nissen you straight out after Shiro that's when it's singing and dancing and that's when you harvest it of course you can harvest it later oh so you can harvest the month of the year the month of Civet and later but the earliest harvest is usually quite a shot of eve the month of Nissen what do you do then you do all the Moluccas that you have to do with the grain that we have in hopes of Shabbos everything you have to do in order to appear the grain in order to have kernels to be able to make flour to be able to produce your foods your breads or you want to sell it but that's not enough because you leave it in the fields for those summer season in order for it to dry up and remove its moist and then you bring it into the house so the Gemara melaka is always at the end the summer it's gonna rain soon you bring it out to the house that's why we established there is a sauna for it but a competition eh why because you finish the Malacca and then you must leave in my sir summer click Amara you surah when you finish the Malacca that's the time of my sister therefore delicious Shana is but a fraud be Tishri so therefore we say ask my sub a miss summer click Maria sir my sub aim is gonna have the same halakha that's uh mostly tomorrow the time when it becomes mature than my sir that's the time when each surah when is the time to give my someone is gonna be the richest Shana for myself what's a good morrow here Kamara here is birth birth that's Gomorrah by true or what is Gomorrah commodities not harvesting you still have a lot of Malacca to do and remember my sir is only motive after good mark Malacca and you bring it into the house so some early tomorrow right when it's all done you give my son that is gonna be usually after the petitioner Shoshanna so that's the time that's the time we define that's the time we define it so destroyed this Tishrei is gonna be some early tomorrow so usually somewhere in the month of Tishri you bring it into the house that's why suka s-- is called hog ha aasif right so now my question is when should start my my sir my my sad dog and what should be the time I say destroy this tisha is a good time I'm gonna do it so cook that's the middle of a month I do it which I this dish so anything that's now ready and came into the house after its registered so part of a new year but came in before it's part of the old year god that's fine what about my sub ahem I say the same thing some of the Gemara yes sir I want should you give my C to give myself after it's Kumar after it's done after its birth that becomes a sirisha since they're born in the month of off so therefore the F Codd Belleville is some early tomorrow that's what the mayor times the laws of it of Simmons suburb us or if Simmons say the same live with with opposite mawkish my sabaha mela my Sedova what's the diff what's the Micah's mom I said Doug initial initial a petition area today my salmon is your son - latisha just like my sister son is to say my sub aim is also dishonest what's the most like is sick the mayor says you learn from my sir Duggan and then you apply it to your own situation they're blessed if Simmons says no you learn from I said nothing exactly what's by mice a dog that mayor says you learn from my sir dog none but then you apply it to the way it works with your situation you don't just copy my sad dogging you learn a new cookie for my sir daughter that what that the time of Rosh Hashanah is some ugly maría that's the surah that's the time of my sir and then you apply it to my survey and you make a different month noble is a fisherman says no you compare it to my sir doesn't shut up just like my son bogging my sadness is all superstition so crash it mice a doggone summer click more assertive Richard Shah aalam Isis is still a donkey tunnel in the common the bright sir was swimming to see a bright side a few days that my sir Duggan is Richard son of a my suspicion it but to say somewhat like a Mario Tishrei is very close to when it becomes completed to call you my son Shana the holy my star comma a whole summer money from you believe them Lea average to dry up be good ownership as others and run this other silos the storage places in the fields so therefore some of the Gemara is when it should Sharna a competition a because gomorrah is right before and that becomes additional Oh My sirs so here - what's the moiré of the animals one of the animals the month of all right because we'd established they become pregnant and other they're born in of so what summers will tomorrow it's gonna be destroyed I shall avenge it made with a blossom adepts women say no you want to compare it to my sir doggone keep shooting my sir Duggan is a competition once they make what is shoddy and I'm changing there's your son huh this is your son this is your son yeah but wasting some re out there made you saying it what are you finishing everything you finishing even the ones growing in this area no no no mom I said Bahama my said talking everybody agrees same but what are you stablishing of nice it dr. waters me some of whom are you want everything you dumped the Malacca the mulatto has done yeah not to crawl out the growth so water yet wait if you're blind into my survey now walk wait once it's more this or the Malacca the slalom and about grain oh so this grain that can grow later oh so we're talking about the majority of grain that you harvested in the time of harvest we're done with the fact that could be grain later yeah with the grade that you harvest for one month you got a good day old no so what's the problem nobody have time it's very hard to separate them but we're not separating them it's a month and a half yes you do but it separated you to make a red mark on it and that's because they they play they run but you're saying that today most sheep are born in May and June not in August here he says they're born in August and oh what's this so you say today lamb I born in Nexus Schulz later focus yeah even in America focus remember Michael did one that was good one early spring late winter early spring another effect of global warming when the lamb I thought that everything was everything that early signals say they manipulate the hormone yeah nothing is natural okay something a motivator so this is so now we established among Lycus why they disagree about this on the myosin bahama it's not about when they're born it's about how we tied the lumbus of comparing it to my sir Douga do we mamas compared to my sir Duggan and we simply copy it's like I do what you do you're doing it as a petition I do it as potentially or we learn from my sir Duggan a principle that then we apply to our own lives he didn't say why he just said it's echoed by Elham their beloved shipment said you're wrong it's as a petitioner so thou mayor i am i struggling why'd they come up with these days it wasn't recorded in the mission that could be somebody asked him but in Mishnah wasn't recorded so generations later well the first one didn't work Robert says not one of me first of all didn't work the mayor is looking not at the my sir dug and keep shooting nothing good of it the Orion made out of it the smarter behind it and the severity applies to my Savannah he's not copying it keep shootin a blazar innocent men are like much more literal looks like my sit down it's like I said Douglas mathematician it's not going to motivate the acid petitionary Shoshana listenership the first of first of I'm sorry dushashana lashana the first day of the month of Tishrei is there a Shoshana for years now we go to the next part of the mission we're done with a feminism we're done with effin burello about my sub aim and now we go to the next Stickle of the mission which is the dishes something that we're most familiar with the acid batiste - a shuttle Hashanah the first day of Tishrei is the Russian summer for years now what does this mean initiation of three years doesn't mean thompson i in zion begins on the first day of Tishri huffed SLO it stops my evolved out of Tishrei is tough shin i ends i that maybe the shop but then the question is why is that mcgeehan Hawara why is that important than allah why do we have to make her ashes honour for this and of course the bigger question would be the history again we have no reason to use any month and say it's the beginning of a year we have to remember the clock what makes a year is an astronomical fact that after 365 and a half days the soul orbit is completed the Sun when we look at the Sun is orbiting around the earth of the earth is orbiting around the Sun it takes 365 and a half days until it reaches the original point and it starts to orbit again so after 365 and a half days you have a new year but remember you could start that year at any point you could start heading here whenever you want it would be an artificial date it's not like a competition a the Sun announces now I'm starting over again in a circle at any point any point you could call this is the beginning this is the end so we always have to understand why certain dates are chosen so we now discuss this as a petitionary which became the classic Rosh Hashanah for the Jewish people and mozzie when we call her Shoshanna we don't mean paisa and we don't mean that it's kinda shocked when we owe me this reddish elbow we mean this try this dish nobody kumarila my illness what do you mean mr. Sun of the Sun okay a new year began thank you for what not for my summer Hema right according to their citizens of may not for Malacca not for the Gullah not for Omer not for Minister Hadassah so the question is for what not free Lamas what's Mila shaman for years okay so we'll see how Maria papa republished such stars but it's not a halakhah that's that's very nice am i what you're saying is for heaven something am I wrong of popular stars this is nagae for documents what do we mean for documents for documents in the documents we used to write let's say I lent you money so the document you have to write at the time of the loan that's very important why is it so important to write it down over the loan because if there's a document there's a lien on your property for me to collect so when I want back my loan I want my hundred thousand dollars that I lent you and you don't have money coming to get you all so I could take your property because there's a lien on your property what happens however if you sold your property Mylene was there first because I lent you the money I want at first you can't just give it away your property before you paid up your debt there's an outstanding balance here what happens if you sold your property before I lent you the money I can't go to the buyer and take away his property why because there was no lien on that property it was sold it already belongs in before the law so here's the question if I really lent you the money and really - listen but I ride in the document that I lent you the money I'm Hanukkah and you sold your building I'm put in so I could come to your buyer and take away the building and it's illegal it's gonna it doesn't belong to me because you sold it I'm poor them and you only borrow the money which I dismiss it but the document best it would it not that's why the date is so important and we have a clock starts McDonough's suelen started smooth herring shading they don't care if the date is later the date days later fine I was Michael I lent you the money rich tradition is and I tell you that I liked it too you live boy okay I was mostly a month and a half you get away with murder if you sell a building that month cuz I'm tired I'm not gonna be able to take it they don't care if the lender is Michael that's his that's his right he's very nice but the other way around it's some like it did it's illegal I'm taking away from a bar you was an innocent man I'm taking away his house and now he asked her to go to the original cell and I take him to court they come to the Toyota to get back to the money then he paid him for a building that he couldn't keep that would be unfair that's a really illegal it's honorable he's a solid I can't be a topic of nine Herman right the levosa can be excitedly come on on the barrios Cashman it's not fit the letters I don't care if he takes the building thank you it's not yours you ready sold it to somebody I can design not sounding about Satan's cash so therefore such a star that have come disqualified and they don't let the mouse' even take the properties that he actually sold after the loan in other words the whole document becomes disqualified it becomes like a Millville pet becomes like a verbal law so what does it piss dissent up up ass a wrap-up is saying that they used to ride the time of the law the time of the loan the month or the date and date they also wrote the year from when no they wrote the year from when the king at the time became king so that's what we said earlier that's the d'amour assuming a struggle with because he's look like the saying the same thing so we used to use the year from when the King became to the Mishna says that there could be Tishrei that's when the new year begins in other words if the king the new king became a king say the King's name was Trump and he became a king uncuffed SLO and I lend you money on some Gedaliah I lend you $100,000 on some Gedaliah what do I say it's the second year of his majesty meaning he would love this maybe he's listening to the shin it's the second year of his majesty right the second year ah he was only a king for three days but it seems like he was a king but nine years so what do you AC nursery son f Hermitage is considered a loo year I think I was a king one day that's one year young man that was a year Richard Shana is the beginning of the second year Lamine of Chaminda the year changes let's say he becomes a king last year Rosh Hashana because someday then if she's on the stack in the second year let's he becomes a king on pour it okay so he was a king for six months and that's at one year so register son is always the anniversary now you'll ask a question why do you why don't you just make that adversity when that anniversary is if you became a king important so put it will be that adversity the answer for that is that they didn't feel everybody will remember these dates because they're not that significant for the Jewish world for the Jewish people and therefore what's gonna happen is there could be a tremendous confusion what's the confusion what's gonna be the confusion I should actually explain enough base they say what do you have to do to remember your wife's birthday you forget it once that's what you have to do so let's see over at poppy of Poppy's up with starters tonight cuz we learned in a mission EMA secretary is started a family domain if you have started claim if you have loan documents that I'm abdomin meaning the time that's written on them is before the actual loan suelen those stories our Siouxland they're disqualified and the lender cannot take and collect his loan from the property that the borrower's sold to somebody even after the loan we treated like a mill gone pear like a verbal loan this is a special class that we give him why because he did something wrong by allowing the date to be before the loan even by one day Omaha mall heron if you have a document with the date is late after the time of the loan shade in its caution why because the lender is not making anybody lose money illegally by making the date late he's not doing anything wrong by it he's doing maybe something wrong for himself but that's his choice cousin Ted you want to be a nice guy go something therefore in order to be able to make this distinction between our starting Mook them and their start remove her the Cohanim said the estimate issue we need a cut-off time for our anniversary why because if every document would be written based on when that key actually became a king so here we have a problem I'm a bestie and a document comes to me and I see a document that was signed by witnesses and the witnesses said the lawyer came to us and said do me a favor do me a favor give me a document that I borrowed money from him and him and the halacha is that you're allowed to do it even though the malva is not there and even though the loan is not happening because the guy wants to say that he borrowed money he needs the document and the aide to say we don't know if the date was before the loan or after the loan but we do know that this live--i basically got money from this malva at another time from the date that's written in the star in other words we know that there was one halvah there was one month there were no too long okay so they say we know that there was alone but we don't know if this date here is the loan that what was it's not the date that was written in the star they wrote their star without seeing the whole phone so if we don't know when the MELAS became amela so we're not gonna know this stars are star MOOC the worst time or let's give an example that actually gives if it says in the star Kislev a the third year of the kink kiss little the third day of the eighth this come and say ah there at which king often they have the same name I mean that that depended on the situation then they say the loan actually happened Thomas of the third year the loan happened Thomas of the third year now if the King became a king after Thomas before kislev if he became so that what what was the vote so then kiss live is before Thomas so the star is a star wouldn't why is this not a look at them because the date was Kistler than the third year and the longest Thomas so it's a possible time but what if it was the other way around what of the king became a king after Kistler before Thomas then after Kissel before Thomas then it's good then Thomas precedes kislev in the year of the king so such time Walker it's kosher so therefore best don't won't know what to do so therefore they always made bad for the tisha should be the cutoff time so therefore you always know that what if the data's kisseth and the long was Thomas so that it's time look at the much time over if the date is kiss them and the long was Thomas just time look at the much time over time look at them because it's just some of them allow him is when the a competition a force Paris matters a lot the stories and therefore it's gonna be a star modem so the Gemara let's just see Barton on the expedition is a Shambhala Malacca I don't understand you a wine earlier you said it second business environment no we asked them tough Basel my hopeless so Watson again Barbara please deliver us you just said the same hole play that he said on national fitness and for the goomar la casa con mouth he saw comma mouth humor silence when we said this asana which TARDIS is the first day of this is talking about Jewish Kings here when we sang extra petitions as a son of three years and they gave for your documents it's talking about non Jewish Kings it's two different types of kings starting tomorrow Hamid is the business and enough game already my Shah know the mouthpiece ullevål malcolmus emblem segmentation Inman inner wisdom us listen are so lush Mena the prison that gimble's said that when it says backup innocent is there's your son that's only for non Jewish King for Jewish King but for non-jewish penis mathematician to perfidy submission according to you I need to produce done I'm ready to tell me what the mission is gonna say the next line that back of the tissues which is summer for shaman which means for non-jewish kings so I'm gonna go murder lawyer please it's not telling you to did it did I know from the Mishnah there is the cry our solution there is that comes and teaches us how the Mishnah knows it remember the Gemara it appears that there goes into all of the details in discussing that took him about Persian history about my family showing that there's a distinction between how they counted the non-jewish Kings anniversaries to the Jewish kings anniversaries so if this is not telling you the halacha he's just saying our luck as a preload to explain the reason the sources of that waka from the book but thou love itself we know from the mission but the question how did the mission to make this distinction why would cause I'll make this distinction so the prison is explained to you from the sukham that is a different emotion solemn alchemist I look but the vote is the same work if they're Shoshanna for the anniversary of the king that is relevant for documents for non-jewish Kings it's going to be the first day of this right that is gonna be the considered the new year of the anniversary for Jewish Kings it's going to be the restrain dismissing and that's what we called her Shoshanna lamella and we recognize the Jewish kings of kings it's interesting but the non-jewish Kings will call it shaman and for the Jewish Kings we'll call it the luck because the real mouse course we want to attribute to the jewish king so the available cultures have trouble of a locker and for the non-jewish kings will call the Trish Hashanah with summon mr. Shawn over the years this is the first perspective of the participant tomorrow is gonna go on to give different perspectives of why this is Irish Hashanah not connected necessarily to the non-jewish seven lines from bottom customer Dolloff his line start slash me another second lash manner by the woods be buddy same so the Gemara is now addressing the next part of the mission and that taught us that the first day of Tishri is Rosh Hashanah with Seanan Jewish Hashanah for years and the question is okay so we start counting our years from F the petitioner which is what we do our years we start counting on the first day of Tishri the question is Allah my hill kisser what are their halawet ramifications in other words why is that really relevant so the first answer was presented by the Papa and if Papa says is extremely relevant for documents which staris has explained at length and what we referring we are referring here to is not counting of the year since the creation of the world but counting of the years of the anniversary of the king who was raining at the time and every effort petitioner is counted as a new year regardless which day in the year he was actually coronated and when he assumed his throne a visitor Gemara wondered we just said earlier that that is designated for the first day of Nisan Richard sama lamaa lava shoulda pissed explain that there were two types of kings there were Jewish kings of there were non-jewish kings the Jewish Kings their anniversary is celebrated on the first day of missin missin is so to speak the Jewish month missin is the month of each es material missin is the month when Jews this is a fiduciary on explains the Jews became an independent people and therefore they can have their own king they're not under perry's dictatorship anymore in other words listen is the Jewish celebration of Independence the celebration when Jews become a nation so therefore that's when Jewish Kings celebrate their anniversary Tishri on the other hand is considered the universal month it reflects all of humanity right especially if you're going to believe I mean we're going to discuss that much like is a little later in the Gemara if the world was created in Tishrei or Nissen but if it was created in Tishrei so then other marushin was created on effort petitio thurman cava other man cava the father's the other man cava are the parents of all of humanity the Jewish people is love with all of humanity so really every person is connected to other men cava he is the father of every single human being it's not the Jewish unique month so this is the says this is just explanation the fire that Tish today F of the tissue Shoshanna Lashon M is what which year the year of the non-jewish king that was the explanation that I say I said your puppet I said that have I said to please that this is a business explanation I if so why does the Gemara quote it earlier in the name of wisdom when really it's a clear mission there's your son home alone with your son of a sonnet and if it isn't it told it to us as a hid this early on DAF Kimmel when it says his son on the maluf him it's only for Jewish people but not for non-jewish community should have it I said the Mishna says a line later mr. Kumar and Susana Kaname the sources and the mystery of Krishna was just explaining how the mission annoyed in other words why we would were differentiate and one of the sources and for this he gave us the sukham of tomas and we learned earlier and i've gimel to establish this truth so this is where the answer is holding at the moment that this both wishes son on the bellossom this is called melaka this is called Shannon this is called for Jewish kings and this is for non Jewish killers something might have I to ve bias n b-boy you say means D bias means if you want a mur say that's why whenever the Gomorrah gives an alternative a second answer it's usually ve boy Samer which means ii-if bias you want Amos say in others if you wish there's another answer what is the second answer the police that could observe the master yup his de who said earlier in the Gemara that Gentile kings count their anniversary from the thursday of Tishri he actually holds that when it says in the Mishnah that f of petitioners or Shoshanna leshawna it's not referring to the years of the king which would of course make it mortgage smack because then it's not a repetition of Rosh Hashanah normal of him is just different kings there's a shuttle the shuttle would actually be a new thing that doesn't exist before according to your Papa's interpretation both are issues shot on the Malacca just one is for Jewish kids one is for non-jewish King so you differentiate it by using the word Malacca and using the word shun so the mind says now it's possible that her shuttle is sanam actually means something completely different as we will see and therefore when it is de said on that gimmick that from mouth film asylum you counts from today it was a hit it wasn't something that says in the mission let's talk about something else I would then be the interpretation of Hashanah leshawna he says look I'm saying it appears the holes I kept saying and therefore he says that for mouth you Masai let me have a different issue tion because he doesn't have that source in the Mishnah not like we explained before in rev Pablo what's could have say to master the knobs a term items ada said when the Mishna says that the first day of traditional a shaman the mission is talking about with the Kufa he's talking about what we call the Kufa which means the change of season we'll explain in a moment with a velocity because up seda said that our mission of follows a ble Ezard the amar who says and this is going to be the discussion on the field petitionary new varaha island that the world was created on Tishrei versus rubio shuo believes that the world was created in the month of Nissen and therefore according to the bellezza that the world was created in disarray so therefore the first Kufa the first coffer of creation is not that cool for listen it's that cool for of Tishri so therefore when you say Rosh Hashana Lashon um that's what you're saying it's delicious Shawna for years meaning the first coffer is not to cool fast listen if first go fast go fast it goes this is following the of Rabbi Eliezer that petition ever had that's a wonderful question you can ask on this also the meiosis same question we asked before fine so we know that this is the first Kufa when the world was created competition and rather than my Hill cursor that's a very good question so briefly when we say look to Kufa what are we referring to we know that there are four seasons in the year generally the tropical year in other words the solar year we have four seasons what we call spring and you have summer and then you have yeah when you have the autumn and then you have the winter the cold months so when we see her now she take a look v by segment the piston it's sitting in on kadam on and the mouse will miss petitioner now please don't have to tell us that there is a sauna for Gentile kings especially Leslie Hubbard of popper the polish dushashana LaShawn and the jacala staris he actually disagrees with Ruth Papa who says Rosh Hashana lashonna means loose Thomas Ella can observe a master in law the producer dilution and Emma's Nyssa when he's looking for an interpretation of Shannon he chooses his aide and not repop the Nevada marcelina Shoshanna Lashon em means with Koufos qumola vonda meaning lamar sham moines in lib real sorry Luka shalt Koufos a comma on oil - olive anima Tichenor the way we count the year is based on the creation and the movements of the Toccoa of the comma and the births of the lavona we always started from Tichenor and not from misson where that bilasa Kodama petition every of them will come on the Perkin on da fiel so we have these four seasons and there no one asked Koufos Nissen this is when spring begins then you have what's known as - Koufos 7 when summer begins then you have to cuff us Tishrei that's the end of the summer autumn begins and then you have it Koufos Tavis this is winter begins I'm sorry Thomas Thomas yeah East Cofer is approximately three months around 91 days so therefore if you start with Tishrei so you'll have to say - and kiss lovely and then you'll have to go first Avis then you'll have david scott are there any left go first listen you'll have missing near seven and you'll have Koufos thomas an english Koufos missing they call today the equinox and it's basically it's marked we know that we see that Koufos immediately because one COFA Koufos Nissen and Koufos Tishrei will be the days when with those days in the year two days out of the year when the day and the night will be equal equal usually it's either a longer they're shorter night or a longer night in a shorter day but those two days when the sun is parallel with the equator according to the orbit so those are unique two days that's begins to go first listen and then go first issue then you left Koufos seven I'm sorry to Koufos Thomas that day will be the longest day of the year and the shortest night of the year and then you'll have to go first Avis and you'll have the exact opposite the shortest day of the year and the longest night of the year so the question is what does the word mean what the word means so the rishonim say that it's connected to the word hawk offer like hackus Kufa equinoxes equinoxes equinoxes let's go fastness Saudi and and basically these are the beginning of the seasons so east hoof is approximately 90 days or 91 days actually there's a locus exactly how you measure the toughest which we're gonna get to not know it generally is not counted in the Hebrew months because it's fat remember our Hebrew months follow the moon and that Koufos are based on the Sun not the moon so therefore the toughest are usually in the days of the secular calendar it's it's it's the 21st so you have the 21st of March around approximately 21st of March is Koufos listen then you have Koufos Tamas is the 21st of June then you'll have Koufos Tishrei will be will be September September 20 September is yet 21st and they left go first Avis is usually around December 21st or sometimes December 23rd ah right around the December 23rd that's gonna be toughest types those are the toughest now the question is when the data coffers begin if the world was created in the month of Nisan so the rabbinical eylem set up the system that history should begin with the season of Nissen so on the Wednesday it says in Hamish that on Wednesday sham said he Hema iris with Hashem I'm the Wednesday of creation so the Morris the luminaries which are the Sun on the moon start functioning so then they start functioning as the Kufa of Nissen the Cofer comes from the word hack off' which means orbit like a coffin right make a coffin time as well right right so the creation of the time and of the functioning of the galaxies was related to what happens in what happens every single year but go for Venus and that's how it begins or if you say according to the bill attacks the of Libya schewe which is gonna be discussed in the few that length or the sit of rebel as it is petitioning of royal if so the first go for would be go fast Tish ret so when the morones the luminaries were hung up so to speak in the heaven and the heck of begins each coffer represents a certain heck of a certain end in the orbit it's not the complete orbit complete orbit ends after 365 days it's a point in the orbit that completes a certain heck of that's why they call it a coffer and there are four such points which basically are responsible for the different types of seasons during the year it's very very cold or it's very very hot or it's beautiful or nice weather that depends on the relationship between the position of the Sun and the earth and each Kufa represents a different position in that relationship hence the different tropical seasons of Nissen thomas tishreen tavis so as a result of this if you say that the world was created in Tishrei and therefore the Cooper's begin with Koufos Tishrei that would mean that Tishrei is the first season by which he count now you'll salem Myhill sister lamai enough come in why is this sauna gaya so if you just look the first opening words of thai service mr. bass are so I'm gonna get back to the stage this is a long complicated Thai service that has to do with the search bonus of kitchen and instant but I wonder I want to introduce ya you have to start calculating from from a point right now from creationist that would be one difference when you start counting counting calculating your mullet face versus look at those missing sums it up he says Oh mine in my little Ivana but Kufa mathematician two things and these two things you see gnashing number one you start counting the birth of the new moon which means the first year Striders so to speak what is called my little Ivana when do you count it not from ebony Simba to measure petitionary and the same is true that Cofer so this is both Nagaya to the Sun which is responsible for the toughest for the tropical seasons and for the moon for the Maya that's right now she says mine in Libra us and we lose himself go fossa come on Mulder Solomon imitation one second no no no he's just setting two separate things created on Friday you're right you're right so we can take about the caca we think about the consideration on 2% yeah so toaster says but if you're sure my name innocent to be sure would say listen now you may say who cares those verses V yesh nuff Kusa mère ubu bit over this is very important there's a big enough cumin and of course that means there's a lot of ramifications in but measure coid the meaning shall sir l'm initials x-axis on the fact that this minion is a half a year before this one because the straightest ish days I have for you before the tradition listen yes and of course a little bit over there are there is a very important result of this and that's why it's Nagila my helpers what is the what is the difference so the toast was just says reaction of course super dumb and you gotta figure it out and then he goes off to a whole other subject about Nissen and dictionary which needs more introductions baleen at the basin are some we'll get back to this theis was just a big a big central to suggest the ketosis initial shock but the players who are here entice this explains that what toasters probably means here that the suction of course of a dumber is generally we have ad in and this is a very important in because it's the Assizes of ibrahim that when it says summer as hoggish of if we have to make sure that either char of if that Nissen is in the month of spring pacer is celebrated in the month of spring first of all that has practical ramifications cuz i'm pay stuff you have to bring a carbon a mer so you have to have ready ripe barley if you still in winter season you're not gonna have your barley you can't bring a carbon timer you don't have your spirit or your being without to limit success say you're affecting Lewis I mean I'm sure it's unique ain't above you have another two months for that but v you see must have a carbon so practically speaking you need to make sure that your pay suck has not happening Hanukkah time that's number one number two the trader clearly says summer I'll show you the shovel and you need a smear why do you need a smear if it whenever it says Smith it means you have to guard it cuz if not the Ghanim is gonna run away and the reason is because pace is gonna run away talk payslip is gonna run away because basis is based on the lunar month we explain and the lunar month is 11 months shorter than the lunar year is 11 months sort of in the solar year and therefore every single year you're gonna have a bigger and larger and larger discrepancy as they have in the Muslim calendar when it comes to Ramadan so therefore summer is right there so if you have to guard card to shovel how do you guard the service basically every few years we have to give our lunar year an extra 30 days and that way it catches up and we don't have a discrepancy between the seasons which are based on the Sun and the LM time which are based on the moon if this is the case cuz I'll had to make sure the Sun hadn't had to make sure that Tess above Nissen was always after to cool fastness Koufos Nissen had to begin before tests of organism in other words before pacer comes in you already have the kufur the error the orbit of Nissen which basically is the introduction of spring so that the carbon pesach and pacer the young to face that is being done in kurdish of if they saw that Koufos Nissen falls out after Tesla venison in other words pace are our pace on the 15th day of Nissen is starting before Koufos listen remember that suaveness and is based on the moon tuku fastness in what we called covetous is based on the Sun so if they saw that test both listen is starting before through first initial so your pacer it's starting before spring this was the reason to grade Ybor asana to add another month to add an extra other so of course even if the Koufos listen would start use ayan listen it's not a prom coup that's gonna start you desire another Shanee or her father Shanee or Sophia they're shiny and with the time pacer comes your perfectly in toughest miss if this is the case we have to understand when the Koufos began why because generally speaking as the plane issuer says from the Gemara generally speaking because i say generally because it's a big mark like this between actual and of other how you counted Koufos and it basically has to do with when the orbit of the Sun is completed every year but generally speaking we're talking about the separation the time of every golfer is 91 days and seven and a half hours 91 days and seven and a half hours which is approximately three months right if a month is 30 days a 30-60-90 approximately a little more than three months 91 days fits in perfectly two weeks 91 days is 13 weeks exactly right 91 has 13 weeks so therefore if that we want to go for another two of us 91 days essentially it's the same day that kufur the next gopher is gonna be the same cool for now one's gonna be the same day of the week but that's gonna be seven and a half hours off seven and a half hours later because one that separation is 91 days and seven and a half hours so this is the case if you're going if you're skipping two to go physically from Koufos tissue the toughest missing so you have 91 days twice and seven and a half hours twice so the difference is gonna be 15 hours that's gonna be the difference 15 hours so here the penne issuer says this is what ptosis means that there's a major difference you start youth Koufos with Tish today or if you started to go Fitness because if you start you cook food with Nissen so then Koufos Tishrei is gonna be 15 hours later you start to Koufos Tishrei so to cook first listen' is gonna be 15 hours later so sometimes the Sun headsman could look at Tessa Bhavna sin and confess listen right and if you started with Koufos Tishrei so then they're going to say you have enough time or the other way they may say you not have enough time in other words this difference of 15 hours could be the question if Tesla Venus and started after to go first Nyssa and then you need an extra month forever Hashanah or Tesla Venus has started before KO fastness and that depends want to go first listeners so if Koufos listen you understand if Koufos listen was the first so the first issue is gonna be later if the first issue is the first that go first listen is gonna be 15 hours later if the first is gonna be see now is later so let's say Koufos listen starts right 14 hours after Pacers begins or whatever after to smokeless in a few hours do you make any Bradshaw no don't you make any bribes on you have to make any Brianna because Tesla venison has to be after to go first listen this would be a major Hewlett if you count like them but loser or you count a clearly show when it comes to the maze fine remember handle Kufa starts in April April 21 I mean March 21 that's fine you're good the act of March good the end of March you got that spring that's gonna be the date the time when the day and the night will be equal basically 6 o'clock a.m. to 6 o'clock p.m. the American calendar which is based on the Roman calendar is completely based on the Sun they don't have come they don't either they don't do they don't work with it you don't need the moon for it they the moon makes it complicated because it's a different Mahalo the Muslims follow only the moon the Romans and today's calendar here in America follows only the Sun ok you have your problems they have their diff different issues to come up but it's basically you're dealing only with one orbit in the Jewish calendar you're synchronizing to different orbits that don't work together they're not supposed to work together but we need them to work together because our months have to follow the moon says ahoy dishes L ahem rush reduction are hadoo shall follow that I do shall Ivana we need to take into consideration the moon we don't have any other months we don't make months based on the Sun we don't take the solar year and split it into twelve parts we don't do that we look at the moon and we follow the orbit of the moon and that's what we make our rich tradition so our pace that has to follow the moon we don't have another pace that's our test focus on the other hand it has to be hard to solve so this is where you need the synchronization look I'd be us somebody once said that Israel is a wonderful countries just in a bad neighborhood yeah but we're gonna learn that you have the two calendars the Julian calendar by Julius Caesar and then the Gregorian calendar that has changed by the Pope in order to make it more adjustable we'll see it becomes very negated our fish - yes always it so that you can make either 29 days or 30 days that because yeah yeah yeah that they can make 29 or 30 do so that's what we say don't make it before as your son said the Ebro year should not be made before the summit should be made as close as possible so that every Jew in cooks loves Mahmoud only bit the other dalamud under you can only make the effort if they did it it's my goodness no no no no they have to do the EBR before Mahmoud harder but they see that the truth remember you could you could calculate that coup for much before yeah yeah yeah the calculation they made before something about invited sorry Shoshanna leshawna means the new year begins what's at the new year begins that we look at the creation of the world the initially and therefore when we look at the office we say what's the first coffer the first coffer is Tishrei madness or what's the first my lid the first mile it is the lavona of Tishrei madness ah according to the bellezza our missionary of Zeta says follows a bilasa that's what a charlatan if not goodbye it's a comma if not gonna be it success it's a whole different part at the petitioner Charlotte sanam has nothing to do with Koufos and only with stars within it has to do with din with judgment what's the deal you know we wield her name the Jewish world everyone knows Rosh Hashanah Yom Kippur you may have been but doesn't say anyway and how much structure think nor does it and he said the word um I didn't even brought in Hamish nor does the Commission even bring the word Rosh Hashana right the name - Shoshanna you don't have in Hamish and how much it says that on the seventh month on the first day it should be your true healer huh so the whole thing about Rosh Hashanah is not stated explicitly in how much so the investments and Rosh Hashana Lashon and means that it's a didn't it's the day that the Year is judged the whole year is judged on this day he has to bring a source for this witness descent the conceived as a pasta Compassion's Acres moisture Devane was praising and extolling the virtues of artists syrup and he says the famous pasta Ariat Sasha malic acid DeRusha Tom made a mere shamela caribou Malaysia Shoshanna the add a three-shot it's the land that Hashem is the eyes of a Shem are on this land from the beginning of the year until the end of the year so the how come and explain this plastic what does it mean his eyes are they from the beginning of the year till the end of the year could have said his eyes are there always if it's from the beginning of the year till the end of the year so then it's always right so to say a national attack of atomic so the hosel th may raise a son and need ein Maya hey besides that basically made a she's our son of a doctor Hashanah from the beginning of every year he judges what is going to happen for this year till the end of the year every year has its own size when its own unique energy its own unique opportunities its own unique mission its own unique challenges its own unique virtues so that's where it is a separation relationship when is that gracious of shuttle when is this beginning of the year again we could make the beginning of the year whenever we want the commuters register snake administrative status bus emphasis ride aesthetician eight this is the beginning of the year saga the Gemara MMI officially Oh how do you know it's Titian it says races are summer after Hashanah see Italian each shot is that is one day in the beginning of the end of the binary loyal of judges and decides what's going to happen for the entire year from the beginning of the until the end of the ad after his son so the question is how do you know tuition it saga dear mother Dixit let's just see that she did save a mere sham al arab nakamura eats her coma doctor actually there's a shuttle the son of the Tanami off her lead in town talking about judgment chuckles water cooled on Bautista Lea's cold boil and judges everyone in the world called Barilla means not only Jews every single person who's a citizen of the world call a chorus from everything that's going to happen with them ad - should I bow to the next issue a tech-savvy national accommodations Hashanah hammock sorrows and eggs are reserved well magnitude you how do you know the fish days of the new more addictive because it's a pasta come to Hill and pay Rick pay Aleph capital pay elephant is actually the sure Shalom of Thursday Tico bhai this chauffeured back assert lianca gay no can I clear all who missed batalik Ayyappan it's a very interesting passage was translated possible Tacoma Heidi Shafer you should blow in the month Schieffer it doesn't say which month it just says blow safer in the month tinkle box idea safe back esse Leone mahogany well there's my castle young Hagane know me so literally them a foursome saved by casa rashly brings into hell and means a designated time Tico bhai the chauffeur you should blow chauffeured bhai dish but Castilian car Ghana with the designated time for the day of our Howland the Gemara here is gonna touch my casa from the word ki-suh which means a cover cover up like missile a fascist eclipse so he says like this what's T Co bhai - a book has Nagaina what do you mean blow show you for during among a whole month you blow show for which month so we see here Tico bhai to show for me they have to blow safer when bhai dish a Castilian Hagino azo hog which is a holiday shanghai - miss castle boy that the toy dish is covered up during that holiday and generally when we say here hi dish we don't need it as we say for this which means a month the reason we call hi - a month because it comes from the word Kadosh which means new like the word kiddush why do we call a month new the answer is because a month is based on the fact that there's a new moon so the whole month is called Kadesh only because it comes from the city shala vana unlike of course the lunar cycle the so that unlike the solar cycle the lunar cycle is one that during the month the moon goes through a complete orbit around the Earth and as we know the system is that there are different stages in the moon what we call the waxing and waning of the moon and generally the moon makes this orbit around the Earth so when the moon actually is in a position where it's between the Earth and the Sun so the moon is facing the Sun we can only see a half of the moon the half of all that we can see 180 degrees of the ball of the moon when the moon is facing the Sun and actually absorbing all of its light but it's parallel it's in between the earth if this is there if this is if this is the earth and then you have here the moon and then you have the Sun on top of it and the moon is facing the Sun so the moon is absorbing all the light and we see absolutely nothing that is the moment of the new moon so to speak when the moon starts moving away a little bit so then you see the thin sliver the crescent of the moon and then as it moves further away you see more of the sliver more depressive it waxes and it grows until the moon goes the other side and now the moon is on the other side and the earth is between the Sun and the moon and now the half of the moon that we see we see perfectly as it's reflecting the light of the Sun and it's showing showing at all it shows us that light and then the moon starts getting closer to the Sun as it's completing its orbit and here again it wanes it becomes smaller and smaller until it become goes back to that position between the Earth and the Sun where again it's going to be completely eclipsed that moment is called Rosh Chodesh but we cannot celebrate that moment yet because we don't see anything when the witnesses see the moon the moon already moved out a little bit so now they could see the new which is always a tiny little sliver and then they can come to Besnard and bet it will make it fresh garnish so that's the moment of the mullet of the birth of the new moon and that's what we mean by high dish it's a new moon why is it called a new moon because it's so to speak reborn of course legate the moon itself the moon is always there the moon didn't disappear but from our vantage point you say the moon disappeared it was gone it was so to speak dead and it has Lisa Mason its rebirth this is called mild olive on Sheamus Italy Scottish come Ison because the earth can't block the thought the position of their at the view of the of the of the moon reflecting the Sun it's just we get to see it because of our position so actually we see the light most when it's the most distant from its source the gobby the sun's light so sera she says Azores also azo hugs are high dismiss customers and now which young TIFF is a young tough of Kesser every other young t'v pay sucks is the 15th day of the month there's no cover-up of the moon Circus is the 15th day of the month is no cover-up of the moon comic am put in my own time Madeira Bona and there anyway not in days of cover-up of the moon slowest is again love Sylvan is not at the day of cover-up of the moon moon you could see a zohar shocked i dismiss castle 1 when is back a stolen car gained a younger gainer that's characterized by cancer we know they answer the only one young to fly that have the emissaries our son so when it says Tico bhai decipher what does it mean it means Tico rice Reuters you should blow on the new moon Schieffer by Castle Ian Craigie no the holiday that is celebrated when you have coitus when you have the new moon in other words when the moon is covered up huh you're a part of Hanukkah but it doesn't begin but guess what a bichon may even exceed so we know that what this possum is talk matter son even though it doesn't say the winter Sun don't say the word Tishrei but it says back a cilium car game okay see right after that it says you should blow straight for Waikiki high cholesterol whoo mich Petrovic a yak it's a time of a hike Aloha stablished for the Jewish people and then we say right after that it's miss but it's a time of justice from the kayako so they have a clear path succumb to Hill in capital pay out of which indicates that the first day of Tishri which is mr. Shawn about cassoulet and contain no is the UM Amish but that's the source that mr. Shaughnessy i'ma did to Hill and pay all of sure so um of young Commission she and that's what if naturally its accessories your son all the Sunnah means it's the racists our son about athletes on a soil it says an acre made Asus our son about your son it's referring to what's racist I found that I don't know what rages our son is but from tell them I see nations are some it is every petition a and that's the miss Butler hey active and that's why it says from the beginning of the until the end of the year cuz he's examining what's gonna happen this year and deciding the fate and the destiny and the unique mission of this year I think I told you once is a beautiful vote from the debris from the South Miami says why does it say made Asia's Hashana bad arteries Shana I'll be dicta either cementations Hashanah Vedanta is Hashanah Amadeus son of a doctor's son for example in English you say for the beginning of the year till the end of the year or from the beginning of a year till the end of a year not from the beginning of the year till the end of a say he said that people in the beginning of the year most people have this feeling that this is gonna be hot sauna it's gonna be the year of my life this is gonna be unbelievable you know remember the first day in yeshiva you come in a fresh Carissa a fresh reverie everything is good it's gonna be the year and then the year goes by a week later you got thrown out the week goes by they come the end of the year it's another year bites the dust another year bites that though you know this is gonna be they I'm gonna make my dreams come true so that's another so Titus things you just know this is this is how this is how life works so first of all don't get depressed there's gonna be a new year second of all try to make sure that the end of the year should to be able to be harsh on and not just some to say we say who will Akane elusive of Shabbos hanga LT a scam after is curvaceous that the avarice should be able to be like the bodacious if you're able to be harsh on to be able to be the year so a Mela what's ratios are shown there's excellent issue something of Martin occupied so we have three interpretations the purpose says it started episode it says it's Koufos Rebbe Nachman says it's judgment you could say you could say you could say but it says in telomere this is the time of mish but you don't have to say any where the Domitian is following a Belleza petitioning of loyola and a quarter of poppy also not to say follows noble ossicles let's notice is not Nagaya malformed asylum they count for Tishri yeah it's not negating yeah so do you motivate what's the difference of what this is the day this is the day to replenish the lager especially examines every person's life and the whole world you know it's the fresh banana fish he makes a freshman enough which was somewhat the listen of a person is open to it so then they can experience it more something about a right to turn it up on them the rabbi's taught key cyclists all who miss Metallica yankov Mohammed the beautiful in with Mohammed shame bezants on my lineage motherland in a Lincoln keeps abreast in Sumatra savage best in Sumatra would not go in to the dinner British on until they don't make sure that best inshallah motto was Mikado's the side dish in other words best in some mindless so to speak as to wait what happens LaMotta is a time of year my then we don't know if they made in Turkish dish today so yeah I did what if L had 30 days then it starts a day later so best in sha Allah my Allah will not go into the day my den until they look at besan cheela Matta that Truckee likely sure although mishpat lilica Yaakov it's Easter all that have to begin the process and then Allah K Jakov could make the mish but based on his strong but it's always kids abetted some artists ahoy - ah ya ya installed into the kitchen aluminum yeah so bastard so Martha's in the hospital did after the kitchen best in the mountains there's no din if the Jew was not makka - LaMotta the high dish is also the remans deserve art you talk about whom on the Kuti Maharana of not even a breslav brings from his Delta Zeta from the Baal Shem Tov says the boss Hampton once said it says in pretty office listening me out to Austin listened in the Cashman so the question is Washington dick took first comes the fisherman then comes the din Cashman is the calculation din is the verdict you don't first make the verdict and then make the judgment that's a corrupt court he first haven't in they make a session and then he says all such as it becomes venafro in me not other me ditoy the shal i mean i tell you exact payment from a person consciously and unconsciously what's per shot the motion of document brings from is a they've all summative that he touched that generally throughout life people are given an opportunity to judge people all the time right Baruch Hashem we have people we meet you could judge people all the time you remember Lila 24 hours a day and some people are busy with that small summative says Bashar somebody comes to bested shall milah they don't start judging his life that's not how it works basically they show him another person's life and basically he has to give judgment or they saw him how are you ready judged over all over the years and then they show him that everything he judged one another person somehow throughout his life he did the same thing or something similar so basically it starts with a din and then it starts with a Dennison - first is add in on somebody else and then they say oh let's make a Cashman here yeah this is your life so basically you were ready made a judgment for yourself nobody else to judge you yeah so the friar Bernardo midnight yeah so that struck me tightly with salami tighter it's all me tighter you decide it but it's avoid me diet because you're deciding it on somebody else and then it's avoid it's midnight to is I decide what's gonna happen to me but some like me dieter cuz I think I'm the signing it on you and really I'm this signing it on myself yes yes yes before you charge a person remember you're judging yourself that's very positively they say in English you point a finger at somebody at that moment you're pointing three fingers at yourself see you see look I'm pointing three fingers at myself and you just as an expression as shelter when you say curses you don't say a shelter shields it and he says this explains a story you have after the story of David and Bathsheba and Tomas Sonos and her Navi came to Dove it on my look and he tells me this whole beautiful story there was this guy who had only a sheep and there was this wealthy man who had a lot a lot of food and this poor man came to the wealthy man he wanted a meal so the wealthy man stole the sheep from the poor man to give it to the poor man that stole the sheep to give it to his guests in other words even though he had so many sheep and this guy only had one sheep he stole it for him and he slaughtered it so he's asked of it what's the verdict for this guy this guy's a lowlife he should be killed so no sir no no he says after her is you're that man there was a man earlier hit II had nothing he just had one woman but Sheva you're the king you have everything and you take you take his wife so mm a look says two words hot I see lusha I said so the trailers why did he have to make this whole just tell him look what you did she says because nobody could judge you you have to judge yourself so he told of it I might look a different story mm ella said what the law says and then he says ah what's the this is what the Maxima be the name of the motion under what's gonna could of this then it could though of this also brings out the kayak of a Jew that nobody alternately can tell you where to go not the guy made not again I'm not even best intial of my cuz I also the reminder shale oil doesn't tell you where to go you're the only one who decides where you go so when the camera says here embezzle some Islanders muscle then Ellen can keep the best and so Martha's afraid it's not only collectively in Claudia so it's also individually Basden shall Milan never goes into a DIN to tell it in on anybody unless you were already McAllister fighters you have to decide you were ready and if in the positive you am accomplished the fighters then the whole thing is different something a motivated tangy that we learnt another Bryce can quickly is Cyril who Emily Eloise Shaw I see that it's a time of din for the Jewish people Lomas oil I mean I am I'm with lemon mich but lilica Yaakov her cholesterol this for the Jew which pathology Jakob is for everybody else so trashy shocked I dismiss Casa might literate hi Kim what's the problem the problem it actually has there one second Rosh Hashanah is already destroy destroy dishes because witnesses saw the moons of Santa Casa remember witnesses came to best and they say we saw the moon last night the twenty ninth twenty nine at night we saw the moon so best that makes 32 Reuters so it's not reddish miss Casa bus it says little hike people who are further to going shaft was Lebanon might of the iris libname is in the morning for those on the West at night for those in the East Leticia katana he saw most listed Usha so generally speaking it's Paquette's are for at least many many people it's not a time when you'll be able to have the vision of the moon like other times of the month they'll only be a few hours during the day that you will be able to see it and it depends in the West in the West you won't see it in the morning and in the east you won't see it in the evening suck the right LM can keep suicide is very common in cover you soulless high-calorie dish you hate mich but luck of this vertical it has to start with high cholesterol and then the reminder shel olam could say miss Potomac a occur without the Jews he came to the mission how do you know that it's also for non-jews cuz it says mich but lil aquella Sunday but I survived m'kay Mohammed lemma that Hercules Shaw if everybody's being judged so just say everybody's being judged why do you single out the Jewish people mallamma cheese Sean there's nothing that Allah did because the Jewish people are judged first you mean versus mean I mean white changes there Webster y-yeah code of that something yeah covers connected I hit well amateur you so much nothing the libel of did could get up listen I'm gonna miss the melon fat sibour if you have a king and an entire community and they're being judged melon is must hit Allah did so you first judge the King Shan Emma Phillips lie my mother when he built the base on Victor's she says last ice mish but I've died whom ish but a my very own behind me lastest mich but of the first as mich but I've died which is his servants why Muhammad only calls out day and then as mr. Tommy is so in other words the prominent one the King goes goes first my timer what's the reason he buddy same lover as IRL amount maker Malcolm right it's not there a parrot or a fairy mean it's not the death of the world it's not respectful that the king should stand outside in other words that he should just wait outside so therefore you do the King first it's have the covered of the mela the by same another reason is Mohammed the late push her own off before the King gets very upset once he starts charging everybody else and he can get very upset so then you don't want the King Chanel's going to judgment so therefore the King goes into judgment first Akashi malice with sip work chakras vertical Donaldson melon is Nutella Mizpah tava - lima caramel a comes first the late push her in a peaceful avoidance simple because of the sins of the symbols so therefore you have the king being judged first and that's why the din of the people proceeds the dinner of the other omus because of both reasons first of all it's neither a hairy sedation weight and number two there should not be high enough once we see what is going on in the world at large by many of the nation's many of the nations of the world yes you say McCready have to be impartial must cut enough you get upset so you change the dim what did you ask about smun just first - not first muscle it's a mus - quickly stole the order no puzzling so the order I don't think anymore no no no they started system based on a mr. smart we explained in the post the melis missus ciller from swimmin mullet sober mela according to this you can explain just like a mountain somebody goes first since call you sober name a la campagne no no the shivers shivers it just brings up inside the shivers of the mela the photo so therefore calculational okay something a motivator I thought the Tishrei is Rosh Hashanah with smitten it's also a Shoshanna was smitten for Schmidt Oh what does it mean for Schmidt that when you say the seventh year is Schmidt what's the seventh seventh year begins as a petition from the mana Manawa how do you talk and know maybe the estimate issue doesn't begin Schmidt how do you know that's the date when you're now lotto anymore work your field you can't plow you can't plant you can't seal your field and cut it over cut it off from everybody else you have to keep it open how do you know this is the time you see if deposit says in passions by heart bhishan now javis Shabbos Shabbos O'Neill audits the posix says on the seventh year you should have a Shabbos a Boston for the land subtly scissored of a karmic oasis where you shouldn't plant your field you shouldn't prune your vineyard the gum so says Sean Ashley is the gum our Sun our Sun initially here we make Xavier shove it says o Bashan ah she is in this posit it says by tisha also the word chamonix if we haven't purchased a kiev later this is partials behind party later we have maybe she's our son of our doctoral Shama and we established that the hash on over there is talking about what what's the nation's our Sean that's talking about tisha today because tacuba hydrophobic a sodium container so therefore we say just like bodacious Hashanah is when Tishrei so when it says bash on our she is I need to know when in the seventh year when does that seventy I say it's a competition for everything tomorrow one second it's not the only time it says Hashanah and how much polygamy Rosh Hashana manisa the exhibition who love them it says about the month of Anacin it's the first month of the month of the empire's boy so you could say when it says uberchaun re is compared to the hot day Hashanah and sadness and that's Josh means that's the beginning of summer series I am NOT asking about other months why I'm not asking other months cuz you don't find house on there by other months and homeless but you find it by Tishrei and you find it by missin which is very interesting you don't have our son anywhere else you have racists our son in a curve and you have a hot sauna in boy but why choosing Tishri awareness and why discriminating against us and for the Gemara done in Shana Shanee Maharaj him misciagna Shana Mahajan they ain't done in Shana Shana mass inertia measure National Adoption meaning our son about Shawn Ashley's doesn't mention months it just says the seventh year so now I'm looking around the Commission I'm looking for a definition of Shana when is my seventh year so I look I look I could go the co-chair Shana and I can combinations are summer but there's an advantage of Nations Hashanah why because my son man but son Ashley's doesn't mention months so I would rather derive the meaning from the shaman homage that also doesn't mention months just mentions a year made HS our son of an African Sun which is like but shall not release rather than deriving the meaning of the Sharma that doesn't mention months from the saw from the year that is mentioned together with months which is I've heard this as a low temperature most emission will become hot summer so therefore you write the exams Shover is a ghazal shovel that can work from both but I don't know which Xavier shove it to choose so when I have a choice between two so Kim what do I do I will choose the pasta that is more similar if I wouldn't have the pasta combination saamne I would be forced to go the hot sauce on and I don't have a problem with that but when you have two different sources and you could choose one over the other you choose the Xavier shopping that is more similar to the pasta that you want to explain so therefore one have a choice I go to Malaysia Hashanah and therefore has all derived that by Shawn arias means when Tishrei and that's why I mentioned it says bad competition is vicious son delish mitten Rashi says me Nolan sheshna Schmidt include ashes from Rosh Hashanah of course he means rosh hashanah at the patisserie our dushashana for us sir by voi the sack erica how do you know this there's no source for this you just know there's a year and the answer is Xavier Shover from gracious Hashanah what do you say about Schmidt yeah but now I think that's what the Gemara means I think that's part of what the Gemara means tomorrow doesn't only mean a technical thing and here it says command here it doesn't say that our shuttle I think the Gemara also means a thematic until the comparison that here you're talking about the year as a whole year some ash trees or eh it's a sonnet after ishani talking about a whole you're spanning the whole year in one shot relations a sonnet after a sauna or Sun Ashby's and here you're also beginning a year you say additional ahahhaha Shoshana for the GAVI months in other words will but this is the first month of the 12 months of the year well either that's part of it that when you could compare to this rather than this much much a shock because over there you're talking about the first month of the 12 months of the year but you're just dividing the year into 12 units and this is the first unit of the 12 units where ratios are Shannon Shannon is you're not dividing the year in units it's just one one collective year this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they you Shiva net slash donate