Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
foreign
how's it teaching about this
in uh page 28 B
has an interesting teachings by the
sieges of an act of an event that took
place
here in this section is talking about
how all of these different
are sages from yesteryear
would do eulogies for different Torah
Scholars
oh they are themselves would do eulogies
and they spend for different Taurus
Scholars and how they would speak good
words about these people and uh
cry over them
and one time
there was a uh
a certain Taurus scholar
that died
and uh they asked
to do any spread on him
to do a eulogy say eulogy on him who is
this Taurus scholar what was what was it
they don't say his name but what was the
story
this Doris scholar people consider them
be learned
the uh uh he learned the sifra he
learned deceively and he learned to
SEPTA
so this person learned the uh all of the
Torah that in essence the oral Torah
that was written at that time he learned
everything
he learned the burrito the sifa the
sifri he learned everything
and he died
so they asked for one of them to
say uh
and I spit on him
founded by you what do you want me to
say exactly
what do you want me to say
they're looking for him to say something
nice about this
he learned so much Torah
man says
what uh
what exactly do you want me to utilize
eulogize exactly
that he's uh
what what that that he's praiseworthy
all I can see is that
woe to the person meaning this person
that died that he is a basket full of
sacred books
that have been lost
so Rashi says what does it mean whoa
that this person is a basket full of
books that has been lost
that although the scholar possessed a
massive massive amount of information
and so on
he is like a basket holding many books
but unfortunately he did not comprehend
the material since he never acquired the
tools of analysis
by submitting himself to
the tutelage of a Taurus age which in
Hebrew means shimus he never had a Torah
Sage
guide him tell him what does it really
mean he simply relied on himself relied
on his own understanding he studied by
himself
just whatever he understood
he figured if I read the books I have a
brain just like the kakama as a brain
the rabbi is a brain and I have a brain
so I don't need the rabbi I could just
read the books and I'll understand the
same thing like the rabbi does
but don't you know that gemara says
it's better to die than that never read
that part yeah I read it but I figured
that's only for some people
so therefore abnachman says this person
is like a basket full of books where he
read a lot of books he knows a lot of
information but he never really
comprehended what it actually says
because he didn't apply to his life
and therefore he felt the grasp the
reasoning behind the rulings the
reasoning behind Allah and was unable to
deal with difficult and conflicting
information
did not regard him as a Bonafide scholar
rather just somebody that knows a lot of
information
that's it
Google also knows a lot of information
but we don't call Google
thank you
[Music]
let me know what you think and make sure
to share other people need to learn too
