Worker's Mistake - When Is He Responsible? - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

let's say you have AG AI NS kangin Ava some once told it there was no fault of mine and certainly an iron is glamor sucked Isis and iron is gumbo or real lioness and autumn her magic is going to be Potter and Pisces Raya is our case why is pepper cumin she'll kill Koba keenum Potter I are the Malayalam the terrace is a tinnitus and is a spotter wonderful so in other words a reddish I feel like a regular automatic he's part of Linus now the question is I buzz I why when he gets paid is he fires I thought I owned a C's Potter so ty says wait a minute what's the locker of Sheamus suckered that gets paid for his work he's kind of on behave of Aveda I gained a vis a real lioness the terrorist is you're getting paid for something do your job shows up Tyson I'm a bazooka finish the tava woman the paid professional is not any different than a shiny moussaka and a sky even Ava so according to tysonis it seems that a regular worker that doesn't get paid like a regular automatic and the fact that he gets paid is more of a fear of like a sham moussaka so according to this we could pretty safely assume that a worker that gets paid has more responsibility getting paid for something you do have to take responsibility but that's not the end of the story the Ramban and Buffum but see enough paydays takes exception with typhus and he says other Muslim onus is Chi of even on erroneous Gomer and now he has to deal with trace this riot Isis has a bunch of Rises so he deals with MinC um but then he comes to the case of Taba woman Shaquille ko what's the killer getting paid or not so suck the RAM ban that basically when someone does any magic he has to pay so a paid sure if it is no different other Mazda he has to pay why Bettina if it does the three Y Z putter subtitle Shane but woman had time elapsed time assume as ik doctor imbalance is the opposite a paid worker has revenue responsible that girl my magic but if you're not getting paid you're doing him a favor and he allows you to do that favor and he wants you to do in that favor he's not even paying you for it it's like he's saying try your best just like if I tell you pair my jacket and you tear it I'll say pay me other move on no it doesn't make sense you allowed me to write I gave you the animal I might have you paying you for it I'm saying try the best that you can but no responsibility so if you're getting paid that's why you're value so what he's saying is that if you're not getting paid I'm giving you a resource to do your best including if your magic your putter the river which is quoted the to Mookie Betts above a comma Hobbs a lien before the third pair says it like DRAM bond a little less of a finish and he says autumn mood Loyola is on all item except following his gamma not like choices again and then he says how do we explain all man the case of the tether woman to kill Co so listen to his Lawson if he's getting paid about this high if he damaged the animal but when he's not getting paid keeping them is asking the tightest on Isaac love autumn I'm a circle is that automatic you notify Smith Burton as a magic versus you give me an animal you're not paying me for it and what do you expect so therefore if I get paid I have to take responsibility if I'm not getting paid if it's phenom it's like you're telling me try your best it's like an I'm an autumn how magic väri shows so now a voice it comes out in a beautiful thing that really a worker basically is like any other person but a worker that's not getting paid is better off than a regular mazak it's like he's saying try your hardest I just give you an example the young Solomon bava kamma para Testament of Allah he this god the Mishna card helps the emissions in bava kamma tata customer base if I hire work at the knock down a wall and as he's knocking down another wolf falls down so we would see other Muto island but the minister's know his putter why so the way the I'm just lame explains is you hide me to knock down a wall I did that and there was no way I should be able to realize that the other world will come falling it must have been a very weak wall or wasn't built properly whatever it is but you hired me to knock down a wall which I did and there's no share my pot so I did the work that you wanted me to do I can't be responsible so that's the asite generally a worker that I tell them to do a job is shy of outside of my Mazak but if you're not getting paid then it can't be responsibility so now let's go back to our original question how do we look at a worker that's getting paid or not getting paid I think it's mamas beautiful according to tasteless a worker that's getting paid has more responsibility than a regular Mazak he's even cyavana lioness why like a Shamus circle according to the river and the RAM bond a worker is basically also Caillou unless he's not getting paid Benny like a magic purchase so in a certain sense according to three Vonda romvong a worker that's not getting paid is less responsible than a red regular automatic now I hope we should be able to glide through all of that with Silas once we have this simple you say let's begin okay let's say someone asks someone else to share and an owner's Goma happened now I did a little my homework and I spoke to someone who was a big market share in the street tub and he said oh I came to the right time he just visited the Schleck toys so I asked them give me some examples of an iron his gum or of annoyingness forgot his sheath so he says I just was a sloth I sniffing chefs are you first chickens I'll tell you perfect examples the way it is in many slash choices that they have a guy holds the chicken the shyster chef and then he takes it away it happens occasionally that the guy is too quick in taking away the chicken and the sauce it obviously can't the Miller chef thing so the animal is at Rafer so that's the case of an omen table of Shakeel cool I mean Lamesa the chicken is a trayful but that's the case of all Yuna's garma what what should the Shaffer dude the guy pulled it away question in that case is the scheisse tire on the damage because the end of the day this is woman tava she kill coldest treat this possible but what do you say I'll say I don't know the Michigan where it says he if you get spare you how you but let's rethink that let's go back to foolish let's remember Paris to me Spartan what's that laughs ah Sheamus off here that there was damage bonus the puss kinda tired his partner right he's high honkin Ava but Lister Missouri Lee Sian so since were saying that the top is the bottom so since we're saying that Taba woman is like a shameless offer he's not worse than a semi-circle so tacky sky of annoyingness but he's not even on his gamma like to reverse the same thing and now you'll appreciate a few lines of Akash with one of the Machine Man I love Co Feud gimel where he says momma's this question that if there was a real illness or in a silver Ines I'm on a path tray I wish a moussaka I could I kiss a moussaka now until today you wouldn't know what what about taz bass means to say what I mean hey mrs. Potter for carrot by other mood the Euler Ernest disguise and what's the analogy to a Shamus soccer but now it's mostly with us the Tasman is understanding that the old one that's paid like a Shamus outlet ah if you'd like a Shamus saw him he has limitation like a semicircle and if it's an honest girl more kiss Seamus saw here he's going to be Potter on the damages so here you see a beautiful example of what seems to give a Pharisee Gemara table of omen is tired but it's not so clear if there's an eye on his goomar he will in fact be put now I should mention what comes out is that according to the Rambam that he thought that either a that he's high of outs even an annoying his goomar this case would also be annoying his gum a nice guy you now what would the best in do in this very case according to Isis and the revoir he's part of according to round bonny sky so that's a basic cloud that whenever there's a Makai kiss we say the most it could say kimly like the patron and I'm not gonna pay so in this case the shape it has right to say kimly like the tasteless and the revoir and therefore is a mockery of the pain and talk of the marsh the marsh am regarding a similar Shila in Dalit the ultimen cough Zion says in the case where it's a mark like is so the Mazda could say Kim Lee and I'm not paying but I what's beautiful is the this page bits brings a riot is your side from a mission bava kamma tada Testament days where he told them to knock down one wall another wall fell down as well ah you see or in his glamorous part and now you understand where he's coming from this we mentioned earlier that a case where it's annoying this gummer even a page where Scott will be part of ok question a you asked you up let's you have an animal and you ask the chauffeur to do it as a favor he's getting paid nothing Bettina okay but what happened in this case he was a paella he was very negligent and he ruined the animal what's the love ash I said Bettina that was pre share you see all say oh wait a minute we said the Farish that Bettina miss Potter that's not true why is between impart the eyes another magic the terrace is I'm allowing them to do at best of his ability but I never allowed them to be paella so here we see and hurts push it a tava Bettina is taka Pato unless it's annoying is gum unless it's impatient and tacky think about all the safaris I'm Mazda he's a magic British us but there's a limitation and has to be that he's trying so here we see a table of Bettina is high on a pleasure okay consider the next question okay again this is another this is a very good example he's getting paid so we know that Lamesa he's hired let's say he's not getting paid and there was a mild illness well marshal the chicken moved so that might be a mild owners can evade them because he's supposed to hold on to the chicken with enough strength that it can't move I mean that's part of their job no chicken excited to get you shocked and they start moving so I wouldn't say that's KN that's on his gumbo I wouldn't say it's kanga Navis can Aveda it's a mild illness and he's not getting paid is he high of when he when the miser the skater was puzzle so this manage the beauty that was cilia according to taste this why what's the whole field he's like a Shamus sucker right but in this case it would be giant the fire because if he's not an honest he's hired but acquainted every other was showing him I'm saying do the best of your ability unless it subsea the same could be Potter he's trying now I can't say that he could have been more careful but it's not it's not appear this is an honest ok Nevada but it's still annoying this so it comes out in this case that taco like the other restraining that the pastor is because I'm a his magic brushes he would be pata unless it subsea and KN Aveda he was talking with EP Porter listen to the next question but approach with caution because yeah you'll see it's a very simple sack if you have this one point a bookkeeper either did not deposit money in the bank and that caused other checks to bounce or he forgot to pay a or his net but it was too busy he forgot to pay a bill and now he has a penalty to pay the mob us are saying pay and he's saying it's not my fault I'm overworked and underpaid you know they I I'm sorry it's not my fault it was an itís so McCoy um he's a paid professional he's a top of home and tavaa ghoom is loved Africa scheisse it and it's not a known his goomar right they forgot to pay a bill they can't deny his Gummer so he has to pay but there's one fact that this case is different in all the previous cases in this case he was a mazak he didn't kill an animal he didn't knock down a wall and the worst scenario failure to pay a bill or failure to deposit money is a grammar he caused a penalty Oh once you talking about a grammar that he may other masochist Pato I sky Everdeen a Somalian that's when he's a cover of the housing here he's an unsightly case I don't know is not an audience but it's a shy geek and his oh come on in the house like he's even part with initially I am right if you say that that's the wise thing to say but not the right thing to say because a missing one Dakota which is the beauty of the sucio let me ask you a question according to your understanding so why is a Seamus circa ever highest a paianquin Ava Vevey de genève of Aveda Verstegen Ava certainly can Ava is always an Isis or at least a drama what's it what's the case of Ganesha there's someone to sleep at night he said Krishna and his nominee has Megabus by anything else article someone breaks into the dining room and steals the item what did i do I did nothing he's even less than a drama so now the question is why is it Terry Makai of astronomer on genever at it's a drummer if not a reduced Graham I did not think the turret is that's the fear of Seamus offer you hi Yvonne genever sup they're looking for some safe and Hamish persimmon cuff ma'am and the tubas he says there's no tour of gramma by a by a trailer for carrot Mesa ball the other batteries me rush Lila sky outside with my cabinet flaw he says every crew every genever bias i'ma bekasi assign him the averse Nikolas cuz - boho an telegram Obama buffalo hockey high F the finish of a Sheamus - Ava is even though it's a Grammys higher as I stated some safe now let's take this step further since was saying that a worker has the denim of a Sheamus off here he's also kyuf on drama no different than a shame er so therefore it's clear Pasha that a work of that did damage with a drama we decide and the truth is it's very logical I pay a bookkeeper to pay the bills and to balance they know the checkbook it shouldn't bounce and he doesn't do anything he says I'm sorry but I'm only a grandma it's illogical it has to be better work as the dhinam of a Seamus of him and its Caillou and Grandma unless of course it's annoying this gum now this will explain another Locker which is a big cookie we've got mention this a few weeks ago let's say I tell my work go quickly there's a big get rid the big fear they're selling merchandise at very very low cost buy me out inventory for the next year I give money go um that's your own job going by inventory there's a big sale and he goes on vacation and he doesn't buy anything so I'm furious that I've lost my - awesome and he says listen I'm sorry but I'm only a drama he's even less than a gram but this is what we call the we spoke about this for weeks ago mineus rava he prevented me from getting a benefit right he didn't damage my house i I lost an opportunity of profit Newman yes we have after Sparta but Raisa Pelham the Richland Bava metzia defiant gimel and the deceivers and our simin she involved thief cut involve says a work is high if I'm Aeneas rather he has to pay question Manish Diana why is a worker different the terraces must cause its massive me vast the work as vena Mukesh a moussaka 7/7 - grandma no if that's his job I can understand his height even I'm a nice rava now the mice and many argue that he's - Gromit us yet but many as rava is even a step less than a grandma he didn't cause any damage he caused you to lose a potential profit nominee as rabbit is lower less than grandma okay so the mellitus is a muck Lakers and of course the ball a bus cannot be McRaven because many players come argue on the receivers but the Havanna that a work has more responsibilities than a regular person he's - grandma and light zombies five how many as forever this would explain another big hug you maybe we'll do it a different time but in the same game or in bava kamma saga testament base it's the same shock on earth and she involved this goddess eve of let's say i want to know if a ship is certain their real estate property so i pay a consultant to look into it and he says buy it it's a great deal grab it and so lots of have avoided it was a terrible deal I lost a big amount of money so now I go to my say you have to pay me you damage me you told me to buy an item that's worth about nothing he says wait a minute that's worse than my grandma he is only a grandma but this is the famous sugar of a merit dinner LaShawn phanie where I pay a consultant tell me should I buy this coin is it an antique is it worth a lot because we have look this is Mama's room at SIA Griffith and ends up being a forgery ends up being a counterfeit so the Gemara and the chef Canora says if he gets paid he has to pay you for the loss what did he do wrong he's only a grandma the terrace is he gets paid for that job he has to come through so we see a pile is - grandma like zombies five ammonia so ever and I and me dinner Gomorrah and stuff on earth and all the gray is hide you gave me bad advice i-it's only a grandma but if you get paid you have to do your job question someone gave in a wedding gown or a shirt to the cleaners and very responsible and a very air Locker cleaners but l'm isis think I damaged along the way he doesn't know how it happened but these things happen so the customer says are the mood the item you have to pay but the storekeeper says listen I tried as hard as I could this is an earnest Gummer who has right of way that's not Michelle was sucio we saw the Taj which says that even ishani moussaka that gets paid is pot annoying his gamma and even though according to their Ambani might be higher but we saw the Martian says in such a case we say you can't be mighty mom and me Suffolk so in that case if of course you both agree that it's annoying is Gummer then the cleaner is not responsible the same applies to a repairman or any workup that did damage if it's an iron is gamma we have this yeast site of the Taj vids then I only dead aesthetic a work is no better than a shiny Mustafa who is a I'm on Geneva but Pato anoints him questions a cook was given a big amount of extensive meat he never did this before but he tried very hard and the miser the meat got burnt now it's larae on a high official a sham it's inedible now he's not a magic but he's a terror human temperament slavka chef it is a paid professional and the flavor this is a bit Pharisee tomorrow not exactly this case the same suger entire Testament base if someone gave a someone that grinds wheat and it gave him week to make pure flour now that no standard procedure you soak the flat the wheat that softens it so then you could take off the bran and you could have pure wheat but this person didn't soak it enough and an ended up being inferior flour so Gomorrah and the circle Gaurav says since he gets paid he's high for the damages then he was not amazing but you didn't do your job and he has to pay so it makes sense that the cook that again if he was not unless it's annoying his Gomer something happened raised the electricity went out and there was no fire but unless it's annoying his of course he would be like a table of woman--she Kilkelly gets paid now baka Shem the Shiba so cams don't Dartmouth I have to cook this sometimes they burn something or because then you know as the Shiva boy says it's always ruined the food is always ruined so then he always desire but it has to be reasonable and a certain understanding as well question a high higher the work of plumber electrician is we're doing work in the house but when he came in he forgot to lock the door and as he's drilling or making noise in the back agon have came in from the from the unlocked door and helped himself and now the vallah bus says you're getting paid you're a topical menu you're getting paid you have to pay me for all the headache so here we come to a simple hillock let's let's slow down III the hired worker I'm responsible for my work I so if I do some damage as I'm doing my work I have to pay my work was not to lock the door now you'll say what it means once you lock the door okay so then you could say III a certain I'd light and lock the door but how do you classify leaving a door unlocked and Agana comes and steals that's a typical case of a gramma a pipe in fact that pirates gathered the famous library is the grandma so now we have to divide the work and the regular responsibilities so talk of the but the worker was was negligent in a certain sense or an artist later I give you a call him but he's not that's not included in his job so we have to look at the lack of locking the door as a regular drama and if we talk about spacious area then he would have to pay budino Shanaya if it wasn't this fault because he found the door locked he just walked in so then no one told the market so it's not his fault then it would not even be a simulation i we heard a similar question where a babysitter was given the Charles to watch you could take the stroll up which she did you took the stroll at her house brought the baby back left the stroller and in the hall downstairs didn't lock the door and someone stole the stroller and the parents are unhappy you left the door unlocked so that case very similar after she completed her job and she brought the baby back so now there's no feel for you of him of a type of woman what is the only obligation I should have locked the door so first of all that's the way I found it I walk in I take the stroller you don't like to do why should I like to do it I mean maybe I should have but I'm not responsible and also since is not part of my job to lock the door it's a regular grammar and a gram of Anna's Aachen is part of it in the other high Medina Sherman and in this case the assumption is it's not a cavern of a Isaac it wouldn't be high if padeen a Somali now if you told her locked the door that's part of his job so then it's the pee in the schmear but typically I she brought it back the way she found it and it would not be a fear okay listen to a story I so listen one of the swarm I should mention that wonderful safe for my Saruman has many human issues he has supposed to be a true story where someone was hired there was a people people had a chest freeze in the basement full of meat they bought it and big volume and they were afraid that it was making noise they called their payment to fix it so he went down to the basement and he fixed it a week later they start smelling something is not kosher what happened was he fixed the fries Ataka but if he didn't put the plug in now you'll ask me how did he know it's fixed if you didn't plug it inside cash of a Mason nikasha Stockman is that's the story to story he didn't plug in the plug and the people are saying you know a lot of meat a lot of this is a few hundred dollars probably into thousands of dollars and he's saying what I did you tell me to plug in the plug I mean you don't have too much say Phil do you plug in the plug but then he said listen I didn't unplugged the plug I came I fixed it freeze that was my job so it's hard to figure out you know if this was a wise decision it probably wasn't but if you go from a hoist to miss but perspective he was not hired to put the plug back he was hired to fix it which he did now if someone pulls out a plug of a freezer so that could be the poison discussed that could be more than grown with that garmi because the hezekiah right away but he didn't pull out the plug he fixed it didn't touch the plug you know be sassy or bigoted see our site so in the worst scenario the plug has nothing to do with his work he wasn't paid to put the plug in so maybe he was you could say he's a grandma he's probably even not even a grandma if you didn't pull out the plug so certainly you can't hold him responsible for that a painter was moving furniture the belt think you do a good job and we get to the back and he broke a leg of the furniture which was a big headache so Kyra this is a new case of a paid professional case of tava Holman and it the assumption was it's not a - Gummer it was like a regular illness but here a vici there's another tough to say that he was not paid to move furniture he was paid to paint if he decides and is all to a better job and moved the furniture so he becomes like a machine on a professional that does something but phenom that the same camara says he's pasta now if when he came to give you an estimate take a look at that the first says what to move that that's actually $50 at least so if he gave you charge for that that's part of his job so then he has to do with carefully and then you have to know if it was an Ernest carve the tree or not but if he did it on his own free will even though he is a PHA the Hohmann but that was not part of his job and it would be part another case I saw in that safe for my saruman beautiful Schuyler because it brings out all the fine points of our Cydia and this is an old-fashioned shilin a Rob was given a box with an s rig to see if it's kosher or not now today they have these forms is not a Schuyler but he had with the pivot the MA with the flax wrapped around the S rig and as he's unraveling someone really did a good job he yanked off the pittin so now the rub is sitting with a clearly Trey apostle arresting and I don't know if he's gonna charge the rubber not maybe to rub on his own star declaring is he hired so first of all this has all of our suger depends how what the story was if robbers not getting paid to check us Reagan say he's the hated papa woman that's that the Phenom say Spartans this an idea let's say he's paid by the key HeLa by their whatever and he has to sit for X amount of hours per day so now he's a table of Oman that's the side so the F we hit Kyra that's totally an hour psyllium if it's a curved lip she or he would be tired thinking a Aveda and if it's a wheel or in his goomar like that man is also five another place to me spot but this safer says a good part and he says he was paid to check Australian that's not his job to open up and unravel the s trick if a person has a sickle you no respect for a Rob we cherish the rubs time is every moment is precious you come to him with the SUV in your hand you don't give it to him here like you open it if he is getting paid he's not getting paid to open the box so that he's doing your job and that's the type of woman should kill called Athena and the rub is not responsible which is a lesson you got to cherish the rubs time and just keep them till to the bare minimum a question which happens sometimes we're a red be a teacher confiscates an item from a student and it got lost or it broke so this is a sort of a sensitive issue because Lamesa the boys are not happy you know they go like one bucket on me and now you see but the rule there is half cabeza Nazca everything is the rabri the miles now the truth is that that could be if that's the protocol of the Shiva that the Rebbe could take away what he wants I saw the Pisgah equation in Geneva I love Italian the Mishnah Lochinvar a spade out that both say taka the deaths that could be the role these Shiva could make a rule that we have to keep discipline in our master clientele so at the mission in the morning and the mark is that press well they'll a no a lifetime a Rebbe that's hitting a Talmud it's a mitzvah hidden and even if you kill them Bishop the Shia gigged is no godless he's doing it British us he doesn't say these words but if he's allowed to kill the Talmud is they're going to take away here's a toy that's the spirit disrupting the class so taking the way away I saw the my station has an issue involvement curse is also marked there that as far as the you know discipline keeping control but if the truth is there's no reason that Arabia should not return it you know how my stomach boy says my Rabbie's a gun if you know that you did the wrong thing well he's right or wrong but you know a boy can't think of every the gana so red we could take it away and but she'd give it back if he lost it so then the hurry has a problem now you you probably could say in our lockup our human should kill Co that's part of his job and he's allowed to take it away but losing it is already KN Nevada and it would be higher and besides it's not good for the two the Talmud that the Rebbe lost it he can't find it why do I have to lose I'd be very careful in such a case it would be a wonderful of Rebbe pays him and tells him I'm not above the Commish but I lost it now if that you know the Rebbe took it away and cousin want to give it back then because it's a bad thing so that of course is a different story but generally the Rebbe could take it away but give it back in a timely manner consider this case a woman was doing his job and but at the end he lost the item for example you come to the cleaners he can't find your shirt they can't find this you can't find a belt so Lamesa here we come to another part of this whole saga and that is the the Mishnah in baba metzia that pay a big bass besides the fact that the omen is getting faith to his job part of the job is to protect the item imagine the cleaner spends four hours cleaning a wedding gown and hangs it up to dry overnight in the street very nice you know but you know it's not gonna be in the morning so part of your job is to protect the item if you have expensive better that you're trying to polish you can't leave it on the count up and go the count then goes somebody's else someone will steal it sews up them the Mishnah and the Maccabean beginning of the tour in the beginning of shin valve close to russian and so does this map that is that the that the the table Holman has also a shine the soccer to protect the item so besides doing repairs you have to make sure that the item does not get stolen or taken now therefore if he's not careful and someone stole the item from the store Avada the woman has to pay there's a big tomb on the PI scheme if the repairman locked his store up with good locks and a gun a broken is he also responsible he's a shameless sucker that's true but once we could say this is more like an earnest Gummer slash list the mozillian case then even a shame I saw his butt but in a typical case he left it in the store and P customs are coming and going and he didn't put it away even during store hours when you really should put it away then the woman is high of I'll sticking a visa boy now if the cleaners lost the shirt so again I'm not a cleaners but it's hard to understand that would be annoying this Gummer if it's an iron is gummy Sparta if it's somewhat of a Kangin Aveda then the cleaners would be responsible I lost belt or loss button all these stories that might be close to an itis if it's annoying as we saw earlier he spots up but in a regular case where it's a oiliness KN Aveda then of course the paid workers have to pay now what's complicated when the cleaner sends out his shirts to some a different company to do it so that's a shame myself it's a muscle to shame the subject so that's a different sugar but basically the worker has that responsibility the item should not get lost I must mention that's the gate to all of us the second year for the Mishnah yes the cleaners or the worker is responsible but once he tells you it's ready there that's where his responsibility ends now this is a crowd maybe a novice the right words people given things to repair or to shirts to the cleaners and they don't pick it up in time and he has to become a storage service the truth is after he tells you that it's ready you have to pick it up there's no longer a Shaima and if he says not responsible fight have left over 30 days so he's not responsible 5 left over 30 days in fact some say could even throw it out these not mcclift to open up a storage you know service for people that don't pick it up so we have to be fair on both sides to make sure that that commerce works last group of questions are called a special situation question explain the Mishnah in buff Mattia that pays my baby speaks about a Szabo now rather Sabol is the Russian the Shahana refuses and our incidence in Simon Shin Dalit Sabah is either a porter a carrier someone that carrying a load so a sample of porter that carrying a load from a Camila Marco him and he trips this girl a fresh area it's an oilless but he's not a kind of posh area but in fact he's not a real - because this girl is sort of in between he really she decided to pay for the broken barrel of wine but dr. Kimura dr. Mishnah he's Pato Jacques de Gomorrah in Murcia the next Amita Peggy mo that this attack Ana's confirming that he has to swear that he wasn't paying any spotter why because if not in the forum avakov is a very much cooler Marco him you're not gonna have anybody that wants to be a Sabol no one's gonna I carry things so really a Sabol that did damage unless it's annoying is Gummer is kyuf but gazelle patted him also Tucanos ha common and this is kept asking us of Americans in Jimin now the chin see if olive and that's how he referred to as a Szabo that he's a carrier he's a porter which really should be shy if he's a type of woman he's getting paid for his job but cuz I'll pass to him now why pump they patted him of all work is so this was the anchor of an achiever paying the gimbal Commission with Kufa in Zion explains that it's a very difficult job and generally porters are Annie I'm interviewing him and it's very common that they drop things and I would add and when they usually drop an expensive item because they carry expensive items and it comes out that he dropped something once a week he doesn't end up making money a whole week because he has to pay from us say the whole week sailor wages to pay for that damage so you can end up having nobody carrying loads so this is the Alaka of a Szabo beginning screening in shock American dollar chintzy Fowler a Szabo is positive on the damages pasta means pasta not just your attacker can overlook it but now the next question will trick you let's say he's a Tamara's only drafted but he says he's a bear Mazel also he got to your house he's holding the blue barrel and then he dropped it so you can I see what's going on is I'm sorry cuz it's so the bottle of buses are soaked under heat okay your putter he goes by the way you didn't pay me for my work they pay you for what for dropping the barrel I got to your house I did my completed my job cuz this sob oh that's not gonna have to pay for the damage could he demand payment suck the smile and see if cotton gimel why not he did his job payin if he dropped it in the beginning he didn't finish the job now the ties of Honor it says this doesn't make sense that's it regret about you getting paid for to break it and then he said if that's the case you're protecting the Sabha more than the customer so the task says you kataka can't pay him make him pay for the item but you're not the paying for his work like the smile you do and I guess their locker would be that the bow the boss whose moocs again his money doesn't have to pay the Sabha because he's the kimly he's the music but your voice it is more to this the department see adapt a game of the same on the graph before the Mishnah tells a story by Rob about Hana that hired workers to carry wine and they will play share yeah not a or in his car of alipio per share so Robert Hana new they're not gonna pay him so quickly so he took their item as a collateral as a Maskin and they went to rob they squealed to Roth I says hey Rob bhajana took our shirt so Rob said what's going on him say so maybe they'll Mazyck just give it back to them don't don't require them to pay surround the Hana says dinner hockey that's the din goes in because the plastic says in mission eight lamonta left but their tie them you have to go the flemish were said in in other words he really was they really were hired to pay and about Rob told them don't require them to pay then they weren't finished they went to Rob's listen we're very poor we have nothing to eat the subway to make money today so Ralph says pay them their wages deenal Haq easiest in the second half of the plastic variks a deacon smart so this is an incredible the for the mistress again that if the work was pasea the Sabha was pasea not only you can't require them to pay but you have to pay the wages this is not quoted in Sahara but the Torah in the beginning of da the Qin quotes this as does the Ravan in hill Keshava see if your tests and there are control can end up simon cowell the gym this is a double finish this is a sample which we know already is a Mishnah but there's a seer and he asked not only can't require him to pay he has to pay the wages why this is the aside that this is our tire of this limit then this is yatras but the finish of all hinduism is the kid to Sahara which is kreisel spicy food iris and cooked pay hey see pay talking about he'll face workers nothing to Sabo through their obligations for the worker to the boss and vice-versa and he says a worker that did work and he ruined their a fillable shia even though he's have to pay this amidst for the flemish usar then on the ballot bias to overlook it and be Michael him and if the work is an ani pay the worker for the work so we see a double kiddush after a double kiddush because because the Gemara is speaking about the saab all that the damage okay I can understand derive the pizza is extending that to a regular worker any worker that don't charge him if he broke it and if he's a Nani payin again that's our let me show then that's the office of the Commissioner now this again is only the kid sir the harvest yaar and the children cooks a mock test seems to say the same thing but basically we see a person has to live with the ostrich is not just you know then then then is usually win-win-win but you have to think about Jana so there's a certain element that we have to always consider now I have to be very clear a sample that did damage that's halakhah kind of scum no one could argue a regular working at the damage there's a list let me said then to overlook his damage now of course if the worker is has money and bow the boss doesn't accept only films you said then so then it's maybe if I care it in that case you could charge the worker but basically a person has to approach with caution when you're dealing with the the same kind of a Latoya what's Kenai dimension talking a lot about responsibility that the dibala boss and the work of the Rambam the end of alphas Spheeris says of a work ask to work Mama's give it all he's got and then he says the same fry of lava Hawkeye fight choy Yaakov at Sadiq alma give a whole ecology of our appeals division and the FA was cab engine oil um Hazare with the great star of having his be benched the family I remember of pounds of heroin says if there are mom calls me active italic now Jakob sisal was it's out that I got me wrong where do we find around Memphis of course some of the target you know we know the photography place but Yaakov exotic so vice to rice the random is teaching us that shoot kiss is defined by a person that's an earlier work up that's a true Sadiq Jakob Assad that because he was an elder her worker and I would air this interesting but Morris speaking about the Orca tsadikim Tichenor what does that mean a Google shell again they said you know fast thinkin HT goofin it's an elder who and L look a person in inflation misfit so therefore besides the aware of the apples to look at the Astra's a move that was moving and did damage as he was moving the items so a mover is a high example of estaba so basically he's protected by a Tucanos Cohanim now if he's a Chia I should mention app shear is not including the kana Sahab that might be love some sugar then but up a regular worker Sabo that's was not push air through his pasta al static honest Hakam now the poisk and Heinicke poisk a mad if he advertises we fully insured and we're responsible services say accepting responsibility that overrides the tour of Tsavo and then it would have to pay a cleaning lady broken item can you Mariah but to pay or a waiter that drop the tray of dishes and a broke so this look like is a new example of tava woman Shaquille ko he's a paid work but Raisa Felder a shortcut early in Shilla man I love Steve Zaillian he says that that taco a waiter or Bashar says that broke should have to pay but the mini ball about them you saw him is that we don't charge them for broken items the Travis your and Simon Cooper also says this evidently we're treating a cleaning woman like a Sabol again the same smart that poor this very little wages so basically we could say that a cleaning lady that the damage or a way to the damage there's an unspoken rule death is Potter now Lamesa a doctor that did damage and sometimes it could be major damage it is a lot of cost medical costs so that's a real type of woman and understandably he's not a poor Sabo is getting a lot of money he survives should have to pay for all the damages but here we have it a Septon bava kamma parrot s a lock agimo that says there's a rightful woman she refurbishes Bearsden Bezeq putter a beret seaman I really like if he did more than he's mostly tired now here we see cross the board a doctor the damage is Patna from all the damages it's not clear why but intercept and getting gimble you exact gimel you'd gimel and say Malacca and Ayers may tikkun olam sup the Taj bits inhale the gimbals sim and pay BAE's really a doctor I did damage to hide even on a Zygon he's a type of human but then he said no one will be a doctor they're gonna be sued and since Nick nurse just arrived for the route place we need doctors there's a special exemption for doctor the damage and this is kept askin and your addition I'm involved see if I'll live i ii arctic and the taste after speaks about birth shows Basden and today best doesn't give us just to be a doctor sucked aerosol can on your idea Steve based on the sheep shaving lady and Alan cooking an olive that today is no longer its best in that pathogen it is a licensed doctor so basically a doctor the damage would be Potter now today but the age of suing and so that if that's the understand and he doesn't mind so you have to you know ESCA Shila but basically a doctor the damage it would be put we had a child of a doctor wrote out to someone a expensive prescription and Burkes um he didn't take it but it would have done great damage and it was the wrong prescription he wanted to return it because that's not to take it and they don't take back you know prescriptions he wants to hire back to the pay so that's a good Tyner because that's not very few mention is it this is a regular case of a mazik he maybe buy some I didn't need ah you'll say the doctors only a grandma but this is like a paid consultant this like you're married you know joking you told me to buy it I was my ta choice I'll pick up Allah custom Ethne and tackle doctor would have to pay interesting question don't quote me on this one but a wife that cleaning the dishes and broke a dish or two she has to pay now tell him this is a not realistic but in opinion in the times that people lived a pig strict dry al-raqqa it's the bow abbas his his his item and she broke it and she's getting paid free room and board Futaba home in Shikoku but the interesting is the rambha Menaka see she's paragraph I love her love the test quoting a you shall being serviced has valid they're really the issue should pay but I'll solemn bias with that things go because it's not going to be a you know a good show and by city has to pay she won't do it he's afraid to do it to the Rambam based on xiaomi says the fee of his outs the Flores I'll show them bias now Lamesa we should be a firm side in and pay hard for the work that she did broke like like we saw Flicka Mario a little more I know I care you know cherish them more and more but what's really I feel most agree - deriving on this Rambam says why - Jim that's not why she's part up she's particles of sh'mey raba by them she saw her lover Kolchak she's working for him she's part outs that so all their training wonder what's driver talking about weird schmear coming to the picture Sokka Lucia she's a wife and a husband so I saw a half a dozen good early acronym if I'm ashamed my mom dolls the first but all your item cannot say this his sight and plus it's musty with us in this case this is mamas like our original tava Holman we said that if he's doing it and he's not getting paid it's like a magic brushes so the post-game are saying in this case she's doing it and in that relationship so was i saying do the best you can and if tacky it is damage that's done shiitake be Potter so they're using that to compare to the case of the Phenom that Lamia she's put at the end of the day the mohabbat and heaven ESDA pay you science as an issue that broke Alamos pot now the grocery delivery service is not simple people get very upset they call the store they're all outraged the truth is it neither for itself but I'm gonna tell you it's not so partial that the storekeeper is responsible the picture the following scenario a you pay extra for delivery and the store doesn't deliver they hire a delivery service so what do you want from me to stalk you but go to delivery service what did I do so in that case it's pasta that the storekeeper that responsible he was a shot when he took your five dollars and he paid delivery service to deliver it got even must have added more to that but Titus fault he didn't do it in the best scenario with custom as a painter is when the storekeeper sent his own delivery person but even and there you have to add another Canadian that Lamai so technically even though he paid cash for delivery he's not yet kind of the goods because kesef is not kind of a metal tolling so technically it belongs to the still belongs to the scorekeeper then he could say you broke your own item so the Meister this is all non Ageha the storekeepers are very accommodating they will refund the broken item but in a case where they hired a different delivery service it's not the responsibility of the storekeeper if he pays good that you can't really demand in that case we had a Schuyler with one the bottom the Shiva went to the Nate blood and they did something you made a terrible mistake and grouted linnaeus trials they took care of it because - design they paid all the necessary medical bills but that's probably not included in riflemen Chyzyk this they private them whatever organization but it's hard to believe that's the rifleman sure his ik but this would be a situation where they took care of it last but not least I want to tell you the sale that happened to the Shiva this was in camp this is bum maybe 17 years old one black hat is the air conditioner from the house and it was not working so he asked his friend also all of seventeen who knows a little more than he does to fix it and he fixed it glad he knew his stuff but he didn't know is when you put the case back on to the air conditioner frame under on the actual unit so there's a bunch of holes I can't explain it but there bunch of holes now he drilled through one hole when she went right into the freon and broke the item so if it was never broken tilma now was broken now I did some you know I did my homework it's very misleading there's a bunch of holes and only one he's supposed to screw in now why they make it that way no one knows a good electrician knows only the middle hole but he did the first toe you know ravine alum it's either the first home and he broke it on the spot so the higher this is what we mentioned in the beginning if he's Bettina he's fired right and Rashi says why'd you do it but no no no Bettina missed highest and Aisha's why are you doing it to show you the Phenom of a head yet I'm sorry we had yet patina ahead yet Bettina Messiah that Camaro says but it didn't make sense to me so that's it that they make sense to me because the crane said the case of the gemara is talking about you go over to someone can you share Andy this is his he's a wannabe sure but not more but this is his debut if he does they'll say I shafted of a magatsum and he tries and here's nobody's doing and he kills the animal so if you didn't know that he's a amateur he should have told you he said listen I'll try but I can't take responsibility so that case it subsea meat side the amateur but in this case that you know that he knows a drop more new book which is still nothing so it's a sum of a kill it's a magic brochure see tackle be partner I couldn't talk to you [Music] Sammy get your attire like your biggest akela of Smith's for today sheer this business leather like to have the grapes will sponsor you cool they're gonna retire seven one eight eight five one eight six five one Smithville's sage a see competitive as determine a few minutes but I'm going to catch their mother gotta throw blows a kiss Susur laughs ego here I'm Terry mr. Sandow model enough officer months is the angled side of the enemy [Music] we fixed [Music] yeah [Music] try not to make any mistakes a buttress missile said to seek your mom they share about working mistakes let's review today's session first of all automatic general clouds other Muto island by an oilless Gummer ties their amber knows his height even on that we saw the reverse as only on a regular - his - Ronnie's government Isis if hold on his gum a spotter and any time a person's an automatic but I mean is Gummer he can't you can't beam high of the magic to pay because he could say Kim Lee but generally other mood Island by a moderate onus all agree he's have to pay the sugi of today was looking at a worker that was paid and did damage as he's working again there was no wasn't amazed it there wasn't here it was sort of an honest choice we got ejected and it became trade so that's the sugar do we look at a paid worker as more of a fear because he's getting paid or less of a failure because he's it's understood that things go wrong and it came out the way be understood was that Lamesa a worker has more responsibilities the fact he's getting paid he's more responsible if he's not getting paid then it's just the opposite the fact that he's doing you a favor it's like he telling him do at the best of your ability it's like a magic Bruce just a nice pot now a pie sure you all agree is valiant work even if he's a woman and he's getting Bettina butter players how you lead the geese anoint his goomar that got paid and the damage is potter because he could take Emily like the schita the Oilers Gomer spot to even buy a paid worker that was the typhus and as far as he's not worse than a sham Basava that putter on a joint is Gomer a bookkeeper that didn't either deposit enough money and checks bounced or he didn't pay those on time and there was a penalty even though in theory it's a grandma but then again shameless suckers hi Bo salon grammar and a paid work as the ax lockers of a famous soccer there are those that hold many a work is kind of a mini as not all agree and my sir you can't be my money of the worker but the aside is a work as more responsibilities when he gets paid a paid consultant gave bad advice you can behind the pay me accorded in even though it's a grandma but that's part of his payment to give good advice a cleaners ruined an item you have to determine if it's an illness gum or a closer eye he's got me who dupatta if it's an illness that car of lafiel I could get like a vada then it would be fired a cook burnt the food if it was a known as gummies pata if it was a matter of - he would be fried but that's not done and it shouldn't be done to make I ever cooked I tried hard he left the door unlocked and as he's working and an oven came in that's not part of his job that's a regular grammar he's even part the medina shamaya because there was no Kevon Allah has ik a babysitter it was returned the stroller to the house and it was stolen she did her job and there's no fee of as far as the stolen stroll up their payment that didn't that fix the freezer but didn't plug it in it came out that he would be pasta because that's a a case of a grandma he was not paid to do the the work also it's not even a grandma probably because he didn't take out the plug but basically he would not be value for that I painted that on his own moved furniture to be able to do a better job and it broke it would so that part of moving is not part of his job and he's pasta on the damaged furniture unless he was paid specifically for the furniture a rug that ruined the Essig as he was unwrapping the pizza piston would be pasta that's not his job that's like an omen table of shaquille coal patina a Rebbe confiscates an item is okay he should give it back if it was damaged but the oiliness of course he's potter but my suburb you should make sure the children don't think the rubbish Khalil is the Ghana for a mazak a worker has a you've a schmira he has to watch the item if he didn't he left it out by day when people are coming and going and it was stolen about this guy if if there was a break-in at night to a secured store that had good alarms and etc then it's an eye on his gum and his pata if you lost an item it was real owners he lost a shirt he's Potter but generally if there's some type of Carville up Seija that he would be five on the lost item once the cleaners or any work that finishes his job the owner must pick it up he's not going to keep it indefinitely he could say if you don't come a 30 days it's Africa and he could discard it there is a specific tour of a Sabol I paid carrier paid Porter or a move up and even if he did damage that it should be five we part to him because of a Tucanos Cazale the there is an onion to pay him that's according to the smize you should get paid for his work the TAS holds your putter from the payment and were able Abbas has the option not paying because he is the most sick the kids are took on the PI scheme say even more so based on a Gomorrah even if he was magic but SIA the Salvos Mazda clip SIA if the fan emissions then to pay em and not charge them for the damage that's awesome so then it's not at the guns come that's a blemish you said in the kitchen chef Aleric extends this tremendous level mr. dim to any work at at the damage so certainly it's something to think about before a ball the boss is my high every worker to pay for a damage think about the hue of em and think about them shows that then and the BA or Casa dictum is worth a few dollars a worker has a few of them to be a colleague Yaakov italic as we said and should work because I a work a move of that did damage and he's insured or guarantees his work has to pay off to guarantee a mushara says away to the damage we overlook minor damage unless of course he's a bishop amaz amazed it but generally a massage I'm sorry should be exempt from any damages a doctor unlike a is not a Savile in that respect he gets paid nicely but there's a special pet or if he's license that he shouldn't be responsible for his damages a wife that damaged things at home is pata a donation some of the native blood and there was damage than my so they did take the responsibility a delivery they're broke at times the Paula bus is not trying to pay but he's nice enough so accept it as that and a volunteer that did damage who does not not an omen he's a hedge it and it doesn't get paid if you know he's a volunteer and just know it is too much more than you do you can't be required to pay because that's all - Kenny did the job and you can't be recurrent be required to pay [Music]