Yevamos Daf 17 by Sruly Bornstein

today's staff is yuval mustafi zayan and we are four lines from the bottom of the test base today's that's being learned is this refurbished miriam leia moisha abba ben devorah the primary topic of which was the halacha and soras that follow me stating that the last several dolphin were a little bit of a digression i wish to mention that whether in fact that soras between beijing and brazil it was base hillo that was ironically machmer and held that at sahara whereas bayshama were materian they were martyred saurus and from there the mishnah and the ensuing several african-american they grasped a little bit to talk about this and then from there additional mahleikasen between bisham and bissell either way tomorrow yesterday staff mentioned that does said that he had a messiah he sat on this mortar the amma he said three things also like this even though they had regular kitchens here to stroll during bayes resort but in this manner by his shami not so much there were no laws of svice that were no egypt stating that chumasumaisu's were naying so that the people living there gave my surrounding even during the shemitah and finally um there seemed to have been some debate amongst whether the people living in kaiduan and tarmudem who clearly didn't behave like jews were they in fact non-jews or maybe they were jews that were born to a parent that wasn't jewish which would have a hummer then in terms of them ever becoming full-fledged hidden because although a non-jew could be magaya and through garris he can become a yid but in israel manza has no takana he has no way of being able to enter the fall regardless these were the three things that rabbis have been working to say as an assailant in the name of he even knew where he was sitting when he said these so the peric is going to end on a little bit of a digression discussing the third of the three things there are places and that is this concept of um so we're going to discuss paramount again in different places where there was some debate amongst the whether the people living there were non-jews which would have been a good thing from the standpoint if they ever wanted to convert and be able to marry together with the israel chair that's something they would have been able to do or were they israel women as a result sue him and as a result have no takano if they ever wanted to properly intermarry together with the doctor the first gemara is rather fascinating from a historical perspective because a non-jew does not have the ability to get married could ask much of the israel so if an andrew goes over to a jewish woman and gives her a ring says israel stating that ravi said i heard from my labrador he set because we're concerned that maybe this non-jew is not really a nonchalant maybe he's a descendant of that so what's the rest of the story in the time of the first faisal nikitas the mauthus of clay strong had been divided into two groups there was the mauthus of the asera and then there was the mouthless of the other two shvatim namely shayta yehudah and shaytamin the two shattered lived in the southern part of eretz israel what was known as judea and the other tench father lived in the northern part of eritrea which was often referred to as the galil the division happened after the period of malach he became the mouth of the southern part of heritage he became the male from the northern part of heritage all but it would remain this way where there would be two kings that were operating and functioning simultaneously inherits israel yet yehuda they were in chairs in the southern part of israel these were descendants of descendants of david and then you had what was known as the malchi israel they were the northern part of eretz israel regardless at some point the king of ashur came and he punished the yidan that were living in the northern part of israel he took them into gallus now he didn't take all of that but he took the overwhelming majority of them where he took them into galas we don't know and interestingly today's staff is going to provide a clue but before that review who descended in the neighborhood have asked that they're ever tainted that if a guy would be makadashi you can't know for sure that he's a non-jew and you have to be concerned that maybe he's a yid and even though there's nothing about him that resembles but maybe he's from that and if he's from and if he's a yid you have to be highest for the condition this woman might be a nation's fish and as a result she cannot get married to a jewish man unless she receives a get from this person again because of the concern that maybe the makadesh although to us he appears like a non-jew is from that serious ashford it's a faith to give him an obvious question let's assume that a percentage of them are that assimilated but the overwhelming majority of course are not descendants of the jews that lived in eretz israel in the northern part of israel at the time that these assassins were taken with the girls it's afraid to get married for the condition why don't you say right it's a software you don't know anytime there's a suffix took place in a place where we know for sure that seriously were taken into goals so if you're in a place where you know for sure that seriously was there in fact a place where they were taken into dallas and do we know where that place is mars says yes the posix says this is a passing in base so the king is something that fascinated the imagination of people for uh thousands of years this gemara clearly provides a clue there's hazards in different places that talk about a river known as the sampati and the ghazal say that were taken to the other side of the samba and this the problem with being on the wrong side of this is that it's impossible to cross because there's rocks and things that emerge from the river which doesn't allow anyone to be able to come across there is however one day a year the measure says that the nars unrest and that's on shabbos but the problem is and because they keep shabbos they run into issues and like this they're not able to ever leave but regardless they're not somebody and that's something we're all familiar with this is a gemara right here where the gemara at least names different places into these places but at the same time we have to appreciate that if we would ever find that they would be treated as being possible and the reason is because you have to assume they didn't keep the halachus and if they didn't keep their walkers they may have married kavi krishnas had children from khabi crisis and if they did that the children are going to be manzarin so at the end of the day that even if you know the places where that series and shot them are it's actually going to be more complicated for them to come and uh now become part of kalya's role because a non-jew at the very least can be magaya but the problem is being that there's a concern now that they're from so any place with assailants as well to win the ghosts you can't even be macabre because there's a khashoggi that they're not going they're actually then the problem is they might be israel it's a shash but the bottom line is don't think that we assume that they're sharing we're assuming that they're possibly persuaded and as a result you wouldn't be able to recapitulate it so when this was said that i understand why you would assume that these people that were living in the city with assassination were taken into dollars would be considered jews what was this gosh what do you mean if you know that that is a shock to 100 so you just track the lineage there's a good chance that someone there's gonna be a yet so he said like this if a jewish mother has a child from a non-jewish father the child is considered but at the same time if a non-jewish mother has a child from a jewish father the child is going to be a non-jew so what was this casual so schmooze kasha was it's even hard to explain the question because it's so obvious what the mother's response is going to be but it's casual so what are you telling me that you know where that science is one of the goals and because you know what that service is fought to run into dollars see telling me now all of a sudden you have to be highest then maybe this year then why are you being if the mothers are not jewish they're not jewish after the immoral that's true if the mothers are not jewish they're not jewish or the icon noise what about if the mothers were jewish right that sarah such fought them dead boys and girls so the boys if they would marry non-jewish women in the kaname the children would not be jewish but the girls if they would marry even non-jewish boys then they would be jewish and certainly if the girls would marry jewish boys then certainly the kids would be jewish so how could we just deflect this whole rivassi by saying the kids are not jewish why because the mother's not a jew but what if the mother is a jew you have all the the jewish girls from the sarasota their children would be here in fact what venus said in case we needed them that if someone has an ankle through a non-jew but it's through his daughter meeting the mother the child is a is a jew it's just that the father is an idiot allah has carbon because consider the jewish so what means is what you want to know which movement is that we have a messiah were taken into dollars all the women suddenly were not able to have children anymore and because they weren't able to have children anymore so it's for that reason so if there's descendants from that it's going to be from the men it's not going to be from the women if it's from the men and the women can't have children obviously it's going to be from non-jewish women so not jewish women the children anyway it's not going to be jewish so this whole shash that maybe it's from that i felt them snatch moves not a real child some said that could be the god kamehameha you have to worry about why because they would turn into nashes the bottom line is it seems how we would treat that this is a fascinating topic why because taramud was a place where there were moms there and because they were mama that were living there they caused problems so the fact that they were monsanto they caused an issue so says the gemara that the day that talmud is going to be destroyed is going to be a about a faith in him if tamworth was destroyed what do you mean today it's going to be destroyed it was destroyed there was a city paramount and there was a city thomas was this humbled was destroyed time it wasn't destroyed and that's what tamira meant they said oh the day were the same city so what does that mean why is it why is it what they would do is they would double up he said if one side would have been destroyed they would have settled on the other side they caught me he saw this in the heights and at the other side the city would have been destroyed that would have settled so the kitten there was one city part of the city was called paranoid the other part of the city was called tamwood part of that city had been destroyed but part of it was not destroyed and when let's say the northern part of the city was destroyed said they settled in the south when the eastern part was destroyed they settled in the way in the west but the end of the day all these hebrew from commonwealth still lived there so the robot was saying that the day that it's finally going to be destroyed it's going to be a metabolic we're going to make a yanthis the reason we're making antibiotics says wow you're such a london you're so gavalbig and you could have been so much bigger you laughed at her panyamas sadly regretfully you come from uh and as a result you never reach your potential but what agave you would have been but not for the fact that you came from our opinion so what was wrong with our ponyo so the people of our panhandle she says it was questionable so he told them enough for the fact he came from our pregnant it would have been mercy when he heard that he was very embarrassed on my way so he told him tell me you know when you pay taxes so to what locale do you pay taxes right who do you pay your state income tax though right you pay to this day pay for this meaning you're resident of the city that you pay taxes though so if you pay taxes to pumahara you don't pay taxes to arbania so then we're going to make you part of the harass he says you're good you can become a goverable you don't have to worry about the fact that you come from a stock where people have lousy because because this was a city this was a statue that uldupsulum used to go to so if someone was a monster someone had questionable useless she was a man's arrest right that's where they all used to go all the pursue them used to there's over there in our panhandle and it like it actually got its name that any person that didn't know what he was from that he was from that he was a person didn't know his ears he had no idea that's where he ended up arbanya was a place where they had the schwa that harpany is deeper than sha'an so what's the oil shall it was one of the names of gehenna so how's the possibility is worse than gehenna so rashi says the evil we are the gehenna he says the people in gahannam are going to have takana like the gemara says because someone that is in gehenna at some point will get out of your head and there's someone that's a monster he's less like takanta he has no hope and as a result in a way harpanya being a monster anyways is worse than being in germany they had they were originally a nation they had resettled in albania absolutely the nation the ecorps the primary nation which from the time they had come from of our daf spain did paramount with the absolutely communist they came from these non-jewish slaves of sweden that we saw yesterday what people knew when they say there was apparently some expression that people would use so a cave is a measurement so a large measurement a small measurement meagandev oil enrolled into oil from sure so these were all cities where they were what's the punch line of what of what people used to say they used to say that from gehennem when you roll down when you've traveled south from germany you end up in taiwan and in maeshan and in arbanya why so it's okay actually it's based on what the martial said earlier because as bad as gehenna is but at the same time gehenna me actually left him me mother said darling but someone that said mom's using like that he has no hope and because he has no hope so therefore it's in a way actually worse off and that was this expression that if somebody would roll out go down from gahennen where would he end up he would end up in these cities where there were manzarin and on that note and pacquiao we survived the first period when we gained right there and we're going to go from the first parrot straight into the second pair which is going to return very much to our regular program today's staff from here until the end is going to discuss primarily we're going to start isis by tomorrow's staff we're going to be learning from the most longest shadow in the park the suji of zika moving along as it relates to the ishmaku-sugiyas here in messages so the topic of the first paragraph was really the first line of sacramento and really our mission begins with the question is and then a third brother levy was born so reuven dies asia's ruling fool's leave on the ship now a lady was born now there's suddenly another brother in the picture who's technically a potential young a mitzvah before shimon has an ability to do ibum or to do khalifa lady is born after a lady is born that's a critical piece shin min does just roofing and then shimen died left over two wives he left over asia's ruling that he had been miyabe and he also was married say left over his wife then wasn't the ivan and now these two women fully the baby the first woman that follows the evil malaysia is asian reuben who by the way had fallen to ebon to levy already maybe it was one that was born when asia's ruling was a obama before shimon did ibum plus shimon's wife that had never fallen to leave to even until next what's that lost i know the first wife that's the issue is actually her body that's asia's ruling yeah it's initial measures of everybody she is not going to have any answer she's free to get humanitarian there's no seeker there's no shame here is the album why because she's just actually everybody want me that's neo and the second wife we shouldn't tell us she's the sorrow of the issues actually what would happen if shinman after reuven died instead of doing hebron he would have done mine so what's mine miner is we're the yavon instead of doing beer which is what yibum is he's makanda sure as if she was a regular community so he would give her kasif or star and say how we have that's just so midday right so we know it's nothing we spoke about this in the introduction to the massachusetts a few times since because midday writes it well it has to be however their opponent said that in the event that the oven does nightmare at least on a rabbinical level something should go into effect so what would happen if shiman instead of doing gi boom he did mine her and then shimon dies so two women are fooling the ibum to levy the first woman that's falling to yibum to levy is asia's ruben who's also a stickle cause and let's explain he can't do boom because she's a taurus it's just actually her body why because she's following the evil that's obvious but also the issue is actually heard by obama is falling being that shimon didn't mind her so on some level asia's rumi's also ancient shimon which means there are two women that are falling with yuba now one with the rabona one but they rise so midriff one on she's in h right the one bit that ryzens are regularly obama but on a rabbani level the regularly above is the tsar station's actually by law you can't do evil but at the same time you have to do khalid so why again pash it because the asia's ashley ibam is only following the ebon with the rabona she's not fooling me for midair isa because midday right so shinnon was never miable so now that shimon die really shivan only has one life with their eyes so if the right source only has one right when they rise this white can't be a tsar as anything if there's only one wife she's not a sorrow by definition so for that reason it's impossible for her to be uh sorry and therefore you can't just allow it to be yoitsa she has to have something so what's that allah has no yield because midday and she's a nation she's a tourist asus actually but at the same time either way the mission that just gave us the example of what is which in short is like what's the short version of it when ruving died levy had not been born yet and as a result asia's ruling becomes an issue is actually how you belong and really really if the mission was going to give us the most simple definition of issues actually everybody lonely we were learning this spanish for the first time so somebody would say kate sanders actually everybody loved me that's what you would say roofing was married he had no children he died and then after he died shimla was born you wouldn't even be talking about lady lieutenant was born ordinarily the mitzvah people but over here there was nobody but why because it's just ruins and it's just actually hurt by long so why did the missionary get all fancy why is there moving and shining and lazy and while we're talking about mimer the reason it's possible the reason is because this mission is not just telling us what asia's actually is it's really commenting on the first mission the first mission didn't tell us in a field of snail and that's why the mission is talking about where there's not just ruben and chiming but there's also a lady and then there was in a field of shame that's partial shot on the mission why the mission didn't just give us a very very basic example because the cape side of the mishnah is really referring back to the first mishna and if you're not sure just look at the first rashidi in the parrot now she understood the commission's question was not what's an example of issues actually because if that was the question of the mission the mission would give it a much simpler example it would give it a much more push the case the turret says it's much from the territory it's obvious that the question was what's an example of venetian or you want to know that oh that example involves already in the field of steel if it involves in a field of near we have to welcome radio into the mishnah and that's why the is getting involved in such a case just one other thing that's worth speaking out right now is that the mishnah was very very precise right this islam a good idea this is something that we talked about before or after one of the shoe room and that is when you go through these cases and we're going to start getting into the cases now not stop so when you go through the cases a lot of different nuances ruben aruba of the times every single nuance in the case is badass i mean there's a reason the mission has said it the way it said it every now and again rashi or toysvilus or one of the regina will say that this is africa but really until proven otherwise you assume that all the details and all the problems that were mentioned in the mishnah are mentioned for a reason so for example the mishnah said that the case that is actually one way says that's where there were two brothers one of them died then the third brother was born and then the second brother did evil right so it was reuben and shimon reuben died with no children lady was born athlete was born then chiming wed and did even what would be if it was reuben and shimon reuben died and then levy was born and then simon died and had another wife it sounds like from a mishnah that would not necessarily be the same allah as it is in our mishnah and emma says we know this already from learning the first paragraph it's what the of that case would be and whether or not asia's rouve who was already asian shimon at the time that levy was born would be treated like an asian actually heard by walmart this was very much the topic of the intense rations of the days but the gemmar mentioned that shimon's issues actually hurried by the next mission we're going to learn it's going to be in tomorrow's life but just the dick took that what happened was levy was born before shimon didn't evolve that's why there's no rabbi mentioned in the mishnah in the next mishna the michigan is going to discuss what happens if it didn't happen in that order but shima did even before lady was born and then the kumar is already going to get involved in the sheet of rav shimon in the sugar so the cases there were two brothers one of them died left over no children and then a third brother levy was born then schmidt did hibou shimon died left over no children and left over asia's reuven who had who he had been miyabe and another wife so these two women now fully evil so the mission has said hurry show you know the first wife lady doesn't do even monkey she's they just actually have a lovely she was his ruling and lady wasn't alive at the time that rufin died the shmir the second one he's also not gonna do ibum khalidsan because she's the tsarnaev and that's the case of ish factually everybody want me to practice this but here's the point the rishonna is the issue is the terrorist issues actually said mandatory we're showing the women whoever has the gears so in the midst of the way we have it right now that to be showing this they should start floating apparently there was another girl that was aware of where the mishna refers to the shania as being their slash right who would you think is the resigner that is actually about a long one why because she was asians ruling she was the one that fell a year boom already back in the day now she's falling for the second time this star is falling now for the first time she's she's the richard winnefelo she fell once before and as a result she's considered to be showing up on me she never established the one that says it also makes sense why because my schneer schneil in a sword the reason that she loved by mommy would be considered the schneer is because she's the second one that she married the assumption for a moment is that shimmer was married when he was miyabim isha's ruling so the second woman that he married was the islam and that's why we refer to the murders then he died right that's not a detail that you would think matters either this way or that way so why would you ever refer today as the because you're making an assumption that it's just a frivolous assumption there's no reason to assume it has no impact on the halal so why would you assume that they should actually was descending is that the rationale to refer to that is because she's the schneer venezuelan she's getting married now for the second time so she was the first one before the yearboom they should actually belong she was asia's ruby but she's also getting married now since faith involved in our our case she was married to rouvey then she got married to sherman and now she felt but the point is is that being that she had been married now for a second time so that's why she would be called the schneider either way if you want to refer to them as the resigner makes a lot of sense and if you want to refer to it as actually what is the macaron the torah is actually about llamas they weren't alive together they didn't have because by the time that lady was born right in our mission it's moving and leaving so by the time he was born reuben wasn't alive anymore okay it says what does that mean they have to be me inside because it's going to be the topic of the raid rashi says there has to be two brothers that are right to harsh in each other two brothers that are uh what does that mean as opposed to brothers that are brothers because they share a common mother so if the brothers share a common father then they're going to be considered brothers linden evil but if they only share a common mother they're not going to be and headed to terror tell us that because the torah said which means it means they are from each other and when it comes to dina yerusha paternal relatives are considered relatives of the midterm relatives are not considered relatives so by the fact that it says it means yerusha and this is the macarthur to the most basic and that is when it says what does it mean it means that their brothers but it's it's neither here nor there it's completely irrelevant what matters is whether they're and how do you know that because it says in the torah they were brothers because they shared the same father yakov but it doesn't matter if it's but but to learn the same words the same issue means the same thing but it's not the same word that's not exercise everyone knows that they thought that it says and somewhere else it says and because the words mean the same thing very small they used the darshan xavier from the shopkins so you see kadashi even in the case of this shot why because at the end today the words mean the same thing without i don't mean to say you can't learn exactly ever between the word in the word what i mean meaning if you have a choice i can learn because they're shoved up to here i can learn excited shove it to there so then you're supposed to pick the thing that's more comparable if however there aren't two options there's only one option and that one option is not a perfect hit that doesn't bother me when is it true that you could darshan to shove a coin that's if there's nothing that's more similar about the eco media but if it's something more similar more comparable kadashian as far as exercise it's better to learn it from the thing that's more comparable faith how do you know to learn it from the beneyaka if it's true the banayakov may not but maybe learning from like the passage says that white was referring to he said they weren't brothers so you see that doesn't necessarily mean brothers so maybe there's a mrs uncle so the gemara says ahem is extra all they had to say was is that they have the same father what it wasn't necessary to say that they're brothers you have to have the same father we know they're brothers it's an extra word to teach me exercise teach me in your vlogmas talk to you so in other words we have two drushes really how we know that when it says in the turkey ish means it doesn't mean the first joshua that we had was it from the word this is a massive shot each shot sounds like it has merit on its own but the gamora says that really the fear ms it's the two shot them complement each other and really we need both shotguns each shat in and of itself is imperfect but once you have the tube shot them together then it's gevalting then it's in the car explains we need athlete which was robbers which was russian already it was a funny word that lord used light said we're not brothers we're rayan we're friends with but we're not brothers the word action doesn't seem like it's the right word something you know why you probably said the word probably such a muslim is that it looks like that just like the word by the banane activist actually maybe to teach me maybe the word by white is also that's what we have the word we're talking about brothers and heads brothers that have the same father and the same mother right that's maybe what you would think yeah therefore the torah also had to say ahem the shabbat by find that even the torah was played so where do you see that so rashford says it's based on the gemara that we're going to learn in a few days where the gemara says that when the of them used to be miyabe the asias hanes used to irish and everything so urushi is an important part it's an integral component of the laws of evil doesn't care about maternal all he cares about is minneapolis so why would you ever have a habit of that you have to be afraid right you think it's the biggest in the world the commissioner because it's this same positive these same words are also the car to the fact that when we talk about brothers and bombs what we mean is as opposed to and it doesn't even matter if they're not achieving um from the binet so just a little bit of raid as it relates to the gemara that we just learned and really to you know some of the gemara's that we learned a little bit recently and this is some classic raid some not such famous raid aimbase magnus for like but again just you say this in terms of learning your vulneras abyssal abyssal vimelantis and in the coastline based on madrid and that is the in the fourth paragraph is he brings that many of the goymen said the goydum said that what happens if you have two brothers one of them dies he leaves over no children however the brother that died was a mummer so for example he was a mushumit he left the industrial way completely maybe converted out of being a yid maybe he's preferred not to be treated like a yid if he would die and leave over no children to go in as quoted by the marduk i said the brother that's alive shimon would not have a mitzvah to do him the same would be true in the event that ruvain was an eat and he died left over no children but he left over ivanka reuben has a brother but his brother is a mushroomid he's a mummer say the guy that his woman would not fully evil what does that mean she doesn't need khalifa if she wants to get married there's no way in the turf the question is why and the discusses it and the quotes from him that we showing them said that the hezbollah in this that permeated the is because we find the different areas in that if it says in the torah it is a requirement of an ache it means that it's a person that keeps terror mitzvahs so for example it says in the torah they now had a charge a yid ripless and when it says it is in this ribbus it says don't take ribs he's considered a brother when he behaves like a brother but if he doesn't behave like a brother he loses his source of being considered a brother so when it says in the turret don't take rivets from your brother it means you're behaving like a brother but if you're a meshumid even though your mother's jewish and your father's jewish it doesn't matter at the end of the day and as a result of it what's the macarthur mitzvot it says brothers once we find that in someone that's a mum is not considered she's not considered a brother so based on that based on that says a mummer will be muffka from evil and it doesn't matter which side of the equation the moon was on because chihuahuan is describing rouven and sherman it's describing the brother that died and it's describing the other one the brother has a visibility but if either one of them is going to be a mummer so they're not going to have the if you think about the smart height for one second this might be the schwarzky in history it's a pell it has no shot it's impossible to even read why what's the power when it says in the terror you shouldn't charge ribbos from your brother what does the terror mean kirby's from your brother as opposed to your first cousin that's okay no what it means is is don't take rivets from a yid why because we're all brothers we're managed brothers no not literally figuratively in fact the rambam says and then why do you find that the torah refers to yiddin as being brothers quote-unquote the reason says that is because they should have said bono what's the definition of a brother definition of a brother is you share a kind of baron so if we're all born in la shem so that means we all have the same parent that lower them so by definition just the textbook legal definition of what a brother is that would make us all brothers because we have the same doctor and if we have the same thoughts and by definition it makes us brothers as they say so it's in that vein that the torah says don't take rivers and from a year because but the terror doesn't mean a biological brother the prayer means he's your brother why because because he's a yi a zen but the point is the point is that the reason there's an idea of someone that's a woman not being because doesn't mean biological brother it means you're yeah you're a member of the tribe well guess what you can lose that source if you don't behave properly and that's because when they said that a person is not following [Music] and he says i think the reason this mistake happened is because we have a tradition the mourinho that mario who's the original goyin that this was attributed to he was a maori nine it was difficult for him to see will the farm and christmas and sometimes his tamida would write overtire in his name and they would write things that he never mean to say ah so says the best even though it's brought down in the name of mario and imam and he never said but this is one of those things that were written by one of the tell me them see i'm not even asking you know what you're going this is possible you never said this should have been right shy that is that what's the macarthur that has to be just don't think about it what does the mean it means and additionally it's learned out from the beneath but the makar or at least one of the two makers that kumar brought to the that hebrew is only by akhman is from the fact that it says foreign that's number one and number two because they have to be brothers in your jerusalem what is the need after brothers number one they both yarsh in their father the father dies the sons of the action and number two their yoshin says what they meant was is that being that you find is a concept that a mummer can lose his status as a yid and one of the places you find that la maisona is on dna yerushno that's the whole occurred that's no origin to this concept so that's the case if you would have a man that would die or that would leave over a child that's a woman being that he wouldn't yarn his father so it comes out that him and his brother are not brothers he said that's him out that if roman and shemin are and one of them is a mummer it doesn't matter which one the is that they won't be evil why because even though they're brothers but at the same time they're brothers men that aren't subject to dina yerusha together and because they're not subjected to together they're as if they would have been because what's the macarthur it's based on the fact that it says so that's the case if you would have now two brothers that are not able to yarcha together so they're not any darwin he says it's a beautiful shtickle terror from the moon there's one problem didn't have the same rashi apparently that we had we read the rashi three times on purpose when we went through the gemara what did gamara say but what's the definition of a they are not and they are from each other now the way the ability has rashes gears so it's very good it's a very nice torah it's because they have to be a bend that's a woman doesn't yash and his father as a result they're not these two brothers so they're not any better than him and that's him that said that if there's a woman there's not going to be any the problem is it's not rashford says he says means you have two brothers and one of them is a mummer is the mummer in theory would be able to yashen his brother we have normal car anywhere that he can't and if we have normal car anywhere that he can so we have to assume he could and if he could so then if you have two brothers where one of them is a woman even though it's true they wouldn't be able to yashin their father together and if that's the case terrorism and the problem is the whole toyota of is based on a gears that we don't have so it's based on again so we don't have the terrorists of the embassy is that if you look on the bottom of the administration so he brings that the emphasis the emphasis that even if we'll assume that the abnormal maybe didn't have the gersa that he quoted but at the same time there's abshad in the salvation along and the emma says to what he wrote because the truth is that there's a big discussion in the chronium exactly how two brothers are in each other so there's a whole saver of nachos right a man dies it's children the main like father mother right there's a whole saver of how yerusha happens at some point brothers could him but there's a shy of how it works does the work direct a brother actually has a school in his brother uber because generation gimbal and reptile and troubas that's not the way it works but rather works with what's known as mishmush what happens is the father yarson's because her and then the son yahshua is from his father so it ends up in the same it's just semantics right just the warriors have to figure out how to paper this album is nicer you want to know how it works it doesn't work that rubin or sh and chimney are you asking each other directly rouven dies yaakov is going to yaris and then shipment is gonna be it's not alive there's a concept it can be irish forever it was no it's what's known as the idea of but the bottom line is that's what's going to happen what's going to happen is it's the arusha's going to have by the day that it's the ability it works works is it works through the brothers it works to the father so if it works through the father then when rashi says they have to be reunited says that by definition it means they have to be the answer to the father because if they can yash in their father if the relationship that he has between the son and the father is god so that means there's no way for them to ash in each other either and if there's no effect on each other so it's in that same vein they would be excluded excluded from the locus of you as well this is the teres from the abnormal womb to explain the but the bottom line is can see the basic was matami on the sheet that's not going to really really didn't like the sheet i mean the shyness that he uses there's absolutely no sound in the world to be soyment on this and the resource of the when he wrote the shogun and in his mahabharat he does not bring the to saga that doesn't matter if the brother that died and he says that a mummer is subject to the laws of evil just like any brothers subject he has one cooler that in the event that the yova got married already and then afterwards she found out that there was a brother and the brother happy to have been a mummer so the other ramos says but the evident mammoth she could be so much on this so it's a fascinating thing because this is the that's like right we're talking about this like i'm iran and this is a that's like oh you know man many many go in them said this really didn't understand the just like and you see that thought it was a ties though it was a mistake it's a mistake the guy who didn't say it if they said it that's one thing but if it's a mistake they didn't say it and the mice all the place can say not that way we're not going to talk about this now it got laid early but the end this is is that there are many fascinating truthers that were written over the years where this was something that played out because the emma says you can a woman that fools the uber if there's a brother that is not going to be miable obviously and also doesn't want to do halita for whatever reason this woman can end up a naguno it can end up being a very very big problem and the truth is in general if you look at this in their troops right today it's it's much less but once upon a time there were real truths that were written the negative thomas and very often it was dealing with a situation where you had a woman she's the obama she's on one side of the world and her husband died with no children there's a brother that's the thing on the other side of the world so go find them now and what's not what happened like leaving a fascinating truth from the night to behood on the table that's hashem will pick it up in the coming days