Yevamos Daf 19 by Sruly Bornstein

today's stuff is yuvonus and we are at the mishnah about 20 lines from the top of the utrecht on the base it has been learned as a reference it's also going to talk a lot about zika it's also going to talk a lot about miner so i think it's kidai as an introduction to the dot to just refresh our memory a little bit about asia by a little bit about zika and a little bit about mine so asia's actually is one of the fifteen areas that i mentioned in the mishnah that is the short definition of an h is actually heard by llama is where ruvin died left over no children and at the time there was no brother after rouven died his brother shimon was born ordinarily shimmer would have a mitzvah people but because shimon and rubin were not alive at the same time they didn't have a quote yeshiva asia's ruvain is considered an asias there's no yipum on a nation's actually the mishnah said that just like there's no ibum and khalid on the nations actually so too they just actually heard by bombay is poetry and the mission in the beginning of the second paragraph said kate said actually gave a very specific example the example was when there weren't two brothers but rather there were three brothers ruvain died and left over a wife no children and a brother named shimon after reuven died levy was born now levy can never do yibung on asia's roofing because asia's ruin is the age of zach but jimin could because for shimon she was not in asia had another wife then she died that shimon's other wife is the sorrow of the ish the mishna said that that is the classic example of what asia's and what the sorrow that's the pre-cap as it relates to issues actually everybody zika so what zika so the icarus of zika is which was yesterday's stating that it's something that underpins and permeates the entirety of massachusetts we mentioned yesterday that the concept of zika is it's a bond it's an energy it's an issue that connects the other and the obama even though there was never anything between them but at the same time there's this automatic connection between the of them and the obama and the truth is zika is something that underpins some of the most basic khalakhas in yavamas the least i say in the torah in order for her to be able to go and marry somebody else the fact that a beer in it of itself is able to create an issue that ordinarily would require hope addition it's all because even prior to the beer there already was some sort of issues there was already some sort of zika stating that there was a major mahriginistan and also where the yeast zika or nz now everyone holds their zika so obviously the word zika is a misnomer the question is what then does in zika mean and what does yeshiko mean the short answer is the amirah and the tainan were debating how much of an issue zika really is meaning how far are we supposed to take zika and we mentioned yesterday there are two nafta minas one primary enough camino and then there's a a secondary nafta the primary nafta mean is as it relates to only suray meaning a person is not allowed to marry his wife's sister his wife's daughter his wife's mother what about if there's a woman that he's not married to but there's a zika a person has a your vomit is he allowed to marry her sister is he allowed to marry her daughter is he allowed to marry her mother that's the majority questions that zika is always to the point that it creates israel the mount bomber that holds eight zika holds that zika is not olive enough in order for it to create israel we mentioned that even the mandama that holds yet zika holds that it's only midrabban but everybody would agree ain't zika that zika is not strong enough in order for it to create a surya stating that in today's dot we're going to be introduced to another sheeta maybe only a havamin in the gemara but a sheet that and that is that it could be there's a concept of zika that is going to create isuriyerva a filmmaker not to be confused with the traditional sheet of zika that's only midura obama this is something that will be even midday raisa it's going to be a very important feature in today's dive hence the introduction of finally miner midday right so there's only one way for the of them to be making this mitzvah vehicle and that is with a maiser beer which is but when it comes to even there's only one way it says in the toyota which means beer so what happens if the oven goes and he did a mice with the obama it's garnished stating that they're upon it said that being that ordinarily that would be considered a mice execution so even here we have to give it some credibility we have to give it some kashivos said if somebody does that the of ovum and the obama are going to be miku dashes quasi it's going to be not a yipum because hebrew is beerus it's ivan but at the same time to say it's nothing that you can't say and as a result it's going to be a little bit as if something happened now not midair isa only mid rabona today's daf we're going to be introduced to another shito which is going to have a different understanding of what exactly mimer might be so again asia's actually holy boy love zika mimer all these ideas are going to converge in a classic yvonne staff today is one of those dolphins that has a lot of ubuntu's cases we know that you say this it's just about applying them and doing the uvamis math regardless without any further introductions okay so the previous mishnah had mentioned the venetians actually what was the case again the case is very very precise because every word in these dafn can literally be marishai lamas they could change the entire suggest the case was where roofing and shipment were brothers ruvin died he left over no children and then before shimon did you boom levy was born then shemin did yebum schmidt had another wife asia's ruben and asian shim in both fellaii boom to levy anxious reuben is the issue it is said in that case pleague everybody agrees you can't do ibum you can't do khalita not with asia's ruling and not with his shim it says the mystery what would be if they wish two brothers and one of them died and in our cases it's always roofing right so roofing died the evening and then immediately and then after she was born and then sherman because she's a tara now why is this different than the first mission there's one difference but the one difference that's going to make the whole difference the difference is in the first mishnah levy was born before shema did even in the second mishnah levy was born after shem and dediban meaning the first mission when levy was born he walked into a zika he walked right into yavama's case at the bris they're readily handling the vomits why because that's mama's what he was born into in the second mission already did you be born 10 years later it just so happens that when shimon died now asia's women has a little bit of a history it's literally from before lady was born she was once upon a time and asia is actually heard by obama either way the mishna says exactly what i said in the previous mission asia's rubens and asia's actually what would be if instead of doing ibum shimon would have done mimer again same case ruben and jim and ruben died shimon did mime and then levy was born but there would be no why you can't do ibum because on the side that the miner is initials we said it's a quasi so it comes out that asia's shimini is just actually how you boil it but then again if mime is a quasi-issues it's also quasi-not initials which means that asia-shipping is not a thorough station it's actually how you're buying it to do eboom you can't do because of the sidesaurus because she is also not a tsar station actually biology so what do you do in a situation like that you do khabit so you don't do it no if you want to do you could do it you could do [Music] were very very similar but there was one difference in the first mishna reuben and shemin then lady was born and then she did evil what's known in the involvement it was first lady was born and then shemin levy when it was yokarish might be strong he was literally born into a yavamas over there in that mishnah there's no rapture the second mission was talking about the same exact case but the difference is that shimon did ye boom before levy was born so that when levi was born all this yevonness was already behind them that's something that had happened in the past levy was not born into your vomit over here we have a rep shipment that says no oh here there actually and partially when you read the mishnah it would seem that shimon's arguing on the second halacha he's not arguing the first allah he's arguing where it was where first and then lady was born but he's not arguing with noi but where first lady was born and afterwards meaning if lady was born into the asian saks then asia's reuben is considered nations actually however if when levi was born shimon had already that happened years earlier the scottish lady anymore and as a result she would not be considered hence again two missionaries very similar cases one difference what's the difference what happened first was levy born first or the chimney even first that's the first mission that's the second missionary and the second missionary the first mission there's no mention of it and it certainly sounds like shimon is arguing with the second allah and now with the first and has you could see why that would be the case stating that um that even though there's no mention of shaman in the first mishnah you should know that ramshiman argued in the first half as well even in the first missionary of shimon holes there's an extra mishna over here why do we need too much snacks unless rap shimon argued with irish as well i don't understand why we need too much nice meaning why did we need the first mishna the first mishna where it was first lady was born and then she diva who was it said for evil namely what was it said for the rabbi to teach me that even and then levy was born so that when levy was born at that point she wasn't indonesia's actually illam anymore that was already gone still astrid abandoned and said it's awesome if levy would be born first and then that even would happen must be that why was the first match the mention it was it's to so really the proper way to have structured would have been to have shimmer not only in the sephora but also in the region he waited for the obama to finish talking and then he argued and heard their first mission of the bhagavad-gita then he heard the second mystery above the seifer arab shiva was quiet he was listening very very nicely and then after he heard both mishnays from said i respectfully disagree literally respectfully he waited until they finished talking and then he argued and he argued on both things literally on the ratio and on the safe it says the gemara you have to say the case would be where there was one brother roofing that's ruby he died and then after he died shiva was born so there's no other brother in the picture it's over there the rip ship and holds of his actually but the minute there's a shin min there's no it's actually anybody about me anymore it doesn't matter when uh well just explain a little bit better did inaudible valloy mace and as a result he never died so then asia's ruined would be an asia's meaning the minute shivan does zebra and then shimon dies no it's not so everybody love me anymore it's true it's him and never did any boom then at me so reuven died and then another brother was born if he's the only brother or if there's nine brothers it doesn't matter if he was born later asia's ruby is going to be a nation's actually alumni but the minute there's a bomb doesn't which is that even though eruption was only mentioned in the baba desai for he's only mentioned the second mishna he's only mentoring the case where it was but at the same time really ripped shipment argued in the first case as well the case of neutron levy is because if not bothered the racial among tony though why do we need above the ratio if rapture doesn't argue in the race she says why would you tell me directions so what's the point in telling me the the ratio and if there's so again so we know that lack of direction we know there's absolutely no must be this in the ratio you know i'll take it even in the rational so we know that richiman argues with duration the seifer that's revolutionary we also now know what is actually about illuminati is meaning we know what it's not it's not the mission on your design we also know what it is that but there was no it was just mace the anchor it doesn't matter if there's one brother two brothers that's the case of isis actually but now the gemara is going to try to understand the why so we understand the sheet of rab sherman of the y the favors was born so at that point she's not a nation's actually about me anymore illinois but in the case where levy was born and then afterwards what's the reason that asia's reuven is was born at that point asia's ruling which was nature is actually now it's true shimon eventually did ibu but once she's an it's actually here by lombo nestra states that she's going to end up being awesome forever so she's always going to be an asia's ah shiloh but mitzvah of roving so now that shimon goes ahead and does it but i don't understand it it has no havana i understand but i don't understand because the reason is because rap shipment holds yeah okay we've seen repeated holds the age zika in the introduction review the daft that is an idea of a zika de eraza okay what does that mean that means rouven died he left there was a brother sherman even though shinnon never did ibum because it was at that point all there was was reuben and chipmunk it was ezekiel and because zika is even though there was no evil it says if hebrew happened so it's as if happened not because there was a real physical yearbook that happened but because it was it was like there was a evil but that's enough to say that when levy is born it's bad because he's coming after there was only one brother shemin and when he was brother when there was only one brother it says if she went already so as a result is the same as even or not you're going to tell me that he holds a zika alone how could it be that by zika alone he would hold that um what's this where you see that was masaka with we've had this mission already said there were three brothers that were married to three wives they were nakrios meaning they weren't related to each other they weren't sisters um they have one of them died falsely and then one of the other brothers did miami so roovin dies right it's always roofing in our cases and then afterwards shimin does minor umace twice in theory television when ruvin died asia's ruling fell the u-bomb fellaini shimon did mimer on asia's ruvain now shimon died without completing the deal so that now shimon is also causing asia's ruling to fully evil so asia's rulings foreign has another wife so asia shimon is also foreign in this picture lady has to do khalifa to both of these women but he's not led to any evil what's the macarthur this the positive says but in the event that there's two women that are causing her to fully eboom in that case there's not going to be any aloha of human at all now this woman aisha's ruben is fooling the bomb she's falling she's also foreign i just explained this a little bit better when rooving died so this woman is just ruling fairly even to leave him right ladies the one brother that's alive now he's the one that's going to rub do i haven't been to steven what am i supposed to do okay why would you have you let me hear the story well i had a brother reuven he died left over no children okay so she's in your vomit now then she did my murder schmeimer is a quasi-issues so once shimmer denied her she became a shtickle asian shimmy she still is just rooming because mine was only a sticker delicious right if she would do yeebam then she would only be falling to ebon station but mimer is not ebon it's also not nothing so what ends up happening is is this woman is now falling the ibu midder abandon and also mahmoud which means that her sorrow is also a problem therefore because you can't do any boom not with this woman that's falling for the second time and not with the sorrow issue in ether that's the halal of the time of communism says but at the same time if the second one you're going to have to do khalifa so even rip is governing exactly how this new boom goes down but at the same time we're as the tanaka says that him and says this is the way you have to do it so you said you can't do ibum on both why not he's asking akasha from rabshimin and it's going to be based on his interpretation of rapture the gemara is going to say this after that this was the rapture and that's going to be the answer to answer this question but this question that the gemara is about to make is not rip shipment talking it's an ammo i'll leave it around someone talking so he said like this why is it me album you can't do evil because the dilma yeah because he's worried and if yes it's going to come out that there are two vomits that are coming from the same bias and if you have two iframers that are coming me by a second so then that is you can't go ahead and do yiban to both meaning rabbi yosef understood that shimon had it sad maybe zika and if the age zika but like a real hd girl like would they rise from the age seeker so it's going to come out that just from the zika alone asia's ruvin is also asia so if asia's rubin is also asian shemin now when shimon died if you're going to go we're going to have to on one side view asia's ruvin as now being asian shipment so if asia's rubin is now asian shemin okay and shimon had another wife so if you're gonna go ahead and do yibong to both of them you're being miable to your vomits that come from the same bias and that you can't do that because so you now let it go ahead and and do two so to do ibum on both of them you can't do why because he hasn't said that it's okay maybe you should do yep on one and let the other one be potter like that can't do the dome because and it's going to come out there's two vomits that are falling from tobacco because asia's ruben and isha shemin are the two vulneras asia's rubens falling from roofing asian shims falling from shipment right if ye zika if but then the problem is both your vomits are falling from humans how do you do you belong to your vomits that are falling from the same man that's not something you're allowed to do if ain't zika sedan asia's rubin's only ages with an asian shim and his own is only asian shimon so in that case you would have to do something to both of them but what's the bottom line you can't do ebon to both why not because maybe yes sika and at the same time you have to do khalid so to the other one because maybe he ain't equal so that's what that law is going to be but what do you see from this head representative you see that shiva wasn't sure but the age zika in zika because he says the way i understand this from the mishnah is the way i just explained it so if that's the case that into asia's shipment and if that's the case really do you want whichever one you want and then the other one is gonna be butter why because you only have to do yi boom or khalifa to one of the two yavanas and once you do that the other one's going to be part there and that should be okay all right if that's the case so why grip shimon then say that that you can't do that why didn't he just say do you want to one the other one should be possible he said he can't do him to both that i understand but he also said that you can't just do give them to one he says you have to at least do khalifa the other one maybe the shadows with their abundant who doesn't maybe say they're up on me but maybe it's only with raphael because people are going to say that is that if you have two-year vomits that fall from two-bottom that one needs ibum and the other one is part of the clone now you'll tell me yeah i just thought you said that that is the rashi explains you need rashi's has verb meaning the case that rip sherman maybe is worried about is what happens if they fall bava sachas so what happens if they both die with asakas so in that case it was never a situation where rooving died and then there was zika the shimon and then shimon died if ruben and shimmer died but so then there was never a zika to that first brother in that case the attack of falling from two different bottom if they're falling from two different mountains you need to do a yuba menace elites at each one separately meaning if one dies first then you're 100 right but what if what about a case where one didn't die first so in that case would be problem now what do you mean if they didn't die first one of them died for us no maybe they died so maybe that's what this is all about so the gemara says that i don't know if you have a riot from the disruption that ripped in with the age zika in ziggler holds yes and the reason he is entertaining or outside that maybe there really is no zika maybe they're not falling both from german it's not because he hears that sad and ziggy doesn't hear it's ada and zika it's what's the direct bond and it's xero maybe they're going to die but in that case you won't have the zika and that's what he's worried about but the gemara says it doesn't matter anyways because i know that's not shauna rob sherman because what time it is not even based on zika viral shadow rep shimon was more related to his related to mimer again what was the case the case was with three brothers and one of them died and after he died the next brother didn't mind her and then the brother that did meimer died so that now asia's ruben is fooling lee boom to levy really meet from dude start them number one inside asia's ruling number two mitzad is sherman now sadish out all you not for just for the torah as well so that's why this is giving you rap shipment argued with that shimon said there's no such a locker okay sherman disagreed with that whole premise okay so what does rupturing and hold sir says that what you should do is you could do yiphon to one and you could be highlights to the schneer but rapchimin himself never explained why it has to be done in that particular way the gemara assumed that it's based on maybe he was massachusetts mesothelioma and it's for that reason his allah was what he said you can't do even the bold because maybe zika and you cannot do yibu and khalifa both because maybe he ain't zika but the gemara says that's actually not unrepresented in fact if shimon himself said shaun rabjamin we don't have to guess we have to make up reasons we have to get involved in shimon maybe learning about zika vide xavius maybe they're going to die and pasha did the work for us he clarified it here in the seventh paragraph of the following he said that if the mimer of the second person is then it comes out or who is originally asia's ruvain is only asian shipment the mammary and if the mimer was not a mimer that ish is ruvain who boiled then really it's she's only h's ruling and as a result i don't hold of your because to me there's no sad over here of zika schneiderman what does that mean that means it says the gemara you want to know this because fundamentally had a different understanding of what mimer does nightmare until now we've understood is a quasi issues it's not a quasi it's a sophic what it is it could be it's a kenyan gomer and it could be it's a nothing and the way we've done it is we've done it as a suffolk that's how we look at it so anytime there's a my mirror i have to rush into starting i have to recognize that it was it was a regular iphone and after it said that it was absolutely nothing so whereas the see it as a quasi rob shimon sees it as maybe it's everything or maybe it's nothing and once you understand this everything's positive i'll call you over on the kind of show let's go through both sheets as it's so clear that had his mind work it's a quasi-isis said i said okay reuven died and shimano didn't mimer so asia's ruby and his asia's ruvain also quasi-asian men so the zika is basically vulnerable singaporean it's not a gay schumer says i know what you're talking about there's no secret space of oven this i hear that the jerush of zika's basically vomit if you can give me a case of zika's basic obama i'm happy to talk to you i'll negotiate with you but this is not zika's basic development this is other issues either it's everything or it's nothing so let's go through two if it's everything if mimer is osaka could you let the other one say okay go marry whoever you want but you can't because maybe my mirror is nothing and the primer is nothing so it comes out one is asia's rubin and one of the shrimp and the two of all this that fell from two different bottoms and as a result you would have no choice you would have to do something so therefore if shimon says that to tell me that they're out because it's because basically now that that's because the apartment but at the same time to do even by both that's not going to be okay why is it not going to be okay to do even by both because maybe miners coiner and of my miss coimba comes out they're both coming from the same bias so by yourself they bought them and to not do anything with one of them that's also not okay because maybe mine was not going to so it comes out that the reason why shimon argued in that mishnah had nothing to do with rapture and having a suffolk where the zika is killed but rather it was based on shimon's understanding of miner so really that is not a zika machine it's a minor macho do you look at neiman as being a quasi-issues would you look at mimer as being uh esophageals stating that if we take a step back for a second we have a sheet disruption where shimon is misopic whether mimer is currently kenyan gum or not and as a result it impacts we have the three brothers married to nauseas where one of them dies and the other one did miami what's that now regarding lady it's mashmal but if shima wouldn't do my then for sure the halakhu would be that levy could be miyabines so what's the kasha let's just put this whole sugar together so if that's the case the we learned to give zika so we saw already acrylic in the world of zika between yoga and to your vomit so says the gemara maybe when it comes to this is a kill between yoga and house that's for you that's only if there was one of them but if there's too many maybe he didn't see that he didn't say that is right argued in the case of him matsu so why grab shim and not hold the vicious actually the terence is because when ruvin died he left over one brother shimon one brother now lady was born it says it was even that's why there's no issues actually everybody know me i in this case with it with three brothers one of them died then the other one died you don't say the same only if there was nightmare even then it's only a sufficient rapturemen's world or the terence is because over there there were two brothers the case was actually and one is that true is that true that rabshima was mahalik between one brother and two brothers and really just to make this point a little bit better so what was saying is that even though she has said the holocaust rip shim and apparition the rabsheman argued even in the first mishnah but it comes out that he only argued in the first mishna of if there was one brother so if it was reuben and shipment and then levy was born and then shimon did boom even though it's being that zeke so it's better that's why shimon argues even in the first mishna but what would be if it was reuben shimon and levi and then yehuda was born so being that when rooven died he felt two brothers in that case you wouldn't have of zika and if that's the case over there shimmer would argue meaning it comes out sometimes rob shimon's going to argue by noil and sometimes he's not going to argue by even the later of shimon is it true that shemin was mahalik between zika musa now this sounds a lot like rip shimmin but that rip shipment only argues by ebay but he's made that which at first glance should completely knock arabic but it's not much that is because we just said that even is going to be maida that there are going to be times that shimon is going to agree by knowledge when is that when there's through your vomit that's the gemara's kashmir my love doesn't the price it mean even even with ezekiel even when you would have seen his father and still you see all ribs is maida in the first mishnah or shuman argues in the first mission of the victory let's let me say that someone says maybe this price is talking about whether there were two yo oh if there were two of them over there it was going to be different to you why don't we just stay in the same case we should have said that whereas that's if there's two brothers but if there's only one of them over there he's going to argue sometimes the prices had contacts and we're not always privy to what that context was but the gemara says the context of this price was maize to show you where they were reuven died left over to yuvam and then yehuda was born so that was the case in a world of two-year-old and this is the way it plays itself happening you want to talk about a yoga mat and over there maybe eruption and apparition but the kimono has one problem says the price has started cloud what does cloud sound like i'm laying down the law of the land it sounds like right this is the way this is supposed to happen if if this is what cloud always means that this is the way it's supposed to be so you can't stop telling me it's only your vomit cloud sounds like this is the rules that i argue it's very nice but that way the gemara after all this year is even though we just went through uh half of we are in the half of the gemara was mavura that we understand time of their shaman it's based on zika and zika is only be of america like yosef and abaya together working on the same page prove that we're maybe and if that's the case that means if it would be sounds like we're not just talking about today obama it sounds like we talk about all cases even beyond america so this is the first cache of the command astronomers the second casa was massive although she has the second cache let's just stop for one second so we're learning is revolution and the gemara is bringing the kasha that who asked vavois yeah so that's right the question is and you have to say the gears over here is reviews can't be the same person so obviously we're hunting a ravel issue and a rubber ocean regardless what was this there were three brothers two of them were married to either two sisters or two of them were married not the two sisters but to a mother and a daughter ayisha baspita to a mother and a granddaughter a isha bhasbana a mother and her son's daughter another granddaughter and then the two brothers die and the wives the two wives either the acharyas or the ishapita or the isha that's both for the ibum to the third brother so again there were three brothers ruben shivan and levy reuven and shimon were both married to women that lavi wouldn't be able to marry both of them married to either two sisters or an isha ubita ishobas beethoven now they both die reuben and chimen and both of these women fellow even you can't do it why not because of zika you're gonna run into problems of uh so you can run into all these issues but at the same time you can't do nothing says that you're going to be part of the gamer shimon says that died first that's the one you should do with and then whoever came afterwards it's already too late what do you mean this is not yeah this is like this so this is didn't they rise in the second year obama should never have full in the ubuntu and we know that's not the case he didn't mean both of them rap shimmer paid to me is the second one freaking more botania here in the mission you could say it but the problem is other bryson the brycer sometimes says things that the mission doesn't say and over here it's so subtle but bryson says rav shuman point there right the mission that just said rupturing invited that's open for interpretation it was written politician that one word that rebbe felt didn't necessarily have to be in the mishnah tamiram hundreds of years later would be discussing and we found over as a rather saying is that where you had three brothers two of them were married to two sisters they were also married to an ishobita they were also married to an ishoba's peter they were also married to isha bhaskaran they each had four wives and all four of these wives i mean welcomed the involvement and all four of these wives had some sort of relationship to each other one pier was sisters isho bita ishoba ishbaspina and then the two brothers died so now what happens is eight you've always fully e-booked the lady and the problem is the tiantif because two of them are sisters right this is what's going on over here so it's a whole nother over here so you know what rip shipment said rap shimon poetr what he meant was is the bazook all the seconds they're all going to be out the reason is because so what happens is it's as if you happen with the first set after that everyone else that a bunch of total that everything sorry service and like this it's not going to be the game that's where you're not going to have to do anything so that's what robert said see there's no writer from here that rib shim and paint means it's not both of them because from he said that it's talking about where there were two brothers that were married to four peers of of craven it's enticed for three reasons that's the key word is so i did two it's not the other two it's the other four it's the whole second set the time size we have another price in this other price range you're not supposed to do with either one of them so you say maris what do you see from here you see that shimon holds that is a tourist from both what's the kasha if so then zika whole joshua doesn't make any sense there's no havana because once one of them dies it's lucid so they're not soros in the zika if she has a joshua that if they're both tsarius and the zika but then that's ours in the zika because once one of them died then the other ones are ready if the way this would have happened was first one brother died and the other brother died i would agree with you my skin is so just to exhale we just discuss the first street in the circuit and that is the shitty revolution who said that even though we are too much nice regarding issues actually we had the first mission which is we had the second mission and in the second mission which meant argued says i disagree there's no issues there's no serious issues actually wrong i'll be really calling her eruption with the first mission as well because he holds even that is going to be even had a right he said he's above the racial man why do we even need the first case in admission must be it's coming to teach me sean eruption why would rip shouldn't hold that way so you can tell me because by the time lavie was born the evil magrum is gone so what are you worried about but in the case of that's not the case so if that's not the case so the shot is so it's for that reason that even though it was but it says if it was because as soon as roofing died shimmer was alive it was if this is if he did if he did it's as if it was even then lady was born then she died over there one thing to remember very clearly that if that's pronounced and that's the only person reaction we have then it would only be true beyond that because we have raised up in holds that zika is not sadami so only if it was reuben and shipman and then lavi was born but it was reuben and ship and the laby and then judah was born that would not be the in terms of any caches and raised ravishia so the muscle reaction of the gemara was to ask us certainly not rayas and the really one cancer that gemara was left with is we had a bryce where shiman seems to say a cloud argued was in the second mission like we have it we have it in the second mission because that's the only time the rapture really argues his mahrigus why did we need the the first mishnah so the mother says sometimes we do that sometimes we say a lesser kadish we build up to a bigger dish why in kamekai might but there is such a indian such a nurse of louis and that's what this mission is it's a lawyer absolutely now the fun begins and this raiso is going to be a rioter a poppa a two of the rebel issue i told now we didn't have a two of the driver issue we were uncomfortable but we didn't have two of the direction now we're gonna bring you checkmate it's going to be a riot for a papa that rav it's going to be a twisted ravage brothers that were in the world at the same time now it's gonna be a long price there'll be a whole bunch of cases um some of the cases the yamara at the end of the daf is going to come back to and the gemara is going to explain so i don't know if we'll get to it today but some of the cases gemara is going to get to later but so we'll go through whatever the gemara is going to get to later quickly and we'll wait until the market gets so there were two brothers that lived in the world at the same time reuben and um vlad he left over no children vomit hashem he lost his mind shinnon got up to do my murder over like his big glasses by my man he didn't get a chance to do mimer actually until his mother had a baby boy who was the boy lately from ace and then shinman died so really a lot of drama but really what happened was he had ruben and chiming rouven die and then levy was born that's regular right there's nothing connecting asia's ruling in an asian shipment nothing happened there was no mimer there was no u-bomb there was nothing and as a result was a very positive case asia's ruling is obviously an issue actually to levy shemin is different not inacious actually everybody loves uh levy there's no shite cause within an ancient rumination if it did anything to issues reuben to create any zika from asia's ruby now that china died so as a result it's possible that asia's rumors what would be if shimon would have been would have done mine it's again reuben are brothers and roofing died and then shimon didn't mind so in this case shinman did nightmare to issues roofing reuben and chipman ruvving died lavi was for sure born after ruvin died so his rulings for sure in this case shimon also did mimer when did china do my relative to lady's birth the prices seem to say it doesn't matter right in the first case first sherman did nightmare then lady was born in the second case first lady was born and then she did nightmare either way when shimon dies the locals are reassuring the asia's rule of energy which is actually about that's easy she's an actual labor moment the schneer and as it relates to the second wife she's gonna need khalitza the reason is is because once shimon does nightmare so on some level asia's reuben is also issue and if h's rumen is also a shimen so now shimon's real wife is going to be uh a quasi-soros that we had in both cases nothing is going to happen to issues shimon we're going to see more about this in the morning was going to get back to these cases consort this is the part we need what happens if now shimon actually did ibu so again the way the price is being set up there's an issue actually by a long way who's they just actually buy llama you have reuven and jim and then levy is born asia's ruling to levy is the issues actually by bombing in the first case shimon did nothing in the second case shimon did meimer and now in the third part okay so what would be if shimon did you bomb for mace and then shimon died and then lady was born so this is easy right so again what happened they had proven in shemin roofing died then shimon did ye boom and then shimon died and that wavy was born so now it's just reuben is an issue actually simon says that it's all the sisters in law is just actually hurt by them this is easy there's not there's no one to argue there's nothing to talk about this 100 percent actually or what would be if after ruvin died the lady was born and after lady was born shimon did yuba from mace and then he died so this was me both wife that's now shimon's wife krishna daddy boom is a regular sanctuary by long white and shimmer's other wife isn't sorry but as a result they're both gonna be a conservative what would be if reuven died and then shemin did yup and after shemin after concert concert just means even after the console navy was born and then died this is [Music] hat there being that at the time the lady was born shimon had already done ye bomb following her and it was never his man at this point you could do even to anyone that you want and you could do khalifa to anyone that you want so the mishna the braiser the bryson the third part of the bryce again the first part of the bride is when nothing happened second was it was minor and the third part that was evil so really you mentioned three different cases of evil right let's just get this caught three different cases of ego the first case is is where ximen did yibum shimin died and then lavi was born the second case is where levy was born and then shimon did and the third case is is where shimon did yebum levy was born and then shouldn't die right so in all three cases simon died the question is is where was shimon's death relative to levy's birth and where was shimon's yibum relative to lady's birth now the way the brice has set it up was the bryce at first mentioned two cases no names no arguments and then there was another case where there's already names and there's ready machoices the case where shimon does yibun then shiman dies and then levi is born there's no mention of a majority because everybody agrees she's an ancient actor in the case where levy is born and then afterwards shipman does it boom again there's no names why do we need that last case the last kata of this bracelet why do we have it let's see lemon the ramek so why don't we just lump it all together why didn't we why did we have two cases and then a third case it should be three cases just put it all together ella lab it's passion the reason we singled out that last case is because there's something very important about that last case you know what's important if that's the case only arguing in that case this is the end it's it has to be that way there's no other way to learn because in our vision yeah there's ambiguity it's another example where the price is just a little bit more clear than the mishna in our mission you have the first mission you have the second commissioner and at the end of the second mission oh you have ruptured so the ship going back on the first and the second part of the mishnah or is rob shiman going with shimon only arguing on the second part of the mission i don't know and the price is cleared because in the price so we mummish we're talking about everything together and we clearly are distinguishing between and even is one is together and then all just going to do a little bit of an analysis let's just go through this bryce uh a little bit more carefully again every single word in this bryce is gold because every single word in the bracelet matters again this is a braiser that talks about asia's actually how you belong so if we thought the two mishnais that we had about ish sasha label illumi was a circle confusing so this bryce is mama's all in literally we're putting everything on the table here we're gonna go through every single scenario every permutation of exactly how this could play itself out that's essentially what the price is it says the price so that the first case was the case where ruben and jim were brothers rouven died and he left over no children and then shimon was about to do miner a dindul mimer and then levy was born and then he died it's very sad park dynamis obviously the price teaches me a lot of prices doesn't just talk this way so there's some sort of kiddish going on over there there must be some sort of what's that but that was shining got up and he was going to do my meditation and then she said i don't want the mimer but he did it anyways he forced her into doing it what's the price is saying the brice is saying there's a nishkai miner that if you do mimer about corcoran it's not a mine would like to have it's not like gravity the time you're going to rise could be done even balkan she doesn't have to be masculine to the ebon she could be forced into it it's considered even the abominable carcass can happen about kirk if you're up on a gaming condition they're about to learn from kids and as a result we're going to learn it from kadushi but the bottom line is that's what the bryce is coming to tell me i'm not last place mimer he wanted to do my murphy's like his speech classes might we didn't get a chance to do my mirror what does that mean i thought that he did miami food that means he had to have a minute to do it and then he said nah he's not doing it so what's the price of telling me that and this he wanted to do with me diet like a mensch and she didn't want it she said you know what i'm doing it is garnished with the with the price of decide to tell me the salah in the world of extraction everybody want me why places but it impacts it so you can say it there but the bottom line is that's what it's talking about and that's a kiddish that miami doesn't work about kharkov and that's the lawyer rabbi the bryson continued and the price said also the miner what would be if children did do something he got up to do my very very hispanic glasses she was masking right these are the two cases that we had in the tumishnides the mission that said also discards and the mission had said also discussed so both of these were discussed on the mission and that's exactly what the prices either one it doesn't matter which one is good automatically part of it sarah meaning levy can do ibum or kalitsa to either one of these women and to any one of these women that he does that's going to be fine and as long as he does that that's going to pop there that's going to pop to the other one so jamar says like this which one of these two cases was rip shimon reference meaning the bryce keta that deals with mimer is discussing two different cases it's talking about and it was talking about beyonce the question is which one of these two cases are we referring to and just to make one other thing clear rashford speaks this out that shipment says what it means is that the beer the khalid is automatically going to panther it's just roofing asia's rumen and argumar is going to be referred to as the ballast she's the one that the miami was down to obviously she was asian so beer khalid said the asian shipment is automatically going to pop but the woman wants to know so obviously that's posh that that's not what we're referring to uh talking about the case where first he did mimer and then afterwards he was born and just like shimon holds there's no way it was let me see that is to one of them the way you always treat it over here it's going to be different so what's because so what's the reason for this the reason is is false because what's written in in my mirror the whole that's going to come together is that mime is not a quasi-ish if shin and is a mime is a suffocation that you done inside that it's an issues government with a riser and you're down inside that it's nothing on the side that nightmare is an issues gummer so it comes out that asia's sh ruvain is no longer an issue by llama because mimer is like is which means which means that you can go ahead and be miyabi let's make this a little bit more clear that means that the asian shimon is not a saris it's just actually however long because if it's so comes out that she's not an iss soros because it was so it comes out it was really lag nothing ever happened so his ruvain is going to be a national actually is a regular because there's no shininess between asia's ruben and nation so the modern chakra of shimon holds that you can be me not either one because sausage relationship is going to be by teresa why because if the mirror is kind of kenyan garment that's one side of shimmer's mimer so it comes out asia-shimin is uh it it comes out that asia's rubin is not an issue actually hurry by lovely so that means the issue is not a terrorist it's absolutely so why can't you do ubuntu and if mine was garnished then asia's ruined it's true isn't it but then there's no shiny creatures whatever you want and that's going to be pateras now why can't you do evil them to issues because on the side the miner's not going so over there that sort of is not going to become popular now notice the bryce doesn't talk about doing the boom with the ballast on my because you're not allowed to do it with the ballast nightmare because like we just said on that side that mime is not going to so it comes out that the ballast is an issue but you could do khalifa so what happens if you did it it's not going to start my time to have a s that's not it might miss going on that chin is like leaving but it's a suffocating suffering can't partner with and as a result that in of itself is not going to be okay you also reminisce [Music] did they rap on an argument of h is actually heard by thomas the mar says because the passage says it says after the after the ebons we look at it as if the abundant and then lady was born so what's ripped sheminstein oh when levy was born the eubank is gone it's not true the issue and afterwards vietnam the abu maharaj is still there and in the uber is showing them as a result she maintains her status his age is actually by going and that's why she's going to be awesome let me ask you a question the mission says meaning i'm sorry once he does evil right once any of them does even regular case of your vomit once the oven doesn't even make at some point divorces his talk is he's a letter remarrier what's the hidden you don't say that the israel comes back he could do that possum nami blame why don't we say ibm different question the question is that maybe when he divorces her he should have to give her khalifa too it shouldn't be enough to give a guy maybe she has to give her colleagues what do you mean they're married now uh a man that's married and wants to divorce his wife just gives a guess it doesn't do khalifa but at times just like mary shawn regarding islam so why don't you say thank you allah regarding this as well so um over there it's different the um the politics says and we learn from there once you get married if you're telling me that once you get married so regarding why so how do you know when to decide meaning with darshaning the issue that once a yoga does give them if he wants to divorce his wife all he has to do is give a gift i what happened to the you know now you're a regular husband and wife what do you mean they got married already oh the terrorists is because of women so the boy says how do you know when to pick and choose that if there's a header of your boom and there's an israel apply the hetero to a case of hat there and apply the isotope case of it yes sir a regular evolutionist hector oh there is a sector in the classic case of hatter we're going to apply the additional hectare of lukaku isha of which is actually in the field of research that's already a case of this sir and then the feeder is shining with this sir so there we go and the issue is going to carry over into part says doesn't hold about dying woman or ishanola he holds that labia was born shivananda danimum already and because women have done eboom already so it's for that reason it's going to be okay element active that's the case interesting what would be if someone has a sister who married his brother from his father meaning then she could have married his brother so it's about in other words a person's brother married his sister was born meaning a brother's there was a brother let's call him levy whose sister had married his brother but that marriage took place before this child was born the maze and then the brother died right we confused this by saying levy it's calm shining better so ruben and jimin are brothers shimon was born after reuven his brother got married reuven was married to his sister in a case where it's possible okay then reuven dies so what's that there's no uber why is it no it's a high side that's the first mission how could it be even worse is this because at the time that shimon was born it was already beheader because roofing was already married to her sister so because reuben was very married to her sister so why don't you say harugaba the hatter so we should say in that case should there was a punchline here where did this sister go mark says no that's very different how you through the leslie terror how you sew this layer there you can't compare it and because it's in this layer so when it comes to this ah over here you can already tell me suarez which is not subject to the hetero and as a result over there you cannot apply this